Retailgentic, presented by the ReFiBuy Media Network and hosted by Scot Wingo, is where Agentic Commerce meets retail innovation. We help retailers and brands prepare for the future of agent-driven shopping with actionable news, expert insights, dxis, forward-looking predictions, and practical guidance on Agentic Commerce Optimization (ACO).
I've said this from day one of my
career in consumer insights specific to
retail is consumers are so routinized.
They do not give up their habits.
Think about the adoption rate of
online grocery shopping in the US.
Even post-COVID, it is still so low,
and the reason for that is because we
grocery shop on such a habitual basis.
We know exactly where items are in our
store, and no one has figured out a way
to intuitively merchandise a digital
grocery store that matches the level
of routine faced by an individual.
So I just think we have these
ingrained behaviors that won't
go away, and also this desire to
be in control and feel empowered.
And I think, a- again, I love agentic.
I do think a big part of the retail
future is agentic, but I don't
think it's mutually exclusive.
Welcome to the Retailgentic Podcast,
where we explore the intersection
of retail, e-commerce, and AI
agents, which we call Retailgentic.
Our mission is simple.
We are shining a bright light
on the new agentic AI shopping
megatrend, which will disrupt the
trillion-dollar digital retail market.
The stakes are high.
Google, OpenAI, Microsoft,
Perplexity, Amazon, Apple, Meta, and
Anthropic are all fighting to be the
consumer AI shopping agent winner.
There are gonna be some tough decisions
for online brands and retailers to make.
What happens to checkout?
How should payments work?
Should you continue to invest
in retail media networks?
What does the world look like when
over half of your traffic is not
from humans, but from AI agents?
These existential questions
are the tip of the iceberg.
On this podcast, we're talking to industry
experts, analysts, and influencers
to get answers to these questions,
identify trends and best practices.
This is Retailgentic, your
podcast partner in navigating
our AI shopping agent future.
And now here's your host, Scot Wingo.
Welcome to the Retailgentic Podcast.
In today's episode, our
guest is Melissa Menko.
Melissa is the Global Director of Retail
Strategies and Insights at Ci&T, which
is a 30-year-old global company that
helps companies in many categories build
efficient and intuitive technology stacks.
At Ci&T, Melissa researches consumer
behavior, thinks a lot about the
consumer experience, and focuses on
best practices and strategies for
their large retail clients In this
discussion, we cover a very wide
range of topics, and I learned a ton.
We talk about changing consumer behaviors
due to Gen AI, a world where consumers
can easily build their own shopping
agents, which is fun to think about.
Some of the best GEO, Gen AI engine
optimization practices for retailers,
the future of loyalty programs,
and TikTok's role going forward.
Finally, we got a special treat.
Melissa was kind enough to give us a
sneak preview of some of their latest
consumer behavior survey data as it
relates to Gen AI that just wrapped
up last week and is not published yet.
So we got a little bit of a, a
little bit of a sneak peek there.
That's just the tip of the
iceberg in this conversation.
Without further ado, here is
my interview with Melissa.
Enjoy.
Melissa Minco, welcome to
the Retail Gen Tech Podcast.
Excited to have you today.
Excited to be here.
Thanks.
So you and I, um, I've been one degree
away from you for many times, but we
have never chatted, and then we were on,
um, we were on a kind of a round table
together, uh, Retail Wire, I think it was.
And I really enjoyed your comments, but
because there was like six of us, we
each got three minutes, so I was like,
"Wow, I wanna hear more from Melissa."
And then I was like,
"I know how to do that.
I'll have her on the podcast, and we'll
have a, we'll have kind of a, a lot of
free time to chat about what's going on."
Thank you.
S- so appreciate you coming on
and, and sharing some thoughts.
Let's jump into your background.
So, so give us a little background
of how you, you, uh, got into the fun
world of thinking about retail strategy.
Sure.
So I've always kind of
had roots in retail.
When I was in high school, I spent
my summers working on the sales
floor at Anthropology, and then after
that, during my summers in college,
I was doing focus group recruiting.
So that was across the board,
learning people's cheese consumption
behaviors and cleaning routines
and making sure they fit the quotas
that the brands I was representing
needed for those focus groups.
So that kind of combination of
retail experience on the floor and
then consumer insights up close and
personal kind of bred this interest
in insights for shopping and customer
experiences in the retail space.
And I went to UW Madison, studied
marketing there because I was just
so intrigued by consumer behaviors
and how they would react to different
deals, discounts, products, et cetera.
And my first job out of college was
then at Target Corporate because
of that focus group recruiting
and retail background that I had.
I was there for two years doing
merchandise strategies, specifically
for Target Canada, which was
a fascinating case study in
attempted international expansion.
And then I went very, uh,
consumer insights focused at
a small market research firm
that was acquired by Gartner.
Was there for six years, specifically
doing consumer insights research
for retailers, and I was advising
retailers every single day on how to
evolve their customer experiences,
their omni-channel routes, and their
methodology from a marketing perspective
in terms of just making sure they could
really cater to their core customer.
And then from there, I ended
up where I am now at CI&T.
They were a client of mine at Gartner,
and we had a call on, I think it
was chatbots- And I was sharing some
of my consumer insights research.
And about a year later, I was at
a small market research firm for a
minute doing pharmaceutical behaviors
and consumer insights, and they
reached out to me and said, "You
did a call with us a long time ago.
We'd love to hire you in-house to
do that consumer insights research
and retail strategy advising for us.
We're a digital consultancy."
So CI&T is a ton of really skilled
engineers who design the websites and
the applications for retailers, but then
also other enterprise businesses as well.
Yeah, and CI&T was new to me,
so I had to do some brushing up.
And I was, uh…
It's, uh, extremely global.
I think headquarters is
in Brazil, but there's…
I see you're in London.
Uh, if you're just listening, you're
missing a beautiful view of the, uh,
the London, uh, sky- skyline there.
Um, and then, uh, offices all over.
Tell, tell us a little bit more about,
like, is their focus 100% retail,
or that's one of many verticals?
And then what, what types of
retail projects do they do?
Would love to learn more.
Yeah, exactly.
So their focus is all across the board.
We have health and life sciences clients.
We have fintech clients.
We have retail clients,
manufacturing, et cetera.
Uh, it's a 30-year-old company, and
really is just devoted to providing the
most efficient and intuitive technology
stacks to all kinds of enterprise clients.
So a lot of it is very technical work.
It's application modernization and
cloud migration, but then there's also
a ton of strategy that we help our
clients with as well on the UX side,
so that they are providing the best
possible experiences for selling to the
end consumer, uh, if it's our retail
clients, um, or to supporting the end
consumer if it's, let's say, a doctor.
So, you know, we've revamped the
healthcare provider systems for some
of our health and life sciences clients
so that doctors can really easily, for
example, um figure out digitally what the
experience needs to be for their patient.
Got it.
Cool.
I wasn't, um, going back to Target, uh,
I recently read an article about that.
I didn't realize it was such a, a thing.
Um, The, uh…
I know you're not, but, but it's
interesting, like, I was reading
this retrospect on it, and there was
something like 16 systems that were
there, and none of them talked to each
other, so, so the folks on the ground
had a really hard time just execute.
It seemed like there was a lot
of lessons to be learned of what
not to do in that, that rollout.
Is that a…
Yeah.
Did you live part of that?
Like, what, what…?
I lived all of that, Scott.
Oh my gosh.
Wow.
I- Sorry,
I didn't mean to bring up bad times.
I'm not triggered at all.
It was just, I'll, I'll never forget
saying to my boss, "There, there has
to be a more efficient way to do this,"
because that was culturally at Target,
they always said, "If you think your
job can be done faster, it probably can.
So ask somebody why what you're doing on
that particular day is taking so long."
This was the one exception.
It was like we didn't have
the right systems in place.
There were a lot of new technology
components being piloted at once, and
that combined with, I think, some faulty
assumptions such as Canadian consumers
shop the same way US consumers do.
No, they don't.
Just because they're the US'
neighbor does not mean they're
the same type of consumer.
Uh, and then also, oh, logistics could
be just as easy because it's a large
country that's directly above us.
No, logistics was very challenging.
We had a lot of inventory
management issues.
It was a, a really big challenge,
especially when you know the brand
can be something so good, because at
that time, I mean, it, it was so…
it was coming off of a really long
stretch of success in the US and Target
was such a golden standard, and consumers
in the US were always excited about it.
Canadian consumers thought,
"This is a huge win for us.
We don't have to drive across
the border for all the brands and
fun items we love," but- Yeah.
It w- it was a lesson, for sure.
Yeah.
Sometimes you learn more from the things
that don't work out than the ones that do.
That, absolutely.
Absolutely, yeah.
Yeah.
And then, uh, I think it's interesting
you did the focus groups because, you
know, you start walking up to random
people and asking about their cheese
consumption, and you, you quickly lose
any, any being embarrassed at all.
Like, you can…
It's kind of a superpower, like,
to not be embarrassed by anything.
There's no shame.
Well, yeah, and I always say that
my interest in consumer insights
actually stems from my favorite
movie, which is Amélie, and the way it
introduces the characters is through
their likes and their dislikes.
And I think that just kind of normalized
for me getting to know people at
a oddly intimate level, for sure.
Yeah.
The other thing I've learned
is people don't like being told
they, they're in a demographic.
But then, like, you start
predicting stuff, and they're
like, "Wait, how'd you know that?"
Yeah.
That's
so- Like, "I bet you shop at Whole Foods."
They're like, "What?
How, how did you know I did?"
"Well, I can just, just kinda tell."
Exactly.
Tote bag and your income.
Yeah.
Well, cool.
Let's talk about, um…
So in your role, you, you have a
pretty broad, you know, spectrum of
things you're talking to clients about
and, and looking at different trends.
What's, what's top of mind these days?
I'm always advocating for the
consumer and the customer experience.
And so I mentioned, you
know, we're very technical.
We do a lot of highly skilled
engineering projects, but we are
doing a lot of innovation when
it comes to customer experience.
Domino's is one of our clients, and
we've been working on their digital
experience, and we're really proud to
be their partner because they are always
kind of at the forefront of innovation.
So I, what I've been thinking about a
lot is just how consumers are interacting
with apps specifically because I just ran
our second- for the year consumer insight
survey, and consumers told us, once
again, that apps are the easiest channel
to use when buying and making purchase
decisions, and yet we see such a hesitancy
from consumers to download retailer apps.
So I'm always just thinking about that
tension, because I know there's so much
opportunity there, and it's just a matter
of convincing the user that it's really
worth the real estate on their phone.
Yeah, as a user you're like,
"Is this thing gonna throw a
thousand notifications at me?"
You're, you're, uh, you know…
We've all tried the apps that, uh,
give you notification spam, and you're
just like, "I, I can't take anymore."
Exactly, and you talked
about embarrassment.
No one really wants to have that
flashing on their phone all the time.
You know, like, "Oh, I have to order
another coffee because it knows that
I'm just so over-caffeinated," and,
and stuff like that, but, but yeah.
Cool.
So, so apps are a big thing.
Um, is…
What, what else, what else have
you learned from that survey?
Yeah.
Let me, let me kind of pull up
some of my notes on that quick.
Is, is fear of notification,
like, one of the things that keeps
people from downloading apps, or?
No, it's actually, it's typically just…
What they told us is
kind of rooted in trust.
They think a lot of times the apps
that they end up downloading are
overpromise and underdeliver, so
they're either glitchy or they don't
provide the experiences they hope for.
They don't give as strong of deals
or discounts, and that's usually
why they're downloading them anyway.
So that's, uh, always very interesting
to me is usually it's from the
perspective of price savings or cost
savings, and I think consumers tend to
realize with apps they're not getting
the deals they'd hoped for with those.
Yeah.
Yeah, my last company was app-based, and
it's incredibly hard because of Android.
So, so you have your, your value,
your, your convenience-oriented
consumers are all on the iPhone,
and they're, like, 70 or 80%.
But then your value-oriented
people who want the app for the,
the promo codes and stuff, to your
point, they're all on Android.
And Android's a hot mess because,
you know, you've got people that are
like, "Oh, I'm from the UK in the US
and I have a Xiaomi phone- … and,
and it's running Android," some
variant of Android you've never seen,
and your app doesn't work on it.
And there's just, like, there's nothing
you can do for that, 'cause you literally
can't get the Chinese phone in the US.
They're upset.
You're frustrated.
It…
The, the Android ecosystem makes
apps, like, almost impossible
to, to build, just, like, the
complexity of it is just bonkers.
Totally.
When I…
This is very timely, 'cause I had
a massive nightmare last week.
You mentioned that I'm in London.
I moved here three weeks ago.
My App Store was still a US
App Store because my AppleCare
was purchased in the US.
So I couldn't download any UK apps.
I was completely locked out,
and I couldn't use my US apps
either, so it was a mess.
Yeah.
Yeah, you realize how important that is
when you can't get to the things you need.
Exactly.
Like Uber, once the, yeah, the
overground is shut down for
the night and stuff like that.
You know, our, our primary focus
is we're really interested in what
we call agentic commerce, so you
know, what that means for the world.
And, um, and for AI and retailers,
there's kind of two views.
There's just how retailers are using
it internally, um, which is more,
you know, kind of from the homepage
back, so, uh, both from, you know,
optimizing their website, chatbots,
c- customer service, supply chain on
the back end and that kind of stuff.
Uh, and then we think more about the
outside in, which is, uh, you know,
ChatGPT is adding shopping features
and, um, Amazon has a re- a, an agentic
feature, and so on and so forth.
What are…
In the world of AI, are retailers
thinking more about optimizing
internally or, or starting to
think more about the external side?
What, what are you hearing there?
I feel like they're focusing
more on the external side, but
what they should be focusing more
on is the internal side first.
And we talk a lot, we actually have
a, a whole long list or a framework
of ways that you can upgrade your GEO
strategy so that your website and your
digital channels are best set up for
success when these agents are crawling.
Because I think external will
absolutely be very important.
There's kind of three types, right?
It's like there's two forms of external.
One is where the retailer owns the
external, and then there's also the
third parties that will own the external.
And then there's the consumer, who may
start building, and probably will start
building their own agents to be shopping.
So there's so many different ways
this will be relevant in terms of how
consumers are shopping, and I think the
retailers that are only thinking of it
in one way are not really internalizing
what omni-channel has become.
I know people have kind of said
omni-channel's an irrelevant term in favor
of unified commerce, but omni-channel
is still, in my opinion, an extremely
important term in the sense of it speaks
to the consumer's experience and then how
they have different channels for different
missions, and they have each channel kind
of positioned uniquely in their minds.
With the introduction of agentic,
this is gonna be no different.
Consumers are going to see a time and
a place for it, and retailers need to
be prepared on all accounts for that.
Let's dig into one of those.
You, you pick.
Um-
Yeah.
So fir- first, um, let's say the
consumer builds their own agent.
Let's, let's just say that for a second.
I think we're a couple years away
from mainstream consumers doing that.
I think maybe we're six months away from
some very crafty individuals doing that.
Um, if and when they do that, there
are going to be a few things I
think retailers need to think about.
First is- Agent ordered pickup in store.
Like, where are these orders
going to be claimed by the actual
consumer in person when their agent
has ordered something for them?
Is it going to be in the same spot that
just buy online pickup in store is?
How is fulfillment kind of
going to be situated with that?
Um, I also think from a GEO perspective,
websites need to be prepared that
they'll be crawled by these consumers,
and so they'll need to be extremely
fluent in consumer lexicon, and
that's changing all the time.
We know language is constantly evolving.
Search capabilities need to match
that from an agentic perspective.
So there's that.
Um, I think those are really the,
the main ways when the consumer
is building it themselves.
But if the retailer also has an
agent operating, then I think the
thing we always talk about is, how
do these agents speak to each other?
Do they interfere with each other?
Is the retailer trying to
block consumer-created agents?
W- just what does that look like?
Yeah.
Yeah, it's interesting.
We've, we've found a lot of folks in the
UK are actually blocking these things.
I was talking to a grocery
company there, and we couldn't
even run an analysis because they
were just blocking everything.
And they're like, the high up…
the high-level executive's like, "I
didn't realize we were doing that.
Why are we doing that?"
And he looked at his team, and
they're like, "We don't know."
And it was probably some IT group
that, you know, there's probably some
malicious denial of service attack,
and then they just, like, threw
out the baby with the bathwater.
Mm-hmm.
And regulations are very strict here.
Right.
So I, I think, yeah, and I, I think we're
going to see what regulation looks like in
the US very soon from an AI perspective.
I know that's been a hot
topic of conversation.
But, yeah, I, I will be very curious to
see if retailers allow consumer-created
agents to crawl their sites.
I would say, if possible, they should
let them so that it's not mutually
exclusive, but just make sure that
they're building their digital
experiences to cater to both their own
agentic experience and the one that
consumers might be building themselves.
Gotcha.
Have you done any consumer
research on the gen AI side?
We've done a ton, actually.
Like, literally just finished
fielding this survey that has
a ton of information on that.
Um, so on generative AI in
particular, consumers are definitely
using it way more frequently.
Some of the statistics that really stand
out to me, um, practically three-quarters
of consumers said they're using AI
tools in their path to purchase at
least occasionally Only one quarter
of respondents said they have not
used an AI tool during their path to
purchase at this point, which is- Yeah,
that's interesting
wild.
I, I've seen 60%, I think, is the highest.
Um, so three quarters would
be a new high water mark.
But it's pretty, you know,
you're, you're more current.
There hasn't been a lot out since GPT-5
dropped in early August, so I don't
know when you ran your survey, but
it's, it's gonna be interes- I think 5
will actually elevate things because it
exposes more people to reasoning models.
There was some drama over
people being attached to 4o.
I think that was overdone, but- Yeah.
Yeah, no, this is fresh, fresh data.
This is, this was done fielding, I
wanna say, end of August, last week.
So yeah, I'm proud that this is
incredibly recent, and I do think
it's very accurate because our sample
size is 1,000 US consumers, and they
are reflective of the population.
It's not skewed younger by any means.
Very cool.
I usually ask this at the end, but
you've already piqued my interest.
Like, do you guys publish this, uh,
research, and how do we get access to it?
We do.
It will be published within
the next couple weeks, so this
is kind of a sneak preview of
like- Ooh, okay.
Yeah.
An exclusive.
Exclusive.
I don't know if it's exclusive.
Sneak peek.
All right.
Yes.
It'll be a data dive.
We don't wanna bore people with a
lengthy report of, of just words.
I've tried that in the past, and what
we've found is people just want the stats.
So it will be like a stat pack, um,
that's released in the next couple weeks.
Okay.
And then do we just go to,
to, um, like your LinkedIn?
Is that the kind of good shortcut, or
just go to Ci&T, or where do we go to find
this?
Ci&T's…
Yeah, Ci&T's website.
So C-I, spell out the word, and T .com,
and we'll have a banner on the
front for a while about this.
Awesome.
I can't wait.
I'm gonna be checking every hour.
I'm gonna have my agent…
I'm gonna build my own agent to
go check for your, your data.
There you go.
Well, thank you.
I appreciate that.
Your agent is our biggest fan, I guess.
Any other kind of things in
the report that shocked you?
I mean, there, there's a ton in here.
I was very surprised to see that the
primary way consumers feared AI would
lower the quality of the shopping
experience was by having some sort of
agenda in terms of what it shows to them.
So this is really important because I
know you were going to ask me my thoughts
on almost, like, sponsored GEO and
retailers being able to pay either to
play or to be higher up in the results
because there's not going to be a second
page anymore, et cetera, et cetera.
I really caution against these third
parties doing that because it will
completely erode their credibility
along the path to purchase.
And I think Amazon is a great
example of the fact that consumers
have trained themselves to not just
click the first thing that they see.
We're really skilled.
We're really well-informed shoppers these
days, and if we think we're being sold
something because a brand has paid and it
doesn't live up to that, like, maybe we'll
try it first, but if it doesn't live up
to that, they wise up really quickly and
they'll change their shopping behaviors.
So, um, consumers really want to feel in
control despite being very open to agentic
and generative AI being really involved.
Yeah, we had the, uh, we had this
professor on, and he had data that showed
people trust Gen AI more than a friend.
Um, and then I saw another one, this
was in E- eMarketer, where, um, it's,
uh, you know, website is at, like,
9% and Gen AI is at 18%, just kind
of tied with store at this point.
So, so it's almost tied with going
into the store, seeing the product,
and talking to a sales associate.
So, so I, I agree.
I'm…
I think Amazon's totally jumped the
shark on ads, and, and I get retail
media networks, and I think they work
okay sprinkled in with the actually
add value, but they've all tipped over
into this, like, you know, uh, eroding,
eroding trust and, and the experience.
Exactly, and if you overpower
the experience, then the consumer
learns to turn- tune you out.
So it doesn't behoove you to have
so much content being thrown at the
customer all the time, or so many
ads or so many brands all the time.
I mean, to your point, the credibility
right now and the trust is there,
so it would be foolish to lose that
opportunity by allowing so many brands to
pay and, and be in that space that way.
There was another research report, this
one was from university, I can't remember
if this was Cornell or Stanford or one
of those, and, um, they, they built
pretty generic agents using just OpenAI
and standard things, and gave them basic
prompts like, "Go find this product."
And the, the…
Without prompting, the agents
would avoid sponsored listings and
advertising and things like that.
So, so it's interesting.
I don't know if they're, they're
parroting consumer behavior or they
kind of intuitively know, um, also
that frequently that, that's a red
herring of it's not, not the best deal,
not the best product on, on the ads.
Exactly, and that goes back to
kind of the three types of agents.
It's, if it's a third party
that is now eroding its own
credibility, that's not great.
If it's the consumer themselves
building their own agents, they
will teach them and, and build them
so that they avoid those pitfalls.
If it's the retailer's agent, I think
there's a really unique opportunity
there to treat it like the rest of
the website, and obviously promote
what makes sense to be promoting
through deals, discounts, et cetera.
But be aware that the consumer has a
different mindset with your agent than
they do with their own agent, because
they're inherently already on your
website, inherently kind of biased Either
towards you or against you because they're
just so hyper-aware of where they are.
Yeah.
Yeah, and by having your own agent,
you mean like, uh, Rufus and Sparky
and those types of guys, kind of
the branded retailer inside the
walled garden type of a thing?
Exactly, and if it's a direct-to-consumer
retailer, them creating their own as well.
Yeah.
And when you're, when you're talking to
retailers, where do you put having one
of those as kind of like the priority
list of maybe the top five or 10
things they should be thinking about?
As in building their
own agent for the site?
Yeah, versus using agents for better
predictive analytics or, um, you know,
m- maybe like just at the website layer.
I'm sure there may even be more…
Like I've start, we're starting to
see reports come out that using it
for store-level inventory can be a
huge margin boost and, and pricing,
uh, at the store level and markdowns.
That's more a back office type stuff, so
like front of the house kind of things.
What, what are, what are some
best practices retailers should be
looking at on how to leverage Gen AI?
Yeah, because I do think back office is
where you should get things down first.
I think that's the foundation.
Inventory management, predictive
analytics, so crucial.
That's the backbone of
high-functioning retail.
I mean, when we spoke about Target
Canada and the fact that the store
shelves were empty, it doesn't matter
if you have this really cool agent
on your website if when the consumer
then goes to your brick-and-mortar
presence, there's nothing there.
That will ruin your brand so
much quicker than if you have
a cool agent on your website.
So I am always an advocate of
using new technology for the
fundamentals first and foremost.
So use these agents back office, build the
technology that you need, and that's what
we're helping our clients do right now.
We're literally using generative AI for
coding purposes and for quality control
and a ton of kind of the back end that
boosts inventory management capabilities,
uh, and saves teams a ton of time.
We have all these great stats on labor
hours reduced in like customer support,
for example, with one of our banking
clients because we've leveraged Gen AI for
coding purposes, um, and for technology,
like application modernization purposes.
So I think that's where I'm kind of
lucky in my job too, because I work for
this company that does so many really
impressive, highly technical things,
but I get to talk about it in a fun,
strategic, innovative way, kind of
bring the best of both worlds together.
Um, but I'm very passionate about getting
your ABCs first, using the technology
for that, and then create the really cool
agent that can interact with the consumer.
Because the consumer won't
be ready just yet, but your
back office needs it right now
Before we kind of pivot to
the future, did you see…
And on the monetization thing, did
you see the f- I think we talked about
this on the Retail Wire, but, uh,
mid-July, Financial Times had this
leak that, that ChatGPT is kind of
under NDA showing a hosted checkout.
And in, in my world, I come from
a marketplace kind of world, uh,
um, it, it's almost like I think
they're gonna become marketplaces.
Now, they may or may not add advertising,
but before I do, I think they'll become
a marketplace, meaning they'll want
things to run through their checkout, um,
and then they'll charge a percentage of
sales just like eBay or, or Amazon do.
Now, unfortunately, people get
Marketplaces are kind of synonymous with
Amazon, and it's kind of a hybrid model
'cause it has the 1P, what I would call
1P and 3P, first party and third party.
So, so I think they'll only be third
party, which will be nice, 'cause
unlike Amazon, they won't be competing
as a n- retailer alongside you.
Right.
But- I don't see a world
where that happens.
They've got, they've got enough
on their plate to deal with that.
Um, so, so what do, do you think that's,
do you think that's gonna happen?
Do you think all the
others will follow suit?
W- and what do you think, do you
think retailers should engage
with that or just kinda like, that
don't lose touch with the consumer?
Do you have a point of
view on all those things?
Yeah, I do think that's gonna happen
because it goes back to frictionless
experiences for the consumer.
I think the consumer is much more likely
to embrace them in a checkout moment
because it's, you know, a one-click
after they've been doing their research,
than they would be with the actual
search functionality of it if they
think that that's biased and sponsored.
The checkout piece, I don't think
consumers really care that much about
from a branded perspective, and I
think in terms of advice I would then
give therefore to the retailers is you
can't really care about that as much
because the actual purchase moment is
so much less branded and so much more
just about efficiency for the consumer.
The branded opportunities and the loyalty
opportunities really come from the full
shopping experience and the search part of
it, if, if the retailer's able to help the
consumer find exactly what they're looking
for in that moment, um, all of that.
So I would really focus on the
brand-building more kind of
relationship-building moments than
the actual purchase part of it.
Gotcha.
Interesting.
But also, don't stop letting consumers
buy from your website because that's
going to frustrate them if they can't.
Yeah.
Yeah, you gotta try to have your, it…
You gotta up your game on your website
too if, if, you know, if people are gonna
shop there then you need to always be
innovating on your website to make the
checkout faster and all these things.
This is what I keep saying, is we
panicked when e-com happened and we said,
"Okay, brick and mortar's irrelevant
and no one's gonna shop stores anymore."
Well, our data still shows that
brick and mortar is the first part
of most purchase journeys across all
categories still, even though e-commerce
grows and mobile commerce continues
to grow, and we would be nowhere
without digital commerce, for sure.
There's a time and a place for every
single channel, and that again, is,
is the value of omni-channel and why
consumers are omni-channel shoppers.
And I think the retailers that press
pause on their own digital experiences to
try to get so far ahead and figure this
whole agentic and generative AI flight out
without keeping tabs on their proprietary
experiences are going to fall behind.
And I'm not saying they shouldn't
double down on agentic and on
generative, like third party and, and
figuring out their place in that mix.
They absolutely need to, and that's
why we have a whole GEO strategy
and framework for our clients.
But at the same time, do not give up
on your proprietary experiences because
consumers are still going to look there
Got it.
Can you share any, like, um, tidbits
from your GEO framework and strategy?
Yes, I can.
I actually have some of those ideas up.
Um, so one thing we talk about is
brainstorm questions your target
audience asks that eventually lead
them to your business as an answer, so
kind of working backwards a little bit.
Um, and then develop content based
on the answers to those questions.
Kind of play Jeopardy, you know?
Um, I think that's
really, really important.
Um, we also talk a lot about just focusing
and doubling down on content and providing
expertise through your content, because
that's what consumers are seeking.
That's kind of what the core
of this movement is all about,
is consumers wanting to feel
more educated than ever before.
So make sure you're empowering
them to feel that way, and content
is really the gateway or the,
the only way you can do that.
Um, so those are kind of the two
tips I would share, and then I would
also direct people to this article,
which we can put in the notes, too.
Uh, but, but yeah, I…
It's really important to be kind
of playing Jeopardy, working
backwards to build, and then also
really focusing on your content
from an educational perspective.
Do you advocate, um…
And we've been doing this in retail for a
while, but I think it's worth revisiting.
So, so, uh, a lot of
retailers have these personas.
Usually they're kind of cheesy, like,
you know, Sally the soccer mom and stuff.
Um, but, you know, there are demographics,
they're real, and then if you can
start thinking about their shopping
journeys, but then instead of just,
like, where they're clicking and, and
attribution and the way we kind of
used to look at it, you need to kind of
think, "Well, at top of funnel, what is
that demographic kind of asking for?"
You know?
And, um, and then as they get in the
middle, what are they asking for?
So that you can, you can make sure
you have the content that then
becomes the answer to that question.
So it's a, it's, it's a little bit
similar to customer journeying, but
different in a way that we're…
The, the things we're exploring are, are
not digital pathways, they're more, you
know, I guess you're calling it Jeopardy.
Exactly, yeah.
You kind of have to work
backwards a little bit.
How would someone arrive at my product
or my business in the first place?
And then make sure that you're
incorporating that, not only into
how you're tagging, but also all
the content that you're creating so
that if these third-party agents are
combing, they'll be able to find you.
Yeah.
A- another topic I find really interesting
is if, if we enter this world where, um,
you know, we have these agents either
built by the shopper or a third party and
they're interacting with the retailer and
maybe you're checking out on the retailer
or, or at one of the external agents,
uh, life's gonna get really complicated,
'cause people could actually build their
own agent that has a checkout, too.
That's a whole nother thing
that can be happening.
So, so people have the ability to build
their own, like, little marketplace in a
way, uh, or multi-cart kind of a thing.
Um, but through all that, I kind
of wonder, it feels like a good
defensive mechanism for that or,
or a way to kind of like inject
your brand is a loyalty program.
But I think it's gonna be very different
than the way we think of it today.
Have you-- I know you've
written about some of that.
Where, where do you think loyalty goes,
and how can you use that in, in this world
as a good little bit of a defense or a way
to keep the customer thinking about you?
Yeah.
I'm fascinated by the topic of loyalty,
especially because I think Gen Z
is the least brand loyal generation
to exist, and I think a lot of that
is the frugality of Gen Z, and also
just the time they've grown up in.
We are so sensitive to deals and
discounts, and we're so able to
find those and almost be our own
agents to find the best deals.
But what's fascinating is, especially
being here in London, consumers
here in particular are very engaged
with loyalty programs, far more
than I've ever seen in the US.
And I was looking at why that might be.
I actually posted about this on LinkedIn
because one of the big grocers here
just changed some benefits or added
some benefits to their loyalty scheme.
Waitrose now does this little treats
thing where if you hit a certain tier
of spending in the month, they'll
give you this surprise little treat.
If you hit the next tier, same thing.
Obviously, Sephora does something
like that, but in the grocery space
we haven't really seen that, um,
encouraging a certain amount of spend.
And it's per month, it's not on an ongoing
basis, so the sense of urgency is kind
of there, which I think is really smart.
Um, but I say all this to say, the reason
loyalty programs are more of interest to
English consumers is because there is a
lower cost of living in the UK than there
is in the US, but there's a higher level
of purchasing power in the US, not the UK.
So, with less purchasing power comes more
interest in maximizing the purchase power
that you do have, the money that you do
have, and that's why loyalty programs are
so big here is everyone's always trying
to get the best bang for their buck.
Whereas with US consumers, we
have a higher purchasing power.
We don't care as much, as we
probably should, frankly, about how
loyalty programs can benefit us.
And so, very long-winded answer to say
I believe loyalty programs will still
be important, but they're really going
to be down to the bare bones, just
about saving consumers money when their
agents are all over the place, crawling,
trying to find what they're looking for.
I think the loyalty program is what will
keep consumers tied to certain brands over
others, and that'll be included in the
criteria for the agent to say, "Purchase
this brand for me," unless this brand
that I have loyalty points with and I've
hit the threshold can allow me to cash in
those points and make a purchase there.
So it'll take into account what
each of your loyalty wallets
looks like at different brands.
Yeah.
Do you think we then get to the point
where every retailer welcomes the,
the shopping agent in and they have
like a little bit of a negotiation?
And the, the retailer, you know,
let's say the retailer's having a slow
month, it's like, you know, September
23rd and they need to juice the top
line and they, they dial the agents
to be a little more aggressive on
discounts and that kind of thing.
It's kinda like we've always
talked about airline-like
seating, you know, or pricing.
Um, I actually think it tends
to go the other way versus
going up like airlines do.
'Cause they have a scarce, you know,
uh, they have a more of a scarce,
you know, one of one of each seat.
Uh, and, uh, we've always
talked about that in retail.
It's just hard to execute.
Now, in stores they have the digital
tags and they're kinda getting
there a little bit, but not at
the individual shopper level where
it could get really interesting.
Totally.
And I, yeah, I, I've always loved
the idea of dynamic pricing.
I think more retailers should be able
to talk about dynamic pricing in a
way that makes consumers warm up to it
because our data has shown consumers
don't love the concept of dynamic
pricing because sometimes they think
retailers are just using it against them.
But to your point, if they can feel
empowered with their agent to haggle
with these different brands and
talk about, you know, "Well, I have
XYZ loyalty points remaining, can
I use these to get a better deal?"
That's where I think loyalty can
definitely come into play here.
Yeah.
I also wonder, we've talked
about group buying for decades.
I'm, I'm sure when you were at Gartner you
got pitched on six companies or something
that were doing some kind of group buying.
They, they kind of come in waves through
the different generations, and none
of them have ever gotten any momentum.
But I wonder if…
So then if we play that out, so,
so now I would say, "All right, I
want this product at this price.
Go find other agents," and then they
could like team up and then go to
the retailer and say, "I've got 10
other people that wanna buy this
Sleep Eight for this price if you can
meet these criteria" kind of thing.
Do, do you think this could
be what opens up that finally?
Absolutely.
That's a really good point.
And each other's agents can have,
like, unique codes when they're
tied to each other, almost like
an affiliate link or whatever.
I mean, you can even tie brand
ambassadorship to that so that people
are getting credits for refer- Like,
if I'm saying to my friend, "Hey,
my agent found this deal on this.
If you go in on it with my agent,
then we can get an even better
deal," then maybe my agent gets some
credit for it with the retailer,
and so there's some mileage there.
But I think even, I mean, all the
catastrophes Ticketmaster has seen,
I could see concerts being a really
important use case for group buying
when it comes to agents because
you're typically not going to a
concert alone, stuff like that.
So any other predictions kind of two
to three years out that, that, uh…
Or you're less and more, you're
more reading the tea leaves right
now than thinking, uh, predicting
too much in the future, but do you
have any points of view on that?
No, I mean, I'm always, always
thinking about the future as well.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Where does…
Because we're on this exponential growth
curve, so, so one, one that kind of
just to start the discussion, I had
Roy Rubin on, founder of Magento, and
he basically says there's a pretty
high probability you won't need a
website in three years for humans.
It, it will be, it'll be just dealing
with agents because The zero-click
world, if you play it out to its
infinite, you know, and you already
talked about 75% are using gen AI, which
is driving clicks down 'cause they're
getting answers instead of clicks.
So, so I saw you shake your head,
you don't think that's gonna happen.
What, what's your counterargument to that?
I ju- it just goes back to
this panic of brick-and-mortar.
I just don't see a world…
Consumer-- I, I have said this
from day one of my career in
consumer insight specific to retail
is consumers are so routinized.
They do not give up their habits.
Think about the adoption rate of
online grocery shopping in the US.
Even post-COVID, it is still so low,
and the reason for that is because we
grocery shop on such a habitual basis.
We know exactly where items are in our
store, and no one has figured out a way
to intuitively merchandise a digital
grocery store that matches the level
of routine faced by an individual.
So, I just think we have these
ingrained behaviors that won't
go away, and also this desire to
be in control and feel empowered.
And I think, again, I love agentic.
I do think a big part of the retail
future is agentic, but I don't think
it's mutually exclusive to websites.
That's the part I disagree with.
I think agentic absolutely will probably
become the first stop for consumers.
I think that's where the big shift will
happen, but I don't think it'll be the
end stop in more than, let's say, six…
I'm throwing a number out, 60% of
purchase journeys because I think
consumers will still have this desire
to then take things into their own hands
and look around on branded websites,
and then ultimately pull the trigger
Got it.
Do you think agentic commerce is additive?
'Cause, 'cause it feels like e-commerce
has slowed down over, you know, over
our, our period of working on this stuff.
So, so you think it'll be additive?
I think it's 100% additive.
I don't think it's mutually exclusive.
I think it's helping consumers learn
certain behaviors, teaching them a lot.
It's making them more savvy shoppers,
which is just the constant quest
that they're on and e- every
year they become more savvy.
But I don't think it's a replacement.
I think it's an augmentation.
Depending on what data, US data
is, we're growing at, like, 6.8%,
and retail's, like, three and change.
And then I saw a Bernstein report
where their Wall Street analyst said
he thinks, um, agentic will add 1.5
to 2.5,
so at the midpoint 2%, which doesn't
seem like a lot, but on top of 6.8
going to 8.8
is a, it's like a 30% lift.
Does that pencil for you?
Yes.
That, that sounds appropriate.
And I also think there's categories
where agentic will be far better for
consumers, and then there's categories
where agentic just doesn't have a place.
If you think about, um, like car buying,
for example, certain people are just
never going to want to buy a car online.
They just won't, no matter
how advanced things get.
Um, or, or produce.
Like, it, it kind of goes back to
buying produce too, which is so
basic, but I, I don't know that people
are gonna feel comfortable buying
certain things through an agent n-
no matter how advanced agents get.
But again, I do think agentic is a massive
part of the retail landscape, and I think
I could…
You said, you know, what
does the future look like?
Are you reading the tea leaves?
One thing I think is the future of
retail is But there's a Melissa agent
that I've created, and she has a
separate agent for each category that
she's comfortable shopping agentically.
So home decor, I have a particular style.
Apparel and accessories,
I have a particular style.
And then travel, for example.
And so the Melissa travel agent does a
great job of figuring out my bookings
for when I go home for the holidays,
but she's not gonna be useful for
planning a vacation because I am
pretty open-minded when I'm planning
a vacation, and my criteria is going
to be in flux, and it just won't work
to have even these rules that are
constantly being relearned by my agent.
It, it won't be productive,
honestly, for an agent there.
But it will be very productive to
just set my calendar to the few times
a year I'm going home, and the agent
can tackle which airline and which
flight time and all that based on a
variety of different evolving reasons.
Um, but like my furniture agent, if
I don't change my style, she could've
easily purchased for the apartment I'm
in right now because I kind of decorated
my apartment that I'm in right now the
exact same way I decorated in the States.
So, you know, or if…
as long as my apparel style doesn't
change, I think it could be great to
have an agent that I've let her know, if
you will, that these are my three style
influencers that I'm inspired by, and
then she goes and purchases things in my
size based on what's on sale and based
on the season and the influencer that
I'm more resonating with at that time.
So that to me is the future with agentic.
Yeah.
I think that's right.
I think, I think the agent
plays a different role.
Like, a lot of them,
it's your point person.
It just, like, runs point
and then checks in with you.
But even on the, on…
where you talk about, like, a fun
vacation, I think you still use
it, but it's more of like your GPS.
You're just like, "Oh, okay."
You're, you're…
it's helping you.
You're like, "Okay," uh, you know.
So, so a lot of people…
The nice thing about being in London is
you can go, like, anywhere in the world.
So you should definitely add Tunisia,
because that's where Star Wars was filmed.
I'm a little bit biased, but…
So, so if I were you,
that's what I'd be…
I'd…
But then I'm like, you know,
is that s- is that scary?
Is it safe?
Where do I go?
Where do I stay?
You can, uh…
all this kind of stuff.
But you want it to, like, help
with the search part, but then you
probably wanna book it yourself 'cause
you're gonna wanna kind of curate
that at a very, very detailed level.
Totally.
Totally.
And I mean, it…
there's certain things it just can't
know that, uh, in certain moments.
Like, all of the sudden my friend
says, "I'm coming with you."
I mean, unless, you know, I
tell it, "Oh, change this to two
people," it's not gonna know that.
So I mean, there's just kind of
an ongoing fluidity with vacation
travel that's different from when
I'm going home for the holidays.
So that's where I think the future
of agentic is, is it very much
exists, it augments, it can provide
me a bunch of options, but it's not
actually purchasing on my behalf
in certain categories specifically.
Awesome.
Well, any, any last, uh, comments you
wanna throw in before we wrap it up?
I don't think so.
I think we've been pretty
comprehensive in our discussion.
Yeah, I'm gonna go, uh, I'm gonna go
check the CI&T website after this to
see if the consumer survey's dropped.
Pro- you probably haven't had time,
but I'm just gonna … Just in case.
Maybe, maybe someone in marketing put
it out there while we were talking.
In the next-
Um-
Oh, actually- Yeah … you know what?
I did wanna bring up one other
thing, and that is TikTok, because
TikTok has been fascinating.
And I think TikTok is a really good Future
forward best practice example for anyone
building an agentic experience to pay
attention to, because TikTok has served
as both an education and an entertainment
platform, and that's how it's been such
a strong purchase engine for consumers,
and brands have really loved it.
So it's a democratized algorithm.
Consumers are not being pushed any
sort of content other than what they're
self-selecting through their algorithm.
It's not about, oh, this person
usually gets the most likes,
so we're sending them that.
Sometimes it's accounts
with 100 followers.
And then it's also the fact that it
has such a wonderful search experience.
You can put in a misspelled, very
specific search query, and it'll
still turn up exactly what you're
looking for, and that's where I think
there's a ton of value in the search
experience that brands are creating
when it comes to agentic and generative.
So that, to me, even though it, it…
I guess it's kind of a combination of
reading the tea leaves and predicting
the future, but I would say look at
what TikTok has done so well to guide
the future of agentic because the more
biased you make it, the more pay-to-play
you make it, the less consumers are
going to respect it, in my opinion.
Yeah.
So you think, so it sounds like you think
TikTok survives agentic, if not thrives?
Yeah.
Oh, oh yeah.
Again, I don't think they're mutually
exclusive, and I think it's because
TikTok so brilliantly is engaging, it's
fun, it's entertainment, it's unwinding.
Its primary function isn't commerce, which
is why it's so successful at commerce,
and I think agentic needs to take a
page out of TikTok's book, actually.
Yeah.
I have an 18-year-old daughter,
and they've totally nailed the
serendipitous pur- purchase.
It's just like, see content, buy.
Just like bam.
Yeah, it's like so fast and
s- and streamed, it's crazy.
Exactly.
And, and I do think agentic will and
can do the same thing, and that's what
we're helping brands do, is figure
that out and what the back end looks
like to support that, but yeah, 100%.
Awesome.
That's a great one to end on.
Thanks very much for taking time.
Appreciate it.
Thanks for having me.
Yeah.
Enjoy London.
Go have a proper cuppa and
all- … all the things.
Fish and chips and all that.
Yes.
Thank you so much.
Like the most unhealthy thing
you can possibly eat, I guess.
Honestly, so good.
Yeah.
Yeah.
But so good.
Yeah.
Yeah.
It's gotta be hot and fresh
and wrapped in newspaper.
Exactly.
That kind of thing.
Yeah.
Or I'm not taking it.
All right.
Thanks, Melissa.
We'll check in with you in, uh, six
months and see how things are going.
Let's do it.
Follow, rate, and share to stay up
to date with Retailgenic, your guide
to the future of AI shopping agents.