This episode breaks down actionable strategies and growth frameworks used by successful e-commerce brands to scale from zero to eight figures in revenue. It dives into high-impact marketing tactics, team building for growth, and the mindset shifts required to operate at scale. The conversation highlights key levers for media buyers, including creative testing, audience segmentation, and ROI optimization, alongside operational insights for e-commerce operators on process, culture, and technology that support scaling effectively.
Key TakeawaysWhy audience segmentation strategies hve proven to deliver the highest ROI at scale.
The KPIs that are critical for measuring success beyond just ROAS during rapid growth.
How organizational culture plays into sustaining e-commerce scale and growth.
They key ways operators balance automation with personalization in customer experience.
The number 1 pitfall brands face when scaling paid media, and how it can be avoided
How team structure evolves as an e-commerce brand grows from startup to multi-million dollar revenue.
Learn more about the Scalability School Podcast or listen to other episodes head to https://scalabilityschool.com
To connect with Andrew Foxwell send an email Andrew@foxwelldigital.com
To connect with Brad Ploch send him a DM at https://x.com/brad_ploch
To connect with Zach Stuck send him a DM at https://x.com/zachmstuck
Learn More about the Foxwell Founders Community at https://foxwellfounders.com/
Scalability School is your cheat code for building a more profitable DTC brand or agency.
We break down tactical strategies, real-time wins, and tough lessons from three powerful perspectives: operator, agency, and community. It's not theory—it's what's actually working in the wild. Skip the fluff, steal what works, and scale with confidence.
If you're quite literally starting at
zero, I think you just
focus on making a diverse range
of creative that is messaging to these
different types of
people we talked about,
load it into one campaign and allow meta
to dictate where the
spend is going to go.
Because when you're quite literally at
zero, and I know that's not
where most people listening to
this are, when you're quite literally at
zero, you need signal.
To Brad's point, spend is a good
indicator, but another
indicator when you're early on
is just looking at Facebook ad comments
and Instagram ad
comments. Seeing what people are
actually saying to the different
headlines, different
personas that you might be targeting
in this creative, because you might
identify something really
interesting in the comments,
which then allows you to make a change to
your website. For us, we
started with these socks,
we had one style of them, and I'm like,
"I don't know who's actually
going to end up buying this,
but we're going to try to sell it to a
little bit of everybody."
What actually happened first was
that we were starting at Facebook ad
comments of people in the
Midwest saying, "All these would be
great for hunting." I never thought, "Oh,
we'd sell these socks to
hunting," or that category,
never really stood out to me. That's when
we started making ads
that called out that persona,
and that's where we actually
caught fire in the first year.
One piece that goes into all of these
ideas is offer optimization
strategy. That can go across
so much of it and is very ignored by so
many people. Obviously,
you've done a ton of offer
testing. Zach, I think that's something
that you do incredibly well. What are the
keys that you wish would be out there
that people don't talk
about when it comes to offers?
[music]
And now, let's take a listen to the
Scalability School podcast.
Okay, and welcome to episode eight, the
zero to eight, zero dollar
to eight figure playbook.
Here we are, Brad and I, Zach's coming on
just a second. Brad,
always good to be with you,
my friend. Likewise. Zero to eight
figures for the episode number eight.
That's where they have to know it. There
you go. Yeah, exactly.
Really, what we're going through
today is essentially, we talked through a
lot of questions we've been
getting from listeners. By
the way, thank you for those of you that
listen and share it with friends.
Obviously, our listeners
are exploding into the tens at this
point, so thank you. We get these
questions essentially,
how do you put all this together, talking
about a lot of different
pieces, talking about a lot of
different tactics, and what are the
things that you can do, and what's a
playbook that we can run,
and what's the playbook that you guys
run, because there's been enough
consistency in terms
of the performance that you had over
time. And so that's really what we're
going through today,
is like, this is what the playbook looks
like. And I'm not sure
this might be two episodes,
the one, a part one and a part two. We're
going to see how we get
through it, but that's where we
are for right now. So let's go ahead and
get started on the
playbook itself. As we talk about
the part one, start wide strategy. Brad,
this is what you went
through. You said a great example
is loop earplugs. So you start wide, and
then eventually you can
scale wide, casting a wide net.
What goes into this spike start wide
strategy in your mind?
Yeah, so I'll back up one step. I think
what's interesting is we
kind of have gone into, I think,
each of these steps over the last several
episodes. I don't know if
we've missed any. I think we've
gone through most of these. And so we
might not go super deep
into each one specifically,
but obviously you can refer back to
previous episodes and go a
little bit deeper. And if you
have any questions, you can always DM us
on Twitter. We love that
too. But starting wide is
really all about... So if you...
Everybody here, for the most part,
everybody that's listening is
kind of in the seven, eight figure range.
So they've got at least some
success, and they're trying to
figure out how to push it forward a bit
more. So at this point,
you've probably got your product,
at least somewhat dialed in, and you have
a sense of what people
like, and you're trying to scale
it out a little bit further. So starting
wide is really all about
casting a wide net, particularly
with your ad creative and your messaging
around what might resonate
with people. And the example
that you mentioned, Loop Earpugs, I think
is an interesting example
of our two reasons. One,
they continue to go wide, but it gives
kind of a great example of
how you can actually get to
that width as well. And so if you go and
you scroll through their
ad library, what you'll see
is they sell earpugs, and it's not like
earbuds where you can put
in, listen to music. It's
literally like noise canceling earpuds.
There's nothing being played
as far as I understand that.
And I don't know where they started,
meaning I don't know which of these
wide buckets they started in, but you'll
see that they message for
parents, right? Or for sleep,
or at festivals because you want to drown
some of that, or people who
are just sensitive to noise,
generally speaking. And that's what we
mean when we say start wide
is you want to build a bunch of
those pillars and angles that we've
talked about in previous episodes where
you can message to a
lot of different people and you can build
out all of those and launch with a
handful of ads. And we
can talk about maybe quantities of ads
and things like that.
Because when you get those up and
running and you have all of those
different people that you're speaking to
and all those different
use cases, you can start to get a sense
of where do I go from here?
Because if you just pick one,
it doesn't work. You're kind of out of
luck and you got to pivot
and go to the next one. So at
least starting wide gives you a chance to
see when I launch these
ads, this is what's resonating
with people off the bat. And then you can
kind of dig into that a
little bit further, which is
step two. But I'll pause there. Talking
about that, I think one of the things
that is in the old time
that a lot of meta advertisers
specifically have came up through was
that you basically run your
ads to you build a general ad or a bunch
of ads that are talking about your
product. And then you
put those via different targeting to the
audiences you're trying to
speak to. And this is obviously
in the new model where all of us live,
which is you're building
the creative to speak to those
particular people right away, which I
think is just worth calling
out because that's a different
way. And a lot of people think about
this. One thing I'm
wondering in your sense is,
because when I've talked about this
before, the number one thing
I hear is, "Well, how do I,
if I don't have a ton of budget, as I'm
building it from $0 to a
lower budget to $5,000 a month
to $10,000 a month, how do I start to do
this testing in terms of
going wide better?" Because
I think what ends up happening is a lot
of people have done two of these. And
persona expansion is
not necessarily something that's gone.
They haven't tried it a ton and they've
maybe listened to the
earlier episode and talked about it, but
they've started with like two
of them. So how do you start
to test this from a budgetary standpoint
in your... Yeah, I think if
you're... Greg, I'm glad you
talked about the tactical setup because I
think it's a really
important point. If you're quite
literally starting at zero, I think you
just focus on making a
diverse range of creative that is
messaging to these different types of
people who talked about, load
it into one campaign and allow
meta to dictate where the spend is going
to go. Because when
you're quite literally at zero,
and I know that's not where most people
listening to this are, when
you're quite literally at zero,
you need signal. And even if it's not
going to be the long-term thing, it's
like you can't get to
the long-term thing if you have no cash
in your pocket to get to the
long-term thing. So sometimes
you just have to start with what you see
is getting some spend. And I think
getting some spend is
important because if you launch it... So
make all of this creative,
load up a CBO, lowest cost,
cost caps, whatever, load it in there and
see what meta spends
towards. Even if it's not performing
super profitably off the bat, spend is
probably the thing to lean into. And I
know we've mentioned
this idea of spend velocity recently
quite a bit, but that should
give you a sense of where you
should be then focusing your attention
from there. Because meta is
telling you people are at least
responding to this in some kind of way.
They're clicking through,
maybe they're not converting
quite yet. But from a very simple zero to
one perspective, load into
one CBO and just start it
all there. I don't think it makes sense
to be splitting up your
budgets across five different
campaigns, across five different
personas. And I also think you should
just use broad targeting.
I don't think you need to
have coach your targeting.
You don't have to do it too much. Yeah. I
mean, Brett, so Zach, when I go to
Foxhole founders meetups, I meet people
and I know this isn't to
inflate your ego. This is a
real thing. People will say, "Dude, I'm
trying to do what Zach Stuck's
doing. I'm building a holding
company. I've got D2C brands. I have an
agency." And a question
that commonly comes across is,
how are the things that he touches so
successful so quickly? So how do you
think about this in terms
of the step one in terms of the zero to
eight for your playbook?
Talking about step one starting
wide. And you can get into other stuff
too, but what are the pieces that you
think about with this?
Because I think a lot of people are
really curious about
this, including this.
Yeah. I mean, the first hack to all this
is that I invented my own
time zone, which is ZST. So I
can show up 10 minutes late to our
podcast recordings and my podcast
partners don't absolutely-
That's a huge unlock.
That's a big unlock. Yeah. I mean, so
we'll start there. Riley at Homestead
knows all about ZST.
The team at Easy Street knows all about
ZST as well. So no, I
think in all seriousness,
the reality is we take a lot of shots
like this starting wide to
try and figure out just get a
taste of what consumers might be
interested in. So if it's from anything
from a health and wellness
brand, all the way to an apparel brand,
to a Home Goods brand that we owned. I
mean, we started with
making a ton of static ads in Facebook.
That's the easiest place
to start driving traffic to
the website, usually to start. And just
seeing what people react to.
And I think to Brad's point,
spend is a good indicator, but another
indicator when you're early
on is just looking at Facebook
ad comments and Instagram ad comments.
Seeing what people are
actually saying to the different
headlines, different personas that you
might be targeting in this
creative. Because you might
identify something really interesting in
the comments, which then
allows you to make a change
to your website. For us, I've talked
about this on many podcasts in the past
for Hala. We started
with these socks. We had one style of
them. And I'm like, "I don't
know who's actually going to
end up buying this, but we're going to
try to sell it to a little bit of
everybody." And what
actually happened first was that we were
starting to get Facebook
ad comments of people in the
Midwest saying, "All these would be great
for hunting." And I
never thought we'd sell these
socks to hunting or that category never
really stood out to me.
And that's when we started
making ads that called out that persona.
And that's where we actually
caught fire in the first year.
So I think to Brad's point, you just have
to study all of the human
interaction of the initial ads.
And for us, that's why I think a lot of
people don't choose to do
that. They just look in the
ad account. They're like, "These ads
aren't working." You have
to dig into those things that
are the fundamentals, which is just like,
"What are people saying
about the ads? What are people
saying in the first customer reviews?
What are the things that they
might be saying even in post
purchase of why they're buying that might
allow you to then find a big unlock to
just double down on?"
So I'd say if there's anything that we do
in the portfolio brands,
even with some of our clients
that we've had some real success with, is
just digging into that
initial data as much as we can
to try and figure out where there might
be a place to double
down. So that to me is usually
the starting point. I mean, it's
interesting in terms of the starting
wide. The next question
I want to get into is, I would say common
mistakes that are made in this one.
Within the first step,
common mistake always is trying to do too
much right off the gates. I
mean, I've seen that a hundred
times, or as I'm sure you guys have, or
like I literally audited an
account the other day. It's
like, "Oh, we haven't had any winnings."
And it'd been running for
two weeks at a hundred dollar a
day budget and there was 15 creatives.
And I was like, "How are you
supposed to have any idea?"
The financial side of it is like, it's
always my opinion. I don't
know how you guys feel better to
spend more in a shorter period of time
even if you can, rather
than try to spread it out. What
are other... I mean, I don't know what
you think about that or what
are other common mistakes you
guys see? I'm sure Brad probably does
this too. I know Brad's more of a cost
control type of person,
so try to use if there's interaction
happening, then Meta will spend more.
Usually for us, when
we start, we're running lowest costs and
we're trying to gas as much
budget as we can right away
to learn quicker. Because if Meta's
seeing some signal in a 24 hour period,
it will start to move
spend pretty quickly over to a specific
ad. I think this is a
point we've maybe made it in
previous episodes about it's super
overwhelming. Everyone talks about the
million things you need
to do. You need to do all this crazy
stuff on retention. You need to do
landing pages. You need
to do everything. I mean, I truly think
until you're at $3,000,
$4,000, $500,000 a month in revenue,
just pushing traffic to your website is
totally fine. I think that
you can get a lot more unlocks
in trying to figure out on the ad front
of who is actually buying
your stuff and what they're
resonating with. I mean, this is where
the creative diversification
stuff starts to come to play. I
know Brad, you had some thoughts on that.
But to me, we've launched
three brands and we've bought
three brands at Easy Street over the last
three years. Of the ones
that we've launched, it's
starting wide open. We don't know what
headline is going to resonate. We don't
know what pain point
is going to resonate. Even if we have a
super niche single-skew
product, we're not sure what
is actually going to click. I think that
that only can happen
really easily in ad creative.
Not worrying about, "Oh, I need to do
landing pages right away.
Oh, I need to do all this crazy
email and SMS flow stuff right away." I
think really it comes
down to just the fundamentals
of trying to figure out why people might
buy your product and what
starts to click and what actually
starts to build momentum. Yeah, I agree.
I just wanted to add two
tactical things because Zach's
mentioning some really tactical things. I
wanted to add two tactical
things that you can do. One is
along with the comments, reviews, and
feedback, you can add post-purchase
surveys and just ask,
"How do you intend to use this product?"
Or you can say and leave it open-ended.
Or we have a couple of clients where
maybe they sell a protein bar. It's like,
"How do you plan to use this? Is it a
meal replacement? Is it a
snack? Is it a pre-workout,
a post-workout?" And then you can start
to see how they're
actually going to plan to use it.
And then you can make creative that
speaks with the
terminology that they're using.
"Oh, you plan to use it as a snack. Are
you a mom and you need...
You're too busy to make a meal?"
And then you can dig into that a little
bit deeper. The other
tactical thing that I'll
mention is I'll give this away for...
Anyway, that DMS me on
Twitter, if you're curious.
I have a deep research prompt that we use
for all clients that onboard with us.
And basically, you plug in your... I
have... It's a really long
prompt. You plug in a URL
and it will do a bunch of... It'll run
for 20 minutes and it'll
give you a bunch of different
research on this pillar and angle thing.
And it can give you a
starting point for what else...
The other reasons people might buy your
product. Now, it helps if
you have some reviews because
it'll work that into. But if you're
struggling to figure out
what does wide mean and what are
examples of how I get there, that can be
really helpful. So I will
share that if you do get me.
And ask for it. Awesome. Just
value add and get... I mean,
probably get 10s of DMS as well. I mean,
who knows? Well, maybe five.
10s. Yeah. Exactly.
You just have to comment,
look, or scale like that. Yeah.
Yeah, exactly. Maybe on YouTube. Maybe
people need to comment on
YouTube in order to get this.
Yeah, exactly. The one thing... Sorry.
The one thing that Brad
said that I think is super
interesting that people, I feel like when
they're getting started building brands,
don't do enough is use the terminology
that their customers use. So,
I mean, you could be selling
whatever. You could be selling rugs. You
could be selling the
supplement. You could be selling,
honestly, anything. There's definitely
terminology that your customers, your
true customers will use
to define your products, why they use
your products, why they like your
product. That's just
wording that you've never used before in
marketing or in any of
your ads or on your website or
anything like that. Really study that.
They go through all of
your reviews, go through your
Facebook comments, dig in because there
might be terminology that
you're just missing or you're
being too generic about that someone
might resonate with if
you niche it in a little bit
more to the actual customers. Yeah, to
Brad's point, I think
that that's one big thing.
You should definitely spend more time on.
I think we've gone into the
second piece of this as well,
the playbook, which is diversifying
winners. Talking about creative
diversity, talking about
same message, new creative style,
duplicate top ads with new copy. I mean,
copy is obviously such
a huge one that's underutilized. I feel
like expand a new
personas and demographics.
We've talked about this a little bit.
Brad, to you in terms of this playbook,
what does this mean in terms of
diversification for you?
Yeah. So, once you start to have some
spending and performance
going into a couple of different
angles, usually what it looks like is you
have one ad that's
spending 90% of your budget in the
ad account and you're like, "Okay, great.
I would like to have spend,
look, or be evened out across
a few more assets." What you can do is
then just obsessively
pay attention to that ad,
how it's getting delivery, and then
figuring out what you can
do to make it different.
Let's say you have a video ad. And so, I
have David's protein
here as an example because I
think their library looks really great.
So, we can talk about
protein bars again for a second.
So, let's say that you've got an angle
that's working really
well. That's for busy moms.
It's like, "Okay, great. How can I..."
And the thing that's working
right now is a video that's
from a mom creator that is talking about
how well it works for her.
Great. What you can do is you
can go to that video and you can figure
out how do I iterate this?
How do I turn it into statics?
How do I turn it into more moms? It's
just taking that and expanding it across
a bunch of different
things. Totally. I mean, a good example
of... Let's just take that
exact example, busy moms.
The post-it note ad is a classic, I'm
scrolling through David's
protein thing. We do a ton of it
at Hollow. There's such an easy way for a
mom to resonate with a
handwritten note on the fridge,
or on, I don't know, maybe a bag in the
kitchen, whatever, buy the shoes before
you leave the house.
I think just taking those moments of that
customer demo and trying to say, "What
are things that they
would do themselves naturally that they
might actually pay
attention to in the feed that just
feels more organic versus maybe just
another direct response
video that you're basically
changing just the three second hook on
it." That to me, I feel
like is a great way. For us,
we found ways where if we're actually
going to do these written
format ads, which gets people's
attention and they're going to read the
text then on this post-it
note, is trying to take that and
apply it to the use case. Where would a
runner be potentially looking
at a note that they wrote to
themselves? Is that on a gym bag? Is that
in chalk where it's at a
workout facility or whatever,
where it's talking about, "Do 20 burpees
today and then also replace
your crappy cotton socks with
alpaca socks?" I think the biggest thing
is trying to get into
their headspace and things
that they might pay attention to. If,
like Brad said, you find
something that starts to resonate.
Yeah, it's almost a style and a feeling
of what they're doing. It's not
necessarily as much of a
diversifying winners is a part of it, but
it's more about taking
already what you know and just
taking it deeper and taking it in terms
of style, in terms of ad
type, in terms of potentially ad
type, potentially the way it's displayed
like you talked about. I
think that's a super interesting
one, looking at different headlines,
urgency, curiosity,
emotional versus logical appeals.
I think that's a big part of it. When
you've seen this not go
well before in terms of
trying to diversify this, what has been
the mistake? I'll say
the one that I've seen
right out of the gates and that I talk to
founder members a lot about
is they take an angle to an
extreme and then double and triple down
on it and don't have enough
that they've proven. It is such
a niche thing that they think that
there's more there that they're
necessarily might not be.
An example of this is somebody the other
day was doubling down on
essentially people that they
identify the people's like gum health was
an issue. It was like oral
care product and they were like,
"Oh yeah, it's gum health. People are
really interested in gum
health." Then all they did
was make all this scientific looking ad
all about gum health and
that's where they took this and
there was no other diversification. It
was like, "Yeah, there was that angle
where they didn't go."
Yeah, there was one bullet on this and
then it was all in. I understand what
you're trying to do.
It makes sense, but you also still have
to keep that diversification
in terms of the message and
the type and everything else. I'm not
saying that that's not a winning angle,
but there's more out.
You're going to kill yourself. I don't
know what other mistakes you guys see.
I'll just hit on one real quick. For
Holo, again, just to use
our own brand example is
it's antimicrobial. It's like a natural
fiber. You can talk about
the fact that your socks
won't stink anymore. No one really gives
a shit about that. We've
tried it, maybe it resonated
in one hook and then it's very easy for
you to tell your team or to
go tell your agency and be
like, "Hey, go make more ads about this,"
and try to run it as hard as
you can. I think unless one
absolutely pops off as far as a headline
or a hook or some type of
new persona that you're going
after, be cautious to double down too
fast or over index.
Definitely over indexing is a
could be a huge pain point. We've seen
that with Homestead clients in the past,
similar to U-Injury,
where they have a bag that sells to a
specific customer and
that's all that they stick to.
It's like, "Okay, well, you might have
tapped everyone in that
niche customer now that has the
ability to spend hundreds of dollars on
this specific type of bag.
You need to think broader
than that." Definitely have seen it on
both sides. Yeah, I would
just add, I think if I had to
pick one thing, and Andrew, I think this
is what you're alluding to
in a way. I think people think
probably due to the chatter on Twitter,
but they think it's just
diversity equals volume and all
of a sudden, it's not actually diverse.
It's not actually looks
different. All of a sudden, you
look back and you zoom out and you're
looking at a figment board
of everything you've created.
This all looks the same, but we didn't
actually change anything
here. We changed the headline
because we thought that that's what it
meant to create diverse
creative. It's like, "Holy shit,
we actually haven't achieved that because
we just wanted to go and achieve this
volume goal of doing
more and more and more." Yeah. Brad's
seen the inside of... We did this
exactly. We hit a point
with one of our new brands where we got
an obsession of hiring
offshore creatives to just
make a ton of statics for us and got to
the point where we were
making 400 statics a week.
They're not unique enough. They were all
starting to look the same
and also just trying to launch
that many assets in a period of time,
depending on your spend
threshold, can start to break.
So yeah, it's definitely about quality of
swing over crazy volume and
different swing, as Brad's
saying. The ads don't look the same.
David's Protein, great
example of that. Go check out
their Facebook ad library. They've got a
ton of diversity in their
account. I think looking at
the third part of this playbook,
strategic whitelisting,
obviously, is something we've
talked about before. I think to get into
this, this is targeting
places in your... targeting
pages rather, in your winning niches,
partnering with relevant content
creators, and collaborating
with niche influencers, niche, niche,
whichever one you feel like,
depending on the day. I think
this is a big one and one that I would
say we are all coming
around to in the last six to nine
months, and particularly in 2025. I feel
like this is an unlock that
we're all utilizing. And last
year, this was a little bit of a secret
sauce. So strategic whitelisting, how
does this done well?
How do you start to find a few of these
folks? And how can this
be part of the playbook?
Yeah, I think that there's different
levels to it. And we just did
an episode not too long ago,
all about whitelisting. And so if you're
looking for more in depth
information, I think that's
going to be your go to. And I will say
before we jump into some of
the things you can do quickly
with whitelisting to get that started,
the next several things, in
my opinion, Zach, I'm curious
if you disagree with this, the next
couple things that we'll talk about, it
doesn't have to go in
this order. Once you have the thing, you
just need something working,
and that's the whole point of
starting wide, you don't have to go in
this exact order. So
just want to call that out.
No, it should be. It's the Brad $500,000
playbook, you can get it today, $4,799.
And it's quite easy payment in the 97.
Yeah, it's all easy payments.
It's a $20,000 mastermind. It's not a
problem. Brad, you got to
productize your mind. But no,
I understand. I totally get to it. It's
not like these can go in
any way. I agree with you,
but I go.
Cool. Yeah, so I think with whitelisting,
so there's a couple
different levels to it. I think
the easiest thing to do is like, okay,
you've got an angle and a pillar, however
you want to call it,
that's working. And you started to
diversify kind of the creative and how it
looks within that. What
you can do, I think that the easiest way
to see if whitelisting can
at least have some kind of
add additional volume to your ad account
is just like literally create a page
that's like going to
chat GPT, give it context about who is
responding to your ad
right now from a persona and
psychographic information. And just say
like, I need a Facebook
page name, like to go with this
or an Instagram page name, like can you
give me 10 examples? It's
going to give you 10 examples of,
I'm not going to make something up off
top of my head. It's going to
give you 10 examples in your
niche. You just grab that plug it into
Facebook, make a Facebook
page, make an Instagram page,
ask it to generate a Facebook profile
image with that. And then you set this
page up, you duplicate
your top ads that are going to that demo
to this page, and you see
what happens. I think we talked
about this on the whitelisting episode,
we did that ripped. It
doesn't always rip, but it can.
Like we can just give an example, right?
Let's say you're like
a men's skincare brand,
then it's like top gifts for men 2025,
whatever, that's the page
name, or like men's health tips
and tricks, whatever. So you can take
that as for GPT is really helpful. But
just to give like an
example of kind of what we're talking
about is something
along those lines. And yeah,
free to do, spin up a page. You don't
need likes on it. You don't need crazy
stuff. You don't need
cover photos unless you really want to.
Definitely just a
profile photo. And yeah,
like Brad said, it's such an easy, I
mean, spend an hour on it
probably in all reality,
but it's an hour task to then see if you
can get some more scale. So
yeah, we've done this now a
handful of times. I think Brad, if you
want to keep rolling in
through the next stage, I can kind
of talk about the influencer whitelisting
stuff that we're doing.
Yeah. So I think there's
kind of like the adjacent one to the
niche page. You can make
your own niche page, right? The
adjacent thing to that is going to like
an advertorial site that
maybe kind of exists in
your industry. I think the quality edit
is one that I was actually
talking about with somebody
on our team today. Like the ritual is
perpetually using the quality edit.
That's like an adjacent
one, but that is one where you have to
pay for them for access.
That's way more involved.
Just duplicate and make your own niche
page if you need to for the
starting. The next kind of,
next step of this is actually going to a
content creator or an
influencer, like a human being as
opposed to a niche page and working with
them. And there's different
levels to this, whether it's
a content creator that has essentially no
following, there's micro
influencers all the way up through
like mega folks. Zach, I think that's
where you have a lot more experience. So
I'll let you jump in.
Yeah. I mean, we tried kind of a handful
of them, right? We tried the one to
10,000 follower person,
the 10 to a hundred thousand. And then
we've also now more recently
been trying to like 300,000 to
a million five follower, influencer
creator, right? I don't know how much
detail we wanted to send to
a previous episode, but if you haven't
listened to that, basically the playbook
that we're doing now
is we're building a relationship with
this person where we're actually taking
the time to get their
contact information, reach out to them,
send them product, just tell
them that we're interested in
a partnership with them in the future and
just see if they want to
get free product and see if
they like it. It's usually where we
start. So it's a slower
process this way than the micro or
whatever influencer they try out
products. Then usually what we're doing
is we're signing like a
60 day contract with this individual
where they have 30 days to
shoot content and then we receive
it, edit it, and then 30 days to launch
those ads based on that 30 day window.
Then we can go into a
month to month contract or a longer term
contract with these people.
We have found that, you know,
for hollow and some of our other brands,
like now we're spending 30 to
$50,000 a month on just like
these contracts because this is a great
way to add diversification
to your ad account of these
creators that are really good at making
content and running
whitelisting ads with their handles
of the content that they shoot. One of
the bigger hacks though with this is
making sure that you're
not just giving every one of these
partners the same brief. So it's like
writing a brief specific
to each one. Now this is where the amount
of work starts to pick up
and this is where I'd say if
you're doing a million plus in revenue,
this is where you can
probably start to tap into this
part of the playbook. A million plus in
revenue per month. This is
where we have found to get
incremental scale. So there's definitely
been some months where this
is like 50% of our ad spend
out to all the AI stuff videos that we
do, all the internal
editing videos that we do, all the
statics that we produce internally is
this whitelisting ads
that with these influencers.
I've seen some brands spend a million
dollars a month behind an absolute
knockout partner like
this. So I mean, it's definitely
something to look into once you're
spending a few hundred
thousand dollars a month on Meta when
you're trying to feel like
you're tapping up against
not being able to spend more
money. This is a great process.
I think that's all super helpful. Again,
yeah, a lot of detail in
the episode that we reported
about it, but I appreciate going through
the playbook again. It's
useful to hear, I think,
across those brands that are doing well
and the agencies that
represent those brands and the
founders membership for this time and
time again, that this is a huge part of
the reason why they're
successful is they have developed and
have a longer term vision with
whitelisting partners,
which is huge. And they've also done what
you talked about
beginning of their own thing to
some degree. One of them was, I think it
was Facebook page, it was
called Make Your Face Feel
Good. And I was like, that's a goodie
right there. And I probably
picked the... So going into
talking about landing page optimization,
how often do you think
when you start to take
winning creatives, personas, and then
building landing pages
that speak to those particular
demographics, how much does that increase
performance that you've seen? That seems
to be a common... I mean, because I will
say that the times that we've
done this, and I've seen other
people do this, it's easily an increase
in 20% in terms of
performance overall, in terms of
decrease in pack or whatever metric
you're looking at. There
seems to be at least a 20...
It's not nothing at my point. So I'm
curious what you think about
it. And what are the keys of
landing page optimization as part of the
playbook? Yeah. And before I
say that, just one more step
back. It's each option in here too. And I
know I just said that it's not
sequential, but I think
the point of this episode, generally
speaking, is once you have something
working, you can just
look back on this, take your notes, and
it's like, "Great,
something's working. What am I supposed
to do next?" And you just go pick one of
these things and it should
be thoughtful. You should be
intentional with what you're doing. But
the point here is, okay,
when you feel stuck and you have
something that's working, but you keep
running... You add budget
and efficiency just drops,
then you can come back to this checklist
and you say, "Shit, I
haven't tried that yet. I should go
do that." With intentionality. So to your
point, funny enough, in the
last week, we've had a really
fun win with landing page tests. So we'll
just say we have a product
going to an older demo. And
we're straight up sending it to the PDP
founder video talking about
why they created it and the
reasons explaining the product fed up
with all the other options that existed
out there. But it was
going to the PDP, which worked fine. And
this is what I meant, where
you could just have to get
something working. It was working really,
really well. But we took
that video and we just like,
we looked at where's the spend going on a
demographic
perspective. Okay, women. It's
going primarily 45 and up. Okay, great.
Now we know a little
bit more about them. What
did the comments say? Does X point
earlier? What do the reviews say? What is
the feedback then to
the customer service team? And we start
to develop an idea of what really matters
to these individuals.
And then we take that and we turn it into
five reasons why. Just
a quick list of page,
primarily because it doesn't require a
lot of dev time, which I
think we just talked about with
Ryan Donne on, I think that's literally
the last episode. It's just
super easy, very copy heavy,
couple images you can throw in there. And
you can have something up
and running in no time. We took
all the learnings from that and we just
put together five reasons
why in order of the volume
that these things were coming up. Meaning
these issues popped up.
The more the issue popped up,
the higher it was on the landing page,
basically. Since we launched that, I
think we're two weeks
into this, the performance on the
efficiency is doubled. Raul
has literally two times time.
Now I wouldn't expect it to double every
time you do this because
there's a couple things that can
happen. One, landing pages enable more
volume so your efficiency doesn't
actually necessarily
change. You're just able to spend more
because you're spending into
it. Or just generally speaking,
or you just get more efficiency, which
eventually leads to the
point number one there.
So that's been insane. And the way that
we launched it actually
was we didn't launch a
post click experience, which I'm pretty
sure in that episode, we
were all like, you should
probably launch a post click experience
split test. I just
duplicated the top ad and flipped
the destination. And basically what
happened in Meta is day
one, original ad to the PDP
spent way more. Then they closed, then
they closed, then they closed. And day
five, it flipped. And
now it's not even close. It's all this
landing page and still holding on
efficiency and still
cranking. And I just keep adding budget
to it. So that's it.
That's my quick example of what
I've seen recently. It's nice. I mean,
it's nice to listen to a
podcast and have something that
people can fall onto that gives
guaranteed results. You know what I mean?
Like that's just so nice.
Brad Vlog guaranteed.
Guaranteed success. Yeah. The one thing
that I want to add is kind of a counter
to what Brad just said,
which is follows getting the point now
where I feel like we've tried every
landing page possible
that we're only now getting incremental
wins off of new landing
pages that we test. So I think
there's a certain point here where after
you've done it, I mean, I
think we talked about it in the
podcast of Doni. We've launched over 100
landing pages in the last
year. After a certain point,
there's a template that works best and
there's a format and
there's language that you use that
just works the best. So I mean, I think
if you haven't run these landing pages
yet, it's definitely
worth doing. Definitely start with kind
of what we talked about before. Start
wide, figure out who's
buying your product, see what paying
points and headlines and hooks are
resonating, get more into
the creative diversity, then maybe play
around with this
whitelisting stuff or move over to a
landing page. I think to Brad's point,
these are kind of the next two things
that we start to mess
around with. But there is definitely a
point of diminishing returns.
You're not going to get this
double ROAS every single time you launch
a new landing page,
especially if you've already tested
different formats, variants, A-B tests of
what sections show first,
all that good stuff. So I
think just to bring it back to reality on
that other side of it is
there will be a point where
you can't push it much more and then you
lean back into the ad
creative stuff and say, "Okay,
well, what more can I go do there?" Yeah.
I mean, I think one piece
that goes into all of these
ideas is offer optimization strategy. And
that can go across so much
of it and is very ignored
by so many people. Obviously, you've done
a ton of offer testing.
Zach, I think that's something
that you do incredibly well. What are the
keys that you wish would
be out there that people
don't talk about when it comes to offers?
So what are the pieces of
it? I mean, it first starts
with the math. If the math isn't
math-ing, it's never going to work for
you. So I say that when
it comes to like, "Hey, we're going to
offer a discount offers a
dollar off. We're going to test
that." Or, "Hey, we're going to do a free
gift to the purchase." What
does that actually mean to
your margin? And what does that mean to
where performance has to
get to for it actually to
back out? Even with bundling. So for
Holo, great example,
started adding bundles in,
increased AOV up. With that increased
AOV, we were able to spend
more into our CPA. And it worked
out and it backed out and it was
beneficial to us. But I think just
starting with the math of
understanding, "Hey, I'm going to, to
Brad's point in one of our previous
episodes, I'm going to make
this starter pack or whatever variety
pack. And then we're going to try and
sell two of them before
we give a bigger discount." You have to
really do the math on
what is the cost of delivery,
like the true landing cost of that
product at the customer's
door with the discount in mind
before you actually figure out then,
"Okay, is this offer going to
make sense for my business or
not?" So that's usually where we start.
So internally, if we
want to change an offer for
Holo or one of our other brands is we
build on a model, build on a
financial model. What is the
cost of goods? What is the cost of
delivery? Hey, if we add more products to
it, does that mean our
shipping cost goes up or a pick pack at
our 3PL goes up? Yes. So we have to
factor that in. Then
we start to figure out, "Okay, here's our
target range CPA that we can
spend into this new offer."
Which may mean, "Hey, if we can push up
AOV 20 bucks, that may
mean we can spend another $10
in cost per acquisition. If we know that
our CPC or cost of traffic
and conversion rate are at these
baseline numbers, I know that I can get
four more clicks and get the same
conversion rate and it's
still going to back out because that's
where the actual cost of
traffic versus conversion rate
backs into your CPA." So I think starting
with the math and figuring
out, "Okay, if I roll out
a new offer, what could that do? What
will that change my AOV to?
And then based on that AOV,
what can I afford from a cost of traffic
or a conversion rate
standpoint of maybe my cost of
traffic can go up, my conversion rate can
come down, or the inverse
or the opposite or whatever?"
I think you have to take into
consideration that math before you pick
your offer, but that's what
a lot of people don't do. And that's why
they're afraid to do it.
Because some people might say,
"Hey, I can't offer 40% offer. I can't
offer 30%. 20 is my max." Well, if you
push up AOV and you get
people to spend twice as much as they are
now, even after discount,
even after cost of delivery,
your contribution margin that you're able
to produce off of your
CPA not increasing because
conversion rate stays flat, cost of
traffic stays flat, because buyer intent
goes up with a better
offer, that's where the real wins can
start to be unlocked. So I
say when it comes to offer
optimization strategies, start with a
math and then figure out how
you can roll it out and what
it can look like on your site and on your
landers and in your ads. Do
you think when you, with all
these options, the idea in theory is you
have something working.
You're maybe hitting your head
against the glass ceiling and all of
these things are checklist options for,
"Okay, if I look back
and I pick one of these, I'm picking
offer, that's maybe going to help me
break through the glass
ceiling." Is that like exactly the thing
about it? Totally. Yeah,
yeah. So for example, for Holo,
we were trying to triple last year, or
triple last year, double
this year. To do that, I'm like,
"Okay, I need to be able to likely
because we're going to double our spend.
We're going to go from
spending 7 million total in advertising
last year to 15 to 20
million this year. Likely the
efficiency of that advertising spend is
going to go down in theory because those
numbers are starting
to get pretty big. I then need to find a
way where my CPA can go up
and the math still makes sense."
So I basically said, "Okay, if my CPA is
going to go up from $50 to $75 on a new
customer acquisition
cost, how can I make those $25 backup?"
And for us, because it's more of a
first-time purchase,
not a crazy LTV play for us, we're trying
to be profitable on first
purchase, I have to push my
AOV up even more. So that's where I'm
basically saying, "Okay,
maybe we're doing bundles of an
8 pair of socks right now and this can be
relevant to anything,
t-shirts, supplements,
whatever. If I'm selling one, I could
sell three." So we basically
said, "Hey, instead of selling
8 on average in our bundles, let's push
up to 12 and let's not change the
discount." And that,
in theory, just pushed up AOV and
maintained our margin
profile that we wanted to be at.
And that's what gave us that little extra
room to spend $25 more and
still be at the same profit
on first purchase. So to me, that's kind
of like it comes either when
you're stuck and you're not
able to push through or when you're
really trying to scale up
and you know with more scale
that your CPA is likely going to go up.
So that's kind of like the
two points where we start to
figure out, "Okay, what's a change in
offer that could maybe help fix this?"
So let me give you a scenario that was
recently presented to me
and see what you think and
reference to offer and sort of all the
things we've talked
about. This particular company,
or this particular company, they have
one... They have a number of products.
They think they have
three products, but they have basically
one bundle that they push
up. It's men's skin care.
And it comes with all three products and
there's not been any innovation
necessarily in the offer
because it's the same products. And there
hasn't been necessarily
any innovation in the landing
pages. They're sending everything to the
landing page for that
particular bundle. They don't have
the inventory or the money to go out
and... I think they're maybe thinking
about developing new
products, but where do they go?
Obviously, I have ideas, but what do you
guys think in terms of
where they could go? Because I think a
lot of folks get into that.
How do they make that offer
more interesting? Because they don't have
the money to go develop a brand new
product or bundle it
differently. It's not like you've got
five face washes or
whatever. It's like, who cares if you
won? I'm a guy, so I'm going to use one
every day maybe. Yeah,
that's a good one. It's a tough
scenario to try and crack. So there's two
things I think of right
away. One is an accessory product
that can cost less than a dollar that
they can source from
overseas that can add $10 to $12 in
value to their overall bundle that might
allow them to push up the
price of their bundle without
having to push up the price of their face
wash or moisturizer or
whatever else they're selling.
So to me, that's like maybe it's like a
scrub brush or something
for their skin or whatever.
It's like you use this every day before
you wash your face and it's
like this extra tool that's
now necessary to get the best experience.
If you can sell that into
it, that's a good option.
I've seen a lot of brands where they've
added this one-off
accessory literally to source from
overseas is $1, $2, but retail value on
it is $15 that'll push up
AOV $15. So that's one that I
would look into if I'm this company, for
example. The other one, which is an
obvious one, is just
increase the price. Try to find a way to
increase the price where you
can make the offer seem more
compelling. So let's say they're selling
this bundle. I just
googled men's skincare bundles
for 40 bucks, 50 bucks. I'm not sure what
they're pricing it at. What
I would try to do is try to
find a way to, on the front end, through
a listicle or a landing
page, educate why our product
is more premium than anything else that's
out on the market so that
someone that's coming in from
a listicle landing page to a product
page, which is likely this bundle page,
is already anticipating
this being a more premium product so that
that way when the price is slightly
higher, they have less
of a reaction to it. So I think that a
lot of brands don't do
that enough, is talk about how
premium things are and use words like
that. Now, the thing that
you can do with that is you can
always price things up and find ways to
discount them down with
subscription. So if I'm these guys,
I'm doing one of two things. If I'm
focused on one-time
purchase, I'm trying to find this
accessory product that's super cheap to
source and easy to source and
bring it in and add an extra
$15, $20 to the AOV of this bundle and
explain why it's necessary to get the
best experience of the
product. Or B, push the price of the
one-time purchase up very high,
significantly much higher,
discount down on sub and save. Maybe
their CPA doesn't change, but
now they're getting much more
subscription revenue. So I'm probably
going one of those two
options, the price increase thing is
another thing that's in the middle. We've
definitely found at Homestead, we had a
client that was selling a product for
$150. We just increased
it to $250 one day on a
shoppable landing page. Conversion rate
didn't change. So I think if you're
acquiring and you're
trying to scale and 90% of your customers
are new, they don't know what your
product is priced at.
They don't know what it was priced at.
You can take those shots
at Gold to see like, "Hey,
what happens if I add another $100 to
this price?" I mean, my conversion rate
could cut in half and
it could still back out if my cost of
traffic stays the same.
So those are the three.
Brad, I know you have to go by the way.
So Zach and I will close it
out, Brad. We want you to stay
alive and not have your wife kill you.
Oh, it's okay. I can hang tight for a
little bit. We're good.
Okay. I'll just, we'll wrap it up here
then. All right. It's my
collapse. Super appreciated.
Good idea, Zach. I mean, I think it's
kind of that practicality,
right? And if you have more
questions like this, always feel free to
direct message to guys
or email me and you're at
talksalabigital.com. I will just say that
I have only received
messages from SaaS vendors. I've
never received a question actually from
the podcast, which is
good and bad. It could be
that we're explaining things well or they
think I'm a total loser or
maybe it's both. So who knows?
But anyway, look, you can always reach me
and your foxalabigital.com or
the guys on Twitter. I think
super interesting to go through. Guys,
anything else in running through the
playbook that we want
to make sure that we're mentioning? I
think just like this is outside of
starting wide because I
think that's kind of inescapable. I think
you kind of need to do that unless you
have a really strong
idea of what's going to work. I think
this again, it's just a checklist of
options that you can work
through when you're feeling stuck. And
this was inspired for me at
least by trying to build an
internal tool for our team. Whereas when
you're hitting the ceiling
and you're not sure what to
do next or things aren't looking like
they're going in the right
direction, go to the checklist
and then think about it. Just stare at it
for a little bit, pick an
option, commit to the option,
and then roll the test with that. So
yeah, hopefully it's
valuable for you all as a resource.
Also, I have had people DM me and ask
questions. So maybe it is a you thing,
I'm not sure. But it
has been very great. And I've really
enjoyed answering some of those
questions. I think at
some point, it'd be fun to share some of
those anonymously here on
an episode. So yeah, Zach,
anything from your own? No, I think it's
looking at all five of
these things in one tweet would
be overwhelming and be like, "I don't
know where to start." Just chip away at
it. I think a lot of
people try to do it all at once and they
kind of half-ass their way
through it. We've used the
word intentional on this podcast and
full-time. You have to be intentional to
get the results that
you want to see. So slowly chip away at
them, start wide, then go
into creative diversity,
then maybe try a whitelisting page, then
maybe try a listicle, then
maybe if that's all of those
things are not working, then maybe it's
your offer. So I think it's just being
intentional about what
you choose to do versus trying to do a
little bit of everything. Unless you have
a big team and you're
a big brand, then go for it and do all of
these things all at once.
Otherwise, for the 99% of us
out there, just pick one and chip away at
it over the course of the
week and likely you'll see some
progress. I will say, Brad, that one
listener sent both of us a
direct message and you had already
responded to him. I said, "Whatever Brad
says, he's my guru," and
then the person just wrote back,
"hehe," which I feel like is proper
response. So they see you
texted us both or message us both.
"Hey, look guys, thanks for being here
and we'll look forward
to the next episode."
The only way that we grow this podcast is
by you sharing it with
your friends. Honestly,
reviews don't really mean anything too
much anymore. They're really meaningful,
but they don't do a lot for the growth of
the podcast. So sharing YouTube links,
sharing Spotify links, sharing Apple,
whatever we call it under the
podcast app now, anything you
can share, the better we're going to be.
Guys, anything else
you want to say on this?
Yeah, please go check us out on YouTube,
rack up those views for us.
We'd love to see it. And then
subscribe. Make sure to subscribe on
YouTube as well. And I
relentlessly refresh the YouTube
comments because it dictates my mental
health for the day. So please say
something nice about all of
us. Thank you everyone. Thanks for
listening. Honestly.