The Forward Thinking Dental Podcast
SEO METADATA
SEO TITLE:
Antibiotic Prescribing in Dentistry and the Gut Microbiome, with Dr Jeremy Lenaerts | PDP254
META DESCRIPTION:
Dr Jeremy Lenaerts on when dentists should prescribe antibiotics, their effect on the gut microbiome, managing swellings, and patient pressure.
URL SLUG:
antibiotic-prescribing-in-dentistry-gut-microbiome
PRIMARY TOPIC:
Appropriate antibiotic prescribing in dentistry
SECONDARY SEARCH TOPICS:
- When are antibiotics indicated in dentistry?
- Antibiotics and the gut microbiome
- Antimicrobial resistance in dentistry
- Abscess vs cellulitis
- Extracting a tooth with an abscess
- Local anaesthesia in infected areas
- Talking to patients who want antibiotics
- SDCEP antibiotic guidance
ANTIBIOTIC PRESCRIBING IN DENTISTRY AND THE GUT MICROBIOME
THE PROTRUSIVE DENTAL PODCAST, EPISODE PDP254
HOST: DR JAZ GULATI
GUEST: DR JEREMY LENAERTS
EPISODE SUMMARY
On this episode of the Protrusive Dental Podcast, Dr Jaz Gulati talks to Protrusive Guidance member Dr Jeremy Lenaerts, a general dentist with a first degree in microbiology and a PhD in microbial ecology, about antibiotic prescribing in dentistry. They discuss how much of global antibiotic use comes from dentistry, why many of those prescriptions are considered inappropriate, and why antibiotics have no role in irreversible pulpitis.
Jeremy explains the true indications for antibiotics, the importance of local measures such as drainage and extraction, and how antibiotics affect the gut microbiome and resistance. They share how they handle patients who demand antibiotics, manage severe facial swellings, extract through an abscess, and give local anaesthetic in infected areas, as well as maximum anaesthetic doses and dry socket. Jaz's Protrusive Dental Pearl is a free antibiotics cheat sheet based on the main guidelines.
IN SHORT
Antibiotics are lifesaving but overused in dentistry. Dr Jeremy Lenaerts explains that they're mainly indicated for systemic or spreading infection, alongside local measures like drainage or extraction, and never for irreversible pulpitis. Overprescribing harms both the individual, through effects on the gut microbiome and resistance, and the wider community.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
- Jaz's pearl: download Protrusive's antibiotics cheat sheet at protrusive.co.uk/abx.
- Jeremy cites research suggesting about 10% of antibiotics are prescribed for dental conditions, with most deemed inappropriate.
- Antibiotics are mainly indicated for systemic or spreading infection, as an adjunct to local measures.
- Antibiotics are not indicated for irreversible pulpitis.
- Draining the pus, by incision, access or extraction, deals with the source of the infection.
- Jeremy explains that broad-spectrum antibiotics can disrupt the gut microbiome for months.
- An abscess is not a reason to delay extraction; local anaesthetic can be given around the site.
- Explaining the reasons clearly helps patients accept that antibiotics aren't always needed.
QUESTIONS ANSWERED IN THIS EPISODE
1. When are antibiotics indicated in dentistry?
2. Why is overprescribing antibiotics harmful?
3. How do antibiotics affect the gut microbiome?
4. What's the difference between an abscess and cellulitis?
5. Can you extract a tooth that has an abscess?
6. How do you give local anaesthetic near an abscess?
7. How do you talk to a patient who wants antibiotics?
8. Are antibiotics useful for dry socket?
IN THIS EPISODE
1. Introduction: antimicrobial resistance and the pressure to prescribe
2. Protrusive Dental Pearl: an antibiotics cheat sheet
3. Meet Dr Jeremy Lenaerts: from microbiologist to dentist
4. The scale of the problem: dentistry's share of antibiotics
5. True indications: local measures first
6. Why overprescribing harms patients
7. The gut microbiome, diet and health
8. How antibiotics damage the gut
9. Tough scenarios and patient expectations
10. Severe facial swellings, and how long to prescribe for
11. Extracting through an abscess: local anaesthesia and drainage
12. Lessons from complicated cases, and signs of systemic spread
13. Maximum local anaesthetic doses, dry socket, root-filled teeth, and outro
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION: ANTIMICROBIAL RESISTANCE AND THE PRESSURE TO PRESCRIBE
JAZ:
Antimicrobial resistance. We see it everywhere. Scarily, it's already been earmarked as the next possible pandemic. That's how significant antibiotic resistance is, and all the organisations say that, as healthcare professionals, we need to be very careful when we prescribe antibiotics and make sure there's a clear indication.
We already know that. But it's funny, because we live in a world where, in some countries, you can literally go to the pharmacy, put some cash on the table and get antibiotics. You don't actually need a prescription.
I'll tell you a little family secret. I have an auntie who, when she has a headache, will pop an azithromycin for it. Just the one azithromycin, the one time. This is absolutely nuts. So, as healthcare professionals, what can we do? How can we reduce antibiotic prescribing?
Well, I think first we need to truly understand the absolute indications, and when we should probably give it more time and just use analgesics, or other ways to manage the infection that don't involve antibiotics. This episode, with fellow Protruserati Dr Jeremy Lenaerts, is a nice overview of when to prescribe and when not to, the impact of antibiotics on your gut, and what we need to be mindful of as healthcare practitioners.
Look, our job is tough. Sometimes your patient is absolutely begging you for antibiotics, and I've been in heated exchanges with patients myself. You show them a radiograph: there's apical pathology. It's chronic; it's been there for years. The patient is in some mild discomfort, and as soon as you say, "Look, there's an infection there," they say, "Okay, Doc, give me the antibiotics."
Then you have to explain how this works and why antibiotics aren't actually indicated. And they think you're stupid, because you've just told them they have an infection: "Why aren't you giving me antibiotics?" That can get quite messy. So I hope you'll be able to relate to some of this and come out a bit clearer on antibiotic prescribing.
CHAPTER 2: PROTRUSIVE DENTAL PEARL: AN ANTIBIOTICS CHEAT SHEET
JAZ:
Every PDP episode, we give you a Protrusive Dental Pearl, and today's pearl is about making your life a little easier by giving you everything on a plate for when you need it. We usually look at the guidelines, SDCEP and a few others, for antimicrobial prescribing. What we've done is take the best guidelines out there
and combine them. It's like a cheat sheet of all the true indications for antibiotics, their interactions with other medicines, and your first-, second- and third-line options: the doses, the days, the whole shebang. If you're on Protrusive Guidance, just scroll down and you'll see it there.
We'll also put it in the Protrusive Vault. If you're not on Protrusive Guidance, please join us. But if you'd just like to download it, head over to protrusive.co.uk/abx. That's protrusive.co.uk/abx to download our antibiotics cheat sheet. Let's join the main interview, and I'll catch you in the outro.
CHAPTER 3: MEET DR JEREMY LENAERTS: FROM MICROBIOLOGIST TO DENTIST
JAZ:
Dr Jeremy Lenaerts, it's so nice to have you on the Protrusive podcast. You're a member of the Protrusive community, and it was nice that we talked more about overall holistic care and some of the reading you've done on this topic. I'm grateful to have, not necessarily an expert in this field, but a day-in, day-out, wet-fingered dentist talking about antibiotics in dentistry. I really appreciate it. How are you, my friend?
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
Very well, thank you. Excited to be here talking to you.
JAZ:
It's nice to see you. Any time I get someone from our community on, it makes me so happy, because I find the Protruserati are just really nice people to engage with. It's been really nice speaking to you on Protrusive Guidance as well, and to finally have you here to discuss antibiotics, their effects on the gut and so on. But first, tell us more about you as a dentist: your journey and your interests.
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
Well, I had quite a long journey into dentistry. I did microbiology at Cardiff University, starting in 1997. That was my first degree. Then I came down to Exeter University in Devon and did a PhD in microbial ecology, which was always very interesting, but not great for career prospects, really.
JAZ:
Well, at least you're a proper doctor.
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
A proper doctor, I suppose. After that, I did a short bit of research, stayed at Exeter, and then had a job with an instrumentation and reagent biotech company. My career really wasn't working out as I'd envisaged, so I thought, "What changes could I make?" One of the things I saw was Peninsula Dental School starting up. I was in the first year through, and the rest is history. I graduated in 2011 and I'm pleased with my career in dentistry.
JAZ:
How old were you when you qualified, if you don't mind me asking?
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
I think I was about 31.
JAZ:
Okay. It's impressive that you achieved so much. What made you pivot your career from what you were doing to dentistry?
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
Good question. I was so specialised before, which made me vulnerable career-wise. If something changes, like funding, you might have to change city, or even country, to get a job in your niche.
That's really why I moved into industry, the biotech industry. Then there was a lot of travelling, and my girlfriend at the time and I thought, "This isn't very good from a family point of view." So I thought, "What could I do that's needed everywhere, where I'd always have a job?" And then I saw the dental school opening in the area.
JAZ:
And you were in the first cohort. That's very good to hear. Looking back at your previous career, as if you've been reincarnated: is it what you hoped for? Do you have more of a family life, or the kind of balance you wanted?
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
Yes, definitely. I'm pleased with the choice. I love dentistry; I'm really interested in it. My clinical interests are a bit of aligner orthodontics and a bit of composite cosmetic work. Apart from that, I'm just trying to do a half-decent job as a dentist, really. There's a lot to be said for dentistry. You get paid well for something you love doing, don't you? It's a bit more stressful than I ever imagined, but-
JAZ:
It's very interesting. I remember Sam Cope, one of our previous guests, who was also a guest on Dental Leaders. He's a physio-turned-dentist, and he thought the physio training was more stressful than the dentistry training.
But now he obviously loves his dentistry more than he enjoyed his physiotherapy career, so that's great. How would you compare your dentistry training with your previous education, the PhD and your first degree in microbiology, in terms of stress?
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
I'd say dental training was a lot more intensive, and probably more stressful, than my previous education. With a PhD, there's no syllabus. You're just given a subject area to work on for three years.
JAZ:
With your PhD, I'm not surprised, but I'm wondering: were you ever attracted to specialising in oral microbiology? Did that ever cross your mind?
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
It did cross my mind. I thought it would probably be a logical way to go, but to be honest, I found it a bit boring.
JAZ:
Good answer.
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
Again, one of the reasons I left was to become a bit less specialised, and I suppose you don't want to re-specialise too much, really.
CHAPTER 4: THE SCALE OF THE PROBLEM: DENTISTRY'S SHARE OF ANTIBIOTICS
JAZ:
Well said. It was just something in the back of my mind that I wanted to ask, knowing I was speaking to you today. But the topic I want to discuss with you is antibiotic use in dentistry. Part of the message is that we already know antibiotics have no role in irreversible pulpitis.
And when we see patients with infections, I think it's well documented that we, as a profession, are perhaps still guilty of overprescribing antibiotics. Over the last decade, I've seen more and more coming out, especially on social media, about gut health and its importance.
That's another reason to be more considered in our decision-making when prescribing antibiotics. So should we start with the background to antibiotic use in dentistry, and its scale?
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
Antibiotics are a central part of our armamentarium. They're lifesaving drugs, among the most important discoveries of modern medicine; you can't get away from that. But, as we've got on the slides here, about 10% of antibiotics globally, and around that in the UK as well, are prescribed for dental conditions. So that's quite a chunk.
JAZ:
It's a whopping amount.
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
It is. And another piece of research found that 80% of these prescriptions are deemed inappropriate.
JAZ:
Wow. So 10% of antibiotics globally are for dentistry, and 80% of those are potentially inappropriate. So, really, dentistry should represent about 2% of antibiotics globally, not 10%.
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
Yes, assuming all the others are appropriate. It should be much less than that. And I think we all know it from our daily experience as well.
JAZ:
Yes, and let's have a real-world conversation. Sometimes a patient comes in, you've got 10 minutes, and they have a swelling. Yes, we should be extirpating, or accessing the canals to drain the pus.
Or we should lance it. But patients often come in demanding antibiotics, sometimes in very heated conversations. I've been in very awkward scenarios with patients, and I get really upset with myself if I start feeling flustered while talking to them.
I try to stay zen and calm. Literally two months ago, Jeremy, I had to explain to a patient why antibiotics were completely inappropriate for his pain. He had acute apical periodontitis. There was no lymph node involvement and no pyrexia. Have I prescribed antibiotics for that in the past, when I perhaps shouldn't have? Yes. But I'm wiser now, and in that scenario I didn't think it was appropriate.
Then you have that kind of conversation, it gets very heated, and they think you're fobbing them off. So I guess we should start with this, for our younger colleagues: what are the true indications for antibiotics in dentistry?
CHAPTER 5: TRUE INDICATIONS: LOCAL MEASURES FIRST
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
Appropriate prescribing is really when there are signs of systemic or spreading infection. There aren't many situations where they're truly indicated. And generally, they should be prescribed as an adjunct to other measures: opening up the tooth so it can drain, and local measures for the abscess.
JAZ:
For our younger colleagues, let's talk about extracting the tooth, or accessing it to drain the pus from the canals. Extraction is one option, but what about when the tooth is already root-filled? What about incising the abscess? Is that something you commonly do?
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
Yes, fairly commonly. A few times a year. A nice, sharp scalpel.
JAZ:
In that scenario, if they've got a swelling and you've incised it and the pus has come out, are antibiotics still indicated as an adjunct, or is getting rid of the pus enough?
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
You really want to stop the pressure building up, and I'd consider that to be enough for treating the acute condition.
JAZ:
Very true. And for younger colleagues, a key thing to understand about when antibiotics are really needed, which I tried to understand earlier in my career, is the difference between an abscess and cellulitis.
With cellulitis, there's a lot more widespread swelling and spread, with nothing really to incise, but an infection you can see. Am I right in saying that's a much stronger indication for antibiotics than a very localised abscess?
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
I'd say so. If the eye is closing, or they're having trouble swallowing, then antibiotics would be appropriate, I'd say.
JAZ:
It's tough, though, isn't it, for general dentists, whether in publicly funded systems like the NHS in the UK or other countries, or in countries where you can buy antibiotics very easily at the pharmacy? It's a worldwide issue, and it's very tough, because we know antibiotics can help in that scenario. What we'll address in the rest of this episode is this: we know overprescribing is bad, but can you summarise why incorrect prescribing, or overusing antibiotics instead of local measures, is bad?
CHAPTER 6: WHY OVERPRESCRIBING HARMS PATIENTS
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
It's not good for the individual, because of its effects on the gut microbiome, which we'll go through later. It also contributes to antimicrobial resistance, both on a global, community scale and on an individual scale. And then you've got the risks of adverse drug reactions, allergies and anaphylaxis.
What I say to my patients about antibiotics is, "This is a temporary fix at best." It may not make any difference at all, especially if the bacteria causing the infection are resistant to the antibiotic you're prescribing.
JAZ:
Do you audit antibiotics in your practice? I think we did; I'll pull up some data from our practice. But do you audit them, you and maybe the other practitioners, if you work with colleagues?
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
I probably prescribe antibiotics about once every couple of weeks on average. It's like buses, isn't it? Sometimes you go a month without prescribing anything, and sometimes it's twice in one day.
JAZ:
And there'll be colleagues listening right now, working on the front line, who don't go a single day without an antibiotic prescription, right?
It really depends on the demographic you work with, and whether you work in a pain clinic or emergency clinic or not. It will vary greatly. My antibiotic prescribing is right down, very, very low. And through experience, having this discussion, I'm feeling a bit more proud of myself now.
I'm a lot more sensible. I'm trying my best to avoid antibiotics, for all the reasons we'll go into. You've touched on resistance at an individual and global level, and adverse reactions. But tell us more. I think I need to learn more about the actual impact on gut health.
CHAPTER 7: THE GUT MICROBIOME, DIET AND HEALTH
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
We know there's a link between the gut microbiome and mental health. And with poor mental health, you get increased levels of systemic inflammation, which is pretty much bad for everything, but also bad for perio.
JAZ:
How could you measure this, Jeremy? If I want to find out how my gut health is... for example, I do blood tests every three or six months, depending on the metrics, so I know my vitamin D levels, my testosterone levels and all that kind of stuff. How do I get an objective measurement of my gut health?
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
There's probably no definitive measure of it. I don't think the science is there yet. Obviously there's the ZOE company. That's probably as good as you'll get, I would have thought.
JAZ:
Oh yes. When I asked you about your diet: what do you think is the best diet, personally? There are people who insist on the carnivore diet,
and people who say you've got to be keto, vegetarian or vegan. You see all that. I'll give you my take, because I'm a bit interested in this field. But what do you do, and what do you believe in?
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
I'd say less processed food is probably a good thing, with lots of fibre and fermented foods. Fibre-rich foods are known as prebiotics: they feed the good bacteria in your gut. That's as opposed to probiotics, which you hear a lot about in the marketing. I think there's very limited evidence at best for probiotics. I guess they sell pretty well on the marketing alone, so there's no reason to do big, expensive studies into them.
JAZ:
Very true. So, simply put, more kimchi.
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
Just a varied, healthy diet with plenty of fibre and fermented food.
JAZ:
I agree, and more and more so. I read an amazing book recommended by Dr Tom Levine, one of our community members on Protrusive. It was called Metabolical, by Robert... I'm trying to think of the author's name. Its theme is the same as the book Ultra-Processed People.
It's all about the damage processed food is doing. So yes, eliminate processed food as much as possible. I'm very mindful of that, though it's very difficult feeding my children, because processed foods are everywhere. So eliminate that, eat lots of fibre. And then, should you be vegan, keto,
carnivore? Where should you be? I think if you feel good in yourself, if you feel okay after a meal... For example, after I eat pizza, I don't feel great, and I know that's a sign. When I eat a poke bowl, I feel amazing. When I eat nuts, I feel amazing.
So listen to your body, and as long as you're pooing well... with those three metrics, I don't think it really matters which diet is best, because we don't know yet, and everyone will claim theirs is the best. Those are the parameters I follow.
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
That's good.
CHAPTER 8: HOW ANTIBIOTICS DAMAGE THE GUT
JAZ:
And on the topic of not feeling good: what happens when someone has an abscess, we give them antibiotics, they go home and take their amoxicillin? We might help them with their infection, but it might have just cleared up after two days anyway.
So we don't know how effective that antibiotic actually was. But what damage have we done to the gut microbiome, and why? You've already said how important it is for our general health, but drive home the message about the consequences of antibiotics for our gut microbiome.
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
Well, we've established that the gut microbiome is pretty important, and antibiotics by nature kill bacteria. So it was logical to make the link between antibiotics damaging the gut microbiome, and broad-spectrum antibiotics such as amoxicillin, which is probably our mainstay for prescriptions, isn't it, probably causing more damage than narrow-spectrum antibiotics. The gut microbiome usually recovers in about one to two months, but it varies between individuals, it can take a lot longer, and the changes could be permanent.
JAZ:
What does that mean for the individual, though? From what we know from the research, yes, all the bugs change. You're getting rid of some good bugs and some bad bugs; you're clearing the dance floor, I guess. But what potential negative consequences could come from this, as far as we know?
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
Let's pick a common one: antibiotic-associated diarrhoea. C. difficile is the abbreviated name, and it's a bacterium that's commonly resistant to antibiotics. When people take antibiotics, roughly 5 to 25% come down with diarrhoea, due to overgrowth of Clostridium, or Clostridioides, difficile.
That's probably a really common example of the effects of antibiotics on the gut. Then there's antibiotic resistance at the individual level. It's survival of the fittest for the bacteria in the gut. You're wiping out virtually all the microbes that aren't resistant to the antibiotic,
so you're developing a community of resistant bacteria in your body. Also, under stress, bacteria are more likely to share genes with each other, so you're more likely to get transfer of resistance genes from one bacterium to another, again changing the community of the gut microbiome and increasing resistance levels.
How could this affect you? Well, at some stage in life you're quite likely to become immunocompromised. I've taken cancer as an example here. You're immunocompromised during cancer treatment, you'll probably get infections, and you'll be prescribed antibiotics for them. If you're harbouring a lot of antimicrobial-resistant bacteria, that's not going to turn out well.
JAZ:
And going back to what you said earlier: if antibiotics clear the dance floor and get rid of the bugs, all the benefits are downregulated, and all the bad things, like increased inflammation, perhaps go up.
We lose the ways the bugs help us. We don't know exactly how impactful that is long term for someone taking antibiotics, from the evidence we have. But I think we can agree antibiotics aren't great for this. With the inflammation and mental health links, and the importance of the gut microbiome, to the best of our knowledge, that's what we lose from antibiotics: we lose out on the benefits and get more of the bad stuff.
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
Yes. So I guess we get short-term gain from antibiotics for long-term pain. Undoubtedly, antibiotics need to be prescribed at some point; that's important. But we need to be very mindful that we might be doing a considerable amount of unknown damage to our patients.
CHAPTER 9: TOUGH SCENARIOS AND PATIENT EXPECTATIONS
JAZ:
Let's finish on a clinical point. An acute apical periodontitis patient comes in. The lower left molar is tender to percussion and has been giving them a lot of pain for the last few days. It's negative to Endo-Frost, so we know it's probably beyond pulpitis; we're dealing with a necrotic pulp. But there's no lymphadenopathy and no pyrexia. And to make it more complicated, the tooth is already root-filled. It's so tempting.
Hand on heart, I'd say most colleagues would probably give in to the temptation: "Okay, you know what? Antibiotics." And when we see these patients again, they'll say, "Oh yeah, I'm better now." But we don't know whether it was the antibiotics, or whether the inflammation just settled,
because the body took over. We don't know. The point I'm trying to make is that the best thing to do then is either get in, remove the GP and dress it as best you can, which is laborious, and not everyone has the skills, and it might cause a perforation or whatever, or extract the tooth. So we're in a very stuck scenario. Any advice for those very tough scenarios?
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
I'd say the tooth is root-filled and has an abscess on it. Pretty much everything that can be done to the tooth has been done, so we've really got two options: take the tooth out, or refer for a retreatment.
It's not guaranteed to work, it's guaranteed to cost quite a lot of money, and I find most people probably just decide to have the tooth out, to be honest.
JAZ:
It's a tough one. But perhaps the role is to make sure they're on the right analgesics, double down on that, and then find space in the diary to deal with it properly, right?
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
Yes, and deal with it properly and quickly. There are some situations, third molars and things like that, or very anxious patients, where you haven't got a chance, in which case...
JAZ:
Jeremy, you're going to laugh at this, or maybe feel a bit sick hearing it, but there are people in my community, the South Asian community, the older generation, who aren't very highly educated. We literally migrated from Afghanistan; we came as refugees.
So the older generation, who aren't very educated, will literally take an azithromycin for a headache. That's the kind of thing we're dealing with. So educating the public is so, so, so important.
And I think it comes down to sympathising and empathising with your patients: "I understand you're in pain. But what you're asking for here isn't indicated. When it's truly indicated, great." Just calm them down; you have to put yourself in their shoes.
They haven't slept, and they're not in the best frame of mind. Document everything, explain why you believe what you believe, and try to hold back the antibiotics where possible. Sometimes the gun's to our head, and it's just tricky. But I think that if, as a profession, we reduce our antibiotic prescribing, we'll be doing a good thing for public health overall.
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
I think if you give most people all the information, they'll make the right decision themselves. And it's all about the consent process, isn't it?
JAZ:
The word "recommend" is perfect, because we're allowed to recommend: "I recommend we go for ibuprofen and paracetamol here." What I very often say to my patients is, "Look, if I give you antibiotics prematurely, when you don't really need them,
"they're less likely to work when you really do need them. Have you tried this? Have you tried that? Once we've tried the strong analgesic route, if you still need antibiotics and we see signs of the infection spreading, I'm still here for you." And a lot of the time, the vast majority end up not needing the antibiotics.
It can be tough, but when patients trust you, they get it, and I think that's an important thing. So, any last thoughts, with your microbiology and PhD background? Any last messages for our colleagues?
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
Regarding antibiotic prescribing, I'd like to mention SDCEP, the Scottish Dental Clinical Effectiveness Programme, because I always use that-
JAZ:
Scotland, the king of guidelines.
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
It really is good.
JAZ:
SDCEP. We'll put the link to that in the show notes, and I think everyone should have it to hand. I agree. And I appreciate your very honest admissions, as I've made too. Sometimes the clock is really against us. But the most important thing, my friends, is never to prescribe antibiotics for irreversible pulpitis. That's the worst, worst, worst indication, I think.
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
It is. And during COVID times, when we weren't seeing patients, that was awful. My key message is that antibiotics are a very useful treatment we have at our disposal, but we ought to think twice before prescribing them, and ask ourselves whether we're actually doing the patient harm. That's probably my key message.
CHAPTER 10: SEVERE FACIAL SWELLINGS, AND HOW LONG TO PRESCRIBE FOR
JAZ:
Jeremy, you used to work in an access centre, I think you said. Tell us about that.
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
Yes, I worked in the dental access centre in Exeter, in Devon, for a few years, and saw a lot of dental emergencies first-hand, probably more than average. Lots of variety, including large facial swellings.
JAZ:
Do you remember how you managed those really big facial swellings? When I was at Guy's, I worked in ADC, acute dental care. As a GDP, I see a patient with a really huge face about once a year.
But in that hospital, we'd see one daily, because it was secondary and tertiary care, if you like. What management did you come across that was accepted at the time, when you were working in the access centre, for those really diffuse, cellulitis-type swellings?
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
If it was a huge, very extreme swelling, and I saw quite a few facial swellings, I used to try to get the tooth out, even if there was some trismus. My general rule of thumb was that if I could get an ID block in, I'd probably have enough access to take the tooth out. That generally worked pretty well most of the time, because the tooth is really the cause.
JAZ:
Which has been the theme of what we've been discussing today. To add how the oral surgery consultants and registrars I worked with managed that scenario:
the scenario where we may need to send patients to acute care, to A&E, is when they have the "hot potato" voice, signs of really severe systemic spread, or difficulty breathing: really quite severe, life-and-death situations.
Sometimes these blokes would walk in with a huge face, but they'd be kind of okay: "Yeah, can I get this sorted, please?" breathing okay and so on. From memory, what they'd do is give a bolus of antibiotic, three grams, straight away, then prescribe amoxicillin and metronidazole dual therapy.
Then, as soon as possible, they'd arrange for the offending tooth to be extracted, usually. That was the management. I don't think much has changed, from speaking to our hospital colleagues. Now, when I see a really nasty swelling and for some reason we can't deal with the source, the tooth, at that moment, I'd actually go for dual antibiotic therapy, which I know goes against everything we're talking about.
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
Yeah.
JAZ:
We're trying to prescribe fewer antibiotics, but there's the distinction of that really nasty fat face, where you want to throw the kitchen sink at it. That's what I remember from the registrars and consultants at Guy's.
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
Yes, I've done the same thing as you, really. You just want to throw everything you've got at it. If amoxicillin isn't effective, then you've got the metronidazole. But like you said, it goes against all we've been taught, but sometimes-
JAZ:
It's good to have it up your sleeve. But the main message, as we keep banging on about, is that you don't want to give antibiotics willy-nilly, and never, ever, ever for irreversible pulpitis. Now, the basics, like timings. Usually when I prescribe amoxicillin or metronidazole,
which isn't very common nowadays, thankfully, it's usually a five-day course, three times a day. I don't really deviate from that, and I don't know whether I should go to seven days if it's a nasty infection.
I also feel the advice has been changing and evolving. There was a phase when I read guidelines saying that, rather than the old saying of "make sure you finish the entire course", if the patient is completely better by day three, perhaps that no longer applies so much and you can stop at three days. I'm actually not sure what the best advice is now. Any idea?
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
Not really, no. I just follow the Scottish guidelines, if I'm honest. I go for five days for pretty much everything. I know the guideline for pericoronitis is three days, but I generally just do five.
JAZ:
I think, if in doubt... I know guidelines are there and you can deviate from them. But if you haven't got a good reason to deviate, you're more likely to get into trouble if you get stuck with a patient whose infection isn't resolving after you said, "It says five days, but take it for three," rather than the whole course.
In terms of complete resolution of that acute episode, it makes sense. But I do see the microbiologists' logic: if it's going to work, don't continue taking it. I get that as well.
So that's in the air. But I think your point about following the guidelines as closely as possible is true.
CHAPTER 11: EXTRACTING THROUGH AN ABSCESS: LOCAL ANAESTHESIA AND DRAINAGE
JAZ:
Then there's the idea that when someone has an abscess, we have to give antibiotics first, because it isn't safe to give local anaesthetic. People justify it: "Oh, we can't take the tooth out now, you have an abscess. We can't possibly take it out while you have an abscess. We've got to wait for the abscess to come down, and then we'll take the tooth out."
I don't follow that. I haven't followed it for years, since my oral surgery experience. Tell us your stance, and what advice you'd offer colleagues listening who may be concerned about injecting into an abscess site.
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
I get a lot of patients saying, "Oh, I didn't realise you could take a tooth out when it's got an abscess on it." And I think, that's absolute nonsense, because even if it resolves and becomes chronic, you'll still have an abscess there, won't you? So quite a lot of the time, that's just an excuse to give antibiotics and not do the required treatment, in my opinion. I'd wholeheartedly take the tooth out with an abscess on it.
JAZ:
Any different ways of anaesthetising in this scenario? Would you inject directly into the abscess, or work around it? What's the best technique?
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
Generally, I try to give some kind of block-
JAZ:
And also work around the abscess, right?
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
Yes.
JAZ:
Buccal, palatal, and also mesial and distal to the abscess.
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
Yes, I'll go buccally, mesial and distal to the abscess. When the area is inflamed, I don't think there's any point injecting directly into the abscess, because you'll just watch it come straight back out, it'll probably be painful, and it won't have much effect. But yes, mesially and distally.
I don't know what you do, Jaz, but I generally do something called supracrestal, I don't even know if that's the right word, into the papilla, keeping firm pressure on the syringe for about a minute, and then I go round palatally as well. If the swelling is buccal, I spend a bit more time putting it in palatally. An oral surgeon once showed me a technique, though it's not very pleasant for the patient if they're not already numb.
It opens up the lumen of the needle a bit more, and then you can get a decent amount in palatally, which helps quite a bit as well. I'm not bending the needle with my fingers; you just put it in and apply a bit of extra pressure, which bends the needle and opens the lumen, I guess.
JAZ:
Got it. So rather than bending the needle before you enter, once you're in, you lean it to one side a little.
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
Yes, that's right.
JAZ:
Okay.
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
Otherwise, there's no room for it. You can actually see the palatal gingiva swelling up. But you wouldn't want to do that unless you needed to, because it'll probably hurt afterwards. Normally, I probe around the tooth with my sharp probe, and sometimes you go straight through the PDL into the abscess.
Once you've done that, there's a pathway to the abscess, so I go in there with my needle and try to get as deep down as possible, directly to where it's needed, for the most effective anaesthesia. Again, that does hurt them a little bit. But if it hurts, you're in the right place, if that makes sense.
JAZ:
Yes. When it hurts, you know it's going to go numb. That's certainly my experience as well. In those scenarios where there's an abscess, obviously you want to get rid of the tooth, the source of the infection, or get to the apex with the root canal approach. You want to get to the source of the infection.
Of course. Now, if there's an actual fluctuant abscess, do you lance it first to drain the pus and then take the tooth out? Or do you take the tooth out and let the pus drain through the extraction site?
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
I don't generally lance it first. It just happens.
JAZ:
Yes, yes.
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
With the luxator and the forceps, it just happens. Also, when you give the local anaesthetic, sometimes you can see pus coming out through the PDL.
JAZ:
One tip I'd give: if you take out a tooth and see a little pus released, but some is still there, I'd suggest lancing the remaining bit and draining it all out. A good saying is, "Don't let the sun set on pus."
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
Yes, I've heard that before. Sometimes there's still soft tissue containing pus, and you want to debride that, I think that's the right word, as much as possible and get some drainage.
What I generally do is leave the patient while I'm writing my notes and get them to massage it as hard as they can. I warn them there'll be more bleeding afterwards, because the blood will keep coming.
JAZ:
Inflammation is part and parcel of that. Now, one thing that confused me at the time is when it's more of a cellulitis and not an abscess. There's swelling, and the patient's face is all puffy and swollen, but there's no localised collection to lance into. It's spreading across the facial planes.
In that case, you're not going to get much pus when you take the tooth out; there's nothing there. So just bear that in mind. Rightly or wrongly, when it was more of a cellulitis, say with a puffy lower eyelid, classically from a canine or something, the oral surgery consultants would err on the side of caution and give antibiotics, despite taking the tooth out.
I don't know what the guidelines say on that. It kind of makes sense, because it's very scary to see someone's face affected like that. But use your judgement. If it's a really nasty one, antibiotics could be part of that patient's care, especially if they're immunocompromised to any degree, for example,
and especially if they're pyrexic and systemically unwell. If there's more than just the swelling, it really helps your cause, and helps justify that what we're doing is the right pathway.
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
At the very, very least, you'd tell the patient, "If there's no improvement in 24 hours, you need to come and see me again." From my experience, they normally don't need to come back. But the swelling takes about two weeks to go down properly, if you've found that as well.
CHAPTER 12: LESSONS FROM COMPLICATED CASES, AND SIGNS OF SYSTEMIC SPREAD
JAZ:
I saw a patient yesterday whom I remember from earlier... actually, it might have been November, so maybe about eight months ago. He came in with a huge golf ball just under the submandibular area. Huge. Probably more like a cricket ball. It was from a lower molar, and he went to an oral surgeon and had the tooth out.
Now that the infection has healed, his mouth opening has only been affected by a couple of millimetres, but when he opens, it feels tighter on the left, and you can visibly see the scarring and fibrosis there. It was a wake-up call. I don't often see that, but it was fascinating to see how much disfigurement and effect it can have afterwards if the healing doesn't go so well.
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
Here's an interesting story. I took out a lower eight for my father. It wasn't a difficult extraction, I don't know what happened, but he ended up with a dry socket, and-
JAZ:
Of course, it's your father. Family members: it always happens. A hundred per cent chance.
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
It gets a lot worse. It's a two-hour trip from his house to my surgery, so I said, "Save yourself the trip and go to the access centre." They dressed it and gave him metronidazole, and it resolved, and then it got worse again. And I thought, "Oh, it'll get better."
It didn't really get better. He came down, I did an OPG, and all was fine. I sent it to my friend in oral surgery, who said it was fine. Then he ended up with this huge, extraorally draining abscess on his face, I don't know.
JAZ:
Like a big pimple, kind of thing?
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
Huge. To this day we don't know what caused it, but I think the diagnosis was probably an infected sebaceous gland, maybe caused by the swelling from the tooth or the socket. Anyway, he was down in my neck of the woods while we were on holiday, so we took him to A&E, and they stitched in a drain. It drained for a couple of weeks, and he was on some antibiotics. But then-
JAZ:
A facial drain, coming out of his cheek?
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
A facial drain.
JAZ:
Coming out of his cheek. Oh my God.
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
Yes. Actually, it was a rolled-up bit of glove stitched in there to keep it open. I'd never seen that before, and I've never seen it since. Anyway, his beard is totally grey apart from one area of black hair in that spot. Strange.
JAZ:
Like fresh growth.
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
Talking about systemic infection, I saw a great poster from, I think, Sam Johnson, the endodontist?
JAZ:
Yes.
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
He did something great on Instagram recently; let me just get it up. He listed the signs of systemic infection: fever, malaise, chills and dehydration. And the warning signs: diffuse facial swelling, trismus, difficulty swallowing and so on.
Those are the kinds of things you want to look out for.
JAZ:
And going back to diffuse swelling, exactly: yes, you can take the tooth out, but with diffuse swelling, because it's a sign of systemic spread, antibiotics are more justifiable than for a round, fluctuant, very localised abscess. That's the distinction we're trying to make here.
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
I think so, yes. And you couldn't even attempt to lance it, could you? You definitely wouldn't do that.
CHAPTER 13: MAXIMUM LOCAL ANAESTHETIC DOSES, DRY SOCKET, ROOT-FILLED TEETH, AND OUTRO
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
Do you know the maximum doses of articaine and lidocaine?
JAZ:
We have it in an Instagram post somewhere.
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
Well, I did a bit of research last night, and there are no hard and fast rules, really. 500 milligrams per appointment is the maximum recommended.
JAZ:
500 milligrams per appointment. But that depends on their weight as well, doesn't it?
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
It does.
JAZ:
For a more petite person it's a bit less, and for a bigger person, a rugby player, probably a bit more. We've got the post here, and it says exactly what you're saying. You do a little calculation: for a 75-kilogram patient, the maximum safe dose of lidocaine is 330 milligrams, based on their weight, which is about seven and a half cartridges.
That's based on 2.2 ml cartridges. If the cartridges are 1.8 ml, there are 36 milligrams in each one, so obviously it depends. Then with articaine, for a 90-kilogram example, you can give about seven cartridges. It says 88 milligrams of articaine per 2.2 ml cartridge. Is that what you've got as well?
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
That's what my maths gave me.
JAZ:
Yes. Lidocaine is 2% and articaine is 4%, hence there's double the amount of the active ingredient in each cartridge. So that makes sense. So it's fewer than seven cartridges, safely, for articaine in a 90-kilogram person. With lidocaine you can give more, and with articaine a bit less, based on that kilogram calculation, a familiar scenario we've faced before.
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
I suppose we shouldn't really be approaching anywhere near that, though, should we? You might give, I don't know, two cartridges of each, and if it doesn't go numb with that, it probably isn't going to.
JAZ:
I think it's more applicable when you're doing multiple-site surgery, like full-mouth implants, with multiple blocks, topping up over several hours. That's when you really have to watch it. For one or two teeth, or even a quadrant procedure, you're right, you'll never get near it. Once you've done about four cartridges, you really have to think, "Okay, I need to try something else here, because this isn't working."
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
I remember being taught that dry socket isn't an infection, but bizarrely, metronidazole does help a bit. What I've been trying to do recently is never give it for dry socket unless I think there's some kind of infection.
JAZ:
Systemic spread, as you said.
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
Yes. Dry socket is difficult, isn't it? You want to do everything you can to help them, because it's very painful. But with the evidence-
JAZ:
I think we discussed this once with someone on the podcast. It was Chris, I think. We discussed how Alvogyl used to be really good.
Then they took out a really important part of the formulation and changed the name from Alvogyl to Alveogyl, changing it by one letter. So they're fooling us a little bit; it's not as good anymore. The good stuff that used to be in the original Alvogyl isn't actually in there anymore.
So it may not actually be that effective. But I think the whole point is the psychological effect: "Hey, this dentist has done something. They've put something in, so I'll get better." And it's a much better thing to put sparingly into someone's socket than to give antibiotics for something they're probably not going to help.
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
Generally, yes. I find patients do get quite a rapid benefit from Alvogyl. And I've been thinking about one of the questions from when we talked about this previously: a patient comes in with a root-treated tooth and pain from it.
It's obviously acute periapical periodontitis. What do you do in your very limited appointment time if they want to keep the tooth? If they want to get rid of it, that's fine; you know what to do. But realistically, I think we'll be reaching for antibiotics in that situation.
JAZ:
I think, unfortunately, in the real world, who's going to be able to remove the GP, get to the apex and reach the source of infection? Hopefully, thankfully, it doesn't happen that often, but it's one of the more common scenarios we see. I think it's about having a good look at the tooth as a whole. Has it even got a fair prognosis, restorability-wise?
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
Yeah.
JAZ:
If it hasn't, why are we leaving the option of a re-RCT and restoring the tooth on the table at all? If the prognosis is going to be poor anyway, maybe we ought to consent the patient more towards an extraction.
But if it has a decent restorative and endodontic prognosis, then yes, sometimes it's not possible to get all the way down through the GP, and you give antibiotics to get them through the acute phase. But what I don't like is repeat offenders: "Oh yeah, I'll get it sorted in future,"
every six months. I have very limited sympathy for those scenarios. I'm very good at encouraging those patients: "Listen, this isn't good. Don't call me at Christmas. Don't call me at Easter. It's going to happen on a bank holiday. Don't even call me." So they get the point.
DR JEREMY LENAERTS:
It's going to happen on your holiday when you're away. And taking GP out and re-endos is more of a specialist thing, really, isn't it, I think.
JAZ:
Yes. I don't think anyone expects you to. That's a fair, real-world point.
Well, there we have it, guys. Thank you so much for listening all the way to the end, and thanks to our community member Dr Jeremy Lenaerts for geeking out with us today. This episode is eligible for CPD and CE credits, and we're a PACE-approved education provider. Just scroll down in the app and answer the quiz. Easy peasy, lemon squeezy. Don't forget to download our antibiotics cheat sheet at protrusive.co.uk/abx.
And of course, if you're already on Protrusive Guidance, we've got you; just download it below. As ever, I'll catch you same time, same place next week. Bye for now.
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
QUESTION:
When are antibiotics indicated in dentistry?
ANSWER:
Dr Jeremy Lenaerts explains that antibiotics are mainly indicated when there are signs of systemic or spreading infection, and that they should be used as an adjunct to local measures such as drainage, accessing the tooth or extraction. He recommends following national guidance, such as SDCEP's. Both he and Jaz stress that antibiotics are not indicated for irreversible pulpitis.
QUESTION:
Why is overprescribing antibiotics harmful?
ANSWER:
Jeremy explains that unnecessary antibiotics can disrupt a patient's gut microbiome, contribute to antimicrobial resistance at both an individual and community level, and carry risks of adverse reactions, allergies and anaphylaxis. He describes antibiotics as a temporary fix at best, which may not work at all if the bacteria are resistant.
QUESTION:
How do antibiotics affect the gut microbiome?
ANSWER:
Jeremy explains that antibiotics kill gut bacteria as well as the infection-causing ones, and broad-spectrum antibiotics such as amoxicillin probably cause more disruption than narrow-spectrum ones. He says the gut microbiome usually recovers within one to two months, but this varies, and resistant bacteria can survive and share resistance genes.
QUESTION:
What's the difference between an abscess and cellulitis?
ANSWER:
Jaz explains that an abscess is a localised collection of pus that can often be drained, while cellulitis is a more diffuse, spreading swelling with nothing to drain. Both he and Jeremy consider diffuse swelling, difficulty swallowing, eye involvement or systemic signs, such as fever or malaise, a stronger indication for antibiotics than a localised abscess.
QUESTION:
Can you extract a tooth that has an abscess?
ANSWER:
Jeremy says yes, and that waiting for an abscess to settle before extracting is often just an excuse to prescribe antibiotics instead of treating the cause. He usually lets the pus drain through the socket during extraction, and Jaz suggests draining any remaining pus, using the saying "don't let the sun set on pus".
QUESTION:
How do you give local anaesthetic near an abscess?
ANSWER:
Jeremy usually gives a block where possible, then infiltrates around the abscess, mesially and distally, rather than directly into it, because injecting into inflamed, pus-filled tissue is painful and less effective. He also gives local anaesthetic into the papillae and palatally, and sometimes uses an intraligamentary route along the PDL.
QUESTION:
How do you talk to a patient who wants antibiotics?
ANSWER:
Jaz recommends empathising, explaining clearly why antibiotics aren't indicated, recommending effective painkillers, and reassuring patients that antibiotics may be needed later if the infection spreads. He tells patients that taking them unnecessarily makes them less likely to work when truly needed. Jeremy finds that most patients make the right decision when given full information.
QUESTION:
Are antibiotics useful for dry socket?
ANSWER:
Jeremy explains that dry socket isn't an infection, so he now avoids prescribing antibiotics for it unless he suspects infection. He finds patients get fairly rapid relief from a dressing such as Alvogyl. Jaz agrees that placing a dressing in the socket is preferable to prescribing antibiotics that are unlikely to help.
ABOUT THE GUEST
Dr Jeremy Lenaerts is a general dentist and a member of Protrusive Guidance. He studied microbiology at Cardiff University, completed a PhD in microbial ecology at the University of Exeter and worked in biotech, before joining the first cohort at Peninsula Dental School and qualifying in 2011. He has worked in a dental access centre and enjoys aligner orthodontics and cosmetic composite work.
RECOMMENDED NEXT
- Protrusive antibiotics cheat sheet: protrusive.co.uk/abx