Protrusive Dental Podcast

🦷 Plaque Friday™ is here!

Get 20% off Protrusive Guidance Ultimate for as long as you stay, plus 7 days free to try it. That’s every masterclass, AskJaz, verifiable CPD on hundreds of podcast episodes, and our new live series Caries, Cracks and Contact Points with Dr Ronit Patel. Use code PF26 at checkout. Ends Monday 30 November, 11:59pm UK.
👉 https://protrusive.co.uk/plaquefriday

Sleep, Airway and Mouth Breathing: An ENT’s Guide for Dentists
Could a “normal” sleep study still be missing your patient’s airway problem?
Why do women and children with real symptoms keep scoring “mild”?
Should a mouth-breathing child see a myofunctional therapist — or an ENT first?
And which four questions screen a child for sleep problems in under a minute?
The roof of the mouth is the floor of the nose — so ENT and dentistry should be in constant dialogue. In practice, they rarely are. In this one, Dr David McIntosh— an Australian ear, nose and throat surgeon with a deep niche in sleep-disordered breathing — makes the case for why that has to change, and gives dentists practical ways to screen and refer. He is direct, analogy-rich and doesn’t mince words; expect a few positions that cut against the grain of how sleep apnoea is usually handled.
 https://youtu.be/QVEc0ocxTCc 
Watch PDP272 on YouTube
Protrusive Dental Pearl: When the Numbers Mislead
Dentists love data — the AHI, the cut-offs (over 5 is mild, over 30 is severe). But take those numbers with a pinch of salt: the thresholds are arbitrary, and a single score tells you nothing about why a patient has the problem.
They don’t account for individual variability — especially in women and children, where a mild score can sit right alongside significant symptoms. Read the number with the anatomy and the phenotype — the clinical signs and the airway assessment — never instead of them.
What You’ll Take From This Episode
This conversation reframes sleep-disordered breathing from a number on a report into something you can localise and refer. 
  • A sleep study tells you IF, not WHY — sleep-disordered breathing is the whole spectrum; a normal study doesn’t mean normal breathing.
  • Phenotyping the airway — map the individual anatomical causes instead of trusting a single score.
  • Why women get missed — the gender bias built into standard adult screening tools, and what to ask instead.
  • The four-question filter for children — snore, mouth breathe, stop breathing, wake up tired: any ‘yes’ means refer.
  • Treat the cause before the function — why myofunctional therapy comes after the obstruction is cleared, not before, and how expansion and surgery are matched to the anatomy.
Highlights of This Episode
  • 00:00  Teaser
  • 01:00  Why ENT and Dentistry Should Be Talking
  • 02:51  Protrusive Dental Pearl: When Sleep Data Misleads You
  • 03:46  Meet the ENT Who Works With Dentists
  • 06:00  Sleep Physician, ENT or Dentist: Who Should Lead?
  • 07:26  Why Children and Adults Are Completely Different
  • 08:58  Sleep-Disordered Breathing Is Not the Same as Sleep Apnoea
  • 09:39  Why a Normal Sleep Study Doesn’t Mean Normal Breathing
  • 10:01  Same AHI, Different Cause: A Tale of Two Patients
  • 12:54  Why One Night’s Sleep Study Isn’t Enough
  • 13:44  Where the AHI Cut-Off Numbers Really Came From
  • 15:27  CPAP Explained: A Bridge, Not a Cure
  • 18:27  When Snoring Hides Something Serious
  • 19:10  What Phenotyping the Airway Actually Means
  • 20:27  Splint, CPAP, or Both?
  • 21:33  Why a CBCT Can Miss a Deviated Septum
  • 25:32  Is STOP-Bang Enough to Screen for Sleep Apnoea?
  • 26:06  Why the Epworth Sleepiness Scale Is a Blunt Tool
  • 26:50  Why STOP-Bang Is Biased Against Women
  • 31:17  Sleep Apnoea in Women: Mild on Paper, Severe in Life
  • 32:05  Midroll
  • 36:56  The Triad: Airway, TMD and Orthodontics
  • 37:12  The Three Most Common Causes of Night-Time Grinding
  • 39:41  The Four Questions That Screen a Child for Sleep Problems
  • 41:03  Tired vs Not Tired: The Sign That Changes Everything
  • 43:36  Should You Refer to Myofunctional Therapy Before an ENT?
  • 45:58  The Hidden Dangers of Forcing Nasal Breathing
  • 52:28  Maxillary Expansion vs Surgery: Which One Fixes It?
  • 54:51  How Dentists Can Assess Adenoids
  • 56:25  Save the Child First: The Drowning Analogy
  • 57:56  Where Dentistry and ENT Go From Here
  • 1:00:05  Outro – New-Look Premium Notes & CPD Outro
From the Guest
Dr David McIntosh is an ear, nose and throat surgeon (MBBS, FRACS, PhD) with a special interest in sleep-disordered breathing and airway obstruction. A self-described compulsive educator, he is the author of several books on Amazon — including dENTal health, on the connection between ENT and dental disease, and Snored to Death, on the lesser-recognised causes of obstructive sleep apnoea in adults.
References & Further Reading
Sources discussed in this episode:
Loved This Episode? Try Next
Airway Dentistry with Jeff Rouse – PDP229
Listen, Subscribe, Earn CPD
This episode is eligible for 1 CE credit via the quiz on Protrusive Guidance.
This episode meets GDC Outcomes C
AGD Subject Code: 730 – Oral Medicine, Oral Diagnosis, Oral Pathology (Sleep medicine)
#PDPMainEpisodes #OralSurgeryandOralMedicine
Aim & Learning Outcomes
Aim: To help dental practitioners recognise sleep-disordered breathing across the whole airway, screen adults and children appropriately, and refer at the right time and to the right clinician.
Learning Outcomes — by the end of this episode, dentists will be able to:
  • Differentiate sleep-disordered breathing from obstructive sleep apnoea, and explain why a normal sleep study does not exclude clinically significant breathing problems.
  • Apply a structured screening approach for adults and children, including recognising why standard adult tools under-detect sleep-disordered breathing in women and children.
  • Evaluate when to refer for specialist airway assessment, and articulate why addressing anatomical obstruction should precede functional (myofunctional) therapy.

What is Protrusive Dental Podcast?

The Forward Thinking Dental Podcast

SEO METADATA

SEO TITLE:
Putting the ENT into Dentistry: Sleep-Disordered Breathing with Dr David McIntosh | PDP272

META DESCRIPTION:
ENT surgeon Dr David McIntosh on sleep studies, CPAP, STOP-Bang in women, four screening questions for kids, and why ENT should come before myo.

URL SLUG:
ent-dentistry-sleep-disordered-breathing-david-mcintosh

PRIMARY TOPIC:
How dentists and ENT surgeons can work together on sleep-disordered breathing

SECONDARY SEARCH TOPICS:
- Limitations of sleep studies and the AHI
- Why CPAP fails without treating the cause
- Phenotyping sleep apnoea patients
- STOP-Bang and the Epworth Sleepiness Scale in women
- Screening children for sleep-disordered breathing
- Mouth breathing and myofunctional therapy
- Maxillary expansion vs adenotonsillectomy
- TMD, bruxism and upper airway obstruction

PUTTING THE ENT INTO DENTISTRY
THE PROTRUSIVE DENTAL PODCAST, EPISODE PDP272
HOST: DR JAZ GULATI
GUEST: DR DAVID MCINTOSH

EPISODE SUMMARY

In this episode of the Protrusive Dental Podcast, Dr Jaz Gulati talks to Dr David McIntosh, an Australian ear, nose and throat surgeon for adults and children with a special interest in sleep-disordered breathing, and author of books including Snored to Death. They explore why ENT and dentistry need to work much more closely together.

David explains why sleep-disordered breathing is different in children and adults, and in women and men, and why a normal sleep study doesn't mean normal breathing. He argues the AHI thresholds have no epidemiological basis, explains why so many adults abandon CPAP, and describes how ENTs phenotype patients to find the cause. He shows why STOP-Bang works poorly for women, gives four simple questions to screen children, and explains why he believes sending a mouth-breathing child to myofunctional therapy before an ENT assessment can cause harm. They also discuss TMD, maxillary expansion versus surgery, and assessing adenoids. Jaz's Protrusive Dental Pearl is to treat AHI numbers with caution.

IN SHORT

This episode explains why dentists should involve an ENT when they suspect sleep-disordered breathing. Dr David McIntosh's view is that sleep studies and screening scores miss many patients, especially women and children, that most mouth breathing has an anatomical cause, and that the underlying obstruction should be treated before myofunctional therapy or relying on CPAP.

KEY TAKEAWAYS

- Jaz's pearl: AHI thresholds are arbitrary, so combine the numbers with the patient's symptoms, anatomy and phenotype.
- David says sleep studies diagnose obstructive sleep apnoea, not the wider spectrum of sleep-disordered breathing, and don't explain why it's happening.
- He says two-thirds of adults stop using CPAP within 12 months, often because of untreated nasal or throat problems.
- STOP-Bang favours men; for women, David looks at nasal congestion, tiredness, morning brain fog and unexplained headaches.
- Women often score "mild" on sleep studies but have severe symptoms, especially from perimenopause onwards.
- To screen children, David asks four questions: do they stop breathing, snore, mouth breathe, or wake up tired?
- David says 80 to 90% of mouth breathing is due to anatomical obstruction, so the cause should be treated before myofunctional therapy.
- Whether a child needs maxillary expansion, surgery or both depends on the balance of skeletal and ENT problems.

QUESTIONS ANSWERED IN THIS EPISODE

1. What is the difference between sleep-disordered breathing and obstructive sleep apnoea?
2. Does a normal sleep study mean normal breathing?
3. Why do so many patients stop using CPAP?
4. Is the STOP-Bang questionnaire reliable for women?
5. What should dentists ask to screen children for sleep-disordered breathing?
6. Should a mouth-breathing child see an ENT before myofunctional therapy?
7. Should a TMD patient with suspected sleep problems see an ENT first?
8. Is maxillary expansion or surgery better for children with sleep-disordered breathing?

IN THIS EPISODE

1. Introduction: putting the ENT into dentistry
2. Protrusive Dental Pearl: the AHI numbers are arbitrary
3. Meet Dr David McIntosh, and who owns sleep-disordered breathing
4. Children vs adults, men vs women: why sleep-disordered breathing isn't one disease
5. Why a normal sleep study doesn't mean normal breathing
6. CPAP: a pump for a blocked sink
7. Phenotyping: what an ENT looks for, and what scans miss
8. STOP-Bang and Epworth: why the screening tools fail women
9. Why women are hit harder, and why TMD patients should see ENT first
10. The four questions to screen children for sleep-disordered breathing
11. Why myofunctional therapy before an ENT opinion can be dangerous
12. Maxillary expansion or surgery? It depends on the child
13. How dentists and ENTs can work together, and where to find David

CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION: PUTTING THE ENT INTO DENTISTRY

JAZ:
The roof of the mouth is the floor of the nose, so ENT and dentistry should be well connected. There should be an open dialogue between ENT and dentistry. But is that the case? Hell no. That's why it's a huge honour to host Dr David McIntosh today. He's a world-renowned ear, nose and throat surgeon for adults and children, and the highly acclaimed author of books such as Snored to Death.

And you know what? Just like all the other Aussie guests we tend to have on, he's remarkable and so straight-talking. I love straight-talking guests, and he'll tell you how it is. He doesn't mince his words. His messaging is super clear, he's a real advocate for airway health, and he works very closely with dentists.

From this episode, you'll learn why sleep studies don't always give you the full picture of your patient's condition. You'll also find out why David thinks you shouldn't see a myofunctional therapist before you've seen an ENT. It's actually controversial, but anatomically it makes sense. He talks a lot about understanding the underlying cause of sleep apnoea, and the concept of phenotyping patients, which I absolutely love.

I do this in occlusion. When I'm assessing occlusions, I kind of phenotype them, so it was really lovely to hear his perspective on phenotyping patients with sleep-disordered breathing. You'll learn the four key questions to ask to accurately screen children for sleep disorders, and why women experience sleep-disordered breathing differently from men, with different symptoms and different challenges.

Hello, Protruserati. I'm Jaz Gulati, and welcome back to your favourite dental podcast. I tell you, this episode with David is going in the Protrusive Hall of Fame. It's been a long time coming, and I love the title: Putting the ENT into Dentistry.

CHAPTER 2: PROTRUSIVE DENTAL PEARL: THE AHI NUMBERS ARE ARBITRARY

JAZ:
If you're new to the podcast, you've picked a bloody good one to join us on. Every main episode we have a Protrusive Dental Pearl. Today's pearl comes from the main part of the episode, and it's about how much we love data. As dentists, we absolutely love data. We like numbers. We like stats.

But I'm going to give you a cautionary warning when it comes to data in sleep-disordered breathing. Take the AHI, the apnoea-hypopnoea index. We look at these numbers: over 30 is severe, over five is mild, and there's moderate in between. And all these numbers are made up.

They're all arbitrary, which is why you should take them with a pinch of salt. These numbers don't account for individual patient variability, especially in women and children, who can have mild scores but really significant symptoms. That's why we need to combine the numerical score with the individual's anatomy and phenotype, the clinical signs and the anatomical assessment, and we're going to deep dive into this today. I won't take up any more of your time. Enjoy this episode, and I'll catch you in the outro.

CHAPTER 3: MEET DR DAVID MCINTOSH, AND WHO OWNS SLEEP-DISORDERED BREATHING

JAZ:
Okay, Dr David McIntosh, ENT, welcome to the Protrusive Dental Podcast. It's an absolute honour to have you here to discuss a super important topic. I'm itching to learn more about your world and, more importantly, how our worlds can work better together.

I'm sure you've got lots of strong opinions there. For those who haven't come across your work before, give us a little bio.

DR DAVID MCINTOSH:
Yeah, sure. First of all, thank you for having me. It's a real privilege and an honour to be here. As you highlighted, I'm an ear, nose and throat doctor. The accent might give away that I'm not from your neck of the woods. I'm from Australia. And my journey has been a blend of fortuitous moments, being in the right place at the right time for the right reasons.

That has led to me evolving as an ENT with a very particular niche interest in sleep-disordered breathing, and in understanding the overlap between my specialty and dentistry. I've got a broad understanding of a lot of what's going on in the dental world, from a pathology and patient management point of view, where the outcomes are substantially better when we all work together.

In that context, as I say, teamwork makes the dream work. We're going to get the breathing sorted and the sleep sorted, but we need to manage all the contributing factors. Me ignoring dentistry would be like dentistry ignoring ENT. It doesn't make sense. There's so much co-pathology in a lot of these patients that we can collectively make a big difference to. So that's me in a nutshell.

JAZ:
Thank you so much. Well, the roof of the mouth is the floor of the nose, right? It took me far too long in my career to realise that. Obviously, from anatomy, you know a skull, you know that. But the actual relevance of it... In dentistry we get so into composite resins and so on, and we realise this too late in our journey. It's not the fault of dental schools per se, 'cause they've got to make us safe beginners, but there's so much we owe it to our patients to learn about.

I'm sure dentists have come to you and thanked you for opening their eyes to various aspects. One interesting thing you said is that you're an ENT, but you've niched into sleep-disordered breathing. Is there a fine line between what you do and a full-on sleep physician?

Because that takes me nicely to my first question, which is about the stakeholders in sleep-disordered breathing.

DR DAVID MCINTOSH:
Yeah.

JAZ:
From my perspective as a lowly dentist, the sleep doctor, the sleep physician, is like the king. What they say goes. Then you've got the ENT perspective, and ENTs are involved. But sometimes they don't get involved. Sometimes it goes straight to the sleep physician and stays there, and the ENT, rightly or wrongly, never gets to give an input, and sometimes even the dentist doesn't get to play.

So where do you think the state of care is at the moment, and what would you wish it to be, if you wish it were different?

CHAPTER 4: CHILDREN VS ADULTS, MEN VS WOMEN: WHY SLEEP-DISORDERED BREATHING ISN'T ONE DISEASE

DR DAVID MCINTOSH:
Sure. There are a lot of nuances to the answer. The first thing to highlight is that systems of management are totally different from one country to the next.

So when I give these answers, there's always a bias towards what I know, which doesn't necessarily match up perfectly with what you know. That's just because different countries do the same thing in different ways. It's not that anyone's right or wrong, but it's worth highlighting as we go.

The other nuance is that we need to be very pedantic about not talking about this subject as if children and adults are the same, because they're absolutely not. There's such a marked difference between sleep-disordered breathing in children and in adults. And in adults, again, there's generally a marked difference between women and men.

One of the problems with this conversation is that everybody throws it all in the same bucket. It'd be like saying you've got arthritis. From a medical point of view, we understand what that means: one or more of your joints are sore. But is it from wear and tear, osteoarthritis?

Is it from an autoimmune disease, rheumatoid arthritis? Is it because it's infected, septic arthritis? And so forth. As a word, arthritis is a generic signpost that doesn't mean anything other than a sore joint. And it's the same with sleep-disordered breathing.

As a term, it doesn't mean the same thing in a child as in an adult. That's why, when I talk about this, I say "paediatric sleep-disordered breathing", to emphasise that's the context. I know this is going to be a long-winded answer, and I should have warned you that I'm very good at long-winded answers.

But I think we'll lay some foundations here that will make the rest of this easy, so let's get those out of the way. The next foundation is: what is sleep-disordered breathing? Don't worry, I haven't forgotten your question, but I want to lay some foundations.

JAZ:
Yeah, sure.

DR DAVID MCINTOSH:
Sleep-disordered breathing is not the same as obstructive sleep apnoea. Sleep-disordered breathing covers the whole gamut of upper airway obstruction, of which obstructive sleep apnoea is the worst part. I'm bringing this up because you mentioned sleep physicians.

The role of the sleep physician is to oversee a sleep study to determine the underlying sleep disorder. The most common one is sleep-disordered breathing, and sleep studies, in children and adults alike, are designed to diagnose obstructive sleep apnoea.

That tells you whether you've got obstructive sleep apnoea. It doesn't tell you why. This is like my arthritis example, and I can give you a perfect example in adults. Both of these people have obstructive sleep apnoea.

Person number one is a 47-year-old male with a BMI of 49. Person number two is a 42-year-old female with a BMI of 20. Which of those makes sense to you in terms of having that level of AHI? In the guy carrying an enormous amount of weight, it makes sense. But for the woman, it makes no sense, because she's not overweight.

And the reason is that we're just measuring a number. We've got the same diagnosis, but totally different causes. With the guy, you'd say, "All right, it's 'cause he's overweight," and ask whether other factors are contributing. But at the end of the day, being massively overweight is the bigger picture.

Whereas the woman I described probably has some nasal congestion, some nasal obstruction, long-standing issues that have led to mouth breathing, with skeletal deficiency. So she's got some orthognathic issues in the mix, and she's got problems maintaining her pharyngeal tone, because in women, pharyngeal tone, which is the throat staying open at night, decreases with age.

Plus, women are more vulnerable to even minor degrees of airway obstruction, for a whole host of background reasons. So it's quite possible that the woman I mentioned, who looks perfectly fit and healthy on paper, could be symptomatically a lot worse than that massively overweight guy.

That's the number one problem I want to highlight with just measuring things from a sleep study. It gives you no information about why. It tells you nothing about that person and why they've got it. And the next problem is that the sleep study only picks up the worst part, obstructive sleep apnoea.

CHAPTER 5: WHY A NORMAL SLEEP STUDY DOESN'T MEAN NORMAL BREATHING

DR DAVID MCINTOSH:
Let me give you another example. With diabetes, we do a blood test and measure your blood sugar. And we have lines in the sand. We actually have two: one that says you're diabetic, and one that says you're pre-diabetic.

The third category is normal. Whereas a sleep study measures whether you have obstructive sleep apnoea or not, when the real line in the sand is whether you have sleep-disordered breathing or not. That's the problem with a sleep study: a normal sleep study does not mean normal breathing.

So a huge range of people can have these sleep studies and be given false reassurance that they're normal, when that's not necessarily true. The next issue with putting a lot of faith in sleep studies is that one night's sleep is different from the next, and the next, and the next.

The science shows that you need to measure four nights of sleep in a row and average them to get a much more representative picture of what's going on. So that's the next problem. If you have your sleep study on a good night, you look good. If you had it the next night, you might look bad.

They've done this research. They've done sleep studies on the same person one night and then the next, and across the board, the difference is so significant that it changes the diagnosis, for better or worse, 40% of the time. So which one do you believe?

The good one or the bad one? If you didn't have both, you can only believe whichever version you scored at the time. Then the last part of all this is the numbers we use, the cut-off numbers. We talk about the apnoea-hypopnoea index, the AHI.

That was created as a research tool back in the day, as a way of monitoring progress through therapy. And the numbers changed as the technology changed. Then we realised children have obstructive sleep apnoea, so we started doing sleep studies in children, and, for no good reason, used adult numbers as the initial thresholds.

Then we realised, "Oh no, children aren't the same as adults," and we changed the numbers. For those familiar with sleep studies, you'll have heard that in adults an AHI of five or more is diagnostic of obstructive sleep apnoea, and in children an AHI of one or more. So I'll put you on the spot. Do you know what research was done to determine those numbers?

JAZ:
I don't, but I'm really fascinated by this, because my eldest, who's going to be seven soon, when he was four, I pushed for a sleep study, and yes, he had mild sleep apnoea. He had his adenoids removed, and suddenly he was a quiet breather at night. It was huge.

And my youngest, who's going to be three next week, was actually diagnosed with moderate sleep apnoea, so his AHI was higher than my older son's. He's got his baby teeth, crowding in his baby teeth, all sorts, and he's such a noisy breather. Last night I was sleeping with him and he was snoring. So I don't know where the numbers come from, but I'm definitely interested in what you have to say.

DR DAVID MCINTOSH:
Yeah, that's easy. There wasn't any.

JAZ:
Okay. Wow.

DR DAVID MCINTOSH:
The numbers are made up. There's no epidemiology that supports those numbers. Zero. The reason I wanted to highlight that is that we have one element of assessment determining a lifetime of care, with all the flaws that come with it, and the excuse is that we don't have anything better, so we just keep doing it.

I just want to highlight it, so people can fact-check me and look it up. This is the reality of it all. So the big one for me is that a normal sleep study does not mean normal breathing. Not even close.

CHAPTER 6: CPAP: A PUMP FOR A BLOCKED SINK

DR DAVID MCINTOSH:
The next thing I want to highlight is the pathway that excludes ENT and dentistry: CPAP treatment. It's quite common here in Australia for adults to have a sleep study, be diagnosed with obstructive sleep apnoea, and be given CPAP.

JAZ:
So in Australia, is it the sleep physician who diagnoses it and then helps them with the CPAP, or does ENT come into it?

DR DAVID MCINTOSH:
It's diagnosed by a sleep physician, who then prescribes CPAP. And CPAP is an Australian invention. The inventor created it as a temporary measure until the underlying causes could be identified and addressed. To identify the underlying causes, you need to see someone who looks inside the nose and throat, and at the end of the day there's only one group of doctors who do that, and that's us.

Remember the example I gave of the guy versus the woman. When it comes to CPAP in adults, two-thirds of patients are no longer using it within 12 months. And a lot of the reason they're not using it is underlying ENT pathology that's compromising how well it can work.

For example, they broke their nose 20 years ago and their nose is blocked, or they've got allergies, whatever. They can't breathe through their nose, they're put on nasal CPAP, it doesn't work, so the pressure has to go up. Putting the pressure up makes it really uncomfortable.

It's no good. Then they get the full-face mask, which feels terrible and has to be strapped on tight, they get bloating from it, and they just give up and say, "This is worse than what I had to start with." The problem is that CPAP is a really good management tool. It doesn't fix the problem, and it relies on being used, and on everything being optimised for it to work properly.

So if the person has a blocked nose or big tonsils, for example, you're swimming against the tide until those things are out of the way. I have this analogy. Say you go into your kitchen and notice the sink is blocked, so you call a plumber to unblock it.

That's what you expect: they'll come and look through the pipes. But instead, the plumber puts a pump next to your sink and says, "Just push this button. It'll force the water through whenever you want it to." You'd be pretty annoyed that they didn't look at the underlying reason the sink was blocked.

JAZ:
That's a brilliant analogy. I love that.

DR DAVID MCINTOSH:
Yeah. But we readily accept providing CPAP to people who've had an investigation that confirms they've got blockages, which doesn't tell you why, and they just get this generic treatment. And one more thing I want to highlight: I've lost count now.

It's more than 10 cases where an upper airway malignancy presented with snoring and obstruction, which was then treated with CPAP, because nobody looked.

JAZ:
So is that because we're not looking enough? Once the sleep physician makes the diagnosis and prescribes CPAP, if the score's better and everything's better, that's okay.

So perhaps what you're saying is that healthcare is a bit disjointed, and there should be a clearer pathway, where once a patient gets CPAP, ENT is automatically involved, rather than it being something you have to fight for. It should be more standardised. Is that a fair way to put it?

CHAPTER 7: PHENOTYPING: WHAT AN ENT LOOKS FOR, AND WHAT SCANS MISS

DR DAVID MCINTOSH:
Yeah. My approach is pretty simple. Any suggestion of snoring, nasal obstruction or mouth breathing is ENT territory as a starting point. Get one of us to physically look, so we can do what's called phenotyping. That means we can say, "This person is of normal body weight, has a deviated septum to the left, has changes of allergic rhinitis with turbinate congestion, and has residual adenoids secondary to underlying reflux, which in its own right has resulted in lingual tonsil hypertrophy.

"There's also associated pharyngeal tonsil hypertrophy. They have relative macroglossia, a narrow maxilla and a retruded mandible." That's phenotyping. It lays out all the dynamics of what's going on in that person anatomically, and serves as touch points for what needs to be sorted.

So that person needs their nose fixed, their allergies managed and their reflux treated. They might need their tonsils out. They might need a tongue volume reduction. They need some form of management of their skeletal deficiencies, one way or another, whether with a splint or orthognathic surgery or variations on that theme, because we know why, and it's totally different from one person to the next.

That's how it should be. And part of that assessment, which is where it blends into dentistry with adults, is working out whether that person is a candidate for a mandibular advancement splint, 'cause it doesn't work for everybody. They won't tolerate it if their nose is blocked. And there's this argument: do you use the splint or CPAP?

What's lost in that conversation is that some people actually need both, and some do really, really well with both. They're going to need the CPAP, but they've got lower airway compromise and collapse, and mandibular advancement mitigates some, most or all of that. That then allows the CPAP to be used at much more tolerable pressures, so compliance increases and management improves.

So, looking at how this whole journey should work: obstructive sleep apnoea is a disease of the upper airway, and that needs to be clinically assessed. I know you can do it with scans, but that's not the same.

There are a whole lot of extra layers we can assess in real time. Not to undermine you, but scans are a great tool and they don't tell you everything. If you get a scan of the nose, for example, around 10 to 15% of the time, because of the way the scan technology is designed, it will miss a deviated septum. So you can have a normal scan.

JAZ:
What kind of scan is this, sorry? What kind of imaging?

DR DAVID MCINTOSH:
A CBCT. It's far better than plain films. Plain films are like looking at clouds, or through muddy water. From a medical ENT point of view, it's, "Oh yeah, let's get some proper X-rays now."

Or, to be honest, let's look at the real thing. But even a good-quality CBCT will miss and under-represent deviated septums. So again, you can be misled by a measurement tool you put full faith in, without realising that, at the end of the day, there are some things you still need someone like me to do.

It also helps map out the plan, 'cause a lot of patients feel lost on this journey. They've had the sleep study, they got the CPAP, they hated it, and they don't know there's anything else they can do. It hasn't even crossed their mind to ask, "Why have I got this?"

I've had patients come in and say, "Oh yeah, I've had a sleep study. I've got sleep apnoea." I ask, "So why have you got sleep apnoea?" "Oh, because they found it on the sleep study." That's their level of understanding.

JAZ:
I can relate to that a lot, and I often think about this. It's the first time I've verbalised it, and I might be talking utter crap here, but hear me out. I'm not into dogs, so we've never had one, but my friends have dogs. And there are certain breeds that we know, because of their anatomy, their phenotype, as you said,

are very likely to have sleep apnoea later in life. Pugs are one of them, I think.

DR DAVID MCINTOSH:
Yeah, big time. Pugs are one of the worst.

JAZ:
Exactly. So is there a population of people, from a certain country or with a certain genotype, where we think, "This population, in the absence of weight gain"... Obviously adding weight can affect all populations.

But in this population, because of their very small mandibles, they're just likely to have sleep apnoea. At what point do we say, "Actually, this is normal for this population," or, "Actually, this is still pathology, and we can still add years to their life"?

It's something I think about, but I've never verbalised it.

DR DAVID MCINTOSH:
Yeah. We live in a blended world these days, so rather than talking about countries, it's probably more about the city people have grown up in than their country of origin. And nothing dramatic really shows up in terms of a disparity, except in one context: Indigenous people versus everybody else.

In the original Indigenous population of Australia, the jaw structures are far broader and more developed. We speculate that it has something to do with diet, because they eat more fibrous foods, whereas in the Western cultures we've grown up in, we eat processed foods. There might be some epigenetics playing into that, and skeletal deficiencies flowing on from that lack of stimulation.

Whereas elsewhere, these Indigenous tribes are literally chewing on roots and all sorts of things that are quite fibrous and tough, and getting a bit of a workout. I don't know. It's an interesting observation, for sure.

But we're definitely talking about something that's on the rise more than it ever used to be, and I think a multitude of factors are playing into that. There's the ENT part, the dental part, and the allergy part in particular. Those are probably the big three moving pieces blending into this overall problem.

CHAPTER 8: STOP-BANG AND EPWORTH: WHY THE SCREENING TOOLS FAIL WOMEN

JAZ:
Well, two things us dentists are taught are that, ideally, every patient needs a STOP-Bang and an Epworth Sleepiness Scale. Do you think that's enough, or should we add other things? Or perhaps you have a criticism of STOP-Bang, and we actually need to look at other things.

For example, we need to take the STOP-Bang and Epworth into account, but also look at the anatomy, listen to the symptoms and look for the signs, and sometimes override the data and go by the patient's anatomy.

DR DAVID MCINTOSH:
Yep. All right. Again, I'm going to wave the Australian flag. The Epworth Sleepiness Scale is an Australian thing. It came out of Epworth Hospital here in Australia. It's a measurement of, as it says, sleepiness. That basically represents your pathology and your intrinsic resilience to it. People can have horrendous obstructive sleep apnoea and feel absolutely fine.

So it's a very blunt tool. My criticism of STOP-Bang is that, again, it's predominantly an adult tool. We have a paediatric sleep questionnaire, BEARS and all sorts of things for kids, but STOP-Bang is for adults. And if you put the STOP-Bang in front of you and we go point by point, male versus female, you'll start to see why it's an issue.

JAZ:
Thank you to the ABC of Anaesthesia Instagram page, which has a lovely image of this. Okay.

DR DAVID MCINTOSH:
S is for snoring, snoring loudly. That's very typical for men, but not for women. So if you're a guy, there's a gender bias towards you getting a point, and a woman will miss out.

Tired in the day applies to both genders. Observed apnoeas is more of a male pattern than a female one, for a couple of reasons. One is that men tend to snore more, which keeps their female partners awake, so the women notice when they stop breathing.

Whereas women tend to mouth breathe and breathe noisily rather than snore. Plus, men sleep through the noise, so they're not witnesses. So again, it's gender-specific in what it leans towards, which means that, as a woman, you're disadvantaged on this scale.

JAZ:
Okay, can I just stop you there and ask about that one? The way I ask it is, "Has anyone observed you stop breathing at night?"

DR DAVID MCINTOSH:
Yeah, stop breathing or choking.

JAZ:
And I was taught that if someone answers yes to this, it should perhaps carry quite a high weighting, and it's more likely to lead to a positive result, or a higher AHI. Do you have views on that?

DR DAVID MCINTOSH:
Yeah. The answer is yes, but there is no weighting. It's one or zero. It's binary. And that's the big problem when we look at the paediatric scores too, which we can look at as well. High blood pressure is far more typical in men than women. BMI is far more typical of the male pattern of disease than the female pattern.

Age discriminates against women, because women tend to start getting this in perimenopause, which is give or take 40 onwards. So they potentially have to live through a whole decade of misery before they score a point for being old enough to have the problem. Neck circumference ties in with obesity, which again is more of a male pattern of disease than a female one.

And gender: men score a point just for being men. They get a free kick. You have to score, I think, five or six out of eight, depending on which country you're in. Women can at best score seven, because they can't get the point for being male, so they're discriminated against straight off.

Plus, they miss out on the point for snoring, the point for observed apnoeas, the point for high blood pressure, the point for BMI, the point for age, and often the point for neck circumference. So honestly, the STOP-Bang is useful if you're a guy, but useless if you're female.

JAZ:
If you were to redesign it and have a female version of STOP-Bang, what other points could you add that a dentist would find useful?

DR DAVID MCINTOSH:
In women, you're looking for nasal congestion, tiredness again, brain fog, particularly in the mornings, and headaches with no clear cause. For those reasons, those would be far more relevant in women than anything on that list.

So when people ask me about these rating scales, my big gripe is that men and women are not the same when it comes to upper airway obstruction. There's a lot of different phenotyping that comes into it, and a lot of other elements in how it presents.

It's particularly common for women to get away with it until menopause comes along. When menopause arrives, their nasal congestion starts to increase and the tone of the pharynx, the lower part of the throat, starts to decrease. So they have the perfect storm: a nose that's blocked and a throat that collapses.

That's why they go along fine and then just fall in a heap. The upside is that they're much easier to manage. The majority just need their nose fixed and a mandibular advancement splint, and they're back on track. But again, that's why someone like me needs to look.

Because otherwise this is all speculation. At the end of the day, it's all got to come down to the individual.

CHAPTER 9: WHY WOMEN ARE HIT HARDER, AND WHY TMD PATIENTS SHOULD SEE ENT FIRST

JAZ:
I've got a patient at the moment whose TMD I'm managing. She's super slim, the loveliest lady. Her sleep quality is always important. I've been on her case: "Hey, we need to look after your sleep. We need to get your sleep assessed." Should my next move be to provide a sleep test, or should I in fact refer to ENT? Because, as you said, she'd score very low on STOP-Bang.

DR DAVID MCINTOSH:
Yeah. She won't score on STOP-Bang. On the Epworth, women might score a bit higher, because they tend to be more tired, as they're more vulnerable to even minor degrees of obstruction. Women usually end up at the low end of severity, as we'd measure it on a sleep study.

But they're at the high end of symptoms, because they're more vulnerable. They have less resilience to the problem. Again, I have an analogy. Compare me with a UFC fighter. If I punch the UFC fighter, he'll just look at me and say, "Is that all you've got?"

He punches me back, and I'm on the ground crying for the next hour, and he says, "I wasn't even trying." It's the same with upper airway obstruction. The same punch has a very different impact on different people.

I could probably hit pretty hard, but to a UFC fighter it means nothing. I'm not advocating violence. I'm just trying to emphasise that the same thing has a different impact.

It's the same with measuring it. An AHI of 12 in a woman and an AHI of 12 in a man look exactly the same on paper. But for that woman, it's almost certainly an absolute disaster for her health and wellbeing, yet she just gets labelled as mild. And that's the next problem with mild, moderate and severe: they're just made-up numbers as well.

JAZ:
Yeah, definitely. What you said about where the numbers come from has been quite eye-opening. But for my patient, should I be getting the sleep test first, or going straight to ENT?

DR DAVID MCINTOSH:
Straight to ENT. Upper airway obstruction, TMD and ortho are basically a triad. They all overlap and interplay. TMD is often tied in with bruxism and clenching, and the number one most common cause of clenching and bruxing at night is upper airway obstruction.

Number two is low iron, and again, women cop that, and kids too, for different reasons. Number three is nasal allergies, and the problem is you can have all of the above going on.

You can have nasal allergies combined with low iron, making breathing and sleep an issue. You go into physiological stress mode, so you're potentially clenching and grinding, and then your TMD starts to play up. And because upper airway obstruction mucks up your sleep, it changes your pain threshold, so you're more vulnerable to experiencing pain as part of your wellbeing, or lack of it.

So get the ENT to look first: "Is there some low-hanging fruit here? Oh, your nose is actually blocked and congested. Let's try some nasal sprays, and then circle back to maybe surgery to really optimise this." Because often-

JAZ:
And should it be any ENT, or one who's declared an interest in sleep-disordered breathing?

DR DAVID MCINTOSH:
Ideally the latter, but in reality we tend to be a bit thin on the ground. It's an easy question to answer by analogy, though. In the dental world, you have oral and maxillofacial surgeons.

Some of them do cancer work, and the rest don't. But you don't think twice. You say, "That looks like a cancer. I'll send that to Mr Smith." Or, "That person's got a tricky seven. I'm not touching that one. I'll send it to Mr Jones."

They're both oral and maxillofacial surgeons, but you've done the filtering within the specialty: this one's for him, and that one's for her. You've got to do the same with your ENT.

But to do that, you've also got to educate your patients, and their parents, on why the person three bus rides and six interchanges away, across town in busy London traffic, is the person to see, rather than the one just around the corner. Because the one around the corner may specialise in something else entirely, like ear disease.

So it's not really their jam, in terms of what they focus on. And look, at the end of the day you just give people choices. It's the same with children. You say, "All right, I need to send you to the kids' ENT," or, "I need to send you to the adult ENT," or, "Guess what? This ENT does adults and kids." Great.

CHAPTER 10: THE FOUR QUESTIONS TO SCREEN CHILDREN FOR SLEEP-DISORDERED BREATHING

JAZ:
Looking at the Paediatric Sleep Questionnaire: the total PSQ can be divided into four subscales: breathing, behaviour, sleepiness and other. A total score above 0.33, so 33% of questions answered positively, suggests sleep-disordered breathing, with a sensitivity of 81% and specificity of 87% in the general paediatric population.

DR DAVID MCINTOSH:
Yep. Now go back to the questionnaire and read out question six.

JAZ:
Okay. "Have you ever seen your child stop breathing?"

DR DAVID MCINTOSH:
Okay. If the answer to that question is yes, the rest of the questions don't matter.

JAZ:
Oh, yeah. This is my son, absolutely.

DR DAVID MCINTOSH:
But that rating scale doesn't allow for that.

JAZ:
Yeah. Again, there's no weighting.

DR DAVID MCINTOSH:
That's really the first question to ask, and if the answer is yes, nothing else matters. It really doesn't. When we break this down, it's got 22 questions, but honestly, there aren't many you need to worry about.

Question one: does your child stop breathing at night? Yes? Fine. Go and see the ENT. Let's work out what's going on. Does your child snore at night? Yes? Okay, go and see the ENT. Does your child mouth breathe through the night? Yes? Okay, go and see the ENT, and work out what's going on.

And question four: is your child tired in the morning? If the answer is yes, go and see the ENT straight away, 'cause that child's in trouble. That's all you need to ask. The rest is just window dressing. It really is. Because any sign of airway obstruction, whether it shows up as mouth breathing, snoring, or, in the worst case, stopping breathing, is sleep-disordered breathing.

That's the spectrum, right there. And children fall into two groups: those who are tired, and those who aren't. Those who are tired have burnt through their resilience, whatever they had, and everyone has an intrinsic amount, a little or a lot.

When they're tired, you've run out of time. You've got zero time. If they're not tired, you've got time, but don't waste it. Get them seen and looked at. Because tiredness, independent of any other question, sleep study measurement or anything at all, is the big indicator of the lifelong harm this child faces from unaddressed upper airway obstruction.

So when you look at the PSQ-22 and all its questions, again, there's no weighting. There should be a section one and a section two. If you pass section one, you'd have to do some pretty heavy lifting to score enough to justify being assessed.

But if you just put the child through this filter, snoring, mouth breathing, stopping breathing at night and tiredness, those four questions are all you need. We can add a lot of other layers. Does your child sleepwalk, sleep-talk or grind their teeth at night? Do they sweat at night? Are they restless? Are they waking through the night?

Are they showing daytime problems, such as learning problems, behaviour problems, emotional regulation problems, poor energy, their education not going so well, hyperactivity? We can add these extra layers, but they don't change the fundamentals.

This is about making something complicated simple. Mouth breathing, snoring, stopping breathing at night, and tiredness. Four questions, done. Someone like me can work out the rest. At a basic level, you're in the dental clinic thinking, "Gosh, I don't have time to ask this parent 22 questions and work it all out."

So you don't even need to. You put them on the intake form-

JAZ:
And there are things we look for, like a narrow palate and crowding. But even at the history-taking level, those four questions are so powerful. I'll make sure we collate them in a document as the heavy filter we can use, to work more closely with ENT.

CHAPTER 11: WHY MYOFUNCTIONAL THERAPY BEFORE AN ENT OPINION CAN BE DANGEROUS

JAZ:
But here's an interesting curveball: myofunctional therapists. I've recorded a few episodes on this, which will probably be out by the time this one is. Myofunctional therapy is essentially about how we get kids breathing through their nose. Dentists are catching on, getting a bit wiser, and starting to refer these mouth-breathing children to myo.

But, as I said at the beginning, that channel between dentistry and ENT, especially in the UK, has barriers, healthcare and government issues. The waiting time for my child was over two years, David.

DR DAVID MCINTOSH:
Which is too long.

JAZ:
For a kid who's not breathing properly. So I went privately to get it all sorted, because, thankfully, I could. I couldn't see my child suffering that way, and thankfully it's an area I'm interested in. A lot of dentists come to me now saying, "Hey, my child's doing this kind of stuff, but I don't know what to do about it."

So even dentists are a bit lost. Going back to the main point: do you think it could be dangerous, or a mistake, for dentists to send a child to myofunctional therapy to convert them from mouth breathing to nasal breathing without first getting an ENT opinion?

DR DAVID MCINTOSH:
Yeah. The short answer is yes, because we know that 80 to 90% of mouth breathing is due to some form of anatomical obstruction. It's not a habit. It's survival. It's an alternative way to breathe, and most of the time they're breathing around a problem. From an ENT point of view, it falls into four big things: adenoids, turbinates, deviated septum, and the one that throws a lot of people, tonsils.

You might ask, "How do tonsils cause mouth breathing? They're in the throat." They are in the throat, but at the back of it, and they're three-dimensional structures. We're used to looking at them front on, and we don't think about how round they are, or that they extend forwards and backwards as well.

Think about where they physically sit. When you breathe through your nose, air passes through the nasal passages, through what's called the nasopharynx or postnasal space, past the soft palate and past the tonsils. If the tonsils are big, they block nasal airflow, so the child mouth breathes. So those are the big four.

Around two-thirds of the time, skeletal deficiencies are blended in, which means the nasal passages, nasopharynx and oropharynx are all smaller, so the ENT pathology doesn't have to be as bad to show up and cause blockages.

So, like I said, 80 to 90% of the time, mouth breathing is due to an anatomical obstruction. Now, if you broke your leg and I said, "You can't walk, so I'll send you to a physio to do some walking exercises so you can walk again while your leg is still broken"...

It's exactly the same thing. You're trying to get a child to do something around a problem. That's not setting them up for success. And there's a huge danger in it, from two perspectives. One is the damage it does to the supporting structure of the outer nose. The other is what it does to the heart.

Unless you have a deep understanding of anatomy and physiology, what I've just said will go straight past you, so let me try to help. You work in dentistry. You've got suction, right? Have you ever had a moment, and you may not have, where whoever you were working for bought some really cheap suction, you plugged it into the machine, and the tubing collapsed in on itself?

JAZ:
Thankfully, that hasn't happened, but I can imagine it.

DR DAVID MCINTOSH:
You've been lucky. Basically, the tubing collapses because it can't cope with the pressure of the air flowing through it. Air flowing through a tube naturally tends to make the walls collapse inwards.

And the nose is no different. The way to get someone to breathe through their nose when there's a blockage is to make them breathe harder. That's how you overcome it. If something's heavy, what do you do? You push harder. You lift harder. And if something's blocked?

You breathe harder. You can force someone to breathe through their nose, past the obstruction, by making them breathe harder. But that also changes the air pressure, and it increases the suction effect of breathing in. If you have a squiz at your nose, at the outer part, it shouldn't collapse when you breathe in.

The reason it shouldn't collapse is that there's springy cartilage on the sides that resists it. But cartilage, like a lot of things in life, drags and sags over time. It's elastic, like a rubber band. You stretch a rubber band again and again and again,

and eventually it loses its elasticity. It doesn't snap back. And the nose is the same. That cartilage can lose its strength, and the nose starts to collapse inwards on itself. That's what we call nasal valve collapse, and it's really hard to fix, especially in a kid.

The second thing is understanding some cardiovascular physiology. In simple terms, the heart pumps blood from the left side to the body, round the arteries and through the organs. It's collected in the veins and goes back to the right side of the heart. For anything above the heart, gravity is the main driver getting the blood back.

But everything below the heart needs some form of pump to get the blood back, and one of those pumps is breathing. When we breathe in, the chest wall expands and the diaphragm moves. That creates negative pressure in the chest cavity, which draws air in, but it also draws blood in.

So breathing is one of the ways we improve blood return to the heart. If we breathe harder, we increase the amount of blood coming back to the heart. And the right side of the heart isn't geared to deal with high-volume return.

The right side of the heart doesn't usually work very hard. All it has to do is pump blood through the lungs to the left side, so it's a low-pressure system. But when you increase the amount of blood it has to pump, the right side of the heart has to squeeze harder, and that puts a strain on it.

That's called right heart strain. So you can actually induce heart disease by forcing someone to breathe through an obstruction.

JAZ:
And you think this could potentially be happening out there? Myofunctional therapists are well-intentioned, but to overcome the nasal obstruction, they provide techniques to breathe through that narrowed or blocked area, which could cause those two issues.

DR DAVID MCINTOSH:
Yeah, I've seen it happen. This is not speculation. I've seen it happen.

JAZ:
So you don't use myofunctional therapy for your patients?

DR DAVID MCINTOSH:
Not as a starting point, any more than an orthopaedic surgeon uses a physio before the fracture is fixed. That's the first thing.

The second thing, and this is important to understand, is what happens when you force the issue. Children are survival machines. This kid has worked out, subconsciously, that their nose doesn't work properly, and that mouth breathing solves it. It's not as if the kid woke up one day and thought, "Oh, stuff it, I'm going to mouth breathe, 'cause my nose is no good." They just fall into it because that's what they have to do to survive.

JAZ:
The path of least resistance.

DR DAVID MCINTOSH:
Yeah, exactly. Then you come along and start trying to force it. But the kid's brain knows that what you're trying to do doesn't work. So what you're actually embedding is a neural pathway of resistance to nasal breathing in the long run, because the brain is learning even more strongly that this is a bad idea.

So it's about having the right thing at the right time. It's like doing a filling: do you drill out the hole first and then place the filling, or place the filling first and then drill it out?

JAZ:
Of course.

DR DAVID MCINTOSH:
It's no different. You address the underlying problem first, and then provide the therapy that appropriately follows on from it.

JAZ:
So, to summarise: myo is useful for training someone to breathe through their nose, but only once the obstruction has been tackled.

DR DAVID MCINTOSH:
It's rehabilitation. It makes sure all the dysfunctions that have developed can be remedied, but you've got to deal with the underlying issue first.

CHAPTER 12: MAXILLARY EXPANSION OR SURGERY? IT DEPENDS ON THE CHILD

JAZ:
Okay. Well, David, final two questions, 'cause of time. You see all the stuff dentists put out there, and particularly with your algorithms, what you speak about and the conferences you go to, you'll come across more and more dentists and orthodontists who call themselves "airway-centric".

Is there something in the world of airway-centric dentistry that you disagree with and would like to publicly dispute?

DR DAVID MCINTOSH:
Yeah, that's a fair call. I think the big one is maxillary expansion, and what it does and doesn't do. People ask which fixes sleep-disordered breathing better, surgery or maxillary expansion. There's a problem with the question.

The problem is that it depends on what's wrong with the person. If the person-

JAZ:
What kind of surgery, though? I'm just trying to-

DR DAVID MCINTOSH:
Let me give you an example. If the person has no ENT pathology whatsoever, zero, but they've got skeletal deficiencies, which is the best treatment for that person?

JAZ:
Expansion.

DR DAVID MCINTOSH:
Expansion. Okay. Now, at the other extreme, this person has big tonsils and adenoids, but perfect skeletal form and function, absolutely perfect, no equivocating or cherry-picking. Which one do they need?

JAZ:
So, surgery.

DR DAVID MCINTOSH:
Surgery. Got it. All right. Now we come to where it blends together, because two-thirds of the time these kids, and we're talking kids, have both. So which is better, surgery or maxillary expansion?

JAZ:
I'm going to jump in and say, only from the lectures I've been to and the profound effect that removing the tonsils and adenoids can have on a child's breathing, I'd lean towards surgery.

DR DAVID MCINTOSH:
I'm going to tell you both. I gave you the two extremes, and everything in between is a blend. So it depends where that person is on the spectrum. If they've got both, but a little bit of ENT and a lot of orthodontic, they'll get most of the benefit from the orthodontic management.

But if they've got a little bit of orthodontic and a lot of ENT, they'll get most of the benefit from the ENT side. And that's the problem: we're trying to treat this as one disease that fits everybody, which means one treatment that fits everybody, and that's just not the case.

JAZ:
Here's a question to help us, then. Tonsils we can see. We get the patient to stick their tongue out, and we can see the tonsils. If they're touching, that's bad. If they're generally big, that's bad. But how can dentists make a call on adenoids?

DR DAVID MCINTOSH:
Okay. It depends on what radiology you have in your practice.

JAZ:
OPGs?

DR DAVID MCINTOSH:
Two things: either a lateral ceph, which is pretty basic but better than nothing, or a CBCT. I don't know where the UK is with CBCT, but from what I gather, the approach over there is pretty archaic, whereas the rest of the world has basically moved on.

JAZ:
Zapping everyone.

DR DAVID MCINTOSH:
Yeah, we've already moved on. But again, different countries have different mindsets, and that's a you problem. So you can appraise the adenoids from your imaging. Otherwise you can't, any more than...

You can't expect an ENT to assess orthodontic and dental issues to the level you can. So it doesn't work the other way either. I wouldn't expect a dentist to appraise tonsils, adenoids, nasal allergies, a deviated septum and so on the way I can. But I've been doing this long enough to look inside a kid and say, "You know what?

"This one needs surgery. This one needs surgery and expansion. This one needs just expansion." It's a spectrum, and it's kid by kid by kid. And in the majority, two-thirds, like I said, it's both. We're having these stupid territorial arguments

when two-thirds of the time it's a mutual problem. So let's put any pretend differences aside and accept that this kid has landed with two problems. It doesn't matter which caused what. We've got to fix it. Now, I'll circle back to what you said: surgery is your quick fix.

Again, my analogy: a child who can't swim falls off a boat into the ocean and is drowning. That child needs two things. They need to be saved, and they need to learn how to swim. Which one are we going to do first?

JAZ:
Let's save that kid.

DR DAVID MCINTOSH:
We've got to save them. That's what we do. They still haven't learned how to swim, and there might be other things that need doing. We can look at all the reasons why after the event. But in the here and now, that child's drowning. Let's save them and have the other conversations later. They become academic, because we've got them out of trouble and bought some time, and then you can start teaching them how to swim.

What I mean is, get the surgery out of the way. Get the ENT stuff off the table. Then we can move on to the myo, the ortho and the allergy treatments, because we've bought the time that child needed, because that child was drowning.

So arguing about why the child couldn't swim is pointless, just as it's pointless trying to teach a child to breathe through their nose when they can't because they're blocked. Teaching a kid to swim is very important, but you don't teach them while they're drowning. It's not the right time.

CHAPTER 13: HOW DENTISTS AND ENTS CAN WORK TOGETHER, AND WHERE TO FIND DAVID

JAZ:
Brilliant. Another wonderful analogy. From the beginning of this episode, I think you've made a really good, logical case for the role ENTs can play, and why dentists and ENTs should connect more. I see some referrals from ENT for tinnitus where they've found no ENT issue, and then we try to manage the TMD in the hope that it will-

DR DAVID MCINTOSH:
The TMD, yeah.

JAZ:
Exactly. So there's a lot we can do together. What I love about this episode is that you gave us a simplified framework, with weighting, especially for children: those four questions to ask, which we'll put in the premium notes for this episode. And a good overview of adults, men versus women, and why there's a big difference.

DR DAVID MCINTOSH:
A huge difference.

JAZ:
And the reasons why ENT needs to be involved in many of these cases. You presented a very good, logical argument. David, where can we learn more from you and check out your work?

DR DAVID MCINTOSH:
Look, I'm a compulsive educator. As I tell people, there's no point in me knowing this and keeping it to myself. I'm up to book number nine on Amazon now, covering different contexts. There's one on adults, one on kids, and one about women. I have one dedicated specifically to the relationship between autism and ADHD and the spectrum of ENT pathology.

A lot of people who hear that think it's all about breathing and sleep. It's not. There are a lot of extra dynamics at play that people don't appreciate. I have one about mental health, one about dental health, and one just about sleep. So I have a range of touch points for people, to try to cover our bases.

They're all on Amazon. But in the meantime, there's everything you can get for free. Just jump on the socials. Use it for good, not evil, as a way of sharing the knowledge.

JAZ:
I definitely follow your page. That's where I found you, on your Facebook page. I'll add the links to the books, especially the dental one, as it's most relevant. I want to thank you for your time. I really like your direct style. You're so snappy and quick, you give us the answers, and you give us wonderful analogies to go with them, which is why you're a wonderful educator. David, thank you so much.

DR DAVID MCINTOSH:
Oh, it's been a real pleasure. Thank you so much, mate.

JAZ:
Well, there we have it, guys. I told you that was going to be a good one. I really enjoyed my chat with David, and I definitely want to invite him back next year, because he's just so straight-talking, and he gave us so many gems.

In fact, he gave us so much information that we've probably got some information overload, which is why you're going to love the Protrusive Premium Notes for this episode. And we've done something cool. We keep innovating and changing how we do things at Protrusive, and starting from this episode, we've completely revamped the way we present our Premium Notes to you.

We've been doing Premium Notes for some years now. Every episode gets summarised beautifully, and a lot of you like to print them out, annotate them and really cement your learning. But now we've upgraded your experience, and I hope you really enjoy the new-style Premium Notes. If you're a premium member, scroll down and download them, or check out the Protrusive Vault, and let us know what you think.

How do you find the new version? We've made it more readable, more concise, and very sleek and professional-looking. By the way, it's a great time to do a free trial of Protrusive and see what all the fuss is about. Download these Premium Notes and check them out for yourself.

It's the Protrusive Guidance app I'm talking about. Head over to protrusive.app, make an account, and start your free trial. This entire conversation with David also gets uploaded to AskJaz, our AI. You can pretty much chat with the podcast. Every episode we've ever done, and all our courses on Protrusive, feed millions of words into our own closed AI system.

It's closed on purpose, so you don't get interference from Google, Reddit and that kind of stuff. You get information from the Protrusive-verse. That's both a strength and a weakness, in my opinion. But if you love everything we do on this podcast, you'll love AskJaz. It really shines on clinical protocols.

Ask it about a clinical issue and try it for yourself. AskJaz is part of the Infinity plan on Protrusive, so head over and start your free trial to access it. This episode is eligible for CPD, and we are a PACE-approved education provider. Everything you need is at protrusive.app, and I'll see you on the app, my friends.

Once again, I hope you enjoyed this episode as much as I enjoyed recording it. I'll catch you same time, same place next week. Bye for now.

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS

QUESTION:
What is the difference between sleep-disordered breathing and obstructive sleep apnoea?
ANSWER:
David explains that sleep-disordered breathing covers the whole spectrum of upper airway obstruction during sleep, including snoring and mouth breathing. Obstructive sleep apnoea is the most severe part of that spectrum. Sleep studies are designed to diagnose obstructive sleep apnoea, so someone can have sleep-disordered breathing without meeting the threshold for sleep apnoea.

QUESTION:
Does a normal sleep study mean normal breathing?
ANSWER:
David says no. Sleep studies only detect obstructive sleep apnoea, so a normal result doesn't rule out sleep-disordered breathing. He adds that sleep varies from night to night, citing research where repeating the study changed the diagnosis 40% of the time, and that a study tells you a patient has sleep apnoea, but not why.

QUESTION:
Why do so many patients stop using CPAP?
ANSWER:
David says around two-thirds of adults stop using CPAP within 12 months, often because of untreated ENT problems such as a blocked nose, allergies, an old nasal fracture or large tonsils. These force higher pressures or a full-face mask, which patients find uncomfortable. He compares CPAP alone to a plumber pumping water through a blocked sink rather than clearing it.

QUESTION:
Is the STOP-Bang questionnaire reliable for women?
ANSWER:
David argues STOP-Bang is biased towards men. Women can't score the point for male gender, and are less likely to score for loud snoring, observed apnoeas, high blood pressure, BMI or neck circumference, and only score for age later. He suggests looking for nasal congestion, tiredness, morning brain fog and unexplained headaches in women.

QUESTION:
What should dentists ask to screen children for sleep-disordered breathing?
ANSWER:
David reduces the 22-question Paediatric Sleep Questionnaire to four questions: does the child stop breathing at night, snore, mouth breathe, or wake up tired? A yes to any of these warrants an ENT assessment. He says a child who is tired has run out of resilience and needs to be seen urgently, and suggests adding these questions to intake forms.

QUESTION:
Should a mouth-breathing child see an ENT before myofunctional therapy?
ANSWER:
David says yes. In his view, 80 to 90% of mouth breathing is caused by anatomical obstruction, usually adenoids, turbinates, a deviated septum or tonsils. He argues that forcing nasal breathing past an obstruction can cause nasal valve collapse and strain on the heart. He sees myofunctional therapy as rehabilitation once the obstruction has been treated.

QUESTION:
Should a TMD patient with suspected sleep problems see an ENT first?
ANSWER:
David recommends going straight to an ENT, ideally one with an interest in sleep-disordered breathing. He sees upper airway obstruction, TMD and ortho as overlapping, and says the most common causes of night-time clenching and bruxism are upper airway obstruction, low iron and nasal allergies. Poor sleep can also lower pain thresholds.

QUESTION:
Is maxillary expansion or surgery better for children with sleep-disordered breathing?
ANSWER:
David says it depends on the child. A child with skeletal deficiency and no ENT problems needs expansion, while a child with large tonsils and adenoids but good skeletal form needs surgery. He says around two-thirds have both, so many need both. He compares surgery to rescuing a drowning child before teaching them to swim.

ABOUT THE GUEST

Dr David McIntosh is an Australian ear, nose and throat surgeon who treats adults and children, with a particular interest in sleep-disordered breathing and its overlap with dentistry. He works closely with dentists, and is a prolific author, with nine books on Amazon, including Snored to Death, and titles on children, women, mental health, dental health, sleep, and autism and ADHD in relation to ENT pathology.