Cognitive psychologist Dr. Cynthia Nebel joins Gene for a lively conversation about what teachers really need to know about the science of learning—and what they don't. They explore cognitive load, motivation, student autonomy, retrieval practice, and why even brilliant medical students struggle to learn effectively. Along the way, Gene puts Cindy's memory to the test with a little 1960s music trivia. The conversation turns to AI, the importance of knowledge, and the challenge of translating research into effective classroom instruction. No clichés, no buzzwords—only stuff that works.
Descriptions of effective teaching often depict an idealized form of "perfect" instruction. Yet, pursuing perfection in teaching, which depends on children's behavior, is ultimately futile. To be effective, lessons and educators need to operate with about 75% efficiency. The remaining 25% can be impactful, but expecting it in every lesson, every day, is unrealistic. Perfection in teaching may be unattainable, but progress is not. Whether you are aiming for the 75% effectiveness mark or striving for continuous improvement, this podcast will guide you in that endeavor.
Speaker: Welcome to Better Teaching: Only Stuff That Works, a podcast for teachers, instructional coaches, administrators, and anyone else who supports teachers in the classroom. This show is a proud member of the BE Podcast Network, shows that help you go beyond education. Find all our shows at bepodcastnetwork.com.
I am Gene Tavernetti, the host for this podcast, and my goal for this episode, like all episodes, is that you laugh at least once, and that you leave with an actionable idea for better teaching. A quick reminder: no cliches, no buzzwords, only stuff that works.
Speaker 2: My guest today is Dr. Cynthia Nebel. Dr. Nebel is the Director of Learning Services and Associate Professor of Psychiatry and Behavioral Neuroscience at St. Louis University of Medicine, and an active collaborator of the Learning Scientists. She has published numerous books and journal articles applying the science of learning to educational and organizational context.
Dr. Nebel has presented the science of learning nationally and internationally, and is dedicated to bridging research and practice to improve educational and organizational outcomes. I think you're really gonna like this one
Dr. Cynthia, welcome to Better Teaching: Only Stuff That Works So excited to be here. Thank you. Oh, you know, it was, it was so, uh... I, I had seen you before. We'd kind of met tangentially at other conferences, but, uh, but St. Louis was really the first time had a chance to, to interact a little bit more. And, uh, I know that you are a cognitive scientist.
Speaker 4: Yep And I wanted to start real basic. Okay? Okay. I want to start real basic because that's one of the things in education. We use a lot of terms that we think the other person knows. Yeah. So just real basic, like tell me, what does a cognitive scientist do? What is the scope? Yeah. And then what exactly is your role within that scope?
Speaker 5: Yeah. So it really actually mar- more interesting of a question than you might realize. Okay. Because within cognitive psychology, we would not consider ourselves cognitive scientists. There's like a, a slight difference there too. Um, so cognitive science is a sort of a broader umbrella term maybe that includes neuroscience and psychology and maybe some philosophy in there.
There's a lot of different things that come under cognitive science, um, all of which looking at the way individuals, um, think and process information. So we've got learning and memory in there, but we've also got attention and problem-solving and critical thinking. So any given cognitive psychologist would be kind of having some sort of expertise in one of those areas.
Probably not all of them, although also probably knows more than the average bear on, on any of them. Right. Right, right. Um, right. So my area of expertise-- So, so I'm a cognitive psychologist. Now, my degree, the program I graduated from was brain behavior and cognition, so I know a little bit more about neuroscience than the average, um, person.
But my degree is really in psychology, which is the study really of, of human cognition and behavior, right? It's the way that we think, but it's all looking at, um, behavioral outputs, um, which, which really means like performance on kinda paper and pencil stuff or, or computer-based stuff. So it's not neuroscience necessarily, which I think the biggest place where people get confused is that if you hear cognitive, people automatically think, "Oh, that's brain science."
And I have said before that, you know, all, all learning is brain learning because you're always using your brain if you're learning. Um, but it doesn't necessarily mean neuroscience, if that makes sense. So instead, um, my sort of niche area of that really is in learning and memory, which is a sort of a subset of cognitive psychology and cognitive science.
Speaker 3: Uh, long time ago I got a degree in, in counseling and, and, and we learned different methodologies and different, uh, beliefs systems- Yeah, yeah ... I guess, with regards to that. And there was a cognitive, cognitive approach- Yep ... and then there was a behavioral approach. Yep. Are those just subsets of, of cognitive psychology, or are they...
Or, because people will make a distinction, "Well, I'm a, I'm a behaviorist. I'm not one of those guys." Yeah. So, um, I would put both of those under the study of human learning, but they're two different traditions to study human learning. So the behavioral tradition is really focused on overt behaviors. So things that we can see, observe, measure, change, um, but is sort of ignoring much of the, uh, internal stuff that's happening.
Speaker 5: Um, and from a, from a true like pure behaviorist standpoint, they would say we have to ignore all of that stuff. That attention and memory and prior experience, none of that particularly matters for like interpretation of the... All that matters is stimulus and response, right? Reward systems and, and those kinds of things.
Um, from a cognitive perspective instead, we're all about the interpretation of that stimulus. That a stimulus comes in, and yes, there's gonna be a response to it, but your response is going to change based on the way that you think about it. So the cognition part turns out to be really, really important.
Now, in today's world, these two things are not usually counter. I don't know that there is a single pure behaviorist out there anymore that would say, "Oh yeah, attention never matters," and vice versa. There's not a cognitive psychologist who wouldn't be paying attention to behavior and reward systems and everything else.
Um, but from the purest sense, it's really just the lens with which you're looking at the world. Am I focused on more of the, the antecedent behavior consequence, or am I focused more on the internal dialogue and, um, how information is being processed as two lenses for how you're interpreting behavior? So you, you work with, uh, you work in two arenas, I'm sure more, but I'm gonna, I'm gonna separate them this way, and that is, you know, with organizations, with organizations outside organizations, organizations within the university, but also you work with individual students.
Speaker 3: Is that correct? Okay. Yeah. So, so let- let's, let's leave the individual students aside for a second because I think- ... that's, that's really interesting. But, uh, this is gonna be interesting too. I don't want people to but, but so, so we talked about these, these two traditions. So when you're working with teachers and we're trying- Yeah
to get teachers involved- Yeah ... I mean, if, if I'm a teacher, I'm thinking, "I gotta get these kids to produce." I'm looking for certain behaviors. Yeah. So, so, so when we're thinking about training teachers or training teachers, getting them familiar with science of learning, uh, which all I'm gonna ask you to define that in a minute.
But if we wanna get them to, you know, to, to, to, you know, like, like, like what do they need to know about this stuff? Uh-huh. And what's kinda nice to know- Yeah ... to get them to, to get the behaviors out of the kids that they're, that they're interested in? Yeah. So I think the, the sort of need to know stuff is, in my opinion anyway, um, what works and why, um, is, is what you need to know.
Speaker 5: So the what works part, that's the, the learning strategies. Whatever the evidence-based, the effective learning strategies. But I think it's im- like critical that teachers know why those things work. Um, I think there's a lot of, you know, people who sell a curriculum, and some of this stuff is baked into that curriculum, yes.
But when we're looking at, you know, Sally's unique classroom on Friday afternoon with these specific learners and this specific material No curriculum can just be handed off and expect to work in the same way all the time. And so in my mind, um, having a basic understanding of why these strategies are effective, like why is retrieval practice a useful strategy for anyone to use?
If you're going to be able to adapt retrieval practice on a Friday afternoon with these students, you have to have an understanding of what really the mechanism is, uh, there. And so when I'm saying the why, I'm saying for retrieval practice, it is the act of bringing information to mind that is resulting in that.
It is not doing a quiz. That's not what retrieval practice-- That's not why it's effective, is because you're asking questions. It's effective only when information is brought to mind. And now Sally can adapt her learning situation to say, "Okay, well, the quiz is getting scrapped 'cause it's Friday afternoon and blah, blah, blah, but I can still get them to bring information to mind."
Or, "It's not about just asking questions 'cause it turns out only one kid is answering it. I need all the kids to answer it," so you can adapt better. What you don't necessarily need to know is how your neurons are changing as you do it. Um, so I find that stuff fascinating, right? I think it's so cool, and it is.
It is really cool. But it's not really-- you don't really need to know any of the neuroscience behind it in order to implement it effectively. So you need to know sort of the mechanisms, but not the, the biology behind th-that. Does that make sense? Okay. Yeah. Yeah, that, that makes a lot of sense. So let's go- Do you agree?
Speaker 3: Pardon me? I said, do you agree? Do I agree? Do, do I agree? You know, uh, I'm very agreeable. We don't need to make this one-sided here, Gene. No, no, we're good. We're, we're good. I-I'll, I'll let you know. I'll let you know. Okay. So, so but I wanna-- before I, I give an opinion, I have an opinion, uh, let's broaden this a little bit 'cause we said we were gonna talk about, well, I did, about just what is science- Yeah -of learning when we think- Yeah -about it.
Um, and I don't want to debate the term. Yeah. Okay? Sci-science of learning, science of this, science of that- Yeah -'cause I have problems with that. But just what's usually included in that, uh, bucket when, when I'm gonna go to a science of learning conference, what sh- what should the sessions, what kind of sessions am I gonna see?
Speaker 5: You want my opinion or you want what normally happens? I wanna... I-I'm talking to Dr. Cindy. I wanna know what you have to say. If I'm scheduling a science of learnings conference, what am I putting in the agenda? Yes. Is that the question? Yeah. That's it. Okay. That's it. Okay. Okay, okay. Yeah, so I think there absolutely are-- of course, there are gonna be talks about, uh, we can call it cognitive psychology as a broad sense, where I, I think there should probably be some basics of what is learning and memory and how does that work from sort of a cognitive-- like, how is information processed?
Um, I think there should be evidence-based strategies based on that. I think there should be more niche topics that are for the individual educators in the room. So, um, for math or literacy or whatever we're talking about. I also think very importantly, there needs to be discussion of when things go awry.
And by that I mean if we're working with individuals who have executive functioning dysfunction, um, or, or we have, um, neurodivergent kiddos, those kinds of situations, learning looks a little bit different in that population, and so there should be a discussion there. Um, what else goes on to the science of learning, though?
Uh, we get a little bit outside, um, what probably is in the core of it, but I think we have to have a conversation about the science of motivation in order to have a conversation about learning. I think it's an integral part of learning and needs to be in there. Um, so we're talking about working memory and long-term memory, and I am so, like, trying to read your face right now and figure out what you're thinking.
Speaker 3: Well, here's-- Well, uh, here, here's, here's what I'm thinking. And, and the, the question is tied to what teachers need to know. Mm-hmm. I mean, because it's so much. I mean, you know. Oh, yeah. Yeah. You, you, you, you know, you know so much. And again, what does, what does a teacher need to know? And I'm glad you went into motivation and, and, you know, neurodiversity and all of these things.
But I remember I I was asked to present to brand-new teachers. It was part of their induction- Oh, yeah ...their first week. And these-- And I was presenting after they had just received two hours of intensive, uh, trauma-informed instruction. And I'm thinking, "Holy cow, I have a master's in counseling. I wouldn't be touching this stuff."
Yeah. And it is so, it is so deep. And, and, and so there are topics that are, uh- Yeah ...important, but I don't know how much you need to know. Yeah. Again, cognitive load for these new teachers, you know? The- Yeah ...you know, I, I-- So, so anyway, getting back to that- Okay ...uh, do they need-- So, so what should they know about motivation?
Uh- Oh, that's a- What do they need to know? What's, what's, what's too much? What's like you're overthinking it type of thing? Yeah. I mean, I think when you're, when you're framing it as what does a beginning teacher, right? Like, what is, what is like the, the heart of what they actually need to know on day one?
Speaker 5: I think, um, I mean, you just said cognitive load for them, right? Because their cognitive- Yeah ...load is so high. But frankly, it's the same thing. You've got novice learners. They probably need to know something about what cognitive load is. I would agree with that. Yeah.
If we're talking about the science of m- motivation, what do, what does a new teacher need to know about motivation? I, I still think that it, it makes sense for them to know the very basics of like self-determination theory. Like that if you've got kiddos who are totally amotivated, then It's not necessarily that you have, like, it, it's not something bad about your class.
Like, I, I wanna separate out the idea of, of engagement and motivation as, like, two separate things that we're talking about here, and I wanna give them the very basics of we need some autonomy for students. We need them to feel like they can achieve, so we need to make sure that the, the level that we're at is appropriate for the students, and they need some form of, of relatedness.
They need to feel like somebody cares whether or not they achieve. And that's it. I really don't wanna go any deeper than that with, with an early teacher, and even that is probably not day one. I'd rather them know that, like, six months in. So, so how, how does my face look now? So here's my- Yeah ... here's my, here's my, here's my question.
Speaker 3: You're like, "You don't like it." No, no, no. It's not that I don't like it. I need clarification, okay? Sure. Because, you know, uh, autonomy, this is one of those- Yes ... you know, we always talk about two things- Oh, yeah, yeah. I was trying to be real simple here, James. Yeah. No, no, no. Yeah, well, teacher autonomy and, and student autonomy, and I re- you know, I understand the importance of autonomy, but, you know, I remember, uh, when, when my daughter was, I don't know, three or four, had to get her dressed for, for preschool.
"Honey, you can wear anything you want. Here are your two choices." You know, so that it's-- I think that's one of the misapprehensions that teachers have when we talk about student choice and student autonomy. Yeah. No, absolutely. It's, it's like it's too much. Yeah. They don't know enough. Yeah. Yeah. No, that's exactly right.
Speaker 5: It's not about like complete freedom here. That's-- When we're saying autonomy, it's, it's not like give them all the autonomy in the world. No. It is-- Uh, all of it is about perception of autonomy within a bounded system, right? So, um, to that point, I... Okay, so I have two kiddos, nine and seven. They both have autism, and they have a subset of autism that's called PDA, pathological demand for-- pathological demand avoidance or persistence.
They, they keep wanting to change it to like persistent demand for autonomy. Basically, like their little bodies go into fight or flight when they- Okay ... feel like they're being forced to do anything. And so, yeah, to your point, literally just this morning, my husband was like, "What are you doing right now?"
And I was like, "I'm getting Annabelle dressed." And he said, "You're holding a lot of clothes." And I said, "Yes. I gave her three options for pants and three options for shirts and said, 'You pick.'" Um, because if I just give her one, we-- there's something wrong with it. But if she feels like she got to choose, now she's okay with that.
And, uh, we do it all day, every day. Um, and it-- I am working with unique kiddos here, right? But at the same time, it's, it's a core part of motivation that I can see lived out every day that no one likes just being told, "You're doing it this way, whether you like it or not," and, um, it-- "and it's this way or the highway.
Like, just suck it up and deal with it." Nobody likes that. The teachers don't like that. They don't want somebody coming into their classroom and telling them exactly what they're hanging on the walls and exactly how everything is structured and exactly what they're teaching today. They want to have some freedom and flexibility, and the students do too, but it's within a bounded system.
So, um, we're not gonna give them full autonomy. The kids don't get to decide what they're doing all day, every day, but they might get, um, uh, I don't know. The autonomy that you can give to kiddos in a classroom might include, um, which book we want to read today, and the class is gonna vote on it. And it's not a huge amount, but it's enough to keep the kids so that they're not disconnecting from the classroom.
That's the idea here. Um, it, it doesn't necessarily need to be a free-for-all, and it shouldn't be. Um- Yeah, no. So, I, I mean, to your point, like, you can't just say autonomy and expect that that now everybody understands what we're talking about. Similarly, you can't say self-advocacy and everybody knows what we're talking about there either, right?
Like, all of it, all of it needs explanation, but- Yes. Yes. Yeah. Yeah. Okay. So let- I also don't know that that's day one for a teacher either. Well- I think they have to be in there for a little bit and see it happening to then understand it a little bit. Well, and I, and I think that is another example. You just gave another example of, uh, they're gonna have students in their class, and they're gonna have this umbrella term of autistic.
Speaker 4: Mm. Yeah. And, and so can you give like, what should they be aware of? What should they look for? What do you, what do you... How might they, uh, adapt something? What, you know- Yeah, Dean- Or is it so individual? God, that-- We-- Yes and no. Um, gosh, you're, you're asking hard questions now. Um- A teacher is also dealing with a lot more than just me saying...
Speaker 5: I can say something here, and it sounds so simplistic and easy to do, but in reality, they're being given legal documents, like an IEP, that they're required to do certain things. Then they're dealing with twenty-five students simultaneously and dealing with behaviors and tiny little emotions and all of it.
Like it's, it's n- none of it is as simple as what we might discuss in this conversation. And I, I wanna make sure that that is like top of mind here, is that I can give some ideas but also- Right ... uh, it's not that simple. Um- Well, I think, I think, I think you need to do that to counterbalance how complex- Exactly
Speaker 3: in a teacher's head it is. Right. You know? Exactly. Exactly. So, so we'll appreciate some more simplistic ideas. Yeah. So because of that, sort of the, the The vast majority of the neurodivergence that we are most commonly seeing in K through 12 education operates on working memory difficulties. Um, and that's where a lot of the, the learning, the attention problems are, are coming from.
Speaker 5: And so for the vast majority of these kids, it is issues of managing cognitive load appropriately. Um, and frankly, many of the learning strategies that we talk about, so retrieval practice, space practice, concrete examples, like these really good learning strategies ultimately operate on working memory.
They reduce the amount of working memory that you need to retrieve information. They build a stronger neural network so that you have more retrieval cues to access information, and you don't have to, uh, work nearly as hard to do that. Um, and so if we're using the really, really effective learning strategies, I mean, there's some nice research showing that those things tend to benefit kiddos with working memory difficulties more than they do the high-achieving kiddos.
So using these things is already kind of providing a little bit of equity in the classroom. You're not hurting anyone, and you're, you're bringing some people up. Do you make any face again? You know, you know-- Well, I'm making a face because Dr. Sarah Oberly is ringing in my ears as you talked about those, those things that teachers can do.
Speaker 3: Yeah. You didn't say executive functions, but those are core executive functions. I didn't, but that is exactly right. Yep. You know. So, so it's, it's simplicity on the other side of complexity- Yeah ... I like to say. There are, there are, there are some things you should do. And I think that's why, uh, we, we, you and I and folks like us, need to take the complexity and make it simple so that-- 'cause they just don't have the, the cognitive space for it.
Speaker 5: Yeah. We, we need- I think it's important to, to make things simple, but also not to simplify them so far that it becomes a prescription either. Right. Um, because then i-it won't work, like I said, in Sally's class on Friday afternoon when everybody had a whole bunch of sugar or something. Like, I-I-- You-- In order for things to be adaptable, uh, they can't be made too simplistic either.
Um- Right ... so there-- I think there's a happy balance there for sure. Oh, okay. Let's, let's move on a-- let's move on a little bit. Okay. Just-- No, j- no, no, no, just because there's so much I want to talk to- with you about. And, uh, one-- Okay, before I talk to-- ask you about your job, which I think is so interesting, uh, the other part of your job is the-- one of the things that, uh, is frustrating to me or t- uh, uh, let's just say frustrating.
Speaker 3: So, uh, you're gonna put on a conference, we're gonna t-talk about retrieval practice. Teachers need to know about retrieval practice. And then I open up, uh, Twitter, and here's Carl, Carl Hendrick saying, "Well, you know, retrieval practice isn't as effective as, as they say it is." Did you read his blog on that?
Speaker 4: No. Okay. Okay. And so, so now I'm thinking, gosh darn it, you know, uh, this is-- no wonder teachers are so frustrated, and they just forget it, you know? Yeah. Yeah. Forget. So anyway, after you read that, I'm interested in, in what, in what you have to say about it. Uh. But we can, we can just, we can just leave that, and then we'll let, um, uh, folks be sure to read that if they haven't.
Speaker 3: Yeah. If they don't, if they don't follow- Now I gotta go look that up, like, right now. Yeah. If they follow, follow Carl. Well, basically, it talks about, and I think the title is something like, uh, The Conditions Under Which They Did the Study Are Not Classroom Conditions. So the effects are not gonna be as great.
Well- But you know-- Yeah. Uh, go. I'm sorry. Go. Okay. So I mean, as far as that goes, like, if you go out there and look at my publications, I have a pub out there that's, like, called something, A Cautionary Note. And it's about the fact that retrieval practice doesn't always work if you're trying to do it not the way that it's designed to be done.
Speaker 5: Um, but I, I don't know that-- I, I'll send it to you, Gene. I'm sure you've probably seen, um, Pooja Agarwal has a beautiful review article out there about retrieval practice in real classrooms and all of the research showing that it, it can be effective in real classrooms. Um, the-- This is true for everything everywhere.
When we are looking at transfer of learning, of learning something in one con-- situation and being able to use it in the other situation, the closer the two situations match, the better it works. And that's true for retrieval practice. If you have identical questions, that's where you get the biggest effect, and it goes down from there.
Speaker 3: Well, let's... Okay, so let's move on because- Okay. Okay. Because, because, you know, uh, one of the things I always take a look at, you know, when I look at a study, I wanna take a look at, okay, let's, let's, let's review the subjects. Yeah. And you know what? I'm gonna stop reading as soon as I see that it's medical students.
You know, it's just... But that's who you work with. It's true. So t- tell us about your work dealing, dealing with, you know, working with, uh, medical students in medical school. Yeah. It's so interesting. Like, I kind of fell into this, if I'm really honest, and I love every minute of it. Um, so I am the director of learning services, which means that I, um, kind of am in charge of designing all the supplemental academic stuff.
Speaker 5: So students go to their core curriculum classes, their anatomy and physiology and cardiology courses, for which I know nothing about, and then I, um, put together, uh, our peer tutoring program. Um, I do workshops with the students. Specifically, they take a course with me about basically how to study, um, along with lots of other things.
Um, and you would think- Yeah ... these are, these are medical students. I know. That is so, that is so funny. Yeah. That is so funny. These are, these are the top of the top students. Yes. These students- Okay, and now we can teach them... Okay, go ahead. Yeah, they're... No, they're so stinking smart that they've never had to study a day in their lives really before they get here.
Um, so in, in... A- I mean, it's almost like I have to do a whole bunch of unlearning with them first because they show up with the worst habits of any students I've ever met. They have crammed their way through everything and gotten away with it. And now, um, medical school is, is just a fire hose of information.
It is a ridiculous... You know how long they have to learn all of cardiology? Three weeks. They have three weeks to learn all of it. Um, it, it's also like a lesson in, in, I mean, curricular programming here. They, they do one class at a time, and each class is three weeks long. And it's, I mean, massing, to say the least But it's fine.
I digress. Um, so the students, they show up, and they really ha-- they have no concept of how, how to do all of this and to do it in a way that is durable. Because the thing is that when, at least at, at my university, they get information in their first week of medical school that they will be tested on, um, eighteen months later on their first board exam, and then eighteen months after that on their second board exam.
And so they need to remember this stuff. It's not just about the exam that they have in class, which is all they've ever thought about up until they get here. It's now also about remembering it for a year, two years, God willing, for their careers. Um, and, uh, they really struggle with it. And what's really interesting too, and what I love about working with these students is that, yes, so much of what I do is about study strategies, but so much of what I do is also about test-taking strategies and well-being.
And, um, I have never in my life recognized how strong of an interaction we have between learning and well-being. Um, so my kiddos that are-- my kiddos, they're medical students, but they'll always be kiddos to me. It's fine. Um, you know, if they're super anxious, if they're burned out, if they have, you know, a grandma that dies the same week that they have a breakup with a significant other, they fail their exams.
Like, performance and well-being are so closely linked and, and being able to-- the-- all of their exams here are like clinical reasoning exams, so they're told a story about a patient, and then they need to diagnose the patient and figure out a treatment and all these things. Um, that kind of like huge working memory load associated with these exams is really, really impacted by all these external things.
I think that's been the biggest sort of eye-opener for me. Otherwise, they look the same as the first graders. They really do. I mean, we're talking about prior knowledge, and we're talking about scaffolding and, um, uh- We're talking about building expertise and expertise reversal, so like what works best for them when they first start in a module and what works at the end.
I mean, it looks so similar to what we would be doing in K through 12 education, except for all the extra stuff. Although all the extra stuff matters in K through 12 education, too. I just feel like I've never paid attention to it before. Well, that's-- Uh, okay. It makes me wonder, again, because that's what you do.
Speaker 3: You have all of these things that you just described that you learned from these folks- Yeah ... in addition to, you know, some, some, uh, uh, ancillary things that, that cause these problems. Uh, and then you're gonna go talk to first grade teachers. So w- can you-- Is there a way to say which informed more? The working with the first graders and then, and then working with these guys or, or is that a silly question?
Speaker 5: I don't know if it's a silly question. It's an interesting question I mean, mm, I think, I think what it comes down to, honestly, is had I, had I been a K through 12 teacher, which I, I haven't, I haven't been in a K through 12 classroom, um, I probably would've come to the exact same conclusions working one-on-one with students.
Um, as an, as a higher education instructor, I haven't spent a whole lot of time sort of on like the one-on-one tutoring kind of programming that I do here, where I-- most of my time is spent meeting one-on-one with students. Most of my time is spent that way. And I meet with a student, and we talk about a new way for them to study over the course of the next week, and they go and they try it out, and then they come meet with me again, and we talk about how it went and what we need to tweak.
And I have just never had that, like, very immediate feedback on how the strategies I'm talking about are working in real time. And, um, it makes me realize how much more we need to do that with educators too, that, oh, yeah, it's really great for me to do this one and done PD session at a conference on a Saturday afternoon.
But I tell them this stuff, and I send them out in the world, and I don't get that feedback of what worked and what didn't and why. And, um, really, I think if we're gonna move, move the needle at all for education in the US, that's what's needed. Because I don't know, did they try it? If they did try it, did it work at all?
Does it need to be tweaked? Or do I need to just completely change the way that I'm talking to them to begin with? I don't know. Yeah. Interesting. Uh, all interesting issues. Well, I want to, uh, uh, I wanna give you a little test here. You ready? Oh, oh, no, I'm not. You ready? I'm terrified. Okay. No, this the, this is the test, and, and then there's a follow-up question after.
Speaker 3: You ready? No. Here's, here's what I'm gonna do. Here's what I'm gonna do, and you know what a great singer I am. Oh, I do. I'm gonna sing a line, and you're gonna, and you're gonna complete the lyric. Oh. You ready? Okay. We'll try it. You ready? Sweet Caroline Bum, bum, bum Okay, one for one Well, shake it up, baby.
Shake it up, baby Shake it up, baby. Twist and shout You're two for two. And then I saw her face Now I'm a believer Okay. Build me up Build me up, buttercup. Don't break my heart Okay. La- Last one. Last one. Last one. You're four for four Hey, Jude, don't make it- Bad Okay. Five for five Make a sad... So yeah. Okay.
Here's what he-- okay, let me tell you. Let me tell you what- Well, that's fine ... okay, what years. Let me, let me tell you what years. Those are '60s, the 1960s, okay? Ah. And so I wanted to give you a test on those because, uh, the... I saw a person in a karaoke bar not too long ago And they sang a song from 1967- Yeah
that everybody knew. Yeah. Then there was a song from 1970s everybody knew. I'm guessing 1960s is before you were born. It, it was, yep. Okay. So, so two questions, two questions. Uh, one, w- why do we know that? And what's the difference between spaced repetition and spaced retrieval? Hmm. So I'm gonna be honest, I was a little nervous about this because it was going to require spaced retrieval instead of just spaced repetition.
Speaker 5: Aha. Um, so I'll-- okay. Um, so why does this happen? Why does this happen? So it probably is a lot to do with spaced repetition. I've heard those songs many, many times before, not just once. Um, and so, um, every time we hear them, there's reactivation of, of that information. Um, music, in particular, for what it's worth, is processed in a completely different area of the brain than, than other information is.
Um, so there's that. Um, and the difference between spaced retrieval and spaced repetition is whether or not I'm listening to the song versus needing to actually retrieve the information. And increased spaced repetition is probably gonna increase better spaced retrieval as well. Um, spaced retrieval is gonna be a little bit more challenging.
So if you've ever had a song that's, like, played on the radio over and over and over again, and suddenly you are like, "I wanna learn that song. That's a good song. I'm gonna sing that song," and you start to sing it, and you're like, "I don't know the words to this song." You're just... You know, you're, like, just singing vowels or whatever.
Speaker 4: Yeah. Um, and you realize, "Oh, okay, I need to, like, actually practice that." Well, what do you do to practice it? You don't just sit there and listen to the song over and over again. You turn the song off, and you try to retrieve it, right? You try to retrieve those lyrics. And that's a little bit more of a, like, deliberate practice, right, that's happening there.
Speaker 5: Yeah. Um, but it also leads to much more durable learning, potentially. So if we take a look at Ebbinghaus's learning curve- Yeah ... and I know it's not, I know it's not exact, but, um- And we-- Should the teacher be doing both spaced retrieval and a spaced repetition? So I think if you're doing spaced retrieval, you're automatically doing spaced...
So, so I think there's two effects. There's the spacing, and then there's the retrieval. So if you're doing spaced retrieval, you're getting repetition, you're getting the spaced repet-- you're getting the spaced part of it already. Um, but with the spaced retrieval, you're getting, like, another additional bonus.
So in the best case scenario, you would be doing spaced retrieval with feedback, right? So without the feedback, the spaced retrieval is not going to be as effective 'cause they need-- then you're not getting the repetition part of it, right? 'Cause if they don't- Okay ... successfully retrieve, then they haven't done the repetition.
Does that make sense? So the re-- Yeah, so the retrieval- Well, the retrieval is an important part because I, you know, I've heard people say, "Well, oh, look at the curve. I'm gonna put this in my calendar. I'm gonna calendar this to review it." Yeah. Well, you-- that review, a big part of that review should be the retrieval.
Yeah, absolutely. And the, and the... Yeah, yeah. Yeah. I mean- Yeah. I mean, I think it, it separate, not necessarily, um, equal here. It good to do spaced repetition, right? That's great. If they wanna review it at some point, that's fine. But better if you can do retrieval first, or at least enough retrieval to activate some, like, surrounding information.
Um, it's one of the things I deal with. We'll take that med school example here for, like, the cardiology. We want students to be doing retrieval, right? But if they have taken that class six months ago, and they can retrieve nothing from the class, then having them jump trying to do retrieval practice is a waste of time.
They can't retrieve anything. There's nothing there. So we have them do a little bit of spaced repetition first, and then start doing spaced retrieval from there. Um, so, I, I mean, it depends on how far out it is, but the retrieval is only beneficial to the degree that you are retrieving enough surrounding information so there's some, some Velcro to stick to when you get the actual answer.
Speaker 3: Okay, and that's your dumbing down of the nerd explanation of the neurons. Yeah. Right? Okay. I, I could've, I could've made that much nerdier- Yeah, yeah ... if you want to Yeah. No, we're good, we're good, we're good, we're good. Well, it's, it's, it's interesting, you know. So we're talking about memory. We're talking about, you know, you talked about, um, uh, you just gave the example again of the cardiology.
I gave the example of, of song lyrics. Is this-- Are we gonna need to remember this stuff with AI? Or what, what's your thoughts about AI? Oh, I have a lot of thoughts about AI, Gene. I have a lot of thoughts. Um, so- The deal with learning and AI and where it's a problem and where it's not is, is essentially like what you just said.
Speaker 5: Is this something you ever want to be able to, to like use and remember later on, yes or no? And, um, if A-- the, the little like very, very dumbed-down way that I've said this is, is if AI is doing the thinking, then AI is doing the learning, right? And so there are lots and lots of things in our lives that we don't need to know how to do.
I, I do not need to learn how to, I don't know, do a formula in Excel that is something I'll never use again. Totally fine for me to go to AI and say, "Tell me how to do this." But if it's something that I want to be able to do, then it would make sense for me to be fast at doing it, or it would make sense for me to be able to reason through it.
I'm not gonna be able to do that if I constantly rely on AI. So in particular, um, I am thinking about times where we need some sort of expertise. So if we kinda go to the literature to think about this. If, um, if we think about, uh, chess, uh, there's a classic chess study showing that, um, people who are novices at chess, if you give them a chessboard and you ask them to try to remember the pieces on the chessboard, they can remember, what is it?
Seven plus or minus two pieces, right? That's, that's working memory. You ask an expert to do the exact same thing. They've played chess a hundred times. You give them the exact same chessboard. Now they can recall something like sixteen pieces very easily. And it's because they're processing it fundamentally differently, qualitatively differently.
They see that and they go, "Ah, yes, The Queen's Gambit," which covers everything I know about chess. Um- And that comes from their experience doing it. Had every time they played chess, they went to AI and said, "What move should I do next?" They would not get any better than the novices because they- they're not learning.
They're having AI do the learning for them. If we think about this in terms of medical school, in ter- in terms of my students, if in a surgical situation, they're constantly going to AI and saying, "What should I do next? What's, what's the best thing?" Now, if there's an emergency situation where they need to think on their feet or a really complex case that they need to be able to reason through, if they don't have that expertise in their brains, if they don't have that, that understanding of the information, then they can't reason through it.
They don't have an entire chessboard that they're working with. They're working with individual pieces. Um, so it, it, it depends on how... what we want individuals to be able to do with information. If we want people to be able to reason, problem solve, think, use information, it needs to be acquired first. It has to be in their brains because they can think about it qualitatively differently than if they only have the bits and pieces and facts that they get from looking something up from AI.
Does that make sense? It makes a lot of sense. I mean, and, and I think it's like, uh, you don't get to use it until you know it. You don't get to use it for, for something. 'Cause I can imagine like, uh, like surgery, you know, being there'd be some sort of, you know, AI programming, but either that programming had to have been done first based on the particulars that the surgeon saw, or every move would have to be checked by the- Exactly
Speaker 3: surgeon at, at the time. Yeah. At, at the time. Yeah. Oh, Cindy, it is always so fun talking to you. You have any questions for me before we go? I do. I have a question for you. Um, what's my question for you? My question for you So you've been, you've been at this for, for a minute. Um, I-- So I talk to teachers a lot, just like you do, and, um- I have a few issues that come up, um, over and over again in those conversations.
Speaker 5: And those issues are, um, multi. So you asked me for one question. I might have a couple questions. Yeah, I'm sure you will. Yeah. Um, okay. So, so the first is it, it makes perfect sense. So for a lot of our learning strategies, so for things like massing, for things like, um, you know, instead of interleaving, blocking instead of interleaving, we get this really a nice initial performance boost.
The interleaving one I really like. There's a really cool study showing exactly this, that you've got students in the classroom, they're blocking things, they're performing to mastery, which is all the hot new thing, talking about mastery-based learning. Well, it looks like they're at mastery and, and the administrator's coming in and he's seeing your students are performing well on absolutely everything.
That looks and it feels good to you, to your students, to the administrators. But students are not going to remember that. They're not gonna remember it a week later because it was blocked instead of being interleaved. If it was interleaved, they never get to mastery on that day, but they, they remember much more of it later on.
It is a really, really difficult thing for any human to recognize sort of the long-term consequences of a behavior today. It's why exercise programs are so hard, right? To see the long-term benefits of a decision you make today is really hard. So when you're talking to educators, how, how do you make that, that connection happen?
In a realistic classroom, how do we get educators to see those long-term consequences of good behaviors today? Well, you know, we criticize a lot of people who critique education, who are not in education, but they went to school once, okay? They went to school once, and so now they're experts. Now, teachers are a little bit different because they have two perspectives.
Speaker 3: They have their N of one, their experience, and when you describe to a teacher what you just described, they realize that that happened to them, even if they didn't go to medical school. They realize that, you know, uh, yeah, it was, it was hard to do this. And if you give them an alternative with some explanation, I think they're willing to try it.
Now, uh, and when I work with teachers, that's all I'm hoping for, is try it. I say, "Think of yourself like a scientist," you know? Mm-hmm. Uh, especially if they're teaching science or they're, you know. Just, just try it. See, see how this works. Uh, and then we'll come back, and we'll talk about it. The, the optimal is be that we would say try it, and then we'd have a coach in the, in the classroom to talk about to be sure that they did it, uh, you know, effectively.
But teachers understand that some of the things that they're doing don't work as well as they're supposed to. Mm. And that, and, and, and, uh, it's no s- it's no surprise to them to get them to do that. One of the things that, uh... I mean, we were-- We didn't realize we were doing science of learning in two thousand three, but we were, you know.
Yeah. I mean- Because, because the research, the research precedes two- two thousand three. Yeah, it absolutely does. Yeah. Uh, but we never said, you know, uh, "This is the, this is the research, and this is why you have to do it, and this is what the study says," you know. Again, because they've been hearing that their, their entire, their entire career.
So I, I, I think most times it's not good that there's an N of one, but some of the stuff is so common that they, that they realize, "Yeah, that's how it was for me." You know, and how can I, how can I, how can I do this differently? The other thing is, uh, the big thing is to get them to try something different Uh, so that they could see the kids' success because there's-- You know how, you know, you're in a class, and you're teaching, and you could just see it on the kids' classroom.
You can see it on their faces when they get it. It's the same thing with the teachers when you're watching them, and their kids are getting something that they had never understood before. So, so that type of feedback for the teacher is, is, uh, uh, really, um, uh, really, really important. Yeah. You know, stuff has, stuff has to work.
I, I, I kind of, um, uh, equate it to, you know, you, you talked about fitness and, and, uh, uh, you know, it's hard. You know, so many-- I know so many coaches, uh, when I'm talking to them, I said, "We want them, the coaches, we want the teachers to be perfect." Well, not perfect. We want the teachers to improve. We want them to do this, uh, just like going to the gym, you want to improve.
But my analogy is, I'm not worried about their technique on their, uh, on their exercises. I just wanna get them to the gym, you know? Yeah. Let's get them and, and try it. Let's, let's get them trying it because if what we're doing is good, if what we're saying is good, if what we're saying works when they try it, then they have evidence.
It's not- Yeah ... it, it, it's not some researcher that said it, so. They don't have to trust me. They can, they can trust themselves. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. I like that. Um- I mentioned it earlier today. I talked about expertise reversal, right? This idea that, um, direct instruction tends to work most effectively and efficiently for novices.
Speaker 5: That's where also we have that spaced repetition. If you still-- if you don't have enough of the information, you need direct instruction again. And then more of the problem-based learning inquiry, that kind of thing, works best to deepen that knowledge once you have that. But there's, there's a whole lot that goes in between those, and I call that the art of teaching.
Um, because it's, it's, it's complicated stuff. Um, but we need students to be at a certain level of mastery before we remove the scaffolds, before we say, "Okay, now we're gonna do something with this information." And I've had a teacher blatantly look at me and say, "How do I know when they're ready for that?"
And, um, I didn't have a great answer. I think I said something along the lines of, "Well, I think that's your job." Um, like, terrible answer. Um, like, that's, that's why I'm not, I'm not in the classroom, right? Uh, that's why I trust you to, to, to-- th- it's a, this is a partnership. But, um, what would you say? Well, uh- What's your better answer?
Speaker 3: Well, I don't-- The better answer, I think, is what, what, uh, I've been doing for over twenty years, and that is explicit instruction, both design and delivery. And I'm gonna tell you, uh, I still don't know when somebody says, "Well, so what do you do?" "Well, I work with teachers." "Well, what do you do?" "Well, I, you know, show them how to teach better."
"Well, what does that mean?" For some reason, the biggest deficit in, in the teacher training program that, that we have seen is, uh, design and delivery of lessons. Yeah. You know, uh, there is-- I tell teachers, you know, uh, "Have you ever had a lesson that was so great and everybody got it?" "Yeah." "Have you ever had one that just bombed?"
Said, "Yeah." "Well, you're not a good teacher one day and a bad teacher the next. It's the design of the lesson." Yep. And, and, you know, I, I tell all my coaches, "Do not do, uh, sample lessons. Do not do, you know, lessons for folks." Wow. And, uh, that, that's one of my rules. And, and I had a principal once, uh, junior high, he said, "You know what?
Teachers are not gonna buy this unless they see you do it." Which means they're testing me. That's all it was. They wanted to test me. "Can you do this?" And I said, "I don't do that." I mean, and he just, you know, "We're not gonna be able to do this unless-- Okay, I'll teach the lesson. Here's what's gonna happen, though."
Uh, you're gonna be in the room, principal, because I don't know these kids. I don't know what their classroom procedures were, and I wanna be sure that I can just teach the lesson. So I taught the lesson, and my evaluation of it was it was okay. I mean, I always tell teachers the lesson was okay if the kids could do it.
If the kids could do it, it was a success. But with regards to, uh, maybe I d- I could have explained this better, all of that, it wasn't, it wasn't, uh, my best. But after, here's what I got from the teachers. "Oh, well, sure they could do that one. That's an easy lesson." And I'm thinking, "They're all easy if you design it well," you know?
It's, you know. And so that's the thing that we have noticed. It's just, uh, the design. And so this whole scripting and DI thing now we're, you know, with, with sold a story. It is, um, uh, every teacher's script. And I... You know, if, if you've, if you, uh, if you work with a veteran teacher, if you go in and, and talk to a veteran teacher who's taught history And you ask him, uh, and you ask the students, "Where-- Did he tell the joke this year?
Did he tell the joke?" They, you know, they have a script. Yeah. You know? But they don't want another script. But that scripting is, to me, is just pre-thought, you know, pre-planning. How am I gonna say this? What's the best way am I gonna say this, taking into consideration cognitive load? I don't want to say it twice differently.
So, uh, uh, lesson, lesson design and then all the delivery components that come from science of learning, you know, can hang in, in the, in the lesson design. But you know what? You can't tell a teacher that. They-- When they-- But they, when they experience it, then they get it. Yeah. Yeah. But you can't say, uh, you know, "That, that's-- I know you've been doing it that way, but it's not very good."
Speaker 5: Yeah. Yeah. You can't, you can't say those words. Yeah. Yeah. Yeah. Well, well- I have a, I have a whole thing about, like, learning styles, but you don't talk to teachers about learning styles by saying what you've believed your entire life is wrong. Like, that's not, that's not how you get people on board with anything.
Speaker 3: Y- I mean, and that, and that, and that's hard, and I think that's why, um, that's why I am upset with a lot of consultants, is because they try to, um, soften the language. L- And, and, and one of the ones that, that gets me as a person who trains coaches is that, "Well, don't look at what the teacher does. Look at the results of the students."
Well, guess what? If the students didn't learn, who's gonna change what they do? Right. So you're just, you're just pretending that, "Okay, I'm not watching you, teacher. I'm watching the students." Of course it's... They're, they're related. Yeah. Yeah. So, so it is, it's, it's design, and you don't have to design all your lessons, but you have to understand what is good design.
Mm-hmm. So when you get an AI-generated lesson, you don't get to use it until you know it. You know? That's exactly right. That's exactly right. So you, you get that, or you get something in your, uh, in a, in a text that was adopted. Yep. Usually those aren't very good either for the reason- No, they're not ... that use it at the very beginning.
They don't know who's in your class. Right. They don't know how that, that's gonna work. So- That's right ... so anyway. So, uh, uh, although I might try, uh... That's your job. I might try that.
Speaker 4: I'll answer. So I was like, "Huh, how do we know when they're at a level of mastery? I don't know. Do it." Oh, God. Sydney, it has most been a joy and a great singing with you again. Yeah, absolutely. And- Let's do it again ... abso- Okay. You got it. All right. Thanks again. Bye. Bye-bye.
Speaker 6: If you're enjoying these podcasts, tell a friend. Also, please leave a five-star rating on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you listen. You can follow me on BlueSky @gtavarnetti, on Twitter/X @gtavarnetti, and you can learn more about me and the work I do at my website, tesscg.com. That's T-E-S-S-C-G.com, where you will also find information about ordering my books, Teach Fast: Focused, Adaptable, Structured Teaching and Maximizing the Impact of Coaching Cycles