In this episode, Andrew Foxwell and Will Sartorius talk with Harry Delmege about using AI for ad creative — specifically where it helps and where it quietly destroys your hit rate. Harry co-founded Roly Poly Digital and is best known for long-form "yapper" ads that have scaled past $1M in spend. His team uses AI heavily for execution and almost never for ideation. You'll learn why manual research still beats AI research, why AI UGC fatigues faster than real UGC, and the one quality Harry now hires creative strategists for.
We discuss:
Subscribe to AI DTC WTF: https://www.ai-dtc-wtf.com/ Listen on Spotify: https://open.spotify.com/show/033haXJDf9RTIAJzUQY4yC This episode is sponsored by Proppel, the hiring agency that has placed more than 75 employees for Foxwell Founders members. Get 10% off your first hire when you mention the AI DTC WTF Podcast: https://www.weareproppel.com/foxwell-... This episode is brought to you by Runneth from Motion: https://runneth.com To connect with Harry Delmege DM him here https://x.com/harrydelmege_ To connect with Andrew Foxwell reach him here Andrew@FoxwellDigital.com To connect with Will Sartorious DM him here https://x.com/will_sartorius To Connect with Thomas Moen DM him here https://x.com/thomasmoen To learn more about Foxwell Founders and conversations like this one, go here: www.foxwellfounders.com Learn more about Foxwell Digital: https://www.foxwelldigital.com All episodes: https://www.ai-dtc-wtf.com
AI DTC WTF is a short, tactical podcast from Foxwell Digital about using AI to get an edge in DTC. Hosted by Andrew Foxwell, Will Sartorius, and Thomas Moen.
Chapters:
00:00 Why AI isn't making better ads yet 01:27 Where Harry Delmege uses AI and where he refuses to 03:02 The Claude skills behind yapper, VSL, and native ads 05:03 Why manually written ads still beat AI first drafts 06:51 Why AI can't mine Reddit for real customer stories 09:07 Where AI creative actually wins, and why AI UGC dies faster 12:28 What a $200K/month ad account looks like now 16:56 Why ad volume is not the game 22:16 The pendulum swinging back to direct response fundamentals 24:40 AI psychosis and the 80/20 split inside an AI-enabled agency 26:20 The one quality to hire a creative strategist for 30:43 What the best AI users will be doing a year from now 32:58 It's not the format that's crushing, it's the story 37:14 Why human QA takes an ad from a 6 to a 9 40:05 How to stop your team from getting AI-dependent 45:27 Why big brands can't get AI animation approved
Your Home For Tactical Tips, Strategies and Ideas for Your DTC - AI Workflows
We all hear a ton about AI.
We all hear about
what it can do and how amazing
it all is. And I don't
think that there's anything
incorrect about that.
But this episode is brought
to you by an AI brain
that is absolutely incredible
for your marketing
team called Runeth. It's from
Motion and therefore
you know it's awesome because it's from
Motion. But really what Runeth
does is connects every
single function of your marketing
department into
one place. It can do so many
different things. It
build you ads. It can verify
that your brand
looks proper. It can verify
that what your top
creatives were and you can
ask it. You can have
it live in Slack or you can
have it live as a CLI
so you can interact with it
any way you want to.
The thing that's really insane
to me about Motion
is how absolutely intelligent
it truly is and
how it works cross-functionally
across the team.
There was recently a marketer
that Reza talks
about in the landing page
on Runeth which you
should definitely check out
where basically she
went on vacation the CMO did
and said if Runeth says
the ad is okay to run then
it is okay to run.
So she uploaded all the context
for the team.
They ran it into Runeth and Runeth
said yeah that ad
is totally on brand. It's absolutely
crazy a number
of things that this can do
and I think the fact
that we all live in silos and
the fact we all live
separately is really really
challenging and one of
the hard parts about AI. So that's
not what this does.
This brings it all together
with shared context,
shared resources and it also
looks at thousands
of ads every day so it's always
up to date on
what actually is the best performing
ads that it's
seeing across Motion and so
that's another whole
thing that it does. It's really
crazy because instead
of one more dashboard you
get a teammate in
your Slack that knows your performance
data cold.
As I said you can ask it
really anything and
answers instantly. Weekly recaps,
top creatives,
which creators your audience
trusts. It learns
your brand, your playbooks and
gets smarter every day.
Ecommerce and D2C teams are
using it to turn
weekly reporting from a two-day
job into a two-minute
conversation. Head to Runeth.com
and see it for
yourself and it also has a 30-day
money-back guarantee.
So if you need a cheat code
in ecommerce and D2C
with your ads and your ad creative
and your marketing
team check out Runeth.com.
30-day money-back
guarantee. It's absolutely
incredible what this
thing can do and I encourage
you to give it a shot.
What's up everybody? We are
live recording a
podcast of AI D2C WTF which
is our new podcast.
podcast if you haven't heard
this or checked it
out and I'm here with my man
Harry Delmage who
is has always been a good
has has always been
an awesome person and I feel
like whose stock is
absolutely just exploding right
now talking about
so many different things especially
with ads and
yappers. The episode we did with
him on scalability
school is everyone wanted to
see it. It was it was
just hot hot hot hot hot. So Harry thanks
for being here man I appreciate it.
Oh good man thanks for having
me happy to run it
back. We're here talking about
you know why AI isn't
great for creative and what happens
in the creative
process so we're actually kind
of you know we talk a
lot of about AI on the podcast
obviously but for
you it's not something you use
very pretty much at all
in terms of making great
ads. There might be
some areas where you use
it in your process
but tell us kind of where
you use AI and where
you don't and how you view
that in terms of its
negative impact almost on
creating better ads
sometimes. Yeah so I mean to
be fair I wouldn't
want to say like I don't I don't use it I
definitely use it but like I think
like we use it more for
for execution right like
you know but like
less ideation but like because
I think that's like
what a lot of bottlenecks are
it's like if you're
a great strategist you have
all these great ideas
but you're just like well
I just don't have
enough time to write these all
down but I think with AI
you you do not have it so it's
like you know for
example where we do use it is
like I'm constantly
building skills or trying
to improve skills
that are like format dependent
so we have like a
Yapa skill a VSL skill like
a native ads you
know they're like the long form
copy ones like have
all that but really what we
don't use it for is
ideation like that's like a
lot of manual stuff
just because I think there's
no way that maybe I'm
wrong but like right now the
AI can come up with a
better ad idea than you I
think like you know
because it has different guardrails
it can't like
you know all this different
stuff baked into
it so I think you know we're
very bullish on
like manual ideation and
then just like AI
execution but saying that
we also do find like
write one bit of manual copy
like per week and
I'm probably actually going to
start doing bounties
for that like whoever writes
the best banger
that's all manual like gets
like a like end of
month bonus or something
on top of like the
commission they already get nice
nice so what you're so
you have skills that are let's
walk through that
so you have like a skill that
knows how to write
yapper ads and you built that
skill in Claude and
it and it it has every yapper
ad you've ever written
along with instructions from
you I assume uh
not every yapper ad we've ever
written but like
all the all the best ones uh
and it's got like a
lot of different contexts right
like you can build it
like you know I ended up doing
quite a few consulting
calls um and a lot of them around
yapper ad so I got
all the firefly notes and then
baked that into like
a new skill um you know took
the breakdowns from all
the winning ads like broke
down like you know
copywriting fundamentals basically
like the way
that we write yappers like
it's going to change
it's like baked into that skill
but yeah only take
the winners and then you
know if there's any
fireflies like any team meetings
about it you just
like get Claude to like scan
that and see if it
can like add anything in I think
recently we were
comparing output and from the
original one that
I've written um only now have
we beaten the output
with like the new skill and
I do think that came
from like all the firefly notes
and stuff like that
so I think if people aren't
putting those into
their skills they're they're
missing out for sure
I mean so you go through and
you have that skill
and then you have what are the
other skills that you
have like VSL um native long
form like you know
those ones where it's like the
the image and then
that like really long ass uh
primary primary copy
uh that basically for any format
you can think of
we have that as a skill um
you know we have like
you know ad analyzer skills
uh anything you want
to do with um as you just basically
want to scale
and give it as much context as
possible so you don't
have to keep like you know prompting
or re-prompting
stuff it just knows how to do it
the way you want it to
right so you have these built
in and you're
going through and then within
the process of ideation
of creating better ads um
well I mean we don't
have to get into that actually
let me put a pin in
that for a second why do you
think the ads that
you're manually writing are better
than what it comes
out with is it because of
the human experience
is it because of you know AI
is just it has those
guardrails so it doesn't
know how to think
outside of that like what is it
about it because I think
you know you look across the
we look across all
creative right now and performance
creative and
those ads that are working
why are they working
what's what is part of it that's
work like that
does it and I think you've
had a higher hit rate
than a lot of I mean there's
a lot of people out
there that have high hit rates
I guess I'd be
curious of your angle has
been we're going to
manually do this and do you
know work on copy and
make sure the angle and that
like this there's a
long form narrative almost to
it what else are other
people doing do you think along
or and also how are
you thinking about it in terms
of AI and what it
does yeah I don't know so many
different ways I guess
I could answer that but I guess
like the reason
we're very bullish on manual research
and we also do a
manual research bounty as well
so like every month
we run one like from manual
research like you post
it into the channel the thing
you found out and if
that like brings around like
the biggest unlock for
that account you also get like
uh like an extra
bonus at the end of the month
I think the reason
is like obviously as we touched
upon like some of
the ideas it just it just can't
come up with like
I don't know maybe if they're
like pretty like
crazy or out there ideas like
maybe like gray hat
ideas whatever you want to
call it like you know
it's it's not going to want
to do that too much
I also feel like you know I've
played around with
it so much and tried to like
extract stories from
reddit with AI and it just I
don't know for whatever
reason maybe I'm just doing it
wrong I could be doing
it wrong but like it doesn't
really pick up on any
good stories and it just skims
everything rather than
actually getting like any
kind of good good
thing like obviously based on
the keywords it might I
don't know I just feel like
it just doesn't give
me what I'm actually looking
for it just kind of
gives me like oh this kind
of thing could happen
and then also like you just
have to trust AI like
face value and like I don't
know maybe other
people are seeing I'm certainly
seeing them like
talk about it like Claude's
output seems to be
unanimously getting worse so it's like
well it's going to do the
same for research and if it's
just like I feel like
I don't know maybe again I'm
using it wrong but the
amount of times I'm like no
take your time make
sure you found this add in
these guardrails like
by that time I might as well
just gone on to like
some subreddit found the story
myself and then I'm
just like off to the races
you know I mean like
I don't think you can get deep
research like deep
knowledge on something just
from like research
alone especially if you're not
like a like if you're
cracked at ads like I'm sure
you could the amount
of time you're spending going
through back and forth
with AI anyway you might as
well just fucking
gone on reddit in my opinion maybe
I'm wrong but like
you know yeah it's almost like
you have you have
to prompt it and give it so
many instructions on
what you're trying to do that
it takes a long
time and you know I also think
there's a piece of the
the way that you connect dots
as a human being of
like what actually is interesting
in terms of an
angle that maybe that you
know you can mine I
mean I think you're using it
if you use it to mine
reviews and to mine you know
certain things
like data that you have on post-purchase
you know
surveys or whatever then that's one thing
because that's not something
you want to do manually
but in terms of going and
doing it on reddit
like it's yourself I think that
a lot of times it's
harder for Claude to do that
anyway like and it's
easier if you go in and look
around and say oh it's
kind of interesting and whatever
how do you I
mean okay so right now looking
across others that are
really you know I know you're
you're looking at
other high-performing ads a
lot what do you think
are components that uh AI has
played into those
to make them successful not
necessarily from you
but from others like what
are they doing is it
is it like that their AI has
helped them to create
uh rapid iterations of animated
ads or you know
what what is it that they're
allowed to do um and
I'm just curious well yeah
I mean I think a
lot of it comes down to like
what you can do
visually like there's a
lot of constraints
where like if you do want to
come up with these wild
stories you know it's kind of hard to do
sometimes with a real person you
know I mean so like you
know something I've been seeing
like crush is just
like you know Pixar stuff but
even like Pixar music
song stuff you know I mean
like you can't really
do that with a person um then
like other things
where like you know some people
are using like AI
b-roll to show situations that
again with a person
like I saw one where I think
it was about a story
about you know how someone went
abroad and it like
led to this like discovery of
something well getting
a UGC creator to do that in any
short amount of time
is just going to take you I mean
it might be fucking
nigh impossible to get someone
to do that then to go
like get the b-roll in this
other country but like
with AI you can have that tomorrow
you know I mean
so again I've seen that work
really well uh I've
also seen AI UGC work really
well um you know but
the one thing I will say with
it that maybe again
others haven't seen that I have
is like it fatigues
quickly you know I mean like you have to
constantly with the disclosure
and everything like it's
because now in the U.S. like a lot of ads
have a disclosure basically uh default
so you've seen you've seen
those work even
with the disclosure on there
but they die faster
uh I mean to be fair like I'd
have to look at like
the disclosure again like we
don't really do many
of them so like we're never
in a situation we
have to like disclose um but
I'd have to check but
even before that like they were
like working good
but like it just would die out
quick but you know
there was that trend where
someone was like
speaking on stage you know what
I mean and as like a
presenter like that that worked
good but I think
just like whereas like if we
write a yapper and
it like bangs like that can
last for months and
months and months like at the
top of the ad account
and like we're seeing that
now rather than being
like okay it's crushing then
we have to like whip
something up uh like there's
like an account we're
in right now where it's like
they have like a UGC
that's crushing we've done some
other stuff while
we're getting the the appers
it might take over for
like a couple of days but then
that real UGC just
comes back to the top again you
know I mean so it's
like you know I'm sure when
we get like more of
the real UGC like we can defer
on it like you know
properly but again it's just
something I see is
like it can work but it just
doesn't have the legs
so I'm just like well why not
just do that and do
the hard thing and just like
you know real people
real research I don't know yeah
yeah yeah totally
I agree it's interesting like
how do you think it's
going to evolve in terms
of looking across a
successful ad account like
is it is it going to
be um you know for example
would it be that
you'll look in a successful ad
account that's spending
200 grand a month and they have you know
the yappers they have uh ads
that are you know
you like generated animated
stuff from you know
uh ai um they have a bunch of
ai generated statics
like what is what is it going
to look like I
mean because I know it's sort
of some of places look
like that now but I'm curious
what your take
is yeah I mean as you know
I'm a fan of a fan of
diversity and I think ai has
made that like so
much like I think that's genuinely
like a huge net
of ai is like now the new amount
of like diversity
you can bring to accounts like
you know we did this
uh ads that like popped off
for this like pet
brand and we had like the dog
talking it and like a
claymation and stuff like
that like that just
wasn't possible like you know for
the average advertiser
like three years ago so the
fact that you can
just like you know pretty much
do that and have that
generated like in a couple
of days now is insane
um yeah I mean like to 200k
I think you can just
you know just pop off with
like one format but
I definitely see the ones that
are like you know
when they hit like you know
big spend is it's
definitely like very diverse
content like founder
content uh like yapper content
maybe like more
performance UGC statics like
ai like you know you're
definitely seeing a lot more
of those come in um
at those like higher spenders
and like all of them
like you know I guess the
ideal thing is like
they all spend like a decent
amount and you can just
you know keep increasing spend
with it rather
than just like them fighting
for spend and just
the spend level staying the same yeah so
basically uh there's the you know
it's right it's going to
continue to be used for diversity
in what you're
saying you know um which is
good so one thing I've
been curious about with you
is let's say you know
we're looking across Andromeda
and Lattice and others
right um and it's we know that
meta wants diversity
and that's what we've been aiming
and building for
do you think that as we're
looking forward if
I run a creative shop what's
your advice to me
in reference to like uh how
do I approach building
a bunch of different ads for
clients is it like hey
let's let's make sure that we're doom
scrolling a lot that we're
going on tiktok a lot
to unlock new styles and immediately
you know
then we're rapidly iterating
those for clients
um like what's the how do
I sort of set up
my organization to continue
to make great ads
utilizing ai but also not utilizing
ai yeah cool
I guess I'll give an answer
for both I mean also
someone's like I've been explained
like Lattice
like three different times I'm
still not even really
sure what it means um I'm not even really
sure what Andromeda means
apart from diversity
I don't know uh so I mean
I'll be honest I'll
be honest with you it's like
uh but yeah I mean
in terms of and this is where
we come back to
ai right like you know we talk
about like review
mining a hundred percent
just do that with
ai that means you can doom
scroll uh what your
prospects feed looks like
even more you know I
mean like you can type in the
niches and watch even
more like instead of just going through
every fucking review one by
one and being like oh
that's another person that
said very good okay
that's like pointless like
I think what it looks
like in the future is just
like really working
out where is great to use
it and that's still
something that we're trying
to work out as well
and that also might change
in six months because
maybe ai will be able to
pull stories like
absolutely perfectly and then
take that and just
crank like an amazing yeah
presence like okay
great but like I think going
forward it's like and
what it is now is it's like
you know people like
using a blend and working out
okay if I can review
like where can I save time
and where can I where
should I be putting more manual
time and that's
the thing is like you know
obviously we've had
like a pretty successful like
first 10 months of being
open and like I can't tell
you how many brand
owners I talk to that like have
a pretty like poor
agencies purely from the fact
they just say like
all they give is like ai slot
like they can tell
the like scripts are written
by ai slot so as
again like you know learning
how to make sure like
you know you're gonna have to
put in time manually
to learn how to be a great copywriter
and stuff like
that you know I mean like
that's all stuff yo
what's going up man what's
up sorry I'm late
no problem by the way will
we're live on x right
now so oh what's up people yeah
so feel free to go
on rt me to get more viewers
yeah it's no I mean
I I think with one thing that's
interesting harry
um that you just said is you
know I think that
there has been a lot of folks
that they see volume
as the game and it's not
about volume right
it's about the quality of the
create of what you're
creating um and you know ai
allows you to create a
ton of volume but that doesn't
necessarily mean that
it's going to net you better
results in any case
and I also think it's really
challenging because
as has always been our industry
there's a lot of
people that are in our industry
that give advice
and that could be on well
you know bidding or
audiences I mean that this is
as tales old as time
like beauty and the beast but
like the the thing
that I see with that that basically
they're huge
accounts um and they are spending
tens of millions
of dollars and they tell everybody
what to do and
then these brands that are spending
50 to 50 to 100
thousand dollars a month which
is a large majority
of e-commerce brands to be
honest like they are
trying to implement a system
where they're creating
400 net new concepts a week or
something and you're
just like you know that's not
going to be it right
and so it like lowers the bar
enough and I think
that's not good for anyone really
that's not good
for for for the you know any
of it um no yeah that
was like that was like stuff
I used to hate is that
you wake up to like some fucking
x screenshot from
like some like of like your favorite
gurus but oh man
like you know the accounts they're
talking about are
way bigger than yours so you're
in completely different
different situations but luckily
that doesn't
doesn't happen to me anymore
but yeah that like
back in the day that was a that
was a painful one
because like yeah they would
want the same thing
it's like I don't think you
even cracked like what
your core messaging is yet or
what actually makes
you different from other people
right and I just
think you expanding it go ahead
yeah and it's also
like I don't think you know
the cpa that they
can afford to have compared to
you so like you know
like it's a whole different
conversation um but
yeah I mean like it's weird
actually talking about
like the volume thing okay
yeah obviously AI
is great for volume and like
execution uh but I
actually saw a post about uh
from a guy called guy
called Jacob uh a friend of mine
you know he's he's
he's pretty active on Twitter
and he's always been
like pretty anti like volume
for the sake of volume
um and he made what I really
liked was a great
post about the fact that he's
actually in like the top
one percent of like advertisers
with like the
amount of ads live and he was like
that's not because I
like launch loads of volume
it's just because I
make great ads and they just
stay active for like
ever they've all got like a
job to be done so I'm
like you know people are like
oh I need to launch
like x amount of ads like all
these ones uh but
it's actually you can just make
bangers that just
have jobs to be done and just
stay active for for
ages and you just compound that
way instead which
is probably the way I would
prefer to do it
personally um but again some people
are going to be like no
that's stupid just make infinite
ads um but also
a lot of those people who say
make infinite ads
never really seem to supply
results that come
with that so I'm not fucking
know yeah well I'm not
trying to start drama but it's
like you know you
always say make infinite ads
but I'm like post some
post some fucking spend on
those ads buddy come
on the so first of all the um
for those of you that
tuning in uh this is a live
stream episode that
shall be recorded as well of ai
d2c wtf which is a new
podcast that will and I and
our friend in Norway
uh Thomas Mullen have started
uh and Harry Delmage
is on here talking about a
whole bunch of stuff
so Harry thanks for being here
um the so let me ask
about I'm gonna ask one more
question and then
will you can kind of hop in so
one of the things that
I think has been I was talking
last night with uh
Hannah Haug and um Matthew Gatozzi
about creative
in this whole ecosystem um
and how I think that
there's this there's this really
hard push and pull
between brands and agency
operatives and or
operators and owners that want
creative strategists to
be putting out more and volume
is the name of the
game and the creative strategist
that actually is
like I need to make sure that
this is good and that
we're getting back to basics
of creating great ads
how how do you see this right
now and how do you
think that we as organizations
can be better in terms
of uh helping our strategists write better
briefs and deliver ultimately better ads
one of the biggest questions
that comes up
inside the foxhole founders community
is around hiring
how do you know and how do
you find great people
that you can actually trust
to do the job that's
why I want to talk to you about
propel propel has
placed more than 75 employees
for members of foxhole
founders some of the hardest
roles our members have
been trying to fill for months
they filled quickly
and efficiently we're talking from video
editors to graphic designers
media buyers and more
in latin america to managers
directors and heads
of department and vps in the
u.s they have done
it all they can help you build
that team that
scales faster I know that this
is an ad read and I know
that it's totally one of
those things you're
like well it's whatever it's
an ad honestly though I
literally use this and have
used propel and the
team over at propel for all of
these things they've
filled offshore they've filled
domestic like I
just said it's absolutely incredible
and honestly the
founder Leandro used to run
an econ brand and
performance marketing agency
so he gets it that's
one of the things I've always loved about
Leandro and what I love about
dealing with him I have
never even heard a negative
review about working
with them one time somebody
said it wasn't working
out and Leandro immediately
replaced the candidate
that he had put in the position
for a person that's
like the only feedback I've ever
heard the way that
they work is simple it's performance
based you only
pay a one-off fee once you
actually hire someone
there's no retainers no ongoing
costs and every hire is
backed by a three-month guarantee
so go to the
show notes check it out let
me know what you think
and if you have questions about
this feel free to
hit me up andrew at foxwelldigital.com
I'm happy
to talk about it if you go
to the link in the
show notes you get 10% off your
first hire with them
it's a great deal really
special for podcast
listeners so I look forward
to hopefully helping
your brand grow and scale
is that question for me or
for Will yeah for you
damn I thought you were talking
to Will that whole
time I'm not gonna lie to
you I feel I thought
you said Will at the start so
I was like okay he's
asking that but okay no I'm
Will can answer that
and then you can chime in if
you'd like I mean I'm
I'm with you I know I have
to answer but sorry I
was just like waiting for Will
to talk because I was
like I don't want to just talk
over but no I can I
can answer yeah I mean like
I think it comes back
to the thing that so much
has rapidly changed
over three years like I was saying
before like three
years ago I would have had like no way of
knowing that I'd be able to create
all this like wild
Pixar or Playmation looking
stuff that like
genuinely does well like that
just just wasn't
something that I thought when
I was like you know
three four years ago and I was
like new to create
a strategy that was like okay
this is a possible
thing to to do um so I think
it's like a natural
pendulum swing right it's like
you just like oh
my god this is so cool I can
just like get every
single one of my ideas down
and I can just like
get everything out and now it's
coming back to that
thing where it's like oh shit
I need to actually
make sure this is grounded
in like proper direct
response proper marketing I
need to QA this all
properly because like you know
depending on the day
it will either give me something
that's like
actually pretty good or just it
doesn't even make sense
I think it's just a natural
like pen and string
back where like people thought
they could just
like one shot or was hoping
they could one shot
a lot of stuff with AI and
it'd be a banger like
that would be the best situation
if I just have
like a random idea and I'm
like okay go write a
yeah right about that and
it spends like seven
figures that's that would be
the best thing ever
like I'm not saying I don't
want that I'm just
saying it's like realistically
it's not there so I think
people are like now coming
back to being like
okay no we actually need to go
back to fundamentals
because like anything right
it's like whatever
sport you do if you stop doing
the fundamentals
and the basics like you will
lose that skill you
will forget how to QA a script
you'll forget how
if an ad is even good or not
like you just won't
know you will look at it and
be like yeah that's
fine but that's just because
you've been like using
AI for every day for the last
six months and you just
have no idea if that's got
better or worse
because it's just your new standard
so I think it's just
naturally naturally coming back
to that and I also
think like brand owners especially
I mean you know
again I'm not speaking for
all people here just
like you know they're they're
coming to me and
like the agency for quality
like that that's what
they want some people like
are like oh yeah like
we want some more volume but
like they only want
more volume once the quality
is proven you know I
mean that's when they're like
hey guys can you
give us more like it's not like
you know I feel like
if I told people what their
like monthly like
deliverables were like a year
ago people were like
that's nowhere near enough how
do you expect us to
scale off that and I just don't
think people got the
results they wanted to were
like oh shit okay
maybe we got to go back to basics
here so that's that's
my view on it yeah I definitely
agree I think you
know we have been actively hiring
creative strategists
and I think one of the most eye-opening
experiences for me is that like a
lot of creative strategists
will just continually write
copy with Claude and
like in the application process
you'll be getting a lot
of responses with Claude
and if you ask to
brief out a handful of statics
and videos you'll get
Claude responses and you know
I'm obviously the
first to admit that like we
are like sort of like
an AI enabled agency but the
reason we are AI
enabled is so we can free up strategists
to actually do
the hard work right like we
want to be able to
produce 80% of your ads bottom
of funnel statics
with AI we still have editors
on all of our all
of our statics but then that
other 20% needs to be
like entirely human driven
like copywriting is
undoubtedly the most important
part of creative
strategy in my opinion and
you can't just like
skip that step and I think we're
just like in this
still in the stage of like
AI psychosis where
it's just like it's a really
fun tool to play with
and I again I'm the first
to sort of fall into
that grouping but like where
you ultimately end up
winning is sort of utilizing
AI to uncover like
angles personas emotions formats
you should be testing
giving the reins to like a really good
copywriter uh who can actually deliver
um and so yeah it's
definitely a combination
of the two and like
finding good strategists that actually
have copywriting
jobs that are actually willing
to sort of do the
hard work is becoming much more
challenging it's just
I think people just assume
that they can just uh
skip steps by using uh you know
language learning model
so yeah I completely agree
with Harry there um
I guess my question to that
is like when you're
looking for a strategist now
Harry like what is
like if you had to sort of distill
the the the the job
down into like one most important
quality of a
person like what do you think
that is one that's tough
one important man okay I guess
just willing to
do the hard work like that's
just just it like
you know because at first
I was like looking
for people who uh okay how
how skilled are they
where have they come from
like you know I want
someone that's got like quite
a bit of experience
but like I'm also finding
that to be somewhat
sometimes again not always like
a bit of a negative
now because I've now got
to like make them
unlearn all the bad habits
they've picked up
whereas like actually uh
you know onboarded
some like really like hungry
people who were like
not green by any means like
at all but like not
these people have come from these
big places or like
you know had this like you know
years of experience
and they're like fucking crushing
but just because
they're hungry to learn they
want like actually
want to learn the craft they
don't think they know
the craft you know I mean whereas
a lot of people
are like oh yeah well I've done
this for x amount
of years now I I can just
keep cranking out I
know everything I already need
to know and if like
they've given up learning still
you know I mean
like they're not going to go
read like breakthrough
advertising for the sixth time
do you know I mean
they're just not going to do
that because in their
head they've like completed
it so I think just
like willing to do that hard work
and go that extra 10
percent is like are you willing
to like QA your
scripts that bit more or are
you just going to
one-shot it with AI and it's
like yeah that's
good enough um so yeah probably
that's the one
thing I'm looking for but it
always changes you
know like first I was like
thinking this is the
case but then in three months
I might find a new
type of person I'm trying to
hide but like yeah
hungry people willing to do
the work and like
generally still curious and like
wanting excellence
whereas like I feel like that's
died a bit not
saying it's because of the
use of AI but like
it seems like a lot of people
have just become
happy with good enough like
even like you know
as for example when like
I like I always do
trial and I always make someone
write a yapper at for
trial like even if it's like
they're not very
comfortable with because it
takes time it's longer
like and we had someone um send
one over the other
day like instantly just replied
and I was like write
that again like you know and
just made them do it
again make them go longer because
it's like no I
don't want it just like oh
with AI like just go
back and do it again yeah I
mean I think I think
that that's I think it's true
it's like that that
desire of somebody who wants
to and knows that it
doesn't it it's um it's going
to take time right
um and also knows that there's
always this constant
desire to continue learning
and to continue
refining right like um if you asked
I don't know Michael
Jordan at the height of his career what's
the number one thing you would
say to somebody
you know to continue to learn
I mean I think or
continue to grow like it had
to be something like
you have to keep training
you have to keep
developing this to developing it which
I think is is the same
because I think it's it's just
very easy to fall
into that the AI trap of of it's
doing it for you and
you think that you're improving
but in reality you're
really not so I think that that
that's is like a trap
that a lot of folks are caught
in and they're out
there seeing like oh I hooked
up all these things
and I have all this you know
data and all these
MCPs um and I'm pumping out more
ads than I ever have
but it's it's like it just loses
that human element
and it loses the hard work that
it takes to actually
copyright really probably
um and I think that
creative strategists know this
I guess is what I'm
getting at and I think a lot
of leaders don't
know this as well right so I
think this is a call to
to leaders to be like hey
this is different
right like we need to not
just be pushing on
the volume button or just
generally saying
personas right but like what
does that even mean
and what are you trying to
do I guess a question
I have for you Harry is you
know let's say that we
look a year down the road
too I'm you know I'm
always in the interest of equipping
people properly
we go a year down the road
what are folks doing
that uh you know has has improved
their ads with
AI like is it just that people
are utilizing AI in
a year more efficiently or that
they've integrated
into their systems better or
you know what is it
that it's that they've done
with AI that's made
their lives easier and better
I think yeah
there's like a case for efficiency
like you know again
go back to the review money
but I think the people
that use it the best and the
people that can like
really use it to bring their
imagination to life
you know what I mean like I think
that's the case now
and I think it will be the case
like even more so
as like you know it gets easier
and easier to like
create these wild things but
like some of the AI
stuff that I see working like
you know people would
do like fake like security
camera stuff like you
know as like a hook or like
you know again we talk
about like that like the pics
are like musical
stuff like anything like that
where you can use it
because before it was such
a constraint and like
now it's not and I think it's
only going to get
easier to bring your imagination
to life but I
think to do that you need to
still keep that like
creativity alive and like I
think a lot of that
comes from like manual stuff
or like experiencing
things and trying to like then
turn that into to
adverts but like yeah obviously
things will get more
efficient reporting like all
that stuff like the
grunt stuff is gonna um basically
make it easier
and then like the things that
you'll probably do
is be like okay well I'm gonna
go out for like two
walks today on those two walks
I'm gonna try like
ideate two fucking crazy ads
or something and I'm
gonna wait for like I'm gonna
be ruminating over
everything I've been thinking
about and then wait for
one to be like airdropped
to me or something
like so I think yeah it's just
gonna become like you
know the people that are crushing
it the people
that are still like you know
keeping their like
imagination and creativity cranking
and then they
can just like use AI to come
up with this like mad
shit that looks awesome you
know what I mean yeah
100% and like sort of piggybacking
out of that I
think a lot of people are just
like using AI wrong
right like AI has opened up this
like so many avenues
of content right like as
you were discussing
earlier like you can do a full
sort of end-to-end
top of funnel animated you
know claymation you
know Minecraft whatever sort
of medium you want
it to be but like fundamentally
you really need a
strong script there like advertising
hasn't changed
at the end of the day we're
all just telling a
story right and now we just
like have additional
mediums to do it so like I think
where people get
what gets so wrong with AI in
general it's like oh
this format is crushing right
now it's not the
format that's crushing it's
the story that you're
telling behind the format and
like again that's
why people have this like sort
of AI psych psychosis
where they're just like building fucking
dashboards and just like you know
spinning their wheels and
like oh yo look at my fucking
sick dashboard and
it's just like it's so infuriating
so it's like not
accretive that's not ROI positive
like what's
ROI positive is like using
these tools to like
underpin like where are my
holes in my uh in the
ads I'm running now like who
who haven't I been
talking to and then like using
Harry's method
where it's just like I'm actually
writing end-to-end
scripts you know I can use
a creator to do a
yapper ad or like if I want to
even test it like I can
spin up like an animated ad
top of funnel ad in an
hour right it's just like it's
so people are just
like are so of the mindset that
like everything that
they're creating with cloud code
is is god's gift to
the earth and like again this
is sort of this
psychosis mindset and it's
just like you have to
sort of go down to fundamentals
like a good script
is a good script and like nine
times out of ten it's
written by a human being but
like then you can
take that script like do a minecraft
one and if that
works well like then get a
creator to go do it
it's just like it gives you
the ability to sort of
catalyze testing in a way we've
never been able
to do so before um and and Harry
I'm curious like
when before you like go and
create a yapper ad
like are you testing that
concept with like an
animated sort of top of funnel
uh no okay so
you're going straight to creator
straight from script to
creator yeah I think so just because like
honestly like a lot of people
can kind of do that like
animation stuff pretty pretty
well I feel like um
because I think like a lot
of the visuals can do
the carrying there you know
I mean like because
they look so like you can tell
so much of that story
with like you know it's a
bit of like a cheat
code for that kind of stuff
um but like still a
lot of accounts are in like
you know haven't quite
cracked yappers and like we're
pretty confident with
how we write it and how we
QA it so we can just
send it straight to a creator
and just be like fuck
it let's let's let's run it
um because it's still
like a thing that I think people
struggle with so it's
just like well while people
are still struggling
why not just just go for that
uh but then if it does
turn it into like AI stuff and
just like you know
spin that concept and that story
uh as many ways as
possible um you know for sometimes
for example
though like on certain accounts
we would do like
you know the long form native
image copy stuff
if that pops off we'll take
like the core story of
that and then apply that to
a yapper because it's
just like a cheap and easy way
to test that story
before you then uh go to that
uh just like full
warning for anyone that does
that don't just like
copy and paste the thing just
because your yapper
script will turn into like a
12 minute long thing
and people can read way quicker
than they can
consume information and getting
a real person with
like not any b-roll or anything
like that being
charismatic for 12 minutes
straight is uh pretty
pretty difficult I wouldn't
I wouldn't necessarily
recommend it so yeah like that's
like a really good
way to test it but then it's
more like once we
have done that um you know I
guess not that I ever
think about like do the hard
thing first then we can
like do the do the easier stuff
and just spin that up
like different ways um and
then there's just
some stories that like again
like I've spoken about
it's like you know if you're
in a pet like pet
niche I would just spend more
of my time doing
like AI animation stuff because
you can make
dogs like talk and shit like
that which is like so
awesome do you know I mean
like that's so cool
you can like yeah you know I
think we did one for a
brand it was like you know
it was like for like
some joint shoes or whatever
uh and like you know we
show the claymation where like
the mum gets like
really upset when like the dog
starts limping because
like got old and the dog's like I don't
understand why mommy's sad and all
this stuff like I'm just
trying to be like a good dog
uh so it's like you
know you just can do that with
like you know like
loads of people are commenting
like this made me
tear up like this like you know
and it got like a
pretty pretty healthy amount
of spend but it's
like you just can't do that with
like yeah like the
apparatus like you know I mean
so it's like that
kind of stuff we just don't necessarily
bother with
the apparatus and we just
go straight to AI
animation yeah but like fundamentally
you still have a
human being writing that script
right like that
is like the research needs to
still come into play
like it's not the animation
that's carrying it
it's it's it's a good script
presumably yeah exactly
I think like more what we do
is like we're really
like heavy on human QA because
like I like I was
saying like earlier like you
know one of the great
things with AI is like especially
of skills is it
like really lowers that barrier
to like execution
where you can actually get like
and with skills you
can get a pretty decent first
draft but I think
that's the problem is people
look at that like oh
that's pretty decent and then
just like leave
it there but it's actually the
ads that like even
when we've curated and I spoke
to um like spoke to
my friend like Luke the other
day he's like head of
performance like another and
he said like the ads
that he sees pop-offs are the
ones that where you
add the tiny details to it
you make the small
changes because like the nuances
really matter so it's
like for execution like and
I fully agree with
that I see the same things like
even if it's not big
changes you're just asking
like so what can we
add a little bit more detail
here can we make that
more emotive and like you need
to in my opinion
you need the human human QA
for that um but yeah
I think most people get to
that point where it's
like okay cool that's like a
six out of ten we'll
just ship it but if you can
get to that six out
of ten and then make it like
nine out of ten like
great that's like kind of like
the way you wanted
to do it because yeah starting
from zero and being
like fuck now I gotta write
like a four minute
script like while you've got all
this other stuff going
on it's like it's not a fun
feeling so it's like
if you can get that first draft
great then cool but
you but that's why you need
to still be studying
still be breaking down winning
ads manually like
you know like I got like a
bloody like this here
like I got the I got the prompts
that I do to run
like winning ads but I also
watch winning ads
manually and like write down
notes myself so you
can still just know what makes
a good ad like I go
on Kalo data and I write down
what the affiliates
are doing when they're like
overcoming objectives
like I'm still doing that manually
so that I can do it
when I get my script back and
I've noticed when I
don't do that my QAing gets
worse because you just
over-reliant on AI and you're
just starting to
accept what it's giving you
because you're like
ah fuck it it's been fine but
a lot of the time
it's not and then as it keeps
going it's worse and
worse you know what I mean
totally it's such a
negative feedback loop and like
I definitely agree
like journaling every morning
like sort of keeps
me humble and like you know
puts puts the earth
underneath my feet like so for
your team like are
there any things like you recommend
for your team
to members or like anyone
else in this space
like how do you sort of keep
that grounding and not
sort of lose yourself in the
psychosis of it all
yeah I mean I just like ask
for for proof around
stuff I'm just like where did
you get that from and
if like sometimes they're like
AI I'm like okay go
and verify it yourself but like
also what we do is
we do like a manual research
challenge every month
where there's like bounties
and it's like if
you get the biggest unlock from
research uh manual
research um then you get you get a bounty
like you know I think like
prizes go up to like
like right now like five hundred
dollars on top of
like the commission they already
get anyway so it's
like you know it's all right
it's not like it
probably could be better and
then also what I'm
going to implement alongside
that is if you write
a manual ad that pops off alongside
the commission
you'll also get like a bounty
to do with that
as well so like really just
trying to get them to
get into the habit of like keeping
the tools tool
sharp um and you know I'd love
for people to do it
just because they think I'm
like awesome and it's
the best company to work at
ever but like you know
like money talks you know
I mean so like just
giving people like financial
ascent like incentives
especially when it's like something
that's like
becoming harder to do because
it wasn't we never like
we had mental friction to do
it before but we had
to do it you know I mean there
was like well I have
to just write this manually
like yeah it kind of
is like annoying that I have
to do it but like I'm
just gonna fucking sit down
and get it done like
that doesn't exist anymore you
can just get AI to
do it so it's even more mental
things about oh
fuck's sake I really have to write
this manually it's
just like okay cool I just I
I gotta give you money
for that effort you know what
I mean yeah I mean I
think that that raises a good
point which is one
I've said a lot uh in coaching
calls other things which
is with employees making
sure that you are
incentivizing them for the
behavior that you
want it's just like anything
else but I mean like
seriously it matters when you
go through and say
this is the type of behavior
we're trying to reward
that's not done enough people
do that in they think
it's under job expectation um
which in some cases
it is but if you are doing
competition or you're
gamifying it or you're you know
doing some sort of
bonus they'd say hey look like
the more I see this
better I am happy to incentivize
you um and
here's what it means like you
will get x number of
dollars like that will drive
better results so I
think that's kind of an interesting
one um as you
go forth one question I have
Harry is on on those
people that are utilizing you
know AI in a way that
makes sense uh in their organization
do you think
that they have is there some
creative director or
brand the brand owner has
a good idea of what
they are okay with with the brand
in reference to AI
like there's or is there like
an AI captain in the
organization or are they just
saying you know what
Harry we trust you you're the
expert go for like
which I just am wondering where
people have been
held back right are you talking
about like in
terms of like like you know I'll
like the my company or
terms of like like when I work
with brands like what
they're saying about the use of
AI yeah I'm wondering
specifically about the people
that are um how do
I say this I'm wondering specifically
about those
organizations that are really
good at AI and they're
like really good at making your
job easy in terms of
getting out better ads do do
they have some sort
of filter that says yes that
can happen with that
that's fine that's on brand for
us um go for it and
they trust you or it's like
they have a process of
okay this goes to this person
they approve it it's
good um like and there's almost
like an AI captain
internally I'm just curious
of your take uh well
yes okay if I've got it confused
let me know but in
terms of like you know when
people I've like
listened to that again I was like
this could be a number of
things but it's been a long
day a lot of calls a
lot of calls you gotta bear with
me um you know it's
a little bit late for me over
here um yeah so in
terms of like when I'm like sending
of if you're talking
about when I'm sending over ads
to clients and like
how they're talking about like
are things on brand
and like with the use of AI
I'll be very honest
like we mostly work with people
that are pretty chill
with a lot of stuff um you know
we work with like
a lot of like supplement brands
and like that kind
of thing um so I would say like
and a lot of people I
think would that come to me know
that like we're very
rooted in like direct response
and like we like to
push it a little bit um but
yeah we've definitely
had it before where people
are like that's not
on brand and like to be honest
if it's like stupid
stuff that I don't agree with
then like we it's
just not like I don't want to
say stupid but like
just stuff that isn't aligned
with me then like
the relationship's just not going
to last very very
long like we do best with people
that are kind of
just like yeah like fuck it
you guys can kind of
and like run whatever you want
essentially like
whatever you think is best
because at the end of
the day they have a freedom
to it they're just
saying that's fine I'm just
wondering because I
feel like there's a big thing
that happens with AI
people are either like there's
a lot of places it
has to get routed and that
hurts them from
creating better ads and there's
other places that are like
the extreme of your side which
is like go for it
whatever we don't care right
and so I'm trying to
figure out like there there
probably needs to be
a middle ground of this of like
getting things out
to because there's going to
be more governance
around this so that's what I'm
thinking yeah yeah
for sure like yeah I guess because
I mean like with
some brands like again with
like some with fashion
like makes sense like you know
you don't like you
know you don't be doing necessarily
like pixels and
it might work I don't know but
like sometimes you
see a bit more branded stuff
with like that but I
guess it kind of makes sense
because fashion it
makes sense you know I mean but
like in terms of other
stuff like I've been speaking
to people like maybe at
like bigger brands and they just
can't even get like
AI animation stuff approved
by brand and I'm just
like that's just the fucking
death of advertising
like what the fuck are we doing
here like this is
crazy like yeah you know like
I get on the other
side yeah and I get on the other
side where people
are like doing like fake doctors
and stuff like you
know it's a bit like whatever
like you know
people have like you know views
on that so it's like
you're right there definitely
probably like is a
middle ground but like I'm always
on the thing of
like lean on the like side
of like a bit more
aggressive you know I mean I think
yeah you know you look at
brands like crushing now and
a lot of them that
are up and coming again can't
talk full of them
because I don't see inside
their ad account but
like they are doing these like
you know being more
loose of it like because it's all like
trend-based as well like you know
there's only so long that
these ads will like kind of
work like claymation
and stuff like that is like
still work because in
some cases falling off a bit
so they're just like
missing trends because they've
got some people in
brand who don't even know what
direct response is
being like oh we can't run that
like well it's stupid
it's obviously it's advertising
it's so well
and that's that's so funny
I mean I I have this
I we should name this like
to come up with a
law for the name the the the
something law of like
the bigger the organization
the worse they are to
work with usually and the and
the more they shoot
themselves in the foot like
I'm gonna say nothing
because there's so many layers
you know you're like
oh my gosh um yeah well Harry thanks for
joining us thanks for joining
the live stream everyone
um if you came on live stream
and uh we'll look
forward to uh doing this again
but Harry thanks
for for coming on today yeah
no all good I have
no idea if I said anything helpful
at all zero you
didn't say anything good it's
terrible yeah yeah no
I just just complained about
volume and big brands
that was it that's it yeah
people people got
their their times worth with
that one let's let's go
you