Sparking interest and understanding in the epilepsies whilst bridging the communication gap between epilepsy patients, clinicians, scientists, geneticists – and the world. Hosted by Torie Robinson.
**NOT FOR CLINICAL OR PATIENT DECISION-MAKING*
Visit www.torierobinson.com & www.epilepsysparks.com.
Trailer
00:00 Maeike Zijlmans
“Because it’s a network, on the one hand it starts focally, but, like, it doesn’t start with one neuron. It’s a network of neurons that that interact and they start the seizures. And in some, this may mean that you have, for instance, 1cm of tissue that should be removed - and that’s enough. And in another person the focus can seem the same but it needs 3cm of removal. And that depends on what kind of pathology is there; what is really affected there.”
Intro
00:27 Torie Robinson
How could understanding our brain’s “tree-like” networks and the foci of seizures help improve epilepsy surgery? And also, what about the effect of epilepsy in-between seizures too?! Well, today, neurologist Maeike Zijlmans joins us to share how combining different types of brain scans such as EEG and MRI, with machine learning, can help personalise treatment - with the aim of improving both seizure control and people’s everyday lives!
Meet Maeike Zijlmans
00:56 Maeike Zijlmans
My name is Maeike Zijlmans. I am a neurologist and professor of neurology at the UMC Utrecht in the Netherlands and at SEIN, which is an epilepsy clinic in the Netherlands.
01:06 Torie Robinson
Why did you choose to specialise or devote your career to helping people with epilepsy?
01:10 Maeike Zijlmans
I just love the brain. I want to know how it works, how it makes us human, and the other thing is that I like to enable cure in a disease that is otherwise lifelong. So, it can have a great effect, I think, as a doctor, and that’s one of the reasons I think most of the…us, study medicine.
Why seizure origins can be hard to find
01:28 Torie Robinson
Well indeed, but the word cure is often thrown around a lot, which I understand, but we're struggling when it comes to “cure” for people with epilepsy. In fact, it's rarely the case. So, could you just tell us a bit about why is epilepsy so hard often to treat, but… and why is “cure” so infrequently possible?
01:50 Maeike Zijlmans
It is, like, a difficult disease. It’s like this electric disease… finding the difference between when and where it starts… it’s, like, really like, as we all know, in a split second. We go from, like, no epileptic activity, no seizure, to seizure activity. It must start somewhere of course, but if you talk about focal epilepsy, but it can be quite hard to exactly find the origin.
How brain networks guide epilepsy surgery
02:20 Torie Robinson
Going to surgery, this is your thing. And when people think about epilepsy surgery, they think about it's just scooping out the dodgy part of the brain causing the seizures. But we know it can be way more complex than that. Everybody's different as well. What do you have to understand before somebody even thinks about going to the theatre to have surgery.
02:40 Maeike Zijlmans
So, I think it’s 2 things we at least need to be aware of which are important to know. One is: epilepsy; it is a disease within a healthy brain network. We need to understand where it starts, but we also need to understand how it’s spread through the network to understand, like, what are the most important connections? What are the most critical paths that are taken? So, on the one hand you want to understand the disease within the network, on the other hand you want to know where it, as I said, where it starts, at the focus, but also the extent of this focus.
03:20 Torie Robinson
If you know the pinpoint where it starts, why… and I'm sure lots of people think this, why don't you just remove that little bit where it starts? Why would you need to remove more than that?
03:30 Maeike Zijlmans
Because it’s a network. On the one hand it starts focally, but, like, it doesn’t start with one neuron. It’s a network of of neurons that that interact and they start the seizures. And in some, this may mean that you have, for instance, 1cm of tissue that should be removed - and that’s enough. And in another person the focus can seem the same but it needs 3cm of removal. And that depends on what kind of pathology is there; what is really affected there.
Life in-between seizures
04:04 Torie Robinson
We're talking about seizures now, and people often think - and this I think includes many people with epilepsy before they're diagnosed with epilepsy - epilepsy is just seizures. I know you look at how epilepsy affects the whole brain, the whole shebang. So, can you tell us some ways that epilepsy can affect people's lives in between seizures, like interictal activity, their cognition, their mood, movement?
04:27 Maeike Zijlmans
We all know that epilepsy is more than just their seizures. We know that people with epilepsy have a lot of other comorbidities, other problems, and I think that indeed the answer is in the interictal activity. So, the activity in the brain when there’s no seizure. I mean, imagine that you have a constant noise in your head, um, it annoys, you. It makes you feel sad, angry, you can’t focus as well as if you don’t have that noise. And I see there’s this constant disturbance of the normal electrical activity that’s needed to function. Some of the answer to this is not just in the seizures but also in the activity that takes place even if there’s no seizure. And we do see that if we look with invasive EEG; you see that people often have many more, little seizures that you don’t even see outside, on the outside. So it’s the literal, small interictal activity. People don’t notice it directly but it happens and there are like, even like small seizures happening maybe that people are just not aware of.
When seizures go unrecognised
05:46 Torie Robinson
Do you know what you make me think of? I think I mentioned this in another episode as well… but you're making me think of, back in the day, I remember having loads of little seizures but I didn't know that they counted - so I didn't bring them up in conversation at appointments because I didn't recognise that they were seizures. Now I know that they were, but these awful feelings of fear that I was having, But an aura is a type of focal full consciousness seizure. And so, like, I was having those a lot. And that must have affected me cognitively, mentally, the whole lot. And I wonder how many people this happens to and we just never hear about it.
06:23 Maeike Zijlmans
I don’t have numbers about that, but I do notice that, indeed, in our population where we record invasive EEG, maybe [in] one third of them we notice more events than the people themselves actually notice.
06:37 Torie Robinson
Lots of people, yeah, they don't know that they are having this abnormal activity at all. They don't even have any awareness or feeling that they're experiencing it, correct?
06:46 Maeike Zijlmans
Mm hmm. Yes, sure.
Could epilepsy surgery be offered earlier?
06:47 Torie Robinson
So, going back to surgery then, I mean, I've heard from lots of people that we think lots of people could have effective surgery, but either they don't have access or then it's not been proposed. Can you give us a couple of statistics that could show us or explain why epilepsy surgery matters and like how it could matter to more people? How many more people might benefit from it?
7:09 Maeike Zijlmans
The challenge is in improving it, because nowadays, it's like [in] 60% [of people] really effective but then another 20% it's a little bit effective. And I think that if we can, you know, come from the 60 to the 80%, then it can also become an early treatment, instead of a late treatment (what it is now). And we know that if you treat early, the chances are also better. You can imagine that if the disease doesn't exist that long that the network is not that effected. But we do not take it as a first resort treatment at this moment because the chances are not always good enough. On the one hand we need to improve the statistics of the outcomes, and on the other hand I think it should become an early resort treatment - instead of a late resort treatment.
07:59 Torie Robinson
I agree. I mean, the average waiting time, like two decades or a fifth of a century is absolutely ridiculous. And in that waiting period you get brain damage!
08:07 Maeike Zijlmans
Well, at least the network gets affected, yeah. The more the more the electricity flows the more easier it finds its path.
08:13 Torie Robinson
Yeah, and you can have injuries, you could, you know, you're at high risk of SUDEP. There are so many different things that could happen. So, I completely agree. The earlier the better. then maybe we need another episode for Engel class or how you measure the success.
How machine learning can spot subtle EEG changes
08:28 Torie Robinson
So, tell us about your work in machine learning. Quickly just tell us what machine learning is, because not everybody knows. And how can it help with your work? What do we call it? Like, advancing brain signal analysis. So, figuring out exactly what's going on where and help more effective surgery. How does that work?
08:46 Maeike Zijlmans
So it's a type of artificial intelligence. And we look especially at the EEG signals - so the electrical signal of the brain. I believe we must be able to find some sort of signature of the epilepsy, and maybe this is sort of a personalised signature. So we need to take into account more than just the electricity; we need to take into account all the information that we can obtain, basically, like, for instance, the pathology and the MRI abnormalities. So, we really need to understand the whole network. But I do believe that in the end we will be able to find some sort of “signature” of the epileptic activity. And why machine learning is so effective in this is that as human observers to understand the the EEG - I mean, yeah, to be honest, we're just looking at, you know, a lot of how it looks like, like these little waves, we're looking at them, we're trying to understand what brain wave is what, etc.. And of course we can notice the real abnormal things - that's easy for us humans.
09:55 Torie Robinson
Hmm.
09:55 Maeike Zijlmans
But is difficult is to understand what is “normal”. And that's something that machine learning can really help with. It can, it can understand what is normal in the EEG activity - if you understand what is normal you can then also see what it subtly abnormal.
10:12 Torie Robinson
Lots of people get scared about machine learning AI, but it's amazing when you can apply it in the right way. And it makes us realise how limited we are, as humans, to notice patterns or abnormalities, especially when they're so subtle as they can be in epilepsy.
10:27 Maeike Zijlmans
Yeah, yeah.
Could treating interictal activity improve lives?
10:29 Torie Robinson
Once we do identify, in more people, in the future, who have this abnormal activity, more people who would benefit from surgery, what benefits would that bring to them in their lives?
10:40 Maeike Zijlmans
Yeah, so, I hope that we do not only treat the seizures. Of course that's our first goal (I mean epilepsy is a lot about the seizures) but I do hope that we also find the effects of the epileptic activity in the brain on the functioning, like, the normal functioning of the brain. And so I do hope that we find a way to not only treat the seizures but also by treating interictal activity we help improve cognitive functioning, um, like mood, erm coping with… yeah, life, haha!
11:00 Torie Robinson
Haha.
11:20 Maeike Zijlmans
Because, I imagine that if this constant interictal activity is gone as well, that you… yeah, that you're just less disturbed, let's put it that way.
11:32 Torie Robinson
I can imagine you'd be able to be calmer, focus more, be more stable, and you'd be able to feel more confident applying for jobs, you'd be able to learn more, you'd be able to do better at school. And you know, people often think of relationships and things like that. You'd be more confident going into those or being within them.
Making epilepsy surgery more accessible worldwide
11:53 Torie Robinson
So, ok, what about global access to this? ‘Cause here we are speaking from Europe. What about people in other countries? What things could they do when it comes to techniques for surgery and care?
12:09 Maeike Zijlmans
So I do hope that eventually we get more and more to, like, a product. One product that fits all.
12:19 Torie Robinson
Okay!
12:20 Maeike Zijlmans
I don't know if we'll ever achieve that but that's really my dream. And then you could, indeed, much more easily uh help people in other countries as well (‘cause nowadays our work is quite intense in the
12:34 Torie Robinson
Yeah.
12:34 Maeike Zijlmans
…sense that we have a lot of human resources needed to do the job). And if we can… part of that… automatise, I hope that in the end we can also help people in other countries, yes.
12:46 Torie Robinson
Are you talking about devices? Or what? What are you thinking of that could be of benefit though?
12:52 Maeike Zijlmans
Yeah, I'm talking about devices that enable us to recognise the signal more automatically and show the surgeon more automatically, interoperability, direct where to go to. And then again, I mean the impact it could have if.. I mean it's a disease that's occurring so much, especially in lower income countries. And yeah, if we can help with the treatment and extend and improve life for a very long period.
Identifying precise seizure foci without surgery
13:23 Torie Robinson
Tell us about a paper of yours as well, applying that looking ahead, how do you think things could improve in 5 to 10 years’ time?
13:29 Maeike Zijlmans
It's really interesting what we're doing now, you know, trying to really solve this puzzle, and, you know, spending a lot of energy understanding the brain, etc., so I love it! You would want to be able to treat more people in a better way. And, ideally, at a certain moment we come to some sort of, I mean, maybe it's not [in] 10 years time, maybe it's 20 or 30 years time, but some sort of way that we - preferably non-invasively - can find, you know, exactly where the epilepsy is coming from and understand really how it is affects the network. Really understand not just the seizures but also the effect on the rest of the brain and that we can then, sort of, in a sort of automatised way say “Ok, this is where we need to go, this is what needs to be treated.”. Yeah. And of course: do that. Ideally, at a certain moment in time people just get something on their head and it says “woo”, ok, haha…
14:28 Torie Robinson
Haha.
14:28 Maeike Zijlmans
… and then, you know, you get another thing on your head and “woo” and it's treated! And that's it, haha.
14:35 Torie Robinson
Haha.
14:36 Maeike Zijlmans
But then, my job is less interesting, that's eh… haha.
Why it’s worth combining MRI, EEG and metabolic imaging
14:40 Torie Robinson
So you had this interesting paper called “Changing Concepts in Presurgical Assessment for Epilepsy Surgery” (it's a bit of a long one!) And that kind of tells us a bit about how technologies are changing the way we think about surgery. What do you think people should take from that? What are some key parts of that paper that are relevant to people listening?
15:03 Maeike Zijlmans
I think one of the key parts is that.. I mean there's a lot of techniques evolving, like MRI is improving, EEG techniques are improving, metabolic imaging is improving. It's like a sort of like s sort of tree, like all these little things are improving. And some say “No, you have to use my method!” and the other person says “No, you have to use my method!”, but in the end I think that the answer is in a multimodal approach. Some people say it's like “You need to understand the focus”, other people say “You need to understand the network” - I think it's both. You know, we need to understand how this focus acts within the network. So we need to combine things in the end.
15:46 Torie Robinson
Well, everyone come as the MDT (multidisciplinary team) and egos to one side and let's try and figure out how to improve the lives of the people affected by epilepsy. Completely agree. Thank you so much.
15:59 Maeike Zijlmans
Thank you.
Closing thoughts
15:59 Torie Robinson
Thank you to Maeike! Epilepsy surgery involves much more than finding where seizures start - but also understanding the surrounding brain networks - ‘cause that matters as well. And success? Well, means looking beyond seizures to what happens when the person isn’t seizing - so, their overall quality of life! Check out Maeike’s paper - link is on the website - and share this episode with somebody who would find it useful. And please do subscribe for more from Epilepsy Sparks Insights. Thanks for tuning in - and I'll see you next time.