The Forward Thinking Dental Podcast
SEO METADATA
SEO TITLE:
Rotary vs Reciprocating Files Part 2 with Dr Samuel Johnson | PDP271
META DESCRIPTION:
Dr Samuel Johnson on glide paths, D-Finders, GP removal, rotary vs reciprocating, and why your file system matters less than your technique.
URL SLUG:
rotary-vs-reciprocating-files-part-2-samuel-johnson
PRIMARY TOPIC:
Choosing and using rotary and reciprocating endodontic files
SECONDARY SEARCH TOPICS:
- Glide path files in endodontics
- D-Finders and in-between file sizes
- Gutta-percha removal in root canal retreatment
- HyFlex vs WaveOne Gold vs Reciproc
- Cleaning the pulp chamber after obturation
- Avoiding ledges in curved canals
- Saying "I don't know" to patients
- Choosing a file system as a new dentist
ROTARY VS RECIPROCATING FILES PART 2 WITH DR SAMUEL JOHNSON
THE PROTRUSIVE DENTAL PODCAST, EPISODE PDP271
HOST: DR JAZ GULATI
GUEST: DR SAMUEL JOHNSON
EPISODE SUMMARY
In part two of the Endo Showdown on the Protrusive Dental Podcast, Dr Jaz Gulati continues his conversation with Dr Samuel Johnson about rotary versus reciprocating files. Sam shares his everyday endo protocol: glide path files, D-Finders, size eight files and in-between sizes, and why he never uses Gates Gliddens.
He explains a hand-held trick for getting a rotary file to length, why he sticks with HyFlex as his "comfort blanket", and which system he'd recommend to a newly qualified dentist. He covers his approach to gutta-percha removal, the risk of extrusion with mechanical files, and why taper and a glide path matter more than rotary versus reciprocating. Sam and Jaz also discuss embracing "it depends" in dentistry, saying "I don't know" to patients, and how patients come to reflect their dentist. Community questions cover Reciproc versus WaveOne, using rotary files in reciprocation, curved canals and skipping the glide path. Jaz's Protrusive Dental Pearl is to cut the GP at the orifice and clean the pulp chamber properly.
IN SHORT
This episode concludes that rotary versus reciprocating is a low priority in successful endo. Dr Samuel Johnson's message is to use a glide path every time, open the coronal to mid third first, choose a file system you like and stick with it, and be honest with patients about what you can and can't do.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
- Jaz's pearl: cut the GP at the orifice, and clean resin sealer from the pulp chamber with isopropyl alcohol before bonding.
- Sam uses a glide path file on every case, and says it shaves time off a lower endo.
- He avoids Gates Gliddens, finding them too aggressive, and preserves pericervical dentine.
- If a canal won't negotiate, open the coronal to mid third, drop to a size eight, and use in-between sizes like 12.5.
- A stuck rotary file can be taken to length by hand, then the motor head placed over it.
- Sam uses Hedström files first for GP removal, then a rotary file, and solvent only late on.
- He sees taper and a glide path as more important than rotary versus reciprocating.
- Choose a file system, stick with it, practise on extracted teeth, and don't be afraid to refer.
QUESTIONS ANSWERED IN THIS EPISODE
1. How do you clean the pulp chamber after cutting the GP?
2. What is Dr Samuel Johnson's endo shaping protocol?
3. Should you use Gates Glidden drills?
4. What should you do if you can't get a file to length?
5. Is rotary or reciprocating better?
6. What is the best way to remove gutta-percha in a retreatment?
7. Can you use a rotary file in reciprocating mode?
8. Can you skip the glide path with Reciproc Blue?
IN THIS EPISODE
1. Introduction: the Endo Showdown, part two
2. Protrusive Dental Pearl: cut the GP at the orifice, and clean the pulp chamber properly
3. Sam's protocol: glide path files, pre-bending and no Gates Gliddens
4. Getting to length: D-Finders, size eight files and in-between sizes
5. The hand-held rotary file trick
6. Rotary or reciprocating: is there a winner?
7. A word from our partner: the Qudent Endo Radar Pro
8. Files for retreatment, and the risk of extrusion
9. Why your file system matters less than you think, and embracing "it depends"
10. Saying "I don't know", consent, and the patients you attract
11. Community questions: Reciproc vs WaveOne, GP removal, curved canals and skipping the glide path
12. Where to find Dr Samuel Johnson
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION: THE ENDO SHOWDOWN, PART TWO
JAZ:
Hello, Protruserati. I'm Jaz Gulati, and welcome back to part two with Dr Samuel Johnson. This is the Endo Showdown: rotary versus reciprocating. We covered a lot of ground in part one, but now we go for the kill. Dr Samuel Johnson reveals which is the best system, and, more importantly, which system he uses and trusts most. We also answer a ton of the questions you submitted on the Protrusive Guidance app.
For example: is there any use for NiTi K-files, or are stainless steel files absolutely fine? Is there ever an indication for NiTi K-files? What's Dr Samuel Johnson's preferred file for removing gutta-percha? What hacks and tips does he have for us? Can you use a file designed for rotation in a reciprocating way?
And is it true that certain brands of reciprocating file can bypass the glide path file? We answer all of these and much more in part two. If you haven't checked out part one yet, do, so you get the complete story. We'll put the link below.
CHAPTER 2: PROTRUSIVE DENTAL PEARL: CUT THE GP AT THE ORIFICE, AND CLEAN THE PULP CHAMBER PROPERLY
JAZ:
Every PDP episode, we give you a Protrusive Dental Pearl, usually something you can apply in your practice, though sometimes it's non-clinical and mindset-based. I've got a double whammy for you. Number one: when you're obturating, please cut the GP at the level of the orifice. I remember re-treating some failed root canals where, yes, it made my job of retrieving the GP easier, but why was the GP so coronal?
It was almost up to the enamel, with so much sealer around it. That just promotes leakage. That space is reserved for your coronal seal, your restorative material. So don't forget to cut the GP at the level of the orifice. The problem is that once you've cut the GP, you have a really messy pulp chamber.
And if you want to restore it, create your coronal seal and bond to the pulp chamber, you want a nice, clean pulp chamber. So how do you get one when sealer is smeared everywhere? If you're using something like AH Plus, a resin-based sealer, use a microbrush or a small cotton pellet soaked in isopropyl alcohol.
Water and ultrasonics won't do it. You need isopropyl alcohol to clean that pulp chamber. Just give it a good wipe, and you'll see it instantly get clean, shiny and glossy, and then you can proceed with your bonding. If you're using a bioceramic sealer, it's even easier.
You just use a little water. Scrub the water in, and it'll clean off your bioceramic sealer. That's the beauty of bioceramic sealers. If you're using a zinc oxide eugenol-based sealer, like Tubli-Seal, a bit of air abrasion and ultrasonics is usually okay. I've read that you should use eucalyptus oil, but I worry about using that, so I stick to the ultrasonic scaler, a good wash, and air abrasion.
I hope that covers most bases. Now let's join part two with Dr Samuel Johnson. Catch you in the outro.
CHAPTER 3: SAM'S PROTOCOL: GLIDE PATH FILES, PRE-BENDING AND NO GATES GLIDDENS
DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
I get asked a lot about my protocol, and it's pretty boring. It's pretty much a size 15 glide path file. If you're not using glide path files, use them. I think they shave about 30 minutes off a lower endo, because I always get a glide path.
JAZ:
Is this a specific glide path file, or one that comes with the HyFlex system?
DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
It comes with HyFlex. Although I sometimes use a Tooth Saver file, because with the HyFlex glide path file, they don't say what phase the file is in. Is it more austenitic, or more martensitic?
Meaning: is it more springy, or more soft? I think it's more towards the austenitic phase. It wants to straighten up more than a normal HyFlex rotary file, which you can bend at the end and it keeps that shape. Those are great, because, especially with MB canals or MB orifices in an upper six, getting the file tucked in can be really difficult, especially if the patient isn't opening very wide.
So if you can just bend the file and tuck it in, that's really beneficial. A lot of the time, if I'm struggling to get to length on a canal, I can get to zero with my hand file, but I have to put a little bend at the end, 'cause there's some kind of very microscopic ledge.
I believe the HyFlex rotary glide path file is a 15/04 or a 15/03. By 15/04, I mean it's ISO 15 at the tip, with either a 4% or 3% taper. I've noticed these HyFlex files want to straighten up. So I use a Tooth Saver file, which still wants to straighten up, but I can bend it ever so slightly, so I can tuck it right down into the canal.
JAZ:
Just for new grads and those new to endo and glide paths, and we could do a whole episode on glide paths: to make it clear, in the vast majority of cases, you make your access cavity, ultrasonic away some of the roof of the pulp chamber, and get the... You don't use Gates Gliddens, right? Am I right?
DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
Never. I just think they're too aggressive. I remember using them when I was newly qualified, and I felt I ledged really far up, in the coronal third of the canal. Now, with what I know now, I think a ledge in the coronal third is really easy to deal with. But as a newly qualified dentist, I remember putting the hand file in and thinking, "This has stopped now."
And I'd think, "I have no idea why this is happening." Occasionally I'll use long-neck, gooseneck rose-head burs. But remember, I'm using magnification, a microscope, so I can look really, really closely. It's all about straight-line access. The straighter you are within a canal, the easier it is to shape, because of that file-gripping effect.
Usually, when you're not reaching length, the tip isn't what's getting stuck. The canal is holding onto the file, which is why you can't get there. It's a concept that doesn't quite make sense until you understand that if you're not negotiating down the canal, all you need to do is open up the canal space.
And this goes back to the glide path file. Rather than doing any coronal flaring with a Gates Glidden, I just get a hand file down there, a size 10 or a size eight. A lot of the time now, I'm starting with a size eight rather than a 10. Make sure you've got patency.
Not all the way, maybe through the coronal to mid third, and then I get my glide path file down there. That opens up the canal in the coronal to mid third and at the orifice, but it doesn't open it up so much that you destroy the pericervical dentine, because you need to preserve that, or you'll weaken the tooth.
That was a massive buzzword about four years ago, and I think there's a lot of truth in it, but, and I'm saying a very controversial thing here, I don't know to what degree it really matters. I mention it because it ties into another concept with files: taper.
By taper, I mean how thick the file is. There was a big hoo-ha a few years ago about using super-small tapered files, and I just find it difficult to obturate and clean with those types of files. But if you want to go down that route, one of the benefits of rotary is the wider customisation.
There's a wider array of rotary files with different tapers. So if you want to open up the canal orifice nice and wide, you've got big, fat tapers, and if you want to do tiny little preps, you've got rotary for that too. And I think the main benefit of rotary files is simply their strong track record. They've been used for many, many years.
CHAPTER 4: GETTING TO LENGTH: D-FINDERS, SIZE EIGHT FILES AND IN-BETWEEN SIZES
JAZ:
The reason I ask is that you said you use the 08 file and then go pretty much straight to the glide path file. Are there any scenarios, maybe particularly sclerosed canals, where you'd be shy of using the glide path file until you'd opened up to at least a 15?
DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
You make a really good point. My protocol is to try to get to length with a size 10, opening up the coronal to mid third first. I'm saying this out loud to everybody: I now exclusively use D-Finders. I very rarely get K-files out. In fact, when I ask my nurse to get a K-file out, she says, "A K-file?"
I don't know if I can move this to show you, but these are all my different hand files, in these tiny little boxes here, and when she has to get the K-files out, she's always quite shocked. I don't want to get too bogged down in why I use D-Finders rather than K-files.
Essentially, it's that gripping effect we were talking about. A K-file has cutting flutes all the way up the shank. D-Finders are essentially a smoother file, so they're more likely to slip to length. As long as the canal is patent and open, I'm onto a winner.
However, if I'm struggling to get down the canal with a size 10, I drop down to an eight. If I'm struggling with an eight, I very, very rarely get a size six out. I have been known to, and I used a size six today, but I feel size sixes are too fragile.
Sometimes you try to negotiate with a size six, and when you put any pressure on it to get down to the end of the tooth, because it's so fragile, it's more likely to bend than push forward. So you might find a size eight is actually a bit stiffer and better for getting down there.
So say I've got a canal where a size 10 doesn't negotiate, and I've opened up the coronal to mid third, so it isn't gripping. I'll then-
JAZ:
Again, the coronal to mid third was opened with your glide path file?
DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
Yes.
JAZ:
The rotary one.
DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
So I'll get a size eight and reach length with that. At that point, I won't pick up the glide path file straight away. I'll try to open up the space with a size 10.
JAZ:
A D-Finder?
DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
A D-Finder, yeah. If I then successfully get to length with a size 10, I'll pick up the glide path file, the rotary 15/03.
JAZ:
So that's the second time you're picking it up, because the first time was when you did the coronal to mid third.
DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
Well, what I'd say is that if I can't get to length with a 10 and I'm struggling with an eight, I've been known to pick up my shaping file, the size 25 HyFlex I usually finish with, and use that to open up the coronal to mid third.
I really open it up, because you'll be using that file anyway, so you're not taking away any more dentine than you need to. So I've got to length with an eight, then with a 10, and then I pick up my glide path file.
The whole point of the glide path file is that you want it to take itself to the apex. You don't want to push on it, because these files are so thin they'll break. And if you have to push really hard with a glide path file, the canal probably isn't wide enough for it.
This is one of your questions. One of the great things about D-Finders is that there's a 12.5 diameter. Have you ever seen in-between file diameters? One thing that's not so obvious to general dentists is that they find it difficult to go from a size 10 to a size 15.
You imagine files going up in nice, even sequences. But going from a size 10 to a 15 is a 50% increase in size. So if I'm struggling, a lot of the time I'll get a size 12, or 12.5, which sits in between the 10 and the 15.
JAZ:
What colour is the in-between size? Do they even have an ISO colour for it? Has it got stripes on it?
DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
Let me show you. They're light purple.
JAZ:
Oh, I've seen those. Light purple. Influenced by my wife, who tells me to get turbans in these exotic colours when I can only see one colour, I'd say that's lilac.
DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
Yeah. It says 12, but I'm almost certain they're 12.5. And you'll also notice, and I'm sure we mentioned this in the last episode, that this is a 21mm file. These are shorter files, and the benefit of a shorter file is that it's less likely to bend, so you can push it a bit harder.
I've been known to shape with a hand file up to a size 20. D-Finders don't go up that high, and that's usually when you've created a ledge, and it's difficult to pre-bend rotary files.
CHAPTER 5: THE HAND-HELD ROTARY FILE TRICK
DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
Another really, really great tip, and I always wonder if I keep repeating myself, 'cause I mention this all the time on the channel, and maybe in the last episode too: you might find you can't get the rotary or reciprocating file down on the motor. You've done all the shaping.
You can get to length with a size 15, say, but when you put the rotary file in, it's still getting stuck and you're not getting there. The best thing to do, and it doesn't make any sense at all, is take the file out of the motor and put the rotary or reciprocating file in yourself, by hand, so you can feel that tactile feedback.
You can push it to length. And then, believe it or not, the endodontic motor will still work even if the file isn't clipped into place. You can just put the motor head over the end of the file. It's not clipped in, but you can turn it on and it'll do the movement. What you've got to be careful of, of course, is that when you pull the handpiece out, you'll forget the file isn't locked in.
It'll drop on the floor and you'll need a new one. We use that trick a lot, especially with the HyFlex 20s, because the 20 is where you can put a bend in the file.
CHAPTER 6: ROTARY OR RECIPROCATING: IS THERE A WINNER?
JAZ:
One of the questions submitted by the community was which you'd take to a desert island, and you'd be taking your HyFlex. But it's a difficult one, because there are so many reasons you chose HyFlex beyond it being rotary rather than reciprocating. So the answer to settle this showdown is a very humble one: "Hey, you know what?
"It's what works in your hands," which is universal in dentistry. But my only concern is this. I know there are no recipe books, and in occlusion there's definitely no recipe book. But is there no rule like, "If you have a curved canal, you should use rotary rather than reciprocating"?
Or, "If a canal has feature X, choose this one of the two"? Obviously there are a million different options, because of the metallurgy, taper and size. But when we boil it down to just these two variables, rotary versus reciprocating, is there no algorithmic decision-making?
DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
I don't think so, no. I think the reason I use HyFlex is that it's just a comfort blanket. And I'm sorry, Coltene. I love the Coltene rep as well. I've got a really good friendship with Emma, and I've known her for years. I do some hands-on work with the Welsh Government, and she always helps me out with HyFlex.
Essentially, HyFlex caught me really early, and now I just use it. Of course, I get given file systems, and I do use them. I do have WaveOne Gold files in the practice, but not because I use them for different cases.
It's because HyFlex originally didn't have longer files. Files come in different lengths: 21mm, 25mm or 31mm. HyFlex didn't have the extra-long files, so for big canines that needed shaping, we used WaveOne Gold, because they're long enough.
HyFlex have just brought out longer files, so I probably won't use WaveOne Gold anymore. So, like I say, it's just a comfort blanket. It's what I'm used to, and that's probably the most important thing. That's the take-home today: find what you like, and stick with it.
In my practice, I see a lot of consultations, and a lot of patients who just want a second opinion, or who've been through the mill with lots of different dentists. A lot of the time, we know it's a really common risk, but a filling's been done, the tooth has kicked off, and the patient has lost confidence in that dentist.
During the consultation, I obviously tell patients it's a really common risk. But I also say, "You might have seen dentist A, dentist B, dentist C, and now dentist D.
"Do you know what? Just choose somebody and stick with them." Because you can put one patient in a room with 10 dentists and get completely different opinions. In the same way, just choose a file system you like, and if you're getting good results with it, stick with it.
But if I were a newly qualified dentist stranded on a desert island, I'd probably take WaveOne Gold with me, even though I don't really use it. The only issue with reciprocation, of course, is that you need a specialised motor. That was more of a difficulty 10 years ago. Now I think most motors do both movements.
I also think changing the forward and backward angles on reciprocation is beyond me. I don't know what's best. But I often change the rotary action, and the torque, when I'm using rotary files, for different types of canals.
I like using the glide path file at quite a low speed, usually about 300 to 350 RPM, and always on the lowest torque setting, because I know that's my backstop. I'm using a very, very thin file in a very, very calcified canal.
I don't want any torsional stress. But when I'm using my larger rotary files, I know the canal's been shaped and it's just the final shaping, so I'll kick it up a notch. I also use XP-endo. Are you aware of XP-endo at all?
JAZ:
I used it once, years ago. I'm trying to think what was unique about it. Is it by Dentsply?
DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
No, I don't think it's Dentsply. It's a purple brand, Swedish, I think. I can't remember what it's called. XP-endo has a kind of wavy file shape.
JAZ:
It removes debris really efficiently. It's by FKG Dentaire.
DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
You're right, that's the one. It's Swiss.
CHAPTER 7: A WORD FROM OUR PARTNER: THE QUDENT ENDO RADAR PRO
JAZ:
On Protrusive, we get asked geeky endo questions all the time, but one of the top questions is, "Which endo motor should I get?" A good endo motor is so valuable, whether you're at a busy practice or an associate moving between practices.
If you do a lot of endo, you'll value a good endo motor. We've teamed up with Qudent to bring you a special promotion on the Endo Radar Pro. I had a product demo a couple of months ago, and the cool thing is that the head itself has free-form rotation. That makes it far less awkward to read your apex locator measurement, 'cause it's not only a motor, it's also an apex locator.
With a fixed head, it's sometimes difficult to read the screen. Free-form rotation really helps you access all the canals, however far back and awkward they are. With other motors, you have to detach and reattach the head, but this one rotates freely. The other trend this satisfies is that dentists buying endo motors nowadays no longer want the screen on the handpiece itself.
That's getting too cumbersome and fiddly, going up and down trying to get the right settings on the handpiece. So we've gone back to favouring a large screen, and that's what this one offers. Dentists want to put the endo motor on the bracket table right next to them and see the screen and the visuals.
It makes it so much easier to toggle file systems, speeds and torque. The motor connects to the handpiece via Bluetooth, so there are no wires, which is great: you still get the feel of a wireless handpiece, but all the settings are conveniently changed on the motor, not the handpiece.
Not to mention, it's more ergonomic this way. The Endo Radar Pro comes with an autoclavable head, which is where you insert your file. If you're limited to endo, or you're a specialist, you'll probably want to buy a couple of additional heads. The promotional price in total is less than £650.
I say less than, because I always like to quote including VAT. Once you check out and enter the code, it'll be well under £650, and there's another perk as well: you get to choose some free files. You can pick Solo files, which are similar to WaveOne, or M-Taper, which is similar to ProTaper rotary.
When I was learning about these files, I found out they've been sold for seven years with 80% customer retention. So you get a new endo motor and get to try a new file system, either reciprocating, the Solo, similar to WaveOne, or rotary, the M-Taper, similar to ProTaper.
The discount and the files are all applied at checkout. The website to claim this is protrusive.co.uk/endomotor. That's /endomotor. And as always, your coupon code is PROTRUSIVE. This offer is time-sensitive: the best pricing is in the first 30 days, or until it sells out. So check it out at /endomotor. Let's rejoin the episode.
CHAPTER 8: FILES FOR RETREATMENT, AND THE RISK OF EXTRUSION
DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
It's a premium brand. You open the box and think, "Wow, this looks fancy." Of course, it's Swiss, and incredibly expensive. But there's another file, I think it's the Finisher, that's shaped like a half-moon. It comes in a sleeve, and when you blow Endo-Frost onto it, it straightens out.
Then you get it into the canal, and once it reaches a warmer temperature, it expands out again. They use it at 1,000 RPM. That's fast. Another file I use, other than HyFlex, is Tooth Saver. As I mentioned, I use their glide path file if I'm struggling to get to length and need to put a little bend at the end.
With Tooth Saver, you can't make a proper bend, but you can make a better bend than with, say, a HyFlex. I also use their 20/07 tapered files for retreatments. By 20/07, again, 20 is the tip size and 07 is the taper. I'm not entirely sure about the 07, because with these tapers, sometimes they're continuous, and sometimes they level out.
If you had a continuous 7% taper all the way up the file, it'd look like a Christmas tree, wouldn't it? These files are also used at 1,000 RPM, at quite a low torque, and they cut through GP like a knife through butter. The issue with rotary files is this: we were talking about reciprocation having more of a tendency to push debris out of the end.
I think that even if you use a rotary file really fast close to the apex, you'll push stuff out for sure. I look at the comments on my YouTube videos, and people constantly ask the same thing: "Why aren't you using a mechanical way of removing GP?"
But in the first instance, I always try to remove the GP with hand files, H-files. I've spoken to many, many endodontists, and they think I'm just taking too much time. But I think if you use rotary or reciprocating files really, really close to the apex when you're removing GP, you're always going to push GP out of the end.
There's a massive debate about whether that matters. Obviously, you'd like to think you won't get any extrusion at all. But for me, I'm always trying to get that perfect post-op radiograph, and a little bit of extruded material isn't great for me, and I don't think it's great for the patient either.
CHAPTER 9: WHY YOUR FILE SYSTEM MATTERS LESS THAN YOU THINK, AND EMBRACING "IT DEPENDS"
JAZ:
As they say in endo, the thrill of the fill. Taking a few things you've said in the last couple of minutes: one was telling patients to just choose someone. I really resonate with that, and it's the same advice I give when a dentist asks on our courses, "Which composite system should I use?"
The first part of the answer is to stop chopping and changing between composite systems. Don't use Kulzer one week, GC the next and Coltene the week after. You've got to pick one and spend a good few years honing your skills and learning the ins and outs of that system before you can truly master it.
You'll end up loving and enjoying it, 'cause the handling all comes. So there are definitely a lot of similarities in what we're saying. The other thing I say to dentists is, "You know what? You're stressing over which composite system to use.
"But the composite system is probably about eighth on the list of what makes a lovely composite." Let's talk anteriors. Number one would be shape. Number two, the line angles. Number three, the surface texture. Number four could be the shade.
And then there are various other things, and which system you used is probably number eight or so. In a similar vein, and let's just make up some numbers, how important is the single variable of reciprocating versus rotary for successful endo? Chemo-mechanical preparation and the use of hypochlorite are probably number one.
Isolation is high up there. Where do rotary versus reciprocating, and the file system you choose, come in?
DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
Very low. I know loads of dentists, from university and from doing courses, and I'd say most dentists just want to be told, "I want to do this thing. Tell me how to do it, and I'll start doing it."
At dental school, I always used to get really frustrated with clinicians when I asked, "What would you do with this?" and they'd say, "Well, it depends." If you're a newly qualified dentist, you want me to say, "Use this file this way."
But if that were true, you'd get dentistry really quickly, and then it'd be really boring after a while. You'd just do the same thing over and over again. I think one of the benefits of this job is that it does depend, and that's what makes it incredibly exciting.
I've said this before: I go to work every single day and look forward to it. Every single root canal, even if it looks really, really simple, has something a little bit different about it. That's also why the clinical cases I post every Friday on my YouTube channel are so easy to find: every single case is just different in some little way.
What I'm trying to say is that I know if you're newly qualified and listening to this, you just want to be told what to do, because it's easier. But try to embrace the concept that it really does depend, and enjoy the journey of understanding that.
If you went to work and absolutely hated this job, it'd be miserable for you. But if you forced me to give you an answer, I'd say WaveOne Gold. That's just from personal experience. I have nothing to do with WaveOne Gold, and I hardly ever use it. I think it's a really, really good, easy-
JAZ:
GDP-friendly system.
DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
It's really, really friendly, and it's a single-file system. You touched on this before. I love this stuff. When I was thinking about this podcast today... I'd literally just finished a root canal. A patient left, and we sat down to do this podcast.
And I was thinking about my files: "Ooh, I wonder if this would work." It's absolutely fascinating. I'm at the point now where a lot of things are on autopilot. Something happens, and I just know straight away what to do.
But when you're newly qualified, everything is up in the air, and sometimes you feel like you're drowning a little, because you're not sure what to do. That's when it's really important to get a mentor, even if it's just someone else in the practice who's happy to talk things through with you.
The great thing about WaveOne Gold is that it's just simple, isn't it? It's one less thing to worry about. But it's definitely not a file system you could use as a single file in every case. And HyFlex is another single-file system.
So just try them. You must hear this all the time, but get extracted teeth and have a go. I know some dentists think, "I don't have time for that. I'm on my lunch break, writing letters." I don't either.
But you know what? It helps so much to have a go on some extracted teeth. And go on courses as well.
JAZ:
Because you might go on one course and learn about HyFlex, then go on another course where they absolutely love a particular system, and they'll give you reasons: "Have you experienced this? Have you experienced that?" And you're nodding: "Yes, that's me." There's obviously marketing and fluff, but this file system will help you with that problem. And because that problem is a big one for you, the system is a painkiller for you, so you resonate with it.
It's like composite. You might use Kulzer for four years, then get introduced to GC, and it intrigues you and solves some of the problems you had with the other system. Once you've tasted both, you can decide that you actually prefer one.
Or you might find that you like one file system for some scenarios and another for others. Taking it back to Class IIs, I have that: for certain types of concavities and whatnot, I'll use one matrix system, and for others, a different one. There's no substitute for experience.
CHAPTER 10: SAYING "I DON'T KNOW", CONSENT, AND THE PATIENTS YOU ATTRACT
DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
Then there's the other side of being a dentist: patient management. When you're newly qualified, you want to feel like you can do everything, and you want to keep up the facade that the patient thinks you're dead good, et cetera, et cetera.
But what you need to realise is this: enjoy your learning experience when you're newly qualified, and don't be afraid to tell a patient you don't know and they need to see somebody else. Do that. If I were having a blind chat with a dentist, I could ask them a few questions about a few things, and I'd know straight away how experienced they were.
Based on their ability to say, "I can't do this. I'm going to send this to somebody else." And definitely don't feel bad about yourself if you feel you can't do something. Most patients understand. And if a patient's going to be upset about you being honest with them, they're the wrong patient for you.
JAZ:
And so you get to eliminate the risk of taking on a patient who doesn't-
DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
Exactly.
JAZ:
It's a great filter. And taking it back to-
DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
Consent is-
JAZ:
Sorry.
DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
No, no. Go on.
JAZ:
Well, we did an old episode with Dr Barry Glassman, probably episode 15 or 16 or something, years and years ago. Dr Barry Glassman is a lovely chap in the States, a TMD and orofacial pain guy. He said there's a beauty in being able to smile at a patient and say, "I don't know."
But there's a way to say it: with confidence. "I don't know." There's a beauty in that. Or sometimes something isn't known, because it genuinely isn't known. Either you don't know, and you say, "I don't know, but I know someone who does," or it's not known, and you say so with a smile, conviction and confidence. That has a lot of value. I'd love to hear what you were going to say about consent.
DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
I just love it. Honest to God, I have a really good friend who's a specialist endodontist, and he thinks I go too far with consent. I do go pretty deep into it, but I suppose that's just my personality.
I'm an ex-worrywart. I'm definitely not as worried as I used to be. I work in two very big practices, and we get a turnover of newly qualified dentists. We used to have a VT here. When they come to me really upset or worried about something, I think, "Oh, I've got to help this person."
A lot of the time, you just shouldn't worry about it too much. If you're a worrywart, it will definitely get better over time. But for me, consent is huge. I've also got a theory: if you work at a practice for many, many years and build up a load of patients you know really well, the patients reflect the dentist.
Always. We used to have a lovely, lovely dentist, honestly fantastic, but she had a very high-strung personality, and all of her patients were really, really high-strung.
I'd love to know what my patients are like. Who knows? I don't think it's done deliberately. You just attract that type of patient. The type of patient who stays with you reflects who you are, I think. And that's a huge reflection.
JAZ:
People buy into you, not just the dentistry. In general practice, that obviously won't happen in your first year, 'cause you haven't built any rapport yet. But by about five years in, your patients are a reflection of you.
And that's very telling. In the interest of time, I'm going to ask some questions from the community. There were so many brilliant questions sent in. But before we do, you said something earlier about how young dentists want to be told, "Do this; if this, then that," like a recipe book.
That literally took me back 13 years, to our very first DF1 study day. Raj Rattan was my TPD, and he asked, "Raise your hand if you like rigid protocols and just want to be told what to do." Loads of hands went up.
Then it was, "Put your hand up if you don't mind there being many different right answers," and fewer hands went up. But I've retrained my mind, and what I've been teaching in our community is that there's a beauty to dentistry. If you just swap the lens you look through, the fact that there are 10 different ways to do something isn't a bad thing.
If you see it as a beautiful thing, you've got 10 shots at doing it and can still be right-
DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
It's fun, isn't it?
JAZ:
It's fun. It's what brings the fun into it.
DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
And when a dentist comes in and asks me questions, it's fun to talk about. A lot of the time it's, "You could do it this way, or you could do it that way." Sometimes a dentist comes in, and I wouldn't say upset, that's the wrong word, but flustered, and then you just say, "You know what? Just do it like this."
I think you need to grasp how fun and interesting this job is. For the people after very, very rigid protocols, what will happen is that they'll break those protocols frequently, and then think, "I've done it wrong," when they haven't.
JAZ:
It's like cognitive dissonance. You feel uneasy with yourself, but you haven't actually done anything wrong. You're just too rigid in your mindset.
DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
Yes, absolutely. And this is where consent comes in. The whole adage of "undersell and over-deliver" is such a cliché, but it's so true. And with an over-demanding patient... I always feel that the people you bend over backwards for the most are the worst patients, because they're never appreciative. Never. It's always the same people, because they always want more.
When I say they want more, I mean their expectations are unreasonably high. Maybe it's the part of the world I work in, but I'd say 99% of the people I come across are rational.
JAZ:
And with experience you learn who isn't, so your filter becomes stronger.
CHAPTER 11: COMMUNITY QUESTIONS: RECIPROC VS WAVEONE, GP REMOVAL, CURVED CANALS AND SKIPPING THE GLIDE PATH
JAZ:
Now, in the interest of time, Sam, I'm going to ask you some questions, and you must answer each in 45 seconds or less. So we have to throw out everything we said in the last minute, about there being beauty in millions of different ways, and you have to tell me straight away-
DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
Let's say the dentist asking this question has come in flustered, and the patient's in the chair.
JAZ:
I'm the flustered dentist, and this flustered dentist is Dr Roxy. Roxy asks, "What's the benefit of a file system like WaveOne versus Reciproc?" These are two different brands. Or are they from the same company? VDW comes to mind.
DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
No, they're not the same company. But weirdly enough, they were created around the same time by different people.
JAZ:
So it's Reciproc versus WaveOne?
DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
I'd say Reciproc is very, very grabby. It wants to drag itself down, especially the early Reciproc. I don't think I've used Reciproc Blue yet. I think WaveOne Gold is probably a bit more user-friendly. One of the reasons I went from WaveOne to HyFlex is that I felt it didn't have that kind of cutting efficiency.
JAZ:
Okay, wonderful. You've already touched on this, but to summarise: what are your preferred mechanical files for removing GP in root canal retreatments?
DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
Hedström files straight away. You want to try to remove the GP in one piece as much as possible. If I'm struggling, I'll use a rotary file, the Tooth Saver 20/07.
They're cheap files and very, very efficient, but you've got to worry about extruding out of the end. And I never used to use it, but I've started using solvent. You take the X-ray, you feel you've removed all the GP, but you can see a tiny bit at the end that you can't quite remove.
Solvent is great for that. But you have to be dead careful with solvent. Don't use it too early, because you'll smear the GP all up the walls and it'll be impossible to remove.
JAZ:
Got it. Christopher asks: can you use a rotary file, like your HyFlex, in a reciprocating motion? And the second part: if a file goes clockwise, can you just use it in the other direction?
He says, "Instead of buying different files, why not use the same file in a different mode? Aside from that, I'd like you to ask him about the possibility of cracking teeth and extruding debris when using reciprocation," which we've touched on already. So really: can you use a file that's meant for rotation in a reciprocating motion?
DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
You can use whatever you like, I suppose. Is it efficient that way? Again, I talk about Tooth Saver a lot, 'cause I know Daniel really, really well. He's a really good mentor, actually. I get a lot of advice from him, and his Tooth Saver files can be used in reciprocation or rotation.
But if you're not sure, I'd stick to what you know. If you're using rotary or reciprocating files off-licence, as it were, you might be more likely to fracture the file. I know that in one of the first papers on reciprocation, they used a ProTaper file, a rotary file, to see if it would work in reciprocating mode, and it did.
But I think that kind of thing is best left until you're much more experienced. And of course, if you're going to do it, do it on extracted teeth first, because it should be in the patient's best interest if you're using files in different ways.
JAZ:
I'm sure you'll find Mustafa on your YouTube channel giving you love and comments. He's a really cool guy, and very experienced. He's very good at endo, so he's got the licence to experiment like that, which makes sense.
DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
I'd love to know his opinion on that. That'd be interesting.
JAZ:
Yeah, we'll get him to post it. He'll post it on the app straight away. Next, a question about efficiency for curved canals. Ty asks, "Which is more efficient?" We're talking speed and efficiency for shaping curved canals: reciprocating or rotary. If that's the metric you're looking at, is one more efficient?
DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
The marketing around reciprocating files is that they're more likely to stay centred during use. When you're more centred within the canal, of course, you're less likely to ledge, and the risk of ledging is the main issue with curved canals.
I don't think there's any difference between the two. Although, and I keep banging this home, I think glide path files cut a truer glide path than hand files do. I think the important thing, the rate-limiting step, isn't reciprocation or rotary. It's probably taper, and making sure you have a glide path.
JAZ:
Super. That makes so much sense. The last question is from Harpardeep, a long-term Protruserati and one of the loveliest dentists anyone will ever know. She has a really good question that ties in nicely with glide paths. She's heard that Reciproc Blue files can bypass glide path files.
In her own words, which are probably very similar to what you're thinking, it's hard to let go of using glide path files or hand files for initial instrumentation. I don't know anything about Reciproc Blue or these claims, but do you have any thoughts or experience with it?
DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
I don't use Reciproc. But one of the reasons Reciproc was created was to see whether they could make a file that did everything, without needing a glide path file.
So I think the original USP of Reciproc was that you don't need a glide path file. Personally, I've had my fingers burnt too many times going straight to length without a glide path file. And I always think that if someone were doing a root canal on me, I'd want them to be using those safe, backstop ways of working.
I wouldn't want them to think, "Well, I just want to be quick, so I'll rag it down there." I'm not saying she's ragging it down there. But the number of times I've gone with the file, "Oh, I'll just go a little bit further," and then it's ledged...
It still catches me out. If I can't get to length, I'll shape it a millimetre short of where I've reached. Sometimes I'll just slip it a bit further, and it always ledges. Personally, I'd always use a glide path file, every single time. But I'm not-
JAZ:
It just makes sense.
DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
I'm not experienced with Reciproc at all. You might find someone who uses it all the time. I couldn't comment.
JAZ:
It all boils down to risk analysis and insurance. If they market that claim, there must be some degree of truth in their testing: they found they were able to bypass the glide path.
But asking whether that introduces a risk is logical. Maybe there is some degree of risk. And like you said, being a bit cautious is your style, and if that suits your style, that may be the answer.
CHAPTER 12: WHERE TO FIND DR SAMUEL JOHNSON
JAZ:
And that takes us to the end of a very grippy episode indeed. Sam, thank you so much once again for honouring us with your presence, your humility, your passion and your enthusiasm. You're absolutely golden. Please continue making those wonderful Friday morning videos, and all the cases you post on YouTube and Instagram.
Guys, I'll link to all of Sam's stuff below. You need to check it out. Is there anything else you'd like the viewers and listeners, who already love you so much, to check out?
DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
Nothing. Just keep enjoying it and keep commenting. I've also started a giveaway: we're giving away a brand-new apex locator when I hit 30,000 subscribers on YouTube. All you need to do is subscribe and comment with a question. That's all we're asking. To be honest, I've learned so much from so many different people, in endo and restorative, and all the comments are absolutely golden. So just keep the comments going. That's all I'll say.
JAZ:
There we are, guys. Keep commenting, including on this channel. Sam, thank you so much for everything. I appreciate you, and I'm sure I'll catch you again, if we keep doing this yearly thing.
DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
Cheers, guys. All the best.
JAZ:
Have a great rest of your day at clinic.
DR SAMUEL JOHNSON:
Lovely.
JAZ:
Well, there we have it, guys. Thank you so much for listening to part two with Samuel Johnson all the way to the end. You're the true Protruserati, the true geeks, and the nicest people in the world, as are all the members of Protrusive Guidance.
If you're not on our app yet, please join. Head over to protrusive.app and make your account on the web. Once you've made your account, you can use those login details on the iOS or Android app. Full members and premium subscribers, scroll down, answer the quiz, get 80%, and our CPD queen, Mari, will send you your certificate.
We release approximately 60 new hours of CE every year, as well as a back catalogue of over 400 hours of quality CPD. We are a PACE-approved education provider, so whether you're in the US, Australia, the UK or anywhere in the world, we've got you covered. Our app and community really are a melting pot of dentists from around the world, even remote islands.
It's amazing how we've managed to attract nice and geeky dentists from all corners of the world, so if you're not on there yet, please do head over to the app. And don't forget, if you're interested in the endo motor, head over to protrusive.co.uk/endomotor. The deal ends in approximately four weeks, or when it sells out.
It will then be replaced with a smaller deal, so you'll still get a small discount, but the money off and the free files are available right now. So head over to protrusive.co.uk/endomotor. Thanks again for listening, and thanks again to Samuel for being a great sport. I'll catch you same time, same place next week.
Bye for now. And by the way, don't forget to subscribe to Samuel's channel as well as this one, if you haven't already. Thank you.
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
QUESTION:
How do you clean the pulp chamber after cutting the GP?
ANSWER:
Jaz recommends cutting the GP at the level of the orifice, leaving space for the coronal seal. For a resin-based sealer such as AH Plus, he wipes the chamber with a microbrush or cotton pellet soaked in isopropyl alcohol, as water and ultrasonics won't remove it. Bioceramic sealer cleans up with water, and for zinc oxide eugenol sealers he uses ultrasonics and air abrasion.
QUESTION:
What is Dr Samuel Johnson's endo shaping protocol?
ANSWER:
Sam establishes patency with a size eight or 10 hand file, usually a D-Finder, through the coronal to mid third. He then uses a rotary glide path file, around a 15/03, to open that section. Once a size 10 reaches length, he takes the glide path file to length, letting it find its own way, before finishing with his HyFlex shaping files.
QUESTION:
Should you use Gates Glidden drills?
ANSWER:
Sam never uses them. He found them too aggressive when newly qualified, and felt they caused ledges in the coronal third. He prefers to open the coronal to mid third with a glide path or shaping file, which gives straight-line access without removing too much pericervical dentine. Occasionally, under a microscope, he uses long-neck rose-head burs.
QUESTION:
What should you do if you can't get a file to length?
ANSWER:
Sam explains that the canal walls often grip the file, so opening up the coronal to mid third helps. He drops from a size 10 to a size eight, which is stiffer than a six, and uses in-between sizes such as a 12.5 D-Finder, because going from a 10 to a 15 is a 50% increase. Shorter 21mm files also bend less.
QUESTION:
Is rotary or reciprocating better?
ANSWER:
Sam doesn't think one is better, and says file choice is low on the list of what determines endo success. He uses HyFlex rotary as a "comfort blanket", but would suggest WaveOne Gold, a simple single-file reciprocating system, for a newly qualified dentist. He believes taper and a reliable glide path matter more than the type of motion.
QUESTION:
What is the best way to remove gutta-percha in a retreatment?
ANSWER:
Sam starts with Hedström files, aiming to remove the GP in one piece. If he's struggling, he uses a Tooth Saver 20/07 rotary file at 1,000 RPM and low torque, but warns that mechanical files near the apex can extrude GP. He now uses solvent for small remnants seen on the radiograph, but only late on, to avoid smearing GP up the walls.
QUESTION:
Can you use a rotary file in reciprocating mode?
ANSWER:
Sam says you can, and notes some files, such as Tooth Saver, are designed for both. But using files off-licence may increase the risk of fracture, so he advises sticking to what you know. If you want to experiment, he suggests waiting until you're more experienced and trying it on extracted teeth first, in the patient's best interest.
QUESTION:
Can you skip the glide path with Reciproc Blue?
ANSWER:
Sam explains that Reciproc was originally designed so a glide path file wasn't needed. He doesn't use Reciproc, so can't comment from experience, but he always uses a glide path file himself, because he has ledged canals when going straight to length. Jaz suggests weighing up the manufacturer's claims against the possible risk.
ABOUT THE GUEST
Dr Samuel Johnson is a dentist with a special interest in endodontics who works in two large practices and sees many consultations and second-opinion patients. He shares clinical endo cases every Friday on his YouTube channel and on Instagram, and does hands-on teaching work with the Welsh Government. He uses a microscope and HyFlex files in his everyday endo.