A podcast for fundraisers who want ideas, examples and inspiration to help you raise more money for your charity or non-profit.
Rob is an author and award-winning fundraising trainer. Each week he and his guests share examples of successful fundraising, as well as lots of practical tips to help you apply these techniques in your own job.
Hi. It's Rob from Bright Spot, and welcome back to the Fundraising Bright Spots podcast. This time, if you've ever included a number in a funding application or proposal or in a pitch or a conversation with a supporter, and you've wondered if there's a way to bring those numbers to life more persuasively, then this is the episode for you. It's with the brilliant Carla Starr, who is coauthor of the book Making Numbers Count. Enjoy.
Speaker 2:I have to admit, I was never a fan of numbers. I actually did end up learning to love working with them. I just realized it's really just writing. It's really just communication in general. I just look at it as a fun, creative exercise now.
Speaker 2:You know, people feel like they have some sense of, this person really knows what they're talking about because they're using all of these numbers. Right? But we fail to understand that that comes at the cost of the other person truly understanding what we're saying. Because even if you were to say, you know, 11,367,285. And by the time we've reached the end of that number, we often forget exactly how many million was it?
Speaker 2:Whereas if you just said like 11 and a half million, that would immediately paint a picture in someone's mind. The world is large. There are many different things in the world and many different amounts of numbers or ways that we could measure people. So I think that, you know, there's always a way that you could find something that's roughly the same size that will paint such a clear image in people's mind.
Speaker 1:Hi, Carla. Welcome to the podcast.
Speaker 2:Hi, Rob. Thank you so much for having me.
Speaker 1:You're so welcome. This is one of the most exciting interviews I've got to do in six years of doing the Fundraising Bright Spots podcast. Some of my listeners know what a big fan I am of your book, Making Numbers Count. And part of the reason they know that is because I've mentioned it on the podcast before, and certainly my colleague Ben and I have taught some of the principles as best we can on our courses. So I was ever so excited when you agreed to talk to our listeners about the book.
Speaker 1:This is not the first book you've written. You've been a successful journalist and writer for many years. Before we get into this book and some of the ideas that might help the charities that are listening, If you could give us a tiny bit of your background, especially for our British listeners in case they they don't know who you are and and where you come from in terms of these kinds of ideas.
Speaker 2:Yes. Of course. I've been a writer. My background, I went to college and I studied psychology and behavioral science. I've always wanted to be a writer though.
Speaker 2:And so my that's what my background is actually in. And my first book was called Can You Learn to Be Lucky? Why Some People Seem to Win More Often Than Others. I wanted to study with the intersection of people who seem to win, what their psychological traits might be, but then also understand how external, like random events might affect their chances in life or how they see themselves or any of those kinds of things. And so Chip Heath, who wrote Made to Stick and Switch, I was passing out, you know, books before it was published to different authors.
Speaker 2:I liked asking them for blurbs put on the cover. Chip Heath liked mine so much that he emailed me and asked if I wanted to work on some projects with them. And that was obviously quite thrilling when one of your heroes reaches out to you. And so I said yes. And sadly, the our working together coincided with marketing my first book.
Speaker 2:So my first book is still available for sale on Kindle and audiobook for any listeners But we ended up working together on a project and we liked that quite well. And then he suggested this idea of working on a book. So the way this came about was made to stick. You know, it's about storytelling in general and how you can make any kind of story stick. And one of the principles there is to work with concrete items instead of abstract terms.
Speaker 2:And he was teaching this at Stanford Business School and one of his students said, okay, you say don't use numbers, but I'm in finance. My whole world is numbers. Right? I can't possibly get away with that. And so we decided to write this book for anyone who just works primarily with numbers and how they can apply those principles.
Speaker 2:I have to admit, I was never a fan of numbers before that. I just sort of told Chip that I was because I thought that would be great to write the book with him. But I actually did end up learning to love working with them. I just realized it's really just writing. It's really just communication in general.
Speaker 2:And so it really just completely eliminated my fear or my disinterest in writing with them. And so I just look at it as a fun, creative exercise now. And I've been teaching this formula and I've been teaching organizations how to do this for the last four years, and it's actually been really wonderful.
Speaker 1:Yeah. Thank you. Several things you you said that chimed with me, not least the one that that you don't think of yourself naturally as as loving numbers. One of my greatest joys in the last couple of years is teaching some of these ideas on as best I can having repeatedly read your book and having fundraisers get it for the first time and then contact me or my colleague Ben afterwards saying they've translated a number and it's led to increased funding, led to a new corporate partnership also. I I think one reason I've enjoyed those so much is because I maths really wasn't my strength at school.
Speaker 1:It struck me partly on the cover of your book. There's a picture of a ruler, and it says one, two, three, four, five at the beginning of the ruler, and then it just says lots and lots and lots. Yes. And and I had never really thought about this, but it is true, the point you make in the book. If if I'm looking at a a child's counting book, and if there's three ducks on the page, at a glance, I can look at it and know that there's three.
Speaker 1:But if there's six, seven or eight, I think I have to actually count them up unless maybe they happen to be in groups of two, two and three. But at a glance, I'm unlikely to know six, seven or eight, whereas and I I think you say in the book that in most human languages, for most of human history, there's been a number for one, two, three, four and five, but there hasn't been a number for the numbers above that.
Speaker 2:There's this principle called subitizing, and it's what we're able to do with numbers that are below five or below. Mhmm. Because it's you know, we have five digits on each hand. And so it's something we can just automatically understand and we don't have to count. So there's suitizing and then there's counting.
Speaker 2:Mhmm. And so, for example, I don't know if you've you heard of the book Project Hail Mary or
Speaker 1:Oh, yeah.
Speaker 2:That came out.
Speaker 1:My my family love it.
Speaker 2:Oh, I love that movie too. I just think it's so adorable. And so I don't know if you noticed, but I read the book and the creature in the book, he's like a spider made out of rocks. He I believe he has six little like on each claw. And he actually he uses a base six counting system instead of a base 10.
Speaker 2:So his number system is completely different. And it's I thought like that's so, you know, again, goes to show to a great writer Andy wears. But he nailed that too, because they had like five little claws on each arm. They would use a base six counting system because that's just what comes naturally to them. So again, it also shows that, you know, that's just how we perceive the world in terms of concrete items in our environment.
Speaker 2:And so that's what comes naturally to us.
Speaker 1:Yeah, it makes sense. And one of the key interesting things early on in the book that I like is where you say along the lines of, although this is about numbers and bringing them to life, often the best thing to do is, for this very reason, humans aren't fluent in numbers instinctively, often the best thing to do is not use a number at all, if that is possible, and and the reason for that is is partly just because of brain processing power. Right? In terms of short term memory?
Speaker 2:Yes. The short term working memory. And then I think it's a trade off because I was just thinking about this yesterday about the illusion of objectivity. Our brain fundamentally, I think what we dislike the most is uncertainty. Think I that's just the greatest fear because our brains are just constantly trying to predict and constantly trying to find patterns.
Speaker 2:Finding patterns helps us use less energy and it helps us navigate our environment better. So any anything we get towards certainty and knowing exactly what's going to come into the future, it just it feels good. You know, it feels like we have some command over our environment. And so when we hear these precise numbers or we give these precise numbers, we feel like it should put people at ease because we know exactly exactly how much we're dealing with. But we fail to understand that there's a trade off between that sense of certainty, but then actual comprehension.
Speaker 2:For example, all these like economics videos we've been watching lately, you know, people feel like they have some sense of, oh, this person really knows what they're talking about because they're using all of these numbers. Right? So it's also a way for us to kind of prove our expertise or show, oh, we've done our homework. We understand it. But we fail to understand that that comes at the cost of the other person truly understanding what we're saying, because even if you were to say, you know, 11,367,285, you know, it's just again, it's like foreign word, foreign word, foreign word, foreign word.
Speaker 2:And by the time we've reached the end of that number, we often forget exactly how many million was it? You know, whereas if you just said like 11 and a half million, that would immediately paint a picture in someone's mind. And I think painting any sort of picture is better than just nothing. Right? It's just sort of like drawing a a rudimentary cartoon instead of just nothing.
Speaker 1:Mhmm. Yeah. One thing I liked in the book was where you talk about Chip trying out with his some of his MBA students and asking them to try and bring stats to life before teaching him the many principles from the book, and how even these highly intelligent people who were high achievers and would have wanted to do well, broadly, their attempts to bring numbers to life didn't work. If anything, they often became more complicated. And yet both you and Chip have discovered, and I have as well, that with a few simple principles or we could call them rules, actually, lots of this is within reach of of frankly everybody.
Speaker 1:If across our chat, we could just pull out a couple of those principles, two, three, four of them, some of your favorites. One of the ones I've heard you say so far, really, one of the themes was along the lines of even if it's not perfect, just do your best to translate any number that you were going to tell a donor or a trustee or similar.
Speaker 2:Absolutely. I think anytime you can find a translation or something that would work, just put that in terms of real life. I think that makes it stick. It makes it just understandable a little bit more. Like Spider Man just came out here in The States, and it was a huge hit.
Speaker 2:And I just read an article trying to put that number into perspective and how many people saw it. You know, I heard all these dollar amounts, and I thought, oh, that's a lot of money. That's a lot of millions of dollars. But then I saw one that said, you know, for how many tickets sold. It said, just imagine as the entire state of Texas
Speaker 1:Mhmm.
Speaker 2:Last weekend saw the movie. And I think that was the first time I thought that's Texas is very big. Yeah. You know? Yeah.
Speaker 2:Yeah. It's the whole thing. So I I never really thought of it in terms of number of tickets sold, but I thought that was just brilliant because that's such a clear image. But then also, I I like that because I think it kind of pushes back against the idea that you have to trade off clarity for precision. The world is large.
Speaker 2:There are many different things in the world and many different amounts of numbers or ways that we could measure people. So I think that, you know, there's always a way that you could find something that's roughly the same size that will paint such a clear image in people's mind.
Speaker 1:Yeah. And so in your book, you just give examples of several of those sentences, something like, to put that in context or Yes. To give you a sense of how small this is or to give you a sense of how big this is. Just what that really means is that's the easy bit, and then the creativity is doing your best to put yourself in the shoes of your listener, reader, donor, and do something to try and help them get a sense of it. You know, I I do have listeners to this podcast in America and therefore for them, the idea of the Texan population will absolutely zing.
Speaker 1:For UK listeners, I think most of them are aware Texas is a pretty big state, but it just we're all clear that it won't be quite as meaningful to someone in the The UK or, you know, The Bahamas as if one tried to to work out what that would mean for them. One I liked recently, there's a brilliant fundraiser in our Bright Spot membership, and I did a session just a couple of weeks ago about some of your principles, and on this same idea, she works for, not a well known arts organization, but she and her fellow trustees, in fact, I think she's a trustee, she wants funders to take them seriously in terms of the impact they have and their reach, and after sharing, these ideas with her, she, just put in the chat, I realized that instead of saying we reach 200,000 people a year through our arts activities, she's now said we reach as many people as attend Glastonbury every year. And what's interesting is not only is it concrete, but also she's done the extra step to make it arts suitable. So she's, you know, one of our principles we'll probably talk about later is that notion of it doing your best to understand and appreciate the world of those you're talking to.
Speaker 2:Yes. Yes. Absolutely. I think, to go and find and understand exactly, what is meaningful to them. Again, it's, you know, everyone understands numbers and their discipline.
Speaker 2:You know, we can also try to understand people's worlds in terms of, like, you know, what age they are. So what cultural references they might understand. You know, like, my mother understands the Beatles, you know, and I think probably younger kids in The US might not understand as much. But, you know, there's always always some little way that you can maybe try to visualize it or make it meaningful to them. I think it's helpful.
Speaker 2:Yeah.
Speaker 1:One of the other themes you've been sharing is this notion of rather than your utter precision, we're about the 6,500,442 doing it that way, the idea of having the confidence to round things up and that that's okay. But interestingly, it applies not just to all those digits, but it equally applies to fractions fractions or decimals or even percentages.
Speaker 2:Yes. I think use the clearest version of the number, like, whatever that might be possible and, you know, give yourself a grace of a few, say, percentage points, like, roughly two thirds, you know, is just so much clearer than, say, you know, 64.5%.
Speaker 1:Mhmm. Mhmm.
Speaker 2:And I think when people say roughly, they'll, like, they'll understand that that's, you know, within a few grace just because that paints such a clear picture. And I think that people they will understand, especially I think if you say something like roughly or around, you know, I think also, like, these words help a lot in understanding. There's a little bit of a margin for error if you say that. But in general, I think that we're not dealing with these have to be precise units in a lab. You know, it's just what's the goal here?
Speaker 2:And I think that's really fundamentally what people need to understand before they get into any of this work. Right? What's the goal here? The goal fundamentally, especially if you're talking about fundraising or if you're talking about impact, is to paint a clear picture in people's mind. And, you know, being able to discuss terms in real world effects, that's going to do it.
Speaker 2:You know, saying 63.2% is is not going to do it. So I think fundamentally, we have to just make sure we keep our our goals in mind, and it's really about painting a clear picture and communicating the idea.
Speaker 1:I was even interested that that extends to percentages and even seemingly straightforward percentages. Someone who came on one of my courses who worked for a small excellent but relatively small organization that supports women who've been on the receiving end of violence and domestic violence, Initially in her proposal, I think it was something like eighty percent of women who've been exposed to this have have experienced various levels of of trauma for several years after, and forty three percent of them have considered taking their own life, which is shocking and strong stuff. But after hearing a couple of these ideas that we think we understand percentages, but still we can bring it to life more, and then she said instead of eighty percent, she said four out of every five women who have experienced this.
Speaker 2:Mhmm.
Speaker 1:And instead of forty three percent she said two out of every five women have considered taking their own life. I thought it was okay before, but after she said it was clearly better. Because again to your principle, our brain has some sense of what five people are.
Speaker 2:Right. There was a a woman I was working with who was raising funds for a special needs program in Australia. Mhmm. And she was trying to figure out a way to discuss her percentages clearly for the trustees, and the numbers weren't working out exactly where they could be as clear as, you know, say four out of five or two out of five. And so I helped her figure out what percentage point would feel she would feel comfortable riding with.
Speaker 2:And we came to the conclusion that she could work with a whole school bus full of children. Right. As the example. And then so she had a picture of a school bus and she said, okay, now picture this like these are all the students, you know, you would see and then picture. Okay, so these few rows over here, you know, they are they have this learning disability and they need to get help and they're unable to.
Speaker 2:So just seeing the picture of the school bus, you know, seeing it on the slide and then imagining, like, this lot over here, like these few dots, you know, these are the ones who who need help. I think just even something like painting that picture really helps.
Speaker 1:Yeah. And that really is in line with some of the other themes. I mean, you mentioned some of the other books that Chip and Dan Heath have written, and one of the themes there is overcoming the curse of knowledge, and wherever possible, making things more concrete and less less abstract.
Speaker 2:Yes. Yes. Again, because we I can constantly overestimate how how much knowledge we have in whatever field it is or whatever numbers we use frequently, especially people, like architecture, medicine, whatever. And so I think it really helps to, you know, see if you could workshop these things with people who are maybe outside of your field of expertise. You know, when you're paying attention to ads or things that you're like, you know, what sticks out to you?
Speaker 2:What's really clear to you?
Speaker 1:Yeah. Excellent fundraiser called Lizzie liked this idea when she came on our course, and a few weeks later, she emailed me to say that she had had the chance on behalf of a relatively small organization that supports children who get into trouble or or or can can be abandoned near railways, and she had had the chance to apply for a corporate partnership but using only, I think it was a 100 words or very few words, and that was all she got. And she said where normally she would have talked about and I forget the number exactly, but it was something like, we receive 11,000 referrals per year. Based on this principle in your book of overcome bigism, she reduced it down to a smaller unit, and instead of 11,000 referrals, she talked about we help nine children every day. And she put that was in her first sentence, sentence, and she was delighted.
Speaker 1:She won the partnership worth £25,000, and neither she nor I can prove to you that that's the only reason why she won, but she was impressed enough and delighted enough to to reach out and let me know several weeks after the course that she had done it differently, and she felt it clearly helped her chances of of of bringing to life the scale of the problem that they face.
Speaker 2:Yes. That's brilliant. And right. I think, there's nine people and just think about, like, the ripple effects of those nine people. Right?
Speaker 2:So it's not just those people. It's, you know, their families and their communities and how many people that they've influenced. And I think it's it's funny because, you know, you start thinking about, like, you know, 11,000, it is. It's just it's so big. What does it even mean?
Speaker 2:But there's just something about making it clearer and, like, really understanding those nine people and what that looks like. That's actually that's meaningful.
Speaker 1:Yeah. And that's the theme that comes across throughout this book. Yeah. We've we've touched on this this idea of trying to understand their world, and I think in the book, you you call it something like find your fathom. Yes.
Speaker 2:Yes.
Speaker 1:So I don't know if you've got any more examples to give us a sense of of bringing a number to life by tuning into the world you're talking to, or or making more concrete in those terms?
Speaker 2:Yeah. I think, fundamentally, I think any idea of number translation that does the job well, ultimately, it comes down to find your fathom or find the way that it translate best. You know, sometimes that could be time. What does this look like in terms of time? Like, that's a way of finding, like, the the unit of measurement that seems to map well into some sort of concrete experience.
Speaker 2:But there is another example in the book where we talked about wealth inequality and, you know, billionaires versus millionaires. And we use this idea of, you know, imagine every you're walking upstairs and every step is $100,000. If you're a millionaire, you would walk up 10 steps. No. If you're a billionaire and then we calculated roughly, like, how long it would take you to walk up 1,000 steps.
Speaker 2:Mhmm. And then we thought, okay. So if you're, say, Elon Musk, you know, you would have to make walking upstairs your full time job for four months. Mhmm. You know?
Speaker 2:I think that just that is just that's unbelievable because then you get an idea of, you know, what that actually looks like in the real world. And then you can sort of, like, parse it parse it around a little bit and see what happens. Or there's another example of looking at disparities and say leadership for corporations Mhmm. And say there are as many female CEOs as there are, say, CEOs named John. The Fortune 500.
Speaker 2:You you can't be precise and clear at the same time. And I think that's all about finding your fathom or finding the measurement, finding the the real life counterpoint or example that maps on to whatever it is that whatever quantity that is that you wanna express.
Speaker 1:Hi. It's Rob. Just before we get to the final part of the conversation, if you find these podcasts useful, just imagine what's possible when we go deeper with your whole team live together. Like the podcast, our Bright Spot membership and our team training days are packed with practical examples and techniques. But because we're working with you in real time, the shift in confidence and results happens at a completely different level.
Speaker 1:To find out more, head over to brightspotfundraising.co.uk/services. There's a excellent fundraiser I know called Gail who used to work for a charity to do with the theatre and giving children from less advantaged areas the chance to go to the theatre for the first time, often for the first time, or certainly to experience the the magic of the arts and of of theatre, and and she was just kind of brainstorming ways to bring this inequality to life in in the context of a theatre that was well known to the arts people she was presenting to at the time. So if they're in Plymouth, she would do it in the context of all of the Stalls area of the Theatre Royal Plymouth, that represents the children we have helped or, you know, those who've never seen a pantomime. So again, like all great fundraising I think and great communication, it's not having a one size fits all. We'll always use the the stat in these terms.
Speaker 1:It's tuning in who's our audience for this proposal or this pitch. What's their world? Can I understand it and appreciate it? And now I'll get creative as to whether it's a theatre or, you know, the population the size of Texas or whatever. It's it's that caring enough about who you're talking to that you Yes.
Speaker 1:Do an appropriate translation.
Speaker 2:Yes. That's a I think that's a brilliant example because I was just thinking about the theater and the arts, and I was just thinking about, you know, it's all about perspective taking, so really understanding the day to day of, like, the lens through which this person might view something. So thinking in terms of the arts, you know, if you wanted to get across any kind of fundraising, think about the the experience of going to the theater, you know, walking in, like, just opening night, seeing all the people who are working there
Speaker 1:Mhmm.
Speaker 2:Seeing everyone in the theater, and then thinking about the people who are working there or different productions. You know, how large is the cast? How large is the crew? Mhmm. You know?
Speaker 2:So all of these real world concrete examples or concrete quantities, those are also potential fathoms. Right? Like, think about all the people who might see a show over the course of the week. Yeah. You know?
Speaker 2:All the different crew you might see. You know, different numbers of cast for different productions. You know, these are all potential measuring sticks. You know? Like, just imagine if, you know, you had your entire cast and they swapped out every night.
Speaker 2:You know, maybe one of those people, you know, would be the recipient of such and such.
Speaker 1:I've just realized, Carla, actually I've been talking about find your fathom. Remind me, there's a particular reason why find your fathom is the name of that principle, and I realized with my own curse of knowledge I didn't state that. So so where does that come from?
Speaker 2:Yes. So, Find Your Fathom. A fathom originally started as a unit of measurement that was just, steady if you, stretch your arms out, it was, roughly from fingertip to fingertip. And this is now used as a unit of measurement that's about roughly six feet or 1.8 meters for water depth. And now, you know, Fathom just sort of is discusses, like, a complex problem, but, like, I can't fathom it.
Speaker 2:So we just thought that was a clever way to help people understand and let them know that, you know, there is a a unit of measurement out there for you that will help translate or express your idea, your number in a very clear, logical way. So one example is I know that people are notoriously bad at, you know, with small units of measurement, like smaller units of weight. You know, a lot of us don't weigh out our food exactly, you know, unless we're on a very regimented diet or we're a chef or whatever. So people discuss the recommended serving size for meat, for example. It's usually, like, roughly two to three ounces, you know, unless you have a scale, you know, in your kitchen that you religiously use.
Speaker 2:You know, the rule of thumb there is that, you know, your serving size of protein should be roughly equal to a deck of playing cards of meat. And I think that's a good example. That's perfect example because that's something that as everyone sees, you know, they might have in their household. They've come across it several times. And also, it's universal.
Speaker 2:So I think that is one of the problems with fathom, you know, fingertip to fingertip that's ranges obvious in person. People used to say roughly the size of your hand. But if you've ever ever met a child or a very large man, you know that the hand size varies quite a bit, whereas a stack of cards doesn't. One rule of thumb I like to think of is, you know, just think of household items, right? Things you encounter on a day to day basis, you know, instead of things that might be, again, specific to your your world, your area of expertise, your discipline, you know, think something that a carpenter or a CEO might encounter or they have seen in their lifetime.
Speaker 2:And that's a very helpful, helpful one, too. Our brains are fundamentally here to help us navigate the physical world. That's all. So just whatever is right in front of our face, you know, whatever that looks like, help us deal with that.
Speaker 1:Makes absolute sense. That deck of cards one is really good because, again, it's really coming right back to probably the first point you made in our conversation, which is wherever possible, try to make things which are relatively abstract as concrete or tangible as you can for your reader, your listener, your funder, your trustees, whoever it might be that you want to understand and be moved to action by this concept. I've so enjoyed our chat, Carla. I mean, I knew I would because your book has already helped me so much, but it's been a real joy to actually get the chance to discuss these ideas and learn more from you today. If people want to find out more about you, maybe your other things you've written, where would they find your website?
Speaker 2:This absolutely is a K Star. It's kstarr.com. I also have a Substack, the star report. It's carlastar.substack.com. Mhmm.
Speaker 2:So, it's where I write about, all sorts of different things, but hopefully, it'll be interesting to your listeners.
Speaker 1:Yeah. Fabulous. Yes. I am you were kind enough to give me a a sneak peek into some of the ideas you're exploring for your next book, which absolutely chime with lots of important themes for charities and fundraisers, so we look forward to that one. But in the meantime, if people want to get a copy of this Making Numbers Count by Chip, Heath and Carla Starr is on Amazon.
Speaker 1:Right? Yes.
Speaker 2:Absolutely. Buy it on Amazon.
Speaker 1:I've enjoyed it so much. Thank you so much, Carla, and I look forward to catching up with you another time.
Speaker 2:Thank you so much, Rob. It's been a delight.
Speaker 1:Well, I hope you found these ideas helpful. If so, I'd be incredibly grateful if you'd help me spread the word by sharing the episode on both with your colleagues and on LinkedIn. Thank you as always for supporting the show and for listening, and I look forward to sharing another Bright Spots story with you very soon.