The Christian Homemaking Podcast: Simply Convivial with Mystie Winckler

FREE Gratitude Reset: simplyconvivial.com/gratitude     Why your gratitude list isn't making you more grateful — and the 3 mistakes to fix.

This is part 1 of our gratitude series — stay tuned for parts 2 and 3!

Are you writing down things you're thankful for at the end of the day but not feeling any more grateful? You're not alone. In this episode, Mystie Winckler shares why superficial gratitude lists don't work and what true biblical gratitude looks like instead.

You'll learn the 3 common mistakes that keep gratitude from sticking:

1. Not directing your thanks to a Person — true gratitude is relational, thanking God in prayer, not just listing things you enjoy or thanking the universe
2. Only listing nice things — God calls us to give thanks in everything, even hardships and derailed plans, not just puppy dogs and rainbows
3. Using gratitude selfishly — trying to manipulate God to get more, instead of trusting Him with what He's already given

Discover how gratitude-fueled productivity gives you momentum and traction for your everyday homemaking work for the glory of God.

Join me for the Gratitude Reset Workshop — all about gratitude-fueled productivity!
Live on Zoom November 19th + replay available when you register
Live attendees get special bonuses
Register here: simplyconvivial.com/gratitude

About Simply Convivial:
Christian homemaking encouragement for overwhelmed moms who want a peaceful, purposeful home. Practical teaching on housework, routines, decluttering, productivity, homeschooling, and biblical perspective to help you build cheerful competence.
Learn more at simplyconvivial.com

0:00 Why Your Gratitude List Isn't Working
2:41 Mistake One: Gratitude Without a Person
6:00 Mistake Two: The Random Grab-Bag List
9:09 Mistake Three: The Trap of Selfish Gratitude
11:21 Building True Biblical Gratitude

What is The Christian Homemaking Podcast: Simply Convivial with Mystie Winckler?

Christian homemakers need encouragement and motivation to stay the course. Homemaking and homeschooling can feel overwhelming, but they don’t have to be. If you’re a Christian mom longing for a well-ordered home, a peaceful homeschool, and a joyful heart—without the stress or burnout—you’re in the right place. Moms can be productive and peaceful when grounded in Scriptural truth.

I’m Mystie Winckler, homeschooling mom of five, founder of Simply Convivial, and your guide to managing both home and heart with faith and focus. Here, we talk about biblical homemaking, sustainable homeschooling, and cheerful productivity—all through the lens of organizing your attitude and embracing your God-given calling.

In each episode, you’ll find practical homemaking systems, homeschooling strategies, and mindset shifts that will help you manage your home without perfectionism or frustration. We’ll tackle topics like:
✔️ Christian homemaking routines that actually work
✔️ Productivity, mom-style
✔️ Homeschooling with peace—even when life gets messy
✔️ Time management for moms (without rigid schedules)
✔️ Decluttering your home & your attitude
✔️ How to be diligent, not just busy

Motherhood is a marathon, not a sprint. You don’t need more willpower—you need a grace-filled, biblical approach to managing life at home. Let’s cultivate faithfulness, embrace joy, and build habits that make home a place of peace and purpose.

👉 Subscribe now and start organizing your home and heart—cheerfully.

Speaker: So you've heard that to be
happier, you should keep a gratitude list.

So you do it.

You have a section on your planner.

At the end of every day, you write
down three things you're grateful for,

and you don't notice any difference.

You don't feel more grateful.

It's just like this thing that
you do because you're supposed to.

But what's the point?

What are you missing?

Why don't you feel grateful after writing
down your list of gratitude items?

Today I'm going to uncover three mistakes
that you are probably making if your

gratitude lists do not feel like they're
working, and what you should be doing

This is part one of a three-part series on
gratitude that you can catch this month of

November, all leading up to my hour-long
workshop called The Gratitude Reset.

During the reset we're going to talk
about how to build true gratitude that

is not just a list at the end of the day

But a real practice that actually
increases our sense of gratitude and

makes a difference in how we go about
our everyday work You can register

for this free workshop right now.

Just go to simplyconvivial.com/gratitude.

The link is also in the description

Now, it's not that making a
gratitude list is a bad idea.

It's a great place to start, but it's also
so easy to get wrong and to misunderstand

It's actually very common for that
gratitude list to backfire because it's

not actually gratitude in the first place.

I'm Misty Winkler, and you've
found the Christian homemaking

podcast, Simply Convivial

My goal is to help you become more
capable and confident and cheerful in

your work at home as a homemaker And
that's not about sourdough and sewing.

It's about managing
our everyday work well.

And it does start with gratitude,
but not in the ways that you might

assume if you're just making a
gratitude list because it's printed

on your pretty planner page.

So grab a basket of laundry to fold,
and let's talk about the three gratitude

mistakes that people make so often
that completely negates the benefit

of gratitude in the first place.

So the first gratitude
mistake that is so common is

That we're really just making
a list of things that we like.

You see, gratitude isn't gratitude
unless it's directed toward a person.

If you say thank you when you
are all by yourself to no one in

particular, what does that really mean?

Is that really gratitude?

But if you look in someone's eyes
and say, "Thank you," you are

creating a connection, a relational
connection with that person.

They feel loved and received, and you
feel cared for And that connection is

happening in your saying thank you to them

So every day we should be doing
more than just writing a list of

things that we like in our planner

We should be finding excuses, reasons,
any and every opportunity to actually

look a person in the eye and say
thank you We will feel grateful when

we do that, and we will feel more
connected and cared for when we do.

Now, of course, as Christians

Our gratitude, especially gratitude
that we write down at the end of the

day, is supposed to be directed to God.

But is it?

Are we actually taking the time to
direct that gratitude to God in prayer?

Are we making that connection,
that relational connection with

God as we are writing that list?

Or are we really just thinking
about the things themselves and

not the person who gave them to us?

When we are grateful to God,
we are still grateful to a

person, because God is personal.

He listens to our prayers, and
He receives our thanksgivings.

But just writing down a list
of things you enjoy is not

actually thanking God for them.

And also, just throwing out and
scattering a general thank you to the

universe is not the same thing at all.

That would be idolatrous, not
grateful obedience and praise to God.

So the effect is not gonna be the same

Your gratitude might not feel
like it's working because it's

not really gratitude at all.

You're not directing it toward a person
in your real life or to your personal

relational God who wants to hear from
you and who requires us to be grateful.

Not to the universe, not to general vague
good feelings, but specifically to Him

Which leads us to the second gratitude
mistake that is so common, especially

for those who are trying to build
that habit of making a gratitude list.

And that is that your gratitude list
is this random grab bag assortment

of just things that you like.

Even if you are grateful and thanking God
in prayer for these random nice things

that you like, you know, the puppy dogs
and rainbows Hot coffee and sunshine

That's a very surface level,
shallow kind of thanksgiving.

God calls us to thank Him for more
than just the things that we like.

Being grateful to God is a
way to change our feelings and

our perspective on the world.

It's not a way to get more of what
we want and more of what we like.

It's a way to like more of what
God is doing in us and in the world

Scripture doesn't call us to just be
thankful for the good things But it

says, "In everything, give thanks."

So if some of our thanksgiving is - not
about the things that we don't like,

the difficulties and hardships and
trials, our plans that got derailed,

things that didn't go our way,
then the gratitude is not doing its

full work in us that God intends.

The gratitude that God calls us
to give Him is full, complete.

It encompasses everything.

And a Christian can do that because we
know that God is working all things toward

our good, and that nothing happens to
us without His direction and a reason.

So therefore, we can still give gratitude
to Him even when something bad happens.

If you talk to any wise, mature
Christian and they are sharing something

difficult that they went through, listen

They will tell you the goodness of God
that they saw in those moments because

they were aware, they were gratefully
aware of God's presence at that time

So it's not like we're asking God for bad
things to happen or enjoying them in the

moment, but we are aware that we have a
good God that we can thank in the midst of

anything for all the work that He is doing

So our gratitude needs to be about the
things actually happening in our life not

about just random puppy dogs and rainbows

When our gratitude focuses in on
the real circumstances of our life,

like it or not, then it changes us

And that leads me to the third
and final mistake that we so often

make when it comes to gratitude.

And that is that really at core, our
gratitude is selfish, which is the

opposite of what gratitude actually is.

So if your gratitude is selfish, it's
not gratitude at all, and that's why

you're not noticing an effect from
it If you are being thankful and

grateful to God for the things that
you like because you want more of that

For your own sake Then
that's not gratitude.

That's just selfishness and trying
to manipulate God by doing what

you're supposed to do so that
you can get more of what you want

God asks us, God tells us to pray
for, God tells us to pray for

patience, for self-control For wisdom

A truly grateful person who is grateful
to God for their good health is not

grateful in a way that is trying to
seek more and more good health from

God, but is rather confident in God
whether that good health stays or goes.

A truly thankful Christian will thank God

Either way

Gratitude lists or prayers of
gratitude are not ways to maneuver

God into giving you more blessings.

You already have all you need
in Christ, and you can make

requests to God, of course.

But they have to be done in gratitude
for what He has already given, in

gratitude for whatever provisions He
decides to send us, knowing that He is

working His good will in us, and that
is likely to be different than our

will for us True gratitude trusts God

Attempts to manipulate God are
not any kind of gratitude at all

So to build true biblical Christian
gratitude in your life that will give

you the momentum and traction that will
fuel your everyday work that you are

doing for the glory of God, then come
join my Gratitude Reset workshop, all

about gratitude-fueled productivity.

It's happening November 19th.

There will be a replay afterwards.

If you register, you can catch the replay

The workshop will be on Zoom, so you
do have to register to get the link

And there are bonuses if you show up live.

So register today.

Go to simplyconvivial.com/gratitude

Or find the link in the description

Increasing our gratitude is all about
repenting and rejoicing and repeating.

And stick around for part two
of this series on gratitude