Zero Click Marketing

What even is content marketing in the zero-click world? Spoiler: it looks a lot like PR, YouTube, and social media.

Amanda Milligan, who leads YouTube strategy at Semrush, joins me to talk about what she's learned from working across SEO, digital PR, and content marketing. We discuss how/why PR practitioners have always been doing zero click marketing, how to build a smarter B2B YouTube strategy, and why the best-performing content isn't always the cleverest.

Timestamps:

00:00 – Why great PR pitches require audience research (and a lot of work)
06:44 – What makes stories newsworthy? Lessons from earned media
08:34 – The digital PR principles that still work today
12:22 – Why AI is bringing SEO and PR closer together
18:14 – Building Semrush's YouTube strategy
21:51 – YouTube content for search vs. the recommendation algorithm
25:44 – Are creators withholding information to drive engagement?
31:42 – Will human-made content become a premium?

Connect with Amanda Milligan: https://www.linkedin.com/in/amandamilligan/
Check out Semrush: https://www.semrush.com/
Check out Amanda and Semrush on YouTube: https://www.youtube.com/@semrush 

Learn more: zeroclickmarketing.co

Connect with Amanda Natividad (@amandanat): LinkedIn | Substack | Instagram | Threads

This episode was produced in partnership with Share Your Genius
www.shareyourgenius.com
 


What is Zero Click Marketing?

Zero Click Marketing is a marketing strategy podcast about content marketing, audience research, and how brands grow when clicks matter less. Hosted by Amanda Natividad, Chief Evangelist at SparkToro and Co-Author of the book, "Zero Click Marketing," the show explores how marketers reach audiences, build influence, and earn attention in a zero-click internet. New to the show? Start with Episode 2: What Zero Click Marketing Actually Is.

[00:00:00] Amanda Milligan: Spend time on your targeting. Don't just send it to an email form or decide that an, a writer is a good fit just because of the publication they're at. Like, what are they talking about? What specific niche are they covering? How does what you're pitching them on fit into that? Providing that value in the pitch very succinctly, but making sure you're doing all the work for them.
[00:00:23] Amanda Natividad: I'm Amanda Natividad, and welcome to Zero Click Marketing.
[00:00:30] I don't get to talk to a lot of people like us in the sense that like you and I are both content marketers. You have a lot more actual like true SEO experience than I do, but also we've been heads of marketing. So that's what's something I'm really intrigued about with you because I feel like I don't meet a lot of SEOs kind of turned head of marketing, right?
[00:00:54] Or people who have been in those both, both of those kind of roles. So maybe we'll start here I am curious, like when you stepped into your role as head of marketing at Stacker, how did you think about marketing and how did you think about content, especially because of your prior experience?
[00:01:14] Amanda Milligan: That was an interesting role transition for me because it was almost like I was
[00:01:18] The benefit of the work I had done before that was my audience research, because that's who we were trying to reach out to at Stacker were businesses who cared about brand visibility, building authority, and I had worked at agencies like Fractal that were specifically about content marketing to get those types of brand mentions and links.
[00:01:39] So I did have to sort of broaden, okay, I, I know this audience because I had all these clients that were this audience. So that was my quote unquote head start. And in terms of just like marketing it overall, it was, if you so intimately know the audience because you're, you've been working in it for seven years or whatever, knowing the communities I needed to be in to explain what we did at Stacker, knowing how to speak that language.
[00:02:07] You know, we were talking about the nuances between SEO and PR folks, and how much overlap there is, but not really at the same time. Those departments are always very siloed at companies, and it depends on the company. And so it was really fun to get into the nuance of, okay, I understand the value prop we have, but the messaging is going to have to be finely tuned to each subset of particular subcategories of SEO audiences.
[00:02:36] I ended up as head of marketing because at Fractal I was head of marketing at the, the ... My seven-year stint there ended with two years of leading marketing at that agency, which was kind of again like, okay, you know the audience, let's try my hand at broader marketing strategies. And I loved it. I really loved it.
[00:02:56] It was my first time really broadening out the content perspective of what content can do outside of just SEO, right?
[00:03:03] Amanda Natividad: Yeah.
[00:03:04] Amanda Milligan: Instead of just like thinking, oh, it's creating blog posts, ranking in Google, building links, all still important, still great, but I was like, okay, what, what happens in a newsletter?
[00:03:14] What happens on social? What happens in video? What does it look like if we build this report? You know, and, and we're not like pitching. I don't have a whole team of people pitching it out. Like, well, how do we promote it? Who do we partner with? It was just so many other new fun questions that I got to layer on the fact that I knew the audience really well.
[00:03:33] Amanda Natividad: That's really cool. I, I love that. Like, I love that so you started out with this SEO and content expertise kind of helped to broaden your skillset by way of audience research, and then you brought that all with you to Stacker. So I think it's also super interesting how you had that content perspective, and I kinda feel like in any marketing team really, or in any marketing strategy, I feel like there is, at the core or at the foundation of that, is a discipline of marketing.
[00:04:07] Like for instance, probably within Stacker, like at the heart of your marketing strategy, it was content. I think at other companies, right, the heart of their marketing strategy might have been like paid social or might still be.
[00:04:22] Amanda Milligan: Yeah.
[00:04:22] Amanda Natividad: Right? Like every company's different, right? Every strategy is different.
[00:04:24] For sure. Is that how you saw your role there, or your- You know- ... or the marketing strategy?
[00:04:29] Amanda Milligan: Honestly, no. I didn't, I didn't think of it as like being foundationally content. Because of the stage of growth, I think that's really what was the factor. It was like they were so ... They had very little awareness when I joined.
[00:04:45] And so a lot of it was like these paid newsletter partnerships, and just literally getting the name out there, and me speaking at conferences to talk about what we even did and share our research, and stuff that I was doing to market the, uh, Fractal, the agency, which was like, we have a ... Stacker, I, you know, I haven't been there in a few years, so take everything I'm saying with a grain of salt, but they distribute stories across a newswire.
[00:05:11] And so we had the data of who was picking up what, which was fascinating in terms of getting immediate results of what topics are performing well. Like, what do people actually wanna see? Which is relevant to almost anybody across different industries. Like, "Hey, this is performing. Go out there and cover the same thing."
[00:05:29] And so I would talk at conferences about that kind of stuff. So it was, at first it was more like, okay, we wanna invest in more content, and we did put out like that, those kinds of reports that I think were really interesting. We did co-branded stuff with other relevant companies. But at, at first it was a lot of paid activations to just get that baseline visibility, and then we layered on authority after that.
[00:05:54] But, you know, we're content people, so I'm al- I always have that in my mind of what is gonna be that next step if we do get that. And I felt we did. I felt we had gotten that traction that people thought of Stacker as like, "Oh, they do earned media. I understand the connection now." And then it became, how do we prove that this is going to be the solution versus, you know, A, B, C, and D, and that requires more.
[00:06:22] It requires more than a paid newsletter placement. It requires showing, like, the case studies, showing the SEOs on our team doing a deep dive into how the technical side of it works with canonicals and everything. Like, there was content that certainly got layered on. Yeah. So it was a mix. It was a mi- That was a long long-winded answer to your question.
[00:06:44] Amanda Natividad: No, I like it. Uh, one last question here, and then we'll move on. You said it a while back about looking at the kinds of different, the different stories that would get picked up. Understanding this was a couple years, this, this was some time ago, right? And it might not, might not be true there today. Tell, tell us more about that.
[00:07:02] Like, what were some of the stories that were most popular? Who picked those up? Like, what were some of the surprises or trends back then?
[00:07:08] Amanda Milligan: Maybe I can send, and you can link to this. It was a SearchLove presentation, and I had spoken to our ... And she's still there. She heads up the, like, MSN distribution side of seeing how you can change your headlines to get better pickups.
[00:07:27] So it was like there were two layers. There was topical, but then there was as detailed as the title, right? And that's a, an age-old thing of your title, your intro, all these things have to be captivating. But some of the things are obvious, like ... Well, maybe not. I don't know, because not everybody does them.
[00:07:47] But in the headlines it would be like if you use specific numbers, the curiosity gap that we talk about in email subject lines also working in article headlines, right? Localizing always killed. If you could take a story that had national data, and the national outlets would pick it up, but then you can break it down by every city ZIP Code, all of the nat- the, the local publishers would pick up the same information.
[00:08:15] You were doing significantly less work and getting 10 times as many pickups. I honestly think a lot of these principles are still very similar. I really do. There are things that we talked about, about link building 10 years ago that are still true if you were doing link building a certain way 10 years ago
[00:08:33] Amanda Natividad: Oh, interesting.
[00:08:34] Well, what's still true?
[00:08:36] Amanda Milligan: Well, 'cause we were doing digital PR back then. And so those tenets are still 90% the same, right? It's like spend time on your targeting. Don't just send it to an email form or decide that an, a writer is a good fit just because of the publication they're at. Like, what are they talking about?
[00:08:57] What specific niche are they covering? How does what you're pitching them on fit into that? Providing that value in the pitch very succinctly, but making sure you're doing all the work for them. Like, don't g- like, oh, even, don't even have them click on anything if you can avoid it. Give them, like, the, the top insights, and then you can add, like, an image or a link so that they can look at it.
[00:09:19] But there, there's so many of these things I hear still because they're still true. It's just that not everybody was doing them because it's a lot of work. It's so much work.
[00:09:30] Amanda Natividad: It requires a lot of audience research and also just giving a sh*t.
[00:09:34] Amanda Milligan: So much. Yeah, it's so much work. Like, I hate doing it. Like, I won't f- f*cking sugarcoat it, I hate it.
[00:09:41] And so I understand why people hire other people to do it because it's the finesse of, like, how do you create the content in the first place that you think stands a chance of someone referencing? Let alone sitting there building a pitch list, looking up all the writers, understanding who they are, personalizing those emails, pitching the content appropriately, following up with all of that.
[00:10:05] I mean, it is-
[00:10:06] Amanda Natividad: It's a lot of work.
[00:10:07] Amanda Milligan: It's a lot.
[00:10:08] Amanda Natividad: I just had, like, screaming flashbacks of when I was doing PR, and PR and link building are not the same thing. However, there are some similar inroads, right? To your point about, like, it's not just pitching the publication because you wanna be in the publication.
[00:10:27] You have to make sure you're pitching to the right writer because they cover your specific niche or that topic, right? Like, it's- Mm ... making it extremely relevant to the person you're pitching to 'cause ultimately you're not just pitching to an entity, you're pitching to a person, too.
[00:10:42] Amanda Milligan: Yeah.
[00:10:43] Amanda Natividad: Both PR and link building, like, have to recognize for that, or have to reckon with that, right?
[00:10:48] Amanda Milligan: Yeah.
[00:10:48] Amanda Natividad: And so the first time I was doing PR, I was doing it very, very tactically, like doing a lot of the outreach. So I was kind of using some of the, some of the principles of doing good link building, right? But mostly it was doing a lot of research. And to your point, it was You know, it's, it was like how did I do it?
[00:11:09] I, I looked at the publications that were relevant. I went to their websites. I read the news. I looked at the masthead, like who are the writers of this publication? I read all their work, and then sought to understand, well, how is everyone's work different from each other's? Mm. And then pitched accordingly.
[00:11:28] And I think, you know, 90% of people won't even do that.
[00:11:32] Amanda Milligan: Oh,
[00:11:33] Amanda Natividad: yeah.
[00:11:33] Amanda Milligan: Right? Yeah.
[00:11:34] Amanda Natividad: Right? Nobody's gonna do that, because that's not fun. That's a lot of work.
[00:11:38] Amanda Milligan: Right. And you, and then you have to sit and wait to see if it just went into the void or if you're ever... Like, that anxiety of waiting for the response after you do so much work.
[00:11:48] I mean, at least- Yeah ... content, you have something, right? Like Yeah. Like, I created something.
[00:11:53] Amanda Natividad: Yeah.
[00:11:53] Amanda Milligan: A pitch, you're just like, "Oh, God." Like, I'm gonna-
[00:11:55] Amanda Natividad: You're just like, "Please talk to me."
[00:11:57] Amanda Milligan: Yeah.
[00:11:57] Amanda Natividad: Or my boss or
[00:11:58] Amanda Milligan: whatever. Truly. Truly. It's funny 'cause now I have to add an asterisk to when I said digital PR earlier, because I know that that's kind of being, like, moved away from.
[00:12:07] Mm. And, and that both of these industries, digital PR. That's what... Digital PR basically being the intersection really. That's how we referred to it back then. I don't even know how everyone's talking about it. I've seen different things.
[00:12:20] Amanda Natividad: Yeah, I don't know. I don't know.
[00:12:22] Amanda Milligan: But how, what are you thinking, like with your PR background, about where we are right now?
[00:12:26] Because honestly, I thought that this convergence would happen faster than it has. Yeah. Where AI answers showing that so many media mentions are influencing responses, I was like, "Oh, surely..." And it is moving that way. Don't get me wrong. Where marketing teams are like, "Okay, we can't just say like this is the SEO team, this is the PR team, and they're just never gonna talk."
[00:12:50] Are you seeing anything in terms of like how that's evolving? 'Cause I am seeing it, but it's not as quick as I thought, and I'm not hearing as much conversation, like pulling in PR folks into these topics.
[00:13:02] Amanda Natividad: Yeah. No, that's a super interesting question. I think about, though, like you're right, I, we are seeing this convergence.
[00:13:10] I don't know if I thought it would happen sooner, but I do think it's really interesting that I'm seeing more people in SEO and GEO, right, more, more of these sort of optimization people, right, talking about mentions. Mm. Yeah. Like brand mentions, ghost citations, which is basically like your work being cited even if you yourself are not being cited.
[00:13:36] I'm seeing that a lot, which whenever I hear mention, I think, "Oh, that's PR. That's a brand marketing, overall brand marketing under that PR thing." I think where we're at today- Makes me really excited for the PR practitioner.
[00:13:53] Amanda Milligan: For sure. Like,
[00:13:54] Amanda Natividad: you know, I mean, I, I think about AI in a lot of different ways. Like, there's environmental impact, there's the, the ethical stuff, like what should we be doing as marketing leaders?
[00:14:04] But I also think about, well, what does all this mean for the person who is boots on the ground doing the actual work day to day? And I think it's an exciting time for PR practitioners because I'm old enough to remember when we used to track KPIs with, like, impressions, brand mentions. Like-
[00:14:24] Amanda Milligan: Yeah ...
[00:14:24] Amanda Natividad: you know, we saw 100,000 impressions on this thing, and having CEOs, right, be like, "What does that even mean?"
[00:14:32] But now that's kind of all we have to go off of now.
[00:14:37] Amanda Milligan: I know.
[00:14:37] Amanda Natividad: And so now it has to be- A full
[00:14:39] Amanda Milligan: circle.
[00:14:39] Amanda Natividad: Yeah. It has to be kind of trusted, or even just like, "Oh, we're getting more AI visibility as a result of PR." Where, like, I think what makes me excited is at least now PRs can say that, and I think because AI is the hot new thing-
[00:14:54] Amanda Milligan: Yes
[00:14:54] Amanda Natividad: that everyone's drinking the Kool-Aid over, it's also like, well, I'm glad for PR that they can now say things like, "Hey, we've increased AI visibility by X percent." Granted We don't know how that fits into our bottom line, if that's tied to revenue growth. But at least PR people can say like, "Well, I'm doing my job," because you know that the, that the mentions, that the visibility are increasing.
[00:15:20] So I'm doing my part. And I like that for them.
[00:15:24] Amanda Milligan: I agree completely. I, I felt like there was this moment of validation for a lot of the PR folks who were like, "We've been saying this forever, that this kind of stuff matters," but we couldn't put numbers on it, and so it was deprioritized. And that's what links kind of became this, like, de facto way of making sure it had value for some, for some people, like, especially, like, more SEO inclined businesses.
[00:15:51] But it has mo- like receded back into this, "Oh, because of the way that LLMs work, we now remember the importance of visibility, of literally just being in the conversation in the first place, and how critically bad it is if you are not." Like, if you just do not invest in those things, and suddenly you're just not participating in any of the, you know, discourse in your industry.
[00:16:18] So yes, I completely agree. I was very ... That was the one big shining thing for me last year during all the chaos. I was like, "Wow, this is really what we've been saying for a long time about authority, is you can't always measure it perfectly, but it's so fundamental anyway." And now at least AI is kind of getting people on board with that and feeling- Yeah
[00:16:42] a little more comfortable.
[00:16:43] Amanda Natividad: Where I think PR can kind of be this unsung hero in a marketing business is, well, one, when it's really good PR, right? Like, everyone knows, like, it's easy to be a really bad PR person. It's real- it's really easy to be bad at any job. But I just mean to be a really good PR executive or leader, it's, oh, that is a really special skill set.
[00:17:07] Like, whatever they're doing, they have somehow mastered compelling messaging to all kinds of audiences. They've figured out how to distill business strategy into a journalist facing way, in a way that they get other people to care. I think that alone is an incredibly hard skill set to hone, and does not get enough, like credit.
[00:17:29] Like that doesn't get enough flowers for what that, what that job really is. And so I like seeing, you know, this PR side being vindicated over, "Yeah, we've been saying this for years."
[00:17:40] Amanda Milligan: It's so funny 'cause I'm never, I am not a PR person. Like that's not- Yeah ... my specialty. I've never had my full-time job be pitching, and yet I feel so protective.
[00:17:50] I've, like, worked alongside these folks for years. And I, yeah, I really feel it's so integral to marketing and has been overlooked. And so it is nice for them to get their flowers and, you know, see how it can Hopefully propel us in the right direction in terms of the way that we're thinking about metrics and results and all the buzzwords, ROI, whatever else you want to say.
[00:18:14] Amanda Natividad: Totally. Okay, let's, let's talk about ... Can we talk about your work at Semrush now?
[00:18:19] Amanda Milligan: Sure.
[00:18:20] Amanda Natividad: Yeah. Yeah, 'cause I think, I think it's really, I think your ... I don't know. Your job seems really fun. You get to really- It
[00:18:25] Amanda Milligan: is fun. I won't lie. It's fun. Yeah.
[00:18:27] Amanda Natividad: You get to geek out about content all the time in all kind of different ways that you would want to.
[00:18:33] I think is, I think my question is just tell me, tell me about some of the things that are really exciting in your day-to-day role now.
[00:18:41] Amanda Milligan: Well, fundamentally it's the fact that I have not specialized in video before this, and right now I'm leading the video strategy for the Semrush YouTube channel. And while the principles of content stay the same, right, you know, create what your audience wants to consume, that value add, there's still the format of it all and the channel of it all.
[00:19:04] And I'm still grappling with in what cases does somebody want a video versus a blog post, how do they want it in that video. You know, we have in our content calendar it's like, okay, this is the really tactical how-to version of this. Here's the heady theoretical thought leadership side of it. You could take the one topic and do several different angles with it, which we do in written content already, but what do people want in v- video content?
[00:19:30] What's already out there that other SEO companies are doing, and where can we fit in differently? Like, what can we provide that's not already circulating on YouTube with these channels that have been around for years? I mean, some folks have been doing this for many years now. So it's just been, like, cool.
[00:19:49] I get to play, like you said, I get to think about content all day, and in a space that I'm not intimately familiar with. I learned a lot in a couple months about YouTube's algorithm, all the nuances of every metric and how it impacts the way that YouTube recommends your video. I mean, fascinating stuff.
[00:20:09] And being able to test as well. Like, we are in an environment where we can do these experiments, do completely different formats, have different folks on, see how it goes, and use that information to inform what we create later, which are things that we should do period, right?
[00:20:28] Amanda Natividad: Right. That's just good strategy.
[00:20:30] If you could give somebody three cheat codes to YouTube, right, like, what would you tell them?
[00:20:37] Amanda Milligan: Well, I think the number one thing is the actual positioning. It's like the idea and the positioning. I'm working with Dan Shure on this. He, he's a, an SEO consultant who's done YouTube. And when he came in, he was like The positioning and the idea, just like we were talking about with link building, the idea is what's gonna make or break the channel.
[00:21:02] And it really ... We had to spend a lot of time on ideation. And it ... So it's hard sometimes if you're starting in YouTube, I would say, it's difficult to look at other channels and be like, "I'll do what they're doing." A lot of them have been doing it for so long that they've kind of like grandfathered themselves in to having that audience, and YouTube, no matter what they're doing, will still promote their content more than other people's.
[00:21:28] So the newer folks have to think about things very differently. And so that's like the first cheat code would be like, yeah, see what's going on, like what the outliers are with your competitors, but don't do what they're doing. And that's why we're experimenting with formats. We have some of like the tried and true formats, but we're experimenting with formats because YouTube as a platform has changed a lot.
[00:21:51] Just the way that people are ... The kind of content they're consuming, it's like such a TV channel now. Like people are using it, it's like the number one TV network, quote-unquote, in the world or US. I gotta check that. And the second thing I would say is just, again, just like any content strategy, have a very specific goal for each video.
[00:22:16] We have two separate categories of videos. We have the ones that are directed toward the algorithm and the ones that are directed towards search. Because now, with so many videos being in AI overviews and in Google video packs and being used as citations and ChatGPT answers, video has become a huge, huge asset for driving search visibility across the different, you know, methods.
[00:22:43] But those are very different targets. We do have some videos that do both, don't get me wrong, but there are times where we have to be like, what is the search that somebody's doing, and what is the video that they are specifically trying to find? And creating that video might not be what the algorithm pushes out as much as like something that is a little more in the weeds or something that is kind of like the, the, the talking head that people are used to on YouTube or
[00:23:12] You know, like there are nuances to the way that you would deliver that content. So have a specific target for every video that you're creating. Who specifically are you talking to? And make sure that's very clear in the title and thumbnail, that somebody knows that, oh, this is for me. It's not always super clear.
[00:23:34] Like, that is a trap we've fallen into. We're like, well, obviously, right? Like- Yeah ... people who are with Semrush, they know who we're talking to. But even within that, there are so many different We've seen it with Claude. People have a wide range of experience with Claude, right? It's always talked about, but people have a wide range of experience with it.
[00:23:52] So, you know, there's little, little nuances there. And I guess third would be that first 30-second engagement rate. Is, is a behemoth. It's so much of how YouTube decides if you're going to elevate past the small groups of people you're getting promoted to. And so really spending a lot of time on your hook, a lot of time on promising what you're gonna deliver on, and also giving somebody something to look forward to at the end of the video, 'cause average view duration also matters a lot.
[00:24:26] Amanda Natividad: Yeah.
[00:24:26] Amanda Milligan: Those are interesting blog posts. We, we almost accepted that people are gonna skim around. But with video, you're not gonna have as much, much success if you're just relying ... Unless you're doing it for search and the chapters or, you know, and all that's fine for search if they're gonna take a snippet.
[00:24:42] But in the algorithm, you need people to stick around. You need to build an audience, truly build an audience.
[00:24:47] Amanda Natividad: Yeah. I think it's interesting. I mean, like, I don't watch a lot of We'll just say work-related content on YouTube. I watch some of it, but not a lot. I would just say that most of my YouTube consumption as of late has been just personal hobby focused.
[00:25:04] Amanda Milligan: Yeah.
[00:25:04] Amanda Natividad: So which is to say a lot of the YouTube videos I'm watching lately are Pokémon Pokopia videos. I,
[00:25:12] Amanda Milligan: I'm so jealous. I need to... I wanna play that so bad, but I don't have the updated Switch.
[00:25:17] Amanda Natividad: You have to get it. The newer one. It's so fun. Is it? I, but I lost so many hours to this game, but it is so... It's such a...
[00:25:24] What I've been doing is, one, instead of doom scrolling, I play Pokopia.
[00:25:29] Amanda Milligan: I
[00:25:29] Amanda Natividad: think that's a great substitute. Which also, which means I might be reading less, but my reading's a lot more intentional. 'Cause then I'm like, "Oh, I really wanna get to speed, like what's going on in the industry today?" So I read people's blog posts and their research reports 'cause I'm like, "Oh, I wanna learn stuff now."
[00:25:43] Amanda Milligan: Right.
[00:25:44] Amanda Natividad: The marketing brain never really stops, right? We're always still, like, looking for patterns and looking for things in the background. And so what I, what I try to notice, or what I notice now in some of these videos is, like, when somebody seems to make a mistake, I wonder, like, was that a mistake? I don't think it was.
[00:26:04] Like, for instance, um, Poco- in Pokopia, you're, you're... It- You could think of it as kind of like Minecraft for Po- for Pokémon. So you're building little worlds, you're building houses or whatever you want. And sometimes YouTubers will include the materials. Like I use, you know, 99 blocks of concrete for this thing, right?
[00:26:25] And they show their ingredi- their, like, ingredient list. Not everyone does that. And so when they, when they don't, I have a feeling it's on purpose. Because they want people to watch the whole video and try to figure it out themselves. 'Cause in the comments, we'll be like, "Why didn't you include the ingredients this time?"
[00:26:44] Or like, "What, let us know, like, what to include in the build," or like, "Can you give us a list?" And I'm thinking it's
[00:26:49] Amanda Milligan: like- And the comments are huge for engagement signals.
[00:26:52] Amanda Natividad: Exactly. It's like, yeah. Right. Huge for engagement. But if they just put it there to begin with, it's tough, right? Because that would make it a more useful and complete video, but it might sacrifice the engagement.
[00:27:04] So I'm, my guess is, like, they pro- like these creators, it's probably some mix of on purpose. Sometimes they include it, sometimes they don't. Maybe they would like to- It's also really hard to create content, right? It's really hard to create these videos. So I imagine part of it is just I didn't have time or I'm burnt out and like I'm, I can't do everything.
[00:27:28] I imagine it's some kind of mix, but at some point I do think it's intentional where they're like, "I'll get more engagement if people keep asking for the list of ingredients."
[00:27:37] Amanda Milligan: I would not be surprised. I would not at all be surprised. 'Cause it's, I mean, it's a brutal algorithm. Mm-hmm. You could spend a ton of time on something and just watch it languish for whatever reason.
[00:27:47] And as anybody who's created content knows, that's, that is a tough thing to face, and a video is a really tough thing to create. It just is. I do think the other thing I thought you were, you were getting at, which you said is great, was like people making intentional mistakes to sound more human. Oh, interesting.
[00:28:06] Like to leave a blooper in- Yeah ... or to like, you know, when my cat jumps into the screen or, you know, jumps into the area because of this perception of video being more real, especially in this AI era of people not trusting written content as much. As, you know what I mean, deepfakes are out there, so who knows how long this will last.
[00:28:26] But I do think that there's this sort of middle ground on YouTube of you wanna look like you are polished, but you don't wanna look too polished. You, you wanna- Mm-hmm ... be like, "I'm a human being talking to you."
[00:28:39] Amanda Natividad: That's true. Are you seeing more of that? Like, more people Or are you yourself doing that?
[00:28:45] Amanda Milligan: Well, we're seeing it and we're testing it.
[00:28:47] And little things. Like, we're testing in our thumbnails, because we're seeing this, having the person's background in the thumbnail. Like, rather than it all being just kind of design with the, with the person, it's, like, their actual background. Like, that seems to be doing kind of well. Oh,
[00:29:01] Amanda Natividad: interesting.
[00:29:02] Amanda Milligan: Yeah, that's what I mean.
[00:29:03] It's like these tiny little things that we're testing because YouTube's preferences seem to change pretty swiftly. And r- I do think it makes sense. You can't be too casual. It can't be, like, too far down. There was that era during COVID where it was like you could just be live streaming in your bathroom and it would be okay.
[00:29:21] But it's not like that. But it's like, it doesn't have to be ... It still has to be well edited. I think that's the difference. The, the editing still has to be good, but you can kind of have a more casual tone. You can kind of allow those bloopers to stay, like, have your personality in it, and I think it's because, especially the way that YouTube functions, they like people.
[00:29:42] The reason people subscribe to channels is 'cause they like the people. Yeah. They also like the topic. But my husband is a YouTube Premium member, and he got me into watching YouTube all the time. It is most of what we watch on TV now.
[00:29:53] Amanda Natividad: Mm.
[00:29:54] Amanda Milligan: And we follow creators.
[00:29:56] Amanda Natividad: Yeah.
[00:29:56] Amanda Milligan: And I watch some of the stuff he watches.
[00:29:57] I'm like, "I don't even care about this. Like, what are we talking about?" But I like this guy. He's funny. I like the way that he presents the information. Like- Yeah ... I can sit there and get into it, and I find myself looking him up when he's out of town, you know? So-
[00:30:08] Amanda Natividad: Yeah ...
[00:30:09] Amanda Milligan: it is that balance. And for me and our team in B2B, B2B YouTube is different from B2C in that I don't think B2B overall has, like, really nailed that balance.
[00:30:23] Because there's just less audience to test it on than, like, a B2C channel. I don't know if that makes sense, but like-
[00:30:29] Amanda Natividad: No, I think that makes sense. I think that it m- might be the appetite's a little bit smaller or there's, or less demand, we'll say. I still think that the, at the moment, at least, like on the B2B side, the things that are winning are still more of the like, "Dude, bro," like, "Yeah, I grew this million-dollar business in like six hours," that kind of thing.
[00:30:50] Yeah. Yeah. Because like that's the kind of B2B audience that would probably be on YouTube looking to learn, yeah, but also are like, "I need the answer right now."
[00:30:59] Amanda Milligan: So we almost have to trust that it is why we're investing in this because it does feel like people are turning to video more. Yeah. And even if it's not what's done, can we hopefully be there to help people realize, like there's other types of content here, and you could be at different expertise levels and you can see different people on video who aren't the typical folks you see, you know, or whatever, and learn in a way that maybe, like you said, maybe it is these preconceived notions about what is on YouTube.
[00:31:29] I mean, it's a good point. But I do think it's being so embedded in so many other things that it'll just continue to increase in popularity in B- on the B2B side. So it'll be, that's what, but we're just testing nonstop. Yeah,
[00:31:42] Amanda Natividad: that's interesting. You know, I was thinking about what you said about like making, adding mistakes or making mistakes and looking more human.
[00:31:50] I was not trying to bring it back to Pokopia here. But I did write a blog post recent, like just the other day on, it was called like What Pokémon Pokopia Taught Me About the Future of Marketing. Love it. And it was this very like kind of kooky love letter to Pokopia that I wrote, but also just in light of here's where I think we are at in marketing and creation.
[00:32:14] And anyway, I'm writing this post and a lot of it I was like, "I'm gonna make this like pretty stream of consciousness because I really want this to be"... 'Cause I mean, a lot, the, the thesis statement essentially is I think we're gonna see more people really put more value on human-made as a premium.
[00:32:32] Amanda Milligan: Yeah.
[00:32:32] Amanda Natividad: You know, and I think people are gonna be willing to pay for that. Or pay doesn't have to be money, right? Pay with attention, pay by way of their email, like putting it, filling in the form, right? So pay is loosely defined here, but people, I think we're gonna see more people pay for that, and I think the people who will win are the people who are actually doing it, like doing the human-made thing.
[00:32:55] And so because of that, I really wanted to make sure that the humanness shined through in that essay, so I had kind of stream of consciousness, like inserted kind of random thought, not random thoughts. Well, random to others, not to me, but like the things that you think while you're writing, I, I left those in.
[00:33:15] I think- I found a typo right before I published, and I can't remember now if I fixed it or not because I did think "Well, if I leave it, people will, will truly, truly know this came from me." I'm like, "But I also caught the typo, so should I fix it?" I know.
[00:33:32] Amanda Milligan: It i- isn't it so weird to be like, do I need to be intentionally slightly, like, less good at grammar
[00:33:40] Amanda Natividad: just to
[00:33:41] Amanda Milligan: prove- Yeah
[00:33:41] Amanda Natividad: I'm a human being? It's... I love m- em dashes. I use them all the time. That's why ChatGPT loves them, because people use them, you know? Like-
[00:33:48] Amanda Milligan: Yeah. But yeah, for video, or, and probably all content, tell me what you think about this. It's been, authority has been huge. Now authenticity is just as huge, and going to get more and more important in the, like, to your point of human-made content.
[00:34:04] And that's what's been interesting. For each person we have on the channel, it's like, okay, there's a level of, we have to make sure the engagement's there, so there is, like, a very specific strategy we have for intros and titles and thumbnails. And yet, how do we make sure this video feels authentic to them?
[00:34:22] Because every person has a very different style on camera. Very different. I'm very just like, "I'm gonna ramble at you. I am fully ready to make a fool out of myself. I can just, like, be on camera and talk." Other people are very tactical, and they convey, like, this calm, I-know-what-I'm-doing presence, and sit here and watch me complete this task.
[00:34:45] And, and they're just very different tones, and that's what's so interesting to me, that that's the creative side of it that I love so much. Of, okay, yeah, we need to make sure this is engaging, we need to make sure people click on it, and also we need to make sure that when they do, they're sticking around because they believe the person on the screen is doing this the way that they would do it, and feels something about the content they're talking about, right?
[00:35:09] And it is a unique medium for that. And, and just like you're saying how you're kind of trying to do that in, in text form, this is just gonna be more and more important. I agree with you. I think- Mm ... how are you gonna maintain authenticity and make it clear? That's the weird part.
[00:35:27] Amanda Natividad: Yeah. That's the- Yeah, how do you not make it look so contrived if you are- Yeah
[00:35:32] really trying to be authentic? Like, if it... Yeah, I don't know. Okay, one last question and I'll let you go. What i- what is one of the top performing videos right now on the Semrush channel, and why do you think that is?
[00:35:44] Amanda Milligan: Well, one of the ones, we have Brian Dean has been on our channel because he founded Backlinko and Exploding Topics, both acquired by Semrush.
[00:35:54] And we were like, Brian used to be killer on YouTube. He brought his channel back recently, and so we've had him on the channel, and one of his best performing videos had the most straightforward title of all of them. And he's done, like, a dozen videos. But the one that popped off the most was literally titled How I Structure Content So AI Actually Cites It.
[00:36:14] It is not jazzy. It is not like, there's no surprise there. And we were, me included, big time me, getting a little too fun with titles sometimes and being like, "Ugh." And the straightforward this is what I'm gonna show you and this is why it matters titles, you gotta deliver on that too.
[00:36:38] Amanda Natividad: Yeah, yeah. He actually does show you.
[00:36:41] Amanda Milligan: And then it's just a video of us, you know, just doing a hoedown. But, you know, that was a big less- like a, it was something that we, like, knew, but to see it at that level, be like, "Wow, okay. It was a very specific problem that people have And this promised a solution to that problem.
[00:37:01] Amanda Natividad: Yeah. I mean, you can't get any better than that, right?
[00:37:04] That is a tried and true, like, whatever marketing best practice behind that, right? Being straightforward, saying what it is, and then delivering the thing, that is what marketing is supposed to be. Yeah. That's what it is. It's- Yeah ... and it, like, it matches how people are searching for it, right? You can imagine everyone searching how to structure content.
[00:37:24] Amanda Milligan: Right.
[00:37:25] Amanda Natividad: Yeah. Right, like how else would you type that?
[00:37:27] Amanda Milligan: And this is one of those ones that did well on both. It did well on the algorithm, and it did well in search. And I think it's because of exactly what you're saying. Like, it appealed to people on YouTube 'cause they're like, "Oh, yeah, I had that specific problem.
[00:37:41] You know, let me click on this." And it's also the way that people are, are typing in the search. Which is, it's not always gonna be perfect like that, but if you can, if you can fit it into-
[00:37:49] Amanda Natividad: Yeah ...
[00:37:50] Amanda Milligan: eight words, definitely try it. At least, you know, do an AB test and see what works well. But don't get too, don't get too cutesy like I...
[00:38:00] Amanda Natividad: Okay. Well, I'll let you go because I need to go so I can go watch this video. Um. So I'll, I'll, I'll drop the link in, in the show notes. But Amanda, where should, where should people go to learn more about you or your work?
[00:38:14] Amanda Milligan: I'm chronically on LinkedIn. I will happily answer any questions folks have. But otherwise, come check out the Semrush YouTube channel.
[00:38:21] Subscribe there. I actually do videos on there too, so if you really want a, a laugh at the way that I present, but hopefully it's meaningful and valuable. But there's some really fantastic folks on the channel, including this Amanda.
[00:38:33] Amanda Natividad: Oh, yeah. Um- Oh, you know what? I embedded that, the video that we did together, I embedded it in my Pokopia blog post.
[00:38:41]
[00:38:41] Amanda Milligan: I gotta
[00:38:42] Amanda Natividad: go do that. I for- I forgot about that. I just remembered it right now. I'm like, wait, the thing we collaborated on that I was talking about earlier, it's there. Ugh, I'm a mess.
[00:38:52] Amanda Milligan: Please. Lots of amazing people on the channel. And we are, like I said, continuously testing out different formats and really care about what people want to see.
[00:39:00] So, A, subscribe, but B, tell me what you wanna see. You're ... I, I can make it happen. So if you're just sitting there like, "I don't know, I really want a YouTube series about blank," let me know. We would love to create it.
[00:39:13] Amanda Natividad: Well, I'm requesting now that you buy the Switch 2- ... get Pokopia, and then start doing some livestreams where you talk about content while you build stuff.
[00:39:24] Amanda Milligan: With my audience of of
[00:39:27] Amanda Natividad: one?
[00:39:27] Amanda Milligan: One. I'll do it. It's just- I'll do
[00:39:30] Amanda Natividad: it ... it's just me. I love it. It's really just me. Thank you for listening or watching Zero Click Marketing. We'll see you next week.