The Honest Money Show is your guide to understanding what money really is, and where Bitcoin fits in. Hosted by Anja Dragovic, Australia's female-led, Bitcoin-only podcast, it cuts through the noise to explore how money shapes our lives, why the current system leaves so many people behind, and what a clearer, fairer future could look like.
Expect honest, accessible conversations with some of the most interesting thinkers in the space, the kind that take you from "I don't really get this" to genuinely curious. No hype, no pressure, just money, made clear.
Whether you're brand new to these questions or already deep in them, you're welcome here.
Guys, if you told me this stuff in 2018,
I would have laughed at you.
No way. Couldn’t happen.
The pet rock has a ten year forecast now.
Now it is a serious,
it is a serious and normal asset.
So boring, so dull, so gray,
and yet so goddamn bullish.
Welcome back to another episode
of Honest Money.
Joining me back on the show today is James
also lovingly known as CheckMatey.
James is an analyst from
CheckOnChain for those who
somehow don't know him yet and I'm very
happy to have him back on the show.
Welcome back.
Thanks Anja. It's really good to be here.
Okay so let's start with the current
market psychology
Obviously I've been in Bitcoin for a very
short time and this is my first
bear market and it's been an interesting
experience to say the least.
So I think that's
a really good place to start.
How for you because like I've been
through one, two, three, now four.
This is my fourth bear market and I do
consider in that for those who are
counting and know I
consider 2019 to be like a second bear
market after the first one which is 2018.
I bought the 2017 top
that's the first time I got in.
I'm curious having this been your first
bear market. So first of all
is this your first bear market full stop
of any asset and just tell me about
your experience.
What was your like?
What was it like and what were the things
that like your take-home lessons
from having gone through what is a pretty
brutal thing?
Yeah that's a really good question.
So it is
my first bear market across any asset
like prior to investing in Bitcoin I
invested into S&P 500
and I didn't really experience the
drawbacks that I guess there have been
some like you know 30%
drawbacks in S&P from memory like not
obviously not as big as not as big as
Bitcoin but there have
been some and I haven't actually
experienced them.
So coming into this I was expecting that
it was going
to happen sooner or later.
I didn't quite think that we were going
to go back down when we did. I thought
we were going to keep rising in November
and December so that was a bit of a
surprise. The other thing as
well like I have read all the books.
I've read a number of books.
I am heavily involved in the Bitcoin
community.
I have friends who are new to Bitcoin.
I have friends who have been in Bitcoin
and have survived a
number of really really bad bear markets
and all the FUD that's come with
throughout the years and
like I have to say it still took me off
guard.
I remember the first kind of pullback
when we went
to like around the 80k mark or something
like that.
I was like okay this isn't too bad.
Like this isn't
too bad. I can um.
Did you feel it in that note because that
was November so I'm glad you brought that up.
Did you feel something change though?
Like the the sheen came off very quickly
and suddenly you're
more attuned to bad news and you start
thinking like a little bit less
optimistic. Was that the
first point where like you felt different
to you? A little bit yes.
Not not as bad as later on.
But yeah I did notice there was more
quarreling on X than there has been
during the the bull market.
Um and yeah there was a little shift.
I wouldn't say it was significant at
least not for me. Um I felt
like I was like I've got this.
I've got this. I'm prepared.
And then the part that you famously call
Um I think that's even when like at one
stage a month before we actually were the
the bear market bottom. I texted you. Yep.
And I was like please don't tell others
but
I'm scared.
I think that was almost verbatim.
It was just I'm scared. What do I do?
What's going on?
Yeah.
It was it was yeah it was a cry of help
like is this over?
Are we ever going to go back up? And
you're like what is your specific fear?
And I think my specific fear was that it
was like never going to go
back up or that we were going to chop
solidate that bear market the way we did
kind of the bull market.
You were basically worried about a
20-year gold-like bear market.
Yeah. Yeah. A 20-year time pain. Yep.
So all of these things I mean at the end
of the day I remember
all of those experiences from 2018.
So my very similar experience I bought
the absolute Pico top in 2017.
First thing I'd ever bought in my life.
I didn't even know an S&P before that.
And then sold off
down like 6k. I bought a 20k.
Sold off down to 6k.
And then we got the bounce up to 14 or I
think 14
or 16 or something.
And that was when like I'm still green as
anything. I don't even know about
bull and bear markets.
I didn't even know this was a thing.
So at that point in time as all people who
come into this industry do you're like oh
what if Bitcoin is going to get overtaken
by this Ethereum thing.
And I went and traded all my Bitcoin for
Ethereum.
It then proceeded to sell off even
more.
And then again I still don't know
anything about it.
So I've got this spreadsheet full of
like 50, 000 shit coins.
And I've put like you know my 50 bucks
across all of them. And they just got
decimated. Oh time and time and time again.
And there was this point in time where we
got to like
it was I think it was November.
And we were just chopping perfectly
sideways at 6k. And me not knowing
anything about you know technical
analysis or all this stuff.
Like I'm trying to learn but it's hard.
I was like it seems like we're forming a
really strong floor here.
So of course I invest more
and then it halves.
And sorry Bitcoin halves.
I didn't know very much Bitcoin at that
point in
time.
I owned a ton of other stuff and it just
went to absolute zero.
Like everything just went to zero.
And I was like okay I've clearly done
something very very wrong.
Now the the two chapters that you
highlighted here.
November well there's three actually.
The November period was very similar to
that like first sell-off in 2018.
That's when you like the smart people
know oh that's not a dip.
That's something much angrier.
It's a phase shift.
You get last gas profit taking.
Speculators rush in
and go but you got to buy this dip
because every dip goes up.
What a massive discount. Let's get in.
And they just get smoked on all the
sell-offs that follow.
And then you get the time paying
capitulation
which I think was February when we went
to 60k for the first time.
And that's when everyone goes oh
wow this is now way lower than I thought
it was going to go.
And people start extrapolating and
going oh my god what if this is just the
start. What like we've gone from 126 to 60.
This is like
we're there in four months.
Oh my god we're going to go way lower.
Then the time paying. And the time
paying is a brutal thing because the
price paying capitulation why it's so
important is at that
point in time it generally happens in the
first half of the bear market.
And at that time you've
got tons of people who are just white
knuckling it really hoping or only just
working out that it's a
bear like because they're just
inexperienced in markets.
So you have the maximum number of people
exposed to the asset that don't know
what's going on.
They don't know what they're doing.
They don't
have a plan and they've been just
blindsided.
And then the price going down is just the
thing they go
no I'm done.
And they get a massive capitulation event.
Lots of people sell then. The time pain is
brutal because the time pain the prices
really go down much more.
You know we got to 60k 59k.
We ultimately bottomed at 58.
It's the same price like for all intents
and purposes it's the same
price.
But the six months of nothingness is so
brutal and it wears people down and then
you get the
final sell-off. Sale is selling.
ETFs are selling. Quantum's killing it.
Cold card is just like oh man
what is going on?
And that's the point in time where even
the high conviction people start to go
I think something's wrong.
But isn't it interesting how that
psychological journey I went through
exactly
the same thing back in 2018.
You know you kind of lose hope.
You're like what what on earth am I doing?
I've done everything wrong.
Like not something wrong.
I've done everything wrong.
But when you come out the other side of
it you get this kind of breath of fresh
air and you go
oh oh maybe like hey it might actually go
up again.
Like and you just have to remember that
that could actually happen.
But isn't it interesting how like there's
a momentum to the downside.
It takes halfway through the bear before
people even realize it's a bear market.
Then they get so into the bear market
that they're like this thing's going down
lower because
everyone wanted 40k 45k.
And then they kind of miss the inflection
back to the upside.
All of those emotions flip them on their
head.
People get in in the second half of the
bull when
it goes past all-time high and they start
feeling really excited.
And you know this I remember back in
my glass node days I would look at
metrics that show selling pressure by OGs
like profit taking old
coins coming back to life and the amount
of people were like oh I should buy when
that metric goes up
because they see it going up at the same
time as the price.
And I'm like no no that is literally the
metric that
stops the price going up.
That is the thing that place people
selling into strength.
But people jump in late in the trend
when it feels exciting and safe and then
they wait for it to get all the way over
the back end and they don't notice when
things start to crescendo
and start falling off and they don't
realize it turned until they're halfway
into the bear. So all of this stuff is
like the cycle of human emotions.
The story that you just told is exactly
what I went through and this is what I
love this data for
because it's the story of all of us going
through our first cycle,
going through our second one,
getting seasoned where you just
stop caring in your third and your fourth.
And then like over time you like lower
prices,
you're like all right now it's got to sit
tight, wait for it. All right, there we go.
Start buying.
And like you can actually just get more
acclimatized to it.
It's a skill like anything else.
Yeah,
that's a really good point because I like
looking back now,
the few things that I regret is I
actually feel like I only started to
really care about like taking the
opportunity of stacking once it was over.
Sure.
It was, it was, it's like, okay, to be fair,
I didn't have a lot of disposable income
to put into Bitcoin during the bear,
unfortunately, but you can still always
squeeze some out. Like if you make some,
you know,
stop having your flat white out in the
cafe every day kind of thing.
Um,
and it was right after like the second
time that he dipped to 58, I was like, okay,
let me just put some limit orders to the
58K. Do you think they ever came around?
No.
It was probably within like a dollar or
something, right? It got real close.
But they didn't, they actually didn't like,
he never went back below,
like went once and put those limit orders
in.
Oh, so we hit it. Oh, I got it. Right.
So you're like,
you're hoping for the second wave and it
just never came.
No, it never came. It never came.
And now I'm like, in hindsight, I was like,
one,
I should not have binged Simon Dixon
podcasts during the bear market.
That was probably not the best use of my
time.
And humorism sells. And as,
as I'm sure he's right on many, many things,
there's very few positive tales in, uh,
in those conversations.
Yeah.
I should have muted some people on X and
not kind of gotten sucked into the whole
negative, you know, debate.
So that's what I would do differently.
And just stack a lot harder.
I just wish I could have this bear market
back.
Let me do it all over again now that I
know what I know.
You're making my business case for me.
This is,
this is exactly why I love this data
because it helped,
it helps me not predict the future.
I can't tell the future,
but it helps me look at, you know,
the way I framed it up.
I don't know where this bear market is
ultimately going to hit its bottom. However,
what am I looking for?
Fear and people exercising that fear,
just taking fat losses.
And I want to see two of them.
I want to see one at the start when all
like the weak hands get out.
And then I want to see the one where
people are just like, Oh my God,
I've been long Bitcoin for such a long
time and I can't do this anymore.
And we got both of them. And I was like,
and then there was just like a series of
events. Cold card happened.
There's a failed soft fork,
sailors selling ETFs and the price went
sideways, not down. And I was like, Oh man,
that looks like seller exhaustion to me.
And there's another thing that
I think is actually,
it's a very psychological thing in markets.
People will often look back and they'll
see 58K and they'll go,
I didn't buy enough at 58K.
Price is trading at 65K. And they go, Oh,
just wait till it goes down to 50K.
Maybe I'll buy at 60K.
But the real answer is like,
there is no difference between 58K and 65K.
And really there's no difference between
80K and 65K over the long term.
But folks, it's very natural.
We look back at things that we wish we
had taken advantage of.
And a lot of people sit,
particularly in the early bull, very,
very sideline because like, oh,
but it has to pull back and it just
doesn't pull back.
So they don't actually get given the
cheaper prices.
And you have to actually just accept that
the past is over.
You cannot in any walk of life,
you cannot go back.
What a lot of people do is they don't,
if you think forward,
let's say that they didn't buy enough at
65.
And then it goes up to 80K and they're
waiting for it to go back down to 75K and
it goes to 87K. And they go, Oh my God.
And then they buy at 87K.
And then what happens?
It goes back down to 80K.
And they go, Oh, it is going to 75K.
And then they sell again only for it to
go to 90K. You know,
this is generally how these things go and
it just wipes people out.
The best thing to do is to kind of,
you understand when we've formed a base,
we've seen those capitulation events,
we should now be expecting that the
downside momentum is slow.
So over the long arc of time,
too many people worry about buying an
asset that they should hold for 10 years,
right?
Plus you're buying an asset that you're
holding for a decade and you're worried
about the next like three weeks of price
action.
It doesn't matter.
And this is where DCA is just so powerful.
You take away the,
I need to make a decision.
You just say,
I want to put X amount of dollars in a
week and I'm just going to let it run.
Just automate it, walk away,
let it just do its thing.
Do I want to buy it when it's cheap?
Is it cheap? Yes. Just let the machine run.
Once you spend a bit more time in markets,
some people like me,
I like being a bit more discretionary
because it's a bit of a game for me.
But at the same time,
I've got a DCA that just hums away because,
you know,
I also could just focus on my analysis
and not worry about do I need to buy,
do I need to do X, Y, and Z.
It's a mental game far more than it's
anything else.
You're trying to manage your own
psychology and your own emotions
because you can't control the market.
It just does what it does.
And you just have to accept it's going to
be random and, you know, improbable.
And sometimes it'll go down really
sharply and you won't be there for it.
And sometimes it'll rip and you just want
to be there for those days where it goes
up a lot.
Yeah. It's interesting
that you say that because, like
I noticed there was always a difference
between what I said and what I did.
So I knew coming in that I, like,
knew it was a volatile asset, but, like,
intraday swings look, like, quite, you know,
large.
And I used to,
when I was first buying Bitcoin,
I used to literally go log into the
exchange and then see the price going up.
I was like, well, let me just wait an hour.
I might come back down and I might get
more sats for my dollar.
Man, do you think I would do something like
that now?
What a waste of time, right?
Like, total waste of time.
Like, total waste of time.
Yep.
But you kind of have to, like, I don't know,
I'm the sort of person I need to learn it
viscerally, like, from experience.
I can't just intellectualize it,
even though I did hear people say, you know,
you're definitely wasting your time with
that.
I just didn't do it.
No, but honestly, it's like a lot of things.
You have to experience it to fully
understand it.
Yeah, markets in particular,
they're very counterintuitive and they
are very, it's a personal journey.
It's actually very mental.
You are fight.
I mean, this is the way I've heard it framed up.
We are trained from a child to, like,
watch out.
Don't fall off those stairs, right?
Watch out for that ledge.
Don't touch the hot plate.
Like, all of these things.
But, you know,
I was a kid in a Chinese restaurant.
They brought out the sizzling hot plate.
I'm staring at it like, what is that?
And my dad go, don't touch it.
And I'm sitting there.
Finger comes out and they're like, oh, [--].
You know, you have to do it.
But have I ever touched a hot plate again?
Not intentionally.
So you have to go through these journeys
of realizing, oh, that wasn't worthwhile.
That was worthwhile.
You know, in my,
I'm going to call it grizzled age, you know,
and again,
there's people who are far more grizzled
in Bitcoin than I am.
Anyone who went through the 2015 bear
market, you know,
they're the kind of people you want to be
in the trenches with.
That was something else.
But you just realize that, like,
none of this stuff really matters.
What you really want to be doing is just
buying when Bitcoin is cheap and not
worrying about the bottom, as in, like,
the bottom wick.
You want to buy the bottom.
The bottom is a six, seven-month process.
And you just want to stack sats through
the whole thing because draw an average
through it.
You know, we went down to 58.
We went up to 80.
But the average through that zone was
like 65, right?
What a great price.
What a great price.
If you just bought the whole way,
your average is like 65, 70,
depending on where you start.
So, you know, to me,
that is the solution to the problem.
Just accepting that you don't know.
Understanding that bear markets take time
and capitalizing on that time.
Not getting caught up in the, oh,
it's going higher,
so I should turn off or turn on or,
you know, just buy the whole thing.
And just know that allow the passage of
time.
And, you know,
as you get further along your journey,
I mean, you know, for me,
I've got my life has changed.
When I started buying Bitcoin,
I was in my 20s.
And, you know, I had no dependents.
I was living overseas, you know, partying,
whatever else.
As you get older, you know,
I've got a son now I've got to worry about.
I've got to worry about different
investing decisions.
I want to buy a property at some point in time.
That's got its own thing.
So now I can't quite just, like,
buy Bitcoin and empty my entire bank
account.
And I have to buy other things as well.
So you start to manage and go, like, well,
what if I pull forward all my demand?
If I really want to buy Bitcoin,
why don't I buy a lot,
as much as I possibly can now?
And then once we get above 100K, honestly,
I probably won't be buying.
Because I'm going to pull forward as much
demand and do as much accumulation as I
can now when it's cheap.
And then I'll go about the rest of my
business.
And, you know, I don't mind if I have to,
like, I want to buy more gold, for example.
I don't really care if it goes up 10,
20% from here and I'm buying there
because Bitcoin will be up 30, 40%.
So I'll delay my gold until Bitcoin's
gone above 100K.
On gold, are people still buying gold?
Like, what's happening there?
Hmm.
So gold is the same trade as Bitcoin.
Sound money, right?
Debasement, all that stuff.
It is obviously an older asset.
It's a culturally significant asset.
And I think the way I frame it up,
so there's an investment angle and then
there's a macro thesis angle.
The investment angle is Bitcoin is my
longest duration asset.
If I'm saving for my son's private school
and high school, right, he's one.
I don't have to worry about that for, like,
11 years.
Bitcoin problem.
If I want to buy a house in the next two,
three years, Bitcoin's fine.
But gold's probably,
if I feel like I want to save for a
deposit,
I don't want to put it in cash because it
might be, like, two,
three years and cash is going to get
killed.
If I think gold is cheap,
I'll probably allocate to gold.
It's, like, a medium term store of value.
If, you know,
gold's probably not going to go down 50%
from here.
It's probably not.
It might go up 10%, 20%.
It might go down 10%, 20%.
Fine.
It's part of the game.
But I know that cash is going to get
killed, right, over that period of time.
So,
and if I was looking to buy a house or
get a deposit in the next, like, 12 months,
probably put it in a bank account with,
you know, high interest.
So, the right tool for the right job.
Now, on the macro side, like, why gold?
Why not some other thing?
And there's tons of other things you
could buy.
For me, I know they're the same trade.
So,
I spend a lot of time thinking about the
debasement trade and the macro setup and,
like,
why I think these are just the correct
assets to be owning at this point in time.
But I think the thing gold has is a
undeniable shelling point.
I do not have to explain to my father.
I can explain debasement and money
printing and all that stuff.
I do not have to explain any technical
shit about Bitcoin.
I can just literally say, yeah,
gold makes sense.
And he's like, yeah, okay, makes sense.
I can't print it.
Fine.
Good.
Scarce money, right?
Romans.
It's very easy to draw any number of
historical analogies about why gold is
going to preserve its value.
You know, there's just the famous saying,
right?
An ounce of gold will buy a men's fine
suit.
And that's just been true forever, right?
No matter where you are,
the price of goods will rise and fall.
But you can generally buy the same amount
of stuff with gold.
So I view gold as like a,
I want to keep this money, right?
I want to hold this purchasing power.
And I view Bitcoin as I want to grow my
purchasing power.
I'm going to take some volatility risk.
I'm going to take some growth risk.
And that requires time.
But anything that I don't, I have time for,
I let it run.
Gold is going to preserve my purchasing
power for that short period of time.
And the last thing on the macro side,
I'm very bullish Bitcoin.
However, there is, there is a world,
if you look at the way the macro is
playing out,
if you take China, Russia, you know,
and I'm not someone who thinks that the
US is going to get, you know, overtaken.
I'm more in Brent Johnson's camp of like,
I think the dollar is the,
there's no second banana when it comes to
currencies and all that stuff.
However, every country,
just like my old man, understands gold.
And as we get a breakdown of trust around
the world,
there is going to be a demand for gold
because it is frankly the only
alternative to treasuries.
It's the only thing because like Bitcoin,
maybe one day,
but we're decades away from it being
large enough for them to just like put
sovereign wealth in.
It'll happen, but not,
I'm not expecting that to happen soon.
That's why I'm buying Bitcoin for the
longterm because I believe that's a
pathway.
But gold is something that like,
it's much more of a surefire bet.
And once you wrap your head around the
size of the bond market that needs to
find a new home,
you know, even here in Australia,
housing has been like our default savings
asset.
And I think there's a lot of Australians
I've heard anecdotally, second, third hand,
even just watching the property market.
There's a lot of people who have,
for the first time in their life,
opened up a spreadsheet and gone, oh shit,
this investment property is not a good
idea.
And I'm in real deep.
And there's a lot of people who are going
to start saying, what else do I buy?
Socks? Gold?
You know,
there's a lot of retirees and boomers who
are going to go, well,
I mean,
like I just could buy some gold because
they don't, don't worry about Bitcoin,
just buy gold.
There's just an army of capital that is
going to buy this thing.
Because it just is, you know what I mean?
Like gold is just a constant and it's
always been a constant.
It will forever be a constant, I think.
So in that regard,
it's the same trade without all the,
I don't have to reason about the future.
I can just see that this is where it's going.
Bitcoin,
there's going to be a journey between
here and there,
whereas gold is just a surefire bet.
Yeah. Yeah. That makes sense.
But I want to go back in time a little bit,
not spend too much time there.
But like last time I had you on the show,
it was like late October, I think,
last year.
So this time last year. Yeah, right.
Some, something, yeah, something like that.
At the top.
I know that we were kind of debating
where we were at,
where there was going to be like,
I think you said 70% bull case,
30% bear case.
Yep.
You can go back and watch the episode.
I can't remember the exact quote.
But like, what do you think we learned?
Did we learn anything from that cycle in
terms of market psychology?
Like,
were we all expecting it to go up a lot?
Yeah. Well,
so this bull wasn't that different to
every previous bull.
And what I mean by that is psychologically,
everyone wanted it to go higher.
Yeah.
Like in 2021, 100K was going to happen.
And here, you know,
higher prices were going to happen.
And what I think this,
this cycle was quite interesting.
There's a few elements to it.
The first one is the treasury company
phenomena.
I think,
and I think most people understand this now.
We didn't have a blow off top in Bitcoin,
but we sure as hell had one in strategy,
in MSDR, right?
That had a blow off top,
like you wouldn't believe.
And all the other treasury companies shot up.
Everyone's piling money to these things
as a speculative bet.
And the capital destruction.
So if you think about that,
all the marginal capital that would have
otherwise just bought spot Bitcoin.
And when you look into the transactions
of a lot of these treasury companies,
they got like coins from a whale in
exchange for shares with warrants and all
this stuff where like there was no actual
Bitcoin being bought.
Like some was, but there was a lot of like,
I'll take your Bitcoin and you get my
shares, but only if the price goes up.
And like,
it's just whales exchanging paper notes,
right?
So there wasn't really this like actual
treasury company buy side.
Obviously strategy bought a ton.
That's a real thing.
But all the marginal money went into
treasury company stocks that were trading
at huge premiums.
So you're buying, you know, look,
there's a whole discussion about MNAVs
and that's not going to go into it.
If you are buying strategy at the top,
you are paying a dollar and they don't
convert that full dollar.
Because when you're just buying stock on
the stock market, right,
it's trading all the time.
Unless they're actively,
strategy is actively selling rather than
some other dude who bought it 50 bucks
and is selling to you at 350 or 500.
A lot of that money that people invested
in the stock did not get transmuted into
BTC purchases.
What actually happened is they bought 33
cents of Bitcoin for their dollar because
it's trading at a 3x premium and then it
proceeded to collapse down to one.
So they kind of just destroyed their money.
So all that marginal capital went into a
stock that then got crushed and strategy
got the least crushed out of all.
Some of these things went down 99% and
then folded, right?
And then became sell side.
So they actually were just purely net
negatives across the whole board.
So a lot of speculative capital got
eviscerated.
So that took out the blow off steam.
I think the rolling out of strategy,
which is just an enormous buyer at the
time and the ETFs and just institutions,
like they weren't the only buyers.
They account for like 30, 40%,
I would say at most.
The other 60% is just spot buyers.
The amount of sell side we saw from old
hands, multiple cycle people.
And people wonder like why they made fun
of the dude for selling 80,
000 Bitcoin for 9 billion,
9 and a half billion at the top.
People made fun of him like,
but it's going to go up higher, bro.
It's like, dude, he's cashing out $9.
6 billion.
He's won.
He doesn't like, don't worry about it.
He's fine.
He'll be okay.
By the way,
how many more 80K Bitcoin slugs has this
dude got?
So I think the amount of selling was
tremendous.
I called it the great rotation.
Geordie Vista called it the IPO moment.
There was a huge like coming of age thing.
And if you think about it,
imagine buying Bitcoin at $10, $100, $1,
000,
going through the 2015 bear market and
like actually being of the conviction to
buy a ton.
You can finally finance your life.
You can now have the life you want.
Buy a bunch of treasuries.
Buy some stocks.
Just I would do the same thing.
And I ask everybody,
imagine you take your bag of Bitcoin,
spend another two or three years buying
as much as you can.
And then the price goes to a million.
What are you going to do?
Just sit there with a bunch of coins on a
wallet?
No,
you're going to go and improve your life
because otherwise you're going to die
with your coins.
And what a miserable experience that is.
The whole point of investing in anything
is to make your life better,
your family's life better,
to do something with it.
Because your only thing that's more
scarce is your time.
And you've got to go and spend it
somewhere.
So the reason we buy anything in the
asset world is because we kind of want to
improve our life in some way, shape,
or form.
We're deferring consumption today so we
can enjoy a better life in the future.
For our kids, for ourselves,
all of the above.
So if you wind back the clock,
if you were the lucky guy who was buying
it $100,
I bet you any money you would have sold
to him at $100K as well.
And for all of us who are buying it,
you know, $50, and $30, and $20,
and whatever thousand dollars you're at,
once it goes to $200, $300, $500, million,
you're going to be in the exact same boat
and you're going to be the exact same
thing.
So we had a massive rotation of what I'm
going to call like the old guard,
the people who got Bitcoin to where it is,
they finally had a chance to exit.
So I think those are the two major
components.
There's a whole other angle,
like the business cycle never really
fired up and all that kind of stuff.
But I think those two just really define
what happened around the top.
And this bear market, frankly,
was fairly soft to ease that all off.
But do you think we're going to see a
similar setup this cycle where, you know,
Bitcoin does a sideways chop solidation
and something like strategy has the blow
off top again?
Is that kind of what you see or we don't know?
I don't know is the first answer,
but I can theorize.
There's a few pillars.
Let me open this up.
First one is for Bitcoin specifically.
I think this cycle is going to be kind of
interesting and special somewhat because
once you break the all time high,
which we will,
you can't really blame it on anything
that's like really obvious.
Like in 2017, it became a household name.
It's when I first heard about it.
And that was just like a coming of age
moment for it.
Kind of moving into its adolescent age.
I think this cycle we became an adult,
young adult in terms of Bitcoin's life
cycle.
You know, it's got institutions.
I mean,
JP Morgan just released a piece saying
it's going to be, you know,
best performing asset.
And like it's now normal.
So I think this cycle is going to be a
normalization where it's just kind of
normal to have a few percentage points
allocated to Bitcoin.
And I just,
I really don't think people understand
the magnitude of capital that like a 2%
average allocation across a bunch of
model portfolios.
It's just an ungodly amount of money.
It's just a huge amount of money.
So I think that the incremental like
normalization of Bitcoin,
you can't blame it on Trump or ETFs or
like, it's just like people just buy it.
It's just demand.
Like it's just straight demand for it.
So I think this cycle is going to be more
sustainable.
In terms of chop solidation, I'd be,
I think that'll be a feature.
In the early phase of the bull,
you want that to be a feature because
that's basically the market building
support on the way up.
But I think as things like options,
which are much larger than futures now,
options on the IB ETF will create call
walls and put walls and there'll be
derivative stuff that like keeps
volatility contained and then it will pop
again.
And so those components play into it.
So I think there's a maturation.
There's a, just like,
you can't really blame the next all-time
high on anything on the demand.
Once you come back from this many bear
markets, you just accept that it's a thing,
right?
So that normalization,
I think is just a massive inflow of
capital.
Now on the treasury company side,
just like shit coins from every previous
cycle,
every cycle we have fewer and fewer
winners and the pool of stupid ideas, right?
In the crypto space got increasingly
stupid.
And then now like they went to meme coins
and there's just like nothing left.
Now they have to try and find something
that's like actually making money,
actually a useful on-chain business of
some form, right?
And good luck with that.
I think treasury companies are the same.
We had this initial like, you know,
Cambrian explosion of just these retarded
companies that frankly had no business
doing what they were doing.
And most of them folded and had to sell
everything.
There's a handful,
and this was always my view,
that we would have a very strong Pareto
distribution.
And for those who aren't statistics folks,
Pareto distribution means you've got one
really big winner, a couple of like second,
third, fourth,
and then you can't even see fifth and
sixth on the mat.
They're so small.
So you get this like very skewed one or
two big winners, three, four, five, six,
seven mediums,
and then a long tail of stuff that you'd
never even worry about.
So I suspect that's more or less what's
playing out,
a very strong Pareto distribution in the
treasury companies.
I also think as we get more aware,
like Strategy, for example,
if you think about the multiples, you know,
there's various ways of MNAV.
That's a whole rabbit hole into itself.
If we think about the premium that these
stocks can command, a very simple,
not perfect framework to think about this
as like a growth multiple.
Strategy's got 840,000 Bitcoin.
Now, that gives them a ton of balance sheet
capacity to buy more.
Like when you've got a big balance sheet,
you can buy more because you've just got
size.
However,
is he going to go to 2 million Bitcoin?
That's going to be real hard.
That's a hard sell.
Like,
I don't think he's going to be able to
get to 2 million.
So therefore,
do you assign him a 2x growth multiple?
Probably not.
So the bigger you get,
the more capable you are,
the more survivable you are,
but you probably aren't going to grow as
fast and as big.
There's smaller companies like, you know,
Strive is kind of one of the faster ones.
Metaplanet's, you know,
I think second or third in terms of size.
They're at 40, 000, 30, 000 coins now,
medium size.
But are they going to get to 840,000?
Probably not.
Can they go to 120?
Yeah, maybe.
So maybe a 3x multiple,
but can they go to a 10x?
Hard.
So I think that the market's going to be
a bit more selective.
Their premiums probably aren't going to
explode as ridiculously as they did in
the past.
Strategy probably won't get the same
premium as a smaller business,
but they also probably won't ever get to
strategy size.
So I think you're going to end up with
this like firming up of things.
So yeah,
we will probably still see some euphoria
there,
but I think it's going to be more
contained, more controlled.
Kind of looks like a more legitimate,
I would say,
version of the shitcoin industry where
like once you've had the initial like, whoa,
we're all going to make money.
And once that goes away, everyone goes, oh,
okay.
Well,
now I'm actually going to look at the
balance sheet or I'm going to just like
take this company and talk to Claude for
a while and work out,
should I buy this one or this one?
How do I think about it?
So I think we move back to a world of
more common sense.
Yeah.
And you mentioned altcoins.
And I'm really curious to know, like,
what are we seeing at the moment?
Has there been more of a decoupling
between Bitcoin and altcoins?
For anyone who's into the altcoins,
what should they be thinking about?
Yeah, honestly,
I used to track it a lot more closely.
And the main reason is I found it
fascinating just as a observation deck of
human experience.
I think a lot of Bitcoin has actually
missed an opportunity by just saying, oh,
shitcoins are shitcoins.
By the way, all shitcoins are shitcoins.
But I think they missed an opportunity of
studying it with like a curiosity lens.
We got to watch why regulations were
invented.
Like we got to see Wall Street bug for bug,
problem for problem,
get rebuilt by this industry in record
speed.
And you got to see all the scams, the rugs,
the bad ideas, the crooked incentives,
the misaligned VCs and like how stable
coins kind of came to be,
where they broke the peg,
why they broke the peg to the upside,
to the downside,
how economic models formed and then
collapsed.
We got to see the financial system get
built from the ground up, collapse, built,
collapse, built, collapse.
And then eventually they came up with like,
oh,
turns out the dollar is actually the most
important thing.
Like it's a fascinating, oh, and by the way,
all the rails that we built, you know,
like people talking about tokenization now,
which I had, by the way,
I have no doubt tokenization will happen.
And there's a story on that for the
on-chain data side as well.
Tokenization will happen.
But is there any reason why any altcoin,
like if it can't,
but let's say it did all run on Ethereum.
The moment that like, first of all,
Ethereum doesn't scale to that level,
but like,
why do you need to buy ETH to do that?
Because I just, you know,
it's like I use the analogy of your car.
I use petrol all the time.
Every time I get in my car, I use petrol.
I don't have a swimming pool and barrels
of petrol in my backyard just in case
because I'm going to use, no,
I go to the petrol station, I fill up.
I go and buy my 50 bucks.
Well, it's not 50 bucks anymore.
I saw a good joke the other day.
I said,
I filled up my petrol tank the other day
for 100 bucks.
It was my lawnmower, but, you know,
you've got to take the wins when you can
get it.
But, you know,
but like I think with all of these layer
ones,
you don't need an excess supply of this
stuff.
You kind of just buy it as you need it.
And the problem is that these things
don't scale.
So then the fees, you know,
if people did put all the stock market on
Ethereum, it just simply couldn't handle it.
The fees would go through the roof.
And then people are like,
why don't we actually move over to this
other thing?
Why don't we build JP Morgan network and
just use that?
You know,
you're trying to monetize a database,
you know, and not just use a database.
So I think tokenization will happen.
But the things you're tokenizing, the bonds,
the stocks, the real estate,
like the Tesla stock on the chain is the
valuable thing.
The chain it's on is just a means to an
end.
So, yeah,
I certainly spent my time studying,
learning about, observing,
watching out of pure curiosity what the
crypto industry is doing.
Over the last, I'm going to say,
three years, people ask me like, oh,
are you going to cover Ethereum or this
via the news?
And my answer is very clear.
No, I'm not.
I just don't care anymore.
I really have lost all interest in it.
I learned a lot from it.
And it's been a massively formative part
of like how I think about this industry
because I got to see all the mistakes.
Right.
When you get to learn from all the
mistakes, it's just invaluable.
But no,
I really just don't actively track it
anymore.
Like I've got my core thesis that I've
formed over many years.
I'm yet to see much data to convince me
otherwise.
So, yeah, at this point in time,
I think it's the curiosity has done its
job.
Now, for the on-chain analysts,
which there are, if you can believe it,
there are more than just me out there.
I do believe that when all these things
get tokenized,
a lot of the metrics that we study for
Bitcoin,
imagine if you could look at all this
data for any stock, for NVIDIA.
Imagine if you could see when all the OGs
who bought NVIDIA years ago started
selling and the profit they were taking
and the coin days they were destroying
and all the stock days,
I guess you'd call it.
But these are all fascinating metrics
that one day the NASDAQ and the New York
Stock Exchange are going to realize that
they have all this data that is like the
on-chain data for these stocks.
And it's a goldmine of insight.
Now,
I need to ask you a question because I
need it settled for once and for all,
at least for me and the listeners as well.
But what is the current Bitcoin cycle?
Is there a cycle?
Is there a four-year cycle?
We still use the term cycle, but what is it?
So everything has cycles.
Humanity, the weather, the clock,
everything has cycles.
Bitcoin has had a four-year-ish cycle.
Now,
what drove that I think has changed over
the years.
When I go back and look and having lived
through much of Bitcoin's history,
there is always a thing that I can look
at to explain why the market was doing
what it was doing.
2017, we had a 100x parabola.
No one knew what Bitcoin was.
It was like a coming to, you know,
a growing up thing.
It was like, wow, what is this internet?
Wow, I've never heard of this thing.
How cool.
Look at it go.
Every time I buy it, it goes up.
Like, it was just a true speculative fever.
Alongside all the ICOs, all that stuff.
That was my first entry point.
2018 bear market is the hangover that
comes after that, right?
That's just markets doing what markets
have to do.
You've got to flush out all the chaff and,
you know, get rid of all the nonsense.
Then we have the bottom.
And what we didn't know at the time is
Plus Token was this like Ponzi scheme
over in China.
And they bought two,
like there was just people buying it to
send to this scam.
So it sucked up like 2% of the Bitcoin
supply in a couple of months.
And it sent prices alongside derivatives
that have come live.
And people were shorting it like crazy at
6K thinking we spent, you know,
a year belting against 6K.
We broke through.
Support is now near resistance.
There's no way 6K isn't going to be
tremendous resistance straight through.
Short squeezes, you know, Plus Token, Ponzi,
all this kind of stuff.
Then we have a hangover,
like a second hangover.
Then we have COVID.
Stimulus, right?
We blast through the roof because it's
like scarce asset.
Everyone's at home.
Bitcoin's the only thing that's around.
Then we have tons of leverage.
If you go back and look at the 2021 top,
there's just a tremendous,
like people were paying 150% annualized
rates to be long on perps.
So like the reason I'm telling all these
snippets, then we had a 50% collapse.
That blew up the balance sheets.
If I actually really think about what
happened, we knew FTX was a fraud.
There's a bunch of other companies out
there that were doing a carry trade with
Genesis and like borrowing money from
Genesis, putting it into GBTC at the time,
closed end fund.
That first 50% sell-off in May,
no doubt would have crushed a bunch.
They're looking at their spreadsheet and
going, guys, we're [--].
We need this price to go up real quick or
we're done.
I think FTX looked at their balance sheet
and goes, we're cooked.
Probably started taking customer funds
and juicing the price back to a new
all-time high.
People sold into it.
Rate hiking.
The reason I'm telling all these stories,
none of that required me to say, oh,
the four-year halving happened here.
Or had to have...
These things were just the cycle that
formed because of the mechanics of the
market.
Where was the demand?
And the run-up in 2021, GBTC hoove it up.
660,000 Bitcoin.
Basically a whole strategy.
Best part of a whole strategy.
In like six months.
It was just a huge, just all-in buy side.
But what was the flip side of that?
That was built on all this leverage.
And then rate hikes came.
Luna collapsed.
Three Arrows was bankrupt.
Genesis is bankrupt.
Then we have the ETFs go live.
None of this stuff requires us to anchor
ourselves to a cycle.
So getting back to your original question.
What I think a lot of people waited for
in this bear market is the four-year
cycle.
And that would mean we should be setting
lows about 10 days ago.
Right?
We should be setting new lows.
And a lot of people anchored to this
thing because it's what happened in the past.
But did it actually happen in the past?
Or did they mistake a data set of three?
That, no doubt.
No doubt.
Like the fact that we topped, you know, 1,
050 days after the previous low is very
interesting.
Because had these like cyclical things.
But did it top because we were 1,050 days?
Or did it top because that might be the
time period that it took people to take
on too much leverage and do dumb shit.
And like, you know,
become convinced that the bull market was
bulletproof and couldn't die.
And then start taking too much risk.
There's a human component to this.
Maybe people have a four-ish year cycle
when we're left into a true free market.
Maybe.
That could be a thing.
But anchoring to the point where you go,
it must happen to the day is purely just
going to get you confused.
Because when it doesn't bottom,
there's bears out there who are still
trying to blow on the price to be like,
stop going up.
I need to be right.
And they need to convince themselves that
if my compass is broken, what do I do?
So that's why, from my perspective,
if it's so simple that you just literally
buy four years later, sell four years later,
three years after that,
buy a year after that.
If that is indeed the clock,
eventually a hedge fund will arbitrage
that away.
And then it will stop working.
And then when it stops working,
all the people who are doing that are
going to start getting fleeced because
they become the fodder.
And this is just like an example.
The market will arbitrage away these
things.
And I think Bitcoin is going to trade
much more like a macro asset.
It's going to be much more complicated to
understand.
It's not going to be as simple as like, oh,
October, October.
Like,
I just don't think it's going to be that
way.
It might be.
But am I going to sit there and be like,
I will not do this thing until it hits my
date?
No,
because that is a complete lack of rigor,
in my opinion.
And if you're looking at the world around
you and understanding what's going on,
it will be far more informative than
anchoring to, frankly,
an arbitrary date on the calendar.
So, what is your roadmap?
How do you think these next few years are
Okay.
going to play out?
Yeah.
So, in the way I frame it up,
bear markets and bull markets,
we kind of have the opposite
of what we know and what we don't know.
There's always uncertainties in the world,
but in a bear market,
we know that the hodlers
will eventually step in.
We know that the demand will come in.
The problem is we don't know who needs to
sell yet.
Who's over-levered?
Who's done something wrong?
Who's, you know, got too much on the line?
Who bought too high?
Like,
we can see where people have bought high.
So, we don't know the seller side yet.
Who is going to hit the red button?
We don't know.
Well, we know people will buy the,
will hit the green button and over time
we will set
a floor.
Bulls are the exact opposite.
We know who's going to sell.
The people who bought the bottom.
Always, right?
The people who buy low are going to sell
high.
They're the smart money.
That's why they're buying in the first
place.
They won't sell all of it,
but they will sell into the rally.
What we don't know is who's going to hit
the green button.
Is it going to be, you know,
are we suddenly going to have a sovereign
wealth fund?
Is it going to be just hedge funds?
Is it just going to be retail?
Is it going to be no retail?
We don't know.
We don't know who the buyers are going to
be,
but we do know who the sellers are going
to be.
So, in bears,
that's why it's kind of a return to
fundamentals.
There's no speculative excess at the
bottom of a bear.
It's also why I prefer to measure
compound annual growth rate from bottom
to bottom.
People like to look at top to top,
and that's, in my opinion, ridiculous,
because you're
taking the least sustainable, most frothy,
brief period,
and comparing it and being like,
look at these two things.
It's like the most unstable things you
can possibly find, and being like, look,
let's
compare them.
No, take the two most stable,
hardcore flaws, compare those.
That's really the true growth of Bitcoin,
where the clearing price is in the worst
times.
That's the best level.
So, my general roadmap,
and the way I think about the start of
bull markets, we've washed
out all the speculators.
I don't believe we will see an influx of
serious new demand, aside from smart money,
people
who are patient, calm, quiet,
willing to wait.
We probably won't see those speculators'
fast money until we clear 100k.
I suspect, just ballpark,
I suspect there's statistical levels that
kind of back this up,
but I think 100k is where people start to
notice it's on Bloomberg terminals and
news headlines and all that stuff.
So, between here and there,
I think we'll generally be quiet, trending.
It'll be trending higher.
I think dips will be for buying.
We may get a bunch of chop solidation
where it just goes sideways for a ton of
time.
We saw that in 2023 and 2016 and all that
stuff.
We may attack 100k and then pull back for
three, four months, and everyone's like, oh,
God,
what a shitty bull market.
But that's also stack central.
Once we clear 100k,
I do believe it's going to be that point
in time where people look
back and go, and every bitcoiner,
and you yourself will go through this
very soon, every
bitcoiner looks back and goes, goddammit,
I want those prices back.
And then suddenly you flip from being like,
Bitcoin feels cheap to being, now it feels expensive.
And every bitcoiner has to get used to
Bitcoin getting expensive again.
So, I think 100k is where that probably
happens.
And my general view is you really want to
take advantage of all prices below 100k
because
once we get above that level,
the headlines start to hit.
People start to come in.
We probably take a run at the all-time
high, I would say, fairly quickly.
That's when we move from the,
and by the way, between here and 100k,
maybe 90, there's
a lot of people who still think it's a
bear, who want it to be a bear,
who will act like
it's a bear,
who don't quite have the conviction to
buy like it's a bull.
So, that's why it's softer, it's quieter,
it's more sideways grind and pullbacks
and all
that stuff.
But once we get above that level,
no one's a bear anymore.
Everyone now is excited and we're
starting to get new people in and that's
what I call
the excitement phase.
And then once we get to the all-time high,
things change again.
So, it's kind of like two chapters,
the recovery till like 90, 100,
there'll be a phase change.
Then we start to move into the excitement
phase.
Once we get above the all-time high into
price discovery,
we move into the euphoria chapter.
And that's where it just becomes like,
it's anyone's guess because we are quite
literally
in uncharted waters.
And that's when we start to see long-term
holders ramping up their selling.
We'll see a lot of metrics.
Now, the question is,
how much sell-side can Bitcoin take?
Because in the last bit bull market,
I know people were disappointed by it,
but I really
do want to impress how much of a punch.
Like,
Bitcoin got full Mike Tyson wailed on in
terms of sell-side.
Just like hands behind back for 12 rounds.
The amount of selling from these OGs was
unprecedented.
And when I say OGs, it's not just like, oh,
Mr. Coins from 2011.
There were people from one year, two year,
three year, five year, six year, seven year.
Every single age band was just all-time
high in terms of sell-side through 24 and 25.
Just month after month after month.
I was amazed that we got to November and
we were still above 100K.
It was just relentless selling.
What is the real message there?
There was enough demand in that lukewarm
bull to keep Bitcoin absorbing the
largest sell-side
event ever at 100K.
Now, yes,
we then had to give some of it back in
the bear, but we went down 55%.
Pretty good.
Honestly, when you really think about it,
like that's kind of impressive.
Then we got a clearing price that was way
higher than most people expected.
And now we're moving higher again.
Those people only needed to finance their
life once.
You know what I mean?
Once you cash out $9. 6 billion,
you probably don't ever have to sell again.
And you might even take some of that $9.
6 billion and buy Bitcoin again.
Maybe.
You know what I mean?
So I think that the wave of selling we saw,
and this is speculative,
we probably don't need
to see that again.
We will still see long-term holder selling.
That will still be the reason the market
stops going up eventually.
But there's a lot of people who took
their 100K chips and are now kind of
happy to let
it run.
They don't need to sell anymore.
They're done.
They did the selling they had to do.
They did the diversification they had to
do.
There's a point in time where Bitcoin
goes up enough that you can just improve
your life,
spread your portfolio out.
And now you're just like, you know,
there'll be people out there who just
live off dividends
now.
And they don't need to work and all this
kind of stuff.
But I think this bull market,
once we go into the euphoria phase,
it's probably going
to be a little bit more,
we're going to see who really wants to
sell because there'll
be fewer reasons to.
The probability of Bitcoin dying has gone
down significantly.
That's why we bottomed at 60K, not at 40.
The probability of Bitcoin dying is
significantly lower.
It's now being talked about in banking
white papers.
Like, guys,
if you told me this stuff in 2018,
I would have laughed at you.
No way.
Couldn't happen.
And yet here we are where it's normal for
JP Morgan to just like list Bitcoin as
like
the best performing asset in their
expected future pathway.
It's like, good Lord, guys.
The pet rock has a 10 year forecast now.
Can you believe it?
Right?
Boomer coin is suddenly like a normal
part of the portfolio.
A normal part of portfolios.
That's the other thing.
People also get kind of wound up about, oh,
it's just an investment.
What about money?
It's like, look, Bitcoin's going to,
first and foremost, as a free market,
people are
going to build treasury companies and
ETFs and stuff that you may not like.
And this is part of the game.
That's how it works.
Most people are not going to
self-custigate their Bitcoin.
Just blankets is not going to happen.
It's too difficult.
It's too hard.
It's too complex.
They don't care.
They don't want to do it.
Bitcoin is going to start as an
investment asset.
However, my son, right?
He's one.
He's probably going to be very,
very familiar with using Bitcoin as
normal money.
Bitcoin is going to advance one funeral
at a time, right?
As we wind the clock forward 50 years,
the probability that Bitcoin is used as a
monetary
asset is significantly higher in 50 years
than it is in the next five years.
The next five years, it has to monetize.
And that's the thing we're here for.
We're here for the monetization.
The reason people buy it and don't spend
it is because they know it's going to go
That's why they're buying it in the first
up.
place.
So I think we're in this like Eddie
Curran or this like, you know,
this estuary between
the old Bitcoin world where the people
who bought it when it was worthless have
finally
financed their lives.
The institutions are finally on board.
It's now going to go through a new
adoption curve of unfathomable size.
Gold went up $20 trillion in 12 months.
Bitcoin's $1.6 trillion.
You know, give us 10% of that.
And everyone listening to this podcast
can be very, very happy.
You know,
can Bitcoin go in a multi-trillion dollar
run?
Yes, absolutely.
Like, honestly,
without too much hassle at all.
I think the future is really, really bright.
And yeah,
it's easy to be stuck in the bear market
doldrums.
But I think that like the probability of
failure of this thing is so low and it's
proven that.
That's why I think this bear and the next
all-time high,
those two in combination will just be
a really convincing story that like we're
past the wild west now, right?
Now it is a serious and normal asset.
So boring.
So dull.
So gray.
And yet so goddamn bullish, right?
People are going to get worked up about it,
but like it's going to be normal, guys.
That is the most bullish thing that could
possibly happen to Bitcoin.
It's just no longer a scam that, you know,
why would I ever own that?
It's like, oh no,
it's actually doing really well.
You should actually get some in your
portfolio.
Like when people are talking over dinner.
Great.
I can't wait for that.
Yeah.
But as a last question,
do you want to tell my listeners what
speaking gigs you've got
coming up and where people can find you?
And also just to end on like,
what are you most bullish on?
Yes.
So we'll be up in, is it May?
Middle of May.
We'll be up there in Byron Bay for the
Bush Bash.
So I'll be bringing myself and the family
up.
So if you're going to be up that way,
a beautiful part of the world.
There's something magnetic about that
Byron area.
Once you get past Ballina, it's just,
it's beautiful.
So we're also heading to Miami in
November for a conference,
which will be good fun.
And honestly,
what I'm the most bullish about,
I'm actually really bullish about our
business.
We are very soon.
Alec,
Jacinta and I are about to ship a new
charting website,
which has been talked about
ad nauseum.
But it is now in a shape where, look,
in my world of building all this on-chain
data, you know,
I've seen plenty of platforms and they've
never been the one that I wanted.
And we now have the one that I wanted.
It's the platform that I've always wanted
to build.
Alec's done a tremendous amount of work
on this thing.
And I've been playing around with it just
before we hit record.
This thing is almost ready to go.
And yeah, I've built,
we've finally built the thing that we
wanted to build for many,
many years.
So I'm super excited for that to come live.
I'm going to say that firmly,
that will be live by the end of the year.
So now I've got a, now I've got a deadline.
All right.
Well, I'll hold you to it.
Thank you so much, James.
Always love having you on.
And thanks again.
Thanks, Anja.
Always a pleasure.