The Forward Thinking Dental Podcast
SEO METADATA
SEO TITLE:
First Permanent Molars of Poor Prognosis: Save or Extract? | PDP279
META DESCRIPTION:
Dr Nicole Sturzenbaum on MIH first molars: when to restore or extract, timing with an OPG, numbing sensitive teeth, and talking to parents.
URL SLUG:
first-permanent-molars-poor-prognosis-mih
PRIMARY TOPIC:
Managing first permanent molars of poor prognosis in children
SECONDARY SEARCH TOPICS:
- Molar incisor hypomineralisation (MIH)
- Timing of first permanent molar extraction
- Restoring MIH molars with sealants, composite and stainless steel crowns
- Local anaesthesia for sensitive MIH molars
- Orthodontic opinion before first molar extraction
- Balancing and compensating extractions
- Talking to parents about first molar extraction
- Prevention-led paediatric dentistry
MAINTAIN OR EXTRACT? FIRST PERMANENT MOLARS OF POOR PROGNOSIS
THE PROTRUSIVE DENTAL PODCAST, EPISODE PDP279
HOST: DR JAZ GULATI
GUEST: DR NICOLE STURZENBAUM
EPISODE SUMMARY
In this episode of the Protrusive Dental Podcast, Dr Jaz Gulati talks to Dr Nicole Sturzenbaum, a paediatric dentist who trained in Germany and founded Toothbeary, a specialist children's dental practice in Richmond, in 2008. They discuss one of general dentistry's trickiest decisions: whether to maintain or extract a first permanent molar of poor prognosis.
Nicole explains that most of the poor-prognosis molars she sees are caused by molar incisor hypomineralisation (MIH), and why it's vital not to blame the child or parents. She sets out her step-by-step approach, from sealants and good-quality composites to stainless steel crowns, how to judge extraction timing from an OPG by looking at the second molar's bifurcation and the presence of third molars, and when to seek an orthodontic opinion. She also shares tips for numbing sensitive MIH molars, answers community questions on chalky molars, space management, long-term prognosis and balancing and compensating extractions, and explains Toothbeary's prevention-led philosophy. Jaz's Protrusive Dental Pearl is about chemical polishing for children with Magic 3.
IN SHORT
This episode explains how to decide whether to keep or extract a child's first permanent molar of poor prognosis. Dr Nicole Sturzenbaum's approach is to diagnose MIH correctly, seal or restore early with good-quality composite, take an OPG to time any extraction to the second molar's bifurcation, involve an orthodontist when unsure, and take the child's sensitivity and pain seriously.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
- Nicole sees MIH, not simple caries, as the main cause of poor-prognosis first molars, and stresses that it's not the child's or parents' fault.
- Seal MIH molars early, and restore small cavities with good-quality composite under rubber dam; Nicole says these last.
- Stainless steel crowns can relieve sensitivity and protect the tooth until extraction or a later inlay.
- Use an OPG, not chronological age; the ideal extraction time is when the second molar's bifurcation starts to form.
- Check for developing third molars, and be cautious about extracting if there are none.
- MIH molars can be hard to numb; Nicole uses pre-operative ibuprofen, nitrous oxide, adequate local anaesthetic and Tooth Mousse beforehand.
- Nicole prefers extracting only compromised teeth, with an Essix retainer to prevent over-eruption, rather than routine balancing extractions.
- Heavy plaque on an MIH molar often means it hurts to brush, not that the child doesn't brush.
QUESTIONS ANSWERED IN THIS EPISODE
1. Why do first permanent molars have a poor prognosis in children?
2. What is molar incisor hypomineralisation (MIH)?
3. How should you treat MIH molars?
4. When is the best time to extract a first permanent molar?
5. Do you need an orthodontic opinion before extracting a first molar?
6. How do you get MIH molars numb?
7. What should you do with the space after extracting a first molar?
8. Are balancing and compensating extractions still recommended?
IN THIS EPISODE
1. Introduction: first permanent molars of poor prognosis
2. Protrusive Dental Pearl: chemical polishing for children with Magic 3
3. Meet Dr Nicole Sturzenbaum and Toothbeary
4. Prevention in paediatric dentistry: Germany vs the UK
5. Why first molars have a poor prognosis: MIH, not just caries
6. Assessing MIH molars: history, an OPG and a step-by-step approach
7. Stainless steel crowns for MIH molars, and restoring them later
8. Getting an orthodontic opinion, and the ideal time to extract a first molar
9. Talking to parents about saving or extracting first molars
10. Community questions: how to get MIH molars numb
11. Chalky molars, hopeless molars and managing the space after extraction
12. Restore or extract? Long-term prognosis, balancing and compensating
13. Final advice: take sensitivity seriously, and seal erupting MIH molars
14. Toothbeary and prevention-led paediatric dentistry, and wrap-up
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION: FIRST PERMANENT MOLARS OF POOR PROGNOSIS
JAZ:
First permanent molars of poor prognosis: this is a real-world challenge that we see as general dentists and paediatric dentists. I know this episode's going to be very popular. Not only do we have a wonderful guest in Dr Nicole Sturzenbaum, but this topic is so foundational. There are so many ifs and buts and timing considerations: making sure the diagnosis is right, and making sure the communication with parents is right. We're talking about children with an adult first molar affected either by caries or by molar incisor hypomineralisation, MIH, which is being talked about so much more now than it used to be.
My own son has signs of MIH. He's got these cheese molars coming through. I remember how devastated my wife was when she started to see that first molar come through. These teeth will often be more sensitive, more prone to caries and more prone to breakdown. So should we consider extraction?
What's the ideal time to extract these molars, if appropriate? What's the cost of not extracting them, and how do you weigh up the pros and cons of extracting versus trying to maintain them? And I haven't even mentioned orthodontic considerations. There's so much to talk about here, and I'm excited, because we're going to feed this episode's transcript into Ask Jaz.
That's where you get to chat with me, and I can speak Finnish, Chinese, Italian, you name it. I speak a whole bunch of languages, and it's my voice. The entire back catalogue of episodes and our masterclasses is fed into Ask Jaz. So next time you have a patient, you can say, "My patient's nine years old, and their first molar looks like this, but their left molar is completely fine.
What should I do?" This episode will help you. It'll even point you to the timestamps in this episode to listen to for a deeper understanding of your individual query. Listen: if you treat or manage children, this will be one of the top episodes you listen to this year.
CHAPTER 2: PROTRUSIVE DENTAL PEARL: CHEMICAL POLISHING FOR CHILDREN WITH MAGIC 3
JAZ:
Before we join the chat with Nicole and learn all about this nuanced topic, I'm going to give you your Protrusive Dental Pearl. I've made it relevant to children's dentistry and how to deliver good care to children, and we're going to talk about hygiene. Patients, adults and children alike, can get very nervous about the mechanical cleaning we do.
They don't like scalers, or the bristle brush or cup with polishing paste. The whole experience can be a bit overwhelming. So for children, I have a product recommendation. It's called Magic 3. You may have heard about it in a previous episode, and you'll hear a lot more about it in the next episode.
The next episode is all about chemical polishing, and the dangers of the mechanical polishing we do. Magic 3 is 3% hydrogen peroxide, and it can be used safely in children, even under 16, because it's a class one medical device. It's not for whitening. It's a colourless plaque indicator.
That's right: it won't turn everything purple or blue. It's colourless. You know where the plaque is because it fizzes, and it also just destroys the plaque, leaving the teeth feeling satin-smooth. If there's calculus, yes, you still need a hand scaler or an ultrasonic scaler. You can't remove calculus with Magic 3.
But for the polishing part, it's a great thing to use. Once you've applied the gel, you can show the child in the mirror, and it fizzes everywhere there's plaque. It's completely painless, colourless, safe and highly effective. It reduces inflammation, and parents and children love it because it's non-invasive.
You do have to agitate the gel a little by the gingiva to get the maximum effect, but it's so much nicer than traditional polishing. It's especially useful if you treat children, and particularly if you do orthodontics in your practice and see adolescents, because it's so effective at removing plaque. It gets into all the nooks and crannies, and it prevents white patches.
That was actually the main reason the inventor, Dr Wyman Chan, made it: to prevent post-orthodontic white patches. But then he found how well it polishes teeth chemically, so it now has a whole bunch of indications. I'll put the links in the show notes, whether you're international or in the UK, so you can learn more about Magic 3. The link is protrusive.co.uk/magic3. That's the word "magic" with a 3 at the end of it. Let's now join the main episode, and I'll catch you in the outro.
CHAPTER 3: MEET DR NICOLE STURZENBAUM AND TOOTHBEARY
JAZ:
Dr Nicole Sturzenbaum, welcome to the Protrusive Dental Podcast. It's so great to have you. I've known of you for a long time, and you get spoken about a lot at home. My wife thinks you're an amazing trailblazer, given everything you've achieved.
When I used to work in Oxford back in the day, we used to refer our patients 50 miles to come and see you. I hear it all the time: patients from Dorset, from here and there. What an incredible practice you've built. My own son is a patient at your practice. So we have to start with you and your journey.
Please tell us about yourself, how you got into paeds, life in the UK, and the things you're passionate about within paediatric dentistry.
DR NICOLE STURZENBAUM:
Okay. Thank you so much, first of all. I feel very honoured, and it's fantastic to work with your wife, by the way. It's actually a long story. You can have the long or the short version. I graduated in Germany, as you probably know, and when you finish, you have to do two years of training afterwards, as you do in the UK. I was so shocked when I went into normal practice after university. I loved university. I loved the courses, everything. And then I started in normal practice, and I didn't like it.
I was so unhappy, and I couldn't believe this was what I'd be doing for the rest of my life. I thought, "I have to come up with something to change this," 'cause I didn't want to do prosthodontics and implants and those kinds of things. At that time, the first postgraduate degree in paediatric dentistry had just come out, and I saw it and thought, "You know what?
When we did paeds at uni, I really liked it. I ended up seeing all the children. Everyone who didn't want to see the children sent them to me." So I thought, "Maybe that's your calling." I did the course, which was amazing, and I was still in the practice, so I tried to set up some days where I only saw children.
I was an associate, obviously. And it was good, but it didn't work 100%. I was so limited in what I could do for the kids. I couldn't do the treatment, because there's only so much you can do in a normal practice. So I realised I had to go to a proper paediatric practice, and there were a couple of large ones in Germany at the time, like ours is now.
So I said, "Okay, let's move to Munich and do the training in a paediatric practice," which I did, and oh my goodness, it was heaven-sent. I really loved it. You know when you can't wait to go back to work the next day because you're already looking forward to it? It opened up a new world.
JAZ:
Amazing.
DR NICOLE STURZENBAUM:
It was amazing. I knew this was what I'd do until I stopped working. And then, unfortunately or very fortunately, I met my husband, who lived in the UK at the time. He's half German, half British, and he studied in the UK. He was a Royal Society research fellow, so he had a job at a university.
So we had to come and live in the UK. And I said from the beginning, "Only if I can really do paeds properly." I couldn't just start doing it somewhere half-heartedly. It wouldn't work. So I had to open my own place. There was nothing like it at the time, so I took the big risk and opened Toothbeary in 2008. It was amazing, but it was hard.
JAZ:
Even now, private paeds clinics are a niche, and they're rare. Back then, it was almost unheard of, so it was a very brave thing to do.
DR NICOLE STURZENBAUM:
It was indeed, I have to admit. I didn't realise. Luckily, I was young enough and naive enough to think, "Yeah, yeah, everyone will love it, and it's just what the country needs." But it was a tough start, especially as I opened Toothbeary exactly as it is now, with 11 chairs. So it was a big place to fill, but that's how paeds works.
You have to have a big place. We had a couple of years where we really had to fight for it, but luckily it worked out in the end. I have a wonderful team, honestly, and wonderful dentists who came to work with me and supported me. At the end of the day, it's a team effort, and that's what created the place and makes it different, for sure.
CHAPTER 4: PREVENTION IN PAEDIATRIC DENTISTRY: GERMANY VS THE UK
JAZ:
Well, I think we could have a whole podcast one day on the qualities of leadership: how to be an effective leader and run a well-oiled machine. From what I've seen at the clinic, everything runs so well, and Sim tells me how well-trained the nurses are and how systematised everything is.
But we'll save that for another day, and I'm sure there's a lot we can learn from you about it. What I want to delve into is the clinical stuff. We're talking about first permanent molars of poor prognosis. But before we go into that, I want to ask your opinion.
There's specialist care, high-level paediatric specialist care for children, and then there's what reasonable dentists can achieve in general practice. How does general practice and paediatric care in the UK differ from general care in Germany?
DR NICOLE STURZENBAUM:
God, that's hard to say, because I left Germany so long ago, 18 years now. But the focus on prevention is definitely much bigger in Germany. It's state-funded, 'cause we have a system similar to the NHS, but in ours, prevention plays a massive role. When I set up days for children, it was state-funded, and you could do toothbrushing classes, sealants and hygiene sessions.
That's part of the state-funded prevention system. Children have to see the dentist twice a year to get their stamp. And later in life, even as adults, if you need proper crown work or prosthodontics, the state contribution depends on whether you've really seen your dentist every six months. You have to prove it. If you haven't, you won't get as much contribution. I think that's key to everything.
JAZ:
So your childhood attendance dictates that?
DR NICOLE STURZENBAUM:
I don't think they still look at childhood attendance. I don't know exactly how many years they go back. But if you're 16 and you've never been to the dentist, you won't get as much for bigger work.
Fillings and so on are different, but if you really need a crown or a bridge, they look at your attendance and contribute accordingly. That's where I come from. So the main thing is prevention, prevention, prevention, which, from my perspective, still makes sense, 'cause it's an infectious disease. We can prevent it.
CHAPTER 5: WHY FIRST MOLARS HAVE A POOR PROGNOSIS: MIH, NOT JUST CARIES
JAZ:
Thanks for sharing that, Nicole. Now, I want to ask about first permanent molars of poor prognosis. I pitched this to the community as well. It's a conundrum that general dentists face all the time, when these sixes, or first molars for the international audience, erupt broken down, or get severe caries at a very early age.
It's a decision-making tree, because we know we could intervene and allow the second molars to come into place, but it's often a big deal. We'll talk about why it can be a big deal for parents. I'm sure you have lots of lengthy discussions with parents who are shocked: "Oh my goodness, my child needs an adult tooth removed."
We'll talk all about managing the parents, which is often trickier than managing the child. But taking it all the way back, can you describe the patients who get referred to you? Why are these first permanent molars in a state of poor prognosis? Is it MIH, caries, or a bit of both? What's the number one reason you see?
DR NICOLE STURZENBAUM:
100% MIH. MIH is the beginning of everything. Of course, most of the time, by the time they end up with us, there's decay on these teeth. But the reason for the decay is the MIH, and for me it's super important to differentiate, because if it's decay from not brushing and poor hygiene, I take a completely different approach than with a child who has MIH, where I know it's not their fault.
It's just the condition. And then, of course, I'm more willing to save the tooth and put in more effort. Even if that sounds cruel, I know the background, and I definitely want to support the child, because I know they suffer as well. With MIH, it's not only the decay. It's the discomfort, the pain, and the journey they've already been through, most likely over the last one to two years. That's why it's a very important diagnosis to make.
And for dentists in general too, if you ask me what general dentists should do: they should acknowledge it, 'cause the worst thing you can do is blame someone when a child comes in with MIH and decay. I have parents who say, "Oh yeah, the dentist said it's my fault."
No. No, no, no, no. It's not the parents' fault. Parents don't even know the tooth has erupted, and by the time it's fully through and has MIH, the child is already sensitive, has pain, and doesn't brush properly because of the sensitivity. That's where we have to be more understanding and more supportive. That's what I think.
JAZ:
So true, because it's completely different from a child who's had access to lots of sugar. MIH, again, is not their fault. But it's interesting that dentists in general practice need to make that distinction and diagnosis. I remember on my elective, maybe 16 or 17 years ago, I was in Vietnam with some Canadian dentists, and when we were talking about MIH, they said, "What's MIH?" Lovely dentists, by the way.
They were celebrating 25 years out of dental school, and they had no idea what MIH was. So to educate anyone watching who hasn't come across MIH before, or any dental students, can you tell us a bit more about the incidence, what it stands for, and what causes it? We know it's not the child's fault, but give us a couple of minutes of background on MIH.
DR NICOLE STURZENBAUM:
To be perfectly honest, we still don't know much about MIH. We don't know why it happens. We have theories, and if you go into the paediatric field, there's so much research going on into MIH, because I think it's one of the biggest concerns right now.
What we know is how it presents. It's called molar incisor hypomineralisation because it affects the first permanent molars and the front teeth. So I always say to parents, "Look, you could have one tooth affected, or 12," because it happens during the development of these teeth.
So one child may have only one defect on one six, while the next has a complete lack of enamel on all their sixes, plus white, yellow or brown spots on the front teeth. It comes in different grades: a very mild form, a moderate form or a more severe form, and you can see it on the teeth to a greater or lesser degree.
You may just have white, yellow or brown spots. You may already have enamel breakdown, or a complete lack of enamel on some molars. But once you've seen a severely affected MIH tooth, you'll never forget it, and you'll know exactly what it looks like, 'cause they look so unique.
CHAPTER 6: ASSESSING MIH MOLARS: HISTORY, AN OPG AND A STEP-BY-STEP APPROACH
JAZ:
I like the term "cheese molar". My son's got them as well. I used to diagnose these, and now my own son has them, and yes, cheese molars, totally not his fault. So once we've made this diagnosis, through clinical observation and history, and figured out it didn't develop from caries...
The caries is quite often secondary to breakdown. When these patients are referred to you, sometimes it's already too late by the time they see you. But for those of us in clinic seeing six- and seven-year-olds, where we can see the brown, the yellow and the surface breakdown and can intervene, we may also need to assess whether the tooth has a future for this child.
Because extraction can be timed to allow the second molar to come into place, and this is where general dentists get a bit confused and stuck. They might want an ortho opinion. They might want your opinion. So what information do you need from the history and radiographs to make a clinical decision with your patient?
DR NICOLE STURZENBAUM:
It's definitely an individual approach. I know everyone always wants a one-size-fits-all approach, but that's impossible, particularly with MIH. As you said, there's the history. Has there already been pain? Was there discomfort? What's the hygiene like? What's the family's approach to it?
What's the ortho situation? What will attendance be like, whatever I do? So it's not an easy task, and it's not a quick fix where the patient comes in, you see them and go, "Oh yeah, there's MIH, let's do extractions." No, that would be wrong.
As you said, you have to look at the development of the seven. If the bifurcation is already developing, that's the right time for extraction. But don't extract when the child only has the cusps of the seven at that point. You have to take an OPG to assess the development of the seven. And then, of course, you have to see all-
JAZ:
Is a PA not good enough?
DR NICOLE STURZENBAUM:
You want to see all the sevens, right? 'Cause you want to do a proper ortho assessment as well, and see how likely it is that this child will need orthodontic extractions. Because if you go down that route, you'll most likely decide to take the sixes, not healthy fives.
But that's most likely not decided at the point when you first see the child. And this isn't evidence-based, but in my experience, decay and enamel breakdown happen within the first two years after eruption. It's very rare to see a 12-year-old with MIH who suddenly has problems with their sixes.
They usually get problems straight away. If I see them at 12, it's usually because someone tried to fix it, couldn't do it properly, and just nursed it along for the next few years, and then we end up with a tooth that may now be unrestorable. That's the worst-case scenario, because then it's too late for extraction, and then what do you do?
So it's complicated, and I know you want a very easy answer from me, for everyone watching. My point would be this. If I were a young dentist, or even an old dentist, in normal practice, and I saw a child with MIH and no enamel breakdown, then definitely a sealant.
Sealant, sealant, sealant straight away. That would be my first approach. If there's enamel breakdown and a small cavity, I'd do a composite filling. Get your margin into healthy enamel and healthy dentine, widen your surface area a bit, and do a good composite filling. And since you asked me about the difference between German and British dentists...
Believe in your capabilities. Do proper, good-quality dentistry, composite dentistry. It works. I know a lot of people think, "Oh no, the fillings will fail." No, they don't fail. Do it well, do it with rubber dam, do it properly, and it will last. I promise you that. That would always be my first approach.
If the tooth is in really poor condition, the child has suffered, and you can see they're not brushing because of the trauma from the tooth, then get your ortho opinion, and maybe refer if you're not sure whether to do the extractions. Alternatives are stainless steel crowns and pulpotomy, but it gets really complicated down that route, because you have to decide: do you really want to save the tooth for the long run, or do you have a six-year-old where you just want to keep the tooth until they're old enough for extraction?
And of course, you need the parents on board. What do they really want? Do they want to put in all that effort to get the best result, or do they want a quick fix? There are so many factors to consider.
JAZ:
There are so many factors: the orthodontic element, the hygiene element, how sensitive it is, and age being a huge one, as well as the parents' wishes.
There's so much. So I appreciate there's no single answer, but the guidelines you've given are very helpful. You gave some nice scenarios, and a clear message that we should be seeing these patients early. We see our six-year-olds twice a year, sometimes four times a year if they're higher risk.
We get to intervene in general care. We don't want to just leave it to brew until it becomes a nine-year-old with a much bigger problem. So early diagnosis and prevention, including fissure sealants, are important. That's a great guideline.
CHAPTER 7: STAINLESS STEEL CROWNS FOR MIH MOLARS, AND RESTORING THEM LATER
JAZ:
Let's talk about stainless steel crowns, which maybe I'm jumping ahead to. When you place a stainless steel crown, or preformed metal crown, is it always to buy time before extraction, or is it with a view to a definitive restoration when the child is older and the gingiva has matured? What's the mindset when you place a metal crown like that?
DR NICOLE STURZENBAUM:
One option, for example, if we know the prognosis is poor, is to keep the tooth until the right window of opportunity for extraction. The other is definitely to keep the tooth and just protect it for the time being.
Sometimes there isn't even a big defect, but there's very high sensitivity. With a stainless steel crown, you cover the tooth, and the child will be pain-free. You don't have to drill much. You maybe reduce the height a tiny bit, if at all, and then you put the crown on.
Then, at 15 or 16, you can take the crown off, and you only have the original defect to deal with, so maybe you can do a ceramic or composite inlay. International standards are moving more and more towards composite inlays on hypomineralised teeth.
But of course, the child has to be a certain age. You won't do that on a six-year-old. It's far too much. But if you have a 10-year-old who's already had a composite filling that isn't working 100% anymore, with some shrinkage or whatever, and the tooth is completely symptom-free, then at 12 you can already put a composite inlay on. That's more and more where it's going.
JAZ:
So when the time comes to remove the metal crown and you clean away the cement, you said there's a ceramic option or a composite option.
Again, the patient's still young, which is why the resilience and minimal invasiveness of composite come in. Would it be a direct composite, like an overlay that hugs the whole tooth? Is that what you have in mind?
DR NICOLE STURZENBAUM:
Just occlusal, if it's only an occlusal defect. Again, the decision to keep the tooth long term depends very much on the size of the defect. If you have an MOD, a breakdown of the enamel, it's really difficult to think the tooth has a really good long-term prognosis.
But if you just have a highly sensitive tooth, where normal composite won't get the child out of sensitivity or pain, then a little protective crown will do the job for the time being.
And in my experience, these teeth are super-sensitive at the beginning, but they settle down. You may have a child who now needs just an occlusal composite filling but is still a bit sensitive. As long as the tooth is in the mouth and matures, and you use your MI Paste, fluoride applications and all the other things we have these days, it gets better, and the teeth are symptom-free after a few years.
JAZ:
Noted. It's really useful to know more about these crowns as an option.
CHAPTER 8: GETTING AN ORTHODONTIC OPINION, AND THE IDEAL TIME TO EXTRACT A FIRST MOLAR
JAZ:
But let's say we're thinking, "Hmm, could this patient be a candidate for extraction?" Would you say to general dentists that getting an ortho opinion before extracting a first molar is desirable or essential?
DR NICOLE STURZENBAUM:
It depends on your knowledge. If you feel very confident in ortho, and you can see severe crowding and know the child will definitely need orthodontic extractions at some point, then you can confidently say, "Look, we'll take these teeth out. There's no point trying to do pulpotomies and crowns on this tooth now.
And then, in three years' time, you'll need a fixed brace, then we'll need extractions, and then what do we do?" Then you can do it now. I've literally just finished my last sedation of the day, where I took out four sixes because of hypomineralisation. It was a referral from an orthodontist, so that's easy. I won't interfere with his decision.
JAZ:
That's good to know. I think most general dentists will probably want an ortho opinion, because it's a big thing to justify to parents, and I'm sure we'll get into communication with parents.
But talking specifically about timing, the ideal window: in the textbook, yes, there's chronological age, but there's also dental age from the radiograph. Can you tell us exactly what you're looking for on the OPG, when it's too late, when it's too early, and when it's just right?
DR NICOLE STURZENBAUM:
Definitely don't go by chronological age, 'cause we all know your age doesn't show the stage of your dental development. So always take an OPG, please. Then look at the bifurcation of the seven. If you can see the bifurcation starting, that's the perfect time. A little before or a little after is fine, of course.
But if the seven is fully developed, you know the gap won't close naturally. You can always involve the orthodontist to close the gap for you. And what we also do, as well as looking at the seven, is look for evidence of a wisdom tooth.
Because we want the children to have two molars in the end. As I said, it's such an individual decision that it's hard to say do this or that. But if a child has no eights, no wisdom teeth developing at all, I feel a bit uncomfortable taking the sixes out.
Then I really have to see that the prognosis is really poor and there's already pain, maybe pulpitis somewhere. Then yes. But not just because there's an occlusal or mesio-occlusal defect. I have parents come in and say, "Yeah, yeah, they need the extractions," 'cause someone told them.
I'll even convince them not to do it if I'm convinced it's the right call, because you can save these teeth really well, with a really good long-term prognosis. So, as I said: look at the seven, look at the eight, look at the ortho situation, look at the pain, look at the history. You have to consider everything.
CHAPTER 9: TALKING TO PARENTS ABOUT SAVING OR EXTRACTING FIRST MOLARS
JAZ:
With these patients, as you mentioned, there are parents who come in with a preconceived idea because another dentist has told them, "Hey, I think these need to come out." In those scenarios, you're thinking about the patient's best interests and advising, "Actually, you should consider saving these teeth."
And there's the other scenario, where based on everything you see, you think extraction is the best choice, but the parents are adamant they want to save little Johnny's teeth. Tell us about the discussions you have with parents, and how challenging they can be.
DR NICOLE STURZENBAUM:
As you said, parents usually have some idea themselves, not only because a dentist has said so, but because they do their internet research, as we know, which makes our lives a bit more difficult than maybe five years ago. But they usually understand if you really show them. You take the X-ray and show them that the seven is there and isn't ready, and that it will tip into the gap, and the risks involved.
Another question, of course, is whether we know the seven is healthy. We can't guarantee it. Having a hypomineralised six doesn't mean the seven will be hypomineralised too, but anything is possible, and then you could end up with no teeth at the back. Those are usually convincing arguments.
Once you've mentioned that you don't know for sure that the seven will be fine, they become more hesitant about taking the six out. That's usually how the discussions go, or else it's about ortho, because most parents these days are very convinced their child will need ortho, so you can explain the impact on that as well.
And if in any doubt, send them to the orthodontist, who will definitely tell them, "Look, if you take the six out, it's not good for the bite. It will make it harder to correct." All those things. From an orthodontist's point of view, that's helpful too, to support what you want to do.
CHAPTER 10: COMMUNITY QUESTIONS: HOW TO GET MIH MOLARS NUMB
JAZ:
Like I said, managing the parents is sometimes the tricky part. I'm going to share my screen now, Nicole, and we'll look at the questions from the community. Roxy asked about the best time to extract a first molar. You've already said it's when you start to see the bifurcation of the seven radiographically.
The other key point to highlight is: please take an OPG to make that assessment, and also look for the crypts of the wisdom teeth. Add to that summary if you'd like, but I think we've already answered that one.
And Kostas, who works in Switzerland, has asked for anaesthesia tips for children. The reason he's asking is that MIH molars are, classically, a bit more sensitive and possibly more difficult to numb, from what I've read. Any tips for general dentists to help these children get numb, maybe even for a fissure sealant if they need to be numb for it, or the composite they may need?
DR NICOLE STURZENBAUM:
Perfect. Super question. Thank you very much, 'cause that's something I wanted to mention anyway, and I'd forgotten. Yes, these teeth are really hard to treat, 'cause they're very sensitive and really hard to numb.
What we do now, if we know the child is already so sensitive that even a check-up worries them, because they're so used to the sensitivity and pain, is follow a new schedule from the EAPD, the European Academy of Paediatric Dentistry, and give them Nurofen before the treatment.
We'd say give it six hours before, but don't hold me to that 100%. We have it written down. Six hours before and then an hour before, a normal age-appropriate dose of Nurofen, just to help with the sensitivity. Then we use nitrous oxide, obviously. I wouldn't use local anaesthetic alone. But if you don't have nitrous oxide, you'll need local anaesthetic, so give a proper dose of local.
And something else you could do, when you see them for the assessment, is give them MI Paste, the calcium paste, and ask them to use it every day for two weeks before the appointment. That will help as well.
JAZ:
Is MI Paste the same as GC Tooth Mousse, or different?
DR NICOLE STURZENBAUM:
Yes. Tooth Mousse is without fluoride, and MI Paste is with fluoride. So use the Tooth Mousse. That's usually what we recommend. Definitely use the Tooth Mousse before and after the composite.
JAZ:
And Nurofen for children as well. That's a top tip right there. Thank you.
CHAPTER 11: CHALKY MOLARS, HOPELESS MOLARS AND MANAGING THE SPACE AFTER EXTRACTION
JAZ:
Louisa asks how to treat chalky hypomineralised molars.
DR NICOLE STURZENBAUM:
More or less, if it's the whole tooth, start with a sealant. If you're worried, you can use Fuji, just Fuji, rather than a proper etch and flowable. But if it's a defined area, I'd just use etch and a flowable, or Helioseal or something like that. If the sealant doesn't work and doesn't last, I'd move on to maybe a protective crown if it's really sensitive. If it's fine, I'd just seal it, use the Tooth Mousse and monitor it.
If it's proximal, we use Icon as well, but proximal Icon is quite technique-sensitive if you already have a slightly porous proximal surface.
JAZ:
Anas has asked something you've pretty much already covered. The decision tree for a hopeless first molar is very complex. But if it's been deemed hopeless, with significant caries, pulpitis or infection as you said, there's no way around it. It needs to come out, right? Then it's about managing the child's anxiety and the anaesthesia.
So for hopeless teeth, there's no waiting for the perfect time. You have to get an infected, painful tooth out. Would you agree?
DR NICOLE STURZENBAUM:
Yeah, yeah. I've done that. Sometimes there's no other way. It's sad, but it is what it is. Sometimes taking the tooth out is just the last resort.
JAZ:
Dr Matt Wickman asked, "What's the best way to treat the space after extraction?" This is a good question. Is space management required, or do we just let the second molar come in and do nothing with the space?
DR NICOLE STURZENBAUM:
If the timing is right, we let the second molar come in. But what we sometimes see is that you have to take the lowers out, but the uppers are really good, and the orthodontist may want to keep the upper sixes for the long-term orthodontic plan. Then we give an Essix retainer to wear, for example, to stop the upper six over-erupting. That's an option. And I don't think I've ever placed a space maintainer for a six. No, never.
JAZ:
So, for those listening at home, the Essix is given for the upper teeth, right? Because you want to prevent over-eruption of the upper molars.
DR NICOLE STURZENBAUM:
Yes. And the question is: is it just one, or do you take two out, or all four? Maybe you have one really bad tooth, and the other three are in really good condition. Do you really want to take all four out? From the referrals I see, at the beginning I always got referrals for all four.
Now the tendency is more towards taking only the symptomatic teeth out, and keeping the others if they're healthy, as long as you prevent over-eruption of the uppers. That's where the Essix comes in.
JAZ:
Great. And I think that also answers Nabiha's question about occlusal wear of a molar where the opposing molar has over-erupted. Obviously, the Essix won't correct over-eruption that has already happened, but it will prevent further over-eruption into the space, and orthodontics could then intrude and correct it.
DR NICOLE STURZENBAUM:
Yeah, absolutely.
CHAPTER 12: RESTORE OR EXTRACT? LONG-TERM PROGNOSIS, BALANCING AND COMPENSATING
JAZ:
Annette asks, "Long term, is it deemed appropriate to have all severely hypomineralised sixes extracted before the sevens erupt, so the sevens can hopefully erupt into the space of the sixes? It would avoid the risk of extensive potential treatment on the sixes in the future."
I think we've kind of discussed that: in the cases where you deem it appropriate, to prevent the restorative burden on those teeth. But I'm more interested in balancing and compensating, which we're about to come to, 'cause someone has asked about it.
Claire Bayliss asks... Hey, Claire, thanks for listening. What's the long-term prognosis of these teeth? When she's asked orthodontists for their opinion, she's had letters back saying it's whatever she feels is a poor prognosis. So they leave it to her.
DR NICOLE STURZENBAUM:
Yes, yes. I've had that too. That's absolutely true: sometimes you ask the orthodontist, and they come back and say, "You should make the decision." I'm happy to make the decision as long as they've done a proper assessment and told me their long-term plan.
And if their long-term plan excludes extractions, I'm happy to decide whether the tooth can last or not. I'd put it like this. If a tooth has already had pulpitis or an infection, I doubt it will last. Then I'd go for extraction.
If I can place a composite filling on, say, two surfaces, not three or four, I'd do that. I wouldn't start doing MOD-buccal. If it gets more extensive, then my recommendation would be... That's hard to say now, 'cause if I say take it out, you'll think anything more than two surfaces gets extracted.
But when I say more than two surfaces, I mean really big surfaces, not just a bit of a missing edge. What we know is that composites covering the lower buccal surface never last really well. They're the ones that chip. Then go for a stainless steel crown. In the upper, funnily enough, composite is more forgiving.
JAZ:
That gives us some guidance. But the meat of the question I really want to get to is this. Claire describes a wonderful scenario where you have one very compromised molar. Where do balancing and compensating come in?
First, for our students who are listening, what are balancing and compensating extractions? And when do you do them? Is there a place for them? Have the guidelines changed? You removed four today.
Is that because you have to do all four if one is bad, or can you just do two? Tell us about balancing and compensating.
DR NICOLE STURZENBAUM:
I'm not into balancing and compensating. That's not from guidelines, it's just what I do. I wouldn't take four teeth out just to balance something, because I don't believe in it. But that's not something you can print or put on the internet as a rule, because I would always work with an orthodontist.
If I say, "Look, I only want to take this one tooth out, because it's the really compromised one and the others are fine," I'd get the orthodontist on board and say, "Look, can we work with that? Can we make it work for this child?" And if they say yes, I'll do that. And now I'm really getting myself into trouble, but I'd say compensating extractions are a very English thing. It's not a European thing.
JAZ:
What's the rationale behind this British approach? Compensating is basically when you remove the opposing tooth, and balancing is when you remove the contralateral tooth. What would someone argue is the rationale for compensating and balancing?
Obviously you don't believe in it, and that's fine. I like clinicians on the podcast to have beliefs and opinions that come from their experience and training. But why do the proponents say, "Hey, you should compensate," or, "You should balance"?
DR NICOLE STURZENBAUM:
Compensating makes sense, because an over-erupted six is a real nightmare, and it's nearly impossible to get it back. So if you know you can't stop the six from coming down, that's a good argument for it. With balancing, yes, there's the question of midline shifts, but again, that's something you need to check with the orthodontist.
What age is the child? Is there already a midline shift? What class are they? If you have a perfect Class I child with good occlusion, good habits, no mouth breathing and so on, then I think the risk of a midline shift because you extracted a six on one side and not the other is negligible.
JAZ:
That helps. At least we know the rationale, and you've given us some good clinical reasoning: you shouldn't really expect a significant midline shift, and removing a healthy molar and the opposing one, going from one extraction to four, does sound quite severe.
What I like is that you've given general dentists some guidelines, and we've highlighted that this is a multifactorial decision that may involve the orthodontist and the parents, the different clinical scenarios, the age and the radiographic interpretation. I feel we've done a good job of summarising these things, and I've asked you some very tough questions.
CHAPTER 13: FINAL ADVICE: TAKE SENSITIVITY SERIOUSLY, AND SEAL ERUPTING MIH MOLARS
JAZ:
So thank you so much for that. Is there anything else you'd like to pass on to the general dentists tuning in today about first permanent molars of poor prognosis?
DR NICOLE STURZENBAUM:
I'd definitely say one more thing we haven't touched on yet: really consider the child's pain threshold and take it seriously.
The question from the Swiss dentist was really, really good, because you might think, "Oh, this has a small occlusal cavity, I'll just do a composite filling." But if the child already flinches when you use the air, be super careful if you only have local and maybe Nurofen, because this is where they get traumatised, and where we end up needing sedation or a general anaesthetic for a child like this.
Whereas if you treat it at the right time, maybe with nitrous oxide, you can just get the filling done. Because, really, with these teeth, with all my experience, hands up, I've had a few times where I really struggled with these children. Even with nitrous, with double local, with Nurofen, they still felt it, and you think, "Oh God."
And it's so horrible, because you want to do a really good composite, but you can't, because you can't dry the tooth. As soon as you use the air, even though they've had local, 1.7 ml, 3.3 ml, they still feel the air. So be careful with that. When you do your initial assessment, check really properly how sensitive the tooth is.
'Cause I've had parents say, "No, no, the child is not in pain, and never has been." Then I ask the child, "Do you feel something when you eat ice cream?" "Yes." Then it hurts. They said they'd never had pain, but they do. They have pain constantly. There's five millimetres of plaque on that tooth.
There's a reason for that. It's not because they don't brush. It's because it hurts them when they touch it. So a tooth with lots of plaque on it already tells you something. Be careful with it. You know it's a sensitive one.
JAZ:
That's a good clinical clue: if there's plaque on it, you know they're not able to brush it well. And I guess the other consideration is that sometimes, instead of a simple direct restoration, a protective crown can give longer-lasting pain relief into their teenage years.
DR NICOLE STURZENBAUM:
And even if the tooth is just erupting... Sometimes a tooth is only halfway through, and you can already see that part of the occlusal surface is so severely hypomineralised that, even in the two months until it reaches full height, you know there will be decay.
Then just cover it with a fluid glass ionomer, Fuji III or something, just to make sure the fissures are closed off for the time being. It's ugly, and it's not what you want to do, but at least it protects it somehow.
JAZ:
Yeah. Dry the tooth as best you can, put some on your gloved finger, smear it into the area, and then you pray. Then, when they come back and it's in a better position for better-quality dentistry, it's got them through that risky time. That's a great real-world point that all clinicians will be able to relate to and implement.
CHAPTER 14: TOOTHBEARY AND PREVENTION-LED PAEDIATRIC DENTISTRY, AND WRAP-UP
JAZ:
Nicole, you've answered all our questions. I'd love to know a bit more about your clinic in Richmond, Toothbeary. Tell us about the services you offer. I know you do a lot of sedation. My son's currently having orthodontics with you, and he's about to turn seven. So tell us more about your clinic and how you can help.
DR NICOLE STURZENBAUM:
Where should I start? The whole idea of Toothbeary was always to provide prevention and high-quality paediatric dentistry, high-quality dentistry for kids. They have the right to high-quality dentistry.
They're not only milk teeth. The worst thing you could say to me is, "Oh, they're only milk teeth. They'll fall out." No. The milk teeth determine what happens in the long run, and the biggest risk factor for caries is previous caries experience. So that's one thing. The other is to really create an environment where children can grow up with really healthy teeth, and that environment is more than just brushing and fluoride application.
It's early orthodontics, as you say. There's mouth breathing, and there are swallowing patterns. These things should ideally be corrected at an early age, because that prevents so many problems in the long run. And if you can avoid big orthodontic treatment at 13, why wouldn't you?
'Cause you can address it at seven, and that completely changes everything. We know a big Class II carries a high risk of trauma to the front teeth. We know mouth breathing is associated with more plaque. So the idea is to correct these things as soon as they happen, and guide development to get the ideal outcome at an early age.
So in the end, we're back to prevention: preventing anything that could happen. I always say to parents that if a child reaches 17 having never had a cavity, with a Class I bite, that will stay for the rest of their life. The risk of getting decay at 25 if you've never had a cavity is very slim, and that's what we want to achieve.
And to do that, of course, you want to do it in such a child-friendly way that the child grows up feeling comfortable at the dentist. That's what I'm seeing now, after 18 years. I have all my teenagers... no, they're students now, going to university, and they have nothing. No decay.
And they really love it, and they won't leave me, even when I say, "Look, I think you've outgrown me," 'cause the small pink bench is clearly too small for a boy who's one metre 90. But they still like it so much, and that's everything I could have hoped to achieve, right? They have good, healthy mouths.
They have good hygiene, and they love going to the dentist. They come every six months, and that's what they'll do for the rest of their lives. Perfect. Mission accomplished.
JAZ:
That's beautiful, and it must be so incredibly rewarding. Now you have 18 years of data, and you've seen all these patients develop wonderful dentitions because of interceptive, prevention-based care. Congratulations on everything you've achieved, and all the best for the future. And thanks for talking about such a tough clinical topic, with so many ifs and buts.
I feel all the general dentists listening today have gained insights they can apply straight away: involving the wider team, reconsidering the diagnoses they make, and making sure MIH is treated differently from purely caries. So Nicole, thank you so much. I'll obviously put the Toothbeary website link below, so people can contact the clinic and consider referring where appropriate.
DR NICOLE STURZENBAUM:
Thank you so much, and I hope it was good enough.
JAZ:
It was amazing. It was amazing. Thank you so much. We've never covered this topic before, so it was great to do so. Thank you.
Well, there we have it, guys. Did you enjoy learning about first molars of poor prognosis? I know there's a lot to think about, right? That's why you're going to love the premium notes for this episode. If you're a paying subscriber to Protrusive, we make these wonderful PDF summaries.
Our members absolutely love them. They like to annotate them, or just read them as a refresher. It helps everything sink in. And to enhance your learning further, those of you with access to Ask Jaz can now test it out: ask AI Jaz about a scenario involving first permanent molars of poor prognosis, and you'll get better advice than ever before.
If you'd like to connect with Dr Nicole and send your thanks, I'll put her contact details below. What she's done for paediatric dentistry in the UK is absolutely amazing. If you'd like to collect CE and CPD certificates for episodes like this one, you need to answer a quiz, and the way to access the quiz is by becoming a member of Protrusive Guidance.
Head over to www.protrusive.app and connect with 7,000 dentists all over the world who are nice, geeky, and want to get better every single day. By 1% every day, you can achieve so much. So thank you so much, Protruserati, for listening all the way to the end, and I'll catch you same time, same place next week.
Bye for now.
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
QUESTION:
Why do first permanent molars have a poor prognosis in children?
ANSWER:
Nicole says that in the children referred to her, the main cause is molar incisor hypomineralisation (MIH). The decay usually follows, because affected teeth are sensitive and hard to brush, and enamel often breaks down within the first two years after eruption. She stresses that MIH isn't the child's or parents' fault, and that blaming them is the worst thing a dentist can do.
QUESTION:
What is molar incisor hypomineralisation (MIH)?
ANSWER:
MIH is a developmental defect affecting the first permanent molars and often the incisors. Its cause is still unknown, and it's the subject of a lot of research. It can affect one tooth or up to 12, and ranges from white, yellow or brown spots to enamel breakdown or complete loss of enamel. Severely affected molars are sometimes called "cheese molars".
QUESTION:
How should you treat MIH molars?
ANSWER:
Nicole's first step, if there's no enamel breakdown, is a sealant. For a small cavity, she places a good-quality composite, extending into sound enamel and dentine, under rubber dam, and says these restorations last. For very sensitive or more broken-down teeth, a stainless steel crown can protect the tooth until extraction or until a composite or ceramic inlay is possible later.
QUESTION:
When is the best time to extract a first permanent molar?
ANSWER:
Nicole says to use dental development, not chronological age. Take an OPG and look at the second molar: the ideal time is when its bifurcation is starting to form, though a little before or after is fine. If the second molar is fully developed, the space won't close naturally. She also checks for developing third molars, and is cautious about extracting if there are none.
QUESTION:
Do you need an orthodontic opinion before extracting a first molar?
ANSWER:
Nicole says it depends on your confidence in orthodontics. If a child clearly has crowding and will need orthodontic extractions, removing poor-prognosis sixes can be a straightforward decision. If you're unsure, get an orthodontic opinion or refer. An orthodontist can also help explain to parents how extractions would affect the bite and future treatment.
QUESTION:
How do you get MIH molars numb?
ANSWER:
Nicole agrees MIH molars are very sensitive and hard to numb. For sensitive children, she follows an EAPD schedule of age-appropriate ibuprofen before treatment, uses nitrous oxide, and gives an adequate dose of local anaesthetic. She also asks patients to use Tooth Mousse daily for two weeks beforehand, and warns that poor pain control can lead to children needing sedation or a general anaesthetic.
QUESTION:
What should you do with the space after extracting a first molar?
ANSWER:
If the timing is right, Nicole lets the second molar erupt into the space. If only the lower sixes are extracted and the healthy uppers are kept, she gives an Essix retainer to stop the upper molars over-erupting. She has never used a space maintainer for a first molar, and now tends to extract only symptomatic teeth rather than all four.
QUESTION:
Are balancing and compensating extractions still recommended?
ANSWER:
Nicole says, as her own view rather than a guideline, that she doesn't believe in extracting healthy teeth just to balance. She works with an orthodontist to plan around only the compromised tooth. She accepts compensating extractions can make sense if an opposing molar would otherwise over-erupt, and feels the risk of midline shift is negligible in a child with a good Class I occlusion.
ABOUT THE GUEST
Dr Nicole Sturzenbaum is a paediatric dentist who graduated in Germany, completed a postgraduate degree in paediatric dentistry, and trained in a specialist paediatric practice in Munich. After moving to the UK, she opened Toothbeary in Richmond in 2008, an 11-chair practice dedicated to children's dentistry, offering prevention, sedation and early orthodontics. Her focus is high-quality, prevention-led care that helps children grow up with healthy teeth and a positive attitude to the dentist.