10 minutes of expert insights every weekday. Your morning ritual for staying ahead in retail media.
Consumers rate Amazon’s ads among the best anywhere, but it can't break marketers' top five.
===
[00:00:00] Kiri Masters: Good morning, and welcome to the Retail Media Breakfast Club. I'm your host, Kiri Masters, and today I'm going to be sharing a piece that I published to my column at The Drum on November 3rd about how the world's [00:00:15] third-biggest ad platform, Amazon, can't crack marketers' top five platforms.
[00:00:22] Let's jump into it.
[00:00:23]
[00:00:24] Kiri Masters: So Amazon is the third largest digital advertising platform in the [00:00:30] world. eMarketer expects it to take nine percent of global digital ad spend this year, and that is about eighty-two billion dollars that is going to be spent on Amazon this year. And it turns out [00:00:45] that shoppers, consumers like its ads as well.
[00:00:50] In Kantar's Media Reactions 2026 study, which surveyed more than twenty-three thousand consumers across thirty-three different markets, [00:01:00] Amazon ranked second for ad equity behind only Google. The year before, on a pure ad preference measure, Amazon actually came first, with Twitch and Prime Video [00:01:15] also being in the top five.
[00:01:17] Now, Kantar changed its headline metric this year, so those two things aren't directly comparable. They are measuring slightly different things, but the direction is the same. Consumers [00:01:30] like Amazon overall in terms of an ad platform. Now, the roughly eight hundred senior marketers in the same study see it differently.
[00:01:42] In their top five list of [00:01:45] preferred ad platforms, there was YouTube, Instagram, Google, TikTok, and Netflix. Now, that isn't a one-off. Amazon has never been in the top five for marketer preference [00:02:00] as a whole Gonka Babani, the Global Thought Leadership Director of Media at Kantar, told me when I asked them to share a little bit more about how they measure this type of thing.
[00:02:13] So the question [00:02:15] here is, why don't the people buying the ads rate the platform that consumers like the best? As I started thinking about this, there's a whole range of explanations for this, and it's actually easy to start with what [00:02:30] doesn't explain it.
[00:02:31] the first reason that is able to be discredited is that it's too new. Now, Babani, uh, told me that there is a bit of a lag here, that Amazon has only really focused seriously on [00:02:45] advertising in the past five or six years, and that marketers tend to stick with platforms whose measurement and transparency they already trust.
[00:02:51] It is all about a comfort zone. But the counterpoint there is how quickly those comfort zones can [00:03:00] move. For example, TikTok. TikTok launched TikTok for Business only in June of twenty twenty, and it was this year, twenty twenty-six, that it made marketers' top five for preference and for the first time for trust.[00:03:15]
[00:03:15] So, you know, there is certainly something to be said about a more mature ad platform with better measurement and, you know, better sort of socialization of how those results are calculated amongst [00:03:30] marketers. But TikTok sprung into that position pretty damn quick. So I don't think it's just about, uh, these platforms that have been around longer, 'cause Amazon certainly has been around for quite some time as an ad [00:03:45] platform as well now on a webinar that Kantar, presented these results on, Poobani also said that TikTok had been investing in the things that marketers say earn their trust, things like measurement, brand safety, consumer receptivity since their [00:04:00] launch, and now they're starting to see those efforts pay off.
[00:04:04] Now it's just curious to me because Amazon has been selling ads for much longer and investing in the same things, um, making [00:04:15] tons of investment in measurement, in brand safety. you know, I-- on a personal level, I started buying Amazon ads for clients when I founded my agency in twenty fifteen.
[00:04:28] And [00:04:30] obviously, the capabilities have come a long, long, long way since then when we could bid on exact, uh, terms or phrase match. There was really just like manual or auto [00:04:45] campaigns. That was it. in the ad console, um, things were called completely different things than they are today. But since then, so many capabilities have been added.
[00:04:56] a data clean room, the measurement products, a [00:05:00] DSP. These are all things that have grown up significantly in that time, and it just seems like that investment hasn't paid off in the same way, at least in terms of advertisers' perception than it [00:05:15] has for TikTok. So quite curious there. it also, second thing that I had to discredit is the offering itself.
[00:05:23] Amazon has all this shopper data over the last decade. It has bought and built the media [00:05:30] platforms to go with it. It acquired Twitch in twenty fourteen. It became the exclusive home of the NFL's Thursday Night Football from the twenty twenty-two season. It made this clean room, as I mentioned, ava-available globally in [00:05:45] twenty twenty-three.
[00:05:46] its DSP buys well beyond Amazon's own properties and is a very competitive DSP, in its own right.
[00:05:55] Now, when that media actually shows up under a different name, [00:06:00] marketers seem to be more amenable to it. In Kantar's twenty twenty-five US data, marketers ranked Prime Video fifth, but Amazon itself didn't make the list. [00:06:15] Costco isn't scaling its RMN with legacy ad tech and manual solutions. It's leaning into a cloud-centric composable stack. As part of the [00:06:30] Costco Velocity Network, GrowthLoop empowers the retail media team to build audiences directly from the Data Cloud, enabling faster activation, greater relevance, and better performance, [00:06:45] all while maintaining privacy and governance standards.
[00:06:50] The result? Exceptional value and experience for Costco members and better ROI for brand advertisers. Learn why the [00:07:00] GrowthLoop Composable Commerce Media Solution was the right choice for Costco's Velocity Network. Visit go.growthloop.com/breakfast. That's [00:07:15] go.growthloop.com/breakfast
[00:07:18] So if we can't attribute the lack of love from marketers towards Amazon as an ad platform, what is it?
[00:07:26] Well, here's where I landed. Amazon has been [00:07:30] misfiled. It sits under retail media in an advertiser's mind, and retail media to many marketers means endemic brands and bottom-of-the-funnel [00:07:45] sponsored product ads
[00:07:46] now I think that how it got there is really due to a couple of issues and preconceptions on both sides. Now, Amazon itself has made some missteps. I spoke a [00:08:00] couple of months ago about how the FTC and twenty-two US states allege that it overcharged advertisers through its sponsored listings auctions, which Amazon disputes.
[00:08:12] But you know, these are the kinds of problems that [00:08:15] every ad giant platform runs into. Google has had plenty of their own meta, and despite all of that, they still sit at the top of these, the list in terms of preferred marketing [00:08:30] platforms. The bigger factor, I think, is actually how the brand world perceives retail media.
[00:08:38] Fellow columnist at The Drum, Mark Ritson, wrote an op-ed in another [00:08:45] publication a couple of months ago dismissing retail media as slotting fees with a fancy name and a dashboard. And more recently, a report from Ipsos called retail media a creative wasteland [00:09:00] that is devoid of anything that could win advertisers an award at Cannes.
[00:09:07] Now, as I wrote in response to that report, retail media is often a performance [00:09:15] play. The money often comes in from the sales team's budget, not from marketing. Buyers test and refine their creative not with the dream of winning a Lion at Cannes, but with a mandate to actually drive [00:09:30] product sales. And this is all, I would say, rational behavior.
[00:09:36] Retailers sell what they can measure, and brands buy what they can defend
[00:09:43] Now, that's not to say that [00:09:45] retail media is capable of more than it's currently used for, but as of right now, budgets treat it as a channel rather than a layer and an audience. So look, it's [00:10:00] tempting to blame the advertisers and lecture them and tell them, "Hey, you could be using retail media this way, so why aren't you?"
[00:10:09] But I don't think that that is really fair. Uncovering a [00:10:15] buyer's problem and building a reason to care is the job of the seller ultimately. Now, not to say that Amazon hasn't tried. I remember a couple of years ago when I was agency side, [00:10:30] um, Amazon was promoting an in-person training program, on how non-endemic advertisers, as in brands that don't sell physical products on Amazon, how they could use its DSP and tap into all of these audience segments that [00:10:45] Amazon has available to activate.
[00:10:47] And I thought that that sounded great for the agency that I was at at the time, whose clients included brands like quick service restaurants and family entertainment. [00:11:00] But our sales leader had no interest in attending because they were too busy selling Meta and Google Search strategies to clients and saw that as a better use of their time.
[00:11:12] So I think that that experience is [00:11:15] broadly applicable across the board is that Amazon is kind of placed into this box, and it hasn't quite unlocked this reason to care for a non-endemic buyer. And without [00:11:30] that buyer, it stays filed in people's minds under retail media
[00:11:36] And Gonca Babani from Kantar, her prescription points the same way. She says that Amazon already has a very [00:11:45] strong, brand amongst consumers for its ad experience, and she said the key is to showcase that to marketers at scale. She said its measurement capabilities need to be conveyed clearly. But marketers aren't off the hook either.
[00:11:59] [00:12:00] Brand side or agency side, their job is to put the money that their clients entrust them with where it works hardest for the brand, not where the team is most comfortable. [00:12:15] I have written in the past about incentives and kickbacks and all kinds of murky things that happen in the world of, uh, advertising.
[00:12:27] It seems less prevalent [00:12:30] in the retail media industry, frankly, and I spoke with other agency folks, uh, about, you know, to what degree they see kickbacks and things like principal media buying, which is prevalent [00:12:45] in other categories like TV. Retail media, I don't really hear about this happening all too often.
[00:12:53] Now, I think that that is a good thing for transparency. I think it's a good, um, thing for the brands that are, that are [00:13:00] entrusting agencies with their ad spend. But, and I really hope this isn't a major reason that retail media falls behind because that would be pretty sad. So what next? I don't think that either side looks [00:13:15] likely to fix this soon.
[00:13:16] Marketers are probably missing part of the picture, and Amazon still hasn't found a way to be filed away under something other than retail media for many [00:13:30] marketers. For the marketers who are willing to look past the label though, it is a possible competitive opening, an ad platform that shoppers already rate near the top, which most of their peers don't take seriously.
[00:13:44] Maybe [00:13:45] it really is the best kept secret. Well, that's it from me today. Thank you for listening to Retail Media Breakfast Club, and I'll catch you tomorrow.
[00:13:53]