Subscribe
Share
Share
Embed
Sky Blue Time Machine is a Coventry City podcast. Each week, Danny and Sarah
work through a season of Sky Blues football — and a second one, from a
different decade. Sometimes the parallel rhymes. Sometimes it doesn't. The
show is the conversation about which.
A KCHN Enterprises LLC production. skybluetimemachine.com
[VOICE_NOTE: Warm, nostalgic, measured pace. Build from reflective to conversational energy.]
REGISTER: warm
**Danny:** Right. So here's where we start. May the sixteenth, nineteen eighty-seven. Wembley Stadium. Ninety-six thousand people. Coventry City three, Tottenham Hotspur two, after extra time. And I want you to picture it as a still photograph, because that's what it became — Kilcline going up the steps, the cup in his hands, half the city watching on a television that had been pulled into a kitchen so everyone could see it at once. That's the summit. That's the highest point this football club has ever stood at, and the whole rest of the story is told relative to it. Wembley again. Seventy-four thousand, four hundred and thirty-four. Coventry two, Oxford one. EFL Trophy. Different competition, different division, different century, and yet — two Wembley wins, thirty years apart, both clubs going home with a trophy.
**Danny:** Same club. Allegedly.
**Sarah:** [wry]Allegedly.[/wry] And that's the show. That's what we're doing for the whole of this series. Eighty-six eighty-seven on one side of the sofa, twenty sixteen seventeen on the other, and we're going to keep looking at them next to each other until something gives.
**Danny:** Something has to give. Because in nineteen eighty-seven they finished tenth in the First Division. Top flight. Tenth. And in twenty seventeen they finished twenty-third in League One. Which, [pause] for anyone counting, is the third tier. So that's three divisions down. In thirty years. While also winning a trophy at Wembley at both ends of it.
**Sarah:** Which is the bit nobody knows what to do with. Because if you tell me a club went from tenth in the top flight to twenty-third in the third tier, I tell you that's a disaster. And if you tell me they won a trophy at Wembley in front of seventy-four thousand people, I tell you that's a triumph. And they're the same season.
**Danny:** They're the same club. Same badge. Same colour.
**Sarah:** And that's the thesis, more or less. We're not here to decide which one matters more. We're here to put them next to each other and see what the gap actually contains.
**Danny:** Right. And I'll tell you the other thing the gap contains. It contains me getting older. So just — [pause] just be aware of that as we go.
**Sarah:** Noted.
**Danny:** I was nine years old when Kilcline lifted that cup. I was thirty-nine when the second one happened. And that's the show, really, isn't it. That's why we're doing it.
**Sarah:** Hi everyone. This is Sky Blue Time Machine. I'm Sarah Skye.
**Danny:** And I'm Danny Bleu. And this is episode one. So if you stick around, that's on you.
[VOICE_NOTE: Measured, reflective storytelling. Build momentum through the goal sequence. Let the narrative breathe.]
REGISTER: conversational, analytical
**Sarah:** Okay. So let's actually start where the club starts, which is the eighty-seven final. Because I think the danger with that final — and I've been thinking about this all week — is that it becomes a highlights reel. It becomes Houchen's header and that's it. And if it becomes that, then the rest of it disappears, and what it meant disappears with it.
**Danny:** Right. And we're not even doing the header today, by the way. The header is — we're saving the header. The header gets its own moment later in the series, because if I try to do it now I'll do it badly and we'll have nothing left.
**Sarah:** It's been ringfenced. It's in a vault.
**Danny:** It's in a vault. Look — what I want to say about the final is, the score doesn't tell you anything. Three two after extra time. You can read that as a thriller. You can read that as Coventry just edging it. The story is the goals in order. Because the order is mad.
**Sarah:** The order is mad. Two minutes in, Clive Allen scores for Tottenham. Two minutes. So the first piece of information ninety-six thousand people get is, oh, this is going as expected. Tottenham are the favourites, Tottenham are ahead, Coventry are about to get pulled apart on the biggest stage they've ever been on. That's the script.
**Danny:** That's the script. And then seven minutes later Bennett equalises and the script gets ripped up. Ninth minute. One-all. And the moment Bennett scores, the whole afternoon shifts.
**Sarah:** Then Mabbutt — Gary Mabbutt — heads it back the other way just before the break. Fortieth minute. So Coventry go in at half-time two-one down, behind for the second time in the game, and the question is whether they've got another comeback in them.
**Danny:** And they did. Sixty-fourth minute. The header we're not talking about. [wry]The one we're definitely not talking about today.[/wry]
**Sarah:** The one that I have written down in my notes as "see episode seven."
**Danny:** Yeah. So two-all. And then it goes to extra time and Mabbutt — same Mabbutt who scored their second — deflects a Lloyd McGrath centre into his own net. Ninety-sixth minute. Three two.
**Sarah:** And that's the bit that, when I was doing my reading this week, I kept coming back to. Because Mabbutt is the player who scores the goal that puts Tottenham ahead and Mabbutt is the player who scores the goal that wins it for Coventry. Same player. The whole game pivots on him.
**Danny:** It does. And there's a cruelty there that I wouldn't wish on anyone, by the way. Mabbutt's career — Mabbutt was a really good footballer. He had a really long, really good career. But for one afternoon, his name is on both of those goals.
**Sarah:** It's almost too neat as a piece of narrative. If you wrote it in a novel, an editor would tell you to take it out.
**Danny:** And the two managers go up the steps together. That's the other bit. Curtis and Sillett. Joint managers. They both lift it. Sillett first, then Curtis, then they kind of hold it together. And the thing about Curtis and Sillett — and this is the bit I keep coming back to this week — is they weren't brought in to win the cup. They weren't brought in from anywhere. They were already in the building.
**Sarah:** Right. Curtis had been a player at the club going back decades — he played there forever.
**Danny:** Both, really. He played there forever. He was managing director by eighty-six. And Sillett had been there as a coach. They didn't get parachuted in by an agent. There was no helicopter. They were just — they were the two blokes who were already there when the club needed somebody, and somebody said, alright, you two, have a go. And they had a go and they won the FA Cup. I mean. [pause] That doesn't happen.
**Sarah:** That doesn't happen now. That definitely doesn't happen now.
[VOICE_NOTE: Measured, reflective storytelling. Build ideas together. Occasional warmth when acknowledging each other's points.]
REGISTER: conversational, analytical
**Danny:** Sillett said something like — and I'm paraphrasing because I don't want to put words in the man's mouth — but the line he gave after the final was that they did it for Coventry. That was the framing. Not for themselves, not for the squad, for the city. And I think that's right. That's the bit Sarah will push back on this, but I'll say it first — that final wasn't a sporting result. That final was a civic event.
**Sarah:** Hang on. I'm not pushing back on the civic event part. I'm pushing back on the mythology part. Because there's a version of this story where eighty-six eighty-seven becomes a kind of golden moment that explains everything else. Like Coventry are forever a cup-winning club because of one afternoon in May nineteen eighty-seven. And I don't think that's right. Because they finished tenth.
**Danny:** Tenth's not bad.
**Sarah:** Tenth is great. Tenth in the top flight is great. But it's tenth. It's not first. It's not a title. It's not a club that was about to win the league. It was a mid-table First Division side that pulled off the cup. And I think when you tell the story as "and then they were the kings of England," you actually take something away from how surprising it was.
**Danny:** Right. No, that's fair. That's fair. I think the truth is that final was the moment the club became permanent. Like, before that, Coventry were a club. After that, Coventry were a club that had won the FA Cup. That's the change. And it's not a change in their league position, it's not a change in their finances, it's not even really a change in their squad, because the squad mostly broke up over the next couple of years anyway. It's a change in what they were allowed to mean.
**Sarah:** And that's interesting. Because that's the thing nobody can take off you. You can get relegated, you can lose Highfield Road, you can move to Northampton for a year, you can get bought by a hedge fund — and the cup is still in the cabinet. Whatever cabinet you're allowed to put it in.
**Danny:** Whatever cabinet you've still got.
**Sarah:** Whatever cabinet you've still got. The cup is still won. May sixteenth, nineteen eighty-seven, still happened. And I think that's the bit you can't argue with. The mythology I can argue with. The result I can't.
[VOICE_NOTE: Measured, analytical storytelling. Build the argument with conviction but leave room for Sarah's counterpoint.]
REGISTER: conversational, analytical
**Danny:** And I'll tell you the other thing that final did, which I think is underrated. It saved the club twice. Because at the start of that season they were in real trouble. Sillett came in in pretty grim circumstances. And by May they're walking up the Wembley steps. So one — it pulled them out of a relegation conversation that was real that autumn. And two — it bought them, what, another decade of being a top-flight club? They didn't go down until ninety-nine. That's twelve more years of First Division and Premier League football. And I'd argue some of those twelve years happen because of the confidence that came out of May eighty-seven.
**Sarah:** That's a good argument. I'd want to test it, but it's a good argument.
**Danny:** You'd want to test it.
**Sarah:** I'd want to test it. I'd want to know whether the squad they had was always going to keep them up regardless of what happened in the cup, or whether the cup actually shifted the institutional belief enough to keep them up for another decade. And I genuinely don't know.
**Danny:** Right. And what are you going to do, run two parallel universes? You can't.
**Sarah:** I have a spreadsheet but I don't have a parallel universe yet. We're working on that for series two.
[VOICE_NOTE: Warm, conversational, slightly playful. Build energy on the numbers. Let the wonder land naturally.]
REGISTER: light_warm
**Danny:** [laugh] Yeah, well, when you've got that, give me a call. Look — the last thing I want to say about the final, before we move on, is the attendance. Ninety-six thousand. And what that means in nineteen eighty-seven, before you've got people on phones, before you've got the highlights coming through on six different platforms — ninety-six thousand people in one place, watching one game, deciding one trophy. There's not a lot of moments in British public life that look like that anymore.
**Sarah:** No. And there's something about the scale of that audience that I think translates very oddly when you put it next to the twenty seventeen final, which is the other thing we have to talk about today, which had seventy-four thousand at Wembley.
**Danny:** Seventy-four thousand, four hundred and thirty-four.
**Sarah:** Which is — that's not small. That's not small.
**Danny:** That's not small. That's a lot of people. That's more people than fit in any club ground in England except Old Trafford.
**Sarah:** Right. And we'll come back to that, because the contrast there isn't between ninety-six and seventy-four. The contrast is between seventy-four thousand at Wembley and one thousand three hundred and thirty-eight at the home semi-final earlier in that same competition. Same competition. Same season. Different audience by a factor of fifty-five. And that's a story for later in the show. But just — flag that.
**Danny:** Flag that. Flag the pig. Don't talk about the pig yet either.
**Sarah:** Don't talk about the pig.
**Danny:** Pig is also in the vault. We've got a whole vault. The vault is enormous. By the end of the series there'll be nothing left but the vault.
[VOICE_NOTE: Measured, reflective storytelling. Sarah analytical and precise; Danny warm and grounded. Build to the stark numbers at the end.]
REGISTER: conversational, analytical
**Sarah:** Okay. So the eighty-seven final, what it meant, what it still means — I'd land it like this. It's the moment Coventry became permanent. It's a moment that mid-table First Division clubs in May nineteen eighty-seven could still be permanent in this way. That's also gone, by the way. Mid-table First Division — sorry, mid-table Premier League — clubs don't win FA Cups anymore. The last time someone outside the established top six won the FA Cup was — I want to say Wigan, twenty thirteen. So you could argue Coventry winning the cup from tenth is more impressive in retrospect than it was at the time.
**Danny:** It is more impressive in retrospect than it was at the time. Because in eighty-seven, that was just what could happen. Someone other than Liverpool or Everton could win the FA Cup. Now it can't.
**Sarah:** Right. So when I said earlier that I wanted to push back on the mythology, the thing I want to be careful about is that I'm not pushing back on the size of the achievement. I'm pushing back on what it explains. It explains less than the mythology says it does. But the thing it does explain — that a club from a manufacturing city in the West Midlands, tenth in the league, with two managers who were already on the staff, could beat Tottenham at Wembley — that thing is bigger than people give it credit for.
**Danny:** [warm]Right.[/warm] Right, that's it. That's the framing. And the reason we're doing the show is because that thing is no longer available to the club that it happened to. Which brings us, awkwardly, onto the table. The actual league table.
**Sarah:** The actual league table. Which is where I live, professionally.
**Danny:** This is where Sarah lives.
**Sarah:** This is my home. So — let me just say the two numbers next to each other and let them do the work. Eighty-six eighty-seven. Coventry City. First Division. Final position: tenth. Twenty sixteen seventeen. Coventry City. League One. Final position: twenty-three. Out of twenty-four. Relegated.
**Danny:** That's the show.
[VOICE_NOTE: Measured, analytical storytelling. Build the argument methodically. Let the metaphors land. Occasional warmth between speakers.]
REGISTER: analytical, reflective, intimate
**Sarah:** That is the show. And the bit that I keep wanting to say to people who aren't familiar with the English pyramid is — those aren't just two numbers on the same scale. They're two numbers on two different scales, and the second scale is two whole tiers below the first one. So if you're following along at home and you're thinking, well, tenth to twenty-third, that's thirteen places — no. It's thirteen places and three divisions. It's the difference between being in the top half of the top league in the country and being in the bottom half of the third league in the country.
**Danny:** And the way I always think about it, Sarah, is the table reads differently depending on which way up you hold it.
**Sarah:** Go on.
**Danny:** Because tenth in the First Division in eighty-seven — that's a finishing position. That's a thing you can be proud of. You're tenth. The other thirty-one professional clubs in England, you're better than them. Or you've finished above them, anyway. Twenty-third in League One in twenty seventeen — that's also a finishing position. The other ninety-something professional clubs in England, you have a relationship with them. Some of them you've finished above. Most of them you haven't. And the table — the way I read the table when we were finishing twenty-third — every rung down felt personal. Like the ladder had been inverted. Like instead of climbing up it, the ladder had been picked up and turned over and you were now reading it from the bottom. Every position down felt like a fall.
**Sarah:** Right. The ladder inverted.
**Danny:** That's the bit. Because in eighty-seven, the league was a ceiling you were trying to push up against. You finished tenth, but you knew there was a ninth above you, and an eighth, and a seventh, and you could imagine moving up. By twenty seventeen, the league was a floor that was giving way underneath you. You were trying not to fall. Twenty-third out of twenty-four means there is one club below you. One. And they're keeping you company on the way out.
**Sarah:** Which makes the cup win sit oddly, doesn't it. Because that twenty-third place is the league position of a relegated club. And on the second of April, that relegated club went to Wembley and won a trophy in front of seventy-four thousand people. And then twelve days later, on the fourteenth of April, they went home to the Ricoh and lost one-one to Charlton — which sounds like a draw, I know I said lost — they drew one-one with Charlton, and that draw confirmed relegation. Twelve days. From Wembley to relegated. Twelve days.
**Danny:** Twelve days. And that draw against Charlton is — that's the pig game. That's the other thing in the vault. Don't think about the pigs.
**Sarah:** Don't think about the pigs. We will think about the pigs later, but not now.
**Danny:** Not now. Not now.
**Sarah:** The thing I want to do, though, because I am incapable of not doing this, is put the two seasons on the same scale. Points per game. Because the points totals don't transfer directly — eighty-six eighty-seven was a forty-two game season, twenty sixteen seventeen was a forty-six game season, so you can't just say sixty-three versus forty-three or whatever.
**Danny:** Oh, here we go.
**Sarah:** Hang on. Hang on. Hang on. Eighty-six eighty-seven, the club won enough games to finish tenth in a forty-two-game First Division season, which puts them at about one-point-five points per game. Twenty sixteen seventeen, in League One, they finished on about nought-point-nine points per game. So on a per-game basis, in two different divisions, against two different sets of opposition, the per-game points production drops by about forty percent. And that's just one season versus the other — that's not even the journey, that's the endpoints.
**Danny:** Right. So you're saying the player who's actually on the pitch has, what, less than two-thirds of the productivity per game?
**Sarah:** Less than two-thirds. Which — look, it's a crude measure. I'm aware it's a crude measure. Different leagues, different opponents, different eras of how points are awarded, blah blah blah. But the order of magnitude is real. The squad that finished twenty-third in League One in twenty seventeen was, on a per-ninety-minute basis, producing about sixty percent of the league points the eighty-six eighty-seven squad was producing in the top flight.
**Danny:** And that's against worse opposition.
**Sarah:** Against worse opposition. Which is — well, it depends how you define worse. They're against opposition who, on average, have smaller budgets, smaller fanbases, lower transfer fees. Some of those clubs in League One twenty sixteen seventeen are clubs Coventry never played in their history before they got relegated to that division. Fleetwood Town. AFC Wimbledon, which is a club that didn't exist when Coventry won the cup. There are clubs in League One that Coventry are playing in twenty seventeen who, in nineteen eighty-seven, were in the Conference or below.
**Danny:** Right. So the pyramid hasn't just changed. The geography of the pyramid has changed. There are clubs they're sharing a division with now that didn't exist when they won the cup, and there are clubs they were playing in eighty-seven who are now in the Premier League and have never come back down.
**Sarah:** Exactly. The whole shape of who you compete against has rotated. And I think that's the bit people sometimes miss when they go, well, eighty-seven is a long time ago. It's not just that it was a long time ago. It's that the institutional context that Coventry City as a club lived inside has been replaced. The clubs around them in the league in eighty-seven — those are mostly Premier League clubs now, or they're in the Championship, or they've disappeared entirely. Bury have disappeared entirely.
**Danny:** Bury have disappeared. Bury played Coventry in League One twenty sixteen seventeen. We've got a record of it. The club doesn't exist anymore.
**Sarah:** Hang on. I want to make sure I get this right. Bury — Bury were in League One that season, Coventry played them, and Bury have since folded. They're not in the league anymore.
**Danny:** They're not in the football league anymore. So one of the clubs around Coventry in the table in twenty sixteen seventeen isn't there at all now. That's what the geography looks like at the bottom of the pyramid. Clubs can just go.
**Sarah:** Whereas in nineteen eighty-six eighty-seven, the clubs in the First Division — Arsenal, Liverpool, Everton, Tottenham, Manchester United, Chelsea — they're all still here. They're all in the Premier League. They're all richer than they were. They're all bigger. And Coventry, who finished above some of them that year, are not.
**Danny:** Yeah. So when I do the ladder inverted bit — and I'll do it more than once across this series, sorry — when I do it, it's not just that we slipped. It's that the ladder itself flipped. The thing that used to be a ceiling is now a floor. The thing you used to try to climb is now the thing you're trying not to fall off. And every rung on that ladder, for the long-haul supporter, every rung has a name and a face and a season attached to it. So when you read the table now, you're not reading positions. You're reading losses.
**Sarah:** Reading losses. That's a good line.
[VOICE_NOTE: Warm and playful banter, light teasing tone, quick back-and-forth rhythm.]
[REGISTER: light_warm]
**Danny:** Don't compliment me, I'll get embarrassed.
**Sarah:** You'll get embarrassed.
**Danny:** I'll get embarrassed. Move on.
[VOICE_NOTE: Measured, analytical storytelling. Sarah leads with clarity; Danny reflects thoughtfully. Build momentum through the pattern of three relegations.]
REGISTER: Conversational, reflective
**Sarah:** The other thing the table does — and I keep going back to this — is it makes you want to find the breakpoint. Like, where did it actually go? Tenth in eighty-seven to twenty-third in twenty seventeen — fine, but did it happen in a year? Did it happen in five years? Did it happen in twenty years? And the answer is, it didn't happen in any of those. It happened in waves. They got relegated from the Premier League in two thousand and one. They got relegated from the Championship in twenty twelve. They got relegated from League One in twenty seventeen, which is the season we're doing. So three relegations, sixteen years apart, eleven years apart, five years apart. The intervals are shortening.
**Danny:** The intervals are shortening.
**Sarah:** Which is what acceleration looks like. The first fall is slow, the second fall is faster, the third fall is the fastest. And that's the shape of the thing.
**Danny:** Right. And I'll just say — and we don't have to dwell on this — but the supporters who lived through all three of those falls, the ones who were there in eighty-seven and were still there in twenty seventeen, they didn't experience it as a graph. They experienced it as — every season had its own grief. Every relegation had its own logic. There wasn't a sense, in the moment, of an acceleration. There was just, each time, the specific reason this particular thing was happening, and the specific players and the specific manager and the specific bad draw at Easter or whatever it was. And it's only when you stand thirty years back and you look at the whole shape that it looks like a graph.
**Sarah:** And that's why we're doing the show, really, isn't it. Because nobody who's living it can see the shape. And the people who can see the shape didn't live it. So we're trying to do both.
**Danny:** Trying to do both. Yeah. Although I think the people who lived it can see the shape now. They just couldn't see it then.
**Sarah:** Fair. Fair correction.
[VOICE_NOTE: Measured, deliberate storytelling. Build intrigue through pattern recognition. Let the coincidence land naturally.]
REGISTER: conversational, narrative-driven
**Danny:** Speaking of which — speaking of trying to do both — I want to take us to a specific morning. Two specific mornings, actually. Because the way both seasons start is almost too on the nose. It's — you couldn't write it. If you wrote it, you'd take it out.
**Sarah:** It's the editor problem.
**Danny:** It's the editor problem. So. August twenty-third, nineteen eighty-six. Coventry's first league game of what will become the FA Cup-winning season. Away. At West Ham. The Boleyn Ground. They lose nil-one. Sorry — one-nil. They lose one-nil.
**Sarah:** They lose one-nil.
**Danny:** Then. December twenty-first, twenty sixteen. Coventry's first league game of what will become the EFL Trophy-winning season. Away. At Swindon. The County Ground. They lose one-nil.
**Sarah:** Hm.
**Danny:** Same opener, basically. Different division, different decade, different motorway, different opponents. Same scoreline. Same season-opening away defeat. Then both of those seasons end with a trophy at Wembley.
**Sarah:** That is — yeah. That's a thing. That's a real thing. The kind of pattern that, on a podcast, sounds like we made it up.
**Danny:** We did not make it up.
**Sarah:** We did not make it up. I checked twice.
**Danny:** And neither of those defeats was, in the moment, an indicator of anything. That's the other bit. Like, you can't reverse engineer your way back and say, ah, but the West Ham defeat in eighty-six was secretly the first step on the road to Wembley. It wasn't. It was a season opener away defeat. They happen. The eighty-six side weren't fancied. The twenty sixteen side weren't fancied. Both teams travelled, both teams lost one-nil away, both teams got on the coach home and that was that.
**Sarah:** And both teams' fans would have gone home thinking, well, that's a poor start, but it's one game.
**Danny:** One game. Forty-one to go in eighty-six. Forty-five to go in twenty sixteen. Hard to do too much with the data.
[VOICE_NOTE: Measured, reflective storytelling. Build texture through detail. Let pauses breathe. Warm but serious.]
REGISTER: Conversational, intimate, reflective
[BEAT: storytelling_turn]
But the thing I keep wanting to get at — and this is where Sarah's going to roll her eyes — is the texture of those two mornings. Because Highfield Road in August nineteen eighty-six was a particular kind of place. You'd have lads going down on a Saturday morning who'd been working in a factory all week. The away coaches were leaving from the Coach and Horses or wherever it was. The pre-match was at the Mercers Arms.
**Sarah:** Was it.
**Danny:** The Mercers was a place where the pre-match was. I don't drink there, I never drank there — too young, obviously, in eighty-six — but it was where the older lads would go. And the whole thing was knitted into the city. You'd see the same faces every fortnight. You'd see the same scarves. And the West Ham game, that was an away game, so most of the city stayed home and listened on the radio, but the morning at Highfield Road for the home opener the following week — that was civic. That was a town meeting that happened to have a football match attached to it.
**Sarah:** And twenty sixteen?
**Danny:** Twenty sixteen, the season opens away at Swindon, the County Ground. Now — I will admit I was not at Swindon. I wasn't going to away games that often by twenty sixteen, partly because of — life. But people I know were there. And the texture of that morning is very different. You're going to a ground that isn't yours, in a competition that isn't yours, against a team that, ten years earlier, you wouldn't have been playing. You're in League One. You haven't played top-flight football for fifteen years at that point. Some of the supporters in the away end at the County Ground in August twenty sixteen are wearing shirts from when they were a Premier League club, and those shirts are now vintage.
**Sarah:** Right. Like, the shirts have outlived the division they were sold in.
**Danny:** The shirts have outlived the division they were sold in. And the trip to Swindon, in the heads of a lot of the supporters, isn't the start of a season. It's the next chapter in a long, slow argument with the people who own the club. Because by August twenty sixteen, the ownership stuff is fully cooked. SISU have been in since December two thousand and seven. The groundshare with Northampton was thirteen-fourteen, they've come back, but they've come back to a stadium that's owned by other people in a complicated way. So when you turn up at Swindon — when our supporters turned up at Swindon — they weren't just turning up for a football match. They were turning up for a continuation.
**Sarah:** A continuation of which conversation?
**Danny:** The conversation about whether this club gets to exist properly. That's the conversation that's been going on, in some form, since the late nineties. And by twenty sixteen, it's the loudest conversation. Louder than the football, sometimes. And I want to be careful, because we'll do SISU properly later in the series — there's a whole episode on it later — but the texture of the August twenty sixteen morning is not the texture of the August nineteen eighty-six morning. The eighty-six morning is anticipation. The twenty sixteen morning is endurance.
**Sarah:** And the team news for both — what's the team news look like?
**Danny:** Team news for eighty-six, you've got Ogrizovic in goal, Kilcline at the back, Peake alongside him, Borrows, Downs. You've got Regis up top with — well, with whoever. You've got Gynn in midfield. It's a recognisable squad. It's a squad that, if you ask any Coventry supporter of a certain age to name the eleven, they could probably get nine of them.
**Sarah:** And the twenty sixteen squad?
**Danny:** The twenty sixteen squad — the manager going into Swindon is Tony Mowbray. By the end of September he's gone. So that team, on December twenty-first, twenty sixteen, is being managed by a man who's got eight more weeks in the job. Which they don't know. He doesn't know. They don't know. Mark Venus comes in as caretaker. Then Russell Slade gets the job on the twenty-first of December. Then Slade gets sacked on the fifth of March. Then Mark Robins comes in. Four men running the team in one season. Four. And the season ends with a trophy at Wembley.
**Sarah:** Four managers. Trophy.
**Danny:** Trophy.
**Sarah:** Four managers in a single league season is — that is a thing of beauty and chaos.
**Danny:** It is a thing of beauty and chaos. And the squad — the squad that loses one-nil at Swindon in August is largely not the squad that's at Wembley in April. Players have come, players have gone, loans have happened. Sordell's there in August, he's there in April. Tudgay's there. There's continuity in places, but the spine of the team going to Wembley is not the same as the spine of the team that started the season.
**Sarah:** Whereas in eighty-six, the spine of the team that loses at West Ham in August is more or less the spine of the team that beats Tottenham in May.
**Danny:** More or less. There's a bit of movement — Houchen doesn't arrive until — Houchen comes in during the season — from Scunthorpe — but the core of the side, the Kilcline-Peake-Ogrizovic-Regis-Bennett spine, that's there in August and that's there in May.
**Sarah:** So one of the things that the matchday tells you is the relationship between continuity and outcome.
**Danny:** Right. The eighty-six side built a thing across forty-two games. The twenty sixteen side survived four managers and somehow ended up at Wembley. And the texture of a matchday morning at Highfield Road in August eighty-six is a city watching its team. The texture of a matchday morning before the Swindon game in August twenty sixteen is a fanbase enduring its ownership while the team plays.
**Sarah:** And both endings are a Wembley win.
**Danny:** Both endings are a Wembley win. Which is the part of the show I genuinely can't get my head around. I've been thinking about this for weeks. The pattern is too perfect. And it doesn't mean anything. It can't mean anything. It's just a — it's just a coincidence with a moral.
**Sarah:** It's a coincidence with a moral. Hang on, I'm writing that down.
**Danny:** Don't write it down. I didn't mean it.
**Sarah:** I'm writing it down.
**Danny:** [sigh] Fine.
**Sarah:** Okay. So if the matchday texture is the thing that holds the two mornings together — and it doesn't, by the way, it really doesn't, they feel completely different — then there's a thing underneath all of this that I want to come at. Which is — and you're going to have to do most of the talking on this, because it's not mine to do — what does it actually mean to be a Coventry supporter? In eighty-six versus twenty seventeen. Like — the sky blue. The colour. The badge. What did putting that on as a kid mean in nineteen eighty-six, and what did putting it on as a kid mean in twenty seventeen?
**Danny:** Right. Yeah. Okay. So. [breath] In nineteen eighty-six, being a Coventry supporter — being a sky blue, the badge, the whole thing — that was an act of civic identity. Being a Coventry supporter and being a Coventry resident, those things weren't separate things. They were the same thing. The colour was the city's colour. The badge was — there were factories in Coventry that had elephants on, by the way. The elephant on the badge is from the city, not from the football club. The badge precedes the football club in some sense, because the badge is the city's badge that the football club has taken.
**Sarah:** Right. So when you wore sky blue in eighty-six, you weren't choosing a football team. You were identifying as being from the place.
**Danny:** You were identifying as being from the place. And the place, at that point — Coventry was a manufacturing city. Standard Triumph was still there, just about. Jaguar was still there. Peugeot Ryton, the old Rootes plant, still going. There were tens of thousands of people in Coventry making cars or making things that went into cars. And the football club, since Jimmy Hill, was the cultural front end of that city. Jimmy Hill — and this gets into the bit we'll do more in later episodes — Jimmy Hill came in as manager in the early sixties and rebranded the whole club. The Sky Blues, the song, the colour scheme, the marketing, the family-friendly stadium — all of that was Hill. And what Hill did was, he made the football club legible as the city's club. Not just a team in the city. The city's club. There's a difference.
**Sarah:** And then by twenty seventeen?
**Danny:** By twenty seventeen, the manufacturing is mostly gone. The factories are mostly gone. The city's identity as a manufacturing town has been — it's not been replaced, exactly, it's just been thinned out. And the football club, instead of being the cultural front end of a thriving manufacturing city, has become, by twenty seventeen, a kind of — a kind of stubbornness. Being a Coventry supporter in twenty seventeen is not civic pride. Civic pride doesn't quite fit, because the civic frame has changed. Being a Coventry supporter in twenty seventeen is — it's defiance.
**Sarah:** Defiance against what?
**Danny:** Defiance against the idea that the club should be allowed to disappear. Defiance against the ownership. Defiance against the rest of football that's largely moved on. Defiance against the fact that the club doesn't really, at that point, own its stadium properly, has been managed badly for a long time, has fallen three divisions, and yet here you are, on the Saturday, putting on the sky blue and going to the Ricoh anyway. Or watching it on the telly. Or driving down from wherever you ended up after you left Coventry to chase work.
**Sarah:** Which is something that, structurally, when I look at the demographics of Coventry, is a real thing. A lot of the people who would have been supporters in eighty-seven — their kids didn't stay in Coventry. So the supporter base for twenty seventeen includes a lot of people who don't live in Coventry anymore but who still consider themselves Coventry supporters, because their dad supported the club, or their granddad worked at the factory.
**Danny:** Yeah. And the generational handover is the bit I find — I find that genuinely difficult, actually, to talk about, because — my dad supported the club because he was from Coventry. I supported the club because my dad did. The whole thing is — you don't choose this. You inherit it. And by twenty seventeen, the people inheriting it are inheriting it not as a thing to be proud of in the way I inherited it. They're inheriting it as a — as a — [pause] as a thing you're being asked to carry. Like a relay. Don't let it drop. That's the message. Just don't let it drop. Whatever the table says, whatever the ownership says, whatever the stadium situation says, don't let the colour drop.
**Sarah:** So the badge in eighty-seven says, I am from this place and this place is going somewhere. And the badge in twenty seventeen says, I am from this place and this place still exists.
**Danny:** [soft]Yeah.[/soft] That's it. That's exactly it.
**Sarah:** And does the identity survive that? Like — at some point, if the institution keeps collapsing, does the identity attached to it just become a memory? Does the sky blue become a vintage thing — like the Premier League shirts the supporters were wearing at Swindon? Just a thing you remember?
**Danny:** That's the question. That is the question. And I'd push back on the premise of it, actually, because I don't think the identity is attached to the institution in the way you're suggesting. I think the identity is attached to the place. And the place still exists. The factories are gone, the institution is wobbling, the league position has collapsed — but Coventry the city is still there. The Lower Precinct is still there. The cathedral's still there. The old one and the new one. And as long as the place is still there, the identity attached to the place has somewhere to live.
**Sarah:** And the football club is the cultural carrier for the place.
[VOICE_NOTE: Measured, reflective, almost philosophical. Let the ideas breathe. Slow pacing.]
REGISTER: contemplative, intimate
**Danny:** The football club is the cultural carrier. That's what Hill set up in nineteen sixty-two and that's what's still operating in twenty seventeen, even when the football itself is bad. The football can be bad and the cultural carrier still works. The badge still means something even when the team's twenty-third in League One. Because the badge isn't about the team. The badge is about the place. The team is just — the team is the conversation the place has with itself on a Saturday afternoon.
**Sarah:** The team is the conversation the place has with itself on a Saturday afternoon. That's — that's it, isn't it. That's the show.
**Danny:** Right. And — look — I want to say the bit, and then we'll move on, because we're going to come back to this in episode three and again in episode eight and probably more after that. But the thing about being a sky blue, the thing about being a Coventry supporter — sky blue is a sentence you finish with your life. That's how it works. You start the sentence as a kid, when somebody puts the shirt on you, and you finish the sentence at the end of your life. And in between, whatever happens to the team, whatever happens to the league position, whatever happens to the stadium — the sentence keeps going. You're finishing it. The cup in eighty-seven was a comma in that sentence. A really big, really bright comma. The relegation in twenty seventeen was a — was a different kind of punctuation. But the sentence is still being finished. By me, by my dad — by my dad's lot — by the people who came after. The sentence keeps going.
**Sarah:** And the question I want to leave hanging, because we're about to take a breath — the question I want to leave hanging is, what happens when the next generation, the people who are now ten years old in twenty seventeen, finish the sentence? What does sky blue mean to them? Because they didn't see eighty-seven. They didn't see the top flight. They saw four managers in one season and a trophy at Wembley played in front of a stadium where their home semi-final pulled thirteen hundred people. That's their starting point.
[VOICE_NOTE: Measured, reflective storytelling. Build momentum through the economic detail. Let the weight of the contrast land.]
REGISTER: conversational, analytical
**Danny:** That's their starting point. And —
**Danny:** And — that's actually where I want to come at this next thing, because the kid who's ten in twenty seventeen, the kid who's at the EFL Trophy final at Wembley — that kid woke up on a particular kind of morning, in a particular kind of country. And I think one of the things we haven't really named yet is the weather around the football. The actual mood of the country in each of these two Augusts. Because they're really different.
**Sarah:** Yeah. They're really different. And this is the bit — this is genuinely the bit I've been wanting to get to all episode, because it's the thing that feels obvious to me from the outside and might feel less obvious from inside it. So — set the scene for me. August nineteen eighty-six. What does Britain feel like that summer? Because I've got my version of it from reading and from David's notebooks, but I want yours, because you were nine.
**Danny:** I was nine. I was — right, look, the thing about being nine is, you don't have a national mood. You've got a road. You've got a school. You've got a Saturday. So I'm not going to pretend I had some kind of Thatcherite analysis going at nine years old. But I can tell you what was around me. Which was — there were grown-ups who were quieter than they used to be. There were grown-ups who'd stopped going to certain pubs. There were houses on the road that had For Sale signs up that hadn't shifted for months. And there were two kinds of grown-ups in Coventry in nineteen eighty-six. There were the ones who still had a job at one of the factories, and there were the ones who'd lost a job at one of the factories. And those two kinds of grown-ups did not, by that summer, talk to each other in quite the same way they used to.
**Sarah:** Right. So the miners' strike has ended in March eighty-five. That's eighteen months before this season opens. And the West Midlands isn't a coalfield in the same way South Yorkshire or Nottinghamshire is — but the industrial story is the same story. The strike ends, the union's broken, and what follows is basically a year and a half of slow, quiet, structural job losses across all the manufacturing towns that were watching the coalfields go.
**Danny:** Yeah. And the thing about the Midlands is — it's not coal. It's cars. But the logic is the same. The logic is, we used to make things here, and we are gradually being told that we are not going to make those things here for very much longer, or at least not in the numbers we used to. Standard Triumph at Canley — the Canley plant — that had been winding down for years by eighty-six. Jaguar Brown's Lane was still there but — you know — the workforce was nothing like what it had been. Peugeot Ryton was still going but it was — it had become a kind of a — it had become a kind of holdout rather than a thriving thing.
**Sarah:** And meanwhile the national story, the Westminster story, is — Thatcher is in her second term. Falklands glow has faded. Westland blew up the cabinet in January eighty-six. Heseltine's resigned. The polls are decent for her but not great. And you've got this — and this is the bit that always strikes me when I read the eighty-six press — you've got this strange split mood, where the City of London is having a really good time. The stock market is going up. There are people in the south-east making money in ways that hadn't existed five years earlier. Big Bang is coming in October eighty-six, financial deregulation. So the financial economy is genuinely booming. And the manufacturing economy is genuinely dying. And those two economies are happening in the same country at the same time.
**Danny:** And Coventry's on the wrong side of that line.
[VOICE_NOTE: Measured, analytical storytelling. Build momentum through the parallels. Let the weight of thirty years settle in the pauses.]
REGISTER: analytical, reflective, building
**Sarah:** Coventry is squarely on the wrong side of that line. So the optimism that you can find in nineteen eighty-six — and you can find it, the polling shows it, the Gallup numbers show fifty-two per cent saying they're optimistic about the economy — that optimism is concentrated in places where the financial economy is the lived economy. It's not concentrated in Coventry.
**Danny:** No. The mood in Coventry that summer, as much as a nine-year-old can read it, was — it was wary. It was wary. I remember — and this is just a kid's memory, this isn't analysis — I remember that the conversations at family things, at — I don't know, at someone's birthday or at Christmas the year before — the conversations had got more careful. People had stopped saying things they used to say. About work. About what they were going to do. About what was going to happen to the kid who'd just left school. There was a kind of — there was a kind of holding of breath, which I don't think I noticed at the time but I notice when I think back on it now.
**Sarah:** And then the football season starts. And what does the football do, in that mood? Because this is the bit I'm interested in. The football is — for a city like Coventry, the football is not a distraction from the mood. The football is part of the mood. So Coventry go to West Ham, twenty-third of August, lose nil-one. What does that feel like, on the back of all this?
**Danny:** It feels like — fine. Honestly. It feels like fine. Because you have to remember, by August eighty-six, Coventry have spent — they've been in the top flight since sixty-seven. Nineteen years. Almost every season, they've been in a relegation fight. The mood of the supporter, the mood of the supporter going into eighty-six, was — we'll be alright. We'll scrap. We'll lose some, we'll win some, we'll finish fifteenth, sixteenth, seventeenth. That's what we do. So losing one-nil at Upton Park on the opening day — nobody woke up on the twenty-fourth of August nineteen eighty-six and thought, oh dear, the season's over. They thought — yeah, that's about right. That's a Coventry away day. We'll get them at home.
**Sarah:** And there's no expectation of a cup run. There's no expectation of finishing tenth. There's no expectation that this is the year. None of that exists yet.
**Danny:** None of that exists. That's the thing about eighty-six that I think gets lost when you tell the story backwards. We tell it backwards because we know how it ends. We know it ends with Wembley. So everything we say about the start of the season has Wembley sitting on top of it, like — like a coat of paint over the actual season. But the actual season, in August eighty-six, was just another season. Curtis and Sillett aren't even joint managers yet. In August eighty-six it's just — it's just the club, doing the thing it does, in a city that's quietly worrying about what's going to happen next.
**Sarah:** And then twenty sixteen. August twenty sixteen.
**Danny:** [exhale] Right. So. Skip thirty years. I'm thirty-nine. The country has — okay. The country has just voted, two months earlier, on the twenty-third of June twenty sixteen, to leave the European Union. And I'm not going to do politics on this show, because that's not what we do, but you cannot tell the story of what the football felt like in August twenty sixteen without saying that everybody was, at some level, processing what had just happened in June.
**Sarah:** And Coventry voted leave. The city voted leave. By a fairly clear margin.
**Danny:** Coventry voted leave. By — I think it was about fifty-five forty-five. Don't quote me. Around there. And the reasons it voted leave are the reasons we've just been talking about. The reasons it voted leave are sat right there in the conversation we just had about nineteen eighty-six. Because the line from the factories closing in the mid-eighties to the referendum result in twenty sixteen — that's not a coincidence. That's the same story. That's a thirty-year story of a place being told that the thing that gave it its identity, the thing that made it, was over, and being asked to find a new thing, and not really finding one.
**Sarah:** Right. And so the country in August twenty sixteen — I was in London by then, I'd moved over a few years before — the country in August twenty sixteen had this — it had this kind of — almost a vertigo. Like, nobody actually knew what was about to happen. Theresa May had just become Prime Minister in July. David Cameron had walked off the lawn at Downing Street humming. The pound had dropped. Article Fifty hadn't been triggered yet. There was this — kind of a pause. And it was a pause that some people experienced as triumph and other people experienced as panic, depending on how they'd voted.
**Danny:** And in Coventry, in the actual city — the mood was — I'm going to say the mood was not triumphal. Even among the leave voters, the mood was not triumphal. The mood was — okay, well, we've done that, now what. There was a kind of — there was a kind of waiting, which is what I think a lot of the country had, but it had a particular flavour in the Midlands, because the Midlands had been waiting for a long time already.
**Sarah:** And then the football season starts. Sixth of August twenty sixteen. Coventry go to Swindon. One-nil. Kasim scored for Swindon.
**Danny:** Late goal, yeah. Gut punch goal as well. Because — look, the symmetry, the eerie symmetry of two season openers, both away, both one-nil defeats, thirty years apart — Sarah, you spotted that, right? You'd written that up.
**Sarah:** I had it in the spreadsheet. It was the first thing — when I started building this series out and matching the two seasons fixture by fixture, that was the first parallel that came up, and it was the parallel that made me think, okay, there might be a podcast in this. Because — yeah. Twenty-third of August nineteen eighty-six, away, lose one-nil. Sixth of August twenty sixteen, away, lose one-nil. Different opponents. Different divisions. Same opening result. And in both cases, the season that follows is going to end at Wembley. Which — at the start of either August, you couldn't have known.
**Danny:** And in both cases, the August defeat doesn't feel, at the time, like the start of anything significant. It just feels like — yeah. Coventry, away, on the opening day. That'll be a defeat. That's the brand.
**Sarah:** [laugh] That's the brand.
[VOICE_NOTE: Measured, analytical storytelling. Build the historical comparison with clarity and weight. Let the numbers breathe.]
REGISTER: narrative exposition
**Danny:** That is the brand. But the difference between the two Augusts — and this is what I want to get to — the difference between the two Augusts is what was sat behind the defeat. In eighty-six, what was sat behind the defeat was a city quietly worried, but a club still in the top flight, still expecting to be in the top flight, still able to point at — Cyrille Regis, Brian Kilcline, Trevor Peake, players who could play at that level. In twenty sixteen, what was sat behind the defeat was a city that had stopped expecting things to get better, and a club that had been managed by a hedge fund out of London for nine years, and a stadium that the club didn't really own, and a fanbase that had just lived through the Sixfields exile a couple of years before, and was now watching attendance numbers tick down.
**Sarah:** And the average attendance for that season is going to come in at about nine thousand.
**Danny:** Nine thousand and change. In a stadium that holds thirty-two thousand.
**Sarah:** In a stadium that holds thirty-two thousand. And the lowest gate of the season is going to be seven and a half thousand for Southend in March. Seven thousand four hundred and sixty-six. Which — that's a number I want to sit with for a second, because that number is — that's not a football crowd. That's a — that's a parish meeting. That's a small concert. That is not a football crowd for a club that, thirty years earlier, was hosting Liverpool in a League Cup tie.
**Danny:** Hosting Liverpool, yeah. Drawing nil-nil with Liverpool in the League Cup at home. We'll do that one in episode two probably. But — yeah. That's the gap. That is the gap. And the mood of the country, in August twenty sixteen, was — I think the honest version of it is, the mood of the country in August twenty sixteen was a kind of held breath that didn't know what it was holding its breath for. And the mood of supporting Coventry inside that held breath was — it was a held breath inside a held breath. It was — we don't know what the country is becoming, and we don't know what our club is becoming, and both of those are happening at once. And there's a Tuesday night fixture against Bury at the Ricoh that nine thousand people are going to go to.
**Sarah:** And what I want to say from the outside — because I think this is something that's hard to feel from inside it — what I want to say from the outside is, the August nineteen eighty-six mood and the August twenty sixteen mood are not opposites. They're the same mood at different stages. The eighty-six mood is the mood at the start of a long decline. The twenty sixteen mood is the mood thirty years into the same long decline. They are continuous with each other. The story doesn't break. The story just — gets longer.
**Danny:** [pause] Yeah. I think that's right. I think — I want to push back a little, only because — there is a thing in eighty-six which is genuinely different, which is that in eighty-six there's still a — there's still a sense of agency. There's still a sense that the city has something to lose. By twenty sixteen, the city has already lost a lot of what was at stake in eighty-six. So the mood is — the mood is more — the mood is more resigned. But you're right that it's the same story. It's not a different story. It's the same story, just further down the line.
**Sarah:** And what the football does, in both years — what the football does is, the football is the place where the city goes to refuse the conclusion of the story. The football is where the city says, no, this is not over, even if everything else is telling us it is. And in both years that refusal ends up with a trophy at Wembley, which is — that's almost too neat. That's almost too on the nose. But it's what happened.
**Danny:** It's what happened. And that's — right. Look. That gets me to the thing I want to talk about for a minute, because if you're going to talk about Coventry as a place that exports a refusal — Coventry as a place that exports something defiant from the bottom of a long decline — there's only one other example in living memory of the city doing that, and it's not the football.
[VOICE_NOTE: Measured, reflective storytelling. Build ideas carefully. Honour the weight of what's being discussed. Warm but not sentimental.]
REGISTER: Conversational, analytical, respectful
**Sarah:** It's the Specials.
**Danny:** It's the Specials. Yeah. And I want to plant this now because we're going to come back to it properly in episode three, but you can't do an episode about being a Coventry supporter, about what sky blue means, about civic identity, without at least naming the Specials. Because the Specials are the cultural equivalent of what the football club did in nineteen eighty-seven. They are the moment when Coventry, as a place, defined the country, instead of being defined by it.
**Sarah:** Okay. So before we go on — for the listener who's not from the UK, or who is from the UK but is twenty-five and doesn't quite — let me set the band up. The Specials. Formed in Coventry in nineteen seventy-seven as the Coventry Automatics. Renamed the Specials in seventy-nine. Jerry Dammers on keyboards is the founder, the bandleader, the songwriter, the whole engine. Terry Hall on vocals. Lynval Golding, Horace Panter, Neville Staple, Roddy Radiation, John Bradbury. Multi-racial line-up. Black, white, mixed heritage, on stage together in a Coventry that, in seventy-seven, seventy-eight, was being pulled at by the National Front, was a city with real racial tension running through it. And the band's whole reason for existing, the whole point of the project, was to put that tension on stage and make it dance.
**Danny:** Right. And the bit I want to add is — Two Tone Records, which Jerry Dammers sets up in seventy-nine, in Coventry — that label, the black-and-white checkerboard, the Walt Jabsco logo, the rude-boy aesthetic — that comes out of Coventry. Not London. Not Manchester. Coventry. And from that label, in nineteen eighty-one, comes Ghost Town.
**Sarah:** Which is — and this is not me overstating it, this is just the historical fact — Ghost Town is one of the most famous singles of the nineteen eighties in Britain. Number one for three weeks in the summer of eighty-one. And the song is about Coventry. The song is about a city where the factories have closed and the clubs have closed and the streets are empty. And it comes out the same week as riots in Brixton, Toxteth, Handsworth, Moss Side. So this is a song from Coventry that ends up being the soundtrack for the whole country having a nervous breakdown.
**Danny:** And the song is six years before the cup. Right? Eighty-one. Cup is eighty-seven. So when I was a kid, when I was four, five, six — Ghost Town was just a song that was on the radio. I wasn't listening to it as a piece of cultural commentary. I was listening to it as a thing that came on between adverts. But what was going on in that song, the thing that song was doing — it was the city, telling the country, we are dying here, and we are going to make you listen to it on a dancefloor.
**Sarah:** Which is a very specific thing. That's not — that's not protest music in the folk sense. That's not somebody with an acoustic guitar saying, look at the suffering. That is — that is the city saying, we are going to make our suffering rhythmic. We are going to make it move. We are going to make you dance to our problem. And that, to me, is the most Coventry thing imaginable.
**Danny:** It is the most Coventry thing imaginable. And the reason I think it sits next to the football the way it does — the reason I think the Specials and the cup run are kind of the same gesture — is because they are both the city, from a position of structural decline, producing something that the rest of the country has to pay attention to. And then, after producing it, going back to declining. That's the other bit. The Specials don't fix Coventry. The Specials make Ghost Town and then, by the end of eighty-one, the band's basically split. Hall, Golding and Staple leave to form Fun Boy Three. Dammers carries on with the label. The cultural moment passes. And Coventry goes back to being a city that's losing its factories.
**Sarah:** And the cup doesn't fix Coventry either. The cup is May eighty-seven. By the end of the eighties, the club's already — it's already not what it was. Regis leaves in ninety-one. Kilcline leaves in ninety-one. Sillett's gone by ninety. The team that won the cup is, within four years, fully dispersed. The cultural moment passes there too.
**Danny:** And what I think is interesting — what I think is the parallel — is that the Specials and the cup run are the two times in living memory that Coventry, as a place, went, here we are, look at us, and the country went, oh, right, hello, we forgot you were there. And both of them, the Specials and the cup run, both of them came out of bands and squads that nobody outside the city had really rated. The Specials weren't a fashionable London band. They were a Coventry art-school band with a weird ska revival concept and they were not the cool thing in seventy-nine when they started. They became the cool thing. They didn't start as it. And the eighty-six-eighty-seven Coventry squad — Cyrille Regis was thirty by then, Trevor Peake came up through Nuneaton Borough, Brian Borrows had come via Everton and Bolton, Keith Houchen had come from Scunthorpe — these weren't superstars. These were players that other clubs had finished with, in some cases, brought together in the Midlands and made into something the country had to pay attention to.
**Sarah:** And you can draw a line, can't you, from the kind of city that produces the Specials — a city with a real racial mix, a city with a real industrial spine, a city with a real cultural centre at the polytechnic and the art school — to the kind of football club that wins an FA Cup with the squad they had. They're both — they're both products of a particular moment of Coventry that, by the time we get to twenty seventeen, doesn't really exist in the same way anymore.
**Danny:** It doesn't. And — look, I want to be careful here, because I don't want to do the nostalgic thing where I say, oh, Coventry was great in eighty-one and now it's nothing. Coventry's not nothing. Coventry's a city, it's still there, people still live in it, it's got a university, it was UK City of Culture in twenty twenty-one — but the specific cultural-industrial mix that made the Specials possible, and that, in some indirect way, made the eighty-six-eighty-seven team possible, that mix is — that mix is gone. That mix you can't reassemble. And so when you ask what sky blue means in twenty seventeen versus what it meant in eighty-seven, part of the answer is — the city that the colour was the colour of, that city has changed. It hasn't disappeared. But it's changed.
**Sarah:** And the colour is doing extra work as a result. The colour is — the colour is having to carry more, because the things around it that used to also carry the city's identity — the factories, the music, the swagger of being a place that the country listened to — those have thinned out. So the football, and the colour, and the badge, end up being a much heavier thing to be wearing in twenty seventeen, because they're carrying a load that used to be shared.
**Danny:** Yeah. That's well put. That's — yeah. The badge is doing a lot of work in twenty seventeen that it didn't have to do in eighty-seven, because in eighty-seven there was a whole city around it doing some of the work as well.
**Sarah:** And we'll come back to the Specials properly in episode three, and we'll come back to Two Tone properly later in the run, but I wanted to plant it now because — to your point — you can't talk about what it means to be a Coventry supporter without naming the other thing the city did, the other moment the city defined the country. They're the two most famous things Coventry has produced in the last fifty years, and they sit next to each other in a really specific way.
**Danny:** They sit next to each other. And I think — I think the best Coventry supporters, the long-haul ones, the ones who were there in eighty-seven and there in twenty seventeen, they know that intuitively. They feel it. They wouldn't necessarily phrase it the way we just phrased it, but they feel it. They feel that the Specials and the cup are kind of the same fact about the city. That's the bit I want to leave.
**Sarah:** Right. And that's the bridge — and this is where I want to land us, because we need to land us — that's the bridge to the last thing I want to ask, which is about the supporter. The actual supporter. The one person, or the type of person, who's been there longer than anyone. Because — Danny, you're nearly forty-nine. You've seen — you've seen a portion of this story. But there are people who saw eighty-seven who were already old in eighty-seven. There are people who saw eighty-seven who'd seen Coventry in the lower divisions before Jimmy Hill. There are people watching twenty seventeen who were watching them at Highfield Road in the fifties.
**Danny:** Right. And — okay. This is the bit I'm going to do, because — because it's a thing that I feel quite strongly about, and Sarah's been sort of nudging me at it for a while.
**Sarah:** I'm letting you have this.
**Danny:** [laugh] You're letting me have it. Right. So — the supporter who's been there longer than anyone. The person I've got in my head when I think about this — I'm not going to name them, because they're real and I don't want to put them on a podcast — but I've got a person in my head, and I think every Coventry supporter listening to this has got a similar person in their head. The man, usually a man, sometimes a woman, who was at the FA Cup semi-final at Hillsborough in eighty-seven, and was at the EFL Trophy final at Wembley in twenty seventeen, and has been to almost every home game in between. And by twenty seventeen, that person is in their seventies, possibly their eighties. They would have started going as a child in the late forties, the early fifties. They'd have seen Coventry in the old Third Division South. They'd have seen Jimmy Hill come in. They'd have seen the rebrand. They'd have seen the rise to the top flight in sixty-seven. They'd have seen nineteen years of relegation fights. They'd have seen the cup. They'd have seen the slow drift down through the divisions. They'd have seen Highfield Road close. They'd have made the move to the Ricoh. They'd have lived through Sixfields, the exile to Northampton, which is the bit that anybody listening from outside Coventry probably needs explaining and we'll do properly later. And they'd have got to Wembley in twenty seventeen, because of course they would have. Of course they would have.
**Sarah:** And what does that person — what is that person carrying?
**Danny:** What that person is carrying — what that person is carrying is the only continuous account of the football club. Because the institution itself isn't continuous. The institution has been managed by — I don't know — fifteen different sets of people. The stadium changed. The squad turned over five, six, seven times. The division changed. The marketing changed. The kit suppliers changed. The owners changed. The badge has been redesigned more than once. None of that is continuous. The only continuous thing is that person, in the seat, going. They are the institution. The institution lives in their attendance.
**Sarah:** And the vocabulary they use for the two Wembleys is going to be different from the vocabulary anyone else uses.
**Danny:** Completely different. Because — okay — for me, eighty-seven is a memory from when I was nine. For somebody five years younger than me, eighty-seven is a story they were told. For somebody fifteen years younger, eighty-seven is highlights footage on YouTube. But for the long-haul fan, eighty-seven isn't a memory. Eighty-seven is — eighty-seven is a moment in a much longer thing they're carrying. They don't talk about it the way we talk about it, because for them it isn't separable from the rest. Eighty-seven, to them, is a Saturday. It's just a particularly good Saturday. In a sequence of Saturdays that goes back to nineteen forty-nine.
**Sarah:** And twenty seventeen?
**Danny:** Twenty seventeen, to them, is also a Saturday. It's a strange Saturday. It's a Saturday where the trophy doesn't quite make sense given the league position. But it's a Saturday. And what they have, that the rest of us don't have, is the ability to put the strange Saturday next to all the other Saturdays and say, fine. That's another one. Onto the next one. The long-haul fan has — they have a kind of equanimity about it that the rest of us can't really fake. Because we haven't earned it. We haven't sat through enough Saturdays to be able to be calm about a strange one.
**Sarah:** And that's the voice — when you go to the Ricoh, when you go to the CBS Arena now, when you sit in the stand, the voice you hear around you that's most different from yours, that you most want to listen to — that's the voice of the person who's been there longer than anyone.
**Danny:** That's the voice. And that voice — what that voice does, when something bad happens on the pitch, is — that voice doesn't shout. That voice goes — yeah, that's about right. That voice has the most West Midlands response, the most flat, the most — yeah, that'll do. And when something good happens on the pitch, that voice doesn't go mental either. That voice goes — about time. And both of those — both the yeah, that's about right, and the about time — both of those are things you can only earn by being there for fifty, sixty years. You can't fake that. You can't read your way to that. You can't analyse your way to that. You have to do the time.
**Sarah:** And that's, in a way, what the show is trying to listen for. We can't be that voice. You can't be that voice — you're forty-eight, you've done forty years. I can't be that voice — I'm an inheritance, I built my Coventry from David's notebooks. We can't be the voice. But we can listen for it. And we can put what we say up against what that voice would say, and notice when our analysis sounds wrong against it.
**Danny:** And the voice would tell us, I think, about both Wembleys — the voice would say, eighty-seven was lovely, twenty seventeen was lovely, and the rest of it is football. The voice would not tell you that one of them counts more than the other. The voice would say, they were both Saturdays. They were both finals. They were both the club, going to Wembley, and winning. Whatever the league position was around it. The voice — the voice would refuse the comparison we've been making for an hour. The voice would say, you're overthinking it.
**Sarah:** [laugh] Yeah. Probably. Probably.
**Danny:** [laugh] Probably. And honestly — that's a fair point. That voice's fair point. We are overthinking it. But the show's overthinking it on purpose. The show is saying — okay, we're going to look at these two Saturdays in detail, because the rest of football culture has not really known what to do with the second one, and the first one has become — the first one has become slightly mythologised in a way that I think obscures what actually happened. So we're going to spend a season pulling them both apart and putting them next to each other. And the long-haul fan, in the seat, who's been there since the fifties — they will probably listen to one episode and decide we are talking nonsense. And that's fair. That's their right. They've earned it.
**Sarah:** And we've not.
**Danny:** And we've not. Yeah. So — yeah. That's where I want to leave the supporter bit. Which is just — there is a person who has been carrying this thing longer than us, and the show should know that person is listening, and the show should be honest with that person.
[VOICE_NOTE: Warm, reflective, slightly breathless—Sarah wrapping up a big episode with earned satisfaction and gentle humor.]
REGISTER: light_warm
**Sarah:** Right. Okay. So that — that's a lot. We've covered — we've covered a lot. We started with the Houchen header from your living room and Bigirimana from a Wembley that was half empty. We've gone through the goals. We've gone through the table — points per game, three tiers between them, all that. We've gone through the season-opener defeats, the Boleyn Ground and the County Ground, both nil-one, thirty years apart, eerie. We've talked about Curtis and Sillett finding the belief inside the building and Mowbray, Slade, Robins managing one season between three of them. We've talked about West Ham at Upton Park and Swindon at the County Ground. We've done national mood. We've done the Specials. We've done the long-haul fan. And we've planted — the ladder inverted has been on this episode at least three times.
**Danny:** Three times, yeah. That's a thing. The ladder inverted is, if anyone's just joining us — Coventry's history makes more sense upside down than the right way up. Coventry win trophies in the wrong divisions and lose league points in the right ones. Coventry win the FA Cup the year they finish tenth in the top flight, which is fine. And then thirty years later, Coventry win the EFL Trophy the year they finish twenty-third in League One and get relegated to League Two. The ladder is inverted. The trophy comes when the table is at its worst. And the worse the table gets, the more likely the trophy is. That's the joke. That's the running joke. It will return. It will return many times this series.
**Sarah:** It will absolutely return. And I will try and find a stat that disproves it, and I will fail.
[VOICE_NOTE: Warm, conversational, slightly conspiratorial. Danny amused; Sarah matter-of-fact but engaged. Natural pacing.]
REGISTER: light_warm
**Danny:** [laugh] You'll fail. Yeah. The ladder is genuinely inverted. The ladder is — the ladder is a mathematical fact about the football club at this point.
**Sarah:** Yeah. And the other thing I want to do before we close — your uncle Trevor.
**Danny:** Oh, here we go.
**Sarah:** Brief mention only. Brief mention only. You said earlier — you mentioned Trevor stopped going after eighty-seven. We're not going to do that now. But I want it on the record that we're going to come back to it. Because Trevor is — Trevor is a version of the long-haul fan we just described, except Trevor stopped going. And the question of why he stopped going is — that's a thing we'll do.
**Danny:** That's a thing we'll do. Yeah. Trevor's TV is where the football lived in our family from the late eighties onwards. We'll get there. We'll get there. We've got — what, twelve more episodes in this run? Plenty of time for Trevor.
**Sarah:** Plenty of time for Trevor. And David's notebooks. Which I'm going to be reading from across the run.
**Danny:** And David's notebooks. Which the listener should know — David is Sarah's dad, who emigrated from Coventry to the States in the late seventies, and he kept notebooks of every Coventry season he could get information on, and Sarah is reading the eighty-six-eighty-seven notebook in sequence, in real time, as we go through this series. Which is — that's the bit, that's the thing that, whenever Sarah quotes from the notebook, the listener should know that's a man who left Coventry in nineteen seventy-something writing about his football club from another country. There's a — there's a real thing happening in that.
**Sarah:** There is. And I'll bring it in when it fits. I won't force it.
[VOICE_NOTE: Warm, reflective, and measured—Danny wraps up with clarity and satisfaction; Sarah matches his thoughtfulness.]
[REGISTER: warm]
**Danny:** Right. So — okay. To bring this thing in to land. The thesis. The thesis we set up at the start was, two Wembley wins, thirty years apart, and the rest of football culture has decided the first one matters and the second one doesn't, and we are going to spend a series asking whether that decision is correct. And what we've done in this episode is, we've laid out the geography of the question. We've put eighty-six-eighty-seven on one side and twenty sixteen-seventeen on the other, and we've said, here are the parallels, here are the differences, here's what was sitting underneath each season, here's what the city was doing at each end. Next week we're going to start opening the cup runs properly. We're going to do the early rounds. We're going to do Bolton Wanderers in January eighty-seven and we're going to do the EFL Trophy group stage in twenty sixteen, which is — that's a very different competition with a very different texture, and I think that contrast is going to do a lot of work for us.
**Sarah:** It's going to do a lot of work. The EFL Trophy group stage in twenty sixteen-seventeen is — for anybody who doesn't know, it's the year the EFL Trophy was opened up to under-twenty-three teams from Premier League and Championship clubs, which was hugely unpopular with lower-league fans, and the attendances tanked, and Coventry's group-stage games were drawing — what, fifteen hundred, seven thousand people. And then the final drew seventy-four thousand. So that competition, just on its own, is one of the strangest competitions ever held in English football, and the fact that Coventry won it is — yeah. We'll do all that.
**Danny:** We'll do all that. So — yeah. That's the show. That's episode one. The thesis is set, the timelines are set, the parallels are set, the running jokes are planted, the people we're going to come back to are introduced. From here on in, every episode is going to be opening one specific thing in detail.
**Sarah:** And the question — the question I want to leave hanging, because Danny said it earlier and I want to repeat it because it landed for me — sky blue is a sentence you finish with your life. And the question is, what does the sentence mean for the kid who's ten in twenty seventeen, who didn't see eighty-seven, and whose first Wembley is a half-empty one. We're going to come back to that.
**Danny:** We're going to come back to that. Right. I should do the credits. Before we go — the data for today's episode came from The Guardian's archive, from Wikipedia, and from Perplexity AI. The show is hosted on Microsoft Azure and our AI pipeline runs with support from the Google Founder Programme. Show notes, transcripts and the episode archive are at skybluetimemachine.com. That's sky blue time machine dot com. We'll see you next week. Episode two. Cup runs, early rounds. Bolton Wanderers in the rain, and an EFL Trophy group stage that nobody asked for.
**Sarah:** See you next week.
**Danny:** Right. Bye.