Safe Travels: A Nature Podcast

Beavers are often called nature's greatest ecosystem engineers. Their dams can reshape waterways, reconnect streams to their floodplains, support biodiversity, and help landscapes retain water. But what does it actually take to bring beavers back to a landscape, and are we approaching their restoration the right way?

In this episode of Safe Travels, we're in Central Oregon at the South Fork of the Crooked River, joined by Dr. Matt Orr, biology professor at Oregon State University–Cascades, and Reese Mercer, founder of Western Beavers Cooperative.

Together, we explore the fascinating relationship between beavers and the landscapes they inhabit, the emerging science of ecological restoration, and the challenges of helping degraded waterways recover.

We discuss the history of beaver removal throughout the American West, how the loss of beavers and changes in land use contributed to degraded stream systems, and why restoring these landscapes requires much more than simply building dams or relocating animals.

Reese explains why preparing habitat and establishing adequate food sources are essential for successful beaver recovery, while Matt shares what years of research and experimentation with beaver dam analogs have taught him about stream restoration.
We also explore how beaver activity can influence water retention, biodiversity, wildfire resilience, and the health of surrounding ecosystems.

Perhaps most importantly, this conversation challenges us to reconsider how we approach conservation. Beavers aren't restoration tools waiting to be deployed. They are wild animals with their own needs, behaviors, and agency. Our responsibility is to understand those needs and create landscapes where they can thrive.

In this episode, we discuss:
  • Why beavers are considered ecosystem engineers and keystone species
  • The history of beaver trapping and the transformation of waterways throughout the American West
  • How cattle grazing and stream incision have changed riparian ecosystems
  • What beaver dam analogs (BDAs) are and how they influence stream systems
  • Why planting adequate food and forage is essential for successful beaver restoration
  • How beavers can help reconnect streams to their floodplains and retain water
  • The relationship between beaver wetlands, biodiversity, and wildfire resilience
  • Why relocating beavers isn't necessarily the solution to restoring populations
  • The importance of long-term monitoring and adaptive management in ecological restoration
  • Whether restoration should recreate historical ecosystems or prepare landscapes for future climate conditions
  • The challenges of restoring ecosystems at watershed scale
  • How individuals and local communities can get involved in restoration
About the guests:

Dr. Matt Orr is a biology professor at Oregon State University–Cascades whose research includes ecology, stream restoration, and the effects of beaver dam analogs on aquatic and riparian ecosystems.

Reese Mercer is the founder of Western Beavers Cooperative, an organization working with landowners and local communities to prepare landscapes for beaver recovery and support watershed-scale restoration throughout Eastern Oregon.

Learn more:
Thanks for listening to Safe Travels: A Nature Podcast. If you enjoy these conversations and want to support independent nature journalism, you can find us on Patreon: patreon.com/safetravelspod 

Safe travels!

Creators and Guests

Host
Joey Liberatore

What is Safe Travels: A Nature Podcast?

Safe Travels explores National Parks and wild places through in-depth conversations with the people who know them best - park rangers, scientists, biologists, geologists, archaeologists, and conservationists.

Each episode goes beyond travel tips to uncover the science, history, wildlife, and conservation stories that bring these landscapes to life.

Hosted by Joey Liberatore, Safe Travels: A Nature Podcast turns expert insight into engaging, accessible conversations - helping listeners experience public lands with deeper understanding and appreciation.

Speaker 1:

Hi, everyone. Thanks for checking out the Safe Travels Podcast. My name is Joey. In today's episode, we are in Central Oregon and I am honored to be joined by doctor Matt Orr and Reese Mercer. Matt is a biology professor at Oregon State University Cascades and Reese is the founder of a tremendous conservation organization called Western Beavers Cooperative.

Speaker 1:

In this episode, we talk all about beavers, their role as ecosystem engineers, human built beaver dam analogs and their impact on landscapes, as well as the emerging science of ecological restoration.

Speaker 2:

Matt Reese, thank you both so much for joining me. We are at the South Fork Of The Crooked River, and today we're gonna be talking all about beavers and beaver habitat. So why is this specific location significant for beavers and your work with them?

Speaker 3:

This property is significant to me largely through the activity of the landowner. He purchased it in around 2005, and he was interested to see what would happen if he removed cattle from his property. So this site was historically grazed. And when we first started working out here, there was a lot of sign of cow activity, sort of petrified cow patties. And, yeah, since then, I've had classes out here for summer field courses since 2007, and we've looked at how the stream might recover passively just by having cows not down in the the stream zone or riparian zone.

Speaker 3:

So we've done stream profiles and measured to see whether this stream behaves similarly to to other streams where cows are removed. And then in 2016, we started experimenting with Beaver based restoration.

Speaker 4:

For me, what I love about this place is this... We're in the Oregon High Desert. So we've got about anywhere from six to 12 inches a year of precipitation, so hardly anything. But this is a main stem of the basin where beavers have been known to travel up and down throughout the corridor in here. And I first got involved with this area in 2019 with Oregon Natural Desert Association.

Speaker 4:

I think they paralleled some of your work, Matt. And they have volunteer planting projects. So planting forage out here for beavers is my first involvement with this area. And then since then, I come out about three or four times a year to document the changes that I'm seeing in the planting, and then also beavers now becoming established in the system over time because some of the forage is available to eat. So it's a very near and dear place to my heart when you're out on the land in...

Speaker 4:

On a hot day and the rattlesnakes are around and the cheatgrass is out there and it's a 100 degrees out. And I wonder why am I doing this work but then I go on the stream under a temperature envelope from the from the vegetation that's been put in place and you feel the cool water and it's like you're in an oasis And then I'm reminded of why this work is important because it's such a contrast to the rest of the sagebrush and and juniper that you're seeing. So it's a very special place to me for a lot of reasons and having the beavers actually settle and stay like we saw earlier today, just reminds me that it is possible for beavers to be out here and hopefully to thrive over time.

Speaker 2:

I wish people had the opportunity to spend the day like I did with both of you and just hear the ideas you're throwing out to each other and the different concepts you wanna try and the tests you wanna look at, not only on this land, but land throughout Central Oregon, and see how beavers react to it. And that's part of the reason why I wanted to have both of you on this podcast because you come from different backgrounds and wanting to help with restoration and to study and learn about beavers. And to hear this dialogue between both of you all day has been really incredible. And Reese, I'll I'll start with you. Where did your passion for restoration and for wanting to work with beavers come from?

Speaker 4:

What started when I was young with, Three Against the Wilderness book, my father turned me on to, and then a brother-in-law who is a fish biologist who told me about beavers in restoration. And then more recently, about twelve years ago, I got the bug, like full time book, to learn more about beavers from a PBS PBS documentary and as I learn more and more about beavers I realized that they are really limited in terms of habitat and forage availability. They used to be on the landscape in great, great numbers and then we removed them two hundred years ago and the land just doesn't work without them. And so it's been a real learning journey for me, from researchers like Matt and from stream restoration practitioners to understand what are the conditions that beavers really need to be successful on the land and then how do we actually help prepare the land for their arrival when they come back in? So that's been a twelve year journey for me doing this work.

Speaker 2:

And I want to touch on that before, Matt, I go to you on your background and why you love Fracestation. But you had mentioned preparing the land for their arrival, not necessarily bringing the beaver here, which is a tease for something that we'll talk about later that you're passionate about, not just relocating beavers but creating habitat that they want to come to. But, Matt, you're an educator, and you are a scientist who has done a lot of incredible research throughout your career from grasshoppers to parasitic flies and beaver dam analogs, which we talk a lot about here. But where did your passion come for science and then wanting to become an educator?

Speaker 3:

Well, I'll speak to restoration because I think Reese and I... I didn't know this until you said that, but I also got interested in restoration through a book that I read. So Reese's was called Free Against the Wilderness, which it... Or actually is another book I've read, but I I read it much later. And that's a great book.

Speaker 3:

I started with a book called Miracle Under the Oaks, which is about it's sort of about the origins of of the science of restoration ecology, but it really starts with just a bunch of people that were into plants and into clearing invasive habitat around the Chicago River. They actually ended up kind of discovering this lost ecosystem that had been kind of buried through human disturbance. And it was... It it literally was just a bunch of people who liked plants, who weren't professionally doing restoration, and it has evolved into this relatively new science of ecological restoration. And this actually...

Speaker 3:

We're in the United Nations Decade of Ecological Restoration. And and so I got really interested in just the idea of restoration at that time, and I'd already been... I'd already done a bunch of research. Like you said, I did stuff on grasshopper speciation and ecology in the Sierra Nevadas, and I'd worked on parasitic flies that attack ants down in South America. But my wife and I just started going out as volunteers to a project that was being conducted in the sand dunes in San Francisco at Fort Funston.

Speaker 3:

And I got into restoration then, then moved to Central Oregon, and there were so many opportunities to do restoration in Central Oregon that I wanted to get my students involved in it. And with the help of the Deschutes Land Trust, I got a a grant to do a field course in ecological restoration. And at the time, I didn't know a lot about it, but the grant was pretty generous, and I I hired a professional restoration ecologist to co teach the course with me, Karen Allen, who was fantastic. And so I kind of learned along with the students in some ways. And, you know, I'm...

Speaker 3:

As a university educator, I really am into the whole idea of, like, learning by doing rather than trying to learn in more abstract ways. And that's one thing that's really accessible about restoration is you can go out as a volunteer and get deeply involved in a project in, like, one day and just learn a whole lot about the landscape and about why you're out there and what the problems are and how people are trying to fix them. So restoration is like a really involving activity and evolving science. So I really like the science side of it too.

Speaker 2:

Earlier, off camera, you and I were talking. You had mentioned that you also just felt so fulfilled doing restoration. And you felt like you yourself had grown as just a human being being involved and feeling like you're part of the ecosystem making an impact.

Speaker 3:

Yeah. So this guy, William Jordan the third, who's one of the founders of the Society for Ecological Restoration, he says, like, one of the biggest effects of restoration is its effects on the restorationist, like, person out there doing it in terms of developing a harmonious relationship with the landscape. And... Yeah. I mean, I think that's true.

Speaker 3:

It's like you get... You go out, you get involved, you get immersed in the ecosystem. You start asking all these questions, and you want to you wanna understand it better. And so it leads to scientific questions, and you wanna you wanna improve it, so it leads to practitioner activities. There's just...

Speaker 3:

And, obviously, there's so much that needs to be done. We wouldn't have this United Nations decade on this activity if it weren't an important and needed activity. And so there's just so many ways to get involved and to grow as a person through through the activity.

Speaker 2:

We have a lot to cover regarding beavers and restoration, but you're an amazing example of somebody who goes out and just does it and is a community organizer and gets volunteers involved in projects that are larger than us as individuals. Can you talk about your organization, Western Beavers Cooperative, and and what your your mission is with that?

Speaker 4:

Yeah. Thank you for asking on that because I get very excited by the idea of thinking at watershed scale but acting locally. And that if we want... I'm I'm working in primarily in Eastern Oregon, lot of rural communities, big landscapes where you can really move the needle on habitat uplift. If you've got one landowner who has 10 miles of stream where he or she wants to do work, that's a that's a big footprint that you can really impact.

Speaker 4:

And so our focus is on working with working lands, large landowners on these big, large Eastern Oregon areas and getting getting local approaches to the way that we're doing the work. So rather than having a top down solution that is centralized, that gets imported into a community, what we're doing is working within those communities to help build community readiness for Return of Beavers and then working to activate those communities so that we've got, for example, a recent project we worked with ten sixth graders to install a cottonwood cutting stool within the local community and we're going to build on that over time with the local conservation district because those kids and that community is getting excited about a return to beavers in their watershed. And so activating really everybody at a local level and then finding solutions that work at the local level according to those community values. So we're preparing not only the land for return of beavers, but also the communities themselves. And beavers aren't welcome everywhere.

Speaker 4:

You know, they can... We have old infrastructure that was designed without beavers in mind, and conflicts happen a lot. And so helping folks to understand that there are solutions where we can adapt the infrastructure that's in place, maybe it... It's an irrigation weir box or a point of diversion or culvert that beavers are very attracted to as a natural place to dam on. And there are solutions that can be implemented to keep the beavers off of the infrastructure, keep the water flowing so that landowners can have the kind of control they need.

Speaker 4:

So we're trying to work at a number of different levels to get... Build community readiness, build readiness for the land, and then also understanding where the beavers are on the land and how we can prioritize restoration efforts to best support their recolonization in these watersheds.

Speaker 3:

I did want to say something too about just to give your listeners some perspective on... Because we're talking about, you know, the importance of Beaver to the landscape, but maybe just to... And and you you asked about this location, but we happen to be in a drainage that back in the nineteenth century was part of Hudson Bay Fur Company. They called it their fur desert policy. And the idea was to...

Speaker 3:

Because because at that time, the the main economic engine in this part of the world was... You know, it wasn't development. It wasn't tourism. You know? It was trapping animals off the landscape and selling furs.

Speaker 3:

And the... Great Britain and The US came to this agreement that they weren't gonna fight over what was called the Oregon territories at the time, which involved Oregon, Washington, Idaho, parts of Montana. But what the British did do in sort of an underhanded way is they decided, well, we're not gonna go to battle over this, but we're gonna remove any economic incentive for the Americans to wanna settle it. And so they tried to trap all of the fur bearing animals out of the area. And so that was a big piece of the extermination of fur bearing animals, particularly beaver, out of here.

Speaker 3:

And so they had kind of primed the watershed by taking out an animal that has these activities, particularly, like, basically cutting down wood and putting it in the stream. And it has so many effects when they do that. And so the beaver were gone, then people came in with cattle, and there were no grazing regulations to begin with. The BLM didn't really exist. And so then the cattle coming in into these environments that had no beaver in them created more problems for the streams.

Speaker 3:

And in these dry, arid landscapes, once you start disturbing the stream, it starts cutting down into its own bank if you've if you've removed all the vegetation. And so these streams get what's called incised, which means they cut down into their own stream bed, and that just lowers the water table. And so then everything around the stream dries out. So you get these really narrow streams that just go straight up into these dry lands, and they're often way down in the water table. And then when they're way down like that and they cut down in their stream bed, big flows come through.

Speaker 3:

And instead of just flooding out and kinda dispersing across the landscape, they just act like these, you know, hydraulic forces, like almost like hydraulic mining for gold. They come in, and they'll just... They can cut down into their banks. I've heard people say that, like, you know, one storm event will cause them to cut down in some areas around here, like 10 feet. And so these are the kinds of problems that we're dealing with is these streams that are called incised.

Speaker 3:

They're cut way down into their channel. They... They're disconnected from their floodplain, And and therefore, the ripe... The the... What we call the riparian zone, which is the zone that's affected by the the stream moisture where you get a whole different plant community, that riparian zone gets really narrow.

Speaker 3:

And so you can contrast that with, historically, these streams overtop their banks. The beavers were always putting wood in, which holds up sediment, slows the flows down, keeps them connected to their floodplains. The water disperses out during high flow events. The water's held up on the landscape more. Like, that's a big thing that beavers do, and that's what that's what dams do in general.

Speaker 3:

Right? Beavers build dams. Dams stop water. And so if you've got a a, you know, an active population of beaver all the way down a watershed, then when the water comes in, it doesn't flow out as fast. And that's an issue for ranchers.

Speaker 3:

You know, they need late season flows for their agriculture. And so there's a lot of reasons to try to build these landscapes up, not just for the sake of, like, oh, they're, you know, they're they're pretty or we like Beaver. I mean, they are pretty, and we do like Beaver. But, you know, the... Of the wider streams and the the...

Speaker 3:

They they say valley floor to valley floor where you get... Or or some valley wall to valley wall, like these big meandering streams with all sorts of side channels on them. Those are much moisture systems, so those can act as fire breaks. They're holding up water. There's a lot of benefits, and that's that's true of, restoration in general.

Speaker 3:

A lot of the restoration that practitioners implement have an economic basis to them. We can talk about forest restoration, so a lot of forest thinning to get rid of a lot of the underbrush and the small trees that have all grown up close to each other and the way the clear cutting because those are... Those create big problems with wildfire. You know, you go elsewhere in the world and people have deforested mangroves, but those act as barriers to storm surges during hurricanes. So there's all these things that nature does for us.

Speaker 3:

They're called ecosystem services. And when you destroy those things and you remove them, then, you know, humans suffer too from that. We... These things benefit us, and and people have done estimates on ecosystem services, and they're in the trillions of dollars. Like, it's very hard to to to rebuild these services without the help of the intact ecosystem.

Speaker 3:

You... There's no real shortcut for, like, for instance, protecting a coastline from storm surges without those mangrove forests there. And so, you know, this is this is one of the kind of my kind of pet peeves about the way people think about, like, ecology versus humans, and people often think of it as, like, this dichotomy where it's either or, but it's really... I think people are starting to realize more and more it's like it's both and. Like, we get all these benefits from nature, and and that's part of what we're trying to do out here.

Speaker 3:

Like, we have ranchers on board to what we're doing. This property had the cattle removed, but Reese works with lots of ranchers who have a lot of concerns and can see the value of reestablishing beaver on their properties. And so, yeah, there's just a lot to be gained from ecological restoration from a human perspective. You know, both coming out and practicing it, if you come out and do it, you you... It will...

Speaker 3:

You will feel better as a human being. Going out, you know... In fact, I was just listening to a podcast about antidepressant drugs, and this psychiatrist was saying, you know, get up and get out and get moving, and you'll feel better. And it's true. It's like you can get out and do restoration.

Speaker 3:

It'll make you feel better as a person. So there's all sorts of, like, benefits to the practitioner, to humanity as a whole, and all sorts of reasons why we're doing it. It's not just... This isn't just beaver conservation.

Speaker 2:

And as I've learned from both of you today, out here in the field, it's much more difficult than just saying we're going to come out here and restore the landscape. There's a lot of trial and error that occurs or planting that occurs that you think that this is your moment. This is what's going to establish a permanent family of beaver here, but then you come back and all the trees are gone. And it wasn't enough. So can you talk about that?

Speaker 2:

How there isn't necessarily a one size fits all solution to this type of work? It's a lot of trial and error, and a lot of learnings that still need to be had.

Speaker 4:

I'll talk about that. I think the example we were looking at is that a number of trees have been planted like in the thousands really and where the beavers had settled, it still wasn't enough. And was part of my interest in coming out here was to see a year and a half later how much of the forage had been depleted and indeed we saw bare stumps. So beavers need a lot of food. And that, I think, was one of the learnings within the restoration industry, if you will, because it has become an industry in many cases where there's a popular refrain to just add BDAs.

Speaker 4:

A BDA is a beaver dam analog, and it functions like like woody debris, it simulates a beaver down or it attempts to simulate a beaver dam. And that's been popularized especially in the West is to add beaver dam analogs. But in order to to activate process based restoration and so that the system can respond and begin to heal herself. And what we forget about is that beavers don't eat BDAs. They don't eat structures.

Speaker 4:

They eat the plants that go into those systems. And many of these, especially high desert kind of Western streams, have been so depleted and they're so devoid of a forage source that the tree planting is really important. And beavers need anywhere from two to 3,000 pounds, a beaver family, anywhere from two to 3,000 pounds of food a year which is if you were to take a half mile of home base kind of a territorial area that they'll defend and live in, it is about five acres of food to sustain them indefinitely. So when we came out here today with our visits and saw that they had already depleted the amount of forage that was provided for them, It just clued me in that we should be planting even more forage than we're already planting, especially in a system that doesn't have forage to begin with, which is a case on a lot of our high desert streams that are... Have really challenging late season drought conditions, and it's really hard to get this forage reestablished.

Speaker 4:

So that was one of one of my big learnings today was we need more... We need even more forage planted, more food planted than we think that we do. And that's a takeaway and a message I'm trying to bring to other restoration practitioners. Don't just rely on this structure and some of the conventional practices being promoted, but it's more complex than that. And there's more to it in terms of how we can support these beavers to reestablish on the landscape successfully.

Speaker 2:

One of the things I find most interesting about these BDAs, the Beaver Dam Analogs that you're talking about is they're synthetic and man made and inserted in with large posts and machinery goes into it and they're difficult to build. And in order to make them work, and Matt, know you'll speak to this, they need a lot of maintenance. But what's interesting, and we've seen it in this location that we're at, is beavers will sometimes adopt these BDAs and maintain them and repair them on your behalf. How inch... Is that a learning for you?

Speaker 2:

Did you expect Beavers to adopt these BDAs? And is it difficult for them to repair it if they didn't originally build them?

Speaker 3:

Well, one thing I would say, just to add on to what Reese was saying, is, you know, her seeing how much of the forage that the Oregon Natural Desert Association came in here at the same time we built our structures, and they did a a good job in a very challenging location to try to get willow reestablished, a little bit of cottonwood, some aspen, some alder. Is there anything else in there?

Speaker 4:

Dogwood, currant.

Speaker 3:

Dogwood, currant. Yeah. So these are all these types, these vegetation types that grow in what we call the riparian zone next to the stream. More importantly, these are woody riparian species, so they have woody tissue as opposed to just soft tissue. And that woody tissue is partly what beavers eat, especially in the winter.

Speaker 3:

And then also that woody material is clearly what they put into dams if they're trying to build dams. And so it's really hard to have beaver in a system without woody riparian vegetation, and it's very hard to have beavers building dams in a system without woody riparian vegetation. And, you know, one of the things that we learned today going out and seeing how much of this woody veg that had been, established by Oregon Natural Desert Association had grown up fairly large and was fairly abundant. A lot of it has been taken out now by beavers. They got it.

Speaker 3:

They opened up one of the fences. There's still like two more enclosures there that are full of vegetation that the beaver can't really get into yet. But they opened up one cupboard, and the beaver ate everything in that cupboard pretty much. And that's something we learned... This is ten years after we started this project.

Speaker 3:

And so things are still happening in this project ten years later. Like, another thing that's happened was after we stopped maintaining our structure, we had our... We built five Beaver Dam Analogs here on this site. And after we stopped maintaining those structures, and we had spent a lot of time trying to maintain them, I thought they were just going to they weren't holding up on their own. We were putting a lot of time into them.

Speaker 3:

But as we were doing that, that vegetation was also growing. And so coincidentally, the beaver had the vegetation available about the same time we stopped maintaining them. And so the beaver actually, yeah, took over maintenance. But that didn't... We didn't really understand that was happening until, like, eight years after our project had started.

Speaker 3:

And so this just speaks to one of the biggest things about restoration. It's sort of like if you, you if you go to the doctor and there's something wrong with you and the doctor gives you some medication, you don't just walk away and never go back to the doctor. And so we come in here and we try to work on these streams and figure out what's wrong with them and then there's an intervention of some sort. But too often in restoration, people just walk away from the project. They don't go back to it.

Speaker 3:

They don't try to figure out how this system is evolving. And and and that's partly because it's hard to fund projects long term. Was the case when I first started getting involved in restoration, and it's still the case now. And so one of the big things missing... So you were asking about kind of like our frustrations or like how do things go wrong?

Speaker 3:

Well, one thing that goes wrong is people don't even know that thing... Anything went wrong. Like, they never go back to their project and figure out what had happened to it. And there needs to be in this field... And I said earlier, this is a pretty young scientific discipline.

Speaker 3:

It really only came into its own at the end of the last century. And and even though it's... I think it's it's quite widely recognized that there's not enough follow-up that's done. So these two things in restoration, the two terms would be monitoring, which is easy to understand. And then the other one is adaptive management, where you go in and you you figure out what happened, then you make some changes, you shift it around.

Speaker 3:

And you probably work, like, in the case of beaver based restoration, you probably work kind of like a beaver. Like, beaver builds the dam, then it realizes there's a leak over there, it has to go do that. And then it might realize that wasn't a great site and needs to go somewhere else. But, like, that's kind of what we need to be doing more than just trying to come up with these, like, single prescriptions that aren't followed through on enough. And then the other problem with not enough monitoring is we don't learn enough, so we don't learn from our mistakes.

Speaker 3:

And and so I... I'm really... This is part of the reason I I really like working with with Reese and seeing what practitioners are doing on the landscape because they're out there doing a lot. And then, you know, I can get my students out there. We do a lot of follow-up monitoring with my students.

Speaker 3:

So that's something where the students can learn a lot and get that value of restoration. But, you know, they're taking a class. And so getting a 10 person work crew out for two days on something is very expensive, but I can go and monitor it with my students. But more of this needs to happen. The the field needs to become better integrated in terms of the on the ground practice with the follow-up science and measurement and then giving the information needed to, like, either fix that particular project or at least learn why it went wrong so people aren't just making the same mistakes over and over again.

Speaker 3:

That's probably the... In my opinion, that's probably the biggest problem in the field right now is there's just not enough... People haven't figured out how to follow-up on projects enough.

Speaker 2:

One thing that you both have alluded to in this conversation is how out of lack these landscapes are and have been, especially since settlement and grazing has occurred. So when you're talking about restoration, are you trying to restore it to a healthy, state of where we're going or where the climate is going? Or is restoration the goal of trying to get it pregrazing and pre settlement? And if so, how do you understand how this landscape worked when that was at this point a hundred years ago or several hundred years ago when it was

Speaker 3:

in its healthiest form? Wallet restoration, there's something called a reference ecosystem. And you... A reference ecosystem is this... Is...

Speaker 3:

It doesn't even necessarily have to be a physical location. It can be sleuthing that you do through historical photos or descriptions of the landscape. It could be... Like, if it's a forest, you could go through the stump record. Like, there's still enough standing stumps there that you can, like, look at tree rings or at least learn something about how the trees were spaced and how big the trees were at that time.

Speaker 3:

You... But then reference ecosystems can also be sites that just haven't received the same level of disturbance. So it could be like a a mesa that's really inaccessible to grazing if you wanna understand what the understory looked like without disturbance from cattle. So you you try to sleuth that out as best you can, and and and and usually, that's a that's a pre, like, anthropogenic disturbance state where we we... The the baseline gets set to, like, pre European, which is, in some ways, kinda strange because we know now that Native American people also had big impacts on their landscape.

Speaker 3:

But also coincident with that is these reference conditions are often just conditions that are also beneficial to humans. So we're... I mean, I've already said about, like, these these these reference condition stream systems didn't have the same issues with, you know, losing water late in the summer and things like that. Pre European forests, a lot of them weren't as prone to catastrophic wildfires. So in restoration, we set it to pre European baseline.

Speaker 3:

You try to infer what it was. And then also what your question kind of alluded to is, where do we go from here, given that there's climate change? And these are all questions that restoration ecologists struggle with. Yeah. You wanna say anything about that?

Speaker 4:

Honestly don't think that hard about it because it's hard to it's hard to know. I mean, there might be a certain species that we might be more inclined to plant that we think could do better in the future with less water and hotter climates. But I'm mostly just looking for how do we support beavers and how do we get an upward trajectory in terms of the land begin... Beginning to be able to heal herself? So small interventions, regular interventions, a lot of monitoring, and then sitting back and watching to see what's happening and how the land is responding and then looking to see if more interventions are required.

Speaker 4:

I'm not thinking thirty years down the road as to whether I should be planting x, y, or z. It seems an impossible task

Speaker 3:

to do that. It depends somewhat on the system too. Like, with beaver based restoration, it it... I think most people would agree, if not everybody, would agree that these systems are more more resilient to climate change if you can get beaver back in there, expanding the riparian zone, holding up water. There are some issues around whether beaver ponds get hotter and that maybe that can become more of a problem with climate change.

Speaker 3:

But I think most people see beaver based restoration as something that will help to act as a a buffer against climate change. But then there are restoration... You know, there's other areas of restoration where these questions become a little bit more difficult to deal with. So another sort of system I work in is like upland restoration. So now we're talking about dry land restoration.

Speaker 3:

And people have addressed that with... Well, we've begun to address that more with what are called seed zones, which is even if it's the same species spread across North America, it may be there are some areas where it has specific genetic adaptations to be in a drier environment and has adaptations to be in a wetter environment, even though it's considered to be the same species. And so restorationists invented these things. Actually, it was it was invented by Ben Forestry for planting Douglas fir and other tree species in the... I think in the Cascades even, perhaps.

Speaker 3:

But the idea was that if you just take a Douglas fir from low elevation and you you take seed from there and you put it up at high elevation for replanting a forest, it's not gonna do as well. And so they've actually figured out all these seed zones based on local genetic adaptation of the same species and figured out, like, you don't wanna take low elevation duck burr and put it up into this seed zone. They mapped all those out, and they've done something similar for dry land plants now. But the problem is, as you alluded to, is climate change is gonna throw all those seed zones into chaos. And so that's where there's a lot of uncertainty there, I would say, in terms of thinking about the climate change in the future.

Speaker 3:

And maybe less so would be rebased restoration, where it seems like, yeah, this is probably something we should be doing because it's gonna be good for climate change in most locations.

Speaker 4:

And I would say one thing we are doing is drawing from diverse species. So taking from different climates, different altitudes for our source materials and making sure that we've got a variety of different species, different altitudes in the planting materials that we're using because ultimately, they... Some may do better than others.

Speaker 2:

So diving deeper into beaver specific restoration, beavers have really become kind of a conservation champion, a climate change hero. They're often referred to as engineers and firefighters and all these attributes attributed towards them. Reese, when we were talking off camera, there's... To you, there's a little unfairness there because the beaver is just doing what the beaver knows what to do. That's how it's programmed and how...

Speaker 2:

That's how it acts. You think there's, an unfair pressure associated with just trying to plop beavers wherever we see fit because we think they're gonna fix all of our issues?

Speaker 4:

I do. So beavers have their own reasons for doing things and we lose sight of that in this discussion. We we messed up the landscape with our actions and our activities over the years. We've we've broken our systems and now suddenly beavers are the panacea. And I agree these systems don't work.

Speaker 4:

They don't function without the beavers back on the land, the beavers who built them. But to be thoughtful about the... What are the root causes of their absence? It's because they don't have enough habitat or it's because we haven't learned how to adapt our infrastructure to be able to live in harmony with the beavers. And so if those are root causes, how does relocating beavers from point a to point b actually solve that cause?

Speaker 4:

It doesn't. What it does is if you have a place where beavers want to be and you pull them out of that place, nature abhors a vacuum and you'll probably have another pair of beavers in there within a year or two. So trapping them out or relocating them from a problem site usually doesn't solve the problem for that site. You'll have other beavers come back in. And then also we know that when you move beavers into another place, when it's incredibly stressful on the beavers, they often don't like being dropped into a whole new location where they don't know forage, they don't know water, they don't know the the conditions of where to fend for themselves and how to set up a home.

Speaker 4:

So it's highly stressful. They're a very shy creature. So to think that we can just relocate beavers all over the landscape and not attend to their needs or be realistic about what the outcomes might be seems really foolhardy to me. So really my focus and my emphasis with people is understand where the beavers are on the land, what their goals are to have their own agency. The reasons for doing what they do is reproductive fitness and having secure place that they can be, and then looking at those strongholds of beaver activities where they're already existing.

Speaker 4:

And our job and our responsibility is to prepare the land for them to be as successful as as they can be at that site, but also for dispersing into new connected areas of the landscape. Also, by taking that kind of pond view, if you will, and starting with the beavers that you already have in place as a strategy, it helps you to prioritize your restoration dollars a lot more effectively because you're not putting money kind of in an ad hoc random way into restoration project A, B, or C, but you're looking more long term at a watershed scale at building habitat and connectivity. And then how do you prioritize that so the beavers themselves can be the engine of their recovery rather than thinking that we're going to just add some forage and add some structure and drop some beavers in and have them be successful. We're already seeing across the country that really that doesn't work very well. So I'm I'm really working to shift the narrative and think more about how do we responsibly support these beavers in place and prepare the land for their arrival and also prepare these communities for their arrival too.

Speaker 2:

They're not just tools and

Speaker 4:

They're not just tools. They have their own agency and their own reasons for doing what they do.

Speaker 2:

And when they do what they do, just by happenstance, we reap a lot of benefits from them building their own habitats and communities. Can you talk about... And, Amal, you covered some of them, but can you talk about some of those benefits that we as people receive? But more importantly, biodiversity skyrockets when they build their own habitats and they build a place where they can thrive. And so what does biodiversity look like?

Speaker 2:

Why does biodiversity start to thrive when beavers are allowed to do what they need to do?

Speaker 4:

Well, when we look at the Eastern Oregon landscape and the Sagebrush Steppe and Oregon has a statewide... What's the SWAP, Wildlife. Their priorities for species of concern and species they want to conserve whether it's at a state level or a federal level. And 80% of the animals in the Sagebrush Steppe and the flora and fauna rely on the types of habitat that beavers provide. So as we know water is life, Beaver dams, beaver activities spread that water on the landscape.

Speaker 4:

They slow the water on the landscape. They re wet the sponge. So not only do you get more diverse species coming in from flora and fauna, but with a wetter sponge, we have a natural buffer for wildfire, for example. So we've been hit very hard this summer by wildfire in many of our beaver sites, and we're already seeing riparian vegetation response just within the last four weeks of the riparian woodies coming in where the beaver dams are still holding up, still ponding, still holding water on the land, and the vegetative response has been incredible. So not only can they slow down the wildfire from spreading on these big wetter areas, And then during the wildfire, they also provide refugia, the ponds do, for animals to come and escape from the impending fire as it's approaching.

Speaker 4:

They can jump into those creeks and those streams that are wetted by the beaver ponds. So not only are we seeing the benefits during the fire, but also post fire, having that rewetted floodplain is helping for the system to more quickly recover and and have more riparian vegetation response for all of the animals to benefit from.

Speaker 2:

When we talk about the reference ecosystem, were there, you know, significantly more riparian zones and areas even within this landscape that we're at now?

Speaker 3:

Yeah. I mean, you go down to Prineville, and there's... If you just stand in Prineville and look where the the valley walls are coming in, like, that entire area was probably all wetted. Like, I mean, and that's miles across. And now the stream's confined down to this one little channel.

Speaker 3:

And a lot of that was done for agriculture. And, of course, we still need agriculture, and so some of that's never gonna come back. And there's human infrastructure built there now. But, yeah, historically, this has been one of the newer things in stream restoration, is this idea that streams historically weren't just these static, they call them single thread channels, but that they were... The channels with themselves were dynamic.

Speaker 3:

So, you know, moving across landscape as floods came through and reworked the topography, but also have this this formation that's not necessarily just one channel, but lots of side channels and lots of little wetlands off to the side. And so these these zones would have been much larger at one time, wider.

Speaker 4:

Yeah. I mean, when you go back and look at us, we talked about Hudson's Bay Company. It was two hundred years, like, 1826 that the army or the snake expedition, snake river expeditions came through this watershed year after year to trap out the beaver very intentionally. And they described trying to move their horses and their wagons through these big wetted flood plains. Settlers that came into this area in the eighteen fifties talk about stirrup high grasses and the challenges of getting through these big wetland complexes that were created by the beavers and hadn't quite been destroyed entirely yet with beavers' absence.

Speaker 4:

So there's a really good record. Even the general land office talks about all these riparian willow communities and plant communities from Beavers. So there's many reference conditions from this watershed even of what the land used to look like before we straighten the streams for agriculture or even the Army Corps of Engineers as recently as as 1964 made a a huge push throughout the West to straighten streams as well in order to evacuate water from the flood plains. And so what we had with the beavers were more water catchments where the water was caught on the land, would wet the land, wet the sponge, and we turn those into watersheds or what we call drainages now. And so if you just think about that shift in the language, it helps you to think about all of our engineering and our infrastructure and our economies have been built around shedding water off the land.

Speaker 4:

Now with drought and the climate changing over time, now we want water back on the land, and I think that's why beavers are being so popularized as as the hero to potentially solve our problems. But without really understanding what the beavers' needs are, what they need from us, and what's our responsibility to them to prepare the land, I think we're gonna have suboptimal restoration outcomes if we're just coming at it from a what can the beaver do for us point of view.

Speaker 2:

We know beavers build dams. We also know they build lodges that they stay in. How exactly do they do this?

Speaker 4:

They are driven by water. So they have an environmental sense of the world. We all do. Right? It's it's...

Speaker 4:

I think there's a word word for it called the Nungweld. Like, what is our lived experience and perception. So we're driven a lot by sight, by sound, and smell. And there, what really drives them is the feel of water. Water is safety for them.

Speaker 4:

They have webbed feet in the back and they have five digits on the front that act a lot like our hands, but the webbed feet in the back occupy 10% of their body size. So it's almost like wearing scuba fins. If you were to walk across the land, try running in scuba fins. And so a predator at top speed can run 30 miles an hour, a beaver can run seven miles an hour on land, but in water they can move a lot more quickly than that. So every waking moment is driven by security and safety, and the further they get away from water, the more vulnerable they are to predators.

Speaker 4:

So they're always thinking about how can I impound water, how can I slow it down and create enough escape cover is what we call it, so that if a predator comes in, the predator won't come in and pull me out of the water? That's really their number one escape mechanism is being surrounded by water. So with that, what they'll look for is during a low flow is to put sticks in the water, they'll put it parallel with the water, they'll start from the sides, and they'll work their way into the center where the highest stream power is. And then they'll start using mud and rocks and other materials. I've seen hubcaps.

Speaker 4:

I've seen remnants from old restoration projects. I've seen There's huge...

Speaker 3:

Like I said earlier, the repair job they did downstream on one of our BDAs had this huge... It looked like a like a ceiling beam from a barn where it's just like

Speaker 4:

They'll use whatever.

Speaker 3:

I don't even know where they got that.

Speaker 4:

Whatever they can get to build the... To build those dams in place. And so as they do that, they wanna raise the water level to create a pond to create that escape cover. And then like we were talking about earlier, Joey, is that they'll create multiple dams. So I mentioned a half mile sort of thereabouts as a territorial home base.

Speaker 4:

They may have five dams in there. May... They may have 20 dams in there. But with each dam that they build, they're looking to get better access to more forage closer to water. So the thought is that within about 25 to 30 feet of water and even a little bit further is their comfort level for forest for foraging on those woody vegetative species.

Speaker 4:

When they start getting beyond 50, 75, or a 100 feet, they're way more vulnerable because it's harder to run back to the safety of the stream. So dam building and then also canal building is another way that they can stay safe in the water away from predators. They also can float materials better, which is why they build their canals. Right? So if they have, let's say, an aspen grove that looks tasty off in the distance, they'll build a canal to that aspen grove, and it usually starts with a pathway to go access that, but over time, it turns into a canal.

Speaker 4:

If you have a wetted canal, you can more easily transport materials back into the safety of that pond to be able to then eat it and make use of it.

Speaker 3:

So Reese mentioned the Umwelt, u m w l t, I believe. It's a German term for just kinda like your lived environment. And like... So I've seen... There there are these things called Unwelt diagrams, which, like, re...

Speaker 3:

They re... They'll they'll take like a human, and then they'll redo the human with body parts exaggerated based on their innervation, like how many nerves they have going into their body, into those... So, like, the human will have these gigantic hands and... But, you know, just so your... Maybe your listeners can relate better to this idea of these beaver just having this urge to, you know, build near water and create this habitat.

Speaker 3:

But... And, you know, there... There's another thing about beavers don't like the sound of trickling water. Right? That that...

Speaker 3:

It... That kind of stimulates their dam building instinct that suggests there's a leak somewhere. But, like, we humans do the same thing. Like, if you think about where's the high priced real estate in Bend, Oregon? It's the houses that are right along the river.

Speaker 3:

You're gonna pay a lot more just to have that view. It's literally... And you may never even go swimming in that river. But just the idea that river's there, it's like... Humans would have had the same thing.

Speaker 3:

Like, if you think of us back when we... You know, we're living a very existent... Of different existence as hunter gatherers. Like, having access to water would have been essential. And so the idea that your house...

Speaker 3:

Even these days, we have these relic instincts that... There are these papers out showing that people can be shown different images of trees, and universally, people like these tree images that are... They're very climbable, and and... But also produce shade. And they're the types of trees that, like, when we were evolving in in in what's called our environment of evolutionary adaptiveness.

Speaker 3:

These would have been things where you could climb quickly to get away from a predator. They would have provided shade. And so, like, even tree architecture is something that perhaps our brains are, like, attuned to. And so, you know, the beaver are just doing, you know, what evolution has selected for in terms of their cognition, and building dams is beneficial to them. Another...

Speaker 3:

One other benefit that I hadn't heard of that... So I'd always heard the, you know, the whole thing about beavers build dams so they have cover so that they can, you know, away from predators and also get out to forage more easily, which is true. But then the other thing that I didn't appreciate until we built these Beaver Dam Analogs was another... And this may be a side effect of the dam or it may be, you know, a a key piece of why these dams are adaptive to them, but the dams actually... In a way, they're they're...

Speaker 3:

Indirectly, they're doing irrigation when they build these dams because they raise the water level. And that raised water level expands the amount of area where this riparian vegetation can grow. And we don't necessarily appreciate that piece of it as much because we see the stream. We see the dam. We see the water raised behind the dam.

Speaker 3:

But... And this is one thing I've come to appreciate just by doing this work out here. It's like when we first started building our dams, we put in these groundwater wells. And, actually, my first groundwater wells out here were literally as crude as... I just dug holes in the stream bank out next to the structure down until I got to the water.

Speaker 3:

Then we put in the Beaver Dam Analogs, and you can watch the water in that hole. It's it's not in the channel. It's off in the bank, and you can just watch that water come up in the hole after you've built your dam. And so that that kind of water is supporting vegetation too. So the Beavers aren't just...

Speaker 3:

You know, one benefit of those dams is obviously stay away from predators, but they may also be, like, actively kind of in a way farming this vegetation by irrigating it.

Speaker 4:

That's a conversation that I've had with with other folks too. Are they are they active farmers? Are they really thinking about what the outcomes are here? The other thing I wanna add to, and and maybe this is the place for it, is that if we think about the beavers that are on this landscape, these are the survivors. They have survived.

Speaker 4:

You know, this is seven... What is it? Two hundred years. It's not seven generations. That would be in human terms.

Speaker 4:

But the animals who are out here, they know how to navigate these waters. They're the survivors from two hundred years ago being extirpated. They're the ones that have figured out how to stay away from predators, how to stay away from trappers, how to not get shot by the local person looking to pop shop shot at them. So they're real survivors, and that's another reason why we want to continue to support them is they've learned these systems. They know these systems, and they know how to work within the hydrology, the sediment, and all of the other things that they have going against them.

Speaker 4:

And they've got that going for them, and they're almost like in their DNA of how to navigate this area. If you were to take a beaver here and put him into the coastal range, how would he fare? I don't know because generationally, that's not in their that's not in their system. So I think that's something that I think about too is that these are the remaining survivors of the ones that have come before and how tough they are.

Speaker 3:

They've they've shown that with this stream here because they... There are smallmouth bass and other undesired fish species in the South Fork. And I think it was back in the seventies, they poisoned the whole stream to try to get the undesired fish species out. And then they thought, oh, yeah. We'll just take some rainbow trout from somewhere else and pop them in.

Speaker 3:

They have not been able to establish a sort of healthy population of red band trout in this stream since then. And I think a big piece of it is they're just... Other populations just aren't adapted to this particular stream habitat. It's, you know, it's it's a spring fed stream. It gets pretty warm.

Speaker 3:

And taking... You can't just take a trout because it looks the same to us and expect it to work the same way if you introduce it here. And so these are all the things we learn as humans when we make these mistakes, and hopefully, we're learning more and more. You know, I worked with those parasitic flies as bio... We've...

Speaker 3:

We went down to South America where where there are... The the main ant species we work on were fire ants that have... That invaded North America in the early nineteen hundreds, and we were looking at these flies as potentially biological control agents of the ants. And the flies attack the ant. They put an egg into its...

Speaker 3:

Up underneath its exoskeleton, and then the maggot hatches out, and it eats the entire inside of the ant. And then it pupates inside the ant's head capsule, and then the adult fly emerges out of the the head... Out of the mouth of the ant. And we thought, you know, are these are these potentially good? Because the ants came up to North America without the flies.

Speaker 3:

And so the idea was, well, do... Could we go down there and get these flies and bring them up and and use them as biocontrol? Well, every time I told people what I was doing, people now realize, because they've seen cane toads, they've seen all sorts of cases where species are relocated to places they shouldn't be, and it hasn't worked out so well. And so people would always say, well, do those flies really belong? What'll happen if you move them around like that?

Speaker 3:

So people have become... That's a big shift from even land managers and wildlife agencies making those decisions, like introducing mongooses to Hawaii. People have become more sophisticated. Even just the general public have become way more sophisticated about thinking about these things. And in the case of our flies, we did very extensive host specificity testing, and they would only attack this one species of ant.

Speaker 3:

But, you know, we learn as we go along, and I think that's another thing about restoration and this whole decade of restoration, the whole idea that humans have made what you could call mistakes. But at the time, people were settling the West, and people needed farmland, and we did all these things and didn't necessarily understand what the consequences would be. And now, we're trying to fix some of those errors and restabilize some of these habitats. So you live and learn. And that's another nice thing about restoration is you're both responding to these sort of impacts of the past, things that have had unanticipated consequences.

Speaker 3:

You're out feeling like you can do something about it. So it can be a very positive thing because you feel like you're out making a difference. And often, you can see the difference very concretely. And so you're responding to mistakes of the past, then that piece of ecological restoration that I'd like to see better emphasizes, let's also respond to the mistakes that we make while we're doing the restoration. Like, let's go monitor it, and let's figure out what we did wrong this time so that we can do it better next time, and keep that being an iterative process.

Speaker 2:

One thing I always find fascinating with these types of conversations is nature always reveals how interconnected it is every time. You know, you you had mentioned that the beaver is just looking after the beaver. It's doing these things because it's trying to find protection and build habitat for itself, but it has all these cascading effects when it does do that. But going upstream from the beaver, you know, beavers within Rocky Mountain National Park are really struggling because there's no large predators to control the population of elk and moose. And so those species are eating all the willow, and so the beaver don't have anything to eat or build with.

Speaker 2:

And so there's all these cascading effects that lead into one species. So when we try to solve something for one species, it's ultimately going to affect something either upstream or downstream from that. Do you always find that fascinating when you're doing this restoration work? Just... Feels like when you press one toggle, something else untoggles....

Speaker 2:

Depressing? Both.

Speaker 3:

I mean, I would say, like, you know, you said upstream and downstream, but it's even more complicated than that because... And this is something that people know, I think, very little about. This is... I'm aware of very few papers on this, and we've looked into it a little bit. But it's not just the stream that we're talking about here because of this idea of the connectedness of ecosystems and all the ecological interconnections.

Speaker 3:

And so when you get a rainfall event out here, it's not... There aren't just storm clouds over the stream. Like, it's raining over the whole habitat, and the hillsides around here become very degraded. There used to be something called cryptogamic crust, which are all these little small, plants that are... And maybe not always even just plants, microbes too that cover the soils and form this kind of sponge right on top of the soil.

Speaker 3:

And then, historically, you have these big native bunch grass populations. And the... And so what we call... So there's the stream, the riparian zone, and then there's what we call the uplands, which is outside the riparian zone. And the uplands are very degraded too.

Speaker 3:

And so it wasn't just the streams that got degraded by human activities. And so when you get rainfall events, that water now hits a more degraded upland, where there's not as much vegetation to absorb that moisture, and so it rushes down into the stream, and you get higher, more powerful stream flows. And so then, that has effects on your efforts at restoration because... And this is what we experienced here is our structures that we built just after high flow years, and you get a good high flow year every three years, they just get blown out. And you've to go in and do all this work to try to rebuild them or maintain them.

Speaker 3:

And so, that's a lot of where this whole idea of building these Beaver Dam Analogs came from originally, was this watershed over here called Bridge Creek, not that far from where we are. It's to the north of us. And the problem there, that had been documented for like a decade and a half, was that Beaver Dams just weren't lasting. They were getting high flow events. The Beaver Dams were getting blown out.

Speaker 3:

And so that was kind of... In a sense, that was kind of the genesis of Beaver Dam Analogs is people went in. You know, there's been other ways that they've been experimented before that, but the way we understand them now or working with them now, that was kind of the project in Bridge Creek, where they went in and built Beaver Dam Analogs, and it seemed to stimulate the Beaver building activity and maybe give them a more stable framework to work on. And they made some big impacts in Bridge Creek via the interaction between the Beaver Dam Analogs and the beaver. So the researchers themselves didn't attribute it to just putting in the Beaver Dam Analogs.

Speaker 3:

It was those two things. It was the human intervention combined with the beaver response. And I think some people have lost sight of of that, you know, that the beavers are involved too.

Speaker 4:

Let me stay on Bridge Creek just because I have the opportunity to... Because it is touted as this great BDA success story of having... The structure in. There were already beavers throughout that whole system because there have been twenty years of tree planting. So they actually had a food food source in there and that gets forgotten and not discussed in much of the research that there was a strong food and forage base in that system.

Speaker 4:

So when the BDAs did go in, that they already had food in there that they would then interact with those BDAs. I just think that's important to share because I think it's a lot... Lost a lot. Yeah. And so I get a lot of phone calls from people who have put BDAs in, and the beavers aren't showing up.

Speaker 4:

And where are the beavers? We put our BDAs in. There's no beavers. And so that's how we're learning is beavers don't eat BDAs, and we need we need a forage source for them.

Speaker 2:

Do you believe that beavers, regardless if there's a BDA there or not, long as they have the forage source, they're gonna make their dams

Speaker 4:

out Absolutely. If they have food in there, they will settle. Now whether they'll be successful or not, it depends a lot on the hydrology and how those big streamflow events are, and then also the geomorphology of the land. And can the water spread out over the land and help dissipate some of that energy. But if there's a food source there, that's where they'll be.

Speaker 4:

I mentioned to you earlier the contiguous stream surveys that we had done showing that it was 53 out of 83 miles had the capacity for forage or excuse me, had the capacity for the good geomorphology and good hydrology, that in theory the beavers could occupy those areas as optimal areas, but in fact they were only occupying four miles of stream because in the remaining amount there was no food in there. So they will always settle in a place with forage. They won't always settle in a place with structure alone because they just don't have the ability to eat and be nutritionally robust and and reproductively fit.

Speaker 2:

I found this part of the conversation really interesting because I think, Matt, earlier off camera, you had told me that you think BDAs are most effective when used as purely a a tool for science, for measuring how stream flow and and other things related to the stream. Do you think that they're better used just for science as opposed to for the purpose of supplying habitat for beavers?

Speaker 3:

No. All I was saying is that this particular project here, we didn't have any illusions about whether we were gonna be restoring the South Fork Of The Crooked River. Although there was a Ben Bulletin headline that came out last year that said, Beavers reclaim South Fork Of Crooked River. So it's actually kinda funny that it was an overblown headline. But it was also...

Speaker 3:

There is some there is some interesting stuff happening out here in terms of the interaction between our BDAs, the veg, and the beaver. But we were mostly... This project was a scientific project aimed at trying to understand the effects of structures and questions about what they would do to hydrology, supporting vegetation built next to the structure. But, you know, you're not gonna restore a watershed with five structures. We just wanted to know on a on a just purely structure by structure basis whether we could have very localized effects.

Speaker 3:

If you want to have a bigger landscape level effect, you're going to probably have to put in a lot more structures. Although, are a lot of projects out there that don't have very many structures. That's probably another thing. Is your... If your project only involves a small number of structures, are you likely to be successful, you know, getting some sort of landscape level effect?

Speaker 3:

And you you probably you probably aren't. But like the Bridge Creek project, that had over a 100 BDAs in it. Do you remember the exact number?

Speaker 4:

It was 12 miles, and I think it was about a 110 thereabouts.

Speaker 3:

So, you know, that's bigger. I mean, we've learned from this project that if you did go in with a lot of money and a lot of BDAs, you could probably have much more of a significant effect. You'd need to do a lot more planting. The planting piece and getting veg established, I think that's something that maybe we haven't discussed enough because Reese earlier said, you got involved out here through a project where you were planting beaver forage. Right?

Speaker 3:

And and... But but the the key about planting beaver forage is that you gotta get all the timing right. Like, if you're just going out there planting and the beaver come through a week later and like, oh, beaver forage, then you haven't established anything. And that actually literally did happen here. So we I was out for one of these planting parties, and we put some willow bundles under a fence because they had to go down to the stream, and we couldn't get them inside the fence.

Speaker 3:

And then I was back, like, a week or two later with my students, and all of those willow bundles had been moved into a... We could look into this Beaver Bank Lodge. You know, it's like a little... And they had taken the willow bundles, and we could see them down in the Beaver Lodge. And so it's like you...

Speaker 3:

Trying to get the vegetation established is really difficult, and then somebody, your listeners might say, well, yeah, just put a fence around it. The problem with that is these big flows come through, and they destroy your fencing. And that's happening every few years. And so getting... So the issue...

Speaker 3:

What... The biggest issue here, and it's like... This is another sort of scientific concept, of this idea of a stable equilibrium. Like, these systems that are really incised, there's not a lot of con... There's not a lot of riparian zone in a lot of places even to plant in because the the stream bank is so steep.

Speaker 3:

And then when you do plant, you might have, you know, sort of itinerant beaver coming through, and they see what you've planted. And they're like, oh, okay. This is good. And, you know, there's not a lot of this out here. And so actually trying to figure out...

Speaker 3:

Like, I I... Honestly, for this spot, like, I... It's it's a little hard to even imagine how you would... Based on some of the approaches we've taken here, you would actually get the system to break out of that stable equilibrium. And so that's another thing I think we should talk about just...

Speaker 3:

Or at least mention in this podcast just to... So your listeners are informed about it. But the alternative to these, like, smaller projects where you plant some... You know, you do some plantings, and then you, you know, build a couple of little BDAs, and everybody goes out and has fun and builds salmon and learns about Beaver and grows as a person. The alternative is you get some bulldozers in here, and you, like, level off some of this stuff, and you...

Speaker 3:

Or you even maybe fill channels and try to bring the stream back more. You know, you basically reconfigure the landscape with heavy machinery. And these projects do happen, and they can be super successful. So there's one at Camp Polk Meadow, was the first one I was familiar with over on Wychoose Creek near Sisters. And that's a completely different approach to beaver based restoration, where you go in with heavy machinery, and you're just like, what do we want this to look like?

Speaker 3:

Now let's build it. The Wycheuse Creek one that they did with bulldozers, they had the vegetation problem solved because they didn't have as many beaver in the system. They fenced... They actually fenced off all of their riparian plantings from deer. So all the way down the creek, they had this huge area fenced off with an electric fence.

Speaker 3:

They were able to leave the stream in this channel that the Army Corps of Engineer engineers had built right down the side of the meadow. And they they built their kinda like dream channel through the meadow. And they actually didn't even push the stream back into it until all those plants had been established with sprinklers for, like, two years. Because then at that point, all the dirt that they'd scraped clean and reconfigured was now covered with vegetation. So they finally...

Speaker 3:

You know, there's this big... There's actually a time lapse image on the Deschutes Land Trust website where they're... Like, the big moment where they just took the bulldozers and they pushed all this stuff into the stream, they they knocked it out of the Army Corps of Engineers channel and into the restored channel. And that project has worked great, and a lot of those projects involving heavy machinery do work great. They're more expensive.

Speaker 3:

They can have some big impacts on the landscape. But but I think in some cases, you know, it's not always these these smaller, like, more, like, you know, light touch approaches. Some of these systems might need a heavy touch in order to go back to where they need to be.

Speaker 2:

I guess a question for both of you is, going back to the BDA, is should they be used specifically for hydrology science? Should they be used for beaver adoption, or should they be used for both?

Speaker 4:

Or other. Right? Heterogeneity of the stream, moving things around, grading fine gravels and and point bars. There's a lot of benefits to BDAs in these stacked systems besides just holding water and then creating irrigated side channels or irrigated

Speaker 3:

So you're saying a BDA that doesn't get adopted by Beaver still can do something Absolutely. As long as it remains relatively intact.

Speaker 4:

I agree. Yes. Yeah.

Speaker 3:

Yeah. Because because it changes in hydrology enough in a system like this where you have a very homogeneous stream where you don't have a lot of riffles. You know? There's just not a lot going on. There are lot of sediment that's just built up on the bottom.

Speaker 3:

You put a structure in of any sort that's that's got any kind of significant effect on the flows, and now you've got maybe some overtopping that does some scouring of those finer sediments out. It leaves behind some gravels. Water rushes around in a certain way and might form a gravel bar on one side and a, you know, sandbar on the other, and those are two different... Distinctly different kinds of habitats. Fish spawn in the gravels, and...

Speaker 3:

So you can create habitat heterogeneity with an unmaintained Beaver Dam Analog, but some of these other effects, you know, in terms of, like, supporting riparian vegetation and so forth, you probably are gonna need to maintain your structures at least for a number of years.

Speaker 4:

You know, I have a a love hate relationship with BDAs. I feel like it... And I've got a few projects I participate in, a few I've designed and implemented, and I feel like one out of four really knock it out of the ballpark. Like, you get the response that you want. Two and four are somewhere in between where you're getting ancillary other responses that are still beneficial and then about one in four is a dud and it's not doing a thing and it's it's super leaky.

Speaker 4:

So I I I still... So you're not getting a 100% success. That's not what I'm seeing. But I'm seeing other benefits, like BDAs can be used for a lot of different things, but I think just knocking the water around and having the stream be able to move around and not stay confined and locked in that channel, I do feel like there's a lot of other benefits that are kick starting process that is more natural rather than just evacuating water from the system.

Speaker 3:

This also, however, goes back to the whole idea of, like, long term monitoring. And so if you put in a structure like that and it doesn't function well and even if... You know, it may get blown out, and it may serve some of those hydrological purposes and change some of the stream bed sediment profile and so forth. But without... You know, longer term than that, like...

Speaker 3:

Because we can go down and see, along here, we've got two failed structures and two structures that have been adopted by Beaver. And then the other structure was taken out by the property owner. And those are behaving super differently. The two ones that have been adopted by Beaver are holding water. They're acting like dams.

Speaker 3:

They're... They've got, like, fairly healthy populations of woody riparian... Restored woody riparian vegetation next to them that they're probably supporting pretty well. And then the structures that have been blown out are doing these things that we've been talking about that are... That have to do with more than just damming water that can be beneficial.

Speaker 3:

But that's still a time scale. And it's like, if there's nothing that they're maintaining that, then over time, you know, twenty years from now, will they still be doing that? Probably not. And so, again, it's a question of... A lot of these boil down to, like, what's the time scale in which you're monitoring?

Speaker 3:

What's your time scale for success and and actual impact? And, like, even these structures that are kinda doing something, but you haven't got beaver back in the system, your woody veg isn't reestablished. The the big thing that we talk about in restoration ecology is this idea of restoration trajectory, and you wanna be able to walk away from your ecosystem and have it on a trajectory that's in line with your goals for that system. And and if it's not, then either your project failed or you need to go back and, like, do adaptive management, keep trying to get it to work. And so I would say that, like, the restoration trajectory for this...

Speaker 3:

These structures that we walked you through today in which you got some images of is low because they're... Even though currently we've got woody veg, we got beavers, they... They're maintaining the dams, there's not enough weaver Right. Vegetation. Yep.

Speaker 3:

And once they're... That woody vegetation, either we keep it fenced, and maybe at some point keeping it fenced will help, but more than... I'd say probably more than likely, they're gonna start getting in the fences or you let them in the fences because it's not clear whether they actually have no woody veg left to eat at this point. They've eaten everything they have easy access to. And so once they've eaten through everything we put out there for them, they're...

Speaker 3:

And and then once there's been a few years of high flow that have that have destroyed those dams and we're not coming back to maintain them, the beavers don't have the wood to maintain them anymore, I think you could say probably pretty realistically that just hands off approach on this location fifty years from now is gonna be pretty much back to where it was before we started. We've learned a lot about restoration by being in here. And like I said, I think if there was more money and you could go in here and really do it up, then there would be... You know, there... You you could kick it out of, you know, that unstable state of unhealthiness.

Speaker 3:

But that state is, like, so persistent right now, and and that's the challenge.

Speaker 4:

But but, I mean, you said yourself this wasn't... Didn't start as a restoration project. This was more a pilot concept. So so the idea that you could go in and add more structure

Speaker 3:

Yeah.

Speaker 4:

Is... And and achieve a different result where maybe you've got an upward trajectory rather than something that

Speaker 3:

You need to get it out of the stable equilibrium and into a different trajectory. You know

Speaker 4:

You need more inputs

Speaker 3:

than what you're key that you said there is you could go back in and do it, but as long as you're having to go back in and doing it, it's not on its own trajectory. So, like, the question is how much work do you have to put in to make that happen? And so this just gets back to what I was saying about, you know, these Beaver based approaches to restoration are much cheaper. They're more light touch. You can do much...

Speaker 3:

A much longer stream reach for way less money. But do they have a stable restoration trajectory? And whereas those heavy equipment projects, although they can they can have problems too. If you if you don't estimate the hydrology correctly, you can have some big problems with those projects. But the...

Speaker 3:

I've seen a bunch of them that look like they are now in an alternative stable state now that is a desired condition. And that's just... People went in with a heavy hand and said, we're just gonna just make this happen.

Speaker 4:

I mean, not to play devil's advocate, but I'm gonna play devil's advocate. The... A lot of these stage zero resets with heavy equipment have not seen a successful beaver return, has been what I'm hearing and what I'm seeing on the land. So what... For example, up on Deep Creek in the Ochicos, beavers have not returned in there.

Speaker 4:

The system appears from the outside for the last ten years, like it's got the right veg. It's got geomorphology. It's got anabranching systems, but the beavers are not persisting in that area. And so I question, if beavers are a restoration goal, that when we do these heavy resets, will there actually be persistent beavers returning?

Speaker 3:

Are you talking about that project, like, right by the campground there? Because I was in there with my students Yeah. This last summer. Mhmm. There's a beaver lodge there.

Speaker 3:

There's a lot of... There was a lot of fresh beaver chew. Now, you know, I don't know what that means exact... There were beaver dams. Another thing to think about, and this is...

Speaker 3:

This gets... This just starts to show you how difficult this can be, is, like, you've got this vast landscape. And you go back and you restore one little spot where beavers work and they can establish. Well, what does that mean for a predator? What does that mean for a predator is there aren't beavers anywhere along here, but hey, every time I go to this spot, I see beavers.

Speaker 3:

And so then actually, if you're only restoring chunks, you're probably gonna have higher predation pressure on your beavers. And so it may be that beavers aren't persisting in those locations just because they're these little predation hotspots. I mean, like, these are all the questions that we just don't even know.

Speaker 4:

Right.

Speaker 3:

You know? And then it just goes to show how difficult a lot of this is. The only thing I'll say beyond that too, though, is, like, it's not as clear that you actually even need the Beaver in those projects once they become established in that alternate state. The... They're, you know, they're probably...

Speaker 3:

You probably wanna get them in there at some point, but those projects don't just, like, evaporate overnight necessarily just because you don't have Beaver in them from the start. Like, there's... You've got time to get Beaver in there and get that system, like, completely functioning back up. Certainly, the ones I've seen are are, like, they look really good. And so, again, it's just...

Speaker 3:

It's kind of this thing of, like, either or, like, what's right for that system? What... You know, making that making that call, and that call isn't just a restoration call, it's a funding call. It's like, what's with this land, with this particular piece of property? There's all sorts of things that go into it.

Speaker 3:

But in some cases, and and this is one thing that Reese is, I think, correctly harping on is there are some places where you just shouldn't try certain things because they're... It's not ready for what you want to have happen there. And so, you know, these are the things that we are, I think, slowly learning.

Speaker 2:

Is that one of those cases where people can over engineer a landscape? You know, you see a landscape and you want a desired outcome for it, we play too much of a hand into that landscape without considering that nature of the landscape, like you said, is not ready for it. Can we over engineer or try to over restore a landscape where that landscape is actively telling us it's not ready for that?

Speaker 4:

Yeah. Absolutely. This is where we go back to adaptive management, like going in one and done and and thinking you're going to achieve x. Do you think we're getting better at more repeat visits, reading the land, seeing what the response is, and responding adaptively, and building a muscle around place and interventions, small interventions that are more process based and just inherent in the way that you're approaching the work. I have seen some of these outcomes too where the...

Speaker 4:

I mean, it looks beautiful up there, but they don't always work the way that they should. And when I think about the price tag, I'm thinking of a project over in Harney County right now. It's three quarters of a mile of stream. They're doing a stage zero reset. They're scraping off the surface of the land and moving a lot of dirt around a hundred hundred thousand cubic yards, I believe the number is, at a price tag of $2,200,000.

Speaker 4:

That's before they've even gone in and replaced any of the vegetation that's in there. So that doesn't seem very scalable. In the Crooked River watershed, we have 12,000 miles of stream. Probably most of it's degraded. You can't spend $2,000,000 per mile of stream and expect to really get any kind of results.

Speaker 4:

Even like we're talking about this project here at South Fork. This is this is one of the headwater streams of the whole Deschutes River Basin. This goes for miles. I don't know the full distance, but this isn't an experimental site. This isn't a restoration site, really.

Speaker 4:

And so treating all of this with heavy equipment... And you can't get the access that you need. That's the other thing. You can't get access into a lot of these sites. So it really kind of goes back to where we started which is hand crews, whether it's paid or volunteer.

Speaker 4:

You know, it took us one hundred and fifty years to screw these systems up. It's not going to be easy to help them move back on their restoration trajectory and any kind of a quick response. They think it needs to take a lot of hands doing the lifting and revisiting over and over again to do a dance with the system in terms of how you can help it get back into that trajectory, that upward trajectory.

Speaker 3:

The only other thing I'd say to that is it's partly how society prioritizes its activities. And so That's true. Like, how many miles were you talking about in the Crooked River?

Speaker 4:

12,000 miles of stream.

Speaker 3:

12,000. So, like, I don't know what that would multiply out to if it was 2,000,000 per mile.

Speaker 4:

Per mile.

Speaker 3:

Okay. Yeah. What does that... I mean, what proportion of The US military budget is that, for instance? Like...

Speaker 3:

So, I mean, it's like... And and and, again, you don't necessarily have to restore everything. All

Speaker 4:

of it. Right.

Speaker 3:

Yeah. I mean, we're one generation trying to learn these things. If we have the long term view, you know, we should be trying to kind of plant the seeds for some sort of longer term process that, you know, go... Is now gonna have to go on for generations.

Speaker 4:

This is generational work. Yeah. Absolutely. Yeah. You're just getting started.

Speaker 3:

Yeah. Yeah. There's a kind of a famous diagram of this these historic stream conditions, and it has to do with how these systems change when you pull the bead route, put the cattle on. And, like, it's all orders of magnitude. So, like, 10 to the zero is one year.

Speaker 3:

And, like, that's the scale over which they get degraded, one to 10. And then and then it shows how they might build back up if you just were hands off over time. Like like, big flows come through, and they widen the channel, and then you get these little inset patches of vegetation. And then, like, over time, time, time, time, maybe you get back to where it started. And, like, that's, like...

Speaker 3:

I think it's, like, 10 to the third of it. It was, like, ten thousand years or something. And so what we're trying to do is do our part to try to accelerate that process. And you might also ask, well, why bother? Why try to accelerate it?

Speaker 3:

And it's partly because of these other things that are happening, you know, like with climate change. We need to build in resilience to climate change. That's one big reason. I don't know. Why else do we need to do it quickly?

Speaker 4:

Not just the let

Speaker 2:

beavers. The beavers.

Speaker 4:

They're on their way. Let's help them along.

Speaker 2:

Reese, earlier you had mentioned that beavers are shy. They're also nocturnal. There's an interesting theory about this. Can you share that?

Speaker 4:

So they've been persecuted largely in North America for the last two hundred years. And one of the explanations that I understand is they... It it was probably the shyer animals that survived extirpation, the ones that were out at night rather than out during the daytime and making themself present and making themselves known. There's actually in a nocturnal animals, there's a membrane in there... In the eyes that nocturnal animals will usually develop, and beavers lack those.

Speaker 4:

So that's one of the theories is that they were never evolved to be primarily active in the evening, but in fact that's what we find. There's very few people who do this kind of work who have actually seen beavers out in the daytime. It's pretty unusual unless they're habituated. I think in the old mill, they come out during the daytime. But generally, wild beavers are shy.

Speaker 4:

They don't like to be handled. They are highly stressed. They experience capture myopathy. They die on handling and husbandry and on release quite often in many relocation scenarios. So they do better being left to their own devices out in the wild.

Speaker 2:

That's fascinating. Earlier in the podcast, we said that beavers are best when we leave them in the environment that they're supposed to be in and let them do their thing, putting labels and pressure on them isn't necessarily the the right thing to do. But I must ask, if you do believe that they are engineers engineers and firefighters and when left to do their thing on these non degraded landscapes, but in landscapes that allow them to thrive, do they create better landscapes in a healthier planet for us?

Speaker 3:

I mean, they definitely have an engineering capacity. I mean, depending on how you define engineering. If you wanna define engineering simply as a human activity, then they're not engineers. But they certainly do things that alter the landscape, and they do it through in... Intentional activities.

Speaker 3:

It's not... You know, some animals will alter a landscape through grazing, and they're they're just trying to eat. But the beavers are actually building structures in an active fashion that adjusts and changes the ecology of their landscape and the physical form of their landscape. And so, I don't know, it just depends on how you wanted to find engineer. But I think I think it's fair to call them...

Speaker 3:

I mean, people call them ecosystem engineers. I think it's fair to call them that as long as you realize, sort of as Reese has been saying, the limitations of that term, like, you're not necessarily gonna get them to do that if you put them into a habitat where they don't have the materials they need or they don't have all the other things that fit their needs. And so... Yeah. Sure.

Speaker 3:

They have a big effect on the landscape. That's why people have started to try to do beaver based restoration. That's why even if you're just trying to attract beaver into an area with more forage, you're you're trying to attract them in to do that thing. The the place where I think it can become a little bit uncomfortable is the idea that, like, that's the re... That's the reason for their existence or that's the only reason, you know, we should value them or that, you you know, the only the only aspects of nature you can value have to have a utilitarian purpose for humans.

Speaker 3:

Like, it's great when when it... When, you know, you can do things that that improve a habitat or improve the conditions for another species, and they also improve our condition. So those are... Those win win situations, but that doesn't mean that other species don't have their own inherent value and that they don't have a right to exist independently of how we value them. So, you know, these are...

Speaker 3:

These get... This gets into, like, philosophical debates and questions that, you know, we don't need to get into. But I think, like, to in the same way that, you know, restoration can connect people to the landscape, I think these charismatic species can too. And, like, even though... You know, Beaver have their own sort of charisma.

Speaker 3:

I mean, that's the mascot of the university I work at. So it must have at least some charisma. So... And, you know, like, panda bears are the are the symbol for some conservation organizations. So, like, those are things that...

Speaker 3:

These are images that connect people in the same way that people wanna be connected to streams, and that gives you a higher property value. We are innately connected to nature. That's because we evolved there. And so, you know, having messages that resonate with those kind of inherent tendencies or instincts that humans have and that, you know, in our increasingly artificial world, we've kind of gotten away from, I think that these are things that are important as long as you don't, you know, go too far with them and expect the only the only beaver that's any good is one that I can make a pelt out of or that can, you know, help restore my property. So...

Speaker 3:

And and that is a big thing about, you know, I think another step that humans have to take in addition to realizing how fragile ecosystems are and what we can do to try to restore them is, like, this capacity to value nature, you know, kind of more on its own terms and for its own sake. And and I think if you do that, and you create that kind of a mindset, then what we'll find is that will circle back and have values for humanity, even if that's not necessarily the starting point of of trying to adopt that philosophical approach.

Speaker 2:

Even though beavers, fairly or unfairly, are made as mascots. When you do make an animal a mascot like that, or a symbol of conservation, or, you know, call them charismatic. By caring about beavers and by protecting beavers, you are in in turn caring and protecting about a whole subset of species that the beavers care for. They're a keystone species. So when they're allowed to do what they do, there's a whole subset set of species that then can thrive because of the beaver.

Speaker 2:

And that is, you know Yeah. The genesis of being a keystone species and and being able to create a thriving ecosystem and they do do that. So when people do care and put a a beaver up on a pedestal, know, in the ways hopefully like you had pervade, you know, in turn they are, you know, protecting and supporting a whole ecosystem of animals and species beyond just the beaver.

Speaker 3:

Yeah. And there's another term. So there's keystone when they have this big impact on the environment, and there's this term flagship species or species that can attract human sympathy and attention for, you know, conservation purposes. So, like, the panda bear is, like, a classic... It's kind of flagship species, monarch, butterflies, things like that.

Speaker 3:

And I think the beaver might might be a low charismatic flagship species possibly, something somewhere.

Speaker 2:

I don't know. They stole your wood. They have some they have some charisma. They have some spunk. For both of you, any final thoughts?

Speaker 3:

I guess my final thought would be is, like, think it's great that you're doing this podcast. I don't know I don't know if you wanna put somebody, like, congratulating you for your podcast into your podcast, but I think you should. And and the other thing I'll say is, I actually learn a lot from podcasts. I'm not saying that anybody's gonna learn much from listening to this podcast, but, like, it is a new... Like, a very new way of, like, trying to understand the world.

Speaker 3:

And there's, like, a lot of really talented people out doing these things. And so, you know, I think you're doing a great job trying to educate people and inspire people. And it's just such a easy way to learn about stuff. And you mentioned to me that you wanted to do this podcast because you felt like there wasn't that there wasn't enough of a knowledge base out there for people to go out and be able to enjoy national parks. Knowing more about the parks would help people to appreciate them more.

Speaker 3:

And so that's just such a great way to get people inspired and to just go out and connect to nature and just enjoy their lives more. So, hopefully, we helped you with your mission. But it's great that you're doing this. And and I would just encourage people to to to to, you know, take what they get out of your podcast and realize there's lots of other good ones out there too. And, you know, not, you know, not be shy about using podcasts as a way to kind of direct you in the world because that is...

Speaker 3:

It's definitely a new and important way that just like... You know, we we we wouldn't have even been able to have made podcasts, like, twenty years ago. As we learn about the world and we learn about how to deal with ecology, we also learn about how to learn about the world. And you're doing a great thing about... This is a great venue for trying to educate people.

Speaker 4:

And and I would add, I guess, is being outdoors. Like, doing this in the setting is awesome. Having... Being able to take you to the sites that we get excited about as you stood patiently by watching both of us go look at new data or or see... Actually experience the site as we're experiencing it.

Speaker 4:

I appreciate you taking the time with that to understand our world a little bit more too before we came into these questions.

Speaker 2:

Well, thank you both. Let's see if I... That all that makes the final cut because shouldn't shouldn't have to be congratulating me. The reason I have both of you on is because of the amazing work both of you do. And it's it's really an honor to be able to see you guys do your work and understand the data that you're analyzing.

Speaker 2:

You know, it's a a tremendous byproduct of doing these podcasts is getting to spend time and and learn myself with the listeners, but also get to see you guys in action and do your work and get to know you as human beings, which is, really important. And, to your point, getting to sit out here in nature and and talk about these discussions, I hope it inspires people to go out and have these types of conversations with their friends and their colleagues out in nature and get to learn about the the natural world even more. But I can't thank either of you enough for the work that you do in this world. Certainly, you with the students bringing them out here and and getting them involved in the landscape and getting to to touch and feel and see these things with their own eyes is is tremendous. And and, you know, being an educator sometimes is a thankless job.

Speaker 2:

So thank you for everything that that you do. And, of course, you with all the work that you do with landowners and landscapes all across the state of Oregon and undoubtedly throughout the country and getting to, you know, nurture Beavers back to health. And even though we don't wanna think of them as celebrities, unfortunately, that's the state of the world right now. And so for you doing this work for them right now and and trying to rebuild their habitat is really special. So thank you both for everything that you do.

Speaker 1:

Thanks so much for checking out this edition of the Safe Travels Podcast. I really hope you enjoyed it. Matt and Reese do incredible work, and I really hope you were able to learn a thing or two about beavers and ecological restoration. If you like this type of content, it mean a whole lot to me if you followed or subscribed on whichever platform you're watching or listening on. And if you'd like to support independent journalism, I also recently launched a Patreon and would love to see you there as well.

Speaker 1:

Thanks so much. And as always, safe travels.