Dr. MCB’s Curiosities

Episode 5 of 7 in What makes a high-performance culture? Today's question: Are we listening—and using what we hear?

Show Notes

Episode 5 of 7 in What makes a high-performance culture? Today's question: Are we listening—and using what we hear?
Dr. MCB starts with your own experience: a time your place at work changed, whether anyone noticed how you were doing, and what happened after you told them something. From there she asks you to be one player and follows that player through four moments we can usually see coming: arriving, a change in role, an injury and leaving. She uses Nancy Schlossberg's four S's (situation, self, support and strategies) as questions to ask the person, and suggests practical steps for each moment: check-ins at thirty, sixty and ninety days, a private conversation before a veteran has to guess what their new role involves, someone who checks in regularly during a long rehab and has no role in deciding whether the player plays, and contact within forty-eight hours of an exit decision from someone who had no part in making it. Along the way she describes Naomi Eisenberger's 2003 brain-scanner study of being left out of a simple ball game, and Leslie Podlog and Robert Eklund's interviews with athletes returning from serious injury. Then you change places and become the person the player tells: the first response, honesty about the limits of confidentiality, clear written rules about who can see what (she calls this lane discipline), and letting people see that something happened. Her answer: many organizations have people who are listening carefully; what we need to examine is whether they can do anything with what they hear, and whether the people who speak up ever see a response. She is clear about the limits: the exclusion study was a laboratory study, and the check-ins, the four S's as a conversation aid and the forty-eight-hour follow-up have not been validated as a package for sport.
This series draws on The Psychology of High-Performance Sports Organizations: Culture, Safety, and Leadership by Dr. Marie Claire Bourque and Madeline Antony (Routledge). Find the book.
Read this question on my website: https://www.dr-mcb.com/curiosities/series/the-culture-playbook/how-do-teams-look-after-people-through-change
Sources mentioned
Research papers
  • Schlossberg, N. K. (1981). A model for analyzing human adaptation to transition. The Counseling Psychologist, 9(2), 2–18. DOI
  • Eisenberger, N. I., Lieberman, M. D., & Williams, K. D. (2003). Does rejection hurt? An fMRI study of social exclusion. Science, 302(5643), 290–292. DOI
  • Podlog, L., & Eklund, R. C. (2006). A longitudinal investigation of competitive athletes' return to sport following serious injury. Journal of Applied Sport Psychology, 18(1), 44–68. DOI
  • Ardern, C. L., Glasgow, P., Schneiders, A., Witvrouw, E., Clarsen, B., Cools, A., Gojanovic, B., Griffin, S., Khan, K. M., Moksnes, H., Mutch, S. A., Phillips, N., Reurink, G., Sadler, R., Silbernagel, K. G., Thorborg, K., Wangensteen, A., Wilk, K. E., & Bizzini, M. (2016). 2016 consensus statement on return to sport from the First World Congress in Sports Physical Therapy, Bern. British Journal of Sports Medicine, 50(14), 853–864. DOI
  • Colquitt, J. A. (2001). On the dimensionality of organizational justice: A construct validation of a measure. Journal of Applied Psychology, 86(3), 386–400. DOI
  • Greenberg, J. (1990). Organizational justice: Yesterday, today, and tomorrow. Journal of Management, 16(2), 399–432. DOI
  • Grove, J. R., Lavallee, D., & Gordon, S. (1997). Coping with retirement from sport: The influence of athletic identity. Journal of Applied Sport Psychology, 9(2), 191–203. DOI
Books and reports
  • Bruce, E. J., & Schultz, C. L. (2001). Nonfinite loss and grief: A psychoeducational approach. Paul H. Brookes Publishing Co.
  • Stambulova, N. B. (2003). Symptoms of a crisis-transition: A grounded theory study. In N. Hassmén (Ed.), SIPF Yearbook 2003 (pp. 97–109). Örebro University Press.
About the host
Dr. Marie Claire Bourque. Her newsletter, Dr. MCB’s Curiosities, is at curiosities.dr-mcb.com.
Dr. MCB’s Curiosities is produced by PIPACO Tech. Dr. MCB is a Clinical Instructor at the University of British Columbia and a Clinical Assistant Professor at the University of Calgary's Cumming School of Medicine. The views expressed are her own and are not endorsed by either university. This podcast is general education, not medical advice, and does not create a doctor–patient relationship.

What is Dr. MCB’s Curiosities?

What are you curious about?

I'm Dr. Marie Claire Bourque, Dr. MCB. I'm a psychiatrist, and I ask a lot of questions. My favourite ones are the ones I don't know the answers to.

That's where Dr. MCB’s Curiosities starts. We take a question about neuroscience, human behaviour, clinical medicine, or something else entirely, and build a podcast episode or series to explore the answer.

I read the research and look at different explanations. What do we know? How do we know it? And what haven't we figured out yet?

You get to follow that search with me, without having to work through all the papers yourself. We'll make sense of the science in plain language, including where the evidence is uncertain or the answer is still taking shape.

You might leave with a clearer answer, a different understanding of something you thought you knew, or another question worth asking.

And if you've got a question I can't answer, send it my way. That's the engine.

Dr. MCB’s Curiosities is produced by PIPACO Tech. Dr. MCB is a Clinical Instructor at the University of British Columbia and a Clinical Assistant Professor at the University of Calgary's Cumming School of Medicine. The views expressed are her own and are not endorsed by either university. This podcast is general education, not medical advice, and does not create a doctor–patient relationship.

In this series, we've been asking what makes a high-performance culture. We've talked about the pressures people work under in sport, whether it feels safe to speak up, and what can make a culture toxic. In the last episode, we looked at how decisions get made, particularly when following our values becomes difficult.

Today, I want to build on that by looking at what happens when someone does tell us something. We may have worked hard to make it possible for people to speak, but we also need to consider what we do with what they tell us, and whether they ever hear back from us.

This is episode five of seven, and the question is: are we listening, and using what we hear?

I'd like you to think about a time when your place at work changed. Maybe you'd just started somewhere and were trying to work out how things were done. Or you'd been there for years, but your role was changing and you weren't quite sure where you fitted anymore. You may have been coming back after an injury or time away, or finding out that your time with the organization was coming to an end.

As you think back, was there someone who noticed how you were doing? Someone you could talk to without feeling that you had to make everything sound fine? And when you did tell them something, what happened afterwards?

Keep that experience in mind as we go, because I'll come back to it.

Welcome back to Curiosities. I'm Dr. Marie Claire Bourque. I'm a psychiatrist and faculty at the University of Calgary and UBC's medical schools, and for eight years I was director of mental health for the Toronto Maple Leafs. This is a show for people who are curious about their own minds, and everyone else's.

Organizations put an enormous amount of time and money into choosing people. We scout, draft, recruit, sign and hire. But once someone arrives, there can be an assumption that because we chose them, they're ready for everything that comes with being here. We may not look closely again until there's a problem.

I don't think that always comes from a lack of care. The organization is trying to get through a season, while the athlete is trying to build a career, and those priorities don't always line up. Preseason is short, so arrivals get rushed. The next roster needs to be settled, so departures can become something we deal with at the last minute. The work of helping someone through those changes can end up without anyone clearly responsible for it.

How an organization notices what people need as their circumstances change, and who is responsible for responding, is what I mean by people systems. It's the fifth layer of what I call the High-Performance Culture Operating System.

What strikes me is how often we know that these moments are approaching. We know when a player is arriving and when a contract ends. We often know well before the player does that their role is likely to change. So today I'd like to follow one player through four moments we can usually see coming: arriving, a change in role, an injury and leaving. And I'd like you to be that player.

So you've just signed. It's your third week, and you're learning how the team plays, but you're also learning how to be in the room. You notice who introduces themselves, who explains something you don't understand, and who seems irritated when you ask. You're trying to work out which questions are welcome and which ones you're expected to know the answers to already. Someone on the staff asks how you're settling in, and you say, "Fine. I don't want to be a problem."

What did you mean by that? It may just have been politeness. But it may also mean you're worried that asking for something will change how people see you. That brings us back to what I've called the silence calculus: the judgment people make about the cost of speaking and the likelihood that it will help. If I ask for support, will it change anything? Will someone think I can't cope? Could it affect whether I'm selected?

So when a new player says, "I don't want to be a problem," I wouldn't assume I knew what they meant from that sentence alone. I'd want to ask a little more, because otherwise the things they're having difficulty with may stay hidden.

There are things a club can organize before the player arrives. We can make their role clearer, and give them a named person to approach who isn't deciding whether they play. Arranging check-ins at thirty, sixty and ninety days is one way of doing that. At the first conversation, I'd want to know whether the player can describe their role for that week, who they would go to if something felt wrong, and what is happening in their life outside the sport. At the next one, we come back to what they raised and find out whether anything has changed. By ninety days, I'd want to ask whether they feel part of the team and what would help if they don't. And if, a month in, a player still only speaks when someone speaks to them, I'd want to look at how we've welcomed them before deciding that the problem is their confidence or resilience.

Now move forward several years. You're a veteran, and your minutes are about to be reduced. The coaches see a necessary decision about the team. You're trying to understand your place in an organization where you've spent much of your career.

There's a concept in grief research called non-finite loss that can help us think about part of this experience. The loss keeps being encountered over time. You may be reminded of it when the team is announced, when someone else takes your place in a drill, or when a younger player becomes the person everyone looks to. You're still there, but your relationship with the team is changing.

If nobody talks about that, the response can be interpreted only as a behaviour problem. The player seems defensive, withdrawn or less willing to contribute. When we see that in a player, it's worth asking what conversations took place when the role changed. Did the person have a chance to discuss it, or were they told what was happening and expected to adjust?

One way of thinking about what someone might need at a moment like this comes from Nancy Schlossberg's work on adult transitions. She was interested in how people manage changes such as a new job, a divorce or retirement. The framework uses four areas, often called the four S's: situation, self, support and strategies. The situation is what's happening to the person, including how much choice they had. Self is what they bring to it, including how they understand themselves. Support is who is available to them and whether those people feel safe to approach. Strategies are the ways they have of coping with what's happening.

I find those useful as questions. As the veteran, you may know exactly what the decision is but not how you're expected to contribute now. Or the role may be clear, and what you're struggling with is what losing the old one means to you. Those would give us different places to begin, which is why we need to ask. We can notice that something has changed without knowing what it means to the person.

So I'd want a private conversation about the role before the person has to guess what it will involve. We can be honest that their minutes are changing and still discuss what they bring to the team and what they want for the next part of their career. They may be disappointed or disagree with the decision. That doesn't mean the conversation has failed. And if mentoring younger players is going to be part of the new role, it needs to be something the organization actually recognizes and makes time for. Otherwise, we may be asking them to accept less playing time while taking on work that nobody really acknowledges.

The third moment is an injury. You're in a long rehab now. Your schedule has changed, you spend more time with medical staff, and the rest of the team carries on. Conversations happen without you, and people don't always know whether to involve you. Some athletes describe feeling as though they've disappeared from the team even while they're still in the building.

There's a study by Naomi Eisenberger and colleagues from 2003 that comes to mind here. Volunteers were in a brain scanner playing a simple computer game where three players passed a ball to one another. They believed they were playing with two other people. Partway through, those other players stopped passing the ball to them, so they were left watching the game continue without them.

The researchers reported activity in a brain region involved in the distress associated with physical pain, and that activity was related to how distressed people said they felt. This was a laboratory study, and we need to be careful about what we carry from it into a dressing room. But it gives us a reason to take the experience of being left out seriously, even when the people doing the excluding don't intend to cause harm.

Now imagine that, in the middle of that rehab, someone asks whether you're ready to come back, and you're not. What does it cost you to say so? If saying "I'm not ready" feels like telling the club you can be replaced, there may be pressure to return before you feel ready. Leslie Podlog and Robert Eklund studied athletes returning from serious injuries, speaking with them more than once as the return unfolded. Their accounts included concerns about reinjury, pressure to get back and worries about their place in the team. The injured body part was only one part of what they were managing.

So when an athlete says, "I'm not ready," I'd want us to take the information seriously and also consider what it cost them to say it. We should be clear that honest reporting of pain or difficulty won't be punished, and then behave in a way that makes that believable. Safe participation still depends on medical fitness and psychological readiness. We can protect someone's ability to speak honestly while being clear that we can't promise a particular selection outcome. It also matters who checks in with the person during rehab. Is there someone who does that regularly and has no role in deciding whether they play?

The fourth moment is leaving. You've been released. A number of things change at once: the daily structure, the relationships, the role and the future you thought you were working toward.

In my clinical work with people in this situation, what often stands out is disorientation. They may be sad or angry, but they're also trying to work out what tomorrow looks like. When do they get up? Where do they go? Who do they see? What do they say when someone asks what they're doing?

Many organizations I've worked with have had very little in place for that. There may be a dinner, a gift or a phone number to call, but the support doesn't necessarily continue once the person has left. We've marked the departure without really planning for the weeks after it.

Being told directly and privately gives someone a different experience from finding out through the press or from a teammate. They should hear the actual reasons, have some understanding of what happens over the next couple of days, and have a say in how they say goodbye. One practical rule I recommend is contact within forty-eight hours of an exit decision from a named person who had no part in making that decision, with further contact already arranged at two weeks and at four weeks. We shouldn't assume that the person who needs support most will be the one who picks up the phone to ask for it. This is a follow-up arrangement. It doesn't replace immediate care, and anything urgent needs attention at the time.

The rest of the team will notice how the departure is handled too. It can become part of what they expect will happen if their own place changes.

So those are four moments we can prepare for. Now I'd like you to change places. You're no longer the player. You're the person the player decides to tell.

By the time an athlete tells someone they're struggling, they may have spent weeks working out who they can approach. They've noticed who talks to the coach, how private information travels, and what happened the last time someone asked for help. The conversation may feel like a beginning to the person hearing it, while the athlete has been thinking about it for a long time.

Clinically, I find that the opportunity to respond can be quite narrow. If the person feels dismissed, if nothing happens, or if the response is to pass information to the coach without explaining why, they may become more guarded. They may continue saying the things people expect to hear while keeping the difficult part to themselves.

The person hearing the concern doesn't need to diagnose it or know how to treat it. They need to acknowledge what they've been told, be honest about the limits of confidentiality, and help the person reach the appropriate support. I'd want that connection to begin that day, with urgent concerns acted on immediately. Depending on your role, you might say, "Thank you for telling me. Let's get you in touch with our welfare lead today. They can explain what happens next and how your information is protected." The words need to fit the arrangements you actually have, and you shouldn't promise confidentiality you can't provide.

The person coordinating support should have no role in selection and should explain the limits before asking someone to share more. That includes who may need to know, what information would be shared and why. Consent matters, and there may also be safety concerns or reporting duties that require limited information to be shared. If a clinician becomes involved, the coaches should receive only the agreed information needed to plan safe participation, or information required by a safety or reporting duty. For example, they may need to know that the player needs a lighter week. That doesn't mean they need the details of the person's treatment.

You may have had the experience of telling someone something privately and later discovering that other people knew. Even if the person believed they were helping, it can change what you're willing to tell them. This is why I'd want what I call lane discipline, which means having clear, written rules about who can see information and what they can use it for, so athletes aren't left guessing about what will happen if they speak honestly.

And we need to let people know what happened after they raised something. We can show that we've responded without disclosing someone's personal information. I worry that repeatedly asking people for their views and then doing nothing can teach them that speaking is pointless. In your own working life, if you've raised the same concern several times, you may recognize the point at which you stop bringing it up. From the outside, the issue may appear to have gone away, when you've simply stopped expecting a response.

Come back now to your own experience, the one you thought about at the beginning. If you told someone what was difficult, you may remember their response quite clearly. Perhaps it made it easier to say a little more, or perhaps you decided you'd shared enough.

If you're thinking about what you could do with this in your own organization, start with one person whose situation is changing now. Someone may already have come to mind as you've been listening: a new signing who is still eating alone, a veteran whose minutes are about to drop, someone in a long rehab. Write down who is responsible for checking in with them and following up. If nobody is clearly responsible, that's something you can address this week.

There's one other question I'd ask. If someone new took over responsibility for looking after the players tomorrow, what would they have no way of knowing? Would they know about the role change that's worrying someone, or the concern a teammate raised? Would they know who is following up? That can help us notice where care depends entirely on one person remembering, or where a concern has never become anyone's responsibility.

I also want to be clear about the limits of what I'm suggesting. Schlossberg's framework comes from counselling psychology. The study on exclusion was a laboratory study, and it doesn't tell us what any particular player is feeling. The check-ins, the use of the four S's to organize a conversation, and the forty-eight-hour follow-up are practical approaches informed by research. They haven't been validated as a package for sport.

I've also been talking mainly about adult professionals. With teenagers, the power differences and safeguarding responsibilities need particular attention. These suggestions have to sit within the safeguarding arrangements that apply to them.

There are parts of this I haven't covered today, including staff who are also living with uncertainty, such as a physio on a one-year contract. There's also a separate conversation about how we choose people in the first place, including what happens when we make judgments about potential at fourteen. Both deserve more time than I can give them here.

Madeline Antony and I discuss the wider framework in our book, The Psychology of High-Performance Sports Organizations: Culture, Safety, and Leadership. The link is in the episode notes.

Coming back to today's question, I think many organizations have people who are listening carefully. What we need to examine is whether they can do anything with what they hear, and whether the people who speak up ever see a response.

If you go back to the change in your own life that you thought about at the beginning, you may have a clearer sense of what helped, or what would have helped. There may be one conversation you need to return to, or one person who is still waiting to hear what happened after they spoke to you.

For me, this is part of what makes a high-performance culture: continuing to take responsibility for people after we've selected them, including when their contribution changes or their time with us comes to an end.

Next time, we'll look at question six: how do we stay grounded when everyone is screaming? We'll consider what happens when outside attention begins to change everyday life inside a team, including whether people still have anywhere they can be out of public view.

Curiosities is education and it is not medical advice. The views here are mine. They don't represent any hospital, university, or organization I work with. If something in this episode sounded like you, bring it to a clinician who can actually assess you. If you want more, follow the show wherever you're listening or watching, and the newsletter link is in the show notes.