TCW Investment Perspectives

In this episode of the TCW Investment Perspectives Podcast, host David Vick is joined by securitized credit specialists Palak Pathak and Maggie D'Arcy to examine a CLO market that has grown in size, liquidity, and relevance for fixed income investors. Drawing on their experience across U.S. and European markets, they discuss what’s fueling demand, where relative value is emerging, and why understanding the manager, underlying collateral, and structure remains essential as the asset class matures.

Creators and Guests

DV
Host
David Vick
MD
Guest
Maggie D'Arcy
PP
Guest
Palak Pathak

What is TCW Investment Perspectives?

TCW is a leading global asset management firm with over 50 years of investment experience and a broad range of products across fixed income, equities, emerging markets, and alternative investments. In each episode of TCW Investment Perspectives, professionals from the firm share their insights on global trends and events impacting markets and the investment landscape.

CLOs have become an increasingly important part of the fixed income landscape,
attracting investors with their income potential and structural protections.

But a growing market also demands greater selectivity, from manager

and security selection to differences between the US and Europe,

understanding where the opportunities and risks lie is critical.

Welcome to the TCW Investment Perspectives podcast.

I'm your host, David Vick.

To help us better understand the CLO market and where we see opportunities
today, I'm joined by two members of TCW's fixed income team.

Pawlik Pathak is a managing director, senior portfolio manager,
specialized in securitized credit and CLOs in particular.

Pawlik has been with TCW since 2007, and is also a
member of the fixed income investment committee.

I'm also joined by Maggie Darcy, a senior vice president,

securitized analyst based in London, specializing in

international asset-backed securities and European CLOs.

Pawlik, Maggie, welcome to the podcast.

Thanks, Dave.

Thank you.

So before we get into the market and the opportunity
we're seeing today, let's just start with the basics.

For those listeners who may be less familiar with the asset
class, maybe just a quick refresher on what is a CLO?

How does it work?

Just a little background.

Sure.

A CLO stands for collateralized loan obligation.

At its most basic level, it's a securitized product.

In a securitization, you take a pool of loans and you
then trunch them out into different layers of risk.

And so for a CLO, the difference between a CLO versus other securitized products

is the fact that the collateral that's underlying a CLO are a portfolio of

broadly syndicated high yield corporate loans across different industries.

Then these loans are all pulled together into an
SPV, just like it is in any other securitization.

And then cash flows from these loans are used to pay the tranches in sequential

order, starting from the top, the AAA tranche, all the way down to the bottom,

which would be the residual which would get the remaining

cash flows that are left after paying all the tranches.

And then as in other securitizations, losses are
absorbed from the bottom all the way up to the top.

And so the AAA tranche, which is the safest,
would absorb the losses last, right?

So all the other tranches would take the loss
first before getting to the AAA tranche.

I think a few things to highlight that make CLOs different

from other securitized products, I think the most

important is that these are actively managed vehicles.

And so most other securitized is a static pool of loans, where the loans that
you see on day one are the loans that are in the vehicle, and they don't change.

Whereas in a CLO, there's a five-year, typically, reinvestment period, where

the manager can reinvest these loans as these loans pay off, or they can

also actively trade the portfolio, meaning that they can actively

go out and sell these loans and buy other loans as well.

And so I think that's the really big differentiator outside
of the fact that the collateral is corporate loans.

Also, I think it's important to note that these underlying loans are liquid,
meaning that these are actively traded and they are marked every day.

And so you really get that transparency into CLO collateral, whereas
you don't really get that in other types of securitizations.

And then lastly, I think what's an important differentiator is that
a CLO collateral represents a broad array of different industries.

So within any other kind of securitization, it's
typically you're exposed to just one industry.

So, for example, in ABS, you have auto ABS, and
that's really kind of focusing on the auto sector.

In mortgage-backed securities, it's really the
residential home sector that you are exposed to.

Whereas in a CLO, it's a broad array of different industries,

just like the corporate credit market, where you have exposure

to anywhere from industrials, to healthcare, to technology,

to business services, insurance, et cetera, et cetera.

And the other thing to point out, I think Pollack mentioned
a lot of similarities between US and European CLOs.

We are virtually a carbon copy of US CLOs.

The biggest difference being industry exposures.

Europe, we tend to see a little bit more tilt, and this
is just by virtue of where the loan market is issuing.

We see more healthcare and business services.

Whereas in the US, you tend to see a little bit
more exposure toward technology and financials.

And the other thing which is obvious about a European CLO is

that we're exposed to a broad array of European countries,

France, UK and Germany being some of the highest exposures.

Whereas obviously for a US CLO, the vast majority
of that is going to be the US leverage loan market.

Great.

Thanks very much.

With that as a backdrop, obviously CLOs lately have been very popular.

We've seen massive growth in CLO investment strategies, lots of assets there.

What factors do you think have really driven that growth and
made them such an appealing investment for so many people?

Yeah, sure.

I mean, I think there's a combination of a few factors here.

One is that CLOs are floating rate instruments.

So they are benchmark off of three months SOFR, which means

that given the elevated rate environment we are today,

they have actually very attractive spread or carry.

Second is that, and I'll go into each of these a little bit in more detail,
is that they've had a very strong historical kind of credit performance.

Over many, many decades of different credit cycles.

And then lastly, it's just a lot of the growth has
been driven through the growth in the ETF market.

So just a lot of easier investor access to CLOs through these ETF products.

We go to the first point, which is a floating rate nature.

Given CLO coupons reset with short term interest rates, there

is very little traditional interest rate duration that you're

getting on CLOs, and you're earning very attractive income.

Secondly is the performance.

So CLO AAAs through single A's have never seen any losses, even through the GFC.

So they've performed really, really well through multiple periods of stress.

So I think that gives investors another level of
comfort as far as how CLOs have performed over time.

And then lastly is the ETF growth.

And so that access to the CLO market has really, really increased.

And if you look at CLO ETF AUM today, it's over 60 billion.

And that growth has really been phenomenal with 15
billion of inflows just year to date into that product.

I'm happy to chime in here on Europe as well to give you a perspective of
growth there, because while we are still really small, we have grown a lot.

And we've seen growth in multiple sectors.

We've seen the first issuance of private
credit and middle market CLOs in Europe.

We saw two of those priced this year.

We continue to see new managers enter the space.

So while the manager count in Europe is arguably much smaller
than the US, we saw five new debut managers enter the market.

And we're hearing a long list of other credit
funds that are looking to enter the CLO market.

So that count of 70 managers continues to grow.

We think that can go upwards of 80 in the next year.

One of the things that we know about CLOs is that they tend to
be fairly liquid, especially with other securitized assets.

How would you respond to that?

The liquidity in the CLO sector has really picked up over the last few years.

Typically, what you would see before, I would say two or three years
ago, would be less than a billion trading in terms of daily volume.

Now what you're seeing is one to three billion.

Two is average now, so almost double what you've
seen in the past in terms of daily trading volume.

And so it is the most liquid securitized sector in the US.

And I think what's really important is that liquidity actually picks up.

During times of volatility.

So during Liberation Week, we saw the most amount of CLO
trading volume that week versus other times of the year.

And that really highlights the fact that where other securitized credit sectors
may go quiet because of the volatility and it's more of a wait and see approach.

Investors really look to CLOs to kind of buy and sell during that time.

We're really impressed with how liquid the CLO
market has gotten over the last few years.

Just to touch on European CLOs, they are arguably the
most liquid securitized product space for non-US dollar.

We saw opportunities to add European CLOs in times of distress

during the 2022 LDI guilds crisis, where we saw over 10

billion of European CLOs trade in a couple of weeks.

We see this as an opportunity to pick up relative value
when European CLOs were trading wider than US CLOs.

And the reason why we saw so many European CLOs trade is because when investors

are looking at the most liquid part of their portfolios, CLOs are the easiest

to sell in times of distress, especially what we saw in this event in Europe.

So you touched on some of the differences earlier on the

difference in Europe and the US, obviously some with size,

some with the mix of underlying assets in the industries.

Any other important differences between the US and Europe,

maybe in the way they trade or other regulatory environments

or anything else that might be relevant for people?

Yeah, exactly.

In Europe, you're going to have higher credit enhancement

or protection against losses than you would in the US

because of the fact that the deals are less diverse.

The other important thing to mention on the structure is we see

European CLOs issue AAA all the way down to single B, whereas in

the US, the vast majority of deals are issuing AAA down to BB.

So you do see more leverage in the structure in Europe
because of the addition of that single B tranche.

So it's one thing to watch out for.

It does actually impact the equity returns as well.

Why we think it's important to invest in both asset classes
because they both offer such differing opportunity sets.

And obviously we'll get into the trading dynamics later

on, but also carry a lot of similar qualities that you

can kind of move in and out of each region very easily.

There's often times where European CLOs are a lot more attractive or a
particular tranche in Europe is more attractive than the US and vice versa.

And the ability for us to be able to move between
the markets, I think is a really wonderful thing.

Great.

So that's a good segue to the next question, which is
just what's the opportunities that look like now in CLOs?

Like how attractive are they relatively?

And does that look different for US versus European investors in those markets?

CLOs offer like a little bit of everything for everybody.

If you want low duration and safe carry, you can invest in AAAs.

If you want kind of more spread and more risk,
you can go all the way down the cap stack.

If you want shorter tenors, there's a very active refi market as well in CLOs.

And obviously then now you also have the
diversity in geography from US versus Europe.

We are at the moment finding on the US side, the shorter
kind of spread duration very attractive right now.

So AAAs all the way down to single A's, I would say we're really
active on the shorter spread duration part of the market.

There is definitely a term curve in the US,
but it's fairly flat when you look at it.

And so we would rather get shorter spread duration at a
similar spread that you would get versus going kind of longer.

And then we've also seen the credit curve steepening recently with
volatility that they were seeing in both markets, US and Europe.

And so we're starting to also being very selective here.

Invest in the lower part of the capital stack in BBBs
and BBBs as that opportunity set has opened up for us.

Yeah, and just to add that where we're seeing
some opportunities in Europe in particular.

One thing to note is the investor base in Europe for CLO investment
grade mezzanine tranches tends to lack the insurance buyer.

There have been really stringent capital requirements for insurers in Europe.

So we tend to see less participation in the AA and BBB tranches in particular.

So I would say those tranches in Europe stand
out for us as relative value versus the US.

Whereas in the US, you see a strong insurance bid across
the investment grade portion of the capital structure.

We do think that could change, especially at the top of the capital

structure, because there are some new regulations coming in effect

for lowering the capital requirements for UK and European insurers.

That actually comes into effect in 2027.

So I think good news for us is we should see more insurers

coming into the market in Europe, which will just

add to the investor base and add to the liquidity.

That may tighten the triple A tranche, because we think that those insurers
are going to come in to the start at the top of the capital structure.

And then, as Pollock mentioned, the credit curve steepening.

So the relative value between the two is really important.

And this is just on a DM to DM basis, so spread to spread.

You actually also get a pickup when you hedge the currency back into dollars.

And that's something we also watch closely in our portfolios.

Yeah, and I think, you know, the ability for us to be nimble as

well, I think is really great, because we can move from primary

to secondary, we can move from US to Europe, we can do all of it.

I think it's really advantageous to our clients that we
can move fast in a market that's extremely liquid as well.

So we can pick up some really good investments by doing so.

Great.

So we've talked a lot about what makes CLOs attractive.

Let's look at the other side of the coin.

What are the risk factors that you look at when you're both
making CLO investments, and then you may be stepping back a bit.

What are the risk factors investors should look
out for when buying or choosing a CLO strategy?

We kind of look at CLOs in terms of like three different pillars.

There's structure, there's collateral, and then there's manager.

So structure is something that is very standard
within both of our processes in US and in Europe.

How much subordination do we have?

How thick is the tranche?

What are the OC tests?

What is the cushion?

And then most importantly, what is the documentation, right?

So when we're looking at a new issue deal, we're very active

in reading through the entire document and giving our

stipulations on any changes that we would like to make.

And if it's a secondary purchase, we'll review the document to
make sure that it aligns with what we're looking for within a CLO.

And so that's the structure portion.

The other is collateral.

And what's interesting about CLOs is because they're revolving, there's a
reinvestment period, the collateral pool is constantly changing, right?

So we're not particularly looking at a specific
loan or a point in time type of analysis.

We're looking more at trends and where the portfolio is kind of moving.

And so we look at concentrations, we look at the weaker credits.

The great thing about loans, as I mentioned
earlier, is that these loans are marked.

And so we can quickly see what loans are trading below

80, what loans are trading below 90, to give us a better

picture of default risk or potential default risk.

Weighted average spread of the loans, that's important
to us because that kind of is an indicator of risk.

How much risk is the manager taking in terms of the loans that they're buying?

And then also portfolio construction and positioning.

Are they taking larger position sizes or
is it more diverse across different loans?

How are they kind of constructing this
portfolio and how are they trading it, right?

Now we get the trading data every month based on their
reporting to see what's being bought and what's being sold.

So I think collateral is an interesting one.

And you really have to have the tools kind of in place to be able to analyze
collateral from not just a point in time perspective, but also over time.

And the last one to mention there is manager risk.

And this one, I think, is sometimes overlooked by some.

But we are very focused on manager selection criteria, both in U.S.

and Europe.

And we actually think it's really important to underwrite
the managers for each of their respective regions.

So there may be a big manager that's issuing in the U.S.

That has done really well.

Whereas we see performance drift in Europe and vice versa.

So it's really important to be able to monitor both of those over time.

So we're looking at, as Pollock mentioned, portfolio
construction, how they're handling the problem credits.

I think really important to see how a manager
trades and resolves issues over time.

And the last one, which I think is also
sometimes overlooked, is position sizing.

If you have a view on a name, we think that if you make a mistake,

if the portfolio has something like 20 to 50 basis points,

they can get around that, where we've seen some managers

try and put 1% to 2% of a problem position in a deal.

And that creates huge downstream issues, especially
when something like Europe is a bit more concentrated.

So we, as investors, prefer managers that are trying to build

diverse portfolios with managing position sizings, and they

haven't deviated from their process through the cycles.

So we all know there are a couple of very large CLO funds out
there that we compare to, and we compare pretty favorably to.

What do we do differently or what are we thinking about
that allows us to differentiate from those larger funds?

For our CLO strategies that focus more on the top of the

capital stack, we really focus on liquidity and short spread

duration, as well as that global relative value, right?

So for the liquidity, it's really we try to focus on tier 1 managers that

may price a couple of basis points tighter, but we're not going to reach

for spread by investing with kind of managers that price

wider than the market for whatever reason that may be.

We'd rather pay a little bit more in terms of basis points and get
that liquidity that's so important in CLOs, especially in CLO AAAs.

The second thing is our focus right now is on short spread duration.

We don't really feel that we're getting compensated for really going longer in
terms of spread duration right now, especially at the top of the capital stack.

There is a term curve, but it's pretty flat,
and so we'd rather stay on the shorter end.

Versus hardly getting compensated in terms of spread by
going out for the longer spread duration securities.

And that kind of really helps us in terms of liquidity
because there's a better bid for shorter duration.

But also in terms of price volatility, right, when you have lower spread
duration, your price is not going to move as much, which is really helpful.

And in terms of global relative value, we are constantly in touch with the U.S.

desk to talk about best trade ideas at the top of the capital structure.

Pollock mentioned the shorter spread duration AAAs in the U.S.

Those look better to the European equivalents,
which are trading much tighter than the U.S.

It's partly a technical phenomenon, but we think
that that AAA level, we lean more towards the U.S.

When we're moving on to the AA level, next
tranche down, we see more value in Europe.

So we've been using more of our firepower to allocate towards
European CLO AA's, which are pricing at the 200 margin.

Whereas you see in the U.S., that's pricing as tight as 150.

So we're constantly talking about these ideas, trading in and out,
not only on spread, but also on credit curve and then manager.

So it's really great to have a global desk
and be able to move in and out of names.

And the fact that European CLOs can be a part of
the vast majority of our portfolios within TCW.

Thank you both very much.

I think that's all the time we have today.

So, Alak and Maggie, thank you for joining me today.

As we've discussed, the growth of the CLO market has created

a broader opportunity set for investors, but it has also

made understanding what you own increasingly important.

Differences in structure, geography, manager selection can

all play a role in determining the risk factors, the risks

investors take, and the opportunities available to them.

As the asset class continues to evolve, taking a disciplined
approach to evaluating those differences will remain critical.

Thanks to everybody for joining us on TCW Investment Perspectives Podcast.

For more information on TCW strategies, please visit TCW.com.

Thanks for listening, and we'll pick up next time exploring
the trends and opportunities shaping global markets.

Thank you for joining us today on TCW Investment Insights.

For more insights from TCW, please visit TCW.com/insights.

This material is for general information purposes only and does not constitute
an offer to sell or a solicitation of an offer to buy any security.

TCW, its officers, directors, employees, or clients may have
positions in securities or investments mentioned in this publication.

Which positions may change at any time without notice?

While the information and statistical data contained herein are based on sources

believed to be reliable, we do not represent that it is accurate and should

not be relied on as such, or be the basis for an investment decision.

The information contained herein may include preliminary
information and/or "forward-looking statements".

Due to numerous factors, actual events may
differ substantially from those presented.

TCW assumes no duty to update any forward-looking
statements or opinions in this document.

Any opinions expressed herein are current only as of
the time made and are subject to change without notice.

Past performance is no guarantee of future results.