Retailgentic | Consumer Behavior & Retail Trend

What happens when the marketing funnel collapses and AI takes over discovery? Scot Wingo talks with Andrea Leigh, Amazon veteran and CEO of Allume Group, about the latest Allume Insider Report (AIR).

We cover:
• How ~60% of shoppers now use AI for product research
• “Value” as price and purpose (Gen Z, resale, circular)
• Social commerce’s rise and the blur between entertainment & shopping
• Why D2C sites are crucial for AI readability
• The shaky future of retail media networks and SEO

Andrea pulls back the curtain on how AI, value, and entertainment are rewriting the rules of commerce. This conversation is a roadmap for brands preparing for the collapse of search and the rise of agentic shopping.

⏱️ Time Stamps
01:41 – Guest intro: Andrea Leigh, Amazon alum & CEO of Allume Group.
03:18 – Andrea’s Amazon career and path to founding Allume Group.
06:14 – Amazon negotiations today: bots, automation, and leverage.
06:59 – Tariffs: who pays and why consumers often shoulder it.
08:01 – The origins of the Allume Insider Report (AIR).
11:10 – Three trends shaping commerce: AI help, value, and fun.
12:02 – 60% of shoppers already use AI for product discovery.
15:16 – Gen Z starts searches on TikTok, not Amazon.
19:29 – ChatGPT Checkout: affiliate or true marketplace?
26:11 – Value redefined: bargain-hunting, private label, and resale on the rise.
31:12 – Social commerce explodes: TikTok Shops headed for $17B.
32:47 – “Amazon solved buying but killed shopping.”
40:05 – D2C sites as AI-readable “source of truth.”
46:22 – Retail media and SEO industries under pressure from AI.
53:20 – Amazon’s Rufus and the fight to compete with LLMs.
52:55 – Closing thoughts + download the free AIR report.

🧠 Want to stay ahead in AI commerce? Subscribe and follow along: 
📰 Subscribe to the free Substack: retailgentic.ai
📺 Watch episodes on YouTube: youtube.com/@retailgentic
🎧 Listen wherever you get your podcasts: Spotify, Apple, etc.

Creators and Guests

Host
Scot Wingo
CEO and Co-founder, ReFiBuy.ai
AL
Guest
Andrea K. Leigh

What is Retailgentic | Consumer Behavior & Retail Trend?

Retailgentic, presented by the ReFiBuy Media Network and hosted by Scot Wingo, is where Agentic Commerce meets retail innovation. We help retailers and brands prepare for the future of agent-driven shopping with actionable news, expert insights, dxis, forward-looking predictions, and practical guidance on Agentic Commerce Optimization (ACO).

Um, I think for, for brands
and advertisers, the lines are

really starting to blur between
entertainment and shopping, and that

traditional marketing funnel is,
like, completely collapsed, right?

If you can discover, research,
and purchase all in, like, two

clicks, like, you- there's, there's
really not a funnel anymore.

Welcome to the Retailgentic Podcast,
where we explore the intersection

of retail, e-commerce, and AI
agents, which we call retailgentic.

Our mission is simple.

We are shining a bright light
on the new agentic AI shopping

megatrend, which will disrupt the
trillion-dollar digital retail market.

The stakes are high.

Google, OpenAI, Microsoft,
Perplexity, Amazon, Apple, Meta, and

Anthropic are all fighting to be the
consumer AI shopping agent winner.

There are gonna be some tough decisions
for online brands and retailers to make.

What happens to checkout?

How should payments work?

Should you continue to invest
in retail media networks?

What does the world look like when
over half of your traffic is not

from humans but from AI agents?

These existential questions
are the tip of the iceberg.

On this podcast, we're talking to industry
experts, analysts, and influencers

to get answers to these questions,
identify trends and best practices.

This is Retailgentic, your
podcast partner in navigating

our AI shopping agent future.

And now here's your host, Scot Wingo.

Welcome to this episode of
the Retailgentic Podcast.

On today's pod, my guest is Andrea Leigh.

Andrea was at Amazon 10 years in a
variety of category leadership roles.

After that, she was VP of strategy at,
at Ideoclick, one of the early retail

media network companies in advertisings,
uh, uh, connected to marketplaces.

And today, she is the founder
and CEO of Alum Group.

Alum Group helps executives at brands
of all sizes think through their

Amazon and e-commerce strategy,
retail media networks, and more.

On a regular basis, they publish
the Alum Insider Report, AIR.

In this episode, Andrea takes us through
their latest report and the big takeaways.

And this may be a surprise to you,
but one of the big topics is agentic

commerce, our favorite topic.

Andrea talks to hundreds of brands
a month, and her insights have

always been helpful to me as I
figure out what is going on and

what's the vibe in the industry.

I hope you enjoy the discussion.

Andrea, welcome to the
Retail Agentic Podcast.

Excited to have you on.

I am excited to be here, Scott.

Thanks for having me.

Yeah.

You're a multi-time Jason and Scot
guest, but first time on the new

podcast, so it's great to have you.

Uh, thanks for having me.

Absolutely.

So I know, uh, all about you, and we've
known each other for far too long.

Um, uh, the-- From an age perspective,
I've enjoyed knowing you that long.

But, um- The, uh…

Give folks a little background
about, you know, you've, you've

been in this game for quite a while.

Give us some highlights of your
career progression and what led

you to what you're doing now.

Yeah.

Um, well, I started my career at Amazon.

I was there for 10 years, and I, um,
launched the health and person- health

and personal care, beauty, and grocery
categories in US, um, Canada, and

Mexico, and spent some time working
on, um, all kinds of things in the,

in the retail side of Amazon: price
matching, um, you know, s- working

with vendors, training vendor managers.

Um, I left there about 10 years ago
and wanted to work more closely with

brands, and so I ran an e-commerce
agency, uh, called Ideoclick.

We were a managed services agency
that worked with about 250 consumer

brands running their business on
Amazon, everything from retail

media to catalog and operations.

Um, and about five years ago,
I founded the Alume Group.

While I was at the agency, I discovered
there was a growing need for, uh,

education in this space and, and
kind of more hands-on, um, strategy

support for, for brands and for
those who help brands be successful,

so, like, agencies and enablers.

And I've been doing that work
for about five years now.

So we have an e-learning suite, um,
of about f- uh, 15 courses on digital

commerce topics, and then we consult
with brands on digital commerce strategy,

Amazon strategy, negotiation strategy,
commercial strategy, um, and work with

consumer packaged goods companies as
well as brands in, in other categories,

sporting goods, electronics, et cetera,
um, and have been doing, working now

on brands, uh, for about 10 years.

Okay.

So there's, like, an education component,
and then a consulting kind of a component.

Yes, exactly.

Yeah.

So got it.

Can you- This is not what we came to
discuss, but just out of intellectual

curiosity, my understanding is you
can't really negotiate with Amazon

anymore because it's a bot basically.

Isn't it an AI on the other side?

Isn't this part of their
hands-off-the-wheel program where-

Yeah.

I mean, it depends on the size.

I think there's-- there are really
different negotiations experiences

depending on the size of the brand and
its importance in the category for Amazon.

And so really large brands still work
with Amazon in a little bit more of a

traditional sense, the way they would
work with another retailer where they're

assigned, you know, a team and they
work on a joint business plan together.

It-- While it's, it's true that
Amazon's a lot more data-driven, um,

you know, it really versus kind of
being more re-relationship driven.

Um, but they st- you know, they still have
relationships with, with those brands.

I think if you're more of like a,
a mid-market or a growth brand on

Amazon, you're definitely faced with
more automation, um, which I think

actually is in your favor in those
cases if you understand how it works

and, and how to work with it, um, and,
and, you know, learn how to use kind

of some of the self-service technology
and tools that are available to you.

Uh, also not the main topic, but
any, you know-- the, the big thing

in the news has been the tariffs.

It's kind of feels like we're on the other
side of it a bit or, um, maybe we're not.

What-- Give us a quick tariff update.

Is that still top of mind with
your clients and, and part of

these negotiations as they go in
trying to find some relief from

that, or what's going on there?

Absolutely.

You know, a lot of brands who are
facing, you know, tariffs as a

part of their manufacturing process
or, um, import process are, are

certainly trying to figure out
how to pass those along to Amazon.

Uh, Amazon, in their last earnings call,
talked about how they're willing to take

on some of that burden, um, in theory.

But of course, the devil's in the
details, and I think it's really

the onus is on the brands to figure
out, you know, how to prove that out

How to prove their case to Amazon.

Um, you know, generally Amazon wants
to make sure that they're not the only

one that's taking a price increase,
you know, that they're, that they've

got some, some data to kind of prove
where it's coming from, et cetera.

I mean, I think the, the unfortunate thing
at the end of the day is that for all

retailers, like a lot of the tariffs are
just gonna get passed on to consumers,

and the result, and the result's
gonna be higher retail prices, um, you

know, because these companies can't
financially shoulder the entire burden.

So, um, so I think that's the unfortunate
piece, but it's just like any negotiation

with Amazon, you know, you have to be
prepared and, um, figure out what your

leverage point is and, uh, and ha- make
sure that you're, you're approaching

them in a very data-driven manner.

Awesome.

Cool.

So that's a good warm-up
for our, our bigger topic.

So you guys put out, um, some
really good data that you call,

I'll let you know, you call it AIR.

So, so tell us what-- You've been
doing this for a number of years now.

Uh, what's the origin of the report?

Where's the data come from?

And, um, and then I definitely wanna
dig into some of the, the updates.

Yeah.

The origin of the report is it came from,
um, some of the education that we were

doing, kind of more bespoke education for
brands, where, you know, before you sort

of start to get to some of the brass tacks
of, of how to work on Amazon, you really

need to tell the story of the shopper
journey and the digital path to purchase.

And that journey is changing so quickly.

As you know, you're in the, um,
you're in the AI shopping space

y- yourself with your new company.

Um, and so we started preparing kind
of a, a module on, you know, the

digital shopping trends to tee up
some of our in, in-person workshops.

Um- And brands really liked that content,
and it seemed a shame to just restrict

it to the brands we were working with.

So we started producing a regular
report called AIR, Illume Insider

Report, we call it AIR, uh, on
all the digital shopping trends.

So it's kind of like a recap,
um, that we update on a regular

basis on what is happening with
the digital path to purchase.

Where is the shopper
starting their journey?

And I think especially in the last, like,
three to five years, I've, I've been

producing this report for a long time.

When I was at Ideoclick, we produced a s-
a similar product under a different name.

Um, but I think especially in the
last three to five years, brands have

gotten really, I want-- like, I guess
I would say distracted by retail media.

And, I mean, retail media
is really important.

It's, you know, that's our advertising
lever on digital marketplaces, like we

certainly need to be focused on that.

But I think in all of the focus on it,
and now even some of the focus on, um,

on AI shopping and agentic shopping,
we kind of have lost a little-- we've

lost sight of the shopper a little bit.

And as brands are trying, especially
large brands, or as they're figuring

out how to budget for retail media
and where it should sit in the

organization, and there's, like, a
lot to figure out to make it work.

How, how, um, effective is it?

Can we attribute some of the
offline sales to what we're

spending on Amazon and Walmart.com?

Uh, I think there's just, we've
lost a little bit of that digital

path to purchase and, and how the
shopper is discovering our products.

And so This kind of, this report
kind of helps orient us in what

has the shopper been up to?

What do they care about right now?

And so we spend a couple of months
preparing the report and going

through, like, all of the industry
reports that are available.

Um, we subscribe to a lot of things.

We talk to a lot of industry experts,
and we come up with kind of a, a

storyline around what's happening.

And, uh, and s- and so that is our,
our AIR report that we're gonna be

talking about today, which has a
little bit of a, an AI angle as well.

Yeah.

Let's jump into it.

What were some of the, the…

What's the narrative that you were
able to put together from all the

data coming out about AI shopping?

Yeah.

I think we narrowed it down this, um,
this first half of this year to kind

of three main trends, and the first is
AI-assisted shopping, and we, we do the

whole report in the perspective of the,
from the perspective of the shopper.

It's worth noting also,
this report is free.

It's available for
download on our website.

Anyone can have access to it.

So the first trend is A- AI, please help.

So this is the idea of the
AI-assisted shopping experience.

The second trend is show me the value.

So I mean, you, as you alluded to with
tariffs and, uh, economic pressures that

people are experiencing right now, the
shopper is becoming more discerning and,

and more, a little bit more value-driven.

But value doesn't mean what we think it
means, so we'll come back to that later.

And then make it fun.

So this idea of content being the
new commerce with, um, you know,

shoppers having a lot of options of,
of where shopping is infotainment or

entertainment or, you know, as a hobby,
but figuring out ways to make that

experience really fun for shoppers.

Let's jump into AI, please help.

Yeah.

So I mean, I think the … This one
probably is, is pretty obvious to, to

most people, but right now, um, the
data is showing that about close to

60% of shoppers have pr- replaced s-
their traditional search engines with

gen AI search or answer engine search
for product research and discovery.

And so if you think about how quickly
that's happened, um, and you kind of

like carry that forward, um, you know,
we used to say that 80% of purchases

were digitally influenced, and now I
think we're quickly getting to a point

where 80% of searches are AI influenced.

Uh, 61% of shoppers are using AI
tools like Cha- ChatGPT for online

shopping assistance, and 82% are
reporting, like, a really high

satisfaction rate with that experience.

So it's speeding up the purchase journey
and often leading to more purchases.

So, and I, and I, uh, I have
this quote from Doug Herrington,

who's the CEO of Amazon Stores,
from the latest earnings report.

And I have to agree with him when
he says that we haven't seen a

technology revolution as large as
this since the start of the internet.

I mean, there really hasn't been anything
that has, has swept, um, swept cons- has

taken consumers, taken hold of consumers
in quite the same way that, that AI has.

And I mean, y- you could say
it's the, the launch of social

media, but that's really a, a…

I think we've, while, um, you
know, obviously the usage rates

of social media are super high, I
think it's a specific experience

and a specific occasion for people.

AI has the opportunity to
impact every occasion, right?

Um, and some of the experts are
anticipating that search, traditional

search traffic's gonna drop
about 25% by the end of the year.

I think you even posted something
really similar, um, a similar

stat recently on LinkedIn.

So, and, and it's no surprise, right?

Because search-based shopping is
broken and it's ripe for disruption.

It's a pain in the neck.

If a shopper has the option to do
something besides go to Google and

search for, you know, or, uh, you know-
Um, aluminum-free deodorant or, uh, you

know, multivitamins for perimenopause.

They're, they're gonna, they're
gonna jump on the chance to

make that experience better.

And I think one of the, one of the real
benefits that AI-assisted shopping gives

us is the opportunity to negate search
terms, and that's something that I think

traditional search has been ripe for
disruption in that regard for a long time.

So if you search, you know, if you search
gluten-free, you're gonna get gluten-free

things, but you're also gonna get things
with gluten because the keyword's there.

You know, AI gives us the opportunity
to refine in a more conversational

way, to negate search terms, to ask
for products that don't include, you

know, certain ingredients or items.

Um, and I think really shoppers
are just ready for reinvention

of retail, and this is it, right?

This is the opportunity.

I feel like the Amazon search
experience has definitely kind of

jumped the shark and gotten much worse.

So there's the paradox of choice, so
there's just too many products, and

then I think the retail media network
monetization has tipped over to the

point where it's no longer, like,
you know, boosting the right content.

And it just is too much noise
and you've lost the signal.

Yeah, and if you look at it by generation,
older generations have a more of a

tolerance for sort of that endless
scroll versus, um, as you ratchet down

in basically age brackets, the youngest
generations have almost zero tolerance.

Like, they, they wanna go to social
media and have social media tell

them exactly what to buy, right?

Like, I have three teenagers, and
they start their searches on TikTok.

Like, they're not even going
to Amazon to look for products.

They're, they're definitely starting
in a completely different place.

Um, I think some of the, the takeaways for
brands and retailers are around agility.

You know, I think a lot of these legacy
brands are really struggling to keep

pace- With these new keys to success,
so which are, um, really thinking

about whether your digital content is
AI optimized, um, you know, whether

your D2C is site, whether you have
one, and if it's AI optimized, because

obviously that's one of the sources
for information that AI is using.

Um, and I think that the, the legacy
brands are taking longer to kind of pivot

to that new way of thinking, whereas more
challenger brands, um, are able to be a

little bit more nimble and test and learn
and experiment to see what's working.

And there's been a whole crop of SaaS
providers out there that will show you,

like, what is your share of voice across
AI and how are you showing up in AI, and

what could you do to be doing a better
job allowing answer engines to read,

you know, your product information.

Uh, even on Amazon, they- they've
reinvented their search with Cosmo

over the last course of the last year,
which is a more contextual search.

And for those who aren't familiar, now
it's taking in the who, what, when,

where, why, and it's reading the images.

And so we need to make sure our images
show, like, a lot of diversity in

who's using the product and where
they're using it and how they're

using it, so that we can be picked
up, um, as often as possible.

I also think it means retail
media is gonna look really

different in the coming months.

I mean, that's a whole ecosystem that
is gonna be completely turned upside

down because it's so keyword-based
right now, and that just isn't how,

um, shoppers are-- Well, first, their,
the retail media is on the retailer

platforms, and AI's taking the
traffic off of them, so there's that.

And then also, um, the, you
know, the-- it's very-- it-- the

whole-- all the technology is very
keyword-based, and I think that's,

that's changing really quickly.

Shoppers, when now that they have an
alternative to trying to find the right

keywords to find the replacement part
for their dishwasher are, um, you know,

they're, they're jumping at the chance.

Do you think RMNs survive this, or
do you think that the engines will

ultimately have an RMN and join some of
these other networks and, and kind of

be more of an open platform in that way?

Or do you have a prediction on that?

Well, I think there's too much
revenue associated with it for the

retailers for them to let it go.

So they're gonna find a way to reinvent
it, whether it's, you know, extending

their ecosystem to different, uh, answer
engines and putting the ads there Or,

um, or finding a way to monetize retail
media in a different way on site.

So maybe if shoppers aren't using keyword
search as much, maybe we move more

toward more of the budgets and, um, you
know, I guess innovation in advertising

happens on more of the display side.

So, and, and audience targeting and,
and, um, and, and those types of ads.

So it's possible that they'll try to
shift some of the, um, advertiser budgets.

But I think the, the advertiser budgets
follow where the shoppers are, and

if the shoppers are on the answer
engines, the ads are gonna go there.

It's just a matter of who
gets to collect that revenue.

So you saw the ChatGPT announcement
that they're gonna have a checkout.

Did-- Do you view…

So it's interesting, so half the people
in our world I talk to, they kind of

view it as like an affiliate-like thing.

But to me, an affiliate happens
at the affiliate site, and this

is gonna happen at ChatGPT.

To me, this is a marketplace.

Is that…

You know, so, so I think for that
to work, you're gonna then have to,

just like Amazon, eBay, and any other
marketplace, you're gonna have to

give OpenAI a, not only just a product
data feed, but an inventory feed, and

then you're gonna get orders back.

Is that, is that how you
interpret what that would be like?

I'm-- We're, and we're all, we're
kinda like we're reading, we're

reading tea leaves here, but yeah.

Yeah, I saw that in your RetailGentic
newsletter, which for anyone listening

who's not subscribed to, um, Scott puts
out a great newsletter on all- Thanks

… that's happening in AI and commerce, and
I really, uh, I find a lot of value in it.

Um, I think that, well first,
yes, I think that's the definition

of a marketplace, for sure.

And, and I agree that these AI answer
engines have the opportunity to

become marketplaces, and ChatGPT is
the one that's the furthest along.

I think that being a successful
marketplace is about more than just

where the shopper can transact, however.

And I do think that there's a long,
these answer engines have a long ways to

go in becoming good at discoverability.

So here's an example.

You can go to ChatGPT right now
and you can tell me, tell it, "Give

me the best, find me the best deal
on Rainbow Light vitamins," right?

And it will give you the lowest
retail price, and it doesn't know

how to think about, um, the quantity
that's included in that package.

So it, it showed me, of course,
the lowest count vitamin.

It doesn't have like a per each
kind of s- concept of a per each.

Um, and I think that there's
a lot that it's still…

I think in order for answer engines
to be really successful marketplaces,

there's a lot of learning they have to do
still to kind of get to the right place.

Um, I st- and I, I consistently, I
mean, I, I consistently use ChatGPT,

you know, Perplexity, et cetera, to
try to shop, and I'm consistently

disappointed with that experience.

So while it might help me narrow my
results or it helps me find a brand

that I might not have found otherwise,
like getting to an actual transaction,

um, is still really difficult.

And so I think they have a long
ways to go and, and in that front,

just in the like discoverability
front and ease of shopping.

I also think that the experience to date
still falls really flat visually and

from a, um, I guess also like a different
kind of discoverability perspective.

And I think in order to be a successful
marketplace, you know, you need to

be able to drive traffic to a lot of
product, different types of products,

um, in a visually stimulating way.

And I think that experience
is still falling flat.

So yes, I think they're marketplaces,
but I also think they still have a

lot of learning to do to be really
effective ones for the shopper.

We could talk about this for,
for a long time, so, and I wanna

get to the rest of the report.

Um, okay, uh, and then on-- So, so
you, you have your report, but then

you're talking to brands all the time.

W- how, you know, how
freaked out by this are they?

Because the customers I'm talking
to, they're, they're pretty

freaked out because they've seen
their Google traffic plummet.

Most of, most of these challenger brands,
though, if you looked at a pie chart of

where their sales are coming from, the
website's pretty small and, you know,

they're getting a lot from Amazon and
TikTok, which are still pretty resilient.

Is it-- Are they just kind of
keeping an eye on it or is there a

four-alarm fire kind of going on?

Well, in some ways I don't feel like
they're as alarmed as they should be, but

in-- because they're n- they're not laying
the foundation for the future of shopping.

But at the same time, brands are pretty
reliant on what the retailer's doing

and what the tech providers are doing.

I mean, they can't just
invent their own marketplaces.

So I guess, like balancing that
with what can they do right now?

I mean, I think there's, there's
a lot they can do just from an

optimization perspective, and that's
where I am suggesting brands start.

So making sure that their content is
really-- And we have some like a punch

list in our report, but making sure
content is really conversational and

matches like how a user is querying, like,
"Help me find a pair of durable hiking

boots that are waterproof and non-slip."

You know, you wanna make sure all those,
like all of that content is included in

your content, making sure to improve and
increase lifestyle imagery, um, making

sure your product info is on some easy
to crawl and easy to cache websites.

So for a while, I think a lot of the
answer engines weren't cr- weren't

pulling kind of recent information
from Amazon 'cause it's hard to crawl.

Um, so this is where you wanna dust
off that D2C site and make sure

you've got a lot of good taxonomy
in there and you know that it's

easy for an answer engine to pull.

Um, and then freshness, I think is an
important part of that AI algorithm.

So making sure that you're, you're
continually updating your listings.

Um, so I think those are
some things they can do.

They can't really like affect
the future of retail media.

They're still gonna put their
money where, where they can.

But I think, I think also looking
for opportunities for test and learns

with some of these answer engines.

You know, if you've got a D2C site,
there's, there are things you can do.

You can work directly with them.

You can do some of the feed type work
that you're working on right now.

Um, and so I think there
are some things they can do.

But to your point, I think you're
right, Scott, like challenger

brands aren't getting all of their
traffic from retail media anyway.

Like they're-- I, I just, um, I've done
a few, uh, analyses for brands recently,

and if you look at as an established
brand versus a challenger brand, typically

the established brand's getting a lot.

They're spending a- almost all of
their marketing budget on retail media.

They're getting almost all
of their sales from it.

Um, they're heavily reliant on it,
or at least they think they are.

And then a challenger brand is spending
almost the balance, the large balance of

their marketing budget on social media
and, and getting a lot of their sales

and in, and, um, a lot of their sales and
interest from like TikTok, for example.

And so I think those brands are a little
bit lower risk for whatever erosion

of search is gonna happen, um, as a
result of, of growth of AI shopping.

Got it.

Cool.

Let's, uh, move on to the
value-driven shopper And you

said that's not what it seems.

I'm curious what that means.

It's not what it seems.

So, well, I think, well,
in some ways it is.

So bargain hunting for
sure is on the rise.

Um, 64% of shoppers are … report
that they're seeking more value, and

they're visiting multiple physical
stores to find the best deals.

That's up from 56% last year.

Uh, 57% say they're spending
more time this year searching

online for the best price.

So obvious- so yes, looking for,
looking for lower prices and,

and that definition of value.

Um, and 57% of shoppers report
switching brands to private

label versus 46% last year.

So, like, a lot of trading down happening.

I think also private label
isn't what it used to be.

You know, those are, you know, for a lot
of retailers like Target, like those are

actually established brands at this point.

Um- Yeah

but, you know, often offered
at a lower price point than

some of the national brands.

And secondhand shopping
is also on the rise.

20% of shoppers say they're increasing
spending on secondhand goods.

60% of Gen Z are stating a
preference for secondhand.

I think this goes beyond actual price
value though, and it, and it touches

on some other values that are really
important, and that's what I mean when

I say value isn't what you think it is.

You know, it's touching on some
values around, you know, s- the

circular fashion economy and reducing
waste and trying to, um, be more

responsible in our consumption.

And, and I think the younger
generations are, are-- have that

a little more at top of mind.

Which is always funny 'cause at
the same time they're doing that,

then they're buying throwaway
garments from Shein, so go figure.

I know.

I know.

It, it-- really kind of we're talking
out of two sides of our mouths, for sure.

Um, and I love this example.

As soon as the char- as soon as some
of the tariffs were, um, announced, the

s- that same day, Chairish, which is a,
um, they're like a used kind of high-end

furniture and decor retailer that I follow
on Instagram, they immediately put up an

ad that said, "US vintage is tariff free."

And, and so brands kind of in the
secondhand market really taking their

moment to, to, to capitalize on that.

But value is not just ab-about price.

I mean, it's about being, think--
it's about all kinds of values, right?

It can be about feel-feeling
more responsible as a consumer.

It can be about having the type of
customer experience, customer service

experience that you're looking for.

It's about having an easy return process.

It can be about a lot of different things.

And 89% of shoppers stay loyal to
brands that share their values.

68% are willing to pay more for them.

And so I think it really comes back
to if you're, if you're s- well,

first you have to know your shopper.

You have to know what their values
are and, um, and making sure that

your messaging and your brand is
aligned with that really well.

But also, if you're straddling
kind of value and values-based

messaging, it's time to choose a lane.

Like you've, you've really gotta be
specific about what aligns most with your

shopper, um, and or risk sort of being
shut out of the value chain altogether.

Yeah.

Okay.

And then were there any things
that, a lot of times I see data

around buy now, pay later with that
younger generation that they…

And I've seen this, I, I have
teenager and mid-20s kids.

They like that BNPL because
they don't like to put big

things on their credit card.

It's a weird…

That it feels like
they're going into debt.

Uh, and they like that buy now, pay later.

Do, do you see that behavior
in the data or amongst your

sample set of a couple kids?

Um, I mean, definitely among my sample set
of my kids, I think they really try to…

They're really trying to manage cash flow,
and they, they don't think about credit

cards kind of the same way that we did.

Maybe it's because they have so much more
knowledge and information, um, about how

that can get away from you really quickly.

I mean, I think you and I maybe
grew up in the era of, like,

you-- of, of credit, right?

And that was just sort of how
you, you put things there and then

you managed your cash flow later.

Um, you know, they're definitely very
cash flow conscious, and so kind of trying

to, like, de- they, you know, they delay
large purchases as long as possible.

I mean, they don't have as much income.

But also they're, um, they're really
mindful of, of trying to amortize some

of that expense as much as they can.

So yeah, I could see that being…

I could see the growth of
that, you know, being…

If that's important to your shopper,
if that's a core value is, is,

um, you know, being able to…

And I was just, I was just on a
podcast where we were talking about

payment, payments and digital payments.

It's really just about knowing your
shopper and what's important to

them, and making sure you're offering
them the options that align with,

you know, what matters to them.

And then what did you, uh,
what's new in the world of social

commerce and entertainment?

Yeah.

So our last ins- our last
trend was make it fun.

Um, and so really if you think
about we, you know, thinking about

recent purchases that you've made
online, like where'd you discover it?

Sometimes it's even hard to say, right?

It's like I, I ended up buying,
transacting on Amazon or in a Walmart

store, or at the grocery store, but
I don't have any idea where I ever

even learned about that brand, 'cause
we're getting in so much stimuli

from so many different places.

But, you know, the lion's share of
shoppers are, are saying that 82%

say they are using social media
for product discovery and research,

and a third of shoppers have
made a purchase there last year.

For Gen Z in particular,
that number is 50%.

So a lot of shoppers disco- you
know, enjoying the discoverability

and, um, elements of social media.

And I think that, uh You
know, TikTok Shops is insane.

It's on track to be, like, a
$17 billion business this year.

The in- the influencer marketing
industry is, is expected

to hit 7 billion this year.

60% of marketers plan to increase
influencer spending this year.

Um, I think for, for brands
and advertisers, the lines are

really starting to blur between
entertainment and shopping, and that

traditional marketing funnel is,
like, completely collapsed, right?

If you can discover, research,
and purchase all in, like, two

clicks, like, you-- there's,
there's really not a funnel anymore.

And I love this quote from Emily Weiss.

She was the CEO-- Well,
she's the CEO of Glossier.

It's kind of an old quote,
but it's held up really well.

"The interesting thing about Amazon
is they've solved buying, but in the

process they've kind of killed shopping."

And, and I think she's-- And, uh,
we, when we do workshops, we pose

this question to the group, and
we get, like, a really good…

There are a lot of people who
agree and disagree, and it's

a really good discussion.

Um, but you know, in some ways
they have killed shopping.

It's, it's, uh, a little bit less fun
to s- to do, to doom scroll through, you

know, 10,000 search results on Amazon
than it is to, to visit a physical store.

Absolutely.

Yeah, shopping on Amazon's not fun.

Shopping on Amazon is not fun.

Uh, does every checkout on TikTok,
is it always Shopify on the back

end, or can you-- Do people wire
up different checkouts in there?

Um, I think, uh, that's a great question.

I think you can wire up other checkouts.

I mean, they've been really focused
on, um, they've been so focused

on growth, like, like aggressively
pursuing a lot of the brands that I

work with, the, the TikTok kind of sales
team trying to grow the marketplace.

Um, and but it's still really
small for a lot of my brands.

You know, it's like, like a really
small percentage of their digital sales.

So I think that investments there
are important, but also, like, it's

important to be investing in a lot
of experimental kinds of shopping.

Um, I wouldn't put all your
eggs in the basket there yet.

Um, but I think investing in
social media from an influencer

perspective is really important.

Like that, I mean, like I said, for
challenger brands, that's where most

of their investment is going and where
most of their sales are coming from.

It seems like it'd be hard if I was like a
supplement company or something like that.

How do you find these influencers?

Because you kind of have to
marry the two together, right?

Like, as a brand, you can do some stuff,
but to really make it go, you need, you

need that extra boost from an influencer.

I mean, there's so many different
strategies brands can employ on this.

Like, if you look at a brand like
Epson, um, you know, they, they've

gone with-- They have Shaq is
like their spokesperson, right?

And so that's like a macro influencer
strategy where you're, you choose

like, like for our generation
it was Jared the Subway guy.

You, you choose one person and you
put all your eggs in that basket and

then you leverage their, um, you know,
their aff- their affinity groups.

I think that if you look at where most
brands are successful, and particularly

challenger brands, they're using some
technology platforms that are available

but are act as like kind of a matchmaking
service so they can put the product out.

The platforms allow them to do some
filters on the types of influencers

and their interests and their values
and then farm out Um, you know, the co-

content production to, like, a group
of, like, nano or micro influencers.

Like, content from many, um, can-- I
mean, it's not unlike Amazon's, uh, search

term bidding where, like, you can pick,
like, the laundry detergent keyword.

It's gonna cost you a lot of money, you're
gonna get a low return, or you can choose,

you know, a whole bunch of, like, middle
range search velocity terms or, or long

tail search velocity terms and get, uh,
like, almost as good of an outcome from a

sales perspective and get higher profit.

Uh, so they, a lot of them are
using matchmaking services to,

to do that and to en- engage with
the right types of influencers.

But it's interesting, I just did an, a
competitive analysis for two different

national brands, and we looked at their,
them versus competition, and the, all the

brands that were seeing the most success
on Amazon from the competitive set and

the most number of branded searches.

And branded searches are really important.

That's like the shopper…

When a shopper makes a branded
search on Amazon, they're really

unlikely to buy anything else.

Like, they're probably gonna buy
the brand, um, the data shows.

And so you want branded searches
on Amazon 'cause you don't

have to pay for retail media.

It's like free, you know,
those are high intent shoppers.

Um, the ones that had the highest branded,
number of branded searches on Amazon

were the ones that had the most amount
of, like, paid partnerships on TikTok.

There was, like, a direct correlation
between what they were doing on TikTok

and the branded searches on Amazon.

So- Uh, so I think that's, uh,
that's a huge opportunity for

national brands to kind of transition
to some more of that strategy.

Interesting.

Yeah.

'Cause usually Amazon's at the top of
the influence tree, like whatever you,

whatever you can get to happen there will
flow to store and all, all your, your,

you know, non-Amazon channels and whatnot.

So it's interesting that in some
ways for the-- And I'm sure it's

the younger gener- demographic that,
that TikTok is kind of up at the top.

Has the TikTok, you know, potentially
being banned and then forever, you

know, given another 90 days, is that…

That doesn't seem to have
slowed anything down, I guess.

No, it hasn't slowed anything down.

I mean, there was a moment where I
think some really large global brands

were kind of considering whether
they should continue investing,

like ahead of any regulation.

Um, but if it's not TikTok, it's something
is else is gonna pop up to replace it.

I mean, it's the-- for the one day
that it went down, I remember my kids

all downloaded some other app that all
their friends were gonna start using,

and I don't even remember what it was.

But that poor app got all the downloads,
and then no one, no one used it after

that when they turned TikTok back on.

Um, and so it will be something like that.

It'll just be some other form
of, of social media that, you

know, helps, um, that, that
offers engagement opportunities.

Seems like an opportunity for one of
these gen AI companies or a startup to

marry the two formats to kind of take,
you know, the, the power of gen AI.

It'll be a better recommendation
algorithm than probably what TikTok has.

Um, but then like mix in the
short form fun part of it.

So there's gonna be a lot of
innovation on these, these,

these intersections of things.

Yeah, I agree

Yeah.

The-- have you played around with any
of the vertical AI shopping things?

Like there's one called Daydream.

Um, we've-- there's, there's a grocery
one coming out they haven't launched yet.

Uh, that's gonna be a whole nother
category that we're keeping a close

eye on to see what's happening there.

Have you seen any of those you like or?

I've spent some time with Daydream.

It's interesting.

Um, I think that there are-- there's a lot
of education I think you have to give the

user to figure out how to, like interact
with the pl- in theory, it's great.

So what it does is you can like show it
a photo or you can, you can use one of

its photos, um, or, or one of their, one
of its products, and you can say, "Yes,

that shirt, but one with like balloon
sleeves," or like, "Yes, that dress, but

I want one that's more waist-defined."

And it allows you that refinement process,
which is really cool, but it's pretty

restricted to their ecosystem still,
which I find a little bit frustrating.

Um, also, I-- it's still just a
web-based experience for me at least.

I don't think they have an app yet.

And I think until they can really get like
an install base and, and track kind of

what's happening there, they're gonna…

I'm sure that's next.

I mean, I'm sure that's what
they're gonna launch next.

I like it in theory.

I think, I wonder like how much of a
competitive advantage they actually

have versus like that kind of
technology being easily copyable or

easily integrated into like ChatGPT.

Yeah.

Cool.

I, I mentioned to you when we were
in the green room that, uh, I'm

gonna be giving a talk at Retail
Club coming up here in mid-September.

Um, and I'm gonna be talking about are
brand sites ultimately, uh, doomed, or

are they gonna be with us for a long time?

Do you have a, you know, when brands--
are brands asking you that question?

Um, and what do you think about it?

I don't think they're doomed.

I just think over the years, the
role of D2C continues to evolve.

So like, it used to be kind of the main
way that you got in front of the shopper

if, like, you couldn't figure out how to
grow your products on Amazon or something.

I think then the role changed a little
bit as, as a lot of brands struggled with

their negotiations with Amazon as, like,
a backup for, you know, either fulfill,

either directing the shopper there or
doing their, or at least doing their own

fulfillment and then list- having, being a
seller on Amazon and, um, ha- making sure

that they have that technology capability
on the back end to do order fulfillment.

Um, I think now it's the opportun- it's
really the only place that you have…

I, I think the opportunity for the brand
store is really high right now in being

the most AI-readable space and the biggest
playground a brand has to experiment

with different types of content.

Like, the retailer marketplaces, online
marketplaces are still pretty restrictive.

Like, the images have to be a certain
way and meet certain requirements.

The bullet points have to
contain certain content.

You can't say this or that.

You can't mention other brands.

You know, there's still a lot of…

And, and that's just Amazon.

Like, Target's even more restrictive.

So I think it is the, the, it's
your biggest white space as a brand

to really, like, include all your
content, talk about your brand.

Those sites are generally
pretty easy for AI to crawl.

So I think they're a great opportunity
right now, um, for, for, like, a

source of truth for answer engines,
and I think that's an important

role they can play right now.

Whether the shopper actually
transacts there or not, who cares?

Like, you got all your information
fed into the answer engine, so that's

great, and I think brands should really
be experimenting with their D2C sites

right now from a content perspective.

Yeah.

It's a big opportunity because the,
i- if you, if your brand, if your

site is driving a lot of transactions,
you can't fiddle with the content

too much, 'cause you don't wanna tank
the human conversion rate, right?

But if you have one that, that's
not super active, then it's a great

opportunity to fill it up with the kind
of m- text, more text-rich content that

a consumer may get bored by, but an LLM
is just gonna love that type of content.

Yeah.

Um, I mean, that's kind of the--
some of the space that, that you're

in, so be interested to hear, like,
have you seen any brands doing

anything interesting or creative
on their D2Cs to try to do a better

job integrating with answer engines?

So having an area, like a tabbed
interface where the consumer can kind

of go to almost like specifications
of the product, you know?

Like you're, you're not gonna
lead with that because that's

just like super text heavy.

But the LLM, it, it wants so much context.

It would like an 80-page PDF of
everything about your product,

like, you know, contents and like,
oh, you know, uh, ingredients.

An- anything like that you can provide
every dimension of every little thing.

But that would be just like
terribly painfully boring

for a consumer to look at.

So, so, so kind of having a way for
the, the crawler to get to it on

the p- it needs to be on the PDP.

There's all these companies that
are kind of saying, "Well, maybe

we'll have this whole other thing
that the, that looks at it."

The LLM's not gonna do that.

Um, I do think ultimately they're gonna
all, all open up merchant centers, and

it, it won't be the traditional feeds.

It's gonna be way
smarter and deeper feeds.

But there'll be a way to feed a bunch
of information into them to, to,

to make sure they have the context.

And are you noticing that the LM--
LLMs are showing any preference for

D2C sites as like a source of truth?

They're pretty agnostic.

They, they tend to-- They really like,
um, anything that has comparison content.

So one of the best content strategies
for a brand is to, you know, if you have

these influencers out there, get them
to do a, a listicle, like top 10 vitamin

supplements for, you know, uh, you know,
whatever condition or something like that.

Um, they love-- That seems to be
like-- As, as you look at the content

they like and rate as influence the
highest, that's number one right now.

Yeah.

That tracks.

As I try to shop on ChatGPT,
often the sources are like-

They love a listicle.

… technology.

Like I can't remember, geek something,
where they like, um, show all--

They do a lot of listicles, right?

Like kind of consumer
report sort of style stuff.

Yeah.

Mm-hmm.

Yeah.

So, so that, that's like at the
top of the tree, and then it, it

does, it isn't, you know, the, the--
They will consume that content.

But that gets down into when
the user's at a more refined…

Like at the research, it may not
come up, um, because at that you're

looking to, you know, is, is this, how
does this compare to other offerings?

But then once you're in the
consideration set, that's when that…

Then, then the user's starting to say
what I would call compatibility questions.

Well, you know, will it work with this?

Is the dress made of cotton or a mix?

And, you know, those types of things.

That's where that content
is, can be super helpful.

Interesting.

And so that would also point to
some of the comparison widgets on

Amazon's, um, you know- Uh, product
pages that you can create too.

Yeah.

Yeah, the Am- Amazon
content's not in there.

So, so Amazon's blocking the bots.

So, you know, one of the negative
things with these challenger brands

is because they've invested so much
in TikTok and Amazon, and that's where

a lot of their content lives, I think
they're gonna be blind to the LLMs.

I, I don't think it's pulling that in,
at least not, they, you know, recently.

Unless they have pretty, what sounds
like pretty well-developed D2C sites.

Yeah.

Yeah.

The D2C site is gonna be really…

You're, you're spot on
with your advice there.

I strongly agree.

Cool.

That's interesting.

Any, um, I don't wanna
use too much of your time.

Any, uh, predictions or other thoughts
that you're hearing from your large

set of brands you talk to every day?

I don't know about a prediction, but
just something that is like, I mean,

it's not keeping me up at night 'cause
it's not really the space that I'm in.

But I, I spoke at the Path to Purchase,
uh, Retail Media Summit this summer,

and it was just this entire conference
of retail media professionals that all

work at like different, different, um,
cogs in the wheel of the technology

surrounding search-based advertising.

And I just, it, it kind-- I had this
thought while I was standing there

in front of the audience that like, I
mean, are these people gonna have jobs?

Like in, in a year or five years?

I mean, I imagine this is
just all gonna transform.

Like, there's still gonna be advertising
dollars, and they're still gonna

be, they need to put it somewhere,
so of course they'll have jobs.

But like th-this indust- that specific
industry is going to look dramatically

different than it does today.

Yeah.

A- and I think a harbinger for that
is I know a lot of people in the

SEO world, and that, that world is
just being, you know, decimated.

And they're, they're trying to
pivot to GEO, but it's so inherently

different, and the tooling and
like the, the, the, you know…

You can influence Google a lot, but the
LLMs are not nearly as influenceable.

So, yeah.

It, that's an, that's another
industry that was so search-based

that it's having a really hard time
transitioning in, into this new world.

Yeah.

We, like, and it almost, like, died.

Like, the old form of it died
and was, had an, was born as it's

been, something new has been born.

Yeah.

They'll, uh, they'll find a place.

I think they're … I don't, I
predict OpenAI's not gonna do ads.

Sam Altman's been pretty, he's got
a pretty valid reason why not to,

but he also has to make, like, 100
billion over the next two years.

So there's a lot of flexibility
when you have a number like that.

But so, so I think some of them
will be more ad-based and there'll

be plenty of ways to get your
products in front of people.

I, I think they'll have a job.

I think that the risk exists maybe
more for some of the, well, in

like the grocery ecosystem, some of
the intermediaries like Instacart

or whatever, who are aggregating.

I mean, they're not even
really a marketplace.

They're kind of a marketplace, but they're
aggregating and helping the shopper

discover across multiple retailers.

And if you look at tech companies
that do that type of, provide

that type of a service, I think
those are at risk if they're not

evolving, um, to, you know, create…

They, now their competition
is an LLM, right?

Like- And as soon as they figure
out how to do some kind of a

delivery across, I think that's,
that's where the real risk lies.

But, um,

it'll be interesting to see
if, if that's true, if what Sam

Altman-- if he stays true to his
word on that advertising dollar.

There are a lot of advertising dollars,
and it goes straight to your bottom

line, and, you know, we've seen how
that has impacted Amazon's experience

at the expense of the shopper, right?

Over the years, even though Amazon
claimed to be so s- shopper-centric.

You know, now it's hard to find
really what you're looking for and

get around all the ads, uh, 'cause
the money was just so tempting, right?

Yeah.

I think they can go a couple years without
crossing that chasm, but Google can't.

So Google's gonna have to figure it out.

They're gonna have to figure out, is there
an intersection there where they can,

they can be as competitive and have as
good as answers as ChatGPT, um, and have

ads and not have it, you know, change,
influence it so much that the consumer

doesn't engage and trust it as much.

So it's gonna be-- There, there's a
lot of like early skirmishes that are

gonna kinda tell us how this is gonna go
that, that we're keeping a close eye on.

Yeah.

And they've kind of fumbled around
with Google Shopping, like trying to

figure out what value it provides and
how to aggregate all those listings

and allow you to filter and…

I mean, I think they end up being, you
know, an initial source of, of product

discovery sometimes, but then that's
not where the transaction is happening.

Yeah.

Yeah.

There's a lot of-- Some of these GEO
experts have found that a lot of the

engines are calling into Google Shopping
to get some products to then-- and then

they, you know, they don't attribute it
at all, but they're, they're using some

inputs from Google Shopping a lot of times
to get the super set of things to look at,

and then they narrow it down pretty fast.

So that, that's kind of interesting.

That is interesting.

I think Amazon's just trying to
go head-to-head with the LLMs.

I think they're like, "You know what?

Let's make our search as smart as possible
so that we don't lose the shopper to an

LLM, and let's give them an answer engine
that's specific to product research and

discovery," which is Rufus, and it'll be
interesting to see if they can compete.

Yeah.

Rufus has not, has been, uh,
extremely underwhelming so far.

Yeah.

I don't know if you've had
a different experience.

It's better than not having it, though.

It's funny to hear him talk about it
because they realize their search is

broken and that Rufus is better, and
they have to, like, be very careful about

how they navigate that, that, yeah, the,
that, that innovator's dilemma is a very

tricky problem for everyone to be in.

It is, and I, I do wonder
sometimes, like, they…

the people running the show over there, I
just-- I feel like they're not totally in

touch with the current shopper experience.

Like, if you listen to the latest, um,
earnings call, there was a part of it

where Andy Jassy said something about
he was touting the capabilities of

Alexa and the voice ac- you know, all
these things, agentic stuff you can

do with your voice now and how you…

And the example he gave was, "Hey,
Alexa, I'm having a din-dinner party.

Like, can you turn the lights
down to, like, this level?"

And I'm like, "Whose use case is that?"

Like, who has an entirely
wired smart home?

Who's having dinner parties and
lowering the light, needing, needing

to use Alexa to lower the lights
'cause you have so many lights that

you have to go turn them all down?

Like, it was just a really weird
example that kind of made me wonder

if they're actually solving concrete
problems that consumers have right now.

Yeah.

Yeah.

The-- I've had Alexa Plus, and, uh, a
lot of the use cases are not shopping.

They're kinda like using…

It's the, the gateway to other apps is
pretty interesting, so it can talk to

Uber and, um, it can book res-reservations
and things of that nature.

But again, it's kind of an interesting…

I don't know how that's ringing Amazon's
cash register to, to u- you know, for

me to use Open Door through Alexa.

So yeah.

Yeah.

It's interesting.

Well, Andrea, I appreciate you taking
time, uh, out of your busy schedule.

Thanks for sharing, uh, all the, the
update of the report and giving us a

little bit of a real-time feeling for
what you're hearing from all your brands.

Thank you for having me, Scott.

I learned a lot from you, as I always
do, and I appreciate the conversation.

And if anyone wants the report, it's free.

It's on our website, illumgroups.com.

Awesome.

And when it comes out next, you gotta
come back on and give us an update.

Absolutely.

Follow, rate, and share to stay up
to date with RetailGenic, your guide

to the future of AI shopping agents.