Actually ADHD | Medication Strategies & Clinical Wisdom

Why Vyvanse became the internet's favorite ADHD medication and what patients and prescribers should actually understand about it. 

Jonathan Murphy, PMHNP-BC, walks through the pharmacology, the Reddit hype cycle, and how Vyvanse fits into the real optimization pathway.

This episode covers:

Why extended-release stimulants became first-line and how insurance approval finally caught up to clinical reality

The two stimulant chemicals: amphetamine and methylphenidate, and why roughly half of adults respond best to one over the other

What "zombification" on methylphenidate signals and what "tweaking out" on amphetamine signals

Why Adderall XR gets prescribed first most of the time and what that pathway leads to

The Vyvanse pharmacology: lisdexamfetamine as a prodrug that converts in the bloodstream to dextroamphetamine

The dextro versus levo amphetamine distinction: dextro for the brain, levo for the peripheral nervous system

Why Vyvanse feels like a smoother ride for patients who don't tolerate the levoamphetamine in Adderall XR

The Reddit dynamic that keeps positioning Vyvanse as the best ADHD medication and why that framing distorts optimization

The Dexedrine Spansule as the older, cheaper alternative that does essentially the same thing pharmacologically

Why "all good, no bad" is the standard, not "good enough"

The big four extended-release stimulants: Adderall XR, Vyvanse, extended-release methylphenidate (Ritalin LA or Concerta), and Focalin

Why there is no best ADHD medication, only the right medication for your brain

This is the thirteenth episode of Actually ADHD. 

The book The Process: An Adult's Guide to ADHD Medication is available on Amazon: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0H2Z6PM4T

For educational purposes only. Not medical advice. Consult your own provider for clinical decisions.

What is Actually ADHD | Medication Strategies & Clinical Wisdom?

Adult ADHD from the board-certified PMHNP behind the YouTube channel Focus Path and the book The Process. Clinical perspective on medication, frameworks, and the conversations the internet hasn't been having.

This is Actually ADHD.

I am your host, Jonathan Murphy,
psychiatric nurse practitioner

And this podcast is sponsored by
the Focus Path YouTube channel

You can go ahead and check that out
on YouTube at Focus Path Systems.

I'm just gonna jump right into it.

Today, I wanna talk about
ADHD medication again

before I get carried away with
various side tangents and rants.

I can see that the initial medication
videos that I posted were quite popular,

so now I got some more to discuss,
certainly You can always refer to my

book, The Process: An Adult's Guide
to ADHD Medication, now on Amazon,

if you do have any questions or just
want everything I have to say about

ADHD in one simple to find place,

Last time I talked a bit about how
the internet is different than my

office, and I encounter different
ideas and points of view The type of

things that you're only gonna find on
the internet, and this is a good one.

It's Vyvanse.

Vyvanse is a popular
extended-release ADHD medication

Which I've referred to as the
internet's favorite ADHD medication.

So today I'm gonna talk about what
Vyvanse is, how to think about it,

and how we got here in the first place

So as I've talked about in the past, as
long as we're excluding the non-stimulant

options and we're only talking about
ADHD stimulant medications, which is

going to account for the vast majority
of effective first-line ADHD medications,

we're talking about two separate
chemicals, amphetamine and methylphenidate

When these drugs were first discovered

there were obviously some benefits.

As time went on, there were clearly risks.

So the limitations are placed upon
the medication, and now we have

ADHD, which does a very good job of
identifying the subset of people who

will actually benefit from the medicine.

So remember that.

We're not talking about
performance enhancement.

We're talking about therapeutic
application of these medications for

a particular individual which just
so happens to make up a subset of

the population, a subset of humanity

Because yes, this phenomenon has been
documented before the medicine was around

And the medicine was discovered before
the appropriate application was found.

So two things can be true at once.

It wasn't until around the year
2000 we got the extended-release

formulations, which really allowed to
improve toleration, Because it allows

the body to absorb the medication in
a gentle way, and from there, it's

dialing in the individual amount of
stimulation for each adult with ADHD.

Just a reminder, I'm talking
about adults with ADHD

The kids from the '80s and '90s that grew
up, because the brain is done cooking.

It's just a different thing altogether.

In pediatrics, while I did treat
children and adolescents for some time

I'm not gonna speak on that population
because I feel they require completely

distinctive treatment approaches.

So I'm gonna talk about the one
I know best, which is adults.

So 95% of the time or more, you're
gonna land on an extended-release

stimulant medication as first line.

Most effective, the most safe

And the hopeful outcome
of all good, no bad

We're looking at the extended-release
stimulant medications,

methylphenidate and amphetamine.

The two most well-known brand names, we
know the names, Ritalin and Adderall.

The extended-release medications are
Ritalin long-acting and Adderall So

Long story made short, with the longer
version in my book, "The Process,"

finding the right ADHD medication
isn't difficult, it's deliberate.

You're applying a medication in a very
specific manner because the medication

is predictable, human beings less so.

Nonetheless, I find whether you start
with an Adderall XR or you start

with a Ritalin long-acting, which
are forms of either drug, the most

popular forms of methylphenidate or
amphetamine essentially People tend

to fall on one side or the other

Meaning some people do best
with amphetamine, some people

do best with methylphenidate.

Another way to look at these medicines,
they both do the same thing essentially.

There are minor differences in
pharmacology If we were talking

about receptor pharmacology and
psychopharmacology, we're using that

discipline as a frame of reference to help
us understand the clinical reality and

the medicinal benefits of ADHD medication.

So when we're talking about the
receptors and how the brain works and

all that, we're thinking dopamine.

Both medications activate dopamine.

We can think of that as providing
central nervous system stimulation to

the brain to a person that needs that,
so therefore the outcome is therapeutic.

Therefore, the stimulant category or
the designation, the pharmacologic

designation of stimulant is in name.

In effect, it's a therapy, and
the goal is not stimulated, it's

equilibrium, balance, or calm

We can think of those non-stimulants
as the lowest level of stimulation

Instead of pressing that dopamine button
directly, it's sort of indirectly.

There's a more subtle approach or reuptake

we can think of it as low levels of
stimulation to moderate and to high.

Methylphenidate is moderate, but
if you are getting dialed into a

methylphenidate and you really are
gonna respond best to an amphetamine,

maybe at a higher dose, it's not
uncommon for people to feel mentally

unusual or simply describing the
subjective experience of feeling,

I suppose, malaise, uncomfortable.

Not anxious per se, but

The best way I hear people put it into
words is, "I don't feel like myself."

But I like to use the
phrase zombification.

So because 50% of people are
gonna do best with either of

these medications, generally

what do people start with?

It's most common these days for people to
start with Adderall XR, which is the most

well-known ADHD medication right now, so
therefore it's prescribed the most often.

Just a quick aside, just because it's
prescribed more often doesn't mean

there's more prescriptions being handed
out or prescribed or whatever it is.

There's more Adderall than ever.

Maybe that's true.

I'm not sure.

I don't know the numbers, but my My
practice, I would say, goes through

periods of time where people are
looking for that ADHD diagnosis.

It spikes up and down.

It's always busy, but it's much better
that Adderall XR is preferred by insurance

companies now, because when I started,
you had to prescribe immediate release,

and I had to do that for years, and then
finally I said, "I can't do it anymore."

And luckily, insurance companies
started approving the extended releases.

So that's really, I think, the main
driver behind the perceived amount

of people on these medications.

The truth is, these medications have
been prescribed for quite some time

and have been in medicine cabinets
and even on drugstore shelves way

back in your granddaddy's age.

So it's a perception
problem for most people.

We're not gonna change the
way the world looks at it.

I'm asking you to figure
out how to best understand

this concept if you're faced with a family
member or yourself with ADHD symptoms,

if you feel that you have ADHD, or
maybe you're a clinician, or maybe you

clearly don't have ADHD, but you need to
wrap your head around how other people

are dealing with a, a different set
of starting points, shall we say

So Adderall XR gets
prescribed most of the time.

And here's the thing, if you have ADHD,
any of the medications I described

before are highly likely to actually
help because the ADHD medications are

the only dopaminergic medications.

You're getting to dopamine.

There's a gate that's closed,
and ADHD unlocks that gate,

and it's dopamine medicines.

So that's the other thing.

For the people that are anti-ADHD,
I think there's also something to be

said for a prescriber toolkit, ' cause
when I went to school, we learned

about antipsychotics, and obviously
those medications are helpful that

people aren't institutionalized,
very important pharmacology.

However, working in an inpatient
hospital, seeing, the movement

disorders, these things are no joke.

And on the outpatient basis,
I've thankfully been able

to say, "Risk-benefit?

No, let's put them over here."

And when I bring them in, it goes
well 'cause the patients need them

But it's always a balance because whether
you choose to prescribe something or

not, choose to move forward or not,
there's still a decision involved,

a risk-benefit on either side.

Applying the intervention or not,
and that's ADHD across the lifespan

And that's how I know it's real

So back to the point the ADHD
medication is gonna work.

And oftentimes when it does, people are
thrilled about it, especially adults.

They're like, "Oh, I'll
take anything along with it.

I'm getting my work done, so what if I'm
grinding my teeth and I'm tweaking out?

This is great."

And I really caution everyone, and that's
why I really ram home all good, no bad.

Especially, too, with the tablets
that were associated with a spike

and crash side effects every time.

You're gonna get more side effects
from caffeine by and large.

The goal for a stimulant for
ADHD is to have no side effects,

but that's in the long term

But ultimately, for my patients on the
autism spectrum, I'd say by and large

methylphenidate responders, maybe those
that are more prone to ruminative anxiety,

more likely to do good on methylphenidate
or respond optimally to methylphenidate.

So it simply looks like this.

People are on Adderall XR, they're
tweaking out, but they're getting

their work done, and they go on
Reddit and they hear about Vyvanse.

"You gotta try Vyvanse.

It's the best ADHD medication.

Vyvanse, oh my God, it's the best."

So there's this really big
response, and someone reads

that, and then they go, "Okay.

I'm tweaking out.

Let me try some Vyvanse."

So they try Vyvanse, which is still
an amphetamine, lisdexamphetamine.

Lisdexamphetamine is a prodrug.

It converts in your bloodstream
from lisdexamphetamine to

dextroamphetamine.

Okay, let's pause for a minute.

So, going back to the amphetamine
piece, it's still the same drug,

but there are two kinds of it when
we're thinking about Adderall.

There's levo and dextro, or D and L.

And that D, dextro, is for
your brain, and the L, levo, is

more peripheral nervous system.

Think of it as your get up and go.

Well, not everyone
needs the get up and go.

Nonetheless, they make and
manufacture dextroamphetamine,

or Dexedrine, single amphetamine.

That's way older than Adderall.

It's the OG.

So what's lisdexamphetamine?

It's a prodrug, converts to
dextroamphetamine, so a sort of

smoother perceived onset toleration.

For the folks that are not doing great
on Adderall XR, it's a smoother ride.

So they get a smoother ride.

They're doing better.

They're still a bit tweaky,
but they go to Reddit and

they're like, "Yes, this is it."

No.

Hold on, because the
goal is all good, no bad.

If you're really tweaking or really
uncomfortable or overstimulated highly,

if you're saying things like, "Okay, can
I just take the medication sometimes?

'Cause I need to focus, but, like, I,
like, can't stop focusing," or, " You

know, I focus really good, but it's,
like, intense and then I crash,"

it's just signs of overstimulation.

. So you want to go to a methylphenidate.

There's so many people that
are on Vyvanse I described.

And Vyvanse is still a good medication
because someone could try Adderall

XR and then move to Vyvanse.

However, these folks are experiencing
minor side effects, mostly doing

good, maybe just some minor
restlessness from the levoamphetamine.

So Dexedrine Spansules is an
extended-release capsule form.

If you can't afford Vyvanse, That
is essentially my hot take on

Vyvanse, which I made a video about

Maybe four to six months ago
on my YouTube channel, and it

garnered a lot of excitement.

And I use the clickbait.

Vyvanse is overhyped, but it is overhyped.

Still a good medication.

If you're taking the medication,
it could be your all good, no bad.

25% of people with ADHD, Vyvanse is
probably gonna be the all good, no bad, if

we're talking about the main medications.

There's exceptions, but the big
four, XR, Vyvanse, extended-release

methylphenidate, Ritalin or Concerta
Count that as one, and then Focalin.

So Vyvanse isn't the best one,
' cause there can't be a best one.

There's no such thing as
the best ADHD medication.

There's only the right ADHD
medication for your brain.

The diagnosis gets you to a
medication, but it doesn't

dial in the individual therapy.

So that's what it's like when
you're actually treating ADHD.

So I thought I'd leave you there.

Thanks again for listening.

My name is Jonathan Murphy,
psychiatric nurse practitioner.

You can check out Survival Modality
Season 2 on the YouTube channel.

I'll talk to you later