Join Andy Marsland in Exploring Clean Energy where we uncover the ideas, innovations, and projects powering our sustainable future.
You may know us as Exploring Hydrogen, where for 31 episodes we’ve shone a spotlight hydrogen. However, our global challenge of decarbonisation is much bigger than one energy vector.
Now, as we continue as The Exploring Clean Energy Podcast, this 2nd season we’re expanding the conversation to include the other stories that are shaping the energy transition of Australia and the world. We hope you enjoy the diversity of thought, and I welcome you so engage with me to help shape the episodes moving forward – so we can bring you the technical experts and projects that you want to hear about and to answer your important questions. Welcome to our energising journey.
You are listening to Exploring Clean Energy, where we uncover the ideas, innovations, and projects powering our sustainable future. I'm Andy Marsland. Welcome to the show. I'm thrilled to welcome our guest today, Paul Jansen, Associate Director, Renewable Energy Development at Haskoning. So a very warm welcome to the Clean Energy podcast. Thank you very much, uh, Andy. Thanks for, uh, for having me and the invitation. Uh, I, I'm quite honored to, to be here in Australia as a Guest from, uh, from the Netherlands, as Paul mentioned, uh, over from the Netherlands. Obviously, the European sector, in a lot of ways, is a lot more advanced than Australia, so we're hoping to learn a few things from you, if that's okay, Paul. So perhaps some of the challenges that you, that you've seen, uh, in your sector of the world, and maybe some lessons learned that the Australian communities can pick up, up on. So let's get into it. Can you give the listeners a bit of a background on firstly, Haskoning, and then secondly, uh, your journey and your position within your organization? Yeah, for sure. Uh, happy to do so. Haskoning is a international engineering and, uh, consultancy firm that is active in over 100 countries in the world, with offices in over 60. And we're a team of about 140 here in Australia, so not that big, but around 7,000 in, uh, in the rest of the world, headquartered in the Netherlands. And we have a really strong background in the maritime sector from about 140 years ago already, but since a couple of decades, of course, also active in, uh, in the renewable energy sector, mainly now in northwestern Europe, but also, uh, looking to expand here, uh, here in Australia. And for my personal background, I started my career in 2009. Uh, I have a background as an environmental scientist, doing a lot of environmental impact assessments and permitting for, um, renewable energy, mainly in the Netherlands, northwestern Europe. And at that time, the central question back there was, can we obtain approval for particular wind farms, how to add more renewables to the grid? And over the past 17 years of working in, uh, in the renewable energy, my work has kind of broadened towards solar batteries, offshore infrastructure, transmission lines, and more integrated energy systems. I think we'll get to that later in, uh- Yes. Yeah ... in this conversation. And increasingly, I work at, at the intersection, I would say, between technology, environment, economics, spatial planning, politics, because that's where most of these renewable energy projects come, come together or maybe sometimes fall apart or fail. And I really enjoyed working on, let's say, both sides of the table. So I did a lot of work for project developers, uh, but I've also been working for, uh, uh, several authorities, mainly working at developing policy. So- Yeah ... extremely broad. And I've got the feeling- It is, yeah, yeah ... this, this conversation today could take us in a number of different directions. So we touched upon this al- already, but northwest Europe, from the outside, uh, it does look like they're a lot further down the renewable energy transition than here in Australia. So what does the energy system look like when renewables move from a relatively small part to becoming a major part? So at, at low penetration, renewable energy is, is mainly a generation challenge, right? How do we get enough wind and solar on the grid? How do we build enough to increase that percentage of, of renewables in our electricity, uh, offer? At higher penetration levels, let's say above around 30% or so, it becomes more of a system challenge, right? So when is electricity produced? Where is it produced? Is there actually grid transportation available, and can we actually store it, and who can use it at, at any given time? Just to, to provide with a few numbers from, from my context. So in 2024, two years ago, renewables, and that'll be wind and solar mainly in, in northwestern Europe, represented around 50% of the electricity consumption in the Netherlands, slightly more in Germany, and over 80% in Denmark. While at those levels, flexibility, storage, interconnection, and the demand become just as important as the actual generation of, of electricity. Yeah. So how, how do we move from, you know, getting more renewable generation built to how do we make the whole system work together and working around that? First phase was actually about this installing of megawatts, right? That's what I mentioned. I mean, maybe up to halfway through the second decade of, of the century, 2015, something like that, it was about installing megawatts. Now, the next phase is about how to make that megawatt useful, right? Can we actually use the produced electrons? And that means integrating electricity with industry transport, heating, storage, and maybe even hydrogen will become more important. So the question is no longer where is the best resource or where is space available for our wind or solar farm, but is there also grid capacity? Is there an actual flexible demand? Is there a customer? Yes. Yeah. So you touched upon a, a few there, but what, what would you say are the major challenges within Europe- Yeah ... then? So, you know, has the social license piece played a, a major part of the challenges over there? Yeah. So I think in Europe, we underestimated a few things in this energy transition, and I would say there's four or five topics there. First of all, we definitely underestimated how quickly the electrification would increase demand. So when things start rolling, the demand really rises, especially in industry, and the supply cannot keep up with that. So second, the effect of simultaneous wind and solar production on prices that really... Like, when you have simultaneous production of solar and wind, you really get the negative prices. Australia's facing that as well, right? Yeah. Um, and then- So, so, so just to dig into your earlier point- Mm-hmm ... um, on the demand side, what was causing that increase in, in demand? So there's really policy in place to actually try to increase that demand, try to have that electrification of, of industry in place. Mm-hmm. Uh, but on the other side, there's no supply, or wherever there is supply, the supply and demand are not at the same place or at the same time, so you get the grid congestion issues, right? Mm. And maybe to touch on that one- Mm ... we really underestimated how long it actually takes to expand the grid. Seems like, okay, you order a, a cable, you expand your substation, but only the procedures take up to four or five years. So in general, the national, uh, grid operator in the Netherlands, TenneT, they allow around 10 years for a grid expansion to actually happen. Well, if the demand increases within one or two years, you'll see the issue arising, right? And I think the last is that there's a lot of cumulative projects, so it's not just one wind project or one solar project or one transmission line, but there's a lot of projects in the same area, 'cause usually these are the areas where there's space available, there's resource, and there's, there's options for actually grid expanding or there is already grid capacity there. So you see a lot of cumulative impacts in the same area. And coming back to that social licensing, you can imagine that is where the challenges then will be. You mentioned before we'd, we'd started recording that communities in parts of Europe, uh, now in, well, increasingly being viewed not simply as stakeholders to consult, but being as actual partners on the project Could you perhaps talk a little bit more about that? Yeah, for sure. So it's called community ownership, and there are actually several models to that, that community ownership. First of all, you have the situation where a community cooperative can actually directly invest into wind or solar project. It can form, for example, a joint venture together with a developer. That's sometimes happening. Or it can be partly owner of the SPV, the, a special purpose vehicle that is usually created for an individual project. Or it can provide subordinate finance to receive a definite share or a revenue from, from these projects. It could also... Other models have, like, community bonds or a local electricity arrangement or a community fund. In the end, it all comes down to actually being partly owner of the project. To give you a perspective, the Netherlands has the aspiration, I would say it's not an obligation, but it's an aspiration to have 50% local ownership for every large onshore wind and, and solar project. It doesn't mean it's always met, but there's an aspiration, and there's some quite good examples of, of projects that actually, uh, work in, in this way. But the most important, it refers to, to actually local equity and actually influence in a project, and not simple distribution of money or revenues afterwards, right? So it's really co-ownership of a project. Yes, yeah. And what's been driving that shift, then? I think the, the social licensing question- Mm because a lot is, it's a major transition, right? We're, we're going from an energy system that was at least in the Netherlands, but I think in Australia similarly, largely underground. So you take fossil fuels. People don't see it. You barely notice that unless you really live very close to a, a mining site or a, a well, to a system that is largely in your face, right? Big solar farms, large wind turbines, and there was increasing resistance towards that changing of the environment that people live in. Well, that change is kind of inevitable, but at least you can try to have everybody hook onto this and, and have some of the revenues. And I think the major shift was thinking about the fairness of, of distributing revenue. So it doesn't have to be equal, but it has to be fair. And I think the good thing about actually being a partly owner or co-developer is that you have a say in the decisions that are made, right? During the development, but also afterwards. Do you feel as a whole that has made things easier, or does it introduce another level of complexity if you've got- That's, that's a really good question, Andy. So I think in the long run it'll help us in the energy transition. In the short term, it doesn't necessarily speed up projects, uh, because you need to do more preparation work. You need to make agreements with local communities or a local cooperative. But once you've actually managed to do that, it might speed up things down the line, might speed up projects there. Yes. And it's also a fundamentally different relationship you have, right, between a developer or an asset owner and the local community. Yeah. Do you have any examples of specific projects that this has worked well for, and then digging into that further, what exactly was the ownership model- Yeah ... that was used in those instances? Yeah, so I've worked for a few of these projects, and some are fairly small, like just a couple of wind turbines, for example, or a local solar field being, what, 20 or 40 megawatts. Uh, but there are really quite big examples in the Netherlands, over 100 megawatt projects, which I would say are substantially, although maybe in your Australian context- they're still considered relatively small. Where a local cooperative of the actual landowners combined with the people living in the area would form a co-op and actually fully 100% develop the project themselves. So the area was designated as a area for, uh, renewable energy development. In this case, it was wind, wind farm, uh, combined with battery. Mm-hmm. And actually, Haskoning supported them in, in, in actually getting their permits, doing all the EIA work, et cetera. And it was a pretty cool project to work on because you really feel part of that, like, community vibe and, and trying to get there for the community together with them. And I think the absolute win is that although there were opponents as well in this, in this project, I won't... I can't deny it, it was a lot easier to get the approvals from, uh, local authorities as well because, well, if there's a group of, in this case it was 1,000 participants, that are actually the proponents of, of this, uh, specific wind farm, it would be quite hard for a local council to refuse that, being 1,000 people of your own community- Yes proposing this project. Yes. Looking at Australia, what do you think, uh, was some of the lessons that we could take from the European experience? So I would not copy the Dutch model mechanically or automatically because Australia's to... is, of course, uh, fundamentally different in terms of communities, uh, uh, land arrangements, and of course, traditional owners here. So Australia could maybe go a little bit further with co-ownership and revenue sharing, local procurement, community governance. And I think there are some first indications that, for example, the, as I read recently, the, the National First Nations Clean Energy Strategy, that already points towards this, this kind of equitable partnerships and, and greater economic participation. And I think that is at least a good idea to open the door towards a more, well, as I, as I mentioned earlier, it's more about fairness instead of... It, it doesn't have to be equal, and especially in a 1 gigawatt project, you're not gonna get a small local rural community to, like, be 50% co-owner, right? That's- Mm that's not really happening. However, if you are party co-owner, you at least have that- equal share or equal say at the table. Yeah. And have there been instances when the developer's taken it on themselves to bring in the local community? I think that's at least from the perspective I know in the Netherlands, but it also is actually in Denmark and in Germany it's similar. This is more of a business model for them that is common. I think there are hardly any projects anymore that are being developed solely by a project developer, uh, intending to actually, you know, develop the project and sell it afterwards. It's, no, I think that's been quite a while since the last of those projects were, were done Yeah. So that seems very different to, to Australia when- Yeah ... w- yeah, there's a lot of cases when developers will get it up to a certain- Yeah ... certain point. So yeah, I guess from a community spec- perspective, having that, that buy-in, as it were, from both sides for the, for the duration and, you know, is not someone who's gonna put something in there and then move on to the next thing. Yeah, and I mean, having the local co-op being a co-owner, those are the people you bump into on a Saturday morning in the supermarket. So, you know, five years down the line, the project's there and there's, I don't know, there's, there's an issue with whatever, shadow flicker from a wind turbine or any- anything that is, that is actually happening, it's easier to get into contact with the local owner than with some distant company that may be, I don't know, o- over on the other side of the country or even a foreign c- company where you could just send an email to some email address and you hope something happens or maybe just nothing happens. Yeah. Yes. Yeah. But what, what, one of the, uh, the other challenges in Northwest Europe is grid congestion. So for someone outside the in- industry, outside the power sector, what do we actually mean when we talk about grid congestion? I would say the simplest comparison would be a motorway at rush hour, right? There may be plenty of generation and plenty of actual customers wanting to buy your electricity, but the infrastructure between them cannot actually carry that electricity flow at that same time. So things go wrong. Again, look at a motorway at rush hour. Um, the road's there. It's capable of actually handling the traffic, but maybe not all that traffic at that given time. But it also doesn't necessarily mean the, the entire grid is, is full, right? It's, it means that a particular line or a transformer or, um, a region reaches its, its, uh, voltage or stability limit during, uh, during certain hours. That's, that's what it is. Yes. Yeah. And what, what do you put that, that down to? 'Cause the Netherlands is, is experiencing some particularly significant constraints. So how did a country with such a highly developed electricity system get to that point? Is that an outcome of perhaps some of the kind of broader systemic planning that wasn't adhered to? Or like, you know, in your experience, how, how do you guys get there? Yeah. So I think it be- it's because several changes happened kind of simultaneously. So first of all, it was a very rapid household, uh, solar deployment. Yeah. Um, I think Netherlands is just second, just behind, uh- Down behind Australia. ... behind Australia, which is quite surprising for a country where the sun, sun doesn't really shines that much as, as it does here. Second is there's a lot of new wind generation, uh, also offshore There's in- increased industrial electrification, I think we touched upon that, uh, earlier, and there's a real rapid growth of EV charging as well. So, um, I think nowadays, uh, the majority of new sold vehicles in, in the Netherlands, but also in, I think in Germany it's similar, is EVs, and that creates all kinds of new major loads. Above that also, uh, we get data centers. Um, they're not the major issue, but they're becoming a serious load factor as well. So meanwhile, building a substation or a high voltage line, that remains very, very slow. It, uh, it takes years due to procedures like planning, land, equipment, well, not to mention workforce constraints. And I think one thing that hap- what was also the case, especially in the Netherlands, is that the local grid operators, they were simply not ready for it. And that sounds a bit weird maybe, but look at these organizations. They've been around for 80 years, maybe 100 sometimes. And for the past half a century, they had to reply to customers' demands or an expansion of capacity every once in a while. There would be a new neighborhood or a new factory coming online, and they would have to expand their grid a little bit locally. Nothing really major changes. And now all of a sudden And they really have to look forward. They, they need to do forward planning. So that was never part of their mindsets, never part of... They, they just were asset owners and, and maintaining that. And then there's an extra interesting thing is that by law in the Netherlands, they cannot invest before there's actually the demand is there. So just to explain, y- we all saw that energy transition coming, right? It, it was not something that was very much unexpected. However, a grid operator can only invest in their transformers or transmission lines once they actually have a signed contract for somebody wanting to transport electricity. So there's a bit of a chicken and egg problem there. And the result now is that congestion in much of, of the country is, is really apparent. So there's about 14,000 demand-side connections request waiting for their actual connection, and another about 8,500 requests for actually waiting for capacity. Yeah. Sorry. So that's mind-boggling, right? Yes. How these numbers are, uh, you're not gonna solve them with just one new connection. No, no, 'cause I think historically, just to, to recap on your point, historically, we've, we've associated grid constraints with more renewable generation coming onto the grid, so it being more of a supply side issue. But you're saying that it's, you know- It's big ... it's both ends as well. It's both ends. It's the demand side as well that's been, been significantly, uh, increasing. And, and the conference that you and I attended, uh, last week, I think one of the, um, one of the presenters was talking about the electricity demand if the data centers and the population increases and the, and, and electric vehicles and the rest of it is gonna be between, was it 4 and 16 times of where, yeah, the electricity demand at the moment over between now and 2040, I believe. I'll get those facts- Mm-hmm ... checked and we can put it in the, in the show notes. But yeah, it's pretty, pretty significant. So we've got that to come here in Australia as well. Yeah, for sure. I don't think... U- unfortunately, Australia's not immune to this, to this issue. So, yeah, the, the, the major Well, not say solution. There's, there's no silver bullet solution to this problem. Uh, but one of the, the, the things you could do is, is actually proper planning of where your production demand is and how that, um, the time in, in between those, those two is working, right? And moving from the grid to local energy systems. So one response you're seeing in Europe is to connect the generation and demand more locally- Mm-hmm than relying entirely on the wider electricity grid. So what does that model look like? So imagine an industrial area with wind or solar generation, several businesses, battery, and a smart energy management system. Um, so rather than every participant independently requesting maximum grid capacity, uh, the participants coordinate their production and, and consumption using a energy management system. So, for example, a cold storage facility might increase demand when wind and solar production is high. You just go to from minus 30 to minus 40, and you'll have it Go back up again, uh, when there's just a little bit less, uh, production of wind and solar. It's not s- such a bad thing for a cold storage facility. A battery, for example, combined with that can absorb short peaks, and maybe even an electrolyzer might operate flexibly, um, when there's really surplus, uh, electricity available. On the other hand, the external grid still remains important there, but it's just used a little bit more intelligently. And as a result of that, you might be able to use a smaller actual grid connection than you would if you would all independently just have a grid connection in this, uh, in this local energy system. Yes. Yeah. And, and people speak in different terms in terms of, you know, energy hubs, micro grid, grids, local energy systems. Are, are they essentially different versions of the same thing, or is it the distinctions between the- Yeah. You, you hear these terms being used well everywhere in, in a different sense. So they all belong kind of to the same family, but they're not identical. Just to explain a little bit, a local energy system is, is kind of the broad umbrella, right? It's the local generation consumption, flexibility, the governance, and could be even the, the community participation that referring to that local part. But it's not a technological thing, a local energy system. Then you have an energy hub that is actually a, that coordinates multiple assets and potentially multiple energy carriers. So could also inclu- in- include heat or hydrogen at a certain location. And then there's a microgrid that's really even more technically specific 'cause that's a bounded electricity network, um, that can be operated as one system and may be capable of being an independent island from a wider grid. But that has to do with electricity, whereas an energy hub can also include heat or hydrogen, for example. Okay. Yeah. Um, so if you put it less technically, every microgrid is local, but not every local energy system is a, is a microgrid. Yeah. And does that change the way that we think and we look, uh, and, and how renewable energy projects are designed and k- moving from We have got wind re-resource here, so and now developers increasingly thinking about the generation, about the demand, about the storage, about the network capacity all together as a whole system. Yeah, exactly. So development should increasingly begin with, with four time series. Generation demand, storage behavior, and, um, available network capacity. Those, those four. So a site with an excellent wind or, uh, very little spatial constraints, but no grid capacity or no actual customer may be very much less valuable than a slightly weaker site with the flexible industrial demand, for example. Mm. Um, so the best renewable resource is not always the best energy project. So- And that is especially true now in, in these really densely populated areas in the Netherlands where congestion is a real thing. Hmm. I was just gonna, gonna ask you, yeah, just, just on that then, what, what have you seen has been the distinguishing factor between those that work in practice and then what those that sound attractive on paper that don't... haven't, you know, materialized or, you know- Yeah ... haven't worked out in the end? Actually, no situation is the same, so it's always tailor-made solutions, right? So, for example, wind plus solar can be very effective when their production profiles complement each other. I think we see some good examples in Australia as well, and batteries are excellent for shifting energy over hours, reducing peaks, providing, uh, market services, and, and improving connection util-utilization. But flexible industrial demand can sometimes be even more valuable because it avoids the storing the electricity in the first place, right? If you can shift up or down while the wind or, or solar, uh, actually produces, that's, that's super, uh, super valuable. And, um, the example of the cold storage I gave before is really a good and easy example for that. Then you have the, the, the question about hydrogen, right? What, what is... what role could hydrogen play in, in, in the whole System there, and I think it, well, it could be useful for fertilizer, of course, or maybe certain industrial processes where hydrogen is used as a, as an ingredient, maybe for ship, shipping fuel, but only with a credible offtake and sufficient utilization. So most of these, uh, energy hubs we see nowadays, at least in the Netherlands, the smaller ones usually don't include hydrogen yet. Hmm. Um, might be in the future. And when you think in a larger scale here in Australia, it might make a lot more sense, uh, where you're talking gigawatt scale projects or actually exporting the ammonia, in this case, usually as a, as a product. But hydrogen, in my opinion, is not automatically the answer to every surplus electron. It, it has a purpose on its own, and it needs to have an offtake dedicated to this specific, uh, project. Yes. Yeah, we've definitely been seeing that, uh, come to light here in Australia over the last, last, uh, sort of four, four or five years that, you know, we've gone from having hydrogen as the, the Swiss Army knife, as it were- that, that can kind of, you know, plug into any, and we're gonna have a hydrogen economy to being very sp- specific use cases of, of where that makes sense, and obviously being a, being a lot more expensive to, to produce at the moment than, than some other, you know, decarbonization, um, opportunities then, yeah, it, it... I mean, it's a good, good kind of tool to have in certain in- instances, but, uh, yeah, we've, we've definitely come to that realization over here as well. Yep. Um, so what are the challenges of going off grid or behind the meter, as it were? And perhaps you can kind of talk about, about, you know, what behind the meter means. Yeah, so, so behind the meter ba- basically means you do not use a, a public grid to connect the, the generation to the consumer. Yep. Um, so for example, it can be, well, let's take that cold storage plant again 'cause it's easy. We've used it before. You actually install a wind turbine next to a cold storage plant, and it directly uses the energy from the wind turbine in that cold storage plant without the need of an external grid. So of course, it needs a cable to connect it to, uh, but it doesn't use the public grid. Hmm. So there's no grid operator involved. There's an energy management system involved, uh, but it's purely on-site. It's not connected to, um, uh, to the public grid. Yeah. So it sounds simple. That's, that's- ... a fairly simple example, but it comes, becomes more complicated if you try to do that in, we go back to these energy hubs again. When you have multiple companies, for example, on a small industrial area, then it becomes a little bit more complicated because, for example, you've got a cold storage plant, but you've also got a distribution, uh, warehouse, and, uh, I don't know, you've got some sort of factory. They all have different energy profiles, different demands. Once you start adding local solar or, and/or local wind to that system, you really need to have a decent management system- Mm ... to be able to, to make that work. Yeah, to balance the demand and the supply- Pro, uh, profiles and obviously, uh, ha- having sufficient storage in to, to meet those, uh, meet those gaps. Yeah, because you can imagine it requires controls, it requires forecasting, storage, redundancy, and, and I think most important of all, clear operating rules. 'Cause conceptually, usually the arrows all beautifully fit on that, on that Powerf- PowerPoint slide, but operationally, it's, it's every arrow has an owner, and somebody has to make the decisions. Um, there's a contract, there needs to be a backup plan. So it's really, it's crucially important to have an appointed operator that actually has the authority to dispatch this storage or manage the flexible loads and to, to trade in the wider market or respond during an outage, for example. Um- And, and in Europe, have those operators been separate organizations, or how does that work? Like, uh, uh, who becomes- Yeah ... responsible for balancing that generation and the storage and consumption? In the examples I, I am aware of, it's always, uh, something that is nowadays still locally organized between the parties involved, and they appoint a certain operator, call it an asset manager, usually an outside company that takes the care of this actual, uh, e- energy system management. Mm-hmm. So it's not done by one of the individuals. It's also not done by the, uh, the national grid operator or the local grid operator. It's usually, um, a private company that's actually taking care of that. Yes. Yeah. So that's-- It does sound complex, so there are obviously specialists in that area to, uh, to be able to do that and put those commercial arrangements in place. And, you know, what happens if someone ge- either gets a plant sh- sh- you know, shut down, so they're not gonna have the demand side? Or conversely, you know, if they've got, for whatever reasons, they need to work 24 hours in the, in their manufacturing facility, and they normally work 12, you know, what happens there, for example? Yeah. I think the, the whole governance and, and the commercial agreements are the most, the most complicated, right? They're more difficult than the technology 'cause the management systems there, it's basically computer that has an algorithm that tells it when to send what amount of power to what location. But it becomes difficult when things change or when there's a sudden increase in demand or, or... And also, they have to take into account that it is a long-term agreement between these parties, and they may have different credit ratings or investment horizons or, uh, some have different tolerances for, for interruption. So- The system must also survive if one of these participants, you know, fails or leaves or, I don't know, has, has different plans. Yeah, different points. Yeah, ex- exactly. So they, they really require a good commercial architecture and not just in the, the, the engineering or the electrical engineering part of things. Yeah. Yeah. One, one of the thoughts that I had coming into this, uh, discussion was that it could potentially be a lot quicker way of getting things set up compared to, you know, through this transition while governments and network operators take, you know, a much slower approach. But from what, what you, what you're saying, possibly that's not the case. But, you know, how... Uh, ty- typically, how long would that whole process start from concept of a project to having that into commercial agreements and developing the project itself? I think you see a shift in, in the, the time it takes from maybe the discussions you have about permitting or about procurement towards that first commercial discussions with, with all the parties involved. So I would say it takes about two years to actually have these agreements for this energy hub in place. And of course, it, it all depends on the situation, right? How many participants do you have? How many different sources are involved? Uh, the, what is the battery capacity? What is the actual available grid capacity at this moment? Is there any, any left, or are we already constrained? So, but roughly I would say about Two years would be realistic, and then add another... In Northwestern Europe, add another three years for project development. And during that five years before it's actually implemented, you always hope that nobody leaves or, you know, expands their plans or changes their, or makes a different management decision about where their, their factory's going to be, uh, positioned. Um, 'cause that, that's the thing. You, you, you develop these kind of local energy systems for a duration of what, 15, 20 years. Um, that's what the assets take to be commercially viable. So you need commitments for those kind of timeframes. Yes. Yeah. Complex, but not insurmountable. No, and I think, yeah, maybe that's where we started, like that demand and, and production side of energy to, to combine that on a, in a, in a smarter way than we were used to. That's the key to actually make the, the energy transition work. Otherwise, we have to build a whole lot of more, more, a lot more transition, uh, or transmission lines. And I'm really curious, well, how are we going to do that? Um- Let's talk about the Australian opportunity. I mean, you're, you're in a, in a global role, as it were. You spent most of your career working in Northwest Europe. So what's... Now you've been, uh, spent some time here in Australia, I'm sure you've had a focus on that in your role prior to, to coming here over the last few weeks. So what's struck you about the Australian renewable energy market? Well, first of all, I think the, the, the combination of, of scale and speed. So it's exceptional wind resource here and, and solar of course. Well, maybe that, that's something I expected, but I was really surprised about how good the wind resource is here in, in Australia as well. And there's quite a large household battery penetration already here in the market. I didn't know about that before I, uh, started reading about it. And of course, it's the sheer size of the projects and the enormous distances you have here between where the resource is, the communities and, and where the demand is. In Europe, um, transmission line of 100 kilometers would be, uh, well, serious, seriously large distance. Here it's peanuts, right? We're talking into the thousands sometimes. Mm-hmm. And I've also kind of been struck by the complexity. So yes, Australia is one country, but project development differs really significantly between states and between the NEM or the Western Australia and the remoter systems. And I think because developments concentrate in particular regions, so cumulative community impacts can, I can imagine they can arri- they can, they can arrive very quickly and, and be really serious for those communities there due to the scale of the, the projects being, uh, being developed. Uh, it's quite a difference having 200 wind turbines surrounding your neighborhood or just projects of 10. Yes. Yeah, certainly the size and the, and the scale, isn't it? And going back to your point about the 100 k- you know, kilometers in Europe might be equivalent of, you know, you may have more, uh, you know, the same or more landholders you're dealing with over, over that shorter distance than- Exactly, yeah than, than the huge, uh, uh, particularly in, in rural areas. Yeah, I think the other day we were working on, on a project in Western Australia, and I think the size of the actual land lease agreement was the equivalent of the, the country of Belgium. Well, that puts things into perspective, right? Wow. Yeah. So as, as we've been speaking about the enormous opportunity for renewable resources, but it's also very different geography, much less, uh, densely connected el- el-electricity system. So how does that make, you know, how does that impact the local and hybrid systems? You know, could that be even more relevant over here? I think so. So especially at more re- remote industrial sites or really off-grid locations and communities that have, at the moment, very expensive and unreliable energy supply, these local energy systems could be, uh, could be very interesting potential or solution where wind, solar, batteries, they can reduce, uh, fuel use or, um, improve resilience of a, of a local small grid network. Although local does not necessarily mean off grid, right? It, it could be off grid, uh, but it does n- not necessarily have to be. Of course, a strong grid connection is always preferred, uh, over a really standalone local system because it's economically more reliable. Yes. Um, but yeah, it definitely could, uh, could have some potential and maybe for, uh, for mining and heavy industry, um- Yeah, certainly a huge, um, part of the economy over here is, is mining. Yeah, so you see that as being perhaps, uh, you know, o- one of the early adopters to this type of model? Well, they, they're certainly set up for it. I mean, they have concentrated demand at a specific site. The land is usually secured. Most of these companies have a serious engineering capacity and capability, and there might, especially with the current diesel prices, there might be a very strong incentive to reduce that consumption. I'm curious what happens there. But, uh, as long as we, we see these, uh, these kind of price levels, well, at least if I were in their boardroom, I would start thinking about electrifying there. So I think, yeah, there's some, there's some interesting examples. Um, I think there are already some smaller mines in Western Australia I read about that, uh, that have like a local, uh, wind, solar, and, and battery combined to actually, uh, reduce their, their diesel, uh, consumption. Um, yeah, and there's some of the mining companies that, uh, actually are into, uh, into that, although it remains to be seen whether they're actually going to do it or it's just, uh, some really good greenwashing. Yes. Yeah. And then there's, there's... And yeah, there's always that in, in people's, people's minds that... Yeah, so, uh, and we, we touched upon it before about the, uh, Australia's renewable energy zones and, uh, looking amount, at the amount of new generation being proposed. Are there any further lessons that you think we should consider from, from Europe? You know, what, what, what do we look at now before conce- congestion becomes even more challenging? Yeah, I would say plan for your region, not just for an individual project. So that includes transmission, storage, system strength, biodiversity, roads, ports, housing, et cetera, and make sure to have meaningful participation in, in that with the local community while making these plans. And I think there are some interesting examples from, from my perspective in, in the Netherlands and in Germany, where we have this local, I would call it regi- regional energy strategies where these, these plans are made, uh, and where you also... And, and it's, it's planned more on a strategic level, right? About, about these things with proper public consultation, where you can also address maybe some more critical questions about environment or, or revenue sharing without every individual project having to do that over and over again. Because, well, I could imagine if I would be living in one of these rural communities, and there's one developer coming in, then there's the next, and the next, and the next, and well, let's say they all have good intentions, but in the end, you're getting asked the same questions 10 times. There's definitely gotta be some fatigue from the local community, isn't it? Yeah, exactly. And you cannot blame the individual developer. But how about cumulative impacts? Who's going to look at that? That's not gonna be done by the individual project developer. That's something that you, in my opinion, should do on a strategic level and make some, some decisions there. So it's basically, yeah, planning is one of the things you do, uh, you could really do properly to then later on speed up the, the actual execution of, of projects. Is that being done well, well in Europe, more of that strategic community consultation? I think we have, we have a lot to learn as well, so it's definitely not perfect. But at least there's some more, uh, attention to, uh, to that nowadays. Maybe also due to the issues we have with the grid congestion and, and it becomes more, more of an urgent issue Yeah. Yeah. Is there anything further, uh, you know, if, if you were having a discussion or advising Australian policymakers, is there any- anything that you'd get them to prioritize over the next five years? That's a good question. Maybe I'm not really in the position to advise them, but if I would be able to give them some advice, uh, I would say, uh, first of all, what I mentioned already, a coordinated, uh, delivery of transmission generation and storage, right? It, it... Just don't plan one without the other. Second, early partnerships with the traditional owners, uh, regional communities, and actual genuine participation would be crucial to keep support of, uh, this, to keep the support for our, uh, energy transition we, we really need. Look at flexible demand and, and storage a- and, and location incentives to reward maybe grid-friendly behavior. So as, as we mentioned earlier in, in, in this discussion, the grid congestion is not happening all the time, right? It's, it's in certain time of day when it's an issue. Well, if you can steer that demand a little bit away from these crucial times of day, that might help a, help a lot and reduce the, the need for new transmission lines. Yeah. So you, you, you're talking about when you say grid-friendly behaviors, going back to your cold storage option, you d- Yeah. That's a- Yeah. If they- The easiest example ... use excess on the market- Um ... then we'll take the, uh, the energy at this time. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. So, uh, uh, yeah, d- see if you can shift the demand away from the peak load hours. Yes. Yep, yep. Um, and think about a regional workforce, housing, uh, infrastructure planning, because a lot of the projects here in Australia are really, really remote, so it will not be easy to have, like, the, the supply chain and the workforce in place to actually, uh, realize that. That will be quite a challenge, I can imagine. 'Cause the... I think the energy transition is ultimately, it's a social challenge, but it's also a delivery challenge. So yeah, targets matter, but substations, uh, like skilled people and I think the community trust, th- these are what, what convert targets into actual, uh, into actual projects and energy transition. It's, it's not just the people. Yeah, yeah. And you've spent a great deal of your career across, uh, all the project life cycle- Mm-hmm ... but, uh, a lot of your career in the pre, uh, pre-FID, final investment decision phase. So why- as some of the reasons that some projects suc-succeed and then others don't. So what, you know, when you look at projects, what ultimately, uh, have you seen that makes them stall, and what tends to separate them? It's a really, really good question, and if I know the definite answer, then I would probably not be sitting here. There's no silver bullet, but there's a few things that really, that really matter. So a successful project, in my opinion, usually has alignment across six fundamentals. I would say you need resource. Let's talk wind, solar. You need good resource, you need land, you need a grid or a local offtaker, as we talked about it. You need approvals, you need community legitimacy, and you need a credible route to revenue. That can either be selling your electrons to the national grid or selling it locally. And if you have a weakness or a problem in, in one of these six fundamentals, you could probably overcome that, maybe change your design. If you have a weakness in three or four, most projects just don't make it to the finish line. Mm. And I think- Out, out, out of those six, is the, is there a common thread that organizations don't pay enough attention to generally? Well, it, it, it depends. I think the best developers identify flaws early, and also they have an integrated view of all these six, right? They do not treat an EIA or a grid connection or the community engagement as a separate work stream because there's, there's links between those. Some, some are preconditions because otherwise there wouldn't be a project. For example, resource, if there's no wind, well, there's no project. Fair- it's fairly simple, right? But approvals, community legitimacy, or a credible route to revenue are more complex. But not, not to say that if, that if you have managed these, then you, you will have a project because they all, all six matter. And I think, yeah, a, a project rarely fails because, you know, at, at a certain time there's no wind anymore or the, the approval takes a bit longer, right? That, that's something a decent project developer will calculate. It usually fails because five individual risks will arrive on that same day, right? That, that is when, when things go, uh, go wrong. And I think s- another change I've witnessed over the, the past years is, at least in Northwestern Europe, is the withdrawal of the more opportunistic project developers and investors in, in the market. So the ones that remain, they're there for the long term, and they own and actually operate assets and not only develop them to sell them as quickly as possible. And I think the positive thing about that is that the remaining developers, they have more to gain from a good relationship with the local community, and they have a long-term investment horizon and, and project pipeline. So they can also implement the lessons learned from 10 years ago instead of, well, having one project and then just leave or sell. So it might result or I believe it might result in, in building better projects in the end. Yes, that's great to hear. And y- yeah, perhaps you, you read my mind because I was actually gonna ask you what, what the, um, you know, what Europe, uh, and the electricity sy- system looks like sort of 10 years from now. So you're saying they're more of that- Ooh. ... more of that engagement and, and not kind of just standalone. I think, yeah, the European electricity system, it will be a lot more renewable, even th- more than it is today. Will be mostly electrified, in my opinion. Very much interconnected, so with other countries, that's a must, and it will be decentralized system. We're already going there, right? It's no longer a centralized coal- or gas-fired power plants, but it's decentralized energy system. But it will be much more actively coordinated than it is today, with more batteries, flexible demand, um, offshore energy grids, and I think consumers and industries will respond more to when electricity is abundant. It's really interesting, last week, the Dutch government, they announced a dynamic pricing for households to become the actual standard contract form from 2029 instead of a fixed tariff. So the price per kilowatt hour a household will pay, you and I will pay, uh, depends on the moment that you actually consume that kilowatt hour. Interesting. Um, instead of, nowadays, the, the norm would be you have a fixed price contract, and it doesn't really matter that much at what time of day you use that electron. Um- Yeah, I think o-over here it is changing because of that- Yeah ... that, um, you know, rooftop solar and with, I mean yeah. Exa- yeah, the free four hours of free electricity per day, right? Yes. Yeah, yeah. Yeah, we're definitely seeing the, uh, the feed-in tariffs going from, you know, pretty significant to, yeah, practically zero now, the feed it- feed-in tariff. So yeah, there, there is that, uh, you know, time of day consumption over here. And what technology or development are you personally most excited about? Well, that's a good question. To be honest, I'm most excited, I think, about the system integration rather than an individual new technology, because I think combining what we already have, batteries, flexible demand, smart controls, with renewables, that, that is really going to, uh, to be what we need to actually make the energy transition happening. And especially at a household level, there will be a lot to gain from, from introducing, uh, energy management systems in your local home instead of, "Now we just pull or put the plug in the, in the socket," and we don't really think about it. And the technology's already there, right, to do that. Same counts for vehicle-to-grid solutions. There's a lot of EVs driving around. Maybe not yet that much, although I was surprised in Australia how much they're already driving around. That's all, like, potential batteries next to your house- Mm-hmm ... that are now rarely being used as such, where there is a big potential. So the technology's there, the implementation just isn't yet, and maybe that's a little bit less glamorous than announcing some new fancy technology. Uh, but I think making use of the existing infrastructure and existing assets or make them work harder than we do will maybe create more value than actually building another new transmi- transmission line. Yes, yeah. I mean, that, that, that vehicle-to-grid is gonna be, uh, uh, significant and, yeah, seems frustrating that it's sort of taking long- longer than it, it should do. Again, perhaps going back to the complexity that something l- you know, on the surface lo-looks fairly simple, that, uh, you know, a number of players and the manufacturers and, and how that all- Exactly ... all works and fits in. And yeah, if we're having this conversation again, look at, look at the positives. If we're having this conversation again, 2035, what do you hope we'll be s-saying about how the renewable energy industry got right in the next decade? So in, uh, in, in- Oh ... roughly 10 years from now. Roughly 10 years. Yeah. Yeah, yeah. I hope we build early enough because we definitely need this transition to, uh, keep going, but we also share the benefits fairly, have everybody on board or as many people as possible. We protected the important environmental and, and cultural values while, while doing that, and, um, we, uh, deliver, uh, electricity that is dependable and, and affordable as well as, uh, low or hopefully even zero carbon. That will not be by 2035. And I hope we stop waiting or postponing in the hope that we find another silver bullet, whether that's the miracle reactor or hydrogen is the solution for everything, or that one battery technology that supposedly solves it all. I mean, new technologies will definitely have their place, and it's, it's great things being developed every day. Um, but the transition succeeds by making it, making these many parts work and implementing and learning instead of waiting. So the real sign of success will be that renewable electricity is, is no longer something novel or, like, a problem the grid has to cope with. It, it's simply the way our electricity system works. Fantastic. What a vision. It's great, great way to, uh, to close out the podcast. So, uh, yeah, thank you so much, Paul. It's great for you, to have you here in Australia, here in the sound studio. I'm sure the listeners are gonna love the, the, the breadth of, uh, of the, of the conversation that we've had today. So appreciate, uh, your time and sharing your thoughts. Thanks again for having me, Andy. It was a pleasure to be here. Thanks for tuning in to today's episode of Exploring Clean Energy. I hope you enjoyed the show. Don't forget to subscribe so you don't miss any future episodes. I'm keen to continue to bring you the best experts and most interesting projects. So if you have an exciting story to share, please feel free to reach out to me on LinkedIn or email. I'm Andy Marsland, and hopefully see you next time.