The history you think you know, with women in it this time
[00:00:00] Intro
---
[00:00:00] Marion Gibson: Hey, I'm Isabelle Roughol, creator and host of Broad History. People who support this show have access on a private member's feed to early and exclusive episodes of broad history, including at the moment, full hour long conversations with the historians who are helping me prepare the upcoming series on the early modern witch hunts.
[00:00:17] I thought I'd give you a taste of what's going on on that feed so you can decide if that's something you wanna listen to further and support. If you do, go to broad history.com/membership, sign up and you'll have immediate access.
[00:00:28] I spoke recently with Marion Gibson. She is a celebrated historian of the early modern witch hunts, and we talked about the 1640s in England.
[00:00:38] That's the Civil War, which really set the conditions for the worst witch hunts England ever experienced. It's the witch hunts you think about, if you think about England with the infamous witch finder, general Matthew Hopkins. We talked about that and we talked about who was accused and also who was doing the accusing and whether we would've been on the right side of history. [00:01:00] Here's Marion Gibson.
[00:01:01] Interview excerpt
---
[00:01:01] Isabelle Roughol: Is there a typical portrait of the accused or does it, run the gamut across society?
[00:01:09] Marion Gibson: Yeah, kind of yes and no. So yes, the stereotypical accused witch is a woman, and that is basically correct. About 90% of people who were accused in England, and about 80, 85% in Scotland are women. So it's a massive preponderance that's really important.
[00:01:26] But they're not always older. They're sometimes seen as stereotypically older. But you do get younger women accused as well. Sometimes people think, oh, they're isolated people. They may be widows. They may be poor. And yes, those things are true, but you also get married women accused. You get people who are actually quite secure citizens in their societies being accused.
[00:01:46] So there's that stereotype which sort of holds true. But then the more the witch hunt grows and the more people become accustomed to the idea of accusing witches, the more unusual people are accused.
[00:01:57] So you get later on in the hunt, you get a [00:02:00] higher proportion of men being accused from what we can see. And some of those men are really very mainstream citizens. There are church wardens. There's even a vicar who is accused and executed for witchcraft. And that's, you know, that's a surprise, I think. What people will see in the book is, yeah, a number of stories that they kind of recognise, and then a number of stories where it seems like, hang on, this person is a lot more, you would think that person would be a lot safer.
[00:02:26] That person seems a lot like us. They're kind of middle class taxpayer type person. Maybe they're male rather than female. They're somebody who seems to be part of the religious establishment. Hang on. Why are they being accused? So the more the witch hunt grows, the more the type of suspect becomes diversified, I guess.
[00:02:46] Isabelle Roughol: Yeah, that's the thing I I was struck by, and I love reading it, is that you're able to see themes and connections across all the different cases, and at the same time, you're able to see the incredible variety and diversity of situations. And you [00:03:00] end up with this very unsafe and unsettling feeling that actually no one is, no one is safe from a witch hunt.
[00:03:09] And including, I mean, we see this, it's not in your book, we see this in Salem, you know, people get accused and then they start trying to deflect and accusing all the people, and in the end, no one is safe, really.
[00:03:23] Marion Gibson: It does feel like that, I think. Yeah. I think one of the things about this witch hunt is just how big it is and how that means that more and more people are accused and then they accuse other people and the whole thing spreads. And I think it's easy to put yourself in that situation and think, yeah, that could have happened to me. That would've been.
[00:03:43] It'd be really easy to accuse somebody like me who is, you know, in my case, a woman that's a good start. That might draw attention. Somebody who maybe stands out in society in some way. It's easy to pick on people. And you can see yourself in those, those figures, I think.
[00:03:59] Would you have accused other people?z
---
[00:03:59] Isabelle Roughol: [00:04:00] Absolutely. Disturbingly, we can probably see ourselves in the accusers as well because they're also very normal people.
[00:04:08] Marion Gibson: They are. And I think that's important. I did want readers to think about that. What would you have done? Would you have accused other people? Maybe you would've done, especially if your life has been quite difficult and you know, who has an easy life these days. If bad things have happened to you or you are extremely anxious about the way the world is going, and again, who isn't these days, it would be so easy to turn on other people and say, well, actually this could be their fault.
[00:04:34] You know, my minister says that it could be their fault. You know, my local magistrates, they seem to think it's their fault. Maybe actually it is their fault, maybe we should find out, should we get some experts in? And of course, the experts are the witchfinders, and in they come and they say, yes, you're absolutely right, Those people really were to blame.
[00:04:51] So it would be easy to do that and to feel vindicated and to feel like actually I, I've done the right thing. I've protected my community by accusing my [00:05:00] neighbour of witchcraft. And now they've been executed, we will all be a lot safer. So yeah, I think we can all see ourselves in that.
[00:05:06] And I also ask myself the question repeatedly, would I have been one of the defenders of accused people? I can't say that I would've been. No, hand on heart. I mean, do we know that what we would've done in a situation like that? If you stand up and defend your neighbour who has been accused, what if they accuse you? It was extremely likely as an outcome.
[00:05:25] So it did take real guts for people to stand up and say, "I don't think that person is a witch." Or "In fact, I don't think there are witches at all." Or, "I think the witchfinders are corrupt. They're doing this for money, or they're doing this for mad religious reasons and we have to stop them." It was very difficult to stand up and say that.
[00:05:43] So I do try and celebrate the defenders of accused witches in the book because I can't necessarily see myself in them, and I think they're kind of special people.
[00:05:53] Isabelle Roughol: Mm-hmm. And of course, actually, you, you quite literally could see yourself in one of your characters 'cause you [00:06:00] found an accused witch named Marion Gibson. That must be incredibly jarring. Tell me about her.
[00:06:09] Marion Gibson: That was pretty eerie. Yeah.
[00:06:11] Outro
---
[00:06:11] Marion Gibson: That was Marion Gibson. I hope this got your interest and if you'd like to listen to the entire episode, go to broad history.com/membership. Sign up and you'll get an immediate link to a private member's feed.
[00:06:23] If you are interested in Marion Gibson's work, you can find the links in the show notes to her books, including her most recent one, Witchlands, which is specifically about the 1640s in England.
[00:06:34] I'm off back to work on the series. I'll talk to you very soon.