Retailgentic, presented by the ReFiBuy Media Network and hosted by Scot Wingo, is where Agentic Commerce meets retail innovation. We help retailers and brands prepare for the future of agent-driven shopping with actionable news, expert insights, dxis, forward-looking predictions, and practical guidance on Agentic Commerce Optimization (ACO).
And Microsoft's Copilot is really an
interesting play, uh, because it's now no
longer, uh, that coded environment that
you have for, for developers anymore.
It's just, "Oh, tell me what I
want," and, and there you go.
You got this program and code
that can do exactly what you want.
I wanna go scrape 1,000, uh,
websites for price points to compare
it to what my price point is.
Here you go, uh, and, and
just by asking the question.
And that's the kind of thing that
I think is gonna start changing
the work environments for, uh,
retail, uh, employees as well
as other businesses as well.
But m- mostly you're gonna see a
lot of the impact on the retail side
Welcome to the Retailgentic podcast,
where we explore the intersection
of retail, e-commerce, and AI
agents, which we call retailgenic.
Our mission is simple.
We are shining a bright light on
the new agentic AI shopping mega
trend, which will disrupt the
trillion-dollar digital retail market.
The stakes are high.
Google, OpenAI, Microsoft,
Perplexity, Amazon, Apple, Meta, and
Anthropic are all fighting to be the
consumer AI shopping agent winner.
There are gonna be some tough decisions
for online brands and retailers to make.
What happens to checkouts?
How should payments work?
Should you continue to invest
in retail media networks?
What does the world look like when
over half of your traffic is not
from humans, but from AI agents?
These existential questions
are the tip of the iceberg.
On this podcast, we're talking to industry
experts, analysts, and influencers
to get answers to these questions,
identify trends and best practices.
This is Retailgentic, your
podcast partner in navigating
our AI shopping agent future.
And now here's your host, Scot Wingo.
Welcome to the Retailgentic podcast.
IDC is a leading global provider of
market intelligence and advisory services.
They work with a wide range of
businesses from B2B to consumer
and across all different sectors.
In today's episode, I'm excited
to welcome Andy Chaurtia.
He is the vice president of research
for IDC's Retail Insights group.
Andy has a report out titled
"Win-Win Product Discovery: A
Retail Agentic AI Use Case."
In this report, Andy goes very deep
into what agents are, how do you
orchestrate them, and how retailers can
leverage agents internally to improve
their product catalog discoverability.
I thought it was a great example.
He uses baseball bats, which is, uh,
a category that is inherently hard to
have a great shopping experience for
in today's filtered navigation user
interface that most retailers have.
After reading this awesome report,
I thought, "We have got to get Andy
onto the Retailgentic pod," and he
graciously accepted that invite.
In this discussion, we hear all about
Andy's long and amazing career, where
he was on both sides of the coin.
He has worked for many retailers,
then also on the vendor side as well.
It would not be a Retailgentic podcast
if we didn't cover agentic shopping.
Andy shares his point of view and
thoughts on where we are today and where
agentic commerce is going in the future.
Finally, Andy, in his role, Andy
talks to hundreds of retail clients a
month and has some really interesting
viewpoints he's gathered from the
summation of those conversations.
Uh, so we get to hear what are retailers
thinking about, what's motivating
them, and where is agentic commerce on
their, their priority list right now.
I really enjoyed this conversation with
Andy and hope you enjoy it as well Ananda,
welcome to the Retailgentic Podcast.
Oh my gosh, I'm, I'm excited to be here.
Thanks, Scott.
Yeah.
You and I, uh, have, uh, we
just really officially met.
I think we bumped into each
other at some trade shows.
You've been in the, the
industry for quite a while.
Um, and I was drawn to you
because you wrote a really good
paper that we'll talk about.
Um, and you're, you're, you know, VP of
research at IDC, but before we go into
what that means, let's go, let's go back.
Let's talk about, uh, I think
it's interesting, I learned in a
little pre-conversation you have
an engineering degree like I do,
so we, we share that in common.
Not a lot of engineers in
the, in the retail world.
So let's, let's start there.
What, what, um, what'd you study
in school, and then let's, let's
draw a path from there to how
you ended up pontificating on
agentic commerce here today.
So I went to Clemson University
as a engineering student,
electrical engineering.
I wanted to get into computers.
Was really excited about parallel
processing, which is really a cool
space in the eng- engineering space.
I, uh, graduated there, got a master's
in, um, uh, electrical engineering from,
uh, University of Massachusetts in Lowell.
And then, uh, went off to Northeastern
for my MBA later on when I realized
this isn't quite what I wanted to do.
The engineering is great for a
background, it sets the stage, but I
wanted to get into the business side.
It was so much more important, and it
actually drives the value, uh, for a lot
of, uh, especially in the retail side,
uh, but in general across the market
around applying that engineering into,
uh, real-time settings, which with some
real dollar values associated with it.
So that was the exciting thing about, um,
me moving in one direction or another.
Yeah.
How'd you end up at Clemson of all places?
I'm, I'm from South Carolina
and I, I'm gonna hazard a guess
you're not from South Carolina.
But how did you end up in
Clemson, South Carolina?
My whole family went there,
uh, like five cousins of mine.
My aunt and uncle both were professors
there of physics and math, so it was
all one of those things where family
connection that really brought me there.
But Clemson's a great football school,
it's got great, uh, programs as well
in agriculture and other stuff too.
So, um, I, I truly enjoyed my time
there and, um, you know, of all places,
uh, South Carolina was not one of
the places that I expected to go.
I was thinking about, you know,
California, Texas, uh, even,
uh, Northeast, but I wanted
to get away from my parents.
That was part of it too.
So
You can, you can do that at Clemson,
you get away from everybody.
It's just like this little isolated city.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Did you get your MBA
straight out of school?
Uh, so you did undergrad, masters, MBA, or
like, did you go something in the middle?
No, no.
So, uh, actually it was well Yeah.
So I was actually going for a doctorate
in, uh, electrical engineering.
That was my plan at the time,
and I realized that, um, uh, this
wasn't exactly what I wanted to do.
It was too much on the side of really,
uh, getting into really detailed
function and understanding, and it
wasn't about, uh, computers anymore.
It actually moved into acoustics
and other types of, uh, mechanical,
electromechanical engineering, which did
not, uh, suit me at all, and I actually
went and attended a seminar a- about
business, and it totally changed my
viewpoint on what I wanted to do next.
Um, it pushed me towards entrepreneurship,
pushed me towards, uh, you know,
starting my own firm, building
out a, a different type of, uh,
uh, focus on where I wanted to go.
And it was a, a, I think, a great
change in, in the direction.
Um, so a few years later,
after I joined a couple of…
and did some, uh, some work,
I went back to Northeastern
as an executive MBA program.
So, um, that was, that
was true- truly worth it.
Very cool.
And then, uh, so you finished
your MBA, and what was your first
job out of, out of that program?
Oh, af- after my MBA.
Oh, well, yeah, uh, I
worked at monster.com.
I don't know if you, that means much to
you, but everybody's probably heard of it.
There's two Monsters.
There's recruiting and cables.
I'm assuming, uh, you did recruiting.
Yeah, this was, uh, recruiting.
This was basically all online and,
uh, I was, uh, the coolest part
of the job was, uh, I was brought
in as a senior manager of, uh,
e-commerce and e-business innovation.
That was the title actually.
So it was really, uh,
an exciting space to be.
It was at the time when Monster
was really growing rapidly.
It had some, uh, uh, super
people working there.
Um, uh, we had, uh, a, a lot of open
dollars and availability of resources
to build whatever we wanted to build.
And, um, uh, you get to see, you
know, kind of the intricacies of how,
um, you know, an internal e-commerce
site really operates and works.
We learned all about, you know, uh, uh,
the business analyst side of things,
the, the understanding the metrics, all
the different pieces that go into job
hunting and, and that whole piece of it.
I moved at, at Monster a couple
ranks up, uh, became a product
dir- a product manager, and
then a product director there.
So that was a load of fun.
Um, uh, and I do miss little bits
of it, pieces of it, uh, but it,
it was also, uh, just a stepping
stone to where I wanted to go.
Um, I did, and you know, after Monster,
I left to, uh, move on to other types of
things, and I started getting into retail.
After a few other steppingstones in
between, uh, I joined Talbots, got, I
got involved with, uh, Staples as well,
um, and both all on the e-commerce
and, uh, you know, side of things.
But it gave me an understanding of what
is needed from a digital perspective
for a lot of these companies.
At the time, they were all starting to
go through digital, initial stages of a
digital transformation, and that was so
critical for retailer at that time, right?
I mean, it was such a big change
and big stepping, and many retailers
hadn't even gone through that yet.
Um, so those were really nice steps to go
through and understand the space better.
When you were at Talbots and Staples,
were you, um- Involved in, you know, that,
that's kind of the era of re-platforming.
Did, did you get involved in some of
those big re-platforming kind of things?
Yeah.
Yeah, there was a lot of that Yep.
There was, there was s- several of those
projects that we, we were going through.
We were also, you know, at Staples,
uh, head of personalization, which
was an interesting space to be in
because they needed, they needed to
kind of figure out what is, what is
this whole world of recommendations
and online, uh, engagement all about.
Um, uh, it, it gave me a different
perspective on what to think about
when a company is really looking
to connect with the customer.
And that was the biggest challenge for
a lot of retailers, figuring out what
is that digital connection piece that
really makes it worth their while.
And at the time they really didn't have…
I mean, it was just at the beginning
and start of the omni-channel
revolution, if you will, and where
everybody's looking at everything
from a single, uh, single perspective.
Um, and what I got out of that was,
you know, the average customer,
when they're looking for a sweater,
they're looking for a sweater.
They don't really care how they buy it.
It doesn't matter if they're buying it in
store or online, through BOPIS, through
whatever other tools that they have, BOPIS
being buy online, pick up in store, right?
So, um, that was a, that was a
kind of a, a revelation, if you
will, for the industry as a whole.
And, and for me, just looking and
talking with the customers, engaging
at that level, uh, changed my
perspective as well, uh, about what
retail really needs to think about.
It's kind of funny.
They're, they're very much…
All the omni-channel guys were
very resistant to, to marketplaces.
Uh, and then suddenly Walmart and Target
ha- helped crack it up, crack it open.
But then they've all become
obsessed with retail media
networks, as you, as you know.
And marketplaces are an unlock for that.
So, so it's kind of come full circle
that the shiny bulb of getting some of
these like pure margin ad dollars is
bringing them back into the marketplace
conversation, a lot of these retailers.
Absolutely.
Absolutely.
I, I think that's, that was a, you know…
Retail media networks right
now I think are on such a tear.
Um, they, you know, uh…
I just saw this little article, I think
it's Kerry Masters, I believe, who was
writing it, and she's i- in ar- up in arms
with another expert in this space, uh,
about whether it matters or not, right?
Yeah.
It's this, uh, annoying
guy named Jason Goldberg.
Oh, yes, exactly.
That's right.
I knew, I knew, I knew
there was something.
He's kind of the grumpy
old man of e-commerce.
I thought it was a cool argument, though.
And, and he, and, you know, Jason
makes some good points, but I,
I don't agree with him at all.
I think, uh, retail media is
at its infancy, nascent stages.
It's got a long, uh, you know, road
ahead, and I think it's gonna permeate
not just retail media, but also AI and
other things that are really gonna change
how programmatic works, how everything
will, will start operating in the future.
People are gonna, you know, kind
of assume that it's gonna work.
They're not gonna even see it happen.
It's…
That's the cool thing about AI.
It's so embedded, right?
It's almost invisible, uh, once
it's working properly, right?
That's where, where I think it's headed.
And people aren't even gonna think
about AI as something different and
new and a shiny object down the road.
It's all gonna be part of, oh, well,
you know, just like the internet
or connecting to something, right?
It's gonna be kind of routine.
Uh, back to your bio, and then
we'll, we'll definitely wanna talk
more about retail media networks.
Uh, so you did a stint at
retailers, so you were on the,
on that side of the house.
Uh, and then you did some pontificating.
I saw you were at Forrester,
and then you did a vendor.
You were at Oracle.
I, I was at, uh, Forrester for a
while, and then I went to, uh, yeah,
and I was a retail analyst there.
That was fun to do.
I enjoyed that work.
Uh, Forrester has actually
a great team of folks.
Uh, not as good as IDC, of course,
but they're, they're there.
I mean, uh, more importantly, um,
uh, the, the thing was, uh, uh, after
that, I got a chance to go into the
vendor side, which was really exciting.
Uh, Oracle and, and their RGBU,
their Retail Global Business Unit.
Um, and we had some fantastic people
working on that side of the coin.
I really got to see how these vendors
really opened up the doors, especially
a company like Oracle, which has
end-to-end solutions, complete, um,
you know, opportunities for people
to kind of, uh, register different
parts of what they need, uh, and
then build that into their solutions.
Now, there's lots of, uh, uh,
opportunities in, in vendors,
in the vendor side anyway.
Um, but, uh, Oracle kind of gave
me that opening and understanding
a little bit better and, and,
and the problems that these, uh,
companies had with implementation,
deployment, rolling out solutions.
Um, so that was, that was
a great experience as well.
That was 2018 to 2020.
Um, the…
Yeah, so that's post a,
a good bit of ATG, right?
So they had integrated ATG.
They kind, kind of turned it from
on-prem into hosted or at least an
option to host, that kind of thing.
Yeah, everything was all about,
at that time, it was all about
moving to the cloud, right?
I mean, that was the big play at the time.
So that migration to the cloud, it was
talked about almost every other call
that I was on and, um, you know, how
to, how to actually make that work.
Uh, I think they did an okay job in
pulling that off at the end of the day,
but it's a long-term process, right?
I mean, every, every one of these
retailers that go down this path
are putting a lot of money, effort,
time, resources into building that
out and, you know, some of them
just don't quite get there because
they didn't plan it out properly.
Or they don't know or have the
understanding of what's coming, right?
I mean, they don't understand
what they need to p-prepare for,
the flexibility and agility.
So those things, uh, I think
are all pieces of that puzzle.
Went from there to Diebold
Nixdorf, uh, which was a real
cool place to work as well.
I was there as a, a pricing strategy,
uh, guy who, uh, instead of just on the
strategy team in general, I was more on
the pricing strategy, uh, side of the
equation, which was really exciting.
Uh, went back to MIT to get a certificate
for that, uh, for pricing, which was fun.
Um, and then, uh, uh, be- being able
to actually apply it in the market
was even more exciting because, uh,
in the retail sector, that's such
a critical piece of the puzzle.
Um, both, uh, you know,
merchandising pricing as well as, uh,
business-to-business pricing is…
Yeah, so it, it was a, a great experience
to understand, uh, how Diebold Nixdorf,
a point-of-sale vendor, was really
driving value across the board.
A- and I also got to see a lot of really
new, uh, and cool innovations that they
were putting out with their, uh, you know,
just their general point-of-sale tools.
Self-service capabilities that they
were working with, and I don't know if
you know anybody from there, but folks
like Matt Redwood and, and, uh, um, uh,
a few others, uh, that were kind of,
uh, driving the show, um, were really
driving and betting on self-service to
continue to grow, grow across the board.
Scale was kind of the, the
name of the game at the time.
And you get to, uh, go to the
bigger booths at NRF when you're,
when you're with that vendor.
Well, Oracle has one too.
Yeah, you're in the…
You're playing with the big
boys at, at the big show, yeah.
But you also have to go on the whole
weekend when you're with those guys too.
When you're a retailer, you can kind of
show up whenever you want, but, like,
when you're a vendor at, in the big booth,
you gotta be there for the whole weekend.
Um, and then how'd you land at IDC?
So, uh, uh, so my former boss, Leslie
Hannah, she called me up and said,
"Hey, Nada," or, you know, well, I don't
know if she called me up or I called
her first or whatever, but we talked.
I knew Leslie from before 'cause,
uh, she was-- she's just a smart
person in the space, and she's, she's
been with us for such a long time
in the, in the industry, and she
knows just about everything about it.
Um, uh, but, uh, I tried to impress
her and did my best to do that.
But whatever I did, it
seemed to have worked.
She decided to bring me on,
on her team, which was great.
Uh-
There were no other candidates,
so you won by default.
Maybe, maybe that was it.
Won by default.
Uh, but in any case, I'm just happy
that she, she brought me on the team.
And that was the, that was the
kind of the s- the starting point.
Um, uh, just recently I
took over, uh, her role.
She retired from, from the,
the company just recently.
So, um, I kind of, uh, now am, uh,
running, running our IDC retail
intelligence team, which is, is a blast.
It's fun.
We have a super group of smart people, uh,
in just about every single aspect of the
business, uh, when we think about retail.
And what I really like about it is it has
a full-fledged team, and it's not just
one or two people, uh, taking on retail.
They really understand the retail space.
Many of them have been there, worked
with retailers for so many years.
Uh, and, um, uh, you know, that
alone gives a, uh, a very different
perspective than some of our competitors.
And not to dis- you know, uh, uh,
to plug, give myself a plug, but I
think IDC is one of the best, uh,
retail, uh, research groups ever
that I've met, that I've engaged.
Um, that said, uh, you know,
uh, that's just a self plug.
So that's really all
that, that really means.
But, uh, it is a, it's a good team.
Yeah, I do think it's
good to get it out there.
So like, so retailers mostly, I imagine,
you know, in my mind, IDC goes way back.
It's been…
It's like one of the old, you know,
almost like, yeah, pr- precedes Gartner
and Giga and For- all these things.
Um, and you know, in my mind, it was
really tied to the computer industry for
a long time, where IDC was kind of like,
you know, covering Dell and like the
computer industry seems to be-- I think
that's my memory of how it was born.
Um, and so I guess your customers
are very large, you know, you know,
probably tend to be on the larger side.
IDC's always been kind of like blue
chip, Fortune 500 type kind of thing.
So you have the larger retailers,
which kind of implies omni-channel,
'cause they tend to be the larger ones.
And, and they, they pay you guys a
monthly fee to get research and to meet
with you, and maybe they're thinking
about re-platforming or they want to
talk about retail media networks, or do
you guys even go into, you know, being,
you know, there's probably a physical--
you probably have pr- people on your
team that are good at the point of sale
systems and, you know, all these things.
Is that, is that how it works?
Yeah, absolutely.
So w- our team is kind of broken
out into different groups.
We have Margot and Filippo working on
technologies and, uh, strategies inside
the store, as well as, uh, you know,
experiential operations inside the store.
Point of sale systems, for instance,
those are all part of, uh, their group.
Uh, um, they also cover things like
technologies inside the store like,
uh, you know, network systems, uh,
IT, uh, uh, capabilities, RFID.
All of that is kind of covered
on that side Uh, digital pricing
kind of falls under my bucket.
I'm still also an analyst even
though I'm running the team.
I'm still active.
Yeah.
Uh, the tags, uh, so ESL tags, um, okay.
So those are kind of me and, uh,
Filippo are kind of covering that.
I don't want to say it's all me.
Uh, yeah, tag- we tag
team them, literally.
Um, but more importantly, um, uh,
I think we have some great people
on the supply chain side, too.
Uh, Jo- Jordan, uh, Spear.
We have Dorothy, who kind of, uh, runs
our, um, hospitality, travel, and dining.
And then we have folks on media
and entertainment, Alex Holtz, who
kind of covers that entire space.
Um, so it, it, you know, really a
talented team just here in the US.
And then we have folks in Europe, uh,
uh, Filippo and Ornella both, uh, working
out of, uh, uh, Milan and, and UK.
Uh, Ornella is covering, um, you know,
customer service, customer experience,
as well as, uh, uh, CDPs, channels,
uh, and also, um, uh, loyalty programs.
Uh, and then, um, uh, we have myself,
who covers merchandising, marketing,
analytics, and specifically artificial
intelligence and retail media.
So those are, uh, kind
of some of the team.
There's some more team members as
well in Asia-Pac, but that's, uh,
that just rounds out the team.
And that's-- the thing about
it is it's a team, right?
I mean, it's we all kind of interface
with, with our customers as needed,
as opposed to kind of locking into
one particular rep who's-- or one
particular analyst who's working with
a retailer or a vendor for that matter.
Yeah.
And retail used to be
kind of like a taxonomy.
Like, you would talk about topic A or
B or C, and then it's quickly become
a graph where it's all interconnected.
And, you know, especially being the AI
guy, you, you could talk about digital
price tags, point-of-sale systems,
and, you know, what we're gonna talk
about, which is agentic shopping.
The, it, yeah, yeah.
All in the same conversation.
So that's, that's one of the challenges
I think a lot of, uh, retailers
are just starting to get a hang of.
Um, they need to have to make
those conversations work.
They need to have the data
in the same, same way.
They need to have their
structure, their organizational
structure operating the same way.
They need to have, um, uh,
the resource structure for the
technology to work the same way too.
So all of those things make it that much
more difficult to kind of fit in to give
a holistic view of the retail business.
And I think that that's a, a great
stepping stone for anybody who's
really, uh, who wants to understand
and, and get into the AI side of things.
You know, when I started AI, it was-
wasn't in, you know, when I was doing my
first job at Monster or, or anything like
that, or even before, uh, when I was in
the defense contracting indus- industry.
It was when I was in ninth grade, and I
wrote a, a, uh, a paper, uh, basically
an essay about artificial intelligence.
Those things at the time was
all about things like the
Turing test and stuff like that.
What, what really constitutes AI?
Um, what, what does a
Bayesian model look like?
What's a Markov model chains and stuff?
These were things that were, uh, really
cool to read about and stuff, but it was
almost like a, a future vision, right?
A sci-fi vision.
You can't actually achieve
that in that time period.
This is 40 years ago
or something like that.
I don't know how old I'm now.
Don't wanna date myself on the
call, but it was a long time ago.
Uh, and the main thing was, uh, you
know, the things that I had kind of hoped
and wished for at the time when I was
writing that paper are coming true now.
They're actually happening.
You have real live LLMs that can actually
do the things that, uh, that were, you
know, kind of imagined in those days.
Um, and it's almost magical because,
uh, you know, it's new, it's
technology, it's kind of cutting edge.
Uh, and that's what makes it really
exciting to be in this space right now.
So you were, you were into
this since ninth grade.
When did…
Did you raise your hand at IDC
and say, "I wanna do that?"
Or like when ChatGPT dropped,
that's kind of-- To me, that's
like when this really started.
Yeah.
Leslie asked me the question,
said, "Do you like AI?"
I said, "Love it."
And I said-- And she said, "Okay,
I'm gonna put you in charge of that."
That's kinda how it worked,
and she was very good about it.
But, uh, the thing is, uh, IDC
actually has put together a lot
of effort behind it, though.
We have other groups, uh, that
are more horiz- horizontal rather
than vertical teams that are
dedicated specifically to AI.
You know, Ritu Jyoti works a whole
team of AI-specific experts that
really understand the space well.
Uh, and they understand almost, uh, not
just the technology and the capabilities,
but from that horizontal perspective
across all industries, if you will.
Uh, and from technology companies that are
really pushing really hard to make sure
that their AI gets to the top of the coin.
You're talking about companies
like OpenAI, Microsoft,
Google, Amazon, you name them.
Um, they're all trying to push for that.
ownership of this space.
And I don't think it's gonna be that
easy to, uh, to say that, uh, that
any one company will really dominate.
Uh, matter of fact, I think it's going
to become a mix and then eventually
it'll fade out into the points where,
um, there are many different players
that are kind of, uh, contributing to it.
Yep.
So you, you probably have, I don't know
how many conversations a week, but a
lot with big brands and manufacturers.
What, what are some of
the top of mind topics?
Like obviously I think AI, but let,
let's dig a little bit, like we
mentioned retail media networks.
Um, what, what are like maybe the
top three or four things that, that
are on people's minds these days?
If you just go to an NRF con- you know,
event, you'll see exactly what's going on.
And they, they basically
all talk about AI obviously.
Uh, AI is one of the big deal items.
There's also retail media networks.
I think that is also a
very hot topic right now.
Um, but a lot of it also goes
back to some of the basics, the
fundamentals of retail, right?
How do you keep a store clean and make
sure that people come in the store?
How do you, uh, you know,
drive traffic to a website?
These things are still essential
components of retail and a lot
of, uh, retailers, they're,
they're looking at that.
The other piece that I think is
really important is, uh, data and
data manipulation and I wouldn't call
it just manipulation, but also, uh,
leveraging data to, to be able to
make decisions and good decisions.
Decision-making data, which is a
different, uh, you know, context than
just collecting data and then having it
sit there in some database someplace.
It's the actual, uh, action-based
data that you can actually use to
make good decisions that translate
into dollar value for the companies.
That is where I think a huge amount
of effort is also placed, and that
ties back right into retail media,
right into AI, right into some of
the needs that come from the new
technologies that are out there.
But yeah, it's still running a
business and operating it well.
Let's talk about, um, so one of the
reasons that it kind of like spurred me
to, to reach out to you was you wrote this
amazing paper, um, called "Win-Win Product
Discovery: A Retail Agentic AI Use Case."
And this is near and dear to my
heart because part of my theory
here is, uh, so I, I have a
theory, so I'm a marketplace guy.
I have a theory that, you know,
number one, I feel like e-commerce
has really slowed down and not really
innovated on the user experience.
That's theory number one.
Theory number two is there's all this
activity of people using the, the LLMs.
I think that's gonna spill over into
commercial, which is gonna spill over
into commerce, and I think they're
looking to monetize, and I think
commerce is the lowest hanging fruit.
When you, you read all the surveys,
consumers are increasingly saying,
"This thing's helping me research,"
and then I think they'll increasingly
research, find, and buy products.
Um, and then I think the other thing
I think a lot about is, and I learned
this at Channelyzer, is our, our
product discovery engines are not great
because, um, we, we have the lowest
common denominator problem that, uh,
goes all the way down the, the whole
tech stack to the product catalog.
It's, it's kind of, you know, the way it's
put together from different systems, the
attributes it has and lacks are gonna be
a bit of a, uh, a challenge for retailers.
So, so you're, you're, you're…
Talk a little bit about the, what
led you to write this white paper
and some of the things you discovered
or recommendations you're making.
And yet I also discovered, I also
learned from this paper you, uh, you
either play a lot of baseball or you
have sons that play baseball 'cause,
uh, you have a, you go really-- I
was also shocked how deep you go.
You go, like, way into
databases and retrieval.
You go deep.
Uh, so, so that's when I was kinda
like, "This guy has to be, like, an
engineer or something because it's,
this is not surface level stuff."
Yeah.
Yeah.
Well, the, uh, so the engineering, um,
background definitely helped a-and,
and I appreciate that, and thank you
for the compliments about the report.
I think it, um, more importantly, uh,
it came from above saying, you know,
"We need something that's deeper than
just that s- you know, top level stuff.
We need something that really goes into
how these things are working, what is
the real value add that they're bringing
to the table, and then the benefits of
bringing in understanding of that space."
I think that was w- uh, the, the
question that was asked from one of
my senior leaders at our company.
Um- And, um, uh, more importantly, I think
the, the second piece to that was how do
you apply it to, uh, a vertical, right?
That was the question that was being
asked at, at this company meeting.
And, um, uh, so I said, "You know,
there's some key use cases we've
already put together for gen AI.
Why don't we see what-- how that
fits in for agentic AI too?"
And that's really what kind of
spurred me on to write the paper.
Um, uh, it was also because I think
agentic AI is a, uh, is something
that is gonna be overtaking the
market in the, in the future.
I mean, without a doubt, it,
it will dominate eventually.
And the problem for most people
to under- is the understanding
of what it means, right?
What is agentic AI in the first place?
What is that concept of an agent, um,
uh, really doing the work for you?
Uh, and I think there's some key pieces in
there that I talk about, such as, um, you
know, reasoning and, and thinking engines.
What do those really mean?
What does that really, uh,
uh, you know, compose of?
Um, the ability to con-constrain those
engines with RAG, for instance, or
retrieval augmented generation, for
instance, or, um, uh, build-building
in, uh, capabilities that actually take
it to the next level of where you have
multi agents or a sequence of agents
that are actually doing multiple problems
at a time to come up with, "Here's
the sequence of what you need to do."
And lastly, probably, uh, orchestration.
That's a key component to the, to
the whole concept of agentic AI,
where you're orchestrating several
different pieces together, and the
tool is doing that orchestrating.
It's just like it's doing, uh, you
know, the probability-based, uh,
uh, estimation of, uh, the next
sentence it's gonna talk back to
you about whatever topic you ask it.
Uh, it has to do the same thing for
here's the sequence of actions that
you need to take to accomplish this
goal or whatever that task might be.
Um, so, uh, and, and I should
probably add one more thing, and
then it's the execution, right?
It has to be connected to
something that's then running
that program and executing on.
So once you have all those pieces-
So, uh, and that makes it a real
function as opposed to just a, a
theoretical, uh, a theoretical one.
And I think, um, uh, uh, that was
what I tried to, uh, explain here and
to show in the form of a use case,
and I took this one use case here.
Uh, but I'm gonna-- we're gonna see this
happen across many different retail use
cases down the road, not just one or two.
Even our gen AI taxonomy that
we've developed, um, really covers
something like, uh, you know, 20
different use cases that are, are
primary, uh, uh, use cases out there.
And to your point, uh, Scott, a lot
of them are in the space of digital
eCommerce product, uh, you know, uh,
descriptions and, and similar, uh, that
are, uh, in many cases, productivity
related right now and efficiency
related, but in the future, they will be
revenue and sales growth related, right?
It's gonna change and shift in time, uh,
towards something far more, um, important
to the retailer I shouldn't say important.
I think cost saving is just as
important, but, uh, you're gonna see
it become more, uh, real for, from a
dollar and bottom line point of view,
um, from profitability point of view.
So that's, that's gonna be cool to see.
So when you're talking about agents,
sometimes I, I hear people kind of use
these interchangeably, and I think as an
industry we need a little clarification.
I kinda think there's, there's kind of
meta agents that are gonna look across
sites, and then there's like intra
agents that are gonna look inside a site.
So Rufus and Sparky are examples of,
of agentic shopping that lives, you
know, they're within the, the walled
garden of an Amazon or a Walmart.
Um, and then you all…
You know, there's another one
that's kind of more like, you know,
Perplexity Buy with Pro, which
is looking across all retailers.
Do you, do you…
Or are you, are you generally
talking about either of those,
or are you specifically talking
about retailers should be
implementing the Sparky-like thing?
Or what, what's your
point of view on that?
There's, there's conditions and
different use cases for both.
Yeah.
And both of those things will be
adopted over time by retailers.
You can't just stick
with one or the other.
Uh, sometimes you need to have
that constraining structure
behind, uh, what you're doing.
You need to have the, the blocks to,
to get answers quickly and to have more
relevant answers anyway to whatever you're
asking for, uh, whether it's execution,
whether it's actual question, uh, a
generic question that you're asking.
Uh, so Rufus, Sparky, these guys are gonna
be very important, but just as much as,
uh, you know, all the models that come
with Perplexity, and they've, they've
worked with Claude, with Gemini, with…
You know, they, they got all of these
different models already built in.
Um, ChatGPT of course.
And, and so you'll see,
see a lot of that as well.
I think, um, uh, the example I wanted
to give here was where do you start?
Kind of here's one example
case that makes sense.
Um, it's, it's a, a fundamental case for
retail anyway, which is product discovery.
How do you actually go about
finding the products you want?
Uh, and then what are the tools and
capabilities that help you as a consumer
in some cases, and then also the retailer?
One of the interesting things
about this, um, this particular
use case is it's a win-win for
both the retailer and the consumer.
Consumer can find the things that they
want faster and more effectively, uh,
and the retailer is able to push and
upsell and cross-sell items that are
more relevant to the consumer as well,
um, allowing for both, uh, parties to
become, uh, you know, uh, get that,
uh, value add at the end of the day.
I think that's an important
component to keep in mind, uh, when
they're thinking about what types
of stuff they wanna build out.
If it's just, uh, you know- value for one
group or the other, it's, um, it's gonna
have some challenges in becoming adopted,
becoming, uh, you know, uh, driven as a,
as a major value add across the board.
Yeah.
Let's, let's dig into that.
That, that's interesting 'cause a
lot of the retailers I've talked to,
there's a fear that they're gonna be
disintermediate- disintermediated, right?
So this…
The-- they want a, they want a human to
come to the website and then upsell them
stuff, and you're, you're kind of making
it sound like if you can get good at
your agent talking to the, the buyer's
agent, then there still will be upsells.
Is that, uh, kinda what
you think is gonna happen?
Actually, I think in the future,
the agents are not gonna be, uh,
recognizable, uh, from a human.
You know, they're gonna have
almost the same capabilities.
They're gonna have almost the same
figuring-- ability to figure out
something like, "Oh, that's a promotion.
Maybe I should take advantage of that
now because it's, you know, it's up
there for 15 seconds," or whatever
amount of time they're gonna give you.
Um, because, uh, my, my human
overlord, uh, is saying that they
want the best, you know, product
at the lowest possible cost, right?
So, uh, there, there's gonna be
a lot of that as well, uh, and
that's gonna take experimentation.
That's gonna take, you know,
exploration of, of these places, spaces.
But there's no doubt that those
things are gonna evolve over time,
uh, to become more human-like.
I think that's just inherent to,
uh, the nature of our business.
Do you see a day where agentic
traffic exceeds human traffic?
And it's like, can you…
Do you have, do you have a prediction?
Is that like, are we 12 months
away from that or like five years?
Oh, I don't have a date, but
I, I know it's gonna happen.
It's, uh…
And it'll happen sooner than later.
We're-- We don't know right now, but
because it's an exponential trend, uh,
I think it'll be adopted very quickly.
People will start seeing more and
more of this- All they need is one,
just like ChatGPT shot through the
roof, uh, in November 20th, 2022.
Um, same thing is gonna happen here.
You're just gonna see one or two examples
or one, two use cases, and then people
will start adopting like never before.
Oh, there's my agent.
I've got one.
I got my own personal agent.
People with more money will, uh,
you know, have their own fleets of
agents and, and they'll use them.
I mean, it'll be a lot easier for
them to go out and, "Oh, I love
that coat that that celebrity
was wearing online," you know.
"Let me, let me see where I can
get that for a low cost," right?
Click, there you go.
A few days later, like…
Or maybe not days, maybe the same day the,
the coat is arriving at your door, right?
So that's the kind of thing that I
think is, uh, is, is gonna be inherent
to the mo- models of, of the future.
Um, but that's still a ways away.
We still have some work to do to
get that working to that level.
But, uh, yeah, it's all gonna
be, it's all about human nature.
We're all greedy for stuff and we're
still materialistic in a lot of ways.
When retailers-- I'm sure this report
stimulated a lot of discussions.
When retailers say, "Okay, I get it.
This, these shopping agents
are gonna be coming to my site.
What should I do today?"
What, what's your…
Do you have some tactical recommendations?
What they have to do, start thinking
about is, um, uh, setting up sites
that are able to cater to both
humans as well as non-humans, right?
I mean, as well as to
agents for that matter.
Uh, and, uh, that doesn't mean, uh,
necessarily changing everything nes-
uh, you know, from the start, but it
has to be easy for, uh, agents and
humans to be able to operate on those.
Um, it may still use
the same types of stuff.
The whole, uh, concept of gen AI
and, and, you know, that I think
is really, uh, has been the major
change is that it now understands
things at the human level, right?
So, um, an agent should
be able to do that too.
The only distinction there is it'll
be able to do it faster, right?
It'll be able to figure out stuff in two
seconds other, rather than 30 seconds that
it takes for a human being to con- you
know, conceptualize a page and figure out
what's on it and, and do what- whatever's,
uh, you know, uh, associated with it.
So I think, um, uh, you're gonna be
able-- You're gonna have to have tools
that are able to capture it very quickly.
You'll have to have
real-time capabilities.
You'll have to have, um, the ability
to think like a human first and
then like a hu- and an agent second.
Agents are still have, maybe may
have one or two purpose points.
Uh, and the initial set of agents
are still gonna be a little slower
at being able to capture, let's say,
uh, sentiment or, um, uh, what a
picture might be representing for,
for a, a juicy hamburger on the
screen or something like that, right?
But, um, ultimately those agents
are gonna understand that too.
I mean, that's not gonna be
difficult for or challenging for
them in the not-too-distant future.
Okay.
So you need, you know…
What, what, w- we're having conversations
with retailers too, and you know,
what, what we have found is looking
at the current agents that are out
there, they, they love context.
It's just like that's their- You
know, context window and everything.
So the more attributes you can give
them, like you normally wouldn't show…
Y-you know this being an
engineering person, right?
Like, you're not gonna show someone
the, you, you're gonna give them…
Humans are looking maybe for three
or four bullet points, but the
LLM wants like 1,000 data points.
You know, it, the more it can learn
about the product and it, you know,
it's makes, it's life, life easier
if they could just all be on the PDP.
So they're, you know, the…
W- I think one way it's gonna be
different is the human PDP is gonna
be this beautiful, very imagey thing,
and I think the other one's gonna
look like a spec sheet basically.
That, you know, I think the LLM
would like much prefer a spec sheet.
Like, you know, give me some images
and stuff, but any content and image,
just like give it to me in text and,
and I'll, I'll gobble that up, and I'll
be able to make recommendations up.
What do you think about that?
Yeah, that's a, that's a good theory.
I think that's how it'll start for sure,
but I don't think that's how it'll end up.
I think, uh, what'll happen is, um,
uh, and, and here's the reason why.
The agent will go and find that
information elsewhere, right?
They're not gonna look at your
site necessarily to find that, the
specs on that particular product
or how well people adopt it.
They'll find stuff and data points
that are associated with that
product that you never even knew
were associated with that product.
Um, an example might simply be I'm
going to the site, I see, uh, let's
take baseball bats for s- for instance.
I, I have 1,000 baseball bats.
Here's, uh, uh…
It's gonna go out and find out
which baseball players, Major
League baseball players actually use
that bat, and it'll come back and
use that as a crit- criteria now-
Yeah
to identify which bat is best for
this particular client, and it doesn't
need to do that from your site.
It'll actually do it on its own.
It'll figure out how to do it on, on its
own and where to find that information on
its own.
Good point.
So I think that's really
where it'll eventually get to.
Yeah.
Uh, but to start off, yes, absolutely.
The spec sheet is important.
It's gonna be, uh, it'll make it
easier for, um, uh, the retailer…
I'm sorry, uh, whoever's using it.
It's not just retailers.
I think it'll be beyond that.
Uh, and more importantly, it,
it's around the metadata, right?
It's all about that metadata set that is
describing what you're looking at, that
context that you just mentioned here.
I think that's such a cr- key
component, um- Because it's the
main piece that's, uh, been eluding
much of our past technology.
Um, and, uh, we just haven't
been able to capture that.
Now that we can and we have the compute
power to, compute power to do it,
uh, it changes the game completely.
Since you're the broader AI guy, I could
talk about this agentic shopping forever,
but let, let's mix it up a little bit.
Um, I think it's interesting too to
think through, you know, so, so if
you think about the foundation retail
is built on, there's this product
catalog and inventory and supply chain.
There's also, you've talked about pricing,
you obviously have a passion for that.
Um, and then there's like loyalty and,
and you mentioned that, uh, as we were
chatting, um, and personalization.
In, in a-- You know, it's gonna be
interesting, do you think those, those
elements of the foundation have an
agentic flavor and a human flavor as well?
Because you could see this agent-agent
protocols being developed that, you
know, to your point, you say maybe
your agent says, "Hey, I know," you
know, maybe part of your prompt is, "I
kind of need this baseball bat today."
So that's gives me the context that
Andy's son has a game today and he broke
a bat, now he needs a new one or whatever.
You know, and, and maybe I
make you a special offer if you
buy in the next five minute.
So there's gonna be…
But then on, on the retailer side,
there's gonna be this calculus of,
you know, maybe I'm swimming in this
one baseball bat and I say, "If you
buy this one Easton bat, I'll, I,
I'd be happy to give you 10% off."
It's a little bit, you know, you, you
told me $100 price point, I'm gonna
get you to $150 with a discount and
maybe get a little bit more out of
you because I'm swimming in this.
I've got a lot of inventory on this
bat or a better margin or whatever.
Do you-- Yeah.
Is that, is that a…
How are all, how are all, some of
these things gonna play out, you think?
Wow.
That's a, that's a deep
question there, Scott.
You asked me to predict the
future for the next, uh-
That's your job.
You're, uh, you're…
It says there ri- retail insights.
It's right there in your title.
That doesn't mean I know it all.
Oh,
we know you don't know it all.
That's the
whole fun part of it,
like- Just this is my job.
So what I, I, I'll give you my
thinking on it, and, and, and you
can take it the way you want, right?
I mean, maybe that's, uh…
So I'll, I'll give you my thinking on it.
So I think there's going to be a, um, uh,
so yes, there is that connectivity between
the agent and agent, uh, onga- ongoing,
and I think that's gonna become more
and more, um, uh, important over time.
There's gonna be, um, uh,
agents of agents, if you will.
Literally an agent who's operating on
the behalf of several other agents in
the, in the, in the background who's
doing their task, and it's not gonna be
kind of like an orchestration agent, but
an agent who's just like a travel agent
would on beha- on somebody else's behalf.
Um, the same type of functionality,
but it's on behalf of other agents.
So the overlord's no longer human,
they're an agent of some sort.
So I think that's gonna also be, uh,
the kind of that multi-structure, if
you will, of, uh, being able to engage.
What I think is gonna happen over
time though is, uh, there's gonna
be a level of authenticity, right?
You're gonna have to find out where is
that human in that loop, and, uh, how,
uh, you know, and put more prioritization
and, and engagement with that human side
of it wherever they are in that process.
Whether they're the ones who say, "Oh,
go find me a bat," or whether they're
the ones say, um, uh, that ha- kind
of gave the initial instruction of,
uh, "Let's get this done in a day," or
whether they have a problem that they
just don't know how to solve, and the
agent is then re- representing that,
uh, that particular human in trying
to get something in a day, the broken
bat or whatever example you give.
So I think, um, we're gonna see a lot
of, uh, of, uh, experimentation up to
the point where, um, then there, uh,
there will be eventually a prioritization
of what's most important versus what's
second most important, third, et cetera,
and they have to figure that out.
The, the agents themselves will do that.
We had a problem like this
before with IoT, if you remember.
Uh, we've been talking about
that in the past, right?
Where, uh, you know, all these internet
c- you know, computers would be talking
to each other, and there is some
of that that goes on, uh, for sure.
But it didn't expand and explode
like everybody thought it would.
I think agents are gonna
be a little bit different.
There will be a little bit of an
explosion there, and people will
devise, uh, tools to do some of that.
And to the point of, uh, you
made before where, uh, you know,
does this fit into pricing?
Does it fit into loyalty?
Does it fit into
personalization and stuff?
I think that is very much where
you'll see different use- types
of use cases come out, um, that,
uh, literally will look for, and
pricing is a great example of that.
You'll see many different variations
of that in the marketplace, and they're
gonna test out these models on their own.
So you're gonna have agent- You
know, groups of agents that are
working together, uh, to kind of
find ways of, uh, of getting the best
opportunity for the consumer as well
as for the, the retailers as well.
Yeah.
We could see group buying actually become
a thing, but it's gonna be agentic.
Yeah.
Interesting.
Yeah.
That's pretty cool to see.
I mean, it's, it's, it's gonna change,
uh, how we think about doing business,
how we think about shopping too.
I mean, that's a, it's a big change.
Have you, uh, I didn't see it in the
paper, and this may be off-script, but
did you, have you looked at MCP and A2A
and some of those, those, those protocols?
I, I have looked at MCP.
I think that's a…
Yeah, I've seen some of
the standards around that.
I think that's a, that's a great
step, I think, in the right direction.
Um, you know, uh, just because
it's, it's starting to establish
a standard, but I think those
standards are gonna change too.
I mean, just because of how,
uh, you know, agents are gonna,
uh, are gonna be developed.
Matter of fact, I think in the not too
distant future, uh, you're gonna have
agents develop the new standards for
that matter, uh, as opposed to what we do
today, where we have a broad scale scope.
And, and those agents are gonna
kinda condense it to just the things
that they need at the time, right?
It's, it's gonna be very much
unique to that particular agent's
particular, uh, needs that they
have at that moment, and that's how
they're gonna actually function.
It's, it's a very, uh,
interesting world in that sense.
Um, I mean, just, uh, you know, two
days ago, just I think two or three days
ago, um, uh, uh, Google came out with
their Google IO conference, and they
had a whole bunch of stuff going on.
Microsoft had another conference
going on at the same time.
All of this stuff is now tying
back to retail and what we're
doing in the shopping world,
and that's a very big deal.
Um, uh, Microsoft's Copilot is really an
interesting play, uh, because it's now no
longer, uh, that coded environment that
you have for, for developers anymore.
It's just, "Oh, tell me what I
want," and, and there you go.
You got this program and code that
can do, do exactly what you want.
I wanna go scrape 1,000, uh,
websites for price points to compare
it to what my price point is.
Here you go, uh, and, and
just by asking the question.
And that's the kind of thing that
I think is gonna start changing
the work environments for, uh,
retail, uh, employees as well
as other businesses as well.
But m- mostly you're gonna see a
lot of the impact at the retail
side, just because that has the
widest reaching impact overall.
Yeah.
I was excited to see Copilot
put out product cards.
So we're, we're starting to see the, the
intersection of what you and I would call
comparison shopping with the agent, with,
with the LLM, which is the first big step.
So now that it understands product
catalog and buyer intent, then we're
gonna get into that agentic flow.
Whereas Google went all the way in.
They, they went from
product cards to buy for me.
Um, so they're already…
They, they're, they're kind of almost at
the furthest, you know, out, you know,
uh, of the maturation scale of this.
Uh, I don't wanna say that.
I, I, I've seen, you know, a lot of
these, like I said, Microsoft, Amazon,
these guys are also doing just as much.
If you look at some of the stuff
that they're working on now, they
have almost the same level of
capabilities that they're building out.
Um, uh, you know, uh, and I think that
those things are gonna be the real,
uh, real drivers in, in the long term.
I don't think there's gonna be
one owner, let's put it that way.
I think there's gonna be many different
players in this space, and the agents
are gonna be unique and almost as many,
uh, different types of agents as you
have different types of models, right?
And you can expand on
that as well if you want.
Uh, you know, not just models, but also
how those models are implemented and
applied to different types of use cases.
So, um, there, there's a
wide world ahead of us.
I mean, that, that's
the cool thing about it.
Um, and a lot of opportunities too.
Sounds like job security for analysts.
So that's good.
Lots of, lots of change and chaos
then, uh, it'll be good for you guys.
Some people are saying things like
we're gonna be replaced by these
AI agents too so I don't know.
I don't know how much job security
there is, but definitely there's
a, there's a job security for those
who are working in the analyst
space and working with agentic AI.
They definitely have some job security
coming up, uh, at least for a, a decade.
So…
Well, awesome.
I, uh, I promised we wouldn't go, uh,
too much past your time there, so I
wanna be, uh, I wanna honor your time.
I know you're a busy, busy person.
So this is good.
We-- I definitely wanna have you back on
in like, you know, three to six months,
so to kinda keep getting a pulse or if
you have any other awesome papers that
you write, uh, I think that'd be great.
If, if folks wanna follow
you, where do you pontificate?
Um, so you can certainly go to idc.com
and, and click on analysts
and type in my name and stuff.
That's the easiest way, uh, probably.
But, um, uh, just look me up online,
you'll find my name somewhere out there.
I got a bunch of different
reports coming out.
Yeah.
Um, and, um, uh, you know, if you go
to the IDC retail section and, and
look at some of the other players in
the market, not just myself, but all
of us talk about and think about AI.
Even though I'm kind of focused on
that, um, every single one of our
analysts really focus a lot on AI
today, uh, and in- including agentic AI.
So, um, uh, great place to connect
with us, and appreciate this, uh,
opportunity to talk with you, Scott.
I mean, this was great.
Absolutely.
And I, I'll give a personal shout-out.
Um, your LinkedIn feed is very good.
So I, you know, if you're
gonna … I'm sure, I'm sure the
IDC path is awesome, but I've,
I've enjoyed your, your LinkedIn.
'Cause you, you give us some
snippets of what you're, what you're
putting out there and, and that's
been a, been a great read as well.
Yeah, absolutely.
I appreciate that.
Yeah.
Thanks for coming on.
Appreciate it.
And I'm sure, uh, we'll have you
back on, or I'll see you at one
of the trade shows here soon.
Oh, I'm sure we will.
I can't wait.
Have a good one, Scott.
Follow, rate, and share to stay up
to date with RetailGenic, your guide
to the future of AI shopping agents.