Why Distance Learning? is a podcast about the decisions, design choices, and assumptions that determine whether live virtual learning becomes shallow and transactional—or meaningful, relational, and effective at scale.
The show is designed for education leaders, instructional designers, and system-level practitioners responsible for adopting, scaling, and sustaining virtual, hybrid, and online learning models. Each episode examines the structural conditions under which distance learning actually works—and the predictable reasons it fails when it doesn’t.
Through conversations with researchers, experienced practitioners, and field-shaping leaders, Why Distance Learning? translates research, field evidence, and lived experience into decision-relevant insight. Episodes surface real tradeoffs, near-failures, and hard-won lessons, equipping listeners with clear framing and language they can use to explain, defend, or redesign distance learning models in real organizational contexts.
Hosted by Seth Fleischauer of Banyan Global Learning, and Allyson Mitchell and Tami Moehring of the Center for Interactive Learning and Collaboration, the podcast challenges outdated narratives about distance learning and explores what becomes possible when live virtual education is designed intentionally, human-centered, and grounded in evidence.
Clean Transcript
Timestamps include the 1:55 intro offset and the approved cuts (07:38–10:49, 34:45–35:22, 43:00–43:51, and post-recording chatter); all are approximate. Estimated total length ~48:30.
Intro — recorded separately (00:00:00)
Hello, and welcome to Why Distance Learning, the podcast for education leaders and practitioners who are making real decisions about how virtual learning gets designed, adopted, and sustained. I'm Seth Fleischauer, founder and president of Banyan Global Learning, and my cohosts are Allyson Mitchell and Tami Moehring of the Center for Interactive Learning and Collaboration. Every episode we try to surface at least one assumption worth questioning.
Our guest today is Dr. Mary Rice, an associate professor of literacy at the University of New Mexico, where she's also part of the education and workforce development team on a National Quantum Virtual Lab project. Before that, she spent years at the University of Kansas's Center on Online Learning and Students with Disabilities. Her work there made her one of the people reporters and policymakers called when schools went online in 2020.
Today we talk about what it actually takes to serve students with disabilities in online and AI-supported learning. Mary has spent years in classrooms and homes watching these tools in use, and she's seen them break down for the kids who most need them to work, like children with speech differences and multilingual learners. She also explains how calling everything "personalized" can let schools lose track of services these students are legally owed. Her answer is more people and more stuff.
This episode is brought to you by CILC, the Center for Interactive Learning and Collaboration, connecting students to real experts through live virtual field trips and experiences — visit cilc.org to learn more. And by Banyan Global Learning, which connects K-12 classrooms with global peers and expert facilitators through live, thematic international exchange programs — find them at banyangloballearning.com.
And now here's our conversation with Mary Rice.
Recording begins (00:01:55)
Seth (00:01:55)
Mary, welcome to the podcast.
Seth (00:02:00)
So you taught middle school English and ESL in public schools for about 10 years. Then you worked at the University of Kansas's Center on Online Learning and Students with Disabilities. Now you're a literacy professor at UNM and also doing education and workforce development at the National Quantum Virtual Lab project. That's a lot of things. How does someone get from a middle school ELA classroom to all of the rest of that?
Mary Rice (00:02:29)
Well, first I want to say that this is a little bit the career of a xennial — a person who was born in the late seventies, early eighties — and your career gets disrupted a lot. But also I'm a person who is from rural America, and like a lot of folks, you grow up and you kind of want to see things, and then sometimes you get your wish. So there's that. And then I'm a nice woman who says yes. So, a canonical try-hard. I'll take you through some of these pieces. I started out my teaching career teaching ESL, English as a second language. But before I got there, I actually originally trained to be an editor. I was a straight-up English major, and I had an internship for myfamily.com, which does ancestry and all of these things. And I was going to go do internships in New York and places like that. And then September 11th, 2001 happened, and you can't go do that.
Mary Rice (00:03:23)
And remember, I'm a person who was always curious about other people and wanted to go see other things and travel, so I'd invested a lot of energy into trying to learn other languages. In the aftermath of realizing I was going to have to pivot a little bit, I'd started volunteering with ESL students at a local high school. And then I actually got a job there for $7.63 an hour after I graduated. Yes, I know. And then I got offered, in a different district, an opportunity to do an alternative certification program, where they started paying me a whopping $7.89 an hour for a little bit of time until I got my certification.
Allyson (00:04:26)
Yes!
Allyson (00:04:29)
You
Mary Rice (00:04:45)
So there was that little knocking about. And I thought, I'll do this for a couple of years and then I'll make my way back to editing. But I actually really enjoyed working with kids. And my dad was a teacher, and my mom actually taught first grade for a little bit, so that was a family narrative that we had as well.
Mary Rice (00:05:13)
And then I had a colleague working alongside me who was my very, very best friend, but she ended up leaving teaching. Before she did, she said, "I'm working with the reading support class" — which is sort of a weaving lane between special education and general education. Some people are going in, some people are coming out, some people we're not really sure. "Would you take on that class?" And I felt like I shouldn't do that unless I went and got a reading endorsement. So I entered an MA program in teacher ed with a reading endorsement attached. So I'm doing ESL, and because I have an English degree, they let me teach English in the era of No Child Left Behind — that's when they started requiring you to have a degree in whatever you're teaching.
Allyson (00:05:57)
you
Mary Rice (00:06:11)
So I picked up the reading and started working alongside special education. And then I had a baby, and I could not go back to teaching regularly, because you can't bring your baby with you. I actually tried one day, because my regular babysitter had gone into labor herself. I had to find somebody else to pick up my baby, and then teach the rest of the day. And I realized that the situation was untenable. And so what else would a smart person do but apply to a doctoral program? I thought I would be busier.
Seth (00:07:03)
Ha ha ha.
Mary Rice (00:07:06)
And I was, but it was a little bit easier to make the schedule work. I started out at the University of Kansas doing stuff with EL and reading, but then the department shifted priorities and people had different grants, and I met Don Deshler, who was doing the Center on Online Learning and Students with Disabilities. And he said, "Come work for me." And I said, that sounds like an interesting thing to do — but also, you could work over the summer, and remember, I've got a baby to feed. So I slid over and started doing that. And when I came to UNM, I was supposed to go back to mostly doing studies in classrooms with teachers, doing reading and content area literacy and assessment. And then came the pandemic.
Mary Rice (00:07:58)
And because I had worked at the Center on Online Learning and Students with Disabilities, my name is on, I don't know, sixteen, seventeen papers on this topic. People would call me from all kinds of countries, like Ireland and Finland, and Education Week, the news organization, talked to me. And I just realized, you know what? Maybe I'll just carve out a life where I do stuff with digital learning for historically underserved children. So I'm pushing along doing that. And then the quantum actually grows out of that content area focus, where I'd been working with people who do STEM and engineering. They called me during my sabbatical, actually. I'm in Boston, trying to give to the ocean as much as I can and hang out with my friends, and they said, "Hey, come do this with us." And I said, "Cool." So when I narrate it, it actually almost makes sense. But you've got to understand these pieces about social and political disruption, and that I'm a person who likes to try new things, and also, we have to just take things in our lives as they come to us. When you get opportunities that you feel are really good, I think you should do them. Like getting invited on this podcast.
Allyson (00:09:33)
You have done so much in your career, and also in life. And I love the idea that when things come to you, you just find a way to work it out and take different chances and opportunities to learn as you grow. So I really appreciate hearing all of the ways that you got to the places you are and will go in the future with that mentality. You've also worked with a friend of the podcast, Ray Rose. When we were getting ready for you to come be a guest on the podcast, we saw that you wrote that when a student with a disability struggles with an online tool, teachers often assume the problem is the student or the screen reader, when usually it's the content not being built to be accessible.
Allyson (00:10:24)
And it's a conversation we always think about, because there are so many different approaches, and accessibility is so important no matter which way you're going to be consuming that information online. So we wondered if you could share a little bit more about that situation with the student — what that looked like, what was actually going wrong, and what did the adults around the students do about it?
Mary Rice (00:10:47)
Well, I've seen children — because I'm in New Mexico right now — trying to use voice technologies, for instance. Students who maybe have speech differences, and also, because we're in New Mexico and we're a multilingual state, students speak different languages, so there's also that layer on top of it. A lot of that voice technology can't understand what they're saying. One time a teacher was trying to have the kids do some stuff about sharks or something like that, and the kids are trying to ask these questions, and the technology can't understand what they're saying, and then it doesn't work.
Mary Rice (00:11:43)
And when it doesn't work, it's frustrating for everybody. The teacher gets frustrated, and when teachers get frustrated, they start punishing the students they can. And it's not that teachers are undertrained, or that they're morally defaulting people or anything like that. It's just that those things are frustrating. And those technologies were not built and trained to pick up the voices of little kids. So that's one. And then also speech differences, and then also the language variations that exist in places like New Mexico. When I say multilingual, I'm not trying to be avant-garde — there really are a lot of different languages. There's English, but there's also Spanish, and there's Spanish. The northern New Mexico Spanish dialect is different from other Spanishes that are spoken in the United States and other places. And then there are nineteen Indigenous Pueblo groups, and three Apache groups, and the Navajo Nation. And that's without talking about other immigrant communities.
Mary Rice (00:13:12)
So another thing: I've been in a second grade classroom where they're trying to use this computer application that's been programmed with artificial intelligence, and it's supposed to be very supercharged in its capacity to deliver personalized instruction. The children are attempting to work, and there are numerous challenges. You've got all twenty children talking to the AI at the same time. The small computers are only equipped with one jack, and most of the children don't have headphones or microphones, because it's hard for schools to get those things. And if you put it on the student supply list, not everybody can bring the same thing, and it's hard to get inexpensive ones that will do the job. But then also the schools stop buying them because the kids would break them. They just do.
Allyson (00:14:06)
Ha ha.
Mary Rice (00:14:07)
So the children have to turn down their volume, and they've got to pick up their small computers and listen to the AI, and they're craning their necks and twisting their heads, trying to get the machines close to their faces. And unfortunately the AI can't understand some of the English spoken by those multilingual children. And then some of the kids have speech differences that present other difficulties. There are nonverbal children in the class who aren't accessing the reading instruction that their peers are, and actually the company has said that it can't meet those children's needs yet, because it takes a little bit of time to figure out how to do that. That means the teacher has to provide the instruction while supervising the other children.
Mary Rice (00:14:53)
And then some children using the computers don't have the impulse control that other children do, or they don't understand the prompt, or they're bored, or they're curious, and they keep yanking the microphone out of the jack. So the teacher has to continually reset the computers to recognize the headphones without the microphones. There's all of these things. During the early days of that reading program implementation, the teachers were saying, "I don't know how this is going to work." But they just get told to make do. And that's in a classroom with a bunch of kids. If you have a distance learning situation, you might only have one child in the home, but you could still have all of those problems. And you might have more than one kid. It won't be twenty, but it might be three or four. I've written papers about parents who are fostering children and doing online learning with them, so you might have lots of kids of numerous ages trying to navigate online learning there.
Mary Rice (00:16:19)
We usually have a picture in our heads of distance or online education as a very calm and quiet mother sitting next to one child, in an idyllic space like the one behind me, with lots of books and a cute little table. But it's usually quite a bit more chaotic than that. So you could still have most of those same sorts of issues, and nobody to ask for help, and nobody to figure out how to do any of these things. These are big problems. These are things that are maybe not insurmountable, but definitely things that are challenges.
Seth (00:17:15)
You call them not insurmountable, but my god, you've painted a picture here of essentially human nature running up against hardware. And I'm like, how are they surmountable? Yes, the calm child sitting next to the one parent who's dedicated to making sure they have their headphones plugged in — that seems like a tenable situation. But a classroom of twenty? I feel like what we used to do is just kick those kids out of class, right? If you can't handle your book, then you don't get a book. That was the old-school, traditional way of doing things. And we don't do that anymore, because we acknowledge that there are many factors that go into a kid not being able to handle a book properly. So with the ideals of education reaching everyone in mind, and the limitations of hardware, how do you see these problems as surmountable?
Mary Rice (00:18:27)
Well, more people, more stuff.
Seth (00:18:31)
Ha ha ha.
Mary Rice (00:18:32)
There's going to have to be more people in these educational situations. However we're going to get them there, we'll have to think creatively about that — whether there are going to be more people online, available, working with families, or, depending on the situation, more people who are able to participate in those distance situations and enter the home periodically. I don't know how states are going to work that out, but at least more people to connect with in the online scenario who are on call or immediately available. And then in classrooms too, in the highest-needs places, we need more people helping children. And then we need more stuff. We need more headphones, we need better ones, we need ones that work. And we have to make different kinds of decisions about how we're going to use the technology, and in what way.
Mary Rice (00:19:43)
There's a bit of a backlash right now on what's called screen time in schools, and I don't know exactly how everyone is counting screen time. But one of the things that worries me is that the screen time that'll get retained is that kind of screen time, and not the screen time where Mo Willems is reading his book to people over YouTube. It's not that I think that's so great — I would like a teacher to read Mo Willems to kids. But during the pandemic, they got rid of a lot of books in classrooms, because they were going to do everything electronically. And now there are no books in classrooms, and now there are no screens. It seems like we could work it out, but we've got to realize everything that's on the table. We've got the same questions about cell phones. It seems like a reasonable thing to do, but we have to think about all the things we offloaded onto cell phones for adolescents in schools. For example, we don't deliver messages to kids anymore in schools. If you call the office and say, "Hey, can you tell my kid that I'm running late and I'll pick them up fifteen minutes late," a lot of schools don't want to deliver that message anymore. So when we go and have these meetings about making sure kids can't have phones anymore, we have to say, "Okay, what are we going to take back up?"
Allyson (00:21:26)
Well, it's also interesting, because it feels like you're seeing two extremes, and the in-between is kind of where it feels like things need to fall. When you were talking about who might be struggling with what, I kept thinking of the teachers in schools that might have a hybrid situation with all different things happening. And so many people experienced that online environment that wasn't ideal and probably had some of those challenges you mentioned — especially adults who weren't in education but still had to connect their student in whatever way that looked. From my own personal experience, I wish my child could have sat next to me and said, "This is so great, isn't this lovely?" But life is happening. It's not practice versus theory.
Allyson (00:22:28)
So is there anything you see in the future about ways of getting that balance into play? I know — more stuff and more people. But what are the steps to getting more people to understand the needs, on both sides — in the school space for the students, but also in the home space, if you're learning outside of a traditional classroom? Sometimes you get math packets explaining how you're actually supposed to talk about math with your students. Is it something like that? How do you build digital literacy for the parents who may not know all of the materials or hardware they might have to help their students navigate?
Mary Rice (00:23:12)
Yeah. Schools tend to both overestimate and underestimate what parents know about digital things. They'll send out a note for an online meeting to talk about what parents need to know about digital technology, not realizing that if you don't have access to digital technology, you probably can't get into the meeting.
Mary Rice (00:23:46)
When I first started, in 2013, at the Center on Online Learning and Students with Disabilities, people were surprised to learn that parents would sign their children up for online and distance learning when they did not have a computer and did not have internet. And we feel like, why can't they know that? But what was driving people toward the virtual charter school space at that time wasn't that they really wanted to do online and virtual learning. It was because they felt pushed away from the traditional school, and that's a different proposition. It wasn't, "We really want to take up this tech." It was, "We're trying to flee a situation that we feel is not working for us." And that's why they don't have these things.
Mary Rice (00:24:46)
But also, parents have been in schools back in their day, so people feel like they have a basic sense of the grammar and syntax of what goes on in a school. That's true whether you're a parent trying to help a kid with algebra homework, or a lawmaker, or a policymaker. We feel like we know the narrative of what goes on in school. But then there's what's under it — under the basic structure. What people don't understand is whatever that next layer is. And even people who did school a lot don't always understand all those pieces and parts. I gave you that narrative where I gave seven different reasons why a kid would pull the microphone out that didn't involve them just being naughty.
Mary Rice (00:25:54)
I've had lots of opportunities to watch kids and think about it and read, and I've worked with kids for ten years. When I was an ESL teacher, I think that's where I learned how clever and cute kids are. And I felt sad, because sometimes I felt like I was the only one in the school who knew that. They would come to my class and be lively and fun, and then when I saw them in other classes, they'd be sitting in the back. Sometimes nobody gave them the book, because they thought, "You can't read it anyway." They would just be not full participants in their educational experience. So you have to have all of these different views of how people experience school. People tend to want to stand in the place where they're standing and say, "This must be the dominant story. This must be how it is." You have to have enough opportunities to see school in enough different ways. At one point I even taught honors — because, like I said, I perpetually say yes. I was teaching honors and ESL and general education and reading support all at the same time. So I saw every kind of kid it's possible to see in a junior high setting, in one day, every day, for years. And if you don't have the opportunity to spend years and years doing that, then you've got to listen to people who do. And that's the thing I don't think people want to do.
Seth (00:27:58)
I imagine that having that viewpoint across all of those different types of students gives you insight into my next question, which is about a paper you wrote with Mark Deschaine, friend of the podcast, and Ray Rose, where you separated personalization, differentiation, individualization, and presence. You've told us academia is partly to blame for the proliferation of these terms, and that marketers like them too, because a term lets you make a promise and then hope nobody notices when the promises conflict. So I'm wondering if you can give us an example of a time when those promises conflict in a real program — where delivering one of those four things might mean giving up another one.
Mary Rice (00:28:57)
The place where I see the clash the strongest, from where I sit, is that there's been a movement to talk about how everything is personalized. And so then either there's no need for an IEP, for instance, or everyone in effect has an IEP. I have zero problem with trying to make sure that all kids have access to continuous cognitive challenge, and even documenting that. That's not a problem for me. But IDEA is real legislation, and it's designed for children to access services for which they are qualified. And there's a real obligation to do Child Find — to go out and seek children who have the particular kinds of disabilities that are listed in IDEA. So the discourse of "everyone has an IEP" might sound inclusive, but it's really not the spirit of individualized instruction per IDEA to not fully consider the specific needs of children through human-centered collaboration. If we want to print out a paper of everything kids can do and where they need to go next, for everyone — beautiful and fine. But not in a way that knocks individualization out of its space in terms of our obligations to get children in front of people who can provide specialized instruction and specialized services.
Mary Rice (00:30:48)
So, the human-centered collaboration, where we're asking parents what's going on with the child and what their needs are. Maybe someone on a past episode has said this: individual parents tend to know certain things about their children that other folks don't. They tend to know their kid best. But schools and teachers should know something about the broad swath of kids, and generally about how different kinds of specific challenges or disabilities operate in school spaces. When you bring everyone's different expertise together, that's where you come up with some kind of a plan.
Mary Rice (00:31:46)
When we mix a pot where we just throw individualization and personalization and differentiation all into it, folks can release themselves from the obligation to provide these services that are very important. And the reason I think people should care about it, from a lawmaking or school governance perspective, is that it may allow money that was set apart for special education to get lost. Federal funds are supposed to flow through to states, and then sometimes that flows through to a district that's supposed to give it to a charter school, if that's where the child is going. Or sometimes it stays at the district, and the district provides services, or sometimes it goes to some kind of intermediate service district. But at some point it's supposed to land at a child who is qualified for these services. When it doesn't get to the kids it's supposed to be serving, that's a real problem. That's why it's important to think about how we're using these terms when we're trying to identify certain kinds of things for certain kinds of kids. Right now, the way I've experienced it, the preferred move is to say everything's personalized. But that word is not in IDEA. Not that I know.
Allyson (00:33:29)
I think it's so important, what you're calling out with that human-centered piece — the idea that the school needs to have these understandings of children and how they're going to operate, and not just depend on personalization driven by the algorithm. How do you infuse the human into what you might be finding are trends in how certain tools are used? So if you're a leader responsible for an online program, and you have students with disabilities — and also, like you said, thinking more broadly about students in general and the families who are enrolled — what's one thing your research suggests they're probably getting wrong, by accident or without taking more time to be considerate? Maybe they just haven't seen that gap yet. What would you have them do differently, even starting next semester, as they plan for the next academic year, since planning starts so quickly after the school year?
Mary Rice (00:34:37)
Well, to your point about human judgment — "humans in the loop" is a term often used right now. The other very specific example I brought today — I decided to use it because I think it'll stick in people's minds — is about a sexual education curriculum. The children are taking this class online, doing the sex ed curriculum, and it's asking them to write a short essay about why you should not get pregnant, basically. There were several questions along those lines about sexual health, and it was abstinence-framed, because that was what was required in the state. Fine. But the students did not understand that they were not supposed to write anything about their own sexual experience — which I think is a tricky thing, a confidentiality or privacy thing, because there was no specific instruction about it. What they wanted you to do was write things about pregnancy from a video, and basically use keywords from the information given in the video about what the challenges would be if a girl got pregnant. They were in a conservative state, so they were pretty specific about that.
Mary Rice (00:36:28)
So when kids didn't do well on it, a complaint went out: "All of this stuff is true — how come I didn't get the points?" And then the principal says, "Well, the machine graded them, and it was looking for these specific answers. You're just supposed to use the video. You're not supposed to write anything about your own experience." Go reset the machine. And that was where the human judgment entered in — just whether or not they were allowed to reset the prompt so they could enter it again. Nothing about looking it over and saying, "Yeah, that checks. That seems fine."
Mary Rice (00:37:25)
And that layer of abstraction — you're not supposed to write about you, it doesn't matter if it's true, it just matters if it's in the video — is so frustrating for a lot of people. But think about if you're a person who is neurodivergent, where literality is part of your worldview. That's going to be a nightmare. And parents aren't able to figure that sort of thing out very easily unless they call and have a whole conversation with the principal, which says a lot about whether they're comfortable doing it. And remember, it's about sex, and people don't necessarily like to call up and complain about that as a topic.
Mary Rice (00:38:25)
And remember, I was a teacher. When I found that the kids were struggling with something while I was circulating in the classroom, I would run up to the board and say, "Hey everyone, look," and show everybody how to answer number five, or, "Look, number six is tricky, and this is why." And then all forty — because that's how big my classes used to be; remember, I say yes — would know. But in an online setting, every person in that class has to contact the principal on their own and ask to get the prompt re-released, unless the school is willing, of its own accord, to say, "We'd better educate people about how to write for machine prompts." Which they did not do.
Mary Rice (00:39:23)
Those are the things that are big hazards. You asked what schools should do today — well, that's what they should do. Instead of making these big packets about how to teach math, they should be going through and looking for those sorts of things. How do we help parents understand what it means to write an answer to a prompt for a machine? How do we help people pick out keywords? What about situations where a child's neurodivergence comes up really easily? And what about trauma? In this case of sex ed, there are all kinds of trauma-related reasons why you might not be able to answer that super well. Where are we going to be an actual human in that way?
Seth (00:40:30)
It's insane to me to think that they were using AI to grade sex ed essays. That is insane.
Allyson (00:40:36)
I was thinking the whole time, it just feels so antiquated — like you're just asking students to regurgitate the information, as opposed to, where is the room for your thought, or your exploration, or the aha moment that maybe even the teacher didn't see? It feels like it's being taken away.
Seth (00:40:55)
I mean, in abstinence education, there's only one right answer.
Mary Rice (00:40:59)
Yeah, yes.
Allyson (00:41:00)
I know. But my philosophical soul is like, "But in philosophy — is this really a microphone, or am I perceiving it that way?"
Mary Rice (00:41:07)
Well, I've seen a wide variety of digital and online curriculum, and maybe some of it is more project-based, and sometimes there's more room for the student in it. But I can tell you that when there is, the teachers get run pretty ragged. I've written about that too. I've been in places where the student and the school work out which parts will be hybrid, which parts will be in person, and which parts will be online, and the teachers are very, very ragged. They're very burned out. So again, you're going to need more people and more stuff. That's all I can say.
Seth (00:41:57)
Can't wait for Mary Rice's education bill called More People, More Stuff.
Mary Rice (00:42:02)
Yes. More people, more stuff. That's when I run for office — just kidding. We need more people and more stuff in educational spaces if we're going to try to make things work. Distance education was originally promoted as a way to save money and cut the fat. But part of the fat is services for students with disabilities, because it takes extra people, extra services, extra equipment. If we really have a commitment to helping everybody do the things they need to do — and we've learned that people can't do digital learning on the cheap very well — then schools need and deserve to be better funded than they are.
Seth (00:43:11)
Yeah. Well, that tees up our last question pretty well. Tami, do you want to take it?
Tami Moehring (00:43:17)
I am happy to take it, because we started out in middle school, which is a really interesting time of our lives, and we ended with a sex ed explanation, which is also really interesting. So I can't wait to hear your answer to this question, Mary, which is the title of our podcast: Why distance learning — when it comes to education, or as a whole?
Mary Rice (00:43:43)
Gosh. Well, for me — my dad had an Uncle Howard who drank turpentine when he was little and burned his vocal cords, so he talked differently. Then he got in fights, and they put him in the Idaho State School back in the day, and he died there. He was there until the late seventies, early eighties. So that is the institutional separation of individuals who are different. And I also had an aunt who was born with an intellectual disability, and not wanting her to be in that situation, the family mostly just hid her — not in a cave, but she mostly did not have interactions with people other than the family. She lived a lot longer, into her seventies, I think. But she did not interact with people other than us. And neither of those scenarios — even though one was institutionalized for most of their life and the other was not — was an inclusive situation.
Mary Rice (00:45:13)
So I think that distance learning, along with an entire repertoire of service and educational possibilities, is extremely important. Not just for "let's be nice to people who have disabilities," but so that people who have differences, challenges, disabilities, special needs — however people want to frame it — can actually make contributions. It's not that we're going to be so good to people. These were wonderful family members, and we missed them. My uncle apparently lived in that school the rest of his life because he was a good teacher. People should be able to make the contributions they can make, however we have to work this out. This is about listening to people and figuring out what all of these edges are. Because these problems are intense and complex rather than easy, we should do that.
Seth (00:46:39)
Beautiful answer. Thank you so much, Mary. Thank you for coming on the podcast today.
Tami Moehring (00:46:44)
Yes, thank you so much.
Outro — recorded separately (00:46:54)
That was our conversation with Dr. Mary Rice.
Mary gave us two pictures of what happens when technology meets real students. In the first, a second-grade class is using an AI reading program that can't understand children with speech differences or multilingual English. Each computer has one jack, most kids don't have headsets, and the company says it can't yet serve the nonverbal students at all. That leaves the teacher teaching those students while resetting machines for everyone else. In the second, an online course uses AI to grade students' sex-ed answers against keywords from a video. The only human judgment in the loop is whether a student gets to resubmit. In both cases, when no one is watching for where a tool fails, the cost falls on the students who are already least served.
Her point about language matters for leaders too. If everything is called personalized, it gets easier to stop asking whether a child qualifies for individualized services under IDEA. The special education funding meant for that child can then get lost somewhere between the state, the district, and the school. Her answer was simple: more people, more stuff, and funding that reflects what digital learning actually costs.
We referenced Mary's recent TCEA article with Ray Rose, "Who Is Missing from Digital Learning?", and her paper with Mark Deschaine and Ray Rose on framing instructional strategies in K-12 digital learning. We'll have links in the show notes.
Thanks as always to our editor, Lucas Salazar, and thank you for listening to Why Distance Learning, and we'll see you next time.