The Boardroom Path

What should you ask before joining a football club board when the owner funds the losses?

On The Boardroom Path, Ralph Grayson speaks with Adam Crockett, director of Game Plan Strategic Advisory and senior adviser at Alvarez & Marsal, about football governance and the role of independent directors. Adam helped develop the Football Governance Act and advised the Independent Football Regulator’s chair and chief executive. He explains how the licensing regime asks clubs to consider financial risks, governance and the plans they have for difficult scenarios.

The regulator’s draft State of the Game report found that 94% of clubs across the top five English leagues were loss-making before tax in its 2025/26 dataset, which combines actual and forecast information. Adam discusses why a board should look beyond league spending rules to liquidity, owner funding and longer-term sustainability. They also consider how to challenge an owner, assess the skills a club needs and consult supporters.

For prospective NEDs from outside football, Adam explains which governance skills transfer and why understanding the game’s economics is essential.

  • (00:00) - Welcome to The Boardroom Path
  • (02:54) - Why Football Governance Is Changing
  • (06:10) - Licensing and Financial Risk
  • (09:49) - The State of the Game
  • (13:50) - Skills Beyond Finance
  • (17:26) - Long-Term Planning and Sporting Results
  • (20:03) - Challenging the Owner
  • (23:39) - Testing Owners and Directors
  • (26:46) - Regulatory Scrutiny and Intervention
  • (29:23) - Due Diligence Before Joining a Board
  • (32:42) - Questions Behind Sporting Decisions
  • (35:03) - Fan Engagement and Club Heritage

Adam Crockett: Adam Crockett is director of Game Plan Strategic Advisory and a senior adviser at Alvarez & Marsal. At the Department for Culture, Media and Sport, he helped develop the Football Governance Act and its implementation. He subsequently advised the Independent Football Regulator’s chair and chief executive. His earlier work covered economic regulation, competition policy and enforcement, including at Ofgem. Adam also advises Football Beyond Borders and serves on its audit and risk committee.

Ralph Grayson: Ralph Grayson is a Partner in the Board Practice at Sainty Hird & Partners, bringing extensive experience in board-level recruitment, assessment, and advisory services. With a deep understanding of the corporate governance landscape, Ralph specialises in guiding senior executives as they transition into impactful boardroom careers. His thoughtful approach, combined with a passion for developing effective leaders, enables him to facilitate insightful conversations that equip aspiring and newly appointed Non-Executive Directors with the tools they need to succeed. Through The Boardroom Path, Ralph leverages his extensive professional network and expertise to empower listeners on their journey into the boardroom.

Episode Insights:
  • League spending compliance and a sustainable business plan answer different questions. Boards need to test both.
  • Liquidity, debt and reliance on owner funding deserve scrutiny before a club encounters financial distress.
  • Independent challenge works best when it is part of the board’s culture and connected to a shared strategy.
  • Directors do not need to select players, but they can question the financial consequences if a signing does not deliver the expected result.
  • Football experience is not a prerequisite for a board role, though understanding the economics and supporters is essential.

Action Points:
  1. Test the funding plan: Review cash forecasts and the club’s reliance on owner support. Ask what happens if that funding stops or is delayed. Discuss what steps the board could take before cash becomes critical.
  2. Stress-test the strategy: Ask management to model outcomes beyond the expected league finish. Consider the effect of relegation or a major decision that does not pay off. Agree how the club would respond and revisit the assumptions regularly.
  3. Check the scope for challenge: Before accepting a seat, discuss how the owner responds to inconvenient advice. Ask how directors obtain the information needed to scrutinise decisions. Look for evidence that the board can challenge as well as support the owner.
  4. Map board skills: Compare the club’s objectives and risks with the experience already around the table. Identify gaps in areas such as finance, governance or commercial development. Decide whether to recruit a director or obtain specialist external advice.
  5. Plan supporter engagement: Identify decisions on which the club needs to consult fans. Explain proposed changes and listen to the responses. Tell supporters how their feedback informed the decision and why the board reached its conclusion.

The Boardroom Path is the essential podcast for aspiring and newly appointed Non-Executive Directors (NEDs) navigating the journey from executive leadership to the boardroom. Hosted by Ralph Grayson, partner at Sainty Hird & Partners, each episode offers insightful conversations with industry leaders, seasoned board directors, and governance experts. Our guests share practical strategies, valuable perspectives, and actionable advice on how to effectively transition into board roles, maximise your impact, and build a rewarding NED career. 

Subscribe now, and take your first confident step along The Boardroom Path. Learn more about Sainty Hird & Partners at saintyhird.com.

The Boardroom Path is produced by Story Ninety-Four in Oxford, UK. 

Creators and Guests

Host
Ralph Grayson
Guest
Adam Crockett
Producer
Matt Eastland-Jones
Producer
Story Ninety-Four

What is The Boardroom Path?

Welcome to The Boardroom Path, the essential podcast for aspiring and newly appointed Non-Executive Directors navigating the journey from executive leadership to the boardroom. Hosted by Ralph Grayson, partner at Sainty Hird & Partners, each episode offers insightful conversations with industry leaders, seasoned board directors, and governance experts. Our guests share practical strategies, valuable perspectives, and actionable advice on how to effectively transition into board roles, maximise your impact, and build a rewarding NED career.

Adam Crockett: It's an industry where 94% of clubs last year made a loss. 29% of clubs couldn't survive more than 30 days if the owner pulled their funding. 60% of clubs in the EFL and the National League are technically insolvent. If you make an investment, your expected return in the last five years has been a loss of 41%. It's an industry on any reasonable metric that has financial challenges.

Ralph Grayson: Welcome to The Boardroom Path by Sainty Hird & Partners. I'm your host, Ralph Grayson, a partner in the board practice. In this series, we'll offer practical steps and useful perspectives for aspiring and newly appointed NEDs. This week we're continuing with our focus on opportunity for listeners to consider board roles in football clubs. So if you were invited to join the board of a football club, what would you want to know before saying yes? Who really makes the decisions and how secure is the funding? And would you be able to challenge the owner when the pressure to win becomes overwhelming?

These are all familiar boardroom questions, but in football they come with some unusual complications. Promotion and relegation, transfer windows, generations of supporter loyalty, and the possibility of the club's financial security rests on one person continuing to write the cheques. The independent football regulator's licensing regime brings those questions into much sharper focus. The question for today is what effective oversight looks like and who's equipped to provide it?

My guest is Adam Crockett, as a senior official at the Department for Culture, Media and Sport, Adam helped design the new football regulatory framework and led work on the Football Governance Act and its implementation. He subsequently advised the IFR's chair and the chief executive. Before football, Adam worked in economic regulation, competition policy and enforcement, including at Ofgem and on the government's response to digital market power.

He now leads Game Plan Strategic Advisory and is a senior advisor at Alvarez and Marsal. He also advises Football Beyond Borders and serves on its audit and risk committee and that gives him an unusually useful perspective on the gap between writing a regulatory framework and making it work in a boardroom. Through his Substack and recent podcast appearances, he's also been explaining what this change means for clubs and investors.

So Adam, welcome.

Adam Crockett: Thank you for having me.

Ralph Grayson: You're joining us in a personal capacity, I should start with, drawing on your experience of designing and implementing the IFR framework. So let's start by exploring what football boards will actually need to do differently and why people listening who've never worked in football might actually have something valuable to offer.

Adam Crockett: Yeah, so the place to start here, I think, is looking at what's happened to football finance over the last few decades, really, where we've seen instances of clubs getting into financial distress, and football has responded to that by bringing in its own sets of rules to try and address those issues and to a degree, some of that has worked, but equally, and there was a report out by the new independent regulator just last week, we've seen instances of clubs not performing very well, even within those frameworks.

So after the European Super League, the government kicked off an independent review to decide how could football's governance be reformed to be as effective as possible and that concluded that essentially the self-regulatory frameworks we see at the moment are an inefficient and imprecise way to try and tackle some of those problems. The problems you typically see are owners coming in, spending lots and lots of money getting the club into a distressed position, and then walking away and the club being in financial distress and what football's own regulatory rules are inadequate at dealing with is trying to manage some of that and then try to address it.

So the government introduced the legislation. What that's done is said, rather than trying to constrain how clubs spend money or trying to curb, making clubs profitable, as existing rules try to do, it set out a framework that you see in financial services. So looking at the business plan, trying to assess risk within that business plan, and where there are risks, trying to mitigate that. And I think you're going to see some big changes if you're on a board. The first place to start is rather than this being a black and white rules-based system and a clear compliance or non-compliance position, the IFR's regime is a more principles-based regime.

So the IFR will be taking a look in the round, is the club complying with the obligations that it has? It will assess the risk within the business plan, and it can then apply its judgement to assess whether intervention is needed. So there will be more uncertainty and it will be a different way of doing things.

Ralph Grayson: I think it's interesting that I know you're an ardent Everton fan, but you come at this not as a football supporter, but as somebody steeped in regulatory understanding and a regulatory background within government and you've just touched on there some of the analogies there are with the establishment of the FCA and comply or explain as we use in governance language.

So just maybe touch on a little bit how somebody who sits in a non-football board might recognise what this regulatory regime is going to look like. How much are they going to feel at home in football that this is a normal governance and board environment?

Adam Crockett: Yeah, so I think probably two main ways into that. So every club going forward in the top five tiers of men's English football will need a licence to operate and within that, there's the first, this financial regulation part of this. So an assessment of the business plan and an assessment of the risks, where the regulator perceives risks, it will put conditions on top of that.

So if you work in financial services, it is a prudential style of regulation, stress testing, looking at forecasts and trying to mitigate that and then the other aspect of it is non-financial resources. So does the business have systems, processes, does it have adequate corporate governance? And where clubs don't have those sorts of things, again, conditions can be put in place as part of the licensing process to make the club more financially sustainable.

So yeah, the model that's being applied here is every club will need to show how on an comply or explain basis it complies with the football governance statement. So how is it taking the corporate governance code the IFR will produce, assess what the club is doing against that, and then give a view on whether that's adequate or not. That's obviously quite typical of lots of more mature industries.

Ralph Grayson: How much of a mindset change do you think owners or the establishment in football at the moment, how much are they going to have to change their mindset to this new regime and for a non-footballing NED coming and joining a board, how much are they going to have to change their mindset to fit in with football?

Adam Crockett: Yeah, I think there will be a big change actually for a couple of reasons. The first is the move away from a rules-based system. So this more principles-based. It's a much more proactive regime than you might see in football at the moment. It tends to be what we would call in regulation ex post regulation, how it's done at the moment. This will be more about pre-empting problems and putting in place plans pre-emptively to solve that rather than waiting for a problem to happen, waiting for detailed enforcement to happen.

So it will be a big change, more onus on the board to take ownership of the decisions, not just to go for a tick-box exercise, but actually strategically own that, fit what is being asked of them to their business model and take some ownership of compliance is the vision for this.

Ralph Grayson: And I guess one of the big practical differences between a PLC board and a football board at the moment is probably the football club is owned by the executive chair, i.e., the chair is executive chair, not non-exec chair, and probably owns the majority of the shares in the company. So if a chair says, "Well, we already comply with the League's financial rules, so we should be fine," what have they misunderstood about what's coming down the road?

Adam Crockett: I mean, I would say that is a fundamental issue if that is the case. They are potentially two very separate things. So if you take football's current rules, squad cost ratio, so a football club has limits on what it can spend on players, whether it's the transfer fees that they pay and the wages they pay and the agents' fees they pay. That is entirely separate from essentially an assessment of, is this football club financially sustainable? Has it properly thought through a range of different scenarios? Has it stress tested them and does it have a plan to manage any risks within the business?

So just because you are, by the letter of the law, complying with squad cost ratio as you know, a Premier League club CFO or board would be assessing, you are doing something entirely different there where you're saying, "Are there more fundamental stresses within this business model? Have we properly thought through what we would do if there was a bad turn of events and do we have a plan to manage that?" And I think that would be a complete mindset change. I think one is looking reasonably reactively and one is taking a more holistic long-term view of the situation.

Ralph Grayson: And as you've already touched on, Adam, the State of the Game report describes a very successful industry with a, should we call it, a fragile financial foundation? So how do you think this chair or executive chair is going to have to change the way they think about the use of the board to address some of these issues?

Adam Crockett: Yeah, so I think it is just worth starting by touching on the State of the Game report and for those that haven't seen the headlines on this, it's an industry where 94% of clubs last year made a loss. 29% of clubs couldn't survive more than 30 days if the owner pulled their funding. 60% of clubs in the EFL and the National League are technically insolvent. If you make an investment, your expected return in the last five years has been a loss of 41%. Debt is very high, I think at five billion of a nine billion pound industry and interest and agent fees at the moment are over a billion pounds and the implied interest rate people are paying is 11%. So on any number of issues and in addition to that, a lot of things have been factor invoiced and so longevity is challenged. So it's an industry on any reasonable metric that has financial challenges.

I think an important part of this process then is to look at that context and look at those numbers, to look at their own business and look at how is that football club performing on those things. And the IFR has been reasonably clear there, the types of things that it's worried about. It's worried about liquidity, it's worried about debt, it's worried about solvency.

So I think the first place for any board to start here would be to take a step back, to properly scrutinise and put some internal challenge on how are we as a football club and a business performing on those areas? Do we have a plan if the situation deteriorates? Is this something where it's football and we'll just have to see it through and it's always been this way or do we have a plan to try and correct it? Those are the sorts of things I think the IFR is going to want to see. I think the IFR's also been reasonably clear that change is going to have to happen here and in fact, the legislation's clear, if it's not delivering its statutory objectives of making sure the industry's financially sustainable, it will have to take action.

So I think every club should be really scrutinising that report, scrutinising their own business, thinking about how do they respond to that and I think the clubs that do that and have a proactive plan, whether it's through their business model or through the other structural changes they can put in place, stands a good chance of navigating this process in a really good way.

Ralph Grayson: I just want to bring that to life a little bit. So it's the role of every board member to oversee strategy. To what extent do you think boards, existing football boards, lack the capacity to write a multi-year business plan, which is actually based on financial projections rather than unfounded hope?

Adam Crockett: I've heard some statistics before from one of the leagues. I think it was one of the lower leagues that the average predicted finish for clubs in that division was sixth. So everyone thinks they're going to get in the playoffs or get promoted, and clearly that can't be the case.

But there are some really serious people at every football club. There is nothing about writing a business plan that is beyond the industry. I think one of the things though that does come through is moving away from the view, I think, when you've got an independent statutory regulator, that this is just the way that football's always done it, because the IFR has come out with its report, said that the industry is at a financial precipice.

I think you can't just be of the mindset that this is the way that football works, because if you do, you can probably expect some intervention and potentially really significant intervention on how much liquidity you have to hold in the business, what your debt pile needs to look like. If you don't act on this and think and put yourself some challenge, you're probably going to fall foul of the regime.

Ralph Grayson: A lot of what we talked about so far has been financial stability and liquidity, but there's a heck of a lot more to running or being involved in the running of a modern sports team, whether that's football or anything else. I mean, we all talk about sport as an asset class now and that's as much about the off-field stability as the on-field success.

So the number of stadia that are doing other things beyond just hosting the match on the Saturday and you think about Spurs with a go-kart track at the bottom and a venture capital lab at the bottom. The number of stadia now I see with hotels on the side. So this is much about a real estate play as it may also be about digital media, entertainment.

So what do you think the skill gaps are more broadly beyond finance that somebody who's interested in joining a football board may bring particular expertise on?

Adam Crockett: Yeah, I think that is a very good, if challenging question. I think, you know, you look at the Premier League, I think half of the clubs have a big infrastructure project planned. My football club, Everton, I think it only probably avoided administration because it had a brand new stadium coming along and Spurs Stadium has been transformative.

So clearly the property play and the real estate play is important. I know as well, a big part of where growth is expected is the fact that these clubs have huge international fan bases, but they're basically only making a pound per fan over their global fan base. So people who can mine the data and reach those international fans are going to potentially see a lot of the upside.

I think the question a board should ask itself is, do we need all of those skills on the board or are there actually third parties that can give us the best advice on that? And maybe given the dynamic nature of the business, the way that the industry's evolving so quickly, a more external recruitment to some of those skills might be a better way to do this than just getting it simply through the board.

Ralph Grayson: So if I just back up on that a little bit, when we first met you made the point to me quite robustly that a football club doesn't behave like a conventional profit-maximising business. Through your eyes, how should a board define success? Because it's a combination of winning, financial resilience, we've touched on fan engagement. There's a lot of different ambitions pulling in different directions here.

Adam Crockett: Yeah, and I think, you know, you can see examples of football clubs that have been run super financially prudently and what that does to the relationship with fans and we do have to remember, we all love sport because we want to see a successful on-pitch product and we want success and glory for our clubs.

One thing I would say though is that generally, if you look at, say, football, a lot of the most well-run football clubs, Paul Barber and what he's done at Brighton or Matthew Benham and how he's used data at Brentford, those football clubs that are well run, you often then see a huge uptick in performance on the pitch. They're not necessarily always contradictory. I think that the mindset change here though is actually one of time. So rather than just thinking about short-run, short-term outcomes, which I think is where solely looking through a sporting lens will take you. I think part of the success of what, say, Brighton and Brentford have done is they've built to the success over a number of years and it took them time to build and I think football clubs that do think on a longer timeframe will probably see better results. And you can see examples to the contrary for that, people that chase success and clubs that have chased success have not always had the success that they've wanted because they've sacrificed long-term strategic decisions.

I think the only other thing I would say as well is I've read Moneyball, which is a fantastic book. One of the points that Billy Beane pointed out was at the end of the process, they had amazing success for a relatively low budget, but what they did was, they didn't win anything, but they got every last dollar out of that team that they could and they had a plan and they stuck to that plan. When they took a step back and why they didn't get all of the results that they wanted, it came down to the randomness and the luck that comes with professional sport. But what they could do and say with a genuine hand on heart was we stuck to the plan and we did as much as we could with the resources that we have and I think that sort of mentality is one that I think could traverse these potentially competing priorities.

Ralph Grayson: I think that mindset's quite interesting. When you were writing the report and helping with setting up the IFR, did you talk to the owners? Was it a two-way process or did you pull the FCA report off a shelf and say, "Well, we'll copy that?"

Adam Crockett: Yeah, I mean, when we did the original independent fan-led review, I think there were over a hundred hours of hearings. So everyone, whether it's an owner or a fan or executives got to make their representations and as we were developing the legislation, we saw owners throughout. You would, in fairness, get a different story from different owners at different levels where they were relative in their performance cycle, those sorts of things. But we absolutely consulted with everyone. There was never a consensus or a consistent view, and I think you probably can't just say owners were of one view here.

But there are some consistent messages coming out. I think certainly in the EFL, there's a widely held view now that the current business model is unsustainable and change is needed and I think there is potentially some consensus in that sense that more sanity might be needed in the industry.

Ralph Grayson: So without personalising it or mentioning examples, did you get the sense that the owners recognise they've got a governance problem?

Adam Crockett: Hand on heart, probably not. I think one thing that I would probably also take away that some owners are a lot more engaged in this than others. So obviously there's a lot of foreign owners in the game now. They're potentially based in the States or other parts of the world. So their ability to be across all of this all of the time is not easy, but there are other people who are very wealthy and would be involved with all of the minutiae of detail. I won't name the person, but a billionaire who knew the legislation back to front. So there are different stories about different owners.

Ralph Grayson: And to what extent do you think the owners need educating that board members are going to answer back and ask challenging questions of them and saying, "We can't afford to do that." Is that an issue? Are people realistic as to the whole point of an independent board is to challenge?

Adam Crockett: From the conversations I've had over the last five years, including the last few months, I think there still probably is a mentality and an education piece to go on across the board, frankly, that significant change is going to happen here. So there is now an independent regulator, each club's going to have a supervisor, and they are going to want to see that decision-making is being taken in a sensible way with the club's long-term interests in place.

I don't think everyone has potentially clocked that and clubs that can demonstrate there is the types of model you've set out there, Ralph, where there is proper independent challenge and scrutiny. And that doesn't mean that the owner can't still make the decisions that they want to, but that it's properly thought through. They are the types of things that the IFR is going to want to see that decisions are taken in a very considered way and I think a bit of an education piece there for everyone.

Ralph Grayson: So it leads into the obvious question before accepting a role, what would you want an owner to commit to when your advice, perhaps shall we say, is inconvenient?

Adam Crockett: I know this personally. So I spent 15 years in the civil service and telling secretaries of state they couldn't do what they wanted to do is a hard skill. I think that this is where the IFR will be helpful. So the first thing to say is, if I was building my perfect board, first of all, one of the things that needs to happen, I think, is a cultural change. One of challenge and one of support.

So you need to be all strategically aligned. What is your goal? What is your plan? Where are you trying to get to? Have a cultural piece about the ability to ask some of the challenging questions and say, someone who's prepared to say, "Have we thought about this?" And I think boards that have that are then likely to land well with the IFR. Boards that don't do that, where it is command and control and decision-making can quickly diverge from the business plan or areas where a statutory regulator like the IFR quickly gets nervous.

What I think though is also important is, you can have an owner that either says explicitly to a non-executive director that they won't pay much attention to what they've got to say or the actions that they take, that's effectively what happens. But this is where it would come back to the IFR and its role. So every club now has a supervisor. Clubs that do diverge from the plan and end up in sets of circumstances that are detrimental to the club's sustainability. The supervisor is going to be all over that sort of information. So really there is an inbuilt mechanism that effectively owners and boards are going to have to be open to more scrutiny. If you don't have that, you can probably expect more scrutiny from the IFR, which might mean things happen to you that you don't want to.

Ralph Grayson: And is the supervisor going to vet an incoming new board member or NED then? I mean, you, I was a bit facetious with you before we started the recording. I said, "Well, what stops an owner just appointing the vicar and then saying, well, now I've got a NED."

Adam Crockett: Well, there's a new regime set called the Owners, Directors, and Senior Executives regime. So any new owner or senior official within a club will need approval by the IFR and lots of clubs have already gone through that process so far. In fairness, there is nothing to say that a vicar couldn't be a person who's suitable to that, but there will be tests that apply to decide whether people can do that. So on the ownership side, there's a fit and proper persons test that most people would just be able to understand.

Ralph Grayson: We hope the vicar would pass the society test. But maybe not the financial ratios test.

Adam Crockett: Exactly and the other aspect of it, as you say, do you have the adequate finances and is that money from an illicit source they're checked?

But on the senior execs and the directors, there is an assessment, again, of fitness and propriety, but also suitability. Essentially, do you have the requisite skills to do this job and if you don't have that, then you wouldn't be approved by the IFR to do that.

Ralph Grayson: So in, I was going to say normal, that's a little unfair to the football world. In regular corporate governance we talk about the skills matrix on the board. Is that something when you were helping write the IFR report and setting it up, was there a formal approach to thinking what a skill assessment looks like on a football board?

And I guess my follow on question to that, because I haven't seen much evidence of it, but we do formal board evaluations here and we've done them with a number of regulatory bodies in and around football, which I probably better not name. But I don't see much evidence, if any, of the football clubs that we've talked to here doing any sort of formal skill assessment or board evaluation of what have we got when we put in our licensing application.

Adam Crockett: So the answer to that is no, we didn't, and I would come back to my first question, which was about how the regime works in practice. So this more principles-based system where it's not black and white has pros and cons. One of the cons is people aren't entirely certain about exactly what is required in all instances, but what it also allows is a club to look at its own circumstances, look at what the regulation sets out, and try to apply that to their own circumstances.

Why I think that's important, so we didn't want to dictate exactly what does the skillset need to be on the board. We've tried to delegate that to the IFR to help guide the industry and the industry to take ownership of some of that. But that's, I think, the types of skills and services that you guys offer, Ralph, are exactly, I think, what is needed here for a club to, if they don't have the skills in-house, to come and speak to people like you and take a bit of an assessment of what we're trying to achieve? What are our skills? What are our competitive advantages? What are our gaps? And then do that skills matrix exercise to try and identify gaps and fill that.

So I think the framework was deliberately non-prescriptive for a series of those types of examples to try to empower the industry and try to empower the regulator to try and get to a better solution rather than parliament trying to pre-emptively design something and almost certainly get it wrong.

Ralph Grayson: And if the clubs don't take this seriously, do you think the IFR and the people at the top of the IFR are going to show some teeth?

Adam Crockett: I think so. So David's a man I've known for probably 18 months now, David Kogan, the chair. He is a force of nature, but he also is a big football man, and he will want this industry to succeed. He just put out a report that basically said the industry's at the financial precipice. So I just don't see a world where both because of the statute he now has ownership of and him as a person is going to want to do anything other than try to get the industry into a good place.

So I think clubs that bury their heads in the sand and don't do anything can probably expect severe scrutiny, potentially conditions that in part govern how their business is going to be run and the other aspect of this is part of that is non-financial. So you might have controls, financial controls or risk controls, put on you as part of your licence application.

The other side of it as well is part of the regime and a lot of the focus is on the financial regulation of the business. So if you don't have good governance and you don't give the IFR confidence that you have good structures in place, I think you can probably expect more severe financial regulation intervention from the IFR in the short term and that's more tangible. There are a lot of people within the IFR who have come from the FCA. I think that they probably would think that significant financial intervention is needed if you don't take significant non-financial intervention proactively as a club.

Ralph Grayson: I love your view on this. So other podcasts are available. I'm an avid listener on my dog walks on a Saturday night of the Business of Sport. Charlie Stebbings on that last week who was a director of Oxford and was involved with Sunderland, if I remember, and knows more about football than I ever will. He was making the point that while the IFR doesn't have statutory teeth, that if they don't act when they see a problem and Kogan suddenly finds himself up in front of the Department for Culture, Media and Sport to say, "Why didn't you do something?" He'll just say, "'Cause you didn't give me the powers. Now I'd like some more powers, please." And he'll get them pretty quickly.

Adam Crockett: I probably think that's unrealistic actually. I think it was quite a bruising process to take the legislation through parliament. So I think, I'm not sure Andy Burnham with his grand list of things he wants to change, another go at football governance is something where he would want to go to. But Kogan's got a pretty big toolkit there to act already, so I'm not sure he definitely needs additional powers would be my own view of the matter.

Ralph Grayson: So what other due diligence do you think a prospective NED should be doing before he or she joins a football board?

Adam Crockett: My own view is I don't think you need to have a football background and be a huge football fan to be successful in this. And in fact, I personally found all the people who worked for me in the five years of working on this in government, the people who weren't football fans were often the most objective and strategic on thinking through some of this stuff.

So I don't think you necessarily have to have a big football background or even be a huge football fan. But I think you want to probably know you're going to be listened to. I think you want to know that there is a commitment to being challenged. I think they're two of the immediate things I would want to see and then I would also want to get a sense of what is the plan for the business, what's the vision for the business, how are they planning to get to their goals? And then really what is the role that they can bring? Given your skillset, what would you bring?

Ralph Grayson: And if you're not a football fan, what are you going to have to learn about football pretty quickly to be effective and add value on a board?

Adam Crockett: You don't have to have a football background and be a huge football fan, but you do have to understand the business and the economics of football and they are very different. As you said before, Ralph, I did economics at university. The first, very first, thing that we learned in any lecture was that all firms are profit-maximising. Well, that goes out the window and there would be riots before clubs started to try and make a profit.

They're not necessarily overly complex businesses. So I think spending the time though understanding where the money's coming in, where the money goes out, the structures, the governance, the relationships, I think if you can understand that, you'll get a good sense of the basics of the industry and then I think from there you can probably then start to identify potential risks that come in because there's probably only four or five revenue lines and four or five cost lines. So trying to understand that you get to a good place. And then you can start trying to think, "Where's this heading? How would I add some value?" Those sorts of things.

Ralph Grayson: So what do you think the balance is between the ability to read a spreadsheet and think about the numbers, but actually having the judgement and the intuition to stand up to the sporting director who says, "I want to buy a new centre forward."

Adam Crockett: There's a nuance to this in my view, which is you need people who can do both. For all NEDs, I think, it's not your job to go in and say, "I wouldn't sign that player." Because you almost certainly don't have the background unless you've actually come from working in football on the pitch to make those sorts of judgments.

But equally, there is, and I think the State of the Game report lays this bare, a short-termism to how certain decisions can get taken. Certainly in certain circumstances. Potentially when clubs are at risk of relegation in the January transfer window. So I think sometimes it's not necessarily though about having a huge knowledge of football or even being a spreadsheet geek to be able to make those judgments. Sometimes it's about just knowing the good strategic questions to ask.

What the IFR, for example, would be wanting to see is why have you made that decision? What happens if that doesn't come off? Do you have a plan if this doesn't come off? And they're just common sense basic questions you can ask. Now you can apply similar frameworks as a NED, I think. You can just ask some fairly rudimentary basic questions to try and understand the decision, how it fits within the strategic plan that you have in place, where this gets you. I think they're all sensible things a NED can do.

Ralph Grayson: And of course in the boardroom, what we talk about all the time is stakeholders as well as shareholders. And what we haven't touched on is the whole area of the fan base. To what extent is the fan integral within the IFR's raison d'être and North Star, and how should a prospective board member joining a football board think about fans and the duty to them as well as the duty to financial stability as well as the duty to the shareholders?

Adam Crockett: I mean they are incredibly important and I think as soon as a club or a board loses its fans, you're in real trouble and it's very, very difficult to turn that round and they are the lifeblood of the club. They are the people that spend their money, help the club through thick and thin. The legislation has specific requirements on clubs which give the fans more power. So each football club will need to consult as part of its licence with their fans on key strategic decisions. So that might be, and tickets are in fact named on the face of the legislation, but clubs are under pressure, they need to grow revenue, they might need to put up their ticket prices. What the legislation has said is you need to engage with your fans in a meaningful way on this.

So what that might mean in practice is you're thinking about putting prices up, you might have held them at the same level for 10 years, going out and consulting on what the change is, explaining the change, listening to the feedback, where you can act on that and where you don't make a decision to change your decision. Explain that and explain why you've reached that decision. So I think meaningful engagement is central to how this will work.

There are three limbs to getting a full licence. One of the three limbs is the fan engagement threshold condition. Do you engage with your fans meaningfully on key strategic decisions? And then fans will also have a say on if you're going to move ground, fans need to be consulted. If you're going to change the badge, if you're going to change the home shirt colour, or if you're going to change the name, you need to also engage with your fans. So what some of this does is the FA already has rules that do a light touch version of this. This is a sort of statutory backstop to make sure that happens and properly engaging with fans will be a licence requirement.

Ralph Grayson: So I don't know whether we've got our listeners to a point where they're either terrified or thinking, "I'd love to do this." But from your perspective and, there's been nobody closer to the heart of this than you, why do you think a board member, prospective board member, should think about joining a football club?

Adam Crockett: The first thing I would say is when I first got to work on football, I was absolutely delighted as a very big football fan, but that wears off quite quickly. this is the best area I've ever worked in and the reason that I say that is, it is like no other industry. In many instances, it's bonkers, but it's also incredibly fun. It makes a huge amount of difference. So you would be working on something that makes a huge difference to thousands or millions of people, is intrinsic to the local community, it has huge profile. They are brilliant things to get to work on, and you really would be making a difference to the community that you serve.

Part of the reason I loved it as well though, I'm sort of a semi-academic economic nerd. They are very challenging policy problems and as some of your questions have laid out, Ralph, they are often with lots of competing tensions in place and for people that like big challenges that matter to millions of people, and by the way, it's fun and it's interesting and you can speak to someone at a dinner party or in the pub about it and they'll get it, you honestly won't get a better opportunity than doing that. So I really would say it is one of the best gigs for your clients to get to work on.

Ralph Grayson: Adam, thank you. What I take from all of this is that a board needs the people, the information and the authority, to make difficult decisions before the pressure in football's going to overwhelm the clubs. So for anyone considering a role in football, the question, it seems to me, is whether their experience can help the club make better decisions and whether the club will let them use it.

If they're intrigued by this dichotomy, how do they follow up with you? Where do they read you on Substack on LinkedIn? And I know you've got your own consulting business now, so if an owner of a football club is thinking, "I hadn't given this the care and attention yet and no better person than the one who helped write the central premise," how do they get in contact with you?

Adam Crockett: So firstly, I'm on LinkedIn so people can find me there. I am at adamc@gameplan-sa.com if people want to email me and then I have a Substack where I've tried to talk about some of these issues in more detail, and I know, Ralph, as part of your doctorate you've been looking at some of that.

I've gone into some of these issues in more detail. So @adamcrockett1 on Substack and I explain a bit more of these things if people want to do a bit more due diligence and hear about the industry and what's coming a bit more.

Ralph Grayson: Adam, that's amazing. I think this story is going to run and I suspect this won't be the last podcast we have on this subject. So in the meantime, until the next time, thank you so much.

Adam Crockett: Thank you.

Ralph Grayson: I hope that you've enjoyed listening to this podcast and have found it helpful when thinking about how to approach your own path to the boardroom. If you would like to push this a little bit further, Sainty Hird runs a bespoke one-to-one programme designed specifically to this end. For more information, please visit our website saintyhird.com, follow us on LinkedIn, and subscribe to the Boardroom Path to receive new episodes. Thank you for listening.