The Forward Thinking Dental Podcast
SEO METADATA
SEO TITLE:
Trayless Whitening Part 1: How It Works and the Protocol | PDP277
META DESCRIPTION:
Dr Wyman Chan and Dr Elvis Law explain trayless teeth whitening: why skip the tray, who it suits, and the exact protocol for an A3.5 patient.
URL SLUG:
trayless-teeth-whitening-protocol-part-1
PRIMARY TOPIC:
Trayless teeth whitening
SECONDARY SEARCH TOPICS:
- Trayless vs tray-based home whitening
- Conscious bleaching and whitening sensitivity
- Whitening strips and acidic gels
- 6% vs 10% hydrogen peroxide whitening gel
- Tray hygiene and whitening results
- Whitening review appointments and refinement
- Letting the patient choose their whitening shade
- Pricing teeth whitening by shade and time
TRAYLESS WHITENING PART 1: HOW IT WORKS, WHO IT SUITS AND THE PROTOCOL
THE PROTRUSIVE DENTAL PODCAST, EPISODE PDP277
HOST: DR JAZ GULATI
GUESTS: DR WYMAN CHAN AND DR ELVIS LAW
EPISODE SUMMARY
In part one of this two-part series, recorded live at Dr Wyman Chan's whitening practice near Shaftesbury Avenue in central London, Dr Jaz Gulati talks to Wyman, who has worked exclusively in teeth whitening since 2002 and did his PhD in it, and to his protege Dr Elvis Law. Their topic is trayless whitening, where the patient paints the gel onto their teeth with a retractor in place, instead of wearing a tray.
Wyman explains why he moved away from trays, despite owning a lab and holding patents on tray-making: no lab fees or tray errors, patients can start the same day, discoloured trays use up the gel, and painting the gel on means less sensitivity and no gum burns. They discuss whitening strips and acidic versus alkaline gels, who is better suited to trays, and how the 6% and 10% gels differ. Elvis then walks through a standard A3.5 case: twice-daily half-hour applications, reviews at one to two weeks, reclining at 45 degrees, and reaching B1 in three weeks. Jaz's Protrusive Dental Pearl is to let the patient choose their target shade, and price whitening by it.
IN SHORT
This episode explains what trayless whitening is, why Dr Wyman Chan and Dr Elvis Law now use it for most whitening patients, and the protocol for a standard case. Key ideas are conscious bleaching, keeping trays clean if you do use them, reviewing patients every one to two weeks, and letting the patient pick their target shade, which then sets the time and price.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
- Trayless whitening means the patient paints the gel on with a retractor in, typically half an hour twice a day, at least two hours apart.
- It avoids lab fees, impression and tray errors, and the wait for trays, so patients can start straight away.
- Discoloured trays use up the gel cleaning the tray instead of whitening the teeth, so tray hygiene matters if you use trays.
- Wyman prefers conscious bleaching, done while the patient is awake, and says painting the gel on slows diffusion towards the pulp.
- Trays may suit patients who need to talk during treatment, or who are worried about the retractor and wrinkles.
- Elvis says almost 90% of his whitening cases have been trayless since 2024.
- Review at one to two weeks to check technique, and have patients recline at 45 degrees so saliva doesn't stop the lower teeth whitening.
- Let the patient choose their target shade from the whole shade guide, and price by the time, gel and reviews needed.
QUESTIONS ANSWERED IN THIS EPISODE
1. What is trayless teeth whitening?
2. Why use trayless whitening instead of trays?
3. Does trayless whitening cause less sensitivity?
4. Who is not suited to trayless whitening?
5. Why does tray hygiene affect whitening results?
6. What is the trayless whitening protocol for an A3.5 patient?
7. Why should patients recline when whitening?
8. Should the patient choose their own whitening shade?
IN THIS EPISODE
1. Introduction: why skip the whitening tray?
2. Protrusive Dental Pearl: let the patient choose their shade, and price by it
3. Meet Dr Wyman Chan and Dr Elvis Law
4. What is trayless whitening, and why did Wyman move away from trays?
5. Are whitening strips worth using? Acidic vs alkaline gels
6. Less sensitivity, conscious bleaching and no gum burns
7. Who isn't suited to trayless whitening?
8. Elvis's journey from trays to trayless
9. Scenario one: an A3.5 patient, and fitting trayless into their lifestyle
10. Trays vs trayless: pricing, tray hygiene, and why 90% of Elvis's cases are now trayless
11. Choosing the gel: 6% vs 10% hydrogen peroxide
12. The A3.5 protocol: porosity, reviews, reclining at 45 degrees, and the result
13. Maintenance, the five-year guarantee, and why some teeth are naturally yellower
14. Letting the patient pick the shade, pricing by time, and managing expectations
15. Coming up in part two
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION: WHY SKIP THE WHITENING TRAY?
JAZ:
Imagine getting amazing whitening results for your patients in tough cases, like tetracycline staining, non-vital bleaching, or white patches, perhaps from post-orthodontic demineralisation. These are some of the tough cases we do. But imagine you could get exceptional results without ever prescribing a whitening tray.
And I don't mean doing anything restorative. I still mean whitening with a bleaching gel, but at no point does the patient put a whitening tray, as we know it, into their mouth. And no, I'm not referring to whitening strips. I'm referring to a system where the patient applies the gel to their teeth.
They literally paint the gel on. You're probably thinking, "Why? Why bother?" We have a great, tried-and-tested system of teeth whitening that's been around for decades, and we can get great results with traditional whitening trays and something like hydrogen peroxide gel. So why skip the tray?
Don't we need the tray to create a reservoir, to create that seal? Well, the answer to that, my friends, is a big, fat no. You don't need a tray. In fact, it's often advantageous to whiten without one. You get less sensitivity, it's faster because you don't need to wait for a lab to make trays, and because of all that, it actually becomes more cost-effective.
These are just some of the benefits discussed by our guest, Dr Wyman Chan, and Dr Elvis Law, who's essentially his protege, who joined me for this very special episode. I recorded it in Wyman's central London practice, and all around me were photos of Dr Wyman Chan standing next to smiling celebrities, from Nicole Scherzinger to Dannii Minogue, and everyone in between.
Dr Wyman Chan is one of the most prominent figures in the world when it comes to teeth whitening. He got his PhD in it years ago, and then that's all he did. He exclusively did teeth whitening, for the highest-expectation patients. What he doesn't know about teeth whitening is not worth knowing.
This episode is fascinating in terms of how trayless bleaching can and should form most of the bleaching you do. But you'll also pick up all this wonderful science behind whitening and expectation management. In this part one, we talk about how on earth trayless whitening works, why it's superior, when not to use it, and your standard case, an A3.5 patient, and the exact protocol for trayless whitening.
In part two next week, we talk about how you can apply trayless whitening to tough cases like tetracycline staining, non-vital bleaching and white patches on teeth. We go deeper into those three scenarios next week. But for today, enjoy part one.
CHAPTER 2: PROTRUSIVE DENTAL PEARL: LET THE PATIENT CHOOSE THEIR SHADE, AND PRICE BY IT
JAZ:
Now, every PDP episode, I give you a Protrusive Dental Pearl, and this one is inspired by something said in this episode. When Dr Elvis Law explains his protocol, as taught to him by Dr Wyman Chan, the interesting thing is how they communicate how white a patient wants to go. Historically, I've asked patients, "How white do you want to go? Do you want to go Hollywood white, Simon Cowell white, something from Love Island, or something a bit more natural, but still white?"
I give them these descriptors, they get a laugh, then I take the shade photos and show them what B1 looks like. That's the way I was taught, and that's the way I've been doing it. But a small distinction Elvis taught me is that he shows all the shade tabs to the patient.
He says, "Well, this is where you're at. How white do you want to go?" And the patient chooses their desired shade. Let me say that again: the patient chooses their desired shade. There are the standard shades, with B1 the whitest, and then there are the Hollywood shades, like OM3, OM2 and OM1.
By doing this, you understand exactly what the patient's expectations are, and you can track them with photographs. More importantly, what they choose determines the price. So rather than having one standard fee for teeth whitening, it should be, and this is what Wyman teaches, priced appropriately.
The shade they choose governs how long it will take, how much gel they'll need, and how many reviews they'll need. And that, my friends, is how whitening should be fairly priced. If someone starts at C4 and wants to get to OM1, it is possible, but it'll take a lot more time, a lot more reviews, and changes of protocol midway through, and that needs to be priced in.
Only you can answer what that looks like in your practice. But maybe it's time to sit down as a team of dentists and therapists and decide how you're doing whitening. Do you have just two tiers, or should there be more, based on the starting shade, the desired shade, how many weeks it will take and how much gel the patient will need?
You're going to take away a lot about communication from this episode and the next. These are exactly the type of episodes our members love. When we make premium notes available to our premium members, we see a huge spike in downloads, and very often members send in photos of themselves annotating them and really cementing what they've learned from the podcast.
If you're not already on Protrusive Guidance, this episode might spark you to finally consider it. Our thousand-plus members around the world are going to love this. Please do download the premium notes below. And of course, we'll be feeding this into AskJaz, so in the future, when you have a case-specific question, it'll be able to draw on the wealth of knowledge shared in these two episodes.
Let's join the main episode, and I'll catch you in the outro.
CHAPTER 3: MEET DR WYMAN CHAN AND DR ELVIS LAW
JAZ:
Hello, everyone. I'm joined today by the Dr Wyman Chan, and I've got Dr Elvis Law as well. To give you some background for those listening, I'm near Shaftesbury Avenue in central London, with Wyman and Elvis next to me.
Behind them are these amazing photos of celebrities. I've got a great view of Nicole Scherzinger right behind me, and all these celebrities have had teeth whitening here. As you walk into the practice, you see "teeth whitening science, guaranteed results".
I'm so excited to be here for a rare live filming episode, so thanks so much for joining us. We're in for a treat, 'cause we're talking about trayless whitening. When Wyman first told me about trayless whitening, I was like, "Wait, what? Is this like strips? Do you mean whitening strips? What's the point? Why? When?" So I've got a gazillion questions to ask, and I'm so excited to do so.
But for those who have been living under a rock and haven't heard of Wyman Chan before, please take a moment to reintroduce yourself. I know you've been on the podcast before, but people may not have listened to that episode, which was brilliant, on all our community's questions on teeth whitening. So, Wyman, remind us who you are, what you stand for, and your interest in teeth whitening.
DR WYMAN CHAN:
Well, thank you, Jaz, for inviting me again for another podcast. I'm really humbled to be here and share my experiences with everyone. In fact, I'm just a simple dentist like you all. I have a special interest in teeth whitening, and I became a tooth whitener 24 years ago, in 2002.
JAZ:
Back when it was illegal.
DR WYMAN CHAN:
It was illegal, and very difficult. That's when I started my whitening centre, or what we call a dental bleaching centre. It was really difficult, because what we were doing was illegal, so we couldn't promote it the way I'd have liked to. But even though we didn't promote it a lot, we still got a lot of coverage.
So I'm just a simple tooth-whitening dentist. That's who I am, and that's my passion. I love teeth whitening. And from teeth whitening, I've developed lots of innovations, and hopefully we're going to talk about prevention later on. So that's it. I'm just a dentist like you guys.
JAZ:
And Elvis, tell us about yourself.
DR ELVIS LAW:
I'm actually a baby dentist. I don't know if I can still call myself that. I graduated from Barts in 2020, so I've only been working as a dentist for about six years. But I was very lucky to be hired by Dr Wyman Chan straight after FD, and working as a-
JAZ:
What a great mentor to have, right?
DR ELVIS LAW:
Yeah, to have a great mentor and work in a private practice straight away. So I'm just really lucky to have been hired by him, and I've been on this journey since I graduated.
JAZ:
What do you like to do? Are you also passionate about whitening, or are there other interests you've developed over the years?
DR ELVIS LAW:
I'm very interested in whitening because I have a great mentor here. I've also just finished an MSc in clinical implantology at the University of Central Lancashire. Well, I've just passed my exam for that.
JAZ:
Congrats. Great.
DR ELVIS LAW:
Thank you.
CHAPTER 4: WHAT IS TRAYLESS WHITENING, AND WHY DID WYMAN MOVE AWAY FROM TRAYS?
JAZ:
You're going to be sharing four scenarios with us that involve trayless whitening, either partly or exclusively. I pitched this topic to you guys in the Protrusive Guidance app, and you had the same questions I have. Trayless? Trays are so important. We were taught that trays are crucial, and getting the right tray design.
What really interested me was that you, Wyman, have a lab that makes trays, and these trays are held in very high regard. Very high-quality trays. So you need very well-sealed, high-quality trays, and good-quality gel, and teeth whitening, as we know, is extremely predictable. So this man who owns a lab that supplies teeth whitening trays to the world is now talking about trayless. That, to me, was very interesting. So what do you mean by trayless? Do you mean strips? Just tell me about trayless and its evolution as you understand it.
DR WYMAN CHAN:
Okay. Trayless. We dentists are so used to using trays for dental bleaching, and that's historical. We've been using trays for more than 50 years now, and I've been using trays since 1991.
Yes, trays are very good. I was taught how to do dental bleaching, mainly home whitening. I also own a lab, and I have four patents on making bleaching trays. Four patents. So how did I evolve to trayless? Because I have a whitening centre, using trays means I need to have a lab.
I need to take impressions, I need to pour the models, and I need someone to make the trays for me. That impedes a lot. When I decided not to do routine dentistry and just do teeth whitening, I was always looking at how to simplify the whole procedure. So I started looking at whether I could do bleaching without all that work, the whole process of making trays.
So I started looking into this trayless system. Strips are considered trays. You still use them like a tray. This is totally trayless. That means we use a retractor to hold back the lips and the tongue, so that we can expose the teeth we're going to bleach.
Also, I think it's important that we can close the deal straight away, rather than the patient having to wait two weeks for the trays to be ready. In those two weeks, they can change their mind. They may not want the bleaching anymore and ask for a refund. With this, we've found closing the deal is a lot easier, and patients changing their minds has gone down a lot.
JAZ:
Well, the reason patients have the consult, or have that discussion with you, is because they want it. And when anyone decides they want something, they want it now, right? I was already thinking, "Why trayless?" And Dr Raquel Valentim in the community mentioned strips, which we'll touch on in a moment.
But sometimes there are deadlines. You have a wedding coming up, or something else. So the option of trayless when there's time pressure makes a lot of sense to me.
DR WYMAN CHAN:
It does. The patient can start bleaching straight away, rather than waiting two weeks for the lab to make the trays. And making trays is not simple. You've got to get every step 100% correct. Your impression has to be very good, the model pouring has to be very good, and then you need a really expensive suck-down machine to make a set of very good bleaching trays. All of that costs money and time.
So imagine you make 20% mistakes at every one of those three steps. That's a lot of mistakes. We avoid those three steps by painting the gel onto the teeth. That means you get the active ingredient straight onto the yellow teeth that are going to be bleached.
Also, over the years, I discovered that when patients came back with their trays, they were so discoloured.
JAZ:
The trays themselves?
DR WYMAN CHAN:
The trays themselves were so discoloured, just like retainers. And I looked at them and said, "Why are they so discoloured?"
With the discoloured trays, we'd put the bleaching gel in, and after a few days, the trays were clean and really nice and bright again. So I realised we'd been cleaning the trays with the gel. Such a waste. So now we don't clean trays with the active ingredients anymore. We use the active ingredients 100% for bleaching.
JAZ:
This reminds me of chairside bleaching. I know chairside bleaching has declined a bit, and most centres now do home bleaching with trays. But when I did chairside bleaching, the patient would come in, you'd put the gingival mask on, and you'd put the gel on.
Now patients get to do this at home for themselves, really. So that's how dentists, and patients, can relate to this way of thinking. And you skip the lab fee, which I actually hadn't considered. So there's the time, the laboratory fee, and any mistakes in tray production.
CHAPTER 5: ARE WHITENING STRIPS WORTH USING? ACIDIC VS ALKALINE GELS
JAZ:
But can you give us a final sentiment on strips? Is there a place for whitening strips in high-quality bleaching?
DR WYMAN CHAN:
On strips, let's talk about the system we use. We use a double-barrel system. That means we use two components, and we only mix them at the point of use. With strips, you can't do that. Everything has already been-
JAZ:
Pre-mixed.
DR WYMAN CHAN:
Pre-mixed and put onto the strip. So the problem, I would say, is firstly how to stabilise the gel on the strip. All the manufacturers use strong acid to stabilise the gel. Using strong acid means you're making the preparation acidic. We don't want to put acid on our teeth for half an hour, an hour, or even, with some tray systems, overnight. You don't want to put acid on the teeth overnight.
DR ELVIS LAW:
You're basically etching it.
DR WYMAN CHAN:
Etching it. You're just removing enamel from the tooth surfaces. So I don't like the idea, but a lot of dentists still do it. They love doing it. So if they like those systems, maybe they should look for a less acidic preparation.
JAZ:
Your gels are alkaline, right? Is that fair to say? Or neutral?
DR WYMAN CHAN:
No, highly alkaline.
JAZ:
Alkaline. Okay. And the only reason that's possible is because it's double-barrel, and they mix at source.
DR WYMAN CHAN:
They mix at source. We make it that way.
JAZ:
So you don't need the acid to stabilise it?
DR WYMAN CHAN:
We still need acid to stabilise the bleach, which is hydrogen peroxide or carbamide peroxide based. We need to stabilise it so it doesn't degrade and you don't lose the efficacy of the bleach. But we have other components, which make it alkaline. So it's very stable.
JAZ:
And is this patented? Is it something only your gels do?
DR WYMAN CHAN:
Yeah, only our gel does it. It's patented. It's very special.
JAZ:
Okay. That's fascinating in terms of learning about the formulation of gels, and alkaline versus acidic. And you've said strips are acidic. Do you think you can get the kind of results we're proud of when we post on social media? My perception, and I might be wrong, is that you can't get a really compelling before and after with just strips. Is that fair to say?
DR WYMAN CHAN:
No. I think you can get very good results with strips as well. That's why I teach strips in the Far East, in China. I wish some of you would come to my classes. I teach dental bleaching very comprehensively.
So it depends. Everybody's different. Tooth structure is different, and the way bleaching affects the colour of the teeth is different as well. In fact, this was my PhD thesis, so it's a secret. I only share it in my classes.
JAZ:
Fine. But there is a place for strips?
DR WYMAN CHAN:
There's a place for strips. They do work well, but the downside is that they're acidic. Being acidic, they can damage your enamel.
CHAPTER 6: LESS SENSITIVITY, CONSCIOUS BLEACHING AND NO GUM BURNS
JAZ:
That makes sense in terms of the formulation of the gel. But let's talk about the indications for trayless. Interestingly, I remember recording with Dr Linda Greenwall about sensitivity and teeth whitening. For those of you watching, I'll put a link to that episode below, and for those listening, check the show notes. We always like to link back to older episodes.
The interesting thing she mentioned was a study where the variable changed was an element of tray design. If you used a rigid tray, it caused more sensitivity, even with no gel. Even without any peroxide, a rigid tray gave sensitivity.
So we know from studies like that that tray design itself can influence sensitivity. Was that one of your reasons for looking into trayless: that it could help deliver the whitening result with less sensitivity?
DR WYMAN CHAN:
That is one of the factors. In fact, I invented a trayless system 20 years ago, literally 20 years ago, when it was illegal. In those days I had a very big dream. We went to the Ideal Home Exhibition at Earl's Court and actually exhibited there for a month, and in those days we only used 6%.
I was there nearly every day. A week into the exhibition, I found a young lady looking for something, and finally she came to our stand and said, "Oh, I've been looking for your stand." I said, "Why are you looking for our stand? We've only been here a week."
She said, "A friend of mine bought a box last week," we had a box, "and a week later she told me her teeth were a lot whiter." A week. That's what got me going: "Why did we get such a good result in one week?" So I started experimenting with the trayless system.
Especially with my bleaching centre here, it saved me so much time, and lab fees as well. It's a no-brainer to use a trayless system. And on sensitivity, yes, trays do cause sensitivity, because they hold the gel in for a long, long time, and the gel has nowhere to go but all the way to the pulp.
If you paint it on, the diffusion is much slower, and the patient is in control. That's why I like to use the term "conscious bleaching". If you bleach your teeth at night, when it starts to hurt, you're already asleep, and the pain is so mild you won't feel it. But over three or four hours, by the time you wake up, it can be quite intense.
That's why I always prefer conscious bleaching: doing it when the patient is awake, conscious. You can do conscious bleaching with trays as well, but the diffusion will be a lot higher and it can get to the pulp more easily. If you paint it on, it only needs to get to the dentine. That's it.
JAZ:
Where the colour is.
DR WYMAN CHAN:
Where the colour is.
JAZ:
That makes a lot of sense. Guys, if this is the first time you're hearing about conscious bleaching, you must check out the previous episode we did with Wyman. The biggest takeaway you messaged me and commented on was the whole concept of conscious bleaching.
I love it. Since then, I've been using it with my patients. Family members would do whitening, and we'd say, "Okay, we're going to do conscious bleaching now." A lot of people have switched over to it. It just makes so much sense. And there's this whole concept that a tray is a closed system, so the gel has nowhere to go except closer to the pulp.
Whereas without a tray, some of it is lost to the air, and it perhaps goes in at a slower rate. In my mind, that makes a lot of sense, 'cause I read somewhere that the gel reaches the pulp within 15 minutes in a tray system, right? Is that accurate?
DR WYMAN CHAN:
Yes, accurate.
JAZ:
Okay. Let's round off the advantages, and why you might consider trayless whitening, before we start on the scenarios. You said speed. You eliminate a lab bill and any errors in tray production. Less sensitivity, 'cause you get to do it consciously, and also because it's not a closed system, so it's not a fast track to the pulp. Any other advantages of trayless? Then I'll ask you who isn't a candidate for it.
DR WYMAN CHAN:
Okay. I agree. All you said is valid. But another important factor is that it doesn't pass onto the gums. If you use the trayless system and accidentally paint it on the gums, it won't burn the gums. You don't feel any irritation or pain at all.
JAZ:
Why is that, sorry? Why would you not feel it if you paint it on the gum?
DR WYMAN CHAN:
Because we have saliva, and we have gingival crevicular fluid, which dilute it really fast. But in a closed system, the gel gets pushed deep into the soft tissues, and that causes inflammation, which can be very painful. So to avoid pain, the trayless system is an amazing system.
CHAPTER 7: WHO ISN'T SUITED TO TRAYLESS WHITENING?
JAZ:
So my question is, when would you want to use the usual way we all trained in, which is trays? When would you say, "Actually, you're not suitable for trayless. We should go for trays"? Are there any contraindications for trayless whitening?
DR WYMAN CHAN:
For trayless whitening, there are no contraindications, unless people don't like wearing the retractor. We have a lot of young ladies, or not so young ladies, who've had fillers. We say, "You wear the retractor. It's just a half-hour treatment twice a day," and they say, "Would that make my wrinkles more obvious?" That's what they worry about, the lines near the lips.
JAZ:
So it's wearing the retractor itself?
DR WYMAN CHAN:
Wearing the retractor, yeah. This is the most common question and concern from patients. We tell them there's no evidence it increases wrinkles around the mouth or face, and that after half an hour they disappear. A lot of them believe that and try it, but some non-believers, who've probably spent a lot of money on Botox and fillers, don't want to risk it. Those are the patients we prescribe trays to.
And trays are not suitable for bruxists, people who grind their teeth at night. Definitely not suitable-
JAZ:
Because the gel will leach out.
DR WYMAN CHAN:
It'll leach out a lot. And you can easily bite a hole in the tray, because most bleaching trays are soft. After a week or two, you've made a lot of holes in them. So those are the pros and cons as I see them.
JAZ:
I need to learn a bit more about the protocol and scenarios, so maybe I'll save this for the end. But in my mind, there's a certain type of patient, because you've already said twice a day, half an hour. When you have the retractor in and the gel painted on, you can't talk.
You have to not talk. With a whitening tray, you can at least have a conversation. Is that a potential advantage of trays, in terms of how it fits into your lifestyle?
DR WYMAN CHAN:
It is. It is. I always tell the patient we have two systems, and I give them the pros and cons of each. I say, "Can you find half an hour twice a day to sit down and relax? I think you deserve the time not to do anything. Just chill out for half an hour twice a day."
It's how you say it, and people love it. I say, "Just chill. If you're the boss and you do it in the office-"
JAZ:
They'll probably come back with better mental health.
DR WYMAN CHAN:
Yeah. And not only that, just get your staff to paint it on for you, and sit there and enjoy yourself. It's so easy. Just chill out for half an hour in the office, twice a day. Or you can do it at home and ask your children to paint it on for you. But if you can't find that half an hour, if you don't want to chill out-
JAZ:
That CEO type who's bang, bang, bang. You know what? Maybe just go for the trays.
DR WYMAN CHAN:
Trays, yes, yes. But a lot of people, especially women, love the trayless system. They see that it's like painting your fingernails-
JAZ:
I was just thinking that.
DR WYMAN CHAN:
Yes. So easy. I say it's just like doing your fingernails, and straight away-
JAZ:
And then you can't do anything for a little while.
DR WYMAN CHAN:
Straight away, they get it. And a lot of people really do want to chill out for an hour a day, because I think we're too busy. We're looking at our computers and our handphones all the time. I say, for that half an hour, just set an alarm, don't look at your handphone, close your eyes and enjoy yourself for half an hour.
JAZ:
Very good. I recently bought a vagus nerve stimulator. I put it on my neck, and it's supposed to stimulate the vagus nerve to help me go into a more parasympathetic state, 'cause, as you can see, I'm very sympathetic. So it helps me go into rest-and-digest mode. But I don't know if it's actually the pulses into the vagus nerve, or the fact that I have to literally sit there and do nothing for 10 minutes, that's improving my sleep score.
I don't know which, so that's to be confirmed. But okay, that really helps in understanding the pros and cons of trayless and who the ideal patient is.
CHAPTER 8: ELVIS'S JOURNEY FROM TRAYS TO TRAYLESS
JAZ:
Now is a great time to discuss scenarios with Elvis. Elvis, you've got four different scenarios where the whole case was managed trayless, or sometimes in combination with trays, and I'm interested to know who the ideal patient for a combination is. Guys, I've seen these scenarios, and they're fascinating and very real-world. We have someone with a single yellow central incisor. We have someone whose teeth are all A3.5. And we've got a few others with more advanced patches and whatnot. So we'll discuss all of these. Let's start with scenario one. What's scenario one, Elvis?
DR ELVIS LAW:
Sure. Scenario one is a patient who came in with all their teeth A3.5. You see that every day, in your patients and mine. They're happy with the shape and alignment of their teeth, and they just want them whiter. So in that case, as Dr Wyman Chan said, I offer them two options: trays or trayless.
JAZ:
Can I ask, Elvis, how long have you been using trayless? Is it new to you? Because obviously you've been mentored by Wyman, and you've done lots of good cases with trays. When you started, maybe you had the same thought as me: "Wait, trayless?"
DR ELVIS LAW:
Yes. I'm so glad you asked me this question, because when I started as a baby dentist, I started with trays as well. Wyman taught me trays first, back in 2021 or 2022. I saw all these pictures of his amazing cases, and as a baby dentist, I was like, "I could never do this. No way. He has 20 or 30 years of experience. He can probably do it. I have no chance."
So I started using trays on normal patients with normal A3 or A3.5 teeth. Sometimes I got them to B1 with trays, sometimes I didn't. And I realised I got better results when the patient's oral hygiene was better.
So I started cherry-picking patients with better oral hygiene for my whitening cases. And what I realised with my tray system is that when I got the trays back and saw them, like Dr Wyman said, the trays were manky. You can see it in your patients' aligners and retainers. They're manky.
And we realised that most of the gel was actually being used to clean the trays instead of whitening the teeth. That's why people with better oral hygiene got better results. Then he introduced me to the trayless system in 2024.
JAZ:
"You are now ready for trayless."
DR ELVIS LAW:
So, yeah, he introduced me to the trayless system in 2024, and I went to Shenzhen to do a course with him. That's the course in China he mentioned, where he does the teaching. After that, I became the only certified Dr Wyman Chan dentist in the UK. And I realised, oh my God, this is actually a revolution. It's a completely new system, where we actually paint the gel on.
JAZ:
Well, it's not new. He's been using this since 1991, right?
DR ELVIS LAW:
He didn't tell me until after that.
JAZ:
But that's amazing.
DR ELVIS LAW:
So now I understand how he gets all these results. In fact, if you look at the pictures, the celebrities are holding Get2Smile. They're holding the paint-on system.
JAZ:
Ah, yes. For those who are listening, I'm in a room, like I said, and I didn't even realise there were more photos of celebrities behind me in this direction. Fleur East...
DR WYMAN CHAN:
Yeah, Fleur East uses Get2Smile.
JAZ:
Who is Fleur East?
DR WYMAN CHAN:
A singer. One of our patients.
JAZ:
Okay, sweet. So they're using trayless. It's something you've been doing for a while. Fascinating. So you were very inspired and enthusiastic after going to China for that course?
DR ELVIS LAW:
Yes. After that, I realised what we'd been doing wrong. The secret sauce is that we need to paint the gel onto the teeth so it's not wasted. That's how it clicked. And on the course, he teaches you everything: how to talk to a patient, how to close the deal, how to introduce the gel, how to lay out the treatment options, and how to price it as well.
And I'm really bad at selling, but it helped me. It was amazing. It was really good learning.
JAZ:
I haven't been on your course in China. I'd love to visit China one day. I'm a big fan of finding a course in a country you've always wanted to visit and making the whole trip tax-deductible.
So if anyone out there wants to go on Dr Wyman Chan's course, I'll put a link below so they can have the awesome experience you've had, 'cause I've heard a few people talk about it now. So you came away from that invigorated, and then you started applying the trayless protocol to your patients.
CHAPTER 9: SCENARIO ONE: AN A3.5 PATIENT, AND FITTING TRAYLESS INTO THEIR LIFESTYLE
JAZ:
So in scenario one, the A3.5 patient, what was your rationale for going trayless? Did you say to the patient, "You can either go the tray method or trayless," and the patient picked? We're talking about scenarios, but we're also talking about real cases at the same time. So tell us about this kind of case.
DR ELVIS LAW:
This can be done with trays or trayless, as we said. In this scenario, we used the trayless system because the patient picked trayless. We asked the patient, "You can either do 30 minutes twice a day," and you only need two hours in between, which is one of the big things-
JAZ:
A minimum of two hours?
DR ELVIS LAW:
A minimum of two hours, yeah.
JAZ:
But you can do it six hours later, right?
DR ELVIS LAW:
Yes, in between. "Or you can wear the trays for two hours in the morning and two hours at night," again with a minimum of two hours in between. I asked her which one she'd rather do, and she wanted the shorter wear time.
JAZ:
I'm just trying to get the protocol right here. So trayless is half an hour twice a day?
DR ELVIS LAW:
Yes.
JAZ:
But the tray is two hours, twice a day?
DR ELVIS LAW:
Twice a day.
JAZ:
Understood.
DR ELVIS LAW:
One more benefit of trayless is that your wear time is actually less.
JAZ:
But we're still respecting conscious bleaching.
DR ELVIS LAW:
We're respecting conscious bleaching. So it's up to two hours with trays.
JAZ:
Two hours, yeah. And up to half an hour trayless.
DR ELVIS LAW:
Yeah. So she picked the shorter one. And what I usually tell my patients is that you don't actually need to do it in the morning and at night. You can do it as soon as you get back home.
JAZ:
6pm.
DR ELVIS LAW:
6pm, yeah. Then make your dinner and have your dinner, and before you sleep, do it one more time. That's good enough. I think that fits much better into everyone's schedule, and patients find it so much easier. And most of my patients wear a mask for their skin every night anyway, so they can just do it while they do that.
JAZ:
Is it a standard mask, like the masks we wear as dentists?
DR ELVIS LAW:
Yes. And they also put a mask over their face. A face mask.
JAZ:
But that's not something you supply the patient?
DR ELVIS LAW:
No, no.
JAZ:
Okay. In my mind, I was thinking you give the patient the whitening stuff, and also say, "Hey, have this facial mask as well." Okay, fine. So they do it while they're doing some other beauty treatment, 'cause it makes sense. You're doing this thing, and now you can't talk.
DR ELVIS LAW:
Yeah. It's like when you do your vagus nerve thing. You can do your whitening as well.
JAZ:
Exactly. It sends these little shocks, right? But yeah, you can whiten at the same time. So you're stacking beauty.
DR ELVIS LAW:
Exactly. You're stacking beauty.
JAZ:
Because it's like, "Now is my beauty time. I might as well get someone to paint my nails, put my mask on, and do my teeth whitening at the same time." But do they need to wear something over their face, like a mask, to contain the gel?
DR ELVIS LAW:
Yes. You can either wear a COVID mask, or we supply a cover for the retractor as well.
JAZ:
Okay. So the science behind that is that you need the mask or cover to stop the gel evaporating outwards. Can you explain that?
DR WYMAN CHAN:
Yeah, correct. It's mainly to maintain the mouth temperature. Otherwise it diffuses away.
JAZ:
So otherwise it's not at the optimum temperature to work. The warmer, the better.
DR WYMAN CHAN:
And it prevents diffusion.
JAZ:
Prevents diffusion. Understood. Makes sense.
CHAPTER 10: TRAYS VS TRAYLESS: PRICING, TRAY HYGIENE, AND WHY 90% OF ELVIS'S CASES ARE NOW TRAYLESS
JAZ:
So I now understand how it can fit into a patient's lifestyle. You've taught me it's twice a day, two hours apart, just half an hour. When you present this to the patient, there are lifestyle factors to consider, which makes sense. But do you pitch one as more effective than the other? And part two of that: are they priced differently?
DR ELVIS LAW:
They're priced the same.
JAZ:
Okay. Makes sense.
DR ELVIS LAW:
Even though there's a higher lab cost with the tray system. The main pitch is about their lifestyle. If they want to wear it during work, and they need to talk in their job, then the tray system will suit them, because you can keep wearing it while you talk.
JAZ:
While you talk. If they need to talk, yes.
DR ELVIS LAW:
And they can work with it. During the day, during their job. But if you'd like to do it all at home, and you'd like half an hour of rest and a shorter wear time, then go for trayless. Is that right?
DR WYMAN CHAN:
I agree with that, totally.
DR ELVIS LAW:
So it's up to the patient, to be very honest with you. Both of them work, but with the tray system, I now have to tell patients they need to keep their trays very, very clean. Otherwise it doesn't work.
JAZ:
I really appreciate that. I'm more than happy on this podcast to say, "You know what? I'm going to take this and change the way I do things," because I don't emphasise keeping the trays clean enough. It makes sense. If your trays get manky, the gel now has to whiten two things, the tray and the teeth, and it's using up the chemical goodness. So one takeaway for me is that, yes, I'm going to consider trayless, because it makes a lot of sense. But if the patient opts for trays, emphasise tray hygiene a bit more. That's a good takeaway, actually.
DR ELVIS LAW:
The science behind it is very simple. When hydrogen peroxide comes into contact with bacteria, it starts to break down. It kills the germs, breaks down and forms bubbles of oxygen. And if it's already forming oxygen, there won't be any free radicals left to attack the stains in your teeth.
JAZ:
What's the best way for patients to clean their trays? I know we're going a little left field here, but dentists would like to know they're giving patients the correct instructions. Should you use a brush? Should you use a retainer cleaning tablet? What's the best way to keep trays clean?
DR ELVIS LAW:
I think it's a combination of the two. I'd brush the inside of the trays really well with soap and a toothbrush, and also soak the trays in a denture-cleaning tablet when you're not using them.
JAZ:
Like Retainer Brite or a denture cleaner. Okay.
DR WYMAN CHAN:
I would advise them to use trayless.
JAZ:
Advise them to use trayless?
DR WYMAN CHAN:
If they can't keep the trays clean, use trayless.
JAZ:
Fine. If they've got a night guard that's manky, maybe say to that patient, "Look, I've seen your night guard. Maybe we should go trayless for you." Okay, fine.
Now, since you've been learning about trayless and offering it to your patients, what percentage end up going for each, whether based on your recommendation for oral hygiene and so on, or on what the market wants? We all know that if you work in one postcode or another, the patient demographic will dictate very different types of dentistry. But in your personal experience, what percentage of your cases end up trayless versus with trays?
DR ELVIS LAW:
I would say now, since 2024, almost 90% of my cases are trayless.
JAZ:
Cool.
DR ELVIS LAW:
There's still a place for trays, and I'll show you later. But I almost never use them unless I have to. So that's the takeaway.
CHAPTER 11: CHOOSING THE GEL: 6% VS 10% HYDROGEN PEROXIDE
JAZ:
Okay. So I thought maybe there was a special case where you'd have to use trayless, but you've just talked about a standard A3.5 case: the conversation with the patient, the positioning, the pricing being the same, and the protocol. So what can we expect in terms of the protocol, the kind of result, and how many weeks it takes? Talk us through this scenario. For the A3.5 patient, what's the protocol, how long does it take, and how often do you review them?
DR ELVIS LAW:
With this trayless system, our protocol is three to four weeks from A3 to B1. So this patient-
JAZ:
And again, that's three to four weeks of doing it twice a day for up to half an hour, all conscious bleaching, right? And can you use any gel? Can it be carbamide peroxide or hydrogen peroxide? Does it have to be Wyman's gel? Can I use other gels? How does it work?
DR ELVIS LAW:
To be honest with you, I haven't tried it with other gels. I've only used Wyman's gel, which is 6% hydrogen peroxide. I'm guessing that with other brands of gel, because they're acidic, they could burn the gums. But with Wyman's gel, you can paint it on near the gums and it won't burn. And I think that's the main-
JAZ:
Wyman, I'd love to hear it from you. I've got no vested interest in your products or anything, but thinking out loud, I don't know of any other whitening company that has a protocol for trayless.
Like, "Hey, guys, here's the protocol for trayless." You have a protocol for trayless. You've obviously thought about it and formulated the gel that way. I don't want to say danger, and I don't want to over-egg it, but there's a consideration about using any old gel, where the company has designed it from the very start to work with a tray, and all the results you see on their social media pages have been delivered with a tray. So there's no established protocol. That's one consideration I'll plant for you.
DR WYMAN CHAN:
It's a very, very good question. As I said, there are hundreds of products out there. We use 6% hydrogen peroxide within the EU, and especially in the UK, because of the law, the legislation.
But outside the EU and UK, we use 10% hydrogen peroxide, which is a stronger gel. I've been working on the formulation for a long, long time. That's why I did my PhD in teeth whitening, on the efficacy and safety of teeth whitening processes. Efficacy is what I started looking at. Yes, a lot of gels could be tried with a trayless system. I think other systems have it as well, like strips. We could call that a trayless system if you wanted to. They use it for half an hour twice a day as well, and they work.
So it's a different formulation. It's all down to formulation. It's all down to science. The science is to make the gel work faster, so it releases oxygen faster and releases the free radicals at a rapid rate. So for example, with the 10%, we only have to do it for 15 minutes, not half an hour. With the 6%, we need to do it longer in this country. In China, Hong Kong, Malaysia and the USA, it's only 15 minutes.
JAZ:
Twice a day, 15 minutes.
DR WYMAN CHAN:
So easy. If they haven't got time to do it twice a day, even once a day can give very good results. I mean, once every other day would give you results.
JAZ:
Now, someone out there might be thinking, why not use 16% carbamide peroxide? But the science is that it breaks down more slowly. The whole thing is the speed, and that's why you're going for trayless, right? You want the most effective and fastest system, and that's why it's hydrogen peroxide. Is there any other reason?
DR WYMAN CHAN:
No. It's safe as well, because the sensitivity is literally zero. You leave it on the teeth for 15 minutes, and it takes 15 minutes to get to the pulp, so it's not in there for longer than that. That's why it's so safe on the pulp. Very, very safe.
CHAPTER 12: THE A3.5 PROTOCOL: POROSITY, REVIEWS, RECLINING AT 45 DEGREES, AND THE RESULT
JAZ:
Okay, excellent. That was one little question I had. Let's continue with this scenario. You said three to four weeks, twice a day, half an hour, to get from A3.5 to B1.
DR ELVIS LAW:
Usually we guarantee A3 to B1. In this case, it was A3.5, which is another four shades darker.
JAZ:
A3 to A3.5 is four shades darker?
DR ELVIS LAW:
Yes.
DR WYMAN CHAN:
Yeah, nine to 12. Three shades.
DR ELVIS LAW:
Three shades up.
DR WYMAN CHAN:
It's the way it was arranged, not by me. It's the way the shade guide was arranged for dental bleaching when I was doing clinical studies, a long time ago, over 20 years ago. It's the way the experts arranged the shade guide.
JAZ:
'Cause a simple brain thinks, "Oh, it's only a 0.5 difference," but it's actually three shades. Interesting.
DR ELVIS LAW:
So, continuing with the scenario, there's also science behind why we say three to four weeks. Every patient has teeth of different porosity. Some patients have higher porosity, so the gel diffuses faster and you get better results sooner. So some patients need three gels, three weeks of treatment, and some need four weeks to get there.
JAZ:
Three to four weeks is a good range, where most patients will respond favourably.
DR ELVIS LAW:
Yes. And we do have a test, a way of taking pictures to check the porosity of the teeth, and that's taught on his course as well.
JAZ:
Very good. One piece of advice I was given is that if, when you're doing a composite, the mouth is open for a while and the teeth go really white from dehydration, that's one measure that this patient will get a good whitening result, because their teeth are more porous.
DR ELVIS LAW:
Exactly. You're on it. So in this scenario, our patient had quite porous teeth, so we got really quick results. After one week you could already see the teeth-
JAZ:
But you reviewed the patient after one week? And this is your normal protocol?
DR ELVIS LAW:
I usually do a review at one to two weeks, just to make sure the patient is doing it correctly and we're delivering results. If the results at one to two weeks aren't ideal, not what I'm expecting, then I'll tweak either the wear time or how the patient paints the gel on.
JAZ:
So a technique issue.
DR ELVIS LAW:
Yes.
JAZ:
I'm sure you'd agree, Wyman, that one potential flaw is the way we give the whitening system and say, "Okay, we'll see you in six weeks, or eight weeks," and then we see what comes back, right?
Whereas this way of doing it, yes, costs more because there's chair time, but that's why it's priced that way, right? Because you're taking control and reviewing. When I learned this years ago, I realised it's not a case of seeing them at the start and then at the end. You need to review them, tweak, ramp up, and all these kinds of things.
DR WYMAN CHAN:
Yes. That's why we call this scientific dental bleaching. We actually do it with science. That's how we record it, and, like Elvis said, Elvis knows what to expect. If it's not what he expected, then, just like with aligners, we do some refinement. That's what we do, refinement, every one to two weeks.
JAZ:
Yes. We wouldn't send a patient off and see them after 20 aligners. We see them after four or six. Are we tracking well? Is everything going okay? How's your technique? That's a good way to think about it. So in this scenario, the patient comes back a week later, you're seeing good progress, so the technique is good and you're happy. Is that what you experienced in this scenario?
DR ELVIS LAW:
Yes. It was good. The teeth had already got significantly whiter, which is what you expect to see. So I planned the second review-
JAZ:
Now, I've got to jump in and ask another question. When I do whitening currently, inspired a little by you as well, but from my prior knowledge, I do the upper teeth only to start with, not the lowers, because the lower teeth are a bit more sensitive, they're smaller, and also so the patient can see the difference. In your protocol, are you doing upper and lower together?
DR ELVIS LAW:
Upper and lower together. And in fact-
JAZ:
And that's the same whether it's trays or trayless?
DR ELVIS LAW:
Yes. Trays or trayless, it's the same. In fact, we have to ask the patient to recline at 45 degrees when they're doing it. The reason is that if you don't recline, you'll find you've only whitened the upper teeth, 'cause your-
JAZ:
Saliva.
DR ELVIS LAW:
Saliva pools on your lower teeth. Our saliva has peroxidase, which breaks down the gel in about 30 seconds, so you have nothing left on there. You actually see patients come back with only the top teeth white and the lower teeth not white at all. And then you know-
JAZ:
That's a good little tip. Guys, if they're doing daytime bleaching, for the lower incisors you've got to make sure they're at 45 degrees.
DR ELVIS LAW:
And then you'll know you have to tweak the technique. That's one of the common things we have to troubleshoot.
JAZ:
Okay, fine. So tell us about finishing off the protocol. At four weeks you're finished, and then what's the top-up protocol?
DR ELVIS LAW:
Because the patient had a good response rate, with nice porous teeth, we stopped at only three weeks, and she'd already reached B1. As I said, after the first week the patient was doing well, so I wasn't too worried, and I set the next recall for two weeks.
JAZ:
Two weeks later.
DR ELVIS LAW:
Two weeks later, so three weeks after starting. That's why it was three weeks in total. We took the pictures, and it's amazing. It's B1, and the patient is really happy.
JAZ:
Okay, perfect. And sensitivity-wise?
DR ELVIS LAW:
No sensitivity at all. The patient didn't complain of any sensitivity, and she just loves the product.
CHAPTER 13: MAINTENANCE, THE FIVE-YEAR GUARANTEE, AND WHY SOME TEETH ARE NATURALLY YELLOWER
JAZ:
Now, with a tray-based system, patients have their trays, and we say, "Okay, after some months you can top up for three days or so." What do you advise your trayless patients to do? Do they keep gel in the fridge and just top up? What kind of conversation do you have about maintenance?
DR ELVIS LAW:
With Wyman's system, we guarantee the patient that in five years they won't go back to their original shade, even if they don't use anything.
JAZ:
And that's a scientifically backed guarantee, isn't it?
DR ELVIS LAW:
Scientifically backed, yes. If patients want to keep their B1 result, what we usually advise is ordering one tube of gel, one week of treatment, every year. So a year after they've finished their treatment, they call us again, get a tube of gel, do it for one week, and they'll stay there.
JAZ:
And do you see the patient again, or do they call and, if they're on the other side of London, you post it to them? How does it work?
DR ELVIS LAW:
It depends. If the patient wants to see me, we can see them. If they're busy, they can just ask us. As long as they come for regular checkups, we're happy to send it.
JAZ:
Fine. Now, before we move on to the next scenario, this is just a common scenario, right? A3.5 teeth. I have two mini questions that I think will help everyone. You have that seven- or eight-year-old patient whose central incisors start coming through, and they're way yellower than the deciduous teeth. We know that's expected, right? The lower incisors and the upper centrals come through at that ugly duckling stage, and you start to see the yellowish teeth.
What I want to know is how much we know about the genetic element: some people's teeth just come through yellower and some whiter, and it's not so much down to what they eat and drink, or extrinsic staining. Can all these patients get the same B1 result? What do we know about individual and genetic variability?
DR WYMAN CHAN:
In terms of tooth colour, it's all genetic. Some people are born with white teeth, and some are born with yellow teeth. I did studies on this in my PhD thesis, so I have some idea, a hypothesis, but it's not proven yet.
I've seen over 20,000 cases myself, so I probably have a good idea why, but it's not proven. This is my hypothesis. A lot of it has to do with the translucency of the enamel that people are born with. If you go back to your anatomy days, the colour of the dentine is yellow.
When you do your preparation for fillings and drill into the dentine, you know it, because it's yellow. And enamel is usually white. When we look at a tooth, the colour we see is the colour of the dentine reflecting through translucent enamel.
So imagine the enamel is very translucent. You'll see more of the colour of the dentine. If your enamel is less translucent, you see less of the dentine's colour, and that group of people have whiter teeth. People with more translucent enamel have yellower teeth. That's my hypothesis.
JAZ:
But can that translucent cohort still reach the same result as their friends with naturally more opaque, less translucent teeth? Or do we need to modify our consent, and say, "Hey, you've got translucent teeth, so I need to set more realistic expectations"? Is that a conversation you have with your patients?
DR WYMAN CHAN:
That's another analysis we looked at in my PhD thesis as well. We looked at light, and I would say we look at the porosity as well. If the gel can diffuse through the enamel and get to the dentine, it really doesn't matter.
It will go white. The whole bleaching process is to bleach the dentine. Make the dentine white.
JAZ:
'Cause that's what gives the tooth its colour, the dentine.
DR WYMAN CHAN:
Exactly. Once you get the dentine white, it doesn't matter whether your teeth are more translucent or more opaque. They'll go white, and they'll stay white. It's the colour of the dentine that we need to deal with and whiten.
CHAPTER 14: LETTING THE PATIENT PICK THE SHADE, PRICING BY TIME, AND MANAGING EXPECTATIONS
JAZ:
Now, before we get a bit more advanced with the next three scenarios, I'm really enjoying talking about the most common scenario we see, the A3.5 shade. So let's wrap that up. My question is about something you mentioned before we hit record, which I found really fascinating: you said the patient picked their shade.
DR ELVIS LAW:
Yes.
JAZ:
The way I've done it, and the way I was taught, is that you show patients the shade they are, and then you show them what B1 would look like, with a shade tab next to the canine, as a reference for where we want to get them to. You're saying the patient picks B1, or A1, or a bleach shade. Tell us more about this interesting variation of the protocol, which, the more I think about it, makes a lot of sense.
DR ELVIS LAW:
Yes. When we start, we tell the patient, under colour-corrected light, what shade they are, and we give them the whole shade guide, arranged by value, and they can pick whatever shade they want to get to.
And I tell them how long it will take to get there and how much it will cost. Most people pick B1, just because it's the last shade before the bleach shades, which we call the Hollywood shades. OM3, OM2 and OM1 are the bleach shades, and we call them the Hollywood shades, or veneer shades. Most people pick B1 because it's the last shade before you get there. It's more natural.
JAZ:
So it's two-tier pricing, is it?
DR ELVIS LAW:
Yes.
JAZ:
But as you go from OM3 to OM2 to OM1, does the price increase as well? Or is the Hollywood range one fee and the more natural range another fee?
DR ELVIS LAW:
It depends on how long you need. It's priced by the amount of gel you need, and-
JAZ:
The time and reviews, yeah.
DR ELVIS LAW:
Yeah. You could say it's two-tier pricing. Actually, no, it's the same pricing, just longer.
JAZ:
Longer, yeah, because it reflects the time.
DR ELVIS LAW:
Yes, exactly.
JAZ:
So what do you think, Wyman, about the vast majority of practices that have one flat fee for whitening for everyone? Surely that's not scientific enough?
DR WYMAN CHAN:
They need to come to my course. Seriously. Teeth whitening changed my life. It's one of the dental procedures that's stress-free and really easy to do once you know how. Just like learning to ride a bicycle or learning to swim.
Once you've learned to swim or ride a bicycle, you always know how to do it. It's just learning how to do it in the first place. We haven't given people that opportunity here, because I used to train here over 10 years ago and haven't done training since. And at that time, I can blame myself, I didn't share very much, because I had a lot of plans. But now I want to share. So come to my course, and I'll tell you-
JAZ:
In China?
DR WYMAN CHAN:
In China. I'll tell you everything you want to know. You can ask me any questions you want.
JAZ:
Okay, fine.
DR ELVIS LAW:
Going back to picking the shades, I do that one more time at the review appointment. When patients come back for review, we check the shade again, give them the shade guide again, and see how much they've rebounded. If they haven't rebounded much, as we said, one tube of gel, used for another week, takes them back to B1. And sometimes patients actually ask for whiter shades. Then we can talk to the patient again about going-
JAZ:
To the next level.
DR ELVIS LAW:
Exactly, to the bleach shades.
JAZ:
Okay. So they know the option's there. They can always try this first, and then see if they want more.
DR ELVIS LAW:
And then go further, yeah.
JAZ:
One common thing I've seen in the community is expectation management: patients come back and they're not happy enough. "Yeah, they're whiter, but I was expecting more." What are the common causes of that?
DR ELVIS LAW:
Expectation management is something that's covered on his course too. It's very important, especially with whitening, and any aesthetic-
JAZ:
Anything cosmetic, yes.
DR ELVIS LAW:
Of course. With any cosmetic treatment, expectation management is key.
JAZ:
Have you heard that from a patient before? "Hey, they're white, but I was expecting more."
DR ELVIS LAW:
Not really, actually.
JAZ:
Okay. Because you've been taught by him and you've been doing his protocol.
DR ELVIS LAW:
Not really. Well, when I started with trays, yes, because the results were inconsistent. Sometimes we got really good results and sometimes we didn't. Again, that's related to tray hygiene, tray wear and the patient's compliance.
With the gel system, you can almost see whether the patient is using it or not. If they're not putting the gel on, you can tell, because it's not working. Unless they have really, really poor oral hygiene, where the gel gets used up on the plaque, in which case you'd really start by improving that anyway.
JAZ:
Okay. I wanted to explore pricing discussions and expectations, and how the patient picks the shade, and I think that's given a lot of our colleagues some inspiration to think about how they deliver whitening.
I feel a lot of colleagues aren't taking it seriously enough. They think of it as a simple item: "Okay, have the whitening, we'll make the tray." That's how the practice has always done it, and there's no thought, protocol or options given to patients for different ways of doing it.
So if anything, this should inspire people to have that conversation at work about how we're delivering whitening as a practice. We've talked about the trayless protocol and its pros and cons, and so many additional points, from reclining the patient to the dehydration tip, plus so many other whitening pearls: formulation, alkaline and acidic gels.
CHAPTER 15: COMING UP IN PART TWO
JAZ:
I know we've got a lot from this, but this is the end of part one. We're going to do part two and discuss three more scenarios. Elvis, can you tell us the other three scenarios we'll be discussing in part two?
DR ELVIS LAW:
We have a scenario with white spot lesions after ortho, a tetracycline case, and a tooth that went yellow after RCT, after trauma.
JAZ:
And these are all still trayless?
DR ELVIS LAW:
Trayless. And external whitening only.
JAZ:
Okay. This was one of the community's questions: can we use trayless for what we'd call internal bleaching? Obviously you're not doing internal bleaching, 'cause you're not drilling an access hole, right?
So we'll talk a lot about how this can be used for dark teeth and the single central incisor, the classic one. So do not miss part two next week. You're guaranteed to get additional whitening tips you can implement in your practice. Wyman, Elvis, thanks so much for part one. We'll see you shortly in part two.
DR ELVIS LAW:
Thank you.
DR WYMAN CHAN:
Thank you.
JAZ:
Well, there we have it. Thank you so much for listening to Dr Wyman Chan and Dr Elvis Law all the way to the end. For those of you who are listening, there was so much to take away, and don't forget to download the premium notes. They really help to cement your learning, and our members absolutely love them.
For those of you who are watching, you got to see the cases. I know we called them scenarios, but they were real cases that Elvis was showing as he described the protocol. It was really important to me, for our audio listeners, that we didn't get too descriptive, so it didn't feel like, "Ah, I need to watch this." You can gain so much just from listening while you're chopping onions, gardening or going for a jog.
I'm hoping this has whetted your appetite for part two next week. We go deep into three scenarios. Again, it'll be quite visual if you want to watch it, but for those of you who listen on Spotify or Apple, you'll be able to tune into the whole thing, and you'll learn the trayless protocol for tetracycline staining, white patchy teeth and non-vital bleaching.
It's quite mind-boggling. I'll put the links in the show notes for where you can get hold of Get2Smile, the gel Wyman invented as part of the trayless protocol. That'll be in the description below, or if you're struggling to find it, please message us on the Protrusive Guidance app.
It's the home of the nicest and geekiest dentists in the world. And speaking of which, don't forget to get your CPD by answering the quiz below. The quiz lives on Protrusive Guidance, so head over to protrusive.app and make your account. Thank you so much, guys, for joining us. I'll catch you same time, same place next week.
Do not miss this one. Part two will be absolutely brilliant for cementing this even further, and it shows you three more case scenarios, which are not easy, and how you can use trayless whitening to really enhance your whitening results.
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
QUESTION:
What is trayless teeth whitening?
ANSWER:
Trayless whitening is home whitening without a tray or strips. The patient wears a retractor to hold back the lips and tongue, paints the whitening gel directly onto the teeth, and leaves it on, typically for half an hour twice a day with at least two hours in between. A mask or retractor cover helps keep the mouth at a warm, steady temperature.
QUESTION:
Why use trayless whitening instead of trays?
ANSWER:
Wyman says trayless avoids impressions, models and tray-making, along with the lab fee and any errors in those steps. Patients can start straight away, which helps with deadlines like weddings and means fewer change their minds. He also found that discoloured trays use up the gel cleaning the tray, whereas painting it on puts all the active ingredient onto the teeth.
QUESTION:
Does trayless whitening cause less sensitivity?
ANSWER:
Wyman explains that a tray holds the gel in a closed system, so it has nowhere to go but towards the pulp. Painted-on gel diffuses more slowly, and the patient whitens while awake, which he calls conscious bleaching. He adds that gel painted onto the gums is quickly diluted by saliva and crevicular fluid, so it shouldn't burn them.
QUESTION:
Who is not suited to trayless whitening?
ANSWER:
Wyman says some patients, particularly those who've had fillers, worry that wearing a retractor will make wrinkles more obvious, and they may prefer trays. Trays also let patients talk while whitening, so they can suit people who want to whiten during the working day. Patients who can't find half an hour twice a day to sit quietly may also be better with trays.
QUESTION:
Why does tray hygiene affect whitening results?
ANSWER:
Elvis noticed his tray patients got better results when their oral hygiene was better. When hydrogen peroxide meets bacteria on a dirty tray, it breaks down into oxygen, leaving fewer free radicals to attack stains on the teeth. If patients use trays, he advises brushing the inside with soap and a toothbrush and soaking them in a cleaning tablet. Wyman's advice is to go trayless.
QUESTION:
What is the trayless whitening protocol for an A3.5 patient?
ANSWER:
Elvis's protocol is three to four weeks of trayless whitening, half an hour twice a day, at least two hours apart, upper and lower arches together. He reviews at one to two weeks to check technique and progress. In his case, the patient had porous teeth and reached B1 in three weeks with no sensitivity. For maintenance, he suggests a one-week top-up each year.
QUESTION:
Why should patients recline when whitening?
ANSWER:
Elvis asks patients to recline at about 45 degrees while the gel is on. If they sit upright, saliva pools around the lower teeth, and the peroxidase in saliva breaks the gel down very quickly. He says patients who don't recline can come back with whiter upper teeth but lower teeth that have barely changed, which is a common thing to troubleshoot at review.
QUESTION:
Should the patient choose their own whitening shade?
ANSWER:
Elvis shows patients their current shade under colour-corrected light, then hands them the whole shade guide, arranged by value, and lets them pick their target. Most choose B1, the last shade before the bleach or Hollywood shades. The chosen shade sets how long treatment takes, how much gel is needed and how many reviews, which is how he prices it.
ABOUT THE GUESTS
Dr Wyman Chan is a dentist who has focused exclusively on teeth whitening since 2002, when he opened his dental bleaching centre in central London. He did his PhD on the efficacy and safety of teeth whitening, holds four patents on making bleaching trays, and has treated over 20,000 whitening cases. He invented the trayless whitening system and the Get2Smile gel, and teaches comprehensive dental bleaching courses in China.
Dr Elvis Law graduated from Barts in 2020 and joined Dr Wyman Chan straight after foundation training. He trained with Wyman in Shenzhen and describes himself as the only certified Dr Wyman Chan dentist in the UK. He has recently completed an MSc in clinical implantology at the University of Central Lancashire, and almost 90% of his whitening cases are now trayless.