The Promote Podcast

The Promote's first live show in New York brought together an invite-only crowd for cocktails and a no-holds barred conversation about capital stacks and characters. Our special guests were Iron Hound's Robert Verrone, one of the country's preeminent workout specialists and formerly head of Wachovia's real estate group, and Joe Lubeck, founder and CEO of American Landmark, one of the country's biggest multifamily investors.

Special thanks to Gaby Rosen of RFR Realty for hosting us, and to Ike Marvet and the World Wide Land Transfer team for their support. 

What is The Promote Podcast?

Your Commercial Real Estate Insider guide. From profiles of the biggest dealmakers to skyline-shaping transactions, we bring you the deals, breakdowns and war stories that move the market — for insiders, by insiders. From bad-boy guarantees to CMBS tranche warfare to syndicator sins, we cover it all.

Each week, The Promote Podcast explores three of the most interesting and consequential stories in CRE, taking you well beyond the headlines and into the heart of the action. Hosted by the award-winning “Bard of CRE,” Hiten Samtani, along with no-BS institutional insider Will Krasne. Now a top 80 pod on Apple in "Business & Investing." Also check out our 3x/week newsletter for industry insiders at https://www.thepromote.com/

Hiten Samtani (00:03)
Hey everybody, it's Hiten and Will. On November 5th, we had our first promote live event at a swanky secret location in the heart of Manhattan.

Will Krasne (00:11)
It was an absolute blast. We talked with a lot of you there, which was fantastic. We saw lots of great people. We had guests, cocktails, kosher food, the whole ten yards.

Hiten Samtani (00:21)
And we recorded the whole thing and wanted anyone who couldn't make it to be able to listen in. So, as a special Friday treat, here's our inaugural promote podcast live.

Joe Lubeck (00:30)
Yeah.

Hiten Samtani (00:37)
This is the Promote Podcast, your insider guide to the money and mania of the CRE markets. I'm Hiten Samtani

Will Krasne (00:42)
Will Krasne.

Hiten Samtani (00:43)
Thank you so much for being here for our first live event. It means a tremendous amount to us to have you here. Give it give yourself some applause. Yeah.

It's like one of those things you throw a party will people show up, and the fact that you're here, that you engage with us, you understand what we're doing means a lot to both world.

Will Krasne (01:00)
It really does. Sometimes you feel like when you're sitting in your bathroom closet recording this thing, it's talking into literally. Well, I've moved up to an office. You you forget that there's people on the other side of this and it means a lot that you listen, means a lot that you enjoy it, and thank you so much for coming, for listening and being a part of this.

Hiten Samtani (01:20)
This is gonna be quite an unusual show if you're used to the standard CRE evening. It's not gonna be that, I promise you. We're gonna have a very spicy, informative, very specific discussion about what moves the market. We're obviously in New York City, so we're gonna focus on New York. There's a few acknowledgments I wanna make in the beginning. So Gaby Rosen, Gaby, if you're around, Gaby, don't be shy. There you are. Gaby and the entire RFR team, especially Deloitte as well, for your all your hard work giving us this stunning view in Manhattan.

Gaby, to your credit, you really understood the promote from the very beginning and you've been a big champion. Thank you so much.

Will Krasne (01:55)
And thank you for being a wonderful landlord to me, six floors up. So I really appreciate that.

Hiten Samtani (02:01)
You should probably jack his, you know, his rent up 'cause he can't say A B's name, right? That's fine. Ike Marvet and the Worldwide Land team. Thank you so much for your support for this evening. It it really means a lot that you understand what we're trying to do and hopefully this is the the start of a long partnership between us.

Will Krasne (02:18)
It's already a partnership because I use you guys for some title work and we closed something with you two weeks ago where the seller gave the wrong wire instructions and the wire bounced back twice and you had to FedEx a check. So appreciate the hard work.

Hiten Samtani (02:32)
In special situations, these guys coming through. We have to shout out the missuses. Saya who's helped us put together this event tonight. Thank you so much. Love you.

Will Krasne (02:42)
And my wife Megan, who is sitting back there with my buddy Artavan. Thank you so much for the support, for making everyone in the apartment be quiet when I'm recording. Love you very much.

Hiten Samtani (02:53)
Also wanted to shout out Aharon Dinowitz and Eric Shuval for helping us bring Joe Lu back in, who's our guest later tonight. And finally, you're hearing us now in the flesh. Normally we sound a lot better. And the reason we sound a lot better is that producer Jay, Jay Cowitt, right there. This is the genius who makes this the show week to week sound as incredible as it does, who pulls in all the the movie quotes and all the trivia and all that stuff. So big ups to you. Thank you so much. This would not be what it is without you. Truly. All right.

Let's get started with the punch list.

Will Krasne (03:25)
Our signature rundown of the newsiest news in CRE.

Hiten Samtani (03:32)
So normally we do this with like a, you know, very specific newsy nuggets, but since this is a live show and a special thing, we wanted to zoom out a little bit and do some thematics. So the first one is what we've been thinking about as the everything store of CRE finance, Apollo.

Will Krasne (03:46)
Yeah, and it's like Apollo Creed when he's like, I'm not a man, I'm a machine. And that's uh that's Apollo here. And they're really doing something interesting. They're filling the void. It's really hard to raise equity. You can raise capital for debt, you can raise capital for Mes, you can raise capital for Code GP, but equity is really tricky, especially core, core plus. And Apollo is thinking, All right, might be an opportunity to put out my like giant t-shirt cannon of insurance money into really nice risk rewards.

Do you want to come up and talk about it?

Hiten Samtani (04:18)
We actually have someone in the audience who wrote what I think is the definitive piece on how Apollo does this, right?

Will Krasne (04:25)
Yeah.

And it's sort of fitting away too. Deal specific underwriting and getting capital for deals is really tricky. And everyone wants like a VIG on the side. So it's like, can I buy into your opco? Can I get part of your GP? Can I have some other like vertical integration that allows me to make more than just the deal level returns? And this is sort of what they're looking to do. They're like, we're gonna structure this to hell. We want minimum distributions. I think there's like make hole in here somewhere with shares. I

Hiten Samtani (04:54)
We'll probably talk about the UDR deal 'cause that's the top of mind right now.

Will Krasne (04:58)
Yeah, and that's basically just pref, right? Like it's, you know, billion three of equity, but it's it's really pref and they have what the sizing to a you know, they can get taken out at a seven and a half IRR or something like that. And it's interesting though, because rates have been so volatile. Today was bad day for the equity markets, great day for the bond market. So if that runs the other way, maybe, you know, that gets a little bit trickier for Apollo and people don't need to go to that everything.

Hiten Samtani (05:21)
You had you had a really good line where you said Apollo is not solving to deal level returns. We'll do a deal, the deal has to work or it doesn't. Apollo's kind of evolved past that.

Will Krasne (05:31)
Yeah, it's like the next phase of evolution which we should all aspire to, which is like the deals are sort of secondary to Yeah, the platform. A friend of mine used to say or still says, if you can raise it, you can do it. And Apollo can raise it.

Hiten Samtani (05:44)
Okay. Next one.

Since we're in Lower Manhattan, we we have to talk about this, the way that this neighborhood is transformed. There's two pronunciations depending on which way you swing. It's either Hamish or Hamish, right? And Lower Manhattan has been there's been this incredible transformation of who is calling the shots. And it's the Hamish. It's the Orthodox builders who've come back. Not since the Reichmans willed Battery Park City into existence, has it been this fascinating a cast of characters in here?

Will Krasne (06:14)
Well, first of all, I want to thank the Reichmanns for, you know, building battery parks so I have a place to live, which is I really appreciate and my son really appreciates all the parks. But yeah, it's it's interesting because you look at these buildings across the street or i the buildings in the sixties or seventies, like you could just buy an office building and you're just rich and every like six or seven years, like, all right, refi, like take out massive amount of capital.

Hiten Samtani (06:37)
This was the model for the families for decades.

Will Krasne (06:39)
And all these things are now depreciated with no basis and you're sort of stuck like having to spend tons of capital to bring things back. The way to do that is to like reset your basis. You're seeing new folks come in. So Yossi Hoffman. Yeah.

Hiten Samtani (06:52)
Bushberg has been buying up everything at the Rudin family's 80 pine. They're doing an office to resi there. They're buying into two bridges as well. And that one's like a I don't know if Mexican standoff is the right, the right word for that, but that dynamic is fascinating.

Will Krasne (07:04)
Like the in reservoir dogs. Yes.

Hiten Samtani (07:06)
Yeah. Yeah. So in two bridges, there's this kind of unusual situation where you have every developer is kind of codependent on the other because they have to all contribute to the MTA station and some other public improvements. And so

One cannot go without knowing that the other is gonna go. And so it's ended up in the standoff, you jump, no, you jump, no, you jump. Now Shit owned one of the sites, Michael Stern owned the other, and Gary Barnett owned the third. Front of the pod. Front of the pod. Yeah, Michael Stern. Gary Barnett is now selling to Bushberg. And the reason that Bushberg is buying is because the Shatreet site, which has been mired in distress for God, five years, I think. Or now I think. Yeah, Shitreet's taken some hits. But he is now been

replaced and Simon Dushinski, the legendary Rabsky group developer, is now calling the shots there. So because he can do that, this is all turning.

Will Krasne (07:58)
Simon's old partner's son in law. Yeah. Is uh

Hiten Samtani (08:01)
Goose.

Talk to me, Goose. Yeah. Sarah?

Will Krasne (08:04)
They're buying forty five broad, I think too. Correct.

Hiten Samtani (08:06)
So this was again one of those perfect sites to illustrate what's going on. Forty five Broad Street was owned by Bob Gladstone of Madison Equities, then was bought by a Chinese developer, and this is when the Chinese were hoping to transform the city. And since it's been taken over by Isaac Katz of Goose. These are guys who know how to build to a budget and can move things forward.

Will Krasne (08:26)
Yeah, tough times make good builders, good builders make too many buildings, too many buildings make bad builders, and then bad builders make good builders. No, something like Okay.

Hiten Samtani (08:34)
Next one

Rob Verrone (08:36)
Yeah.

Hiten Samtani (08:37)
This is a I gotta give you credit for coining this phrase. Uh we're gonna talk about men with deep pockets, which is a signature promote line.

Will Krasne (08:44)
One of the best because, you know, again, in this time where paper wealth has never been greater, there is still something to be said for someone who can splish the put whenever I like.

Hiten Samtani (08:55)
Before I knew you had tweeted like every single real estate guy has a lot less cash than you think. That's bearing out.

Will Krasne (09:02)
Correct.

Joe Lubeck (09:04)
Who

Will Krasne (09:06)
Ask me how I know.

Hiten Samtani (09:07)
uh

What is happening? There are men with genuinely deep pockets from other industries who are stepping into a lot of these built

Will Krasne (09:13)
One

we wanna talk about was I don't know if her I'm sure I pronounced that incorrectly.

Hiten Samtani (09:17)
If you don't know Will or you're new to this podcast, Will has a Will's not good with names, let's just put it that way.

Will Krasne (09:22)
Yeah, I've like you know

that that guy. Um so he's bought what, one Whitehall, one one Greenwich, seven sixty seven third, and you're buying two of these again from families. Yes. So I think Rudin

Hiten Samtani (09:35)
The Rudin family and the Sage family. So two of the dynasties of real estate. So they're coming in, they're what is the bet exactly?

Will Krasne (09:41)
Rates are moving all over the place. The future is unknowable. Un unknown. You can rely on basis and also if you're cash, if you're buying like heavily cash, you don't have to carry this thing as much, which you know makes the IRR look worse. But a lot of times some of these guys maybe can't spell IRR and that's they're better off for it.

Hiten Samtani (09:59)
They're probably better off. And where are they coming in from? So Idan is a a shipping man, as they used to say. The other big, big player in this was a guy called Teles Mystakidis. I think he's a copper multibilionaire. We're going to talk about this with Joe later on. Real estate for a little while had become like a get rich industry, but what it really is at the heart of it is a stay rich industry. And so these people know that very well.

Will Krasne (10:22)
And of course a tax deferment industry.

Hiten Samtani (10:25)
Exactly. All right. Next one. We have a little surprise. When I started on this beat, I was fanboying over this gentleman that we're gonna bring up for a second. But this gentleman has probably seen more capital stacks than anyone in this room, and that is a big statement given the quality of this room. So Rob Verrone from Iron Hound, please join us up here.

What do you mean?

Rob Verrone (10:52)
I can't drop any F bombs or anything? I gotta

Hiten Samtani (10:54)
I brought you in from Cripriani, you were just down the street.

Will Krasne (10:56)
We're

gonna get demonetized.

Hiten Samtani (10:59)
Rob, thank you so much for being with the promote. What we want to talk about with you, I think you have probably the greatest insight on. First as a lender. Rob, by the way, for those who came in late, has one of the coolest nicknames, former coolest nicknames I've ever seen. He was known as large loan varone in the run-up to the GFC. But now he is on the other side of it. He's a cap stack surgeon at Iron Hound. What we wanted to talk about with you, Rob, is the great cap stack reset where it's still New York City. These are still incredible properties.

But there is a reckoning that is happening kind of in the underbelly of the cap stack.

Rob Verrone (11:32)
Everywhere in the cap stack, right? It's senior mortgages are distressed, mes pieces are distressed, pref is distressed. So everyone had a great Argus model or a great IRR model, and they're all wrong. A lot of it's wrong because, you know, no one's uh pro forma's ever worked, everyone's budgets was off. And uh, you know, it's it's not just interest rates. Like there were just a lot of shitty operators out there who were given a lot of money over the years.

Hiten Samtani (11:57)
But a lot of the shitty operators are coming back to operate those buildings again.

Rob Verrone (12:01)
are

able to restructure the deal and bring in money, they could find a way to to save it again. But it doesn't mean that, you know, version two is gonna work out any better.

Will Krasne (12:08)
I like the guys who lost the building and then buy it back because you're like, the second time we're gonna figure it out. It's like, you know, we're gonna get divorced and then we're c gonna have another kid and come back together.

Hiten Samtani (12:18)
Rock Point at a hundred somewhere in Boston. That's an incredible example. I think they're buying it at a third of their original purchase price.

Rob Verrone (12:24)
Two

people who buy their debt back. There's the person that during the workout figures out a way to do a consensual deal or get a last look or buy it when it's auctioned by CBRE or something. And then there's gentlemen or our borrowers who literally just wait. So we've done deals where eight years ago we had a workout that didn't work. And eight years later, the CMBS lender or someone pukes it out and we're buying it for 10 cents on the dollar eight years later, right? And where we probably offered 50 cents on the dollar five years ago.

So

Will Krasne (12:54)
So what happens of the building in that intervening period? Because they're getting cash starved and it costs again money to release these things. Sure.

Rob Verrone (13:01)
Or there's a beautiful thing called advancing in in the C MBS world and you know sometimes the advancing pays for things, other times they leave the building empty and the lender just chooses to pay the property taxes. And by the way, some of those bets, more often than not, they don't pan out, but some of those pan out, right? You sit around for a long time and you know, rising tide just just bails you out.

Hiten Samtani (13:22)
You spend a lot of your time with the special servicers who are representing the bondholders. Has there been some sort of come to Jesus moment? Because we're seeing so much of the stuff finally move. I've heard a lot.

Rob Verrone (13:33)
I don't know if there's a larger percentage, whether it's number of loans or are UPB that are getting modified or moving now than there were 10 years ago. The business has changed drastically from 2008, right? So 2008 you had L and R was a special servicer and L and R owned the bonds. CW Capital was a special servicer and CW Capital owns a bond. Now you have a controlling class representative.

So there's all these different agendas. It's what happens in the cap stack and how everyone's positioning themselves, who has a bonus they're trying to get paid by the end of the year, who doesn't want to take a loss by the end of the year, who, if they do take a loss on that bond, they get wiped out and someone else gets in control. It's it's so much more than what's the property worth. And that's really what it's supposed to be, right? How could I make more money than foreclosing? That's sometimes sixth on the list, right?

Hiten Samtani (14:28)
Will has this great line about career risk and that that that's really what it is, right? I

Rob Verrone (14:32)
Say this now at this point in my life because I don't care if people get mad at me, but if we don't do a workout, I don't get paid, the borrower loses the deal. But the truth is, the special servicer, if they're wrong, they foreclose and they rejected my 50 cent offer and they sell it for 30, they don't get fired. Like no one gets paid less. So they don't have as much. Yeah, there's someone in the bond stack that may get clipped a little bit, but when the incentives aren't a hundred percent there, where if you're wrong and you're wrong a number of times, you

You could argue maybe you get downgraded by the rating agencies or maybe you don't get hired on enough deals, but lenders are wrong sometimes, right? But borrowers are also ridiculous, right? So borrowers will literally have a hundred million dollar loan and they'll try to convince me the property is worth 50. Yeah. But meanwhile, when they're going to get another loan, they're putting the property worth 150, right? And they're, you know, or there's three buildings that sold for 700 bucks a foot and they want me to try to convince someone it's worth 300 bucks a foot.

Hiten Samtani (15:28)
Part of what you're doing is amateur psychologist a little bit, talking these people off yes, talking people off a ledge a little bit and and helping them come to whatever the reality is at that moment. Or, you know, reality plus sofa, let's say.

Rob Verrone (15:41)
We have a a reputation and what I tell my borrowers all the time is sometimes I'm gonna fight with you and these are guys who've engaged us and paid us a fee and expect us to work for them. Like sometimes I'm gonna fight with you more than I do with a lender, right? There's only so far you're gonna push a lender and there's only so much kind of BS that you could feed them. And then it's just reality. We try to keep everyone honest as best we can. We work for the deal. That's really the way we like to say it at the end of the day, right? But we know who pays us. We we we don't we don't forget that.

Hiten Samtani (16:10)
If you could share one war story from from your time, I know you don't want to talk about specific clients. You'll figure a way out. Yeah.

Rob Verrone (16:16)
One war story. I mean there's tons of war.

Hiten Samtani (16:19)
You got the scars, so I want to hear about

Rob Verrone (16:21)
Six six six Fifth Avenue when we did that deal for the Cushners and then Bornado came in and uh you know we ended up selling a light in Aries.

Hiten Samtani (16:29)
Vornado came in with this hostage pref, right? Is that right?

Rob Verrone (16:31)
It was a consensual deal between Charlie Kushner and Vornado. And at the time, Vornado owned the special servicer, right? So Vorneto was the owner. So when Wendy Silverstein came in, she was negotiating for guys that worked for her. So it was just an interesting deal. And then we sold the light and air easement to Barry Sternlick so we could build the Baccarat Hotel and we're able to use that money, which is really the lender's money, if you think about it. We we used that money to be our new capital that we committed. So it was a fascinating deal and it worked out for everyone.

Hiten Samtani (17:02)
Thank you so much for being with the promote. Thank you. Pleasure.

How's everyone feeling? You can hear us okay? All good at the back? Blake, you're my sound check back there. You good? Okay. So we're very fortunate because of what we do to know a lot of big players in the business. But what Will and I really look for are the cowboys.

Joe Lubeck (17:30)
See how

Hiten Samtani (17:31)
That's what we want. There's enough suits out there and they're not interesting. Will, as you like to say, they make widgets.

Will Krasne (17:37)
Yeah, someone I won't say who said I went to a company that had, you know, two billion of AOM and we made Ferraris and it was fucking awesome. And then I left and we had many, many multiples of that and we made Toyotas and it sucked.

Hiten Samtani (17:52)
Yeah. And so we're very, very, very thrilled to have someone here who we consider a real cowboy. And we spent a little time with him on the prep call and we we both called each other out. And we're like, okay, this is this is gonna be great. So Joe Lubeck is the founder and CEO of American Landmark, which is one of the country's biggest multifamily players. But the way he thinks about the business and the way he talks about the business is such a refreshing change from a lot of the stuff out there. So very happy to have Joe. Joe, please join us.

Joe Lubeck (18:22)
Well it's a tough act to follow with Mr. Barone who's an industry legend and uh some great repartee and w we have uh also our share of war stories, but probably not as entertaining as some of his I think

Hiten Samtani (18:35)
I think you're gonna do just fine. I'm gonna share. We were so excited when we had Joe. I actually considered and I asked Sai who put this together. I'm like, can we call RFR and see if they'll allow us to smoke a cigar indoors? But they didn't go for it. Still honored to have you. Where do we want to start with Joe? Will

Will Krasne (18:53)
Talking about Cowboys and Suits, there's a lot of different ways to go about this business. And someone who started their first property was a hotel where it's another fine landmark property from the beginning. And then eventually spinning out on their own. What was it like when you put all of your capital on the line? And it's not enough capital to call it capital really at that point. It's like all the dollars.

Hiten Samtani (19:22)
And Joe, I should I will add to that, you didn't come from means. You you figured it out. So losing money at that time meant quite a bit. You didn't mu have much of a fallback.

Joe Lubeck (19:31)
No, there was no backup plan. There was absolutely no backup plan. But I appreciate being described as a cowboy because I consider myself pretty much as conservative and low key as it comes. Okay. But I have known when to take reasoned chances. but I also came from nothing. Literally I lift home at fifteen with four hundred bucks. How I ended up in the apartment world I can only say was God's plan. You know, man plans and God laughs and

Hiten Samtani (19:59)
Tracht and got laughed, yeah.

Joe Lubeck (20:01)
So I grew up with my grandparents and my grandfather came from also nothing and he had to go to work in fourth grade. My grandfather thought it was a good idea for me to go to work in fourth grade. And so literally he would get me up at four thirty in the morning, five o'clock I'd go to work. This is fourth grade, fifth grade, sixth grade, seventh grade. I would have to go to work at this terrible apartment building. I grew up in a decent but lower class neighborhood in Philadelphia. And I would have to do every horrible job there was, take out the trash.

pick up the dog poop, mop the floors, shuffle the snow when appropriate.

Will Krasne (20:35)
Megan, are you listening for Nico?

Joe Lubeck (20:37)
Then and

Hiten Samtani (20:37)
Builds character.

Joe Lubeck (20:38)
it was good training. Um and I still get up at 4 30. It's bred into my DNA at this point. I would uh go to school and then I'd come back after work and be the assistant maintenance guy carrying the tools. And I remember at that time saying, I want nothing to do with real estate and I certainly want nothing to do with apartments.

And I was gonna be a lawyer. I ended up working my way through college, got a master's, worked my way through law school, and I said, I'm gonna become a corporate lawyer and work in Delaware and make corporate law. I ended up getting a very nice job with a fund here in New York that has long since been bought and bought and bought. Um, but it worked out very well. I advanced pretty quickly and was making reasonably good money for a guy who had nothing. And thank God I married a wonderful woman who was sent to me first class, first day of law school and

was assigned as my study partner, amazingly enough. At some point I had seen what was going on in the fund, and I was also overseeing a number of different industries, both real estate, manufacturing and others. One of those was apartments. And the CEO of the fund came to me and said, We're having problems with this apartment fund. I heard you know about apartments, go fix it. And of course I didn't want to disabuse him of the fact that it was fourth grade that I learned about apartments.

And I said, sure, I can go fix it. And in fact, I did. And I went back and said, I want to be the CEO. And he said, Joe, we love you. We're going to give you a promote. We're going to give you equity. We'll give you whatever you want, but you can't be the CEO because you're too young. They wanted a guy who looks like me now with no hair and a gray beard. And so they hired the gray beard guy. And under very favorable circumstances, I left and gave up what at that time for a kid who grew up with nothing was a very nice paying corporate New York law job. And

Told my wife, honey, we're gonna invest all our money in a defaulted um ninety unit former motel in St. Petersburg, Florida. And I went from being a New York corporate lawyer to being the maintenance man. And the sign you're referring to, I put up a big sign in the front that said another fine landmark property. And it was neither fine nor was there another. It was the only one. Um but I I really felt that based on some fundamentals that I had learned that I could be successful, and I was one of the first.

major movers to the Sun Belt. I saw what was happening at that time. I said, I want to be in the Sunbelt. There's no unions. It's politically favorable. It's tax

Hiten Samtani (23:00)
Well T B D now, right?

Joe Lubeck (23:01)
Yeah. Well you never know now. But before there's gonna be rent control and things of that nature, or before w w when we have right to work states and the job growth and population growth drives everything and it's still continuing.

Will Krasne (23:13)
Are seeing anything though on supply though too? Because that's something I've had a lot of conversation about, which is population growth and job growth really helps the demand side of the equation, but there's the other side of the equation too, which is how the Sunbelt has been a graveyard for some folks the last handful of years.

Joe Lubeck (23:27)
Well, I've been through four or five cycles. So I've seen this before. The bankers move in herds. Yep. Right. And so do builders. So they all do their study and the bankers say, Well, by the time this guy screws up, I'll be in another job, so I won't get the blame. And they let the coffers open and way too much gets built, and then nothing gets built. So we saw overbuilding, not just in the Sunbelt, but everywhere. But I look at the ratio long term of not existing units to new units. I look at jobs.

It's a new unit.

Hiten Samtani (23:58)
We'll talk about market fundamentals more in a minute. So much of this starts and ends with relationships. You built a relationship with is it the Salkin how am I saying it wrong? Yes. Family.

Joe Lubeck (24:07)
I'm all confessed.

Hiten Samtani (24:08)
The Sulkins family out of Israel, a massive conglomerate. Yeah. Elko. That is the kind of move that can set up a company, a person for a long time.

Joe Lubeck (24:18)
It did.

It did. And that was after I'd been in business for about ten years. I had two really unique meetings. One in two thousand I met David Arthur who was the founder of Brookfield. And back then they were a nice small company, only about sixty billion, and still based in Toronto. And David took a liking to what we were doing, had seen how we grew, had seen our fundamentals of Sunbelt Focus, self managed, middle market, stay in your lane, if you will. And so that was a fortuitous meeting.

Hiten Samtani (24:45)
Did you ever get to meet the the secretive directors behind Brookfield who are behind Brookfield who are the Matrushka doll of Brookfield?

Joe Lubeck (24:52)
I

I appeared at a number of various meetings with with Mr. Arthur. And a a great story with David Arthur is way back when David took me to his box for the Madonna concert in Toronto about twenty-five years ago. And uh she came on so late that we both went to sleep. But the meeting the Sulkin family, this is a cool war story. For those of you who mi can remember when Isaac Chuva bought the plaza from Trump and

Everyone said, Who's this crazy Israeli who paid way too much? Um, and he conduited and made a billion dollars. And he didn't want to take the billion dollars home. So through some mutual friends, he reached out to us and asked if he could buy multifamily. And that was how he started his multifamily portfolio. So I sold him 5,000 units. It was a great day. We were all very happy. A couple months later, I get a call from a mutual friend who says, I've got this family from Israel that wants to meet you. He said, Okay, who are they? they're the Sulkin family. They have

Multiple publicly traded companies. There are nine countries. I said, Great, let's meet them. Do they want to invest? Yes, they want to invest. So I got together with them, and of course, they said, we want to invest in the company. We want to be platformatic partners. At that time, we had already seen the GFC getting ready to come. This is 2006. We I was sitting on cash from the sale. They obviously were sitting on a plethora of cash. And we partnered and it worked out great. And I said, So how did you hear about me? They said, Well,

We were supposed to be in the deal with Chuva and he cut us out, so we figured we'd come find him. And that's a true story. And we've been partners now for twenty years and it's been a great run.

Will Krasne (26:29)
That's amazing. So you've built portfolios, I think, four times in multifamily. At least. How do you put together a portfolio and try to really achieve a portfolio premium? Like is it geographic focus? Is it different types of housing? Blackstone launched a SASB yesterday, I think, and it was high rise, mid rise, gardens, vintages from like fifty nine to two thousand two. How do you think about putting yours together?

Joe Lubeck (26:51)
Well, we set up a very basic goal, as I said, which was twenty Sunbelt Cities, self managed, very focused. And I was fortunate in that I partnered with Brookfield and Morgan Stanley and I started C three for many years. Grew to ten thousand, sold five, grew to twenty, sold ten. Most of those were not large portfolio sales. I've always had the view, rightly or wrongly, that I want to keep the product fresh. We're a value added player, but we always wanted to have best in class value ads. So our portfolio is typically newer.

Than most value add folks. and many of the people who've been hit recently were people who are value added buying 70s, 80s, 90s. Our average age of portfolio is two thousand and eight. So it's very different. But um we took a lot of risks and we sometimes got a portfolio premium, but that's very much time dependent. As we grew, we grew to thirty one thousand units ultimately. My bought grub and Ellis, which at the time was in serious trouble. Our plan was to go public.

And we were thirty one thousand units at that time. About twenty four thousand were in the private company. Bank of America was advising us on going on the NYSE, and they said you're worth more private than public. And we said, Okay, run a process. I stepped down from the board, got some backers and I was gonna buy my own company and uh we got outbid by Starwood and it was

Hiten Samtani (28:10)
Gary

shows up. This is a one point nine correct.

Joe Lubeck (28:13)
Point

nine seven closed in um January of twenty sixteen. and it was a great day. And of course, people like, oh, Joe Lubeck sold a company for two billion. Yeah. The bank took the first one point two. Yeah. And the the investors took the next six hundred, but it was a great day, and everyone was happy and and and we did very, very well. They wanted to buy the platform as well, um, and have that as their management. Which you did not, and we said we're not doing it, we're gonna do it again. So at that point, we

Kept over three hundred people on the team, even though we went from thirty one thousand units down to seven thousand.

Hiten Samtani (28:47)
go from being like a household name to having to figure it out again.

Joe Lubeck (28:51)
Yeah,

and we did and we said at that point we wanted to start doing funds. So we opened the capital markets in New York, in Tel Aviv and in Dubai. And we were one of the first, certainly, if not the first, Jewish owned company to open in the Dubai Financial Center. Long before the International Accord.

Hiten Samtani (29:07)
So something you probably don't know about me, I'm from Dubai. And so when I see you go out there, one of the things we were talking about is the code switching you need because you're raising money from Qatar, the UAE, Deep Brooklyn and Park Avenue. You bet. Yeah. And each LP has not only a different sensibility, obviously, in what they the way you kind of tailor your messaging, it's also very different considerations and what they are looking for when they put money in with you. So let's

Joe Lubeck (29:33)
Absolutely.

Hiten Samtani (29:34)
talk about that because I know a lot of people out here are

are constantly jonesing for money from all different quarters, right? That's that's the game. And to see someone who's done it in so many different contexts is is valuable. Yes.

Joe Lubeck (29:46)
Well, it's been very interesting because when we started, um, of course we already were pretty well known in Israel and we were able to raise a lot of money there, all the major funds. But moving in those different worlds, particularly earlier, because I would go to Tel Aviv and then I'd have to fly to Damascus or Rome to go to Dubai. Uhhuh. Now of course there's six fights a day, no problem. I don't say that I was ever treated unkindly. I was always treated with respect. Um and I view that we're all children of Abraham, and the more we can in improve

international commerce that that helps to solve many different issues. But there's no question that I had to sometimes literally wear different hats. em And uh um and it's been a very interesting journey in that regard. And now of course we're growing a lot of high net worth families here as well. And usually with the high net worth families it's a whole different story. First thing they say is we don't do funds. Then we explain to them why and why that should be a portion of their allocation.

And typically we get a very positive response. And fortunately over the years, one of the things I'm most proud of, we've always been low leverage, except for my first five deals where I was levered up to here. Um, and the bank that sold me the stuff, not only did they give me a discounted price, but they then basically gave me ninety six percent financing from a bank that had taken the property back. And that bank liked me so much they gave me two more and it sort of led to now there was another fine landmark property.

Will Krasne (31:13)
There's a multifamily dive article that came out in January earlier this year. And you said, you know, through the both the value added strategy and fine-tuning of operations, we can grow NOI and provide an appropriate returns to investors. So I think there's been a lot of discussion about multifamily, get generational wells, do this. What is an appropriate return in multifamily, in your opinion? And has it been warped the last 10 years? And are we back to sort of a different epoch?

Joe Lubeck (31:39)
It's been through multiple changes. The last few years have been the most interesting, certainly. I've faced numerous headwinds in my career. If you look at the last thirty years and you look at the arbitrage model, which is what's the cap rate, what's the interest rates, and can I make money? Our model's very different. So yes, we want to make money, yes, we monitor the arbitrage, but it's all about operational alpha and boots on the ground and basis and making sure you're buying right, selling right, and don't ever have a gun to your head.

Today our whole portfolio is around fifteen billion, but in the multifamily flagship American Landmark it's around ten and we're fifty three percent leverage. So that helps.

Hiten Samtani (32:15)
How are you dealing with the as we said, this five year crazy period where people were making twenties and r just going ham, you know, going from six thousand year one year to twenty two thousand units the next, right? Like we saw this.

Joe Lubeck (32:28)
Top.

Yes. Well, we've been very consistent. And the goal is to just work our plan in the same 20 markets that we've been in. And if you focus on cash flow and growing NOI, things can change that are somewhat out of my control. Cap rates, interest rates. This year everyone predicted a return to normalcy, and cap rates would return to normal, interest rates would go down. I didn't see it that way. But for what we're buying now, the last two years, twenty-four and twenty-five, we did almost no trading. And in the usual year,

We'll be buying 1520 deals and selling 10 or 12. I've been accused of selling too soon. But in this current market, there's certainly a refocusing. First, people are more willing to accept a lower IRR for safety and security. This current fund, I've averaged a 20 IRR and a two for 30 years. And right now we're telling our value add investors, although it really looks and feels like Core Plus, we're targeting a 14 or 16.

Which we think is reasonable, gross, and then there's gonna be some fees and costs associated with that. But that seems to be very acceptable where people are giving up some of that IRR goal where you want it to be high teens or twenty, but are instead focusing more on current cash flow.

Will Krasne (33:42)
When talk about safety though, I hear this again all the time. So I'm sort of I'm tweeting through it, where they're like, I can't get this market through IC. I always feel like if everyone else is going there, that means the prices are going higher. What do you think safety is?

Joe Lubeck (33:56)
Safety is not about winning the deal for sure. And unfortunately the brokers over the last X number of years convinced people that you won the deal when it was awarded to you because you were willing to pay more than anybody else. That's not when you win. When you win is when you exit successfully. So we're fine if we don't win the bid. Our numbers are a number and we're very cautious. Austin's a great example. We knew it was coming because we have boots on the ground. I do think in two years from now, there's gonna be the stress and we're starting to see it now.

in the higher quality product, but most of the distress is really in the C product, and it's everywhere. If I wanted to go out tomorrow and buy C product at 50 cents on the dollar, I could buy 20,000 units tomorrow. Literally. I get calls every day. Do you want to buy 10,000 units here, 10,000 units there? It's not what we want. We sold to a relatively smart operator who had about 10,000 units, who decided to expand and over lever and overpay.

Because he wanted to enter certain markets. I won't mention which market or which company, but it was a strong Florida market. And we sold him a very nice 2007 product for $290,000 a unit. He levered it up and of course defaulted to the lender. And then the lender agreed to take a haircut. And the lender called us and said, Do you want to buy it back? I said, sure. And then we gave them another haircut and another haircut. And we're now buying that $290,000 deal for $165,000 a year.

Hiten Samtani (35:22)
You're

on your uncontract at one sixty five a door. Yes. There you go. Deals to be had. I'm gonna close this out with and I appreciate this audience has been amazing and thank you be for being who you are and and listening to us the way you do. You've done this for quite a while. You've sold, you've made let's say post economic is a good way to describe where you are. Okay. What gives you the juice? And not you've got to just give me what is the thing that wakes you up at four thirty that more importantly wakes Aharon up at six and brings him in.

Joe Lubeck (35:50)
Yeah.

Well I've retrained Aharon. He was he was an eleven o'clock guy and now he's getting up at five thirty to be doing

Hiten Samtani (35:56)
What is it about the business that is that is motivating you to just keep doing it?

Joe Lubeck (36:01)
Well,

it it sounds like a a little bit of uh corny religious, but I've always believed that uh if I work hard and pray and give, that I'm gonna be successful and I enjoy doing what I do with the people I do it with. I've surrounded myself with amazing people, many of whom have been with me for ten, fifteen, twenty years. Um, but at the end of the day, the real reason is my wife, who says, Honey, we're married forty years and it's great when you're home for four hours.

So it's very motivational and that's really the bottom line.

Hiten Samtani (36:34)
That's the kind of dad joke that we're gonna leave you with. Thank you so much. The bar is open. Please stick around. We're here. Thank you all. Appreciate you.

Will Krasne (36:41)
Yeah.