Transformative Principal

Timothy Dasey, a former MIT Lincoln Laboratory leader, shows principals how AI in education should shift schools toward challenge-based learning and away from siloed subjects.

Show Notes

Timothy Dasey spent 30 years at MIT Lincoln Laboratory and now consults on AI in education. He explains what has changed in AI over the last year, what schools should ask the companies selling them tools, and why general thinking skills will count for more than subject expertise.

Dasey describes the teacher as a compass, not a GPS. You point students toward where they need to be, tell them when they are off track, and let them struggle productively. Jethro adds his own proof: a block of cross-subject challenge time where girls learned to fire someone with empathy.

What you'll learn

  • Pose a hard, age-appropriate challenge before you teach the material, and let students struggle with it first.
  • Act as a compass who tells students when they are off track, not a GPS who gives every turn.
  • Ask AI vendors how you can monitor what their product does, since they cannot test every way it will be used.
  • Use AI first to cut teacher workload, so teachers have the time and energy to try new things.
  • Bring students into the change by letting a class test different uses of AI and compare results.

Chapters

  • 0:00 Meet Timothy Dasey and his AI background
  • 3:38 How AI changed in the last year
  • 8:32 What schools should ask AI companies
  • 12:33 Productive struggle and the teacher as compass
  • 14:48 Why general skills matter more than domains
  • 23:15 Jethro's cross-subject challenge time at school
  • 29:57 How to make school change stick
  • 36:39 Why you still need numeracy and understanding

Times are for the episode without ads. Your player may be off by the length of any ads.

Questions this episode answers

What should schools ask AI companies before adopting their tools?
Dasey says AI companies cannot test every way their product will be used, so they do not exactly know what they are selling. He tells schools to make sure there are ways to monitor what is going on and to filter out content kids should never see.

What is the teacher's role when students have AI?
Dasey wants the teacher to be a compass, not a GPS. The teacher says which direction students should be heading and tells them when they are off track, and students work out how to get back through productive struggle.

How do you start changing how a school teaches without doing it all at once?
Dasey says change needs activation energy, so start by lowering teacher workload with AI. Then try things and keep what works. A science teacher can work with the math teacher on a shared challenge, and students can help test AI in class.

About Timothy Dasey

Timothy Dasey spent 30 years at MIT Lincoln Laboratory, runs an AI consulting company and wrote Wisdom Factories: AI, Games, and the Education of a Modern Worker.

Links and resources

Working on this at your school? Get a free preview of a 10-week leadership pathway built from episodes like this one at transformativeprincipal.com/start.


Thanks to our Sponsor Broadcast Made Easy who help you start a news broadcast at your school by having everything you need in one easy-to-download place. Check it out today and get your kids creating. 

We’re proud to be sponsored by IXL. 

IXL’s comprehensive teaching and learning platform for math, language arts, science, and social studies is accelerating achievement in 95 of the top 100 U.S. school districts. Loved by teachers and backed by independent research from Johns Hopkins University, IXL can help you do the following and more:
  • Simplify and streamline technology
  • Save teachers’ time
  • Reliably meet Tier 1 standards
  • Improve student performance on state assessments

🚀 Ready to see why leading districts trust IXL for their educational needs? Visit IXL.com/BE today to learn more about how IXL can elevate your school or district.

Creators and Guests

Host
Jethro Jones
SA
Guest
Summer of AI
The Summer of AI Series included folks from a range of perspectives talking about AI.

What is Transformative Principal?

Jethro Jones interviews instructional leaders from around the nation to learn and teach what it takes to become a transformative principal. Episodes address topics like Response to Intervention (RTI), Multi-Tiered System of Support (MTSS), Positive Behavior Interventions and Supports (PBIS), the latest advances in educational research, standards-based grading, and interviews with industry leaders like Bill Daggett, Rick Wormeli, Todd Whitaker and even people outside the education like Seth Godin, JeVon McCormick, Liz Wiseman, and more.

If you've been thinking about news broadcast, but don't know where to start and don't want to have that lift, use broadcastmadeeasy.com to make it super easy for yourself. I am really excited about our sponsor, Broadcast Made Easy. As a principal, I created a daily news show at all of my schools, but you know what? It took a ton of work. Broadcast Made Easy makes it super simple for you to get started.

They provide templates, scripts, job descriptions, applications, the whole nine yards. You buy it once, no subscription, and it makes getting started so much easier. Another thing they have is specific videos for every holiday you could possibly imagine. So that as part of your news broadcast, you can share what holidays are coming up, less than a minute, and very simple, straightforward, just the facts that makes it really easy to start conversations about those holidays.

So go check it out at broadcastmadeeasy.com and let them know that you heard about it on Transformative Principle. That's broadcastmadeeasy.com. This B Podcast Network show is presented by IXL. IXL's all-inclusive online teaching and learning platform simplifies edtech needs and accelerates achievement in 95 of the top 100 U.S. school districts. IXL delivers personalized learning across a comprehensive pre-K-12 curriculum, including math, language arts, science, and social studies, and helps you assess student performance through actionable, real-time insights at every level of your school or district.

This one solution performs work that typically requires dozens of tools. Want to find out why so many leading districts trust IXL? Visit IXL.com slash B-E. That's IXL.com slash B-E. Welcome to Transformative Principle, where I help you stop putting out fires and start leading. I'm your host, Jethro Jones. You can follow me on Twitter, at Jethro Jones.

Welcome to Transformative Principle. I am grateful you're here for the Summer of AI series brought to you by School AI and AIleader.info. I'm excited to have Dr. Tim Dacey on the program today. He has spent 30 years at MIT's Lincoln Laboratory, which is their national security hub, where he developed and then led technology analysis development for a wide array of challenges. He's also been a teacher, and he's taught at the college level and middle school level, even though he wouldn't consider himself a teacher.

He has a consulting company now that focuses on AI opportunities and strategic implications for a variety of communities, including education and entrepreneurial investment and biotech. He recently published a book called Wisdom Factories, AI Games, and the Education of a Modern Worker about AI's impact on work and the education reform implications. Tim, welcome to Transformative Principle. It's grateful to have you here. Thank you. Great to be here.

Well, first, is there anything from your intro, from your bio, that I did not get? No, it sounds great. You know, my teaching stints were very short, so that's why I don't advertise myself as a teacher, but it did give me enough of a perspective on some of the challenges. I consider myself more of a learning scientist, whether it's for humans or machines. So I think we're going to talk a lot about the future of work, which I think is the framing behind everything that education should be concerned with.

It's the context for the system, but also I expect we'll get into, you know, some of the challenges that schools and teachers face, you know, what can be done near term versus what has to be thought about for more significant transformation longer term, and then how do you get going? Yeah, and I think the thing for me is the value of you coming at this problem from a different angle and arriving at the same conclusion that I came at this problem from a different angle at, and in my experience as a teacher and a principal, seeing how this, how we need to reform our system, and you come into that same approach, I think that's really exciting.

So again, thank you, Tim. You can learn more about Tim at timdacey.com, and we'll get to his interview here in just a moment. If you've been listening to Transformative Principle for any amount of time, you know that I have a love-hate relationship with EdTech. We have the ability to personalize learning for every single one of our students, and yet so many of our EdTech tools fall short.

We need our technology to do more for us. That's why it's so important for me to know that IXL provides true personalized learning across the entire pre-K-12 curriculum, and that it's proven to benefit all student populations, including English language learners and students in special ed programs. As a principal, I've used this in my school. As a parent, I've had my children use it as well. And let me tell you, this is a tool that definitely helps students learn and practice better.

IXL is research proven to accelerate achievement. Studies across 45 states show that IXL schools outperform non-IXL schools on state assessments, and independent research from Johns Hopkins University verifies that IXL meets ESSA Tier 1 standards. With those results combined with IXL's teacher-friendly reputation, what more could you ask for? Now, you also know that I don't care so much about test scores, but I know that they are legislatively convenient and something that we have to deal with and manage on a day-to-day basis.

If you can implement something that is easy and effective, why wouldn't you do it? If you have a goal to increase achievement for all students, make sure to find out what IXL can do for you. Visit IXL.com slash B for a demo. That's IXL.com slash B E. So, Tim, why don't we start by talking about this new and emerging field of artificial intelligence that you've been in for 35 years?

How has artificial intelligence changed over the last year versus over the last 35 years? Well, I think for a long time, even going back to my graduate school days in the late 80s, early 90s, we thought of AI as a tool basically to remove drudgery, to do routine decision-making. So, AI is primarily a decision-making tool, although what has happened in the last year is that the nature of the decisions we're asking AI to make are much more abstract.

And by that nature, they end up being useful in a lot of different creative domains, not just the routine, boring, repetitive task domain. And that's a tremendous difference. You know, for the longest time, the talk in AI was, you know, beyond the horizon was always going to be, yes, someday we can maybe get it to do all these fancy things. But I think it has surprised even the community how rapidly some of that has been realized in in terms of its ability to deal with idea generation and synthesis and generation of, I'll call it insight.

These are all anthropomorphic terms, but, you know, certainly the text that comes out of ChatGPT at some level does a certain amount of cogitating and reasoning. But all it's doing is doing a repetitive task over and over and over again. The difference is that we now can make these things massive, right? The ChatGPT, GPT-4s sort of is on the order of the brain's size and scale in terms of all the connections and stuff within it.

And so behavior has emerged from that. But we've also given it very abstract questions, complete this text, predict the next set of text. And that's different than what, at least through most of my career, we were working with. You know, if we wanted to diagnose breast cancer through looking at breast cancer images, that had a very constrained problem definition and a pretty constrained application. But now we have these multi-purpose tools.

And I think that's the biggest difference from what we had before. Do you think that the capability was there before and we just hadn't tapped into it? Or has it really been a recent development that because we have such large models now that we can actually tap into things that we just didn't have the capacity for before?

You know, it's a very recent development. I remember talking to people four or five years ago about software code generation using AI. And, you know, these are very sophisticated computer scientists that I spoke with and almost all of them said, no, we're not going to do that anytime soon.

But, you know, the AI that's available to do that doesn't do it in a holistic way, just as AI doesn't do most tasks entirely, right? But it gets pretty far so much so that, you know, something like half of the code Silicon Valley is churning out now as AI generated. Yeah, that's really fascinating. We didn't predict these things. And it's really a function of emergent behavior that we still don't entirely understand.

But it turns out if you make some of these systems big enough, it starts to do things you didn't explicitly design in.

And that we still don't know the limits of. There are some theories, including ones that OpenAI have generated about, hey, if I keep adding more data, how much better will I get? But these are just, these systems, I think what has gotten the AI community to sound alarm bells is they know that these systems are babies. And there's a tremendous, there are all kinds of opportunities and directions to improve these.

And there's no reason based on the rapid growth that we can expect that it won't be able to be improved.

So things like the veracity of information you get from it, there may always be problems at some level. Just like there are getting information from a human being. But we're going to see dramatic advancement as AI is applied and these products are spun off into niche areas. The law firms will have their own with, you know, much more well-verified information. Doctors will have their own. Education will have their own with very different safety protocols and everything else that students and classrooms need.

Yeah. Well, let's talk about that a little bit. What, what, what types of things do you think we should be building in for safety? And I mean, what I'm really getting at is as schools start to adopt AI tools, what kinds of questions should they be asking the companies that are providing these to make sure that they're making good choices around it?

Well, okay. So there's a two, there's a two part. I mean, I think there is a real problem in terms of understanding how well something will do, especially a new product out on the market. One of the reasons you see these AI companies getting their products out fast, you know, a big part of it, of course, is money. But another part of it is they actually, without lots of people doing lots of different things to the system, they can't anticipate all the ways that it will be used.

And so because of that, they can't test the AI fully. And what they do is they want the crowd, so to speak, all these creative individuals out there who are using ChatGPT and other tools in ways the developers didn't imagine. So a big issue from the AI company side is, I don't exactly know what I'm selling, okay? That's, one could say that's a big problem for schools.

But I do believe that, and over the next year or two, schools should be cautious, understanding that their kids are going to be using these tools. They're available, you know, you can try to lock down their laptops or whatever school devices they have, but they will be using these tools to some degree, okay? Warts and all. So we're moving from an era where all of the test points in what software or another technology will do can be tested, to now an era where I can't test all the different ways the technology will do.

That's not dissimilar from getting a new teacher in the classroom and not knowing exactly how the teacher will react to different situations. The key is going to be making sure that you have ways to monitor what's going on, that the AI manufacturers can at least make sure that egregious stuff that kids should never see are going to be filtered out. And the rest, I very strongly believe that educators will be best off as they go through these transitions to try to figure out how to use AI appropriately, to bring students into that process.

You know, to say to them, look, this course might look a lot different in a year or two. Help me figure out what it's going to look like. We may try, you know, half of you use this tool for a while and half of you don't, and we're going to design an experiment to see which results in better learning. But whatever it might be, if you bring them into the process, even if somehow whatever you're trying to teach in the class is not done as well as it could otherwise have been with a different model, the students are learning so much.

They're, first of all, they're getting engaged in their own and invested in their own learning. But secondly, they, you know, they're learning all of these big picture skills about what, you know, how do we, the teacher in the classroom, how do we define what needs to be learned, given that the world has changed? And how does that manifest in the ways we need to get that out?

And it may very well be, just as an example, you know, there's research out in the educational world. I wish I could cite the reference at this point, but I'm bad with names.

There's research that if you pose a developmentally appropriate, difficult challenge to a kid before they learn the material and let them pull their hair out for enough time that they don't get totally dissuaded. And then put that aside, start teaching them the material as you normally would. There's a lot of evidence out there that indicates that the students will learn better by the end of that process and along the way, just by showing them where they're headed.

So that the phrase we use in education for that is productive struggle. And Joe Bowler is a big proponent of that. And that's something that my approach to what school should look like is more along those lines that kids can most likely learn almost anything they need to learn in school, essentially by themselves. And they just need a good teacher to be a compass to help them see where they're going and to identify when they've learned the things that they've that they that they're supposed to learn.

So, you know, we've had the stage on the stage, and then we move to a guide on the side as the role for the teacher and, and my idea is that the teacher should be a compass among us that the teacher is saying, here's the direction we need to be going. And you all should, you know, be moving in this direction and my job is not to guide you there, or to stand up and say this is everything you need to know, but rather to be the compass that tells you when you're off track that doesn't, it's not a GPS that tells you what direction you need to go to get back but says hey, this is where you need to be heading, and you're not heading in that direction.

What do you need to do, and how do you need to work to get back to where you need to be and I've had success in in running that in my own school and in teaching that in other schools and there's a lot of power in that that the that productive struggle becomes becomes really powerful. So in your book, you talk about education reform that is needed to get kids ready for a career where they're going to be exposed to AI, what about our current system is not sufficient, and what does it need to look like?

Sure, so the general message I'm giving in the book is at least split into three pieces. The first piece is, you know, we're, we're moving toward a realm and fairly quickly, I believe, where general cognitive skills will matter more than domain specific expertise, that is over the arc of a career, you're going to be persistently presented with novel situations, your job is going to keep evolving as technology changes as paradigms change.

And you'll probably, at least based on the trends that we're seeing, you'll probably have multiple careers. And so, and so, and by that, I mean very different job types. And so it is that change and the, and the fact that the world is changing so fast, that really is, is, is getting schools to pivot toward those 21st century skills, you know, the, the general cognitive abilities that are applicable to multiple kinds of domains and problems, right?

Those transferable skills. So that's the first part of the message. The second part of the message is more important though, because that first part has been said by many, right? The second, the second part of the message is, it's not the best way to get there, the way we're doing things. And that is because really schools are, you know, the whole, the whole division of courses, the whole decisions about credentials at the higher education level.

All of those are based on preparing people to be in what I'll call knowledge domain specific areas. If you're a doctor, you're going to be the best at medical information. If you're a chemist, you're going to learn chemistry. And high school is a rehearsal for those different choices about college. A lot of, a lot of high school is, right? If you ask a science teacher, why are we teaching all these things?

He'll say, we want to expose kids to the, you know, these different domains, but it is, but it is the nature of dividing things up, right? Usually this is true within a business as well as, as, as say a school system, which I will call, you know, somewhat different than the, than the money-making concerns with business. But you, how you divide up your, your functions really drives the overall ethos of the system.

So if I'm, if I'm in a business and I divide stuff up by marketing and sales, et cetera, that's a very different paradigm and has very different frictions, we'll call it, than if I divide it up by product line. And I have, you know, the people in a product line have to deal with all those things relevant to a product. So school has largely been divided up by expertise areas and there are exceptions.

Of course, literacy, we view as cross-cutting. So that's something that's taught, you know, regardless of a particular domain. But for the most part, that's been the paradigm really since mass education was formed. We're now seeing that AI is going to be doing a lot of the detail work and a lot of what we had traditionally would say is about expertise preparation. So those general cognitive skills matter more, at least, you know, one could argue whether they do now or not, right?

But at least we're in that, we're in that rapid evolution toward, toward those, those kind of transition. And that means very, very different things for how do you optimally teach it. So what my primary message to schools is, look, work on AI in the classroom, refine pedagogy. I think there's great work going on in that way. And it's going to be an iterate, try, fail, improve kind of situation.

But there needs to be a lot of stepping back as well, because the curriculum is not set up well to teach critical thinking or creativity or problem solving. To do that, you have to tap into the, you know, we learn because, you know, our memory system is fundamentally associative, right? So we have, we have connections between our experiences, we'll call that episodic memory, between our knowledge and factual memory, between, you know, all these different sensory modes we have.

And, you know, that, those giant network of association is what drives learning. The better network you have, the better you're going to learn. If you want to get to transferable information, right, if you want to support those general cognitive abilities, then you have to get to the nodes in that associative network that connect to a lot of different things. And the way you do that is by having people work on problems that have trade-offs and uncertainties and that delve in, that rely on domain knowledge from a lot of different places.

So I'll give you an example. I'm droning on a little bit, so cut me off if I'm. No, I'm following, I'm following. So for many years when I was at MIT, we were developing games in order principally to get people to have a better discussion with us about what AI might help their jobs in what way. So we would sit them down at computers and we would have them play part of their job out in a game framework.

We'd give them particular scenarios and say, figure it out. And then we would talk to them afterward about, you know, what did that, they learned from that. So several of those games ended up being in a general category of resource management. So we build resource management game for military logistics folks, for FEMA emergency managers, for public health officials, you know, for law enforcement. And that's a general skill, right, that a lot of different jobs have.

Frankly, if I want to manage my time, I'm dealing with a resource management problem, right? Yeah, totally. So I believe that school is much better off carving up the world according to common cognitive challenges rather than according to knowledge domains. And that paradigm shift is critical because the way you get to transferable skills is you have to get to these trade-offs and situations where one factor has to balance or be weighed against another, where the answers are not obvious.

Or maybe there isn't a single answer. So there are subjects that do this well. There are teachers, great teachers will always do this well, but they're constrained, right? If I'm in my geometry class, I'm constrained about being critical thinking about geometry, whereas I'm better off in a real world context teaching people a skill that, hey, you know, the orbital path of a Mars, you know, mission that we might imagine has some geometrical principles.

It has some physics principles in order to understand if people can handle it, it has medical issues, right? If you organize life around or life in a school around big challenges and then dive into the knowledge they need, you're both helping engagement directly, I think, because you're making it more tangible what this is useful for. But you're also forcing the thinking and the discussion about how these different silos are used together to solve problems.

And at this point in human history, those are the skills that I think matter more. And AI is really driving a lot of that. Here's the truth. School leadership is demanding. It's rewarding, but it can also feel lonely and so overwhelming sometimes. That's why we created Linked Leaders, to make sure great leaders keep leading and good leaders get the support to become great. At Linked Leaders, you're never on your own.

Whether you're building culture, navigating board relations, or tackling special education challenges, you'll find solutions from leaders who've been in your shoes. And the best part, you don't have to wait months for a big conference or spend thousands of dollars hoping to make the right connection. With Linked Leaders, you can log in today, get straight answers from experienced mentors, and walk away with a playbook that works right when you need it.

Linked Leaders is efficient, personalized support that keeps you moving forward. Sign up for free at linkedleaders.com. Tim, it's really fascinating. I wish that you could have been at my school in the 2017 to 2019 years, because this is exactly what we were doing. And what I found really fast is that my teachers, if I had to take this experiential learning that we were doing out of their classroom subjects and put it in a period that was not connected to their general topic, so that they had the freedom to let it touch everything.

And what's, so that's what we did is we gave them an hour and a half, two times a week to, for kids to solve these problems that they were, that they were looking at. And we said, your goal is to make the world a better place. You can define world, you can define better, and you can define what problem you're solving. And what was really cool is that we saw exactly what you're talking about, and you and I have never met before this, but it's like, it's like you were at my school and did a little case study on what we did, because that's exactly what we were doing.

And what was amazing was kids learned more in that time period than they did in their regular classes, and we had evidence to show that they were learning more because they weren't constrained in a negative way with the topic that they had to learn in that class. So girls teaching younger girls how to do volleyball, soccer, and cheer passed off more standards in that class than they passed off in all the rest of their classes that year.

Because they were, they had to pull from different areas, they had to learn and understand different things. In fact, one of the skills that they learned was how to fire someone with empathy and compassion, which is not on the standards for any K-12 school. But that's a skill that is incredibly important and meaningful as a human to have, and these girls learned how to do that. And that, that's what I think is so amazing, is when we, when we take the subjects away, we actually have more freedom for kids to learn even more.

And one of the things that I was working on was eliminating our English language arts class as a whole, because English language arts touches every other subject, and it's all about communication. And so you actually don't need the English class to show that you're learning those things, and it then becomes incumbent on every teacher to make sure that they are effectively communicating and effectively teaching, communicating, both hearing, receiving, listening, and speaking, writing, communicating outward.

That is, that is really powerful. So is this, is this how you would describe your upside down schooling approach? Right. It really has two pieces, I guess, to reference sort of other educational theory. One is that it's challenge-based learning, as you talked about, right? So I've already said something about that, but the other is that it's, it's knowledge on demand, right? Right. So instead of, you know, what I was, I was talking about is, you know, it's, it's teaching the forest and then filling in the trees, or using selective, selective teaching of trees to, to, to, to give a forest view.

Or, you know, that's what I was, you know, I was talking about, you know, I was talking about genetics, right? Oh my gosh, that gives me such headaches. Right. Grego Mendel teaches us very little about what's going on in genetics today. Right. Don't teach it as a history lesson because you want to use history in the story about it to create engagement. Give people interesting challenges to conjure on and they'll get interested. Yeah.

You know, explain to them why we can't do X, Y, Z in the field. And, and here's, here are the problems with that. But here's what we do know. And, and, and when you do that, I think you immediately engage the creative juices in, in, in, in human beings in general, right? If you were to, if you were to get a new job and they sit down and they talk to you about, you know, read them, read this progression of manuals for the next month.

First of all, no employer would do that because they want productive output output from you as soon as possible. Yeah. But, but you're not going to even recall or remember most of what you were taught because you didn't get to use it. And most knowledge that we give students now will allow them to use it. And I say, we, I was briefly a middle school teacher and I also taught at the college level, but not long enough to call myself a teacher.

But, but, but we have a lot of these, even the projects we assign in classes, they're narrowly defined projects. I mean, maybe I'm teaching somebody about electromagnetics at the college level and Maxwell's equations, right? But that doesn't teach me anything about how to address a new problem. What questions should I ask of it? What are the possible, you know, different kinds of math that I might be able to use to help address it?

What does history teach me? What are, what is a good piece of literature about this kind of topic? All of those things can be brought in under the, under a context. And in the process, we're teaching the students to, to, you know, basically to do things like the workplace does. And, and, and I think, you know, replicating that model to the degree you can is, I think, pretty important for, you know, if you want people to practice, to be good at situations, you got to put them in those situations.

Yeah, totally. And, and, and what we certainly learned during the pandemic was that school is just made up, and nothing really matters. And that was a, in my opinion, a horrible lesson for our kids to learn from it. And I saw many high school students who said, this doesn't matter because I'm going to get an A in the class anyway, and I'm going to totally stop and totally check out, and I'm still going to graduate, not a problem at all.

Which, you know, if our purpose is to educate kids, we, we certainly educated them, but we did not educate them in a way that I think most of us would be proud of. And we, we told them that these things that we put so much emphasis on before, just don't matter. And so how, how do you suggest we make these changes, so that they're, they're actually capable of sticking, and really continuing on beyond, you know, just what's happening right now?

Well, I think there are some key pieces. I mean, first of all, we have to accept that change is hard. And, you know, most change requires, you know, I'll call it activation energy, which is a chemistry term. And that refers to, you know, getting from one stable state of a chemical to another stable state of a chemical, I may have to put energy into the system to get it there. Right? That's what enzymes do, because they, they make that activation energy less.

Same thing is true at an organizational level, right? If there's too much friction, if teachers are, are stressed out so much, they're not going to be able to look past their nose. And, and so a lot of what I think AI in the classroom is best focused on to start is how do we make that teacher workload less, so that we, you know, we give them time to really think and experiment at some level with how they're going to go about their next lessons and their next classes.

So that's one. I think the other big thing is, you know, Rome was a built in a day. I mean, I come from the tech community that learned a long time ago, that when you deal with complex issues, you don't try to sit there and plan it out for years, you just start trying things, and you keep what works and you jettison what doesn't. And that can be, you know, the interdisciplinary part. So we're talking about, I want problems that are more complex, right? And that have a lot of squishy factors associated. So age appropriately, of course.

I want to make sure that I'm working on particular multidisciplinary challenges. And I want to make sure that students have some agency in the type of knowledge and the type that, that, you know, there may be some core knowledge pieces that everybody needs, but there's probably more individualization in terms of how students will go after that. So those three pieces don't have to be done all at once in one big swoop. It may be that, you know, I'm the science teacher, and I'm going to go down the hall and talk more to the math teacher to make sure that I can incorporate a few things they're working on into my lessons, right?

So that there's some synergy between the different parts of a day that a student is learning. Or maybe I'll work a common problem that we agree is a nice challenge that sort of pulls out both pieces of knowledge that we like. It could be that, as I said, we get students invested in the process of change itself and say, let's, I want the class to experiment with different ways of using AI, you know, and you guys can help with that. And that gets both the teacher and the students invested in the change. And that allows you to get a lot more feedback, of course, too.

And so, you know, you have to start chipping away. It doesn't have to be everything at once. The reality is standards are a real constrainer. I mean, one of the unfortunate thing, and I don't mean that standards are unimportant, but when you create standards, you essentially try to lock in something, right? And this is what we must teach. And, you know, we need the opposite. We need a lot of individual creative educators trying a lot of different things.

And that is a direct friction with what they're generally asked to do, which is to follow according to the standards. Yeah, totally. And a good example of that to illustrate why standards can be so damning is that when you have a standard, you also have a finish line. And so if, for example, I'm writing a book right now called Bad Advice for New Principles, and one of the things in there is talking about standards.

And one of the examples that I used, and I just wrote this chapter this last week, so it's fresh on my mind, is that the standard for third grade math in the state of Washington is to be able to do multiplication and division up to 100. And so when that is the standard, then that is also the limit that you automatically set on all those students. And some students may decide to figure out what 10 times 11 is, and some may decide to figure out what 25 times 37 is.

But the reality is that all of your problems, all of your things are going to go up to this level, and then they're going to stop, and they're not going to go beyond that. And so when a student says, hey, I can do up to 10 times 10, and up to 100 divided by any of these numbers, then they've reached that limit, and they're not going to push beyond that, unless they have some reason to.

Unless you make it so that it means something to them, right? It has meaning. I remember there's a, I think it was seventh or eighth grade, and I remember after class one day, there was a particular science teacher I liked, and we were chatting, and I said, yeah, I understand the metric system. And he picked up a box of paperclips, and he said, okay, you do? How much does this weigh in grams?

And, of course, I didn't have a very good answer, because I knew how to do, I knew what the, you know, the terms meant. I knew that this was a thousand times more than that, but I didn't have a feel, I didn't have numeracy, a sense about those numbers. So, you know, I think people bemoan the fact that somebody can't do calculations, students can't do calculations in their heads the way my parents' generation did.

I would say, yeah, yeah, but, you know, they're going to have to use technology to do that, but the key is, when the answer comes out, did they know that, you know, when I added two three-digit numbers, I should be getting another three-digit number or a low four-digit number, I shouldn't be getting something with seven digits, right? Did I have enough understanding of the conceptual principles?

Because, sure, it would be nice if everybody could add things in their head, but the reality is, there aren't many times when people need to do that anymore. And we can use technology for that, and almost in every situation, we're going to have technology for that, and it's honestly silly to think that we wouldn't, you know? I mean, I, on that front, I would say the vast majority of my calculations now happen in a spreadsheet using spreadsheet and formulas much more than even using a simple calculator.

And that that is the literacy that is much more valuable, and, you know, what's funny is using chat GPT to do mathematical things, I've seen how it totally makes up numbers and does things incorrectly and doesn't have a firm grasp of what those skills are. And if I were just using it as a calculator, punching things in and trusting that it's right, I would be wrong many of the times that I've tried to use it for those things.

And that's that literacy or that numeracy that you're talking about, where you have to understand the bigger picture, and you have to have those foundational skills in order for you to know whether or not those tools are actually helping. And to your point earlier about making life for teachers easier by taking some of the workload off, that's important too, but if you ask the AI to write you a lesson, but you don't understand what you're trying to teach in the lesson, it does you no good to have the AI do that task for you.

And so you still have to have some of these skills, and you can't rely on it wholeheartedly without having an understanding as well. And that's a nuanced piece of this that I think the general public doesn't totally understand. They see what AI can do, and they think, well, that's amazing. And, you know, another last example about this particular topic is, I use a program called Descript to edit my podcast.

And it has this thing where it automatically finds filler words, like if somebody says, here, here's a good idea, then it'll take out that first here and say, this is probably a filler, and we can delete it. But sometimes it gets it wrong. And as you're listening to it, then you're like, wait, you didn't understand what the person was trying to say. When I said like that time, I was trying to give an example or use a simile, and you took it as me using like as a filler word.

And, you know, that you still have to have the understanding. And that's why this foundational literacy, numeracy, whatever these foundational knowledge pieces are, are so important. And if we can, do you have anything to add to that, or can we change gears? No, I think what we're talking about in terms of the general progression is we're moving to much more abstract, you know, I'll call it increasing levels of abstraction, right?

Whereas it used to be useful to solve a math problem. Now it's useful to get a computer to solve a math problem. In the workplace, it's, you know, when people get more experience, the best ones know which math to pick to ask a computer to do. In the future, when AI is doing and knows which math to pick, it's about us setting up the problem so that AI can figure out which math is appropriate, right?

It increases our level of abstraction. And what I would claim is that we don't get to those higher levels of abstraction by having people do all the levels underneath. I don't teach somebody to be a good construction worker with heavy equipment by handing them a shovel and having them shovel for a month. That's a really good analogy that we need to teach them how to use the tools they're actually going to use and understand what they really need to be doing, what their purpose is in that role.

Yeah, this was a great conversation. Time just flew by. Yeah, it was fun. Yeah, I appreciate this. I like that I wasn't talking all the time. Yeah, good stuff. So definitely a lot more to talk to. I definitely suggest that people check out your book, which is Wisdom Factories, AI Games and the Education of a Modern Worker. And we didn't even hardly talk about games and so much other stuff, but this was really good.

Do you want to share a place where people can go to connect with you, Tim? Yeah, the best place to go is timdacey.com. And, you know, there are various options, both for my, about my book. You can learn about, you know, other articles, other podcasts, other newsletters, et cetera, that I put out, and as well as my consulting services. Excellent. That's timdacey.com. And thanks again, Tim, for being part of Transformative Principle in the Summer of AI series.

Thanks, Jethro. Do you want to simplify your school's technology, save teachers' time, improve students' performance on state assessments? You can do it all, but don't waste another minute. Head straight to IXL.com slash BE to learn how IXL's research-proven teaching and learning platform can help you achieve all these goals. That's IXL.com slash BE. When I was a principal at a Title I elementary school, we had Playworks, and it dramatically changed how our school functioned.

Kids show up to school when they want to be there, and that's the whole idea behind Playworks. What they do is they train staff to build belonging and connection right into recess so the kids feel connected and want to come back. They have tons of games that they teach the kids that are fun, enjoyable, and games where either everybody wins or the loss gets you back in the game very quickly.

One principal put it, when the teacher hops in the game and everyone's playing together, that builds camaraderie between students and adults. And the research backs it up. There was a UC Berkeley study that found that Title I schools partnering with Playworks had significantly lower chronic absenteeism. If you're thinking about attendance this year, and we all are, visit Playworks.org slash podcast to get the 30-day attendance reset and additional helpful resources that you can implement today.

Don't wait on this.