Before there was anger at private equity groups, data centers, and landlords, most political angst was directed at the billboard industry. And then it suddenly eroded. In this Billboard Mastery podcast we’re going to explore how the billboard industry was able to get out of the political doghouse.
Welcome to the Billboard Mastery Podcast, where you will learn the correct way to identify, evaluate, negotiate, perform diligence on, select the construction type, build, rent the ad space and operate billboard signs. And now here is your host – the guy that built from scratch the largest privately-owned billboard company in Dallas/Ft. Worth – Frank Rolfe.
Billboards weren't worth anything until 1965, and that was when the first billboard hater, Lady Bird Johnson, LBJ, the president back then's wife, she decided to try and influence and manipulate Congress, and she championed this concept of restricting billboards into certain zonings, certain heights, certain spacings. And many people believe she did this selfishly because she didn't want any billboards in front of her bluebonnet filled frontage along the roads down there in Austin, Texas. But whatever her motive was, that bit of hatred, that spite that Lady Bird Johnson had back then, that's what created the entire billboard industry as we know it today. Because until Lady Bird did the Beautification Act, you could build a billboard anywhere, and as a result, the supply was infinite, and under the law of supply and demand, when the supply is infinite, the price can't go up. If you wanted a billboard back then, you didn't have to rent one, you could just go ahead and build one, stick it on a tree, whatever you wanted.
Then came Lady Bird Johnson, and that's when all the riches began for the industry. But how did the industry go from being filled with haters to where it is today? This is Frank Rolfe, the Billboard Mastery Podcast. We're trying to unlock how billboards got out of the PR doghouse, and how all of that constant hatred finally dissipated. So after Lady Bird Johnson did the Highway Beautification Act, and I'm sure it was much to her chagrin that she didn't get it right. In fact, if she had just left billboards alone, then it probably would've died out over time because there would be no modern billboard industry. There would be no billboard companies. There would be no one wanting to get involved in the industry, because if you build a billboard, someone would build it right next to you, you wouldn't be able to rent your space, and you would ultimately give up.
But nevertheless, Lady Bird put her mark on the industry, and the actual money was initially made. And after Lady Bird Johnson came the endless nemesis to the billboard industry known as the Sierra Club. Now, the Sierra Club was woke before the word woke was invented. They were into green energy. They were into basically anything that was anti-industrialization of America. And they viewed billboards as the ultimate evil. They said that billboards made all the roads look ugly, that they were just these hideous constructions, and that they needed to go, and they fought billboards at every turn. And that started all the way back with the Beautification Act, and it kept going full throttle.
And then ultimately, the Sierra Club changed. It morphed right around the year 2000. So for about 30 years, the Sierra Club tried to torment billboards and billboard owners in every way imaginable. They would even go to cities and try and force cities or coerce cities into making billboards suddenly no longer valid to build new units on, to try and throw people into moratorium. They were absolutely relentless. But then they ultimately gave up.
And the next thing you knew by the 2000s, the Sierra Club, instead of opposing billboards, were actually renting billboards and using them to promote their other causes, such as trying to eradicate coal as an energy source. So why did the Sierra Club ultimately give up? Well, I think they realized at some point they just weren't getting anywhere because billboards are protected and have always been protected by law.
They are, in fact, property. And under American property rights, as much as you might hate billboards, there's not much you can do about it. You can whine all you want, but billboard leases are typically in the decades in length. There are many billboards out there which are over 100 years old. And as much as the Sierra Club would run around and whine about it and complain and picket, there was nothing a city could do. The signs were already up, legal, non-conforming, grandfathered status, and unless a giant windstorm came and blew them down, there was really nothing that the activists could do to do anything about the billboard. And I think it took them years to realize the futility of their actions.
But after decades of wasting time and money, going around, trying every way they could to harass people, they ultimately realized it was not reducing the number of signs at all. The number of signs was, in fact, multiplying constantly despite their accusations that signs were ugly and needless and needed to go. Of course, another part of the problem was that the Sierra Club was always considered, even back in its heyday, kind of a crazy group. If you ever saw them in person or listened to them, and you can do so today on YouTube and other places, listen to some of their speeches, particularly some of the older stuff, that was not a crowd that was very well respected or adopted by most city zoning departments or city hall.
So they were coming off kind of a little overly aggressive, and they were definitely far, far ahead of their time. Are there any new groups out there besides the Sierra Club to attack billboards? Well, in modern times, there have been some groups who have voiced only a concern over digital LED signs, claiming that they're too disruptive, that they move, that they're too bright. But even then, most cities over time kind of got bored with that whole initiative. Many people find billboards today to be a positive part of the community, allowing local businesses to advertise, drivers to get important information to tell them where things are, and to understand what options they might have at the next exit.
So today, most of that wrath, most of that hatred against signs has pretty much diminished and is off the table. Now, does that mean that states and cities will suddenly relax their sign ordinances? No, I'm not saying that. I don't think in the years ahead we'll probably see a single city that alters their sign ordinance to allow new billboards to be built. And that's really great for the industry because it's the supply and demand that gives billboards all that value.
So I don't mind for a minute the fact that probably they are never going to open the doors and welcome new applications for permits. But at the same time, it's nice that we don't have this incessant background noise from the Sierra Club and other groups that all hate the industry and want to continuously trash it. In times like these, where America has become so politically unstable, it's definitely a good thing for the billboard industry that in our case, it has all calmed down. This is Frank Rolfe, the "Billboard Mastery" podcast. Hope you enjoyed this. Talk to you again soon.