Subscribe
Share
Share
Embed
A daily essay on history, freedom, and democracy, read aloud. Not from a historian or a journalist, but from a tour guide and traveler who has spent as much of life inside America as out of it. Field Notes on the Republic is one person learning out loud, writing toward an America that treats education as a virtue and means it when it calls itself a melting pot. New episodes every day.
On the morning of August 18, 1920, a 24-year-old state legislator named Harry Burn walked into the Tennessee House of Representatives wearing a red rose pinned to his lapel. In that room, on that day, the rose was a declaration. A red rose meant a vote against the Nineteenth Amendment. A yellow rose meant a vote for it. Burn wore red.
He had a letter in his pocket. Before the morning was over, he would ignore the rose, follow the letter, and cast the vote that gave American women the constitutional right to vote. The story of how the franchise expanded is often told as a story of vast forces, decades of organizing, marches, arrests. All of that is true. But it came down, in the end, to one young man and a note from his mother.
By the summer of 1920, the campaign for woman suffrage was old. Seventy-two years had passed since the Seneca Falls Convention of 1848 first declared that women should have the vote. Generations of organizers had spent their lives on it. In June 1919, Congress had finally passed the Nineteenth Amendment and sent it to the states.
An amendment to the Constitution does not become law when Congress passes it. It becomes law when three-quarters of the states ratify it. In 1920, that meant 36 states. By that summer, 35 had ratified. The amendment was one state short.
The remaining states were mostly unpromising. Several had already rejected it. Some would not bring it to a vote in time. The suffrage movement's hopes narrowed to one place, Tennessee, where the legislature was called into special session to decide.
Tennessee was divided, and the division was bitter. Anti-suffrage forces, well organized and well funded, filled the hotels of Nashville. The state Senate approved the amendment. Then it went to the House, and the House was a deadlock. Twice that day, members voted on whether to set the amendment aside, and twice the vote came back tied, 48 to 48. A tie meant the amendment failed.
There was no avoiding it any longer. The House had to vote on ratification itself.
Harry Burn was the youngest member of the Tennessee legislature, elected at 22, from the small East Tennessee town of Niota. He was up for reelection. Many of the voters in his district opposed suffrage. He had, in the earlier procedural votes that day, sided with the opponents. The red rose on his jacket told everyone in the chamber where he was expected to land.
What the chamber did not know about was the letter.
It had come from his mother, Febb Burn, a few days earlier. Febb Burn was a widow who ran the family farm, a college-educated woman who read several newspapers a day and followed national affairs closely. She could not vote. Some of the tenant farmers on her own land, men, could. She had noticed that.
Her letter to Harry ran seven pages, most of it the ordinary news of a small town. But near the end she turned to the vote in front of her son. She told him to vote for suffrage. She told him not to keep the suffragists in doubt. And she added a line that has lasted a hundred years: don't forget to be a good boy.
When the roll call reached his name, Harry Burn said "aye."
The chamber, by every account, did not believe it at first. A young man in a red rose had just voted for the amendment he was wearing the rose against. There was confusion, then uproar. The vote carried, 49 to 47. Tennessee became the 36th state. The Nineteenth Amendment had its three-quarters.
Burn, in the days after, was accused of everything from bribery to a clerical mistake. He answered the charges directly, and his answer is worth quoting because it is more than sentiment. He said he had always believed women had a right to vote. He said his mother was a college woman who followed every public question and could not vote, while illiterate men could. Confronted with the fact that his vote would put him on record forever, he said, he had to vote for ratification. The letter did not invent his conviction. It gave him the moment to act on it.
A week later, on August 26, 1920, the Secretary of State certified the amendment. The seventy-two-year campaign was over. The franchise had grown by some twenty-six million people.
It is worth being clear-eyed about what August 1920 did and did not do. The Nineteenth Amendment removed sex as a barrier to voting. It did not, on its own, deliver the vote to every woman. Black women, especially in the South, would face the same poll taxes, literacy tests, and intimidation that kept Black men from the ballot, and that wall would not come down until the Voting Rights Act of 1965. The Nineteenth Amendment was an enormous step. It was not the finish line. Both of those things are true, and an honest account holds them together.
But sit for a moment with the mechanics of how it passed. A constitutional amendment, the product of seventy-two years of national struggle, came down to a tied legislature, then to one 24-year-old, then to a letter his mother wrote mostly about local news. The franchise did not expand because the outcome was inevitable. It expanded because a tie had to be broken, and a young man chose, in the open, on the record, to break it the right way.
That is the part I would ask you to carry. We are used to thinking of great changes as the work of great forces, and they are. But the forces always, in the end, run through particular people in particular rooms making particular choices, often small choices, often under pressure, often when the easy vote points the other way. Febb Burn could not vote. So she wrote to the one person who could, and asked him to be a good boy. He was. A republic is enlarged exactly that way, one person deciding that the record should show them on the right side.
Field Notes on the Republic was written and read by Michael Fowler. It was produced for Quorum (Supply Co.), an American civic purveyor. Music is "When Johnny Comes Marching Home," performed by the U.S. Military Academy Band, West Point.