Subscribe
Share
Share
Embed
Your brand's reputation isn't built in a moment — it's built over time. And in today’s fast-moving world, waiting to communicate until you have to is a dangerous strategy.
The Pool Theory is a modern framework for proactive visibility — created for leaders, entrepreneurs, and organizations who want to build trust before the spotlight hits.
This audiobook walks you step-by-step through how to assess your current visibility, spot your blind spots, strengthen your authority, and create a sustainable rhythm for showing up with clarity and confidence — no matter what comes your way.
Whether you're a founder raising capital, a policy-facing business navigating public perception, or a personal brand building long-term influence, this audiobook will help you:
✔ Clarify your message and visibility goals
✔ Build media and stakeholder relationships that matter
✔ Prepare for high-stakes moments before they arrive
✔ And create a presence that earns trust — even when you're not in the room
Includes access to a free companion workbook with worksheets and reflection prompts at thepooltheory.com.
Don’t wait for a crisis to show the world who you are. Start filling your pool now — before you’re thirsty.
Chapter 7: Metrics That Actually Matter
When it comes to brand visibility and communications, we’ve trained ourselves to chase the wrong scoreboard.
• How many followers?
• How many likes?
• What’s the reach?
Those metrics aren’t useless — but they’re not the full picture.
Because if 100,000 people see your content but no one trusts your leadership, or understands your value, your pool isn’t growing — it’s leaking.
In this chapter, we’ll shift your mindset from vanity metrics to value metrics — the ones that tell you if your brand is actually working in the ways that matter most.
The Two Types of Brand Metrics
et’s talk about how to measure your visibility the right way.
Picture a simple table with two columns. On the left? Vanity metrics. On the right? Value metrics.
Now, I’ll read through a few pairs — so you can hear the difference between surface-level attention and meaningful connection.
Here we go:
• Follower count... versus stakeholder engagement.
• Impressions... versus content shares by the people you actually want to reach.
• Likes and views... versus inbound referrals and real invitations.
• Page visits... versus time spent on the page — did they skim or actually read?
• Newsletter size... versus how many people are opening your emails and writing back.
Let’s break this down:
Vanity metrics measure attention.
They’re the surface ripples — things that feel good, but don’t always move the needle.
Value metrics measure connection.
They tell you if your message is landing with the people who matter.
And connection — not just attention — is what fills your pool.
So as you look at your data, don’t just ask “How many saw this?”
Ask: “Did the right people care enough to act?”
That’s your real measure of momentum.
Start With This Question: What Are We Trying to Influence?
Metrics only matter if they tie back to something meaningful.
So before you build a dashboard, ask:
Who are we trying to influence — and what action do we want them to take?
For example:
• If you're trying to win public contracts → Do decision-makers recognize and trust your company?
• If you're trying to attract investors → Is your leadership team seen as credible and compelling?
• If you're trying to build authority → Are people referencing, quoting, or inviting you into high-level conversations?
• If you’re trying to gain local clientele → Do people in your community see you as the go-to expert and know what you offer without having to ask?
Those outcomes are measurable — but you have to define them first.
Three Signals Your Pool Is Growing
Here are three of the most powerful (but often overlooked), indicators that your communications are working:
1. You’re being mentioned in the right rooms — without being in them.
• Clients mention seeing your CEO’s article.
• A neighbor says, “I’ve seen your business pop up everywhere lately — what exactly do you do again?”
• A local chamber contact tags you in a thread before you even join the conversation.
• A reporter calls you directly for a quote.
• Partners reference your messaging in their own pitches.
That’s not SEO. That’s authority.
2. People respond to your content — in ways that lead somewhere.
• Not just likes, but real comments, replies, and DMs from relevant people.
• Not just “cool post,” but “can we hop on a call?” from someone in your own zip code.
• A referral lands in your inbox with the subject line: ‘You’ve got to talk to this person — I follow them on LinkedIn.’
• Not just open rates, but forwards, shares, and invitations that follow.
That’s not hype. That’s influence.
3. Stakeholders are more aligned — and stay longer.
• Your assistant knows what kind of opportunities to flag because the messaging is clear and consistent.
• Your long-time customers become informal ambassadors — tagging, recommending, and defending your brand.
• Employees cite your messaging in conversations.
• Board members refer to your public communications in meetings.
• Clients stick with you through price changes, pivots, or growing pains.
That’s not reach. That’s retention.
My Approach to Measurement
I encourage clients to build lightweight, focused dashboards using a mix of quantitative and qualitative metrics. A few things we track regularly include:
• Media mentions in strategic outlets
• Backlinks and SEO ranking for core message themes
• Share of voice vs. competitors
• Inbound partnership or investor inquiries
• Engagement from key personas (e.g., state officials, press, buyers)
• Internal confidence — measured by employee surveys or exec input
• Monthly Authority Score (a 1–10 rating across clarity, credibility, and consistency)
We don’t drown in data. We focus on meaningful movement.
Real-World Example: A Construction Company Rebuilds Its Reputation — and Its Visibility
One of our clients, a family-owned construction company with more than 20 years of success, came to us during a period of both crisis and transition. Known for their quality workmanship and longstanding client relationships, the business had grown steadily over the years — but had never focused much on brand visibility or community presence.
That changed quickly after a tragic accident.
A company vehicle, clearly marked with their logo, was involved in a road incident where an employee accidentally struck a bicyclist. The incident made the local news. Both the driver’s name and the company name were mentioned in early coverage. Even though the team cooperated fully with investigators and responded responsibly, the damage was already done.
Leads slowed. Community trust faltered. Referrals dried up.
The company had been excellent at its work — but had done little to tell that story publicly. When the crisis hit, there was no pool to draw from.
At the Same Time, a Leadership Shift Was Underway
The incident also coincided with a generational handoff — the founder was passing the reins to his son, who had a fresh vision for the business. It was a chance to reset not just the management structure, but the entire brand presence.
We partnered with them to reestablish their identity from the inside out.
The goal wasn't just damage control — it was to lay a foundation for future trust, community connection, and visibility.
What We Changed
We helped them restructure their brand communications around three measurable priorities:
1. Positive visibility in local and regional media — not about apologizing, but about showing up for the community, including coverage of their volunteer projects, safety innovations, and workforce development work.
2. Local lead generation from higher-trust channels — shifting away from broad online ads toward relationship-based marketing with real community touchpoints.
3. Leadership presence and storytelling — positioning the new CEO as the next-generation builder focused on transparency, safety, and integrity.
What Happened Next
Within six months, the company had:
• Earned multiple features in local press — not about the incident, but about positive, forward-looking community work
• Begun rebuilding its referral pipeline through new partnerships with schools, suppliers, and neighborhood groups
• Increased qualified local leads by over 40% — without spending more on ads
• Seen internal morale and public perception recover, thanks to consistent, confident, and aligned messaging
They didn’t need more marketing. They needed a narrative shift, rooted in who they really were — and a new rhythm for how they showed up.
The Pool Theory in Action
This story wasn’t about likes or impressions. It was about building authority and visibility that aligned with values — and doing it with enough intention to weather scrutiny and spark growth.
Because when the pool is shallow, even a single incident can feel like a flood. But when it’s full — even hard moments become part of a longer, stronger brand story.
Coming Up Next: Tracking the Pool Over Time
You’ve done the work — now it’s time to see the progress.
In the companion workbook, you’ll find the Brand Health Tracker — a simple but powerful exercise that helps you monitor the metrics that actually matter to your visibility and brand trust.
This isn’t about likes or views.
It’s about real signals:
• Are people referring you?
• Are opportunities finding you?
• Are you becoming the go-to voice in your space?
You’ll identify 3 to 5 value-based metrics, set benchmarks, track your goals, and reflect on what’s working — and what’s worth refining.
You can download the full Pool Theory Tool Kit, including this worksheet, anytime at thepooltheory.com.
Because here’s the thing:
When you measure what matters, you don’t have to wonder if you’re ready.
You’ll know you are.
Next up, let’s talk about what happens when the numbers look good… but the foundation isn’t.
We’re diving into the story of Boeing and the 737 Max crisis — and what it reveals about the danger of relying on the wrong scoreboard.
Let’s unpack what happens when metrics mislead.