System Speak: Complex Trauma and Dissociation

We respond to a listener email to share what we learned about aphantasia.

Research Links:

Aphantasia: in search of theory

The multitude of aphantasia subtypes and their respective cognitive differences and pathological considerations: A review on the emerging condition.

Phenomenal Access Dissociation: Blindsight, Aphantasia, and the Structural Unity of Identity Without Phenomenal Channel

The double dissociation between cortical blindness and aphantasia: A review of 55 cases

A Systematic Review of Aphantasia: Concept, Measurement, Neural Basis, and Theory Development



Our website is HERE:  System Speak Podcast and sponsoring nonprofit website is HERE: S3C Foundation.

You can submit an email to the podcast HERE.

You can JOIN THE COMMUNITY HERE.  Once you have registered with the network, you will receive an invitation to orientation, and then can use a non-Apple device or non-safari browser to join groups HERE. Once you are set up, then the website and app work on any device just fine.  We have peer check-in groups, an art group, recovery groups, social events, and classes.  Additional zoom groups are optional, but only available by joining the groups. Join us!

Content Note: Content on this website and in the podcasts is assumed to be trauma and/or dissociative related due to the nature of what is being shared here in general.  Content descriptors are generally given in each episode.  Specific trigger warnings are not given due to research reporting this makes triggers worse.  Please use appropriate self-care and your own safety plan while exploring this website and during your listening experience.  Natural pauses due to dissociation have not been edited out of the podcast, and have been left for authenticity.  While some professional material may be referenced for educational purposes, Emma is not your therapist nor offering professional advice.  Any informational material shared or referenced is simply part of our own learning process, and not guaranteed to be the latest research or best method for you.  Please contact your therapist or nearest emergency room in case of any emergency.  This website does not provide any medical, mental health, or social support services.
★ Support this podcast on Patreon ★

What is System Speak: Complex Trauma and Dissociation?

Emma shares about complex trauma, deprivation, and dissociation (CPTSD, OSDD, DID). Educational, supportive, and inspiring, System Speak documents the best and worst of life through insights, conversations, and collaborations. An archive curated for dignity for all.

Speaker 1:

Welcome to System Speak, a podcast about Complex Trauma and Dissociation. It's our story, our learning, and the ideas we've been working with as they've unfolded over time. Earlier episodes give context for where we are now, and current episodes may engage more advanced material, harder content, or reference earlier conversations. A few things to remember as you listen. The podcast is education, reflection, and storytelling.

Speaker 1:

It's not therapy, and listening doesn't create a relationship. Although I am a therapist, I am not in that role here, and nothing that I share is individualized clinical advice. Every system, every internal world, all of your own stories are all different and you take up your own shape. What we share about ours won't translate directly to yours. It isn't meant to.

Speaker 1:

We're all different, and all of our stories matter. As always, take care of yourself during and after listening. We are so glad you're here. I'm so excited you're both here. We got an email.

Speaker 1:

I don't know if I can even say it right. We got an email asking about Aphantasia. How do you say it? Is that right?

Speaker 2:

I don't know if I say it correctly or not. Sometimes I have heard aphantasia. Sometimes I've heard aphantasia. I wing it depending on the environment that I'm in.

Speaker 1:

That's very gracious. The deaf girl does not know if it is a long A or a short A. But there we go. We've had the questions about it. And I'm sure, I mean, I'm just guessing because this is a moment where I cannot speak from lived experience, but it is a moment of when we talk so much about things like internal worlds or flashbacks or all these different examples that are such common language with dissociative folks generally.

Speaker 1:

To have that and so literally experience those things differently or not experience that, the visual picture, I can't even imagine. So there was no way for me to answer the email other than I will find people to ask. Just for starters, I would be curious how would you define that word or explain it to people who don't know?

Speaker 3:

So this one is interesting for us because we hadn't realized it was literal. We didn't know that people literally could see in their heads. We assumed it was a gross exaggeration and that everyone was kind of on the same, like, yeah. Well, it's not like you're actually seeing the thing. You're just kind of conceptualizing it.

Speaker 3:

Right? So it wasn't until we were, like, talking about building, like, a stuff in EMDR, like, preparing for EMDR. And our therapist was like, can you see in your head? And I was like, well, yeah. I mean, I think so.

Speaker 3:

Not, like, literally, but nobody can. And she was like, actually, people people do see in their head. So it is there's, like, no picture internally, but I was confused because I can conceptualize a thing, and I just thought that that's what everyone was doing. Doing.

Speaker 1:

Oh my goodness. Okay. So this is how you discovered it for yourself that that was what was going on with you?

Speaker 3:

Yes. It was, quite the surprise because I had just thought that no one could mean that literally. Right?

Speaker 1:

Wow. What about what about you? How did you discover it?

Speaker 2:

Similarly, actually, I did not know that when people say, you know, counting sheep at night, that that was actually, for some people, making sheep in their head. I can't even imagine. I, as a kid, we have popcorn ceiling which is that horribly textured. It's just, you know, the worst ceiling but I would look at it and I would stare at it so intensely and think, oh yes maybe that bit right there can look like a sheep and that is what I would do at night instead. It wasn't until I was an adult and my friend was actually in nursing school doing an assignment where she asked me to draw a clock which is just typical run of the mill kind of checking cognitive functions specifically to rule out or slightly suss out if there is cognitive decline such as Alzheimer's or dementia.

Speaker 2:

And I drew a clock but I drew my numbers on the outside of the clock and my friend did not understand and there was a moment of both of us thinking, Wait what happened here? Because I'm looking at that like nothing is wrong. She is looking at that like it makes absolutely no sense and it's not, any of the forms

Speaker 1:

of what she was told to look for.

Speaker 2:

Yeah that was when she said, Do you not see a clock in your head when I ask you to draw a clock? And I said, No I don't see anything in my head. Do you actually see things in your head? And she said, Yes I can see anything I think of in my head. And that was my moment of going, Oh okay.

Speaker 2:

And then so much made sense so quickly because I'd always gotten frustrated with guided meditation or when I did EMDR over a decade ago being told to visualize a safe place and to think of how it feels and how it looks. And I run this loop in my brain of reminding myself this is what a tree looks like. This is what water would look like. This is what the ground would look like, except I can't see it. So it's just, I do know that this thing is green.

Speaker 2:

I do know that this thing is brown, and I do know that this thing is theoretically kind of glue.

Speaker 1:

And, yeah, that's how I found out. Oh my goodness. Have either of you done any research at all of just, like, what does this mean, and where does it come from, or other people have it? What what have you learned?

Speaker 3:

Well, I went into a research spiral after my therapist was like, Can you not see in your head? And I was like, Well, I think I can. I can conceptualize the thing. Then I looked it up and people do actually see in their head. So I went on like an online research spiral and also just asked all of like my close people, can you see in your head?

Speaker 3:

And some of my close people also cannot and, some of them have the hypervisualization. Like one of my friends was like, like, if someone tells me to picture an apple, I can picture the apple and turn it around. I can make it rot in my hands. I can change what kind it is. I can hold it out in space and see it from any angle.

Speaker 3:

I was like that is wild to me but I was. I was looking it up, because so many of the resources for mental health and for DID involve visualization and it was a really isolating experience before meeting other people and even after meeting other people who have DID and feeling left alone and like finding community. There's still this level of being on the outside looking in and trying to understand. And so we listened to a few podcast episodes about aphantasia and looked up ways ways to build an internal world even if you can't see it. And it's definitely like, I still go on the research spirals about, is there a way to see inside someday?

Speaker 3:

No. Probably not. So I'm adapting my life.

Speaker 1:

Wow. So this is just a trait you have, like people who like cilantro and people who hate cilantro.

Speaker 2:

Owen? We also did research. I remember finding a picture, and I think it was of an apple funnily enough where it showed I guess a spectrum of visualization and on one end of the spectrum there's the Aphantasia and there is nothing there it's just a black square and then as it went further to the right there was slightly more clarity in each subsequent photo. After I saw that I had to ask everybody that I knew what they saw in their head and what it looked like and where on that scale it landed. And I realized I don't even know how to explain it.

Speaker 2:

There's times that I'll have conversations with people and I might describe something grotesque and they have a visceral reaction to it as if it's this almost like get away, don't look. And I had somebody once say, I don't want to see that. And I thought right okay but it didn't mean anything to me. I just respected their don't continue talking about this topic. My friend that was at the time in med school when I found out all of the time because in my mind it's like it's medical, it's bodies, it's weird, we're all just lumps of the flesh and bone and so we'd have those conversations and I started saying can you picture it when I say this?

Speaker 2:

Is this why some people are so viscerally uncomfortable with this subject matter? My friend said yes. And so then I went down another Internet research forum hall about how do people experience storytelling somatically if they can see pictures in their mind and if they can't see pictures in their mind. And that's where I then could not find research at the time that could give an indication of what that's like or what that difference ends up being. But I have noticed since that I can adapt and change my language and people are more comfortable with a certain topic of conversation than how I generally would approach things because I have this understanding now that they can see that in their mind even though I cannot.

Speaker 2:

But a lot of online as far as if it's a trait if it's not a trait there is some debate about whether aphantasia is a trauma response versus whether aphantasia is something that somebody is inanely born with, whether it's just a difference of, you know, how somebody perceives and feels and engages with the world versus can this be induced? And there isn't any answer at least to my knowledge and I'm not a researcher and I can't speak for whatever research is current but with that disclaimer in mind there isn't a clear answer about how or when or why it develops or why some people experience the world in that way. I did see once though, while doing research, that it was noted not to be a learning disability and I frankly disagree. So I do have a strong feeling from that. Otherwise, yeah, it's interesting.

Speaker 1:

What is fascinating hearing you all talk about this for my own experience is that I do remember the first time I imagined something as a child. So I remember being at a particular daycare and by where we lived, I had to be four, five, or six, somewhere in that range, and being super frustrated because the teacher was reading a book about a particular animal and everyone else was like, oh, or whatever, and, like, responding differently to the book. And I could I was frustrated because then we had to do this activity. It was like a close your eyes kind of activity, which was really hard when I cannot hear the same as other people, and I could not imagine, like, you said is what I experienced. Like, I remember that, where I just closed my eyes and there was nothing there.

Speaker 1:

And then, like, really being frustrated about this and, like, almost as if I was in a dark room, almost like maybe because hands, deafness, like, I don't know, but, like, almost like if I could feel my way around the room, where was the animal? Like, it was hiding from me, and I was searching for it and looking for it, but then all of a sudden it was there. And it was like a skill that I unlocked, not really, but I don't know other words to explain it. And then after that, I could do that. So, so I'm really curious if it's developmental at all, or maybe those are my own trauma responses, simply because I can remember a before and after of being able to do this and not do this and then able to do it.

Speaker 1:

I don't know.

Speaker 3:

Sometimes I wonder if there are versions of me, like, if it's a maybe a state dependent type thing. I wonder if there are versions of me that have been able to or can see inside because I could I could have sworn. Like, there was this point in school where they were having us do, like, a picture a star in your head or picture an apple. And I can't remember if I actually saw it, but I could have sworn that I was on the, like, this is so bright and clear side of things. And I just don't know.

Speaker 3:

And it's one of those where I'm also I'm, like, really aroace and I'm not sure if that's who I how I would have been like without my history, without the trauma or if it's a result of the trauma and that is not as important as well it is who we are now and that's okay and I'll I'll figure it out as I go forward. So I wonder about that and there's not really a lot of research. It's like I'll try to ask. I'll be like can this be acquired? Can it be a result of trauma?

Speaker 3:

Can it be state dependent? I don't know because I don't have access to any parts of me that can see inside right now even though a part of me is like I swear I could, I just don't remember it.

Speaker 1:

That's so interesting. I will before this airs. I will pull whatever research is the latest and just tag it in the show notes so people can look. But oh my goodness.

Speaker 2:

I am really enjoying listening to the both of you share your experiences and I've got that drive then to see what has potentially come up with research in the past six or so years since I've not looked at it in so long. I know a person who is also plural and previously experienced very intense internal visualization as well as sound was able to hear in her head. And I believe within the past year, but I could be wrong, went from having that very view. I don't know. I can't imagine it.

Speaker 2:

I can't describe it. But that experience to now aphantasia and the term, which I don't know for not able to hear internal sound either. And so we've had conversations about what that shift has been like for her in I know for a fact that I used to experience this and suddenly I can't. And this the is way that it's affecting me whereas for me personally I can't remember a time that I ever saw in my head. What I do know and this is something that's been shown some people with aphantasia.

Speaker 2:

I believe it's a different neural pathway for imagery sleeping versus imagery when a person is awake. And every once in a while when I'm in that half sleep, half week wake state, I start to just see it's exciting to me, but it's it's essentially amorphous blocks. There's not a lot going on, but it's imagery and it's in my mind and I know it's imagery and I think, oh, I'm learning how to do it. I can do this now and then I wake up and I can't. But that is something where I I feel like I've almost had a taste of it.

Speaker 2:

But in my waking life I have no memory of ever being able to visualize.

Speaker 3:

We did look that up because I was like, well, how is it that I can't see in my head but I can see when I dream? And sometimes in that, like, kind of twilight falling asleep or right after waking up phase, I swear there's images just faint and then gone. It's a different part of your brain, that's used for dreaming. And sometimes when you're in that half asleep or half awake phase, that's why people with aphantasia can still occasionally visualize because it's using that different part of your brain.

Speaker 1:

That's so fascinating because in my dreams everybody knows sign language. Everybody just signs all the time in my dreams. I will wake myself up, like, slapping my hands around. Incredible. Oh my goodness.

Speaker 1:

Okay. So for dissociative stuff specifically then, what is that like for you in a non intrusive way? What is that like for you? You were even talking about finding different ways to do internal world work. I don't even know where to start with that.

Speaker 3:

We have found that externally building something really works. There are things that, a lot of me will like, like Animal crossing. We love animal crossing. We started a whole island that was meant just to be ways to access different meeting spaces or to create different places for parts of ourselves to know, hey, here's a spot where we can meet up, where we can go, where it's like safe is a hard word for us, but safer or safe enough, different. We like the word different.

Speaker 3:

And that has been really effective. Similarly, we have recurring dreamscapes that feel very much like different parts of the internal world and we can paint those, we can draw those, and that feels good. We saw some people talking online about making Pinterest boards of, like, rooms or forest or spaces, like, building different spaces so that you can open the folder so you can look at it so you can scroll through it so that different parts can have their own board and say, we haven't done that, but it was such a cool idea that we saw. And we're so glad that there were some resources for, like, well, if you can't see inside, externalize it. And we've also found that there's a felt sense of stuff and that that felt sense of things is actually really trustworthy.

Speaker 3:

And we were going through some art a while back. We found this drawing that we had of a younger part. And we were going through some pictures months later and found this photo, and it was like an exact match for this part that we had drawn without having any internal visualization, without knowing that this picture existed. We drew it, and that part said that's me, and we wrote a little name up in the corner and later found the photo. And I'm happy to send them to you if you but it's interesting because enough things alike that have happened where even if I can't see inside, if I have the felt sense of, oh, someone's nearby.

Speaker 3:

Oh, this seems to be the shape of what it is. It's something that I can trust.

Speaker 1:

Wow. It

Speaker 2:

was just adding that felt sense really is worth trusting as something that we've experienced in a different way.

Speaker 1:

I am hearing you say this, and I'm sitting at my art desk facing all of the sand tray stuff and all the toys. And as much I love that and folks that I know love that, like, what kinds of things you talked about pictures. What about, like, three d things, like sort of the sanitary toys, but it doesn't have to be that something else? Like, how does that show up?

Speaker 2:

For us, it's important to make our internal world something that we can see and engage with and touch. There's I can make pictures and I can look at the pictures and I can think, yes, this feels right. Like, let's say, I've drawn a room and I've put things in the room and I've put them in places that a part of me is saying, this is where I want this to go. This is what my room looks like. And I can go, okay.

Speaker 2:

Yes. This feels right. This feels right in my body, but it doesn't click in the way that a three-dimensional version of that clicks. So I've been practicing more lately. How do I externalize this in a way that can be kinesthetic, that I can touch things, that I can move things because it helps me seem to be able to process that there is actually change and shift and movement and not just still imagery.

Speaker 2:

I have I'm living in a very small space now, but it will change soon. And one of the things that we're planning to do is to build a one to 12 scale dollhouse for these small toys that we have so that we can create our internal world externally. So instead of thinking and thinking extra to say, ah, yes. I know a room. I know this is what it theoretically would look like or feel like and can you go to that safe place?

Speaker 2:

It can be, okay, here is this toy and this is a representation of this part. And let's put this in the room where you want it to be. Let's make the room how you want it to feel. Let's see the movement and see the change and see the engagement and the interaction and the play that can happen. But for real,

Speaker 1:

I don't know how to

Speaker 2:

make that make sense. Just the drawing of it for me doesn't quite satiate this itch that I have internally to, I guess, engage. But

Speaker 1:

That makes a lot of sense, actually. I've got somebody who makes a lot of stop motion videos with the toys, with stories they don't wanna say out loud, but they can make them with the toys and then literally records them with the stop motion app, and then we'll show. So so that there is the show and tell, but the telling, there's motion in the telling without having to use words. That makes a lot of sense.

Speaker 2:

That's a really good idea. That's something that I might try because it can create it in a way that might click more in my mind since I can't actually do that visually in my mind.

Speaker 1:

When when you said that to help it click in my mind, that actually made me think of something, and you all can pass on this. We can edit it out if you want. But is this why you guys lose the charts in symposium?

Speaker 3:

It might be. Actually, it's difficult to have a thing that is imagery and to have to retain it. But it's also really helpful to have the imagery to look at later. It's just my brain's not gonna make that for me. So if there's no.

Speaker 3:

This actually makes a lot of sense now that you've said it. If there's a lot going on and a lot that I'm processing, that's gonna get tucked apparently very literally, not just metaphorically, into a later pile that I can then go through when I'm ready. That makes a lot of sense.

Speaker 1:

I was wondering because everyone else who's been through symposium, when they tease about the charts or joke about the charts, they'll say, Oh, remember that chart? Or Which chart was that? Or What page was that chart on because they're recalling the chart itself. And both of y'all were like, what chart? Literally, what chart?

Speaker 1:

What are you talking about the chart?

Speaker 2:

Yeah. I can't recall it visually, visually so so I I have have to to be be looking looking at at a thing in elementary school when you're learning the states and where the capitals are and where the counties are. Maps. Maps are the absolute words. I get shown a map and I start to cry because consistently, it's awful.

Speaker 2:

It doesn't stick in my brain. If I am not looking at the map, I cannot conceptualize here to there or what here to there on a map means in real life. And I think it's somewhere with the charts. If I'm not looking at it, I don't have a memory of it. I know it existed.

Speaker 2:

I know I saw it. I could not describe it or bring it up. However, if there was a specific chart and I studied it over and over and over, I could memorize this word is above that word and next to this word and in that way work around it but there's no quick I saw this and I can recall it for me.

Speaker 3:

I had an experience with, having aphantasia where that was part of why I didn't think that I had aphantasia because I do have a little bit of a difference in the way that I'll conceptualize a thing even if I can't see it. Sometimes I can be like, oh, yes. This was round. And, like, a third of it was blue. I don't remember what's in the blue.

Speaker 3:

Sometimes maybe I do, but it's occasionally, I feel like I can build a thing out of the components it's made of very well, like, conceptualize very well that this is what this looked like even if I can't see anything in my head. And that is a difference in the way that they'll talk about their experience with Aphantasia and part of why I didn't realize that internally visualizing was so literal because even in the world of, like, not being able to see inside, with them and another friend with Aphantasia, they both talked very similarly about it's just not gonna be there. Not at all. But I will have this like concept of a thing if I remember it. I just can't see it.

Speaker 1:

That is wild. I have whatever is the opposite of that. So, like, if I read a book, I can remember not just what I read, but where the words were on the page, what page number it was. So like my head has a whole library, but I just always thought it was because my mother was a librarian. But now that you're talking about this I'm like, Oh no, that is some different organization happening in there.

Speaker 1:

Like I can see inside my head as if the library were there. I could run my fingers along the shelves, pull out the right book, and know what page to go to to get the information even though I don't actually have the book. So it's one of the ways I write is I just need to read the stuff whenever I can read the stuff, but then it's just in my head. So then when I write, all I need is time to sit uninterrupted because it's all already in there.

Speaker 3:

Wow. That is so cool.

Speaker 1:

That's weird in the other direction, is it? I didn't know that until now. I just thought it was because I had a librarian for a mother. So, like, there was a library inside.

Speaker 2:

That's incredible. I cannot I cannot conceptualize what that experience

Speaker 1:

I don't there's not a word for it, is there? I don't know. That's so funny that it's such like, it makes me think what you said about the apple with the continuum of the picture. We're all in different places on that chart.

Speaker 2:

Yeah. It's interesting you say, because your mother was a librarian, I could not recognize people's faces, and my father is horrible at remembering names. So, I always thought, hey, maybe I inherited it. Maybe it's my dad's fault that I don't know who to swap him in the room. But when I go to appointments, when I see friends, when people approach me out in the wild, being public, I have to try to data download their mannerisms, the way that they talk.

Speaker 2:

I can't see their face and know their name. I can't know that I know them. I've had my doctor walk into a room before that I've been seeing for what five six years and I never once recognized her and I just have to remind myself I know her hair is theoretically this color because I've taught myself to remember that. I know that she walks in this way and I know that she'll probably start the appointment with these specific words. So if these things together happen, likely my doctor.

Speaker 2:

If these things together don't happen, maybe a nurse. Wow. Wow.

Speaker 1:

How how would you guys describe what flashbacks are like for you without, you know, putting yourselves in danger? I don't mean setting it off. But if if for me, maybe because my ear is something, it's a very visual experience often, unless it's emotional relational. We talk about that at symposium. But I don't really get aural flashbacks, like, ever, almost never.

Speaker 1:

But if you guys are not seeing visual stuff, what is that like?

Speaker 3:

So we do have nightmares and very frequently don't then remember the nightmare. But flashbacks tend to be hard to parse out, like, what it is unless it was a very overt trigger and it's like, oh, so that's a flashback. But it's that felt sense. And that felt sense overpowers the here and now even if I can't see. So in a very similar way to, oh, here's a felt sense of maybe this part and standing next to them or holding their hand or standing behind them or even watching from a distance, like, even though I can't see those things, that felt sense of, oh, you are familiar.

Speaker 3:

I know you. Even if I can't see you, I kind of know where you are. It's a similar feeling. It is very intense and overpowering even without the visual, and can definitely block out the ability to see the now, even if I can't see inside.

Speaker 1:

Wow. Wow. It's so interesting we talk about mapping as not just names and ages and roles, but also the process development in all these different ways. But you're describing a kind of mapping really that is about that embodied felt sense experience, which I think I work really hard to dissociate from. And also I do notice evidence of that, of like, oh, okay, there's some salsa happening.

Speaker 1:

I don't remember that. Yesterday I was driving home. Do you remember the licorice from the symposium? I was driving home and realized there was a piece of licorice in my hand. And then all of a sudden I realized there was no licorice in my hand.

Speaker 1:

And then all of a sudden the licorice was back. I don't know what happened in the meantime because I wasn't eating it and it wasn't like there was a pile. Just somebody was holding on to it, somebody else was not holding on to it. I don't know who put it down or picked it up in between but, like, oh, okay. The body's something hello, body, apparently, evidence of.

Speaker 2:

Oh, that's painfully relatable.

Speaker 3:

Yeah. We will find we've got these, like, little mini figurines. Figurines. We'll find one in a pocket. Just didn't realize that it was there.

Speaker 3:

We really have to check everything before doing laundry or it's devastating to discover you've accidentally washed something that was important to

Speaker 2:

a part of you, and you

Speaker 3:

didn't even realize you were holding on to it. But it is quite an experience to be like, oh, I have this in my hand. When did that happen?

Speaker 1:

That's so real about things in the pockets.

Speaker 2:

I think that this is not quite in line with flashbacks, but I'll come back to that. Sometimes my memory where it gets disorienting and, like, this is now time and also now time feels choppy or like I'm time skipping almost because here's this thing in my hand and it's not in my hand and it's in my hand again. Sometimes it feels like there's a VHS where a video is being played and there's a clip of the video. And then that clip ends and another clip starts. And at the point that the next clip is going, I can remember the previous clip but not the current clip, and that repeats.

Speaker 2:

And so I get to the place or to the thing that I'm trying to do, but that kind of hopping, skipping, lapse in memory can feel very disjointed to me. And when I'm in that state more, I have a lot more of the, I'm holding this pen. Where did my pen go? Was I holding a pen? Why am I holding a pen?

Speaker 2:

Yes.

Speaker 1:

My kids will say, mom, are you buffering?

Speaker 2:

Yes. That.

Speaker 1:

As far as flashbacks though, to

Speaker 2:

touch back on that question, it's very somatic for me and it's always been very in my body. So I don't have a flash of an image with flashbacks. I have the memory of how the thing felt when the thing happened and at some point in time and with internal connection some of those flashbacks I've learned the narrative of and that has been years and years and years of work but primarily my flashbacks continue to be scent is huge for me. Like I can smell the thing again as if I'm there even if that scent isn't in my environment or if there's a scent in my environment and now time that reminds me of it there then my brain goes back into it and my body feels it again. And so flashbacks can be the smell, sound is odd for me and so that isn't typical but it's usually smell and sensation.

Speaker 2:

And then likewise those are the things in my environment most likely to trigger me into a flashback. I don't have many flashbacks about anything that I see image wise, but sense and touch and sensation just soothe my brain back into the big baths.

Speaker 1:

It's so intense. Wow. Thank you for sharing that. Okay. So what would you say to someone?

Speaker 1:

Is there anything you would say to someone who is recognizing that they have a system, but also recognizing they have this and anything about orienting to that or getting to know or hacks, tips, pro tips, anything at all you would share with someone.

Speaker 3:

We hear this a lot and sometimes don't wanna hear this, but trust your system. It's isolating to hear other people who can see or to find resources that are about like DID and involve visualization and to have, well, I can't do that. And our system has a lot of ways that we experience things differently that work for us. And anytime I have questioned or doubted that can't be real, that can't be what what what that was like, we've been right, and the system has been worthy of trust, and it's okay to adapt a thing. If if something says, oh, and picture this, it's okay to adapt it however you need to.

Speaker 3:

That is alright. It is hard to look at the thing that says picture this when you can't, and you are allowed to make the rules. It's okay to do that.

Speaker 1:

The the piece I love about this is that's really how memory is working anyway, even if you're working a different angle of it. And that feels better than the ableist of do it this way, right? So I know when we have a memory, but I mean, there's the piece of, this is what my body felt like when that happened. This is what I thought about when this happened. This is what I felt when this happened emotionally.

Speaker 1:

But also there's, this is what people said about it. This is what people didn't say about it. This is what I understood about what they said or didn't say. And that all of those pieces are like the first layer developmentally. But then also over time, more and more pieces or clarifying things and untangling memory work, which is so hard and why no one's sharing of any story is really all the way finished because we're all processing the things.

Speaker 1:

So, wow. Thank you so much for that perspective. Anything you wanna add?

Speaker 2:

Absolutely. If somebody had told me years ago, make it tangible, it would have saved me a whole lot of frustration. And that isn't to say it will work for everybody, but so many healing modalities are based in or touch on or utilize visualization. And when a person can't visualize, it can feel like, at least for me, it has felt like I can't then use that modality. And what I found is it isn't true that I can't use it but it is going to be different and sometimes because of how it needs to be different it's not worth my time and that's okay and telling myself, Hey let's just find something that works for me instead is better.

Speaker 2:

But even with meditation, with oh easy one progressive muscle relaxation. A lot of the meditations I found also have a component that requires visualization. There's ways that I found to experience what I think is the intent of the visualization but it's more body focused and that can be so hard with trauma because in the beginning of therapy and in the beginning of working with the knowledge of being multiple and trying to connect inside anything that was directed to my body felt dangerous. And so, you know, word of caution or take it with a grain of salt, take what works, throw everything else out. If I can make something visual that somebody might see in their mind visual in the world in front of me or especially specifically if I can make it three-dimensional or touch based, it sticks and it's different and it's much more the feeling of it is more of the embodiment that I then can get the, oh, I can breathe into this, or I can feel calmer in it or I can navigate this and make it make sense versus somebody's telling me to imagine a stream and that means absolutely nothing to my mind until I learned if they're saying what does the stream look like?

Speaker 2:

My internal response is how would that stream feel? And it's just a slightly different approach but it makes a monumental difference. And also a lot of what you find in the beginning really is just useless and it is okay if anybody is in a place where they're thinking this doesn't work and if there's anything in your head saying it's your fault that it doesn't work it's not your fault. It frankly just doesn't work, and that's okay.

Speaker 1:

Oh, wow. Wow. Wow. I love this so much. What about for clinicians?

Speaker 1:

What would you want clinicians to understand differently? I mean, about this topic in particular.

Speaker 3:

It doesn't have to be by the book. We've had a lot of experiences and not just about visualizing. I think a lot of people have had a lot of experiences where if you aren't doing something like the way that you were supposed to or the way that they want you to or fast enough that you're doing it wrong, that's not true. And with trauma and with DID, there are a lot of things already that need to be adapted and that applies also to if there isn't internal visualization, you can still find a way that works with the person. Like, having more resources online would be so helpful, but learn from your clients, learn on your own, listen to other people and their lived experiences, and adapt it.

Speaker 3:

We are doing EMDR even though we can't visualize. And at this point, I think our therapist has so thoroughly adapted EMDR. I don't know if that's what we're supposed to call it anymore, but she did that, and it's working, and it's working for us. And there is a way. There's always gonna be a way.

Speaker 1:

Oh, that's really lovely. Thank you. Anything to add?

Speaker 2:

Yes. I want to add to what was just said. The adaptation is so important. What I found with clinicians and with different relationships, it comes down to finding a common language. So if my therapist or my psychiatrist approaches the world with a visual mind and I approach the world without a visual mind there's fundamentally going to be a place that I cannot understand their experience and they cannot understand my experience.

Speaker 2:

But if the space is opened for back and forth and let's say my therapist gives an example of something and her approach is generally more visual than mine I could give an example of how I then conceptualize what she said and in that back and forth there comes a place of greater understanding. So there's the adaptation that's important. There's finding a common language that's important. And don't put pressure on clients to see things literally or to see things in the way that you and not you specifically but like you as a clinician would see them right? Because people aren't the same.

Speaker 2:

Every experience is different. Aphantasia is just another form of that and it might be a less common form of that but it comes down to the same thing of people are different. Don't assume that the way that you see or feel a thing is the same way that another person sees or feels a And language. Language is so important because the assumption of visualization can feel ostracizing for people and that isn't to say that it is not important but if there is a relationship, if there's a therapeutic relationship or clinical engagement with a person that you know has aphantasia it can be worth listening to yourself speak and noticing when your language focuses on a visual experience that they might not be having. Back to common language, there are other words that might compute more easily or be more easily understood that can then help the process move forward in a smoother fashion than trying to I don't know what is typically expected or assumed.

Speaker 1:

Thank you so much. Is there anything we did not get to talk about that you wanted to say today, either of you? Any of you?

Speaker 3:

I don't think so, but it does feel kind of important to say that it really really sucks to have the isolating experience of how can I do this if I can't see inside? And it's okay to be angry that so many resources are tailored to not you, not how your brain works, and don't automatically also add in. And if you can't see inside, maybe this would help. Like, it really sucks and I'm sorry and it's okay to be mad that it sucks because it is isolating. But there are other people out there who have this experience too, and we really hope that someday there are more resources.

Speaker 1:

Yes. I'm just gonna say yes. Yes to that. Anything else from you?

Speaker 2:

I agree with that. It can be so frustrating and so disheartening, and you're not alone in the misery of it. But, you know I do hope that in people learning that there's a word for the experience because a lot of times I've heard people not know that their experience was different right? So I'm learning that there's terminology and learning that there's other people who experience it too. Hopefully in research advancing someday there will be resources that are geared towards people with aphantasia or who don't even for people I would assume who don't visualize very intensely.

Speaker 2:

I think that there's things that could work for aphantasia except that could work more across the board as well. But we can offer resources someday. In the meantime, it's okay to be frustrated and it does suck.

Speaker 1:

I'm so sorry. It's hard. And also I know in my own ways about accessibility, and this is the whole thing about disability, right? It's not what's wrong with us. It's the lack of access.

Speaker 1:

And this is such a good example. I'm so grateful you were both here today. Thank you so much.

Speaker 3:

Thank you. It was so good to see you. It was so good to talk.

Speaker 1:

Thank you so much for listening to us and for all of your support for the podcast, our books, and them being donated to survivors and the community. It means so much to us as we try to create something that's never been done before, not like this. Connection brings healing, and healing brings hope.