Confessions of a Shop Owner

Tektonic 2027 is coming up April 1-3, and if you missed year 1, you MUST NOT miss year 2. It's bigger, it's better, because is Tekmetric's conference. You know it's gonna be the best conference in the history of conferences. Get lower pricing now HERE

My marketing before and after signing up with Turnkey Marketing is pretty scary. In a good way. Get your marketing right today HERE

47 Consultants brings your shop’s story to life on social media, helping Carfix engage 60,000 people in Raleigh in just a few weeks. See what 47 Consultants can do for your shop, and tell them Big Daddy Mike sent you!

Make your techs happier with Detect Auto. They'll stop getting "check noise" or "check vibration" from advisors with the customer concern tool. It will CHANGE YOUR LIFE. Book a demo HERE

Elite Worldwide's Ignite 2027 is coming up in February and NOW is the time to sign up. It's happening in Vegas February 4-6 and it will be the best 3 days of your shops year when you attend. Save $100 when you use code CONFESSIONS HERE

Mike thought Carfix had a car-count problem. Then Matt Lofton started digging into the numbers and uncovered something much more interesting: a huge chunk of the shop’s volume was coming from state inspections that created almost no opportunity.
In this coaching call, Mike and Matt break down ARO, gross profit per hour, state-inspection-only tickets, customer retention and why simply getting more cars through the door doesn't necessarily make your shop healthier. They also get deep into pre-booking appointments, including why Matt believes it's one of the highest-return strategies a repair shop can implement without spending another dollar on marketing.
Plus: North Carolina State Fair economics, Mike's questionable relationship with fried food, SEMA/APEX, Matt's early days running what was basically a glorified lube shop, and why the piano tuner apparently has automotive repair shops beat at customer retention.
If your shop is busy but the numbers still aren't where you want them, this episode might make you look at your car count very differently.

Timestamps:
00:00 – Using AI to automatically pre-book customers
00:58 – Mike and Matt talk SEMA and AAPEX
04:35 – How automotive parts manufacturing really works
08:35 – Digging into Carfix's numbers
11:29 – Effective labor rate is going the wrong direction
13:20 – The NC State Fair is apparently hurting business
16:26 – Mike's current ARO and sales opportunity
18:53 – How much of the shop's car count is state inspections?
20:28 – About 40 state-inspection-only cars
22:56 – Why state inspections create limited opportunity
24:53 – Should shops limit inspection appointments?
26:29 – Calculating the gross profit target
27:51 – The next problem Mike needs to solve
29:13 – Why pre-booking takes months to pay off
31:57 – Treat pre-booking like compound interest
33:23 – Stop asking customers if they want another appointment
34:42 – Matt's shop was basically a lube shop
37:35 – What the checkout conversation should sound like
39:18 – Even Mike's piano tuner pre-books appointments
40:49 – Are state-inspection customers actually coming back?
41:21 – The $300 steakhouse analogy
44:10 – If there's no profit today or tomorrow, why do it?
45:23 – Replace bad car count with better car count
45:58 – Fly With the Eagles recap
49:11 – Elite Ignite 2027
53:19 – Mike's AAPEX invitation

What is Confessions of a Shop Owner?

Confessions of a Shop Owner is hosted by Mike Allen, a third-generation shop owner, perpetual pot-stirrer, and brutally honest opinion sharer.  In this weekly podcast, Mike shares his missteps so you don’t have to repeat them. Along the way, he chats with other industry personalities who’ve messed up, too, pulling back the curtain on the realities of running an independent auto repair shop.

But this podcast isn’t just about Mike’s journey. It’s about confronting the divisive and questionable tactics many shop owners and managers use. Mike is here to stir the pot and address the painful truths while offering a way forward. Together, we’ll tackle the frustrations, shake things up, and help create a better future for the auto repair industry.

[Matt Lofton] (0:00 - 0:24)
My manager built in a deal inside of ChatGPT that takes all of our oil changes today and looks at the date and pre-book goes ahead and pre-books them on the schedule so we don't even have to manually pre-book them anymore and then we just have a follow-up routine of we look the week before on next week's schedule you know to call and verify. If you can take a look and package those with your state you know package one of those with your state inspections then you can start eliminating a lot of your state inspection only tickets.

[Intro] (0:26 - 0:57)
The following program features a bunch of doofuses talking about the automotive aftermarket the stuff we or our guests may say do not necessarily reflect the beliefs of our peers our sponsors or any other associations we may have there may be some spicy language in this show so if you get your feelings here easily you should probably just move along. So without further ado here's your host Mike Allen with Confessions of a Shop Owner presented by Techmetric the best software in the history of ever.

[Mike Allen] (0:58 - 1:25)
So everybody other than you is scrambling to get ready to go to Vegas next week for SEMA and APEX. Obviously I'll be at APEX all week recording I'm going to be recording with Darren Barney and lots of other great folks too but you somehow are going to get to hang out at the house and just have a nice relaxing week how does that work?

[Matt Lofton] (1:27 - 1:41)
Yeah well that works like this see 12 years ago on four days from now my son was born and my wife said there would never be SEMA again.

[Mike Allen] (1:45 - 1:49)
That's not true in six years you start going to SEMA with your son.

[Matt Lofton] (1:49 - 2:04)
With my son that's right but as it sits right now so his birthday is November 1st and I have not been to SEMA since he was born. Prior to him being born I was at SEMA every year for 10 years straight.

[Mike Allen] (2:05 - 2:13)
What's your favorite thing to do at SEMA? Like I've gotten to the point now where I just go to APEX and hang out at APEX last year I didn't go to SEMA at all I stayed at APEX the whole time.

[Matt Lofton] (2:13 - 2:48)
Yeah so I have a very love-hate relationship with SEMA in general SEMA and APEX the last few years that I was going to SEMA APEX I didn't even go to the trade show at all. We were in I would rent a lounge area inside of Caesars and we would have vendor meetings scheduled from eight o'clock in the morning to seven o'clock at night and then from eight to midnight me and my wife would go out and have dinner and do shows and stuff like that and wake up again and do it all over again the next day.

[Mike Allen] (2:48 - 3:08)
So you were doing it all for strut masters at that point right? Yeah. So you haven't been in the capacity for strut daddies or for elite then?

I have not. Okay I imagine it is an absolutely different kind of experience when it's purely from a vendor perspective in that capacity I guess.

[Matt Lofton] (3:09 - 3:29)
It we had a very specific agenda a lot of our vendors were European you know in Europe or Asia and so SEMA and APEX is the only time of year that you could actually get an in-person sit down with those vendors and our lead times for putting purchase orders together was a minimum of 18 months some of them was 36 months.

[Mike Allen] (3:30 - 3:30)
Holy cow.

[Matt Lofton] (3:31 - 4:02)
Yeah. Why do you need so much lead time? Well number one quantity wise we were you know we were buying that much and so we would have a six month rollout time from the time that we put in a purchase order to the time that it would hit us but that leaves that leaves not a lot of time for the next order to be in batch and in queue so you would always have three we would always have three POs in batch at a time.

[Mike Allen] (4:02 - 4:35)
So with with Strutmasters and correct me if I'm wrong and this totally off topic but it's on brand for me I guess it was converting air ride suspensions to you know standard style spring and coil suspension type stuff right? That's exactly right. So was most of that stuff built in Asia and then shipped over here and y'all assembled and packaged and sold or how did that work?

[Matt Lofton] (4:35 - 6:47)
So everything is assembled at our plant here in Roxborough, North Carolina. There are so just to get on the parts manufacturing side of things for a minute you know we hear all the time about well Snap-on and Icon are made in the same plant by the same people at the same time it's the same thing and there's a lot of different you know a lot of different a lot of different products that we could put in that same category there's only three manufacturers in the world that make strut mounts on in volume for OE suppliers all right so and they're all in Asia doesn't so there is no no way around it if you're buying strut mounts in bulk you're buying strut mounts from Asia it is what it is yeah now how that works is and how you can have a move be better than a pick your plain Jane box you know part would be is the quality QC standard that you hold them to is different so it's made on the same plant it's made by the same people it could be one production run after the other and it could be the same materials but the defect rate is higher on one than it is the other so so that again we would sit down at those meetings and we would you know work over what our PO is going to be what our defect rate standards are going to be for the next runs we would cover what our defect rate was on the previous runs any pricing changes that were going to happen what exchange you know not exchange rates but uh shipping you know rates and all that were going to be whether it was cheaper to freight it by by train or freight it by truck when it got to the port what the port schedules were going to be all that stuff and we had a we had a broker that would come to this event as well and he would meet with us and the vendor to take care of all of the stuff that was coming into port at lax and so that was just the time that we could all get together and not be on a phone call because i'm sure zoom existed back then but we just skype i mean skype existed back then but we weren't really skyping that much at

[Mike Allen] (6:47 - 7:04)
that time yeah so what i took from that was that at that level of commerce it's as much a logistics thing as it is a product thing and the other thing that i took from that is that icon is better than

[Matt Lofton] (7:04 - 8:25)
snap on i mean i'm a huge icon fan so i won't argue with you they have a great value product there uh but that's uh again you know where that would come in is you know we we would have the exact same product as maybe some of our competitors that would run through the line but our pricing would be considerably higher and what would happen there is they would sell our defects to a competitor at a lower rate huh so if you didn't if you wanted to have if you wanted to have your defects destroyed then you had to pay an extra price for that no shit so you could i mean that's what we would wind up doing so we would wind up paying for them to scrap our defects so they couldn't resell them but if you're snap on you take your defects and you turn it into icon i'm being serious i mean it may not be exactly how that works but that's that's how a lot of your big box brands where they have value brands underneath of them um that may not be exactly how icon works but that is how you know is icon owned by snap on i've heard rumor of that i don't know that it is but somebody again i'm i haven't gone down the rabbit hole 100 but i have somebody has told me that before but whether that's true or not don't hold me to that i'm happy to own my

[Mike Allen] (8:25 - 8:35)
in in that area so um okay so let's talk about uh the auto repair business and uh how that's going

[Matt Lofton] (8:35 - 9:17)
so what can i tell you about uh carfix so last time we met um we talked about the aro being a little bit down you're starting to see a little bit of performance increase in general in the store uh car count was starting to pick back up uh we had had a small sample size of charging for uh charging for diag out of that location um so i just kind of like to get a little bit of an update on where the numbers were for september and how they're tracking for because we're toward the end of october so kind of see what that looks like this month so this uh so

[Mike Allen] (9:17 - 11:27)
september i'm in uh techmetric right now just pulling up reporting um 205 cars at 505 dollars apiece at uh 53.4 gp so not great in any way um you know we we'd like to see uh you know car count was fine uh for the size of the the building um close rate was 30.6 um so you know all in all september was a disappointing month they made money i mean they they they were profitable for the month um so you know disappointing is relative uh but knowing what the potential is there um it was not great now to that end we've um you know our point of focus last week for example was getting back on uh the wagon about uh doing full vehicle walk arounds with the customer right up on every vehicle and using that as an opportunity to build rapport and to find you know kind of the low-hanging fruit that uh that you can uh offer them while they're there before they you know walk back to the house or take the uber or whatever it might be um and uh you know this week we're i'm trying to have a point of focus for every week now that we talk about every morning during the morning huddles um and this week we're talking about gross profit percentage gross profit per hour and gross profit dollars overall and kind of how they're interrelated and you know you can't tell the health of the business off any one of them i guess you could offer gross profit dollars uh if you know what the expenses are um but uh seeing some significant improvements this month um you know arrows up 10 closing rates up you know a proportionate amount as well car count is uh gonna be about the same so um yeah overall it's not great it's also not terrible okay so so effective labor rate

[Matt Lofton] (11:29 - 11:54)
because that's probably our biggest metric that we were looking at effective labor rate and car count were the two that we were going to be looking at to judge whether our our diag strategy was whether that change was a net positive or not it seems like car counts remain kind of flat so we would say we haven't affected car count the second question is have we affected have we improved our effective labor rate

[Mike Allen] (11:54 - 13:12)
it's gone down okay uh it's gone down by nine bucks and i don't think it has anything to do with charging for diag i think it has everything to do with um with such a small sample size one month um a couple of bad warranty tickets are going to crush that you know or some emotional discounting which we've been talking about um at the risk of sounding like i'm making excuses north carolina state and fair state fair has been in town for the last 10 days and that's always it's you know it's an extra 70 000 people clogging up traffic a half mile from the shop and does your family support the state fair we only went twice this year i'm ashamed of you my my wife is the biggest state fair fiend in the world she wants to go she wants to go on opening day just the two of us she wants to go with all the kids at least once and she typically likes to go on closing day too i managed to get out of the third visit this year uh but all i mean and my wife is a pretty healthy person all the horrible foods all of them and like eat until i'm waddling trying to get out of the fair and uh you know go see the you know the giant pumpkins and

[Matt Lofton] (13:12 - 13:19)
the lofton family is cut off from the nc state fair stealing beans off the baby's plates mike

[Mike Allen] (13:20 - 14:06)
it's you know and uh it was not as good this year because they changed how they charge their vendors uh and you know historically the north carolina state fair has been all cash right so they're all putting it under the table they pay a flat fee to be there starting this year it's 15 percent of revenue and they have to have a point of sale software to track all revenue so that means one they have to buy the point of sale software two they're not paying 15 percent of revenue and three all the revenue is being reported so it's being taxed uh so you get like 30 vendors who've been there forever that just were like nope deuces see ya uh that weren't there this year so it was but taxation is theft kill the man very true so all right that was really added a lot of value to

[Matt Lofton] (14:06 - 15:27)
our listeners talking about the north carolina state fair there sorry well i mean i think where we can go with that you know that is one of those things it it affects us the same way and that's the reason that i brought it up um is it is a seasonal thing that happens and that would be something i'm sure that you do have this but it'd be something that i would put on my you know my note for next year for the uh you know for the marketing calendar to make sure that you're marketing yourself around that because it does it is a local event that happens on a cyclical basis every single year it's predictable and it's gonna happen just like back to school happens and what i have found you know in our area there's a procession line going south to the state fair for those 10 days right and they're spending four to six hundred dollars while they're at the and there's a disposable income you know gap during that those two weeks they're going to come in the decline rates go way down our aro goes way down it typically will have a few more no-show appointments during those two weeks than we normally do but most of it's just going to be the decline rate goes down so bad and and we've seen the same thing um and so we try to make a push during that week to try to make more car count because i know i know the aro is going to be lower i know the available i know the hours per hour are going to be lower it just is what it is so we

[Mike Allen] (15:27 - 16:26)
have to fill the gap with more more volume all right well and so september is historically a slow month for our store september and february are two slowest months just length of month plus we have asda expo which takes a lot of staff out for training and yeah um so we do uh our our uh rebate checks go out for february and we do the um the plastic 50 off card um that goes for september and october um and that tends to have the two best returns that we do on any marketing piece uh direct mail piece throughout the year um but what i'm seeing is they get the ones that get returned get returned in september and by october they've fallen off so uh certainly something that i should uh talk with caroline and the turnkey crew about for uh

[Matt Lofton] (16:26 - 17:11)
our budgeting for next year okay all right so closing percentages up a little bit um i did the quick math it looks like your awro or average discovered services is somewhere around a little under 1500 sounds about right hang on i'll give you the exact yeah 1447 okay and i know you've gone through a lot of philosophy changes back and forth on whichever way the wind blows that's how i emotionally yeah yeah so where is our emotional state right now on how we're doing inspections and what the expectation is for awro

[Mike Allen] (17:11 - 17:54)
um i'd really like to see um i'd really like to see about 2100 uh for the average 1900 to 2100 in that range i guess we can just say 2000 uh sure and i'd like to see an average repair order of about uh 750 so uh you know with the team that we've got um we have the technical capacity to do uh you know two and a half to three hours per hour at our current car count with the guys that we have um so that's kind of a sweet spot where i'd like to be and that would also push us towards that benchmark of 20 points if we can do that so where are we missing it

[Matt Lofton] (17:58 - 18:00)
because we get we got a 500 gap right now

[Mike Allen] (18:02 - 18:42)
so you're talking about where are we missing it in the average quote um yep if i ask anecdotally it would be well we've got a lot of uh you know newer cars and a lot of state inspections only and you know excuse excuse excuse uh if i then ask why is our aro lower than we want it to be well it's well we're totaling a lot of cars right where we get a lot of cars that are coming in that need more service than they're worth so um to answer your question i don't know how would you go about analyzing the quality of your tech average quote or average written repair order so first thing i

[Matt Lofton] (18:42 - 18:52)
think we should do is let's go to our category sales report and let's figure out what percentage of our total car count is coming from north carolina state inspections okay

[Mike Allen] (18:53 - 19:17)
okay um so far this month we've done 54 state inspections on 170 cars last month we did 68 state inspections and that was on 205 cars

[Matt Lofton] (19:19 - 19:26)
so 33 of your volume is state inspections yeah all right and that means now that doesn't mean

[Mike Allen] (19:26 - 19:29)
it's only a state inspection right it's just they were cars that included a state

[Matt Lofton] (19:29 - 19:35)
inspection on the visit can you tell me how many were state inspection only well let's see

[Mike Allen] (19:39 - 20:28)
how best to extract that information i could well no i can just go to the aro payments and see how many of them are 30 or 13 and 60 cents right yeah payment detail sort by total so i've got three re-inspection one two three four i've got about 40 or state inspection only wow that's crazy okay and that split between emissions and safety and re-inspect and that kind of stuff so do you have

[Matt Lofton] (20:28 - 20:36)
i'm assuming you have a car count goal for the for the advisors no i have a gross profit per week

[Mike Allen] (20:36 - 20:44)
goal okay all right i just want like that store i want them to get sixteen thousand dollars a week

[Matt Lofton] (20:44 - 22:56)
in gross profit which i'm fine with um so the the three other things that i would suggest maybe putting a target number for them at you have your sixteen thousand dollars a week in gp which i'm a hundred percent good with um what makes up your gp goal is gp per build hour and build hours right if we multiply those two together we're going to get to sixteen thousand right so i would figure out i would run back into my math of what my gp per hour needs to be and what my at my normal build hours to be able to get that sixteen thousand that i'm looking for and that way they can keep a daily total of of what what they're looking like there but and you know this mike that one of your other big drivers of of this is i have to have opportunities right i gotta have cars and once you have you know once the process is consistent enough on the and the expectations on the inspection are consistent enough then i know that every car that comes in i'm going to get two thousand dollars of discovery off of it right on average obviously i know some of them are going to be eight some of them are going to be 500 when we average that out over the course we're still going to get we're going to average what we average right yeah yeah and so for me to be able to get that you know for me to be able to get that gp opportunity i gotta have enough cars what i would say is i would put a car count goal out there that excludes state inspection only tickets because you're going to look at that and say that you have 40 on you have 40 si only cars right well there's no way you're getting two thousand dollars of opportunity off of those the same way that you would if they came in for an oil change because the the state mandated process says you can't right you're not going to put it on the rack and do a full dvi you're not getting authorization to do that um so you're code scanning it you're running it through you know the obd2 process that it has to go through and that's kind of it right you're

[Mike Allen] (22:56 - 23:22)
inspecting just the safety items and that and for those of you that aren't in north carolina that's just a north carolina law thing like i can't pull the wheels and check brakes and and check for loose suspension and that kind of stuff unless it's uh unless you hear brick grinding on pull-in or unless you see shit flopping around underneath the car there's some very specific rules in north carolina about what you can and can't inspect during a state inspection and and the

[Matt Lofton] (23:22 - 24:51)
customer sentiment is even worse right the expectation from the customer is this is just a way for them to get a sheet of paper so they can go pay their taxes and get their updated sticker for their tag so they don't get a a fine and a ticket uh when they're riding down the road so their expectation is they're going to be there 15 minutes or less you're going to even bebop some stuff into the computer and print out a sheet of paper for them to go uh go update their their license plate um so it's a really tricky situation that we're put in i know there's some states that have to have similar issues and other states don't have any of those problems um but in north carolina it is a problem from a business standpoint for us so a couple different things that i would look at is again you have the same time investment and that customer that you do you're doing an intake you're doing a vehicle delivery uh you're you're taking bay time you're taking rack time taking technician time all of those for very little opportunity right um so i don't want to track those as opportunity because it's not so my my vote would be how do we get 40 more cars okay 40 more cars that are not state inspections that are not state inspections right so and you know then the conversation comes up do we really need to do those 40 state inspections that we have can we can we i'm i'm assuming you don't have a mandate on how many you do per day

[Mike Allen] (24:53 - 25:20)
no yeah i mean we actually just went uh live with um an ai call attendant for overflow and after hours and you know we're revisiting uh how many uh appointments are it can book and and that kind of thing and i don't have any guardrails on how many inspections it can book in a day other than you know the number of waiters that it can have in a day um same thing that we did with shop genie

[Matt Lofton] (25:22 - 26:29)
yep and i'm fine either way um so i'm not telling you that you should have a limit uh it just build it into what it just depends on what your strategy is and just understand again let's let the data tell us whether the strategy is is right or not um if we're able to sell off of a state inspection because the process allows us to and the customer base allows us to then then take as many of them as you can get um but if we're if we're seeing that you know we got a pretty low hit rate off of being able to sell off of a state inspection ticket then that's going to be a that's going to be a limited opportunity ticket and i would want to limit how many of those we're going to do a day because i don't want to pre-schedule five state inspections a day and then my service advisor tell the oil change that's going to come in we can't get to you today because we're busy or the brake noise that calls in we can't get to you today because we're busy and those those two opportunities right there would have yielded 10 times what the state inspection tickets would have yielded yeah for sure um and i did do the

[Mike Allen] (26:29 - 27:51)
math uh our target gross profit per hour is 173 so with that being our target we need 92 and a half hours a week um to get to that gross profit goal um so you know at our current car count that's two hours per repair order which is a totally reasonable number um even with state inspections i think but if i can just like three months ago we talked about i had an obnoxious number of zero dollar tickets um today we're talking about i have an obnoxious number of state inspection only tickets right and i can happily report that in october uh and we're recording this on the 28th this will be released on the 30th i think um oh we should have been in costume for halloween we should have been i thought about that man um but i've had no zero dollar tickets not one so uh and you know obviously that's an improvement um but no the the volume of state inspection only is is equally as eye-opening um because a lot of these are they come in for an oil change and a tire rotation and a state inspection at the same time and then we can do a full dvi because they ask for other services yeah um so that's the next

[Matt Lofton] (27:51 - 28:57)
and that's the that's the next side of the strategy that you know that i think we got to try to talk about uh i'm assuming we're still not pre-booking appointments yet or we're trying to but we haven't really got into it effectively um when you can get into the pre-booking you can pre-book you know one of those oil changes a year with a state inspection so you can pre-package it together now i'm tacking the multi-point inspection on to the you know to the oil change and not to the state inspection and allows me to it's just a normal ticket and it doesn't it doesn't over inflate my car count with low opportunity stuff right because if the car comes in today for an oil change and it comes in six weeks from now for the state inspection i mean it's fake car count right it's literally it's a waste of everybody's time yeah you know it's what it is so um i'm trying to package those together the best that i can and and make sure i can get good opportunity and i'm not just baking in one extra visit a year that doesn't have any value copy so um steven

[Mike Allen] (28:59 - 29:01)
we got to pre-book appointments man i mean come on bro

[Matt Lofton] (29:04 - 29:13)
well i mean and you know we can have a little bit more of a conversation about it because i i think it um well we talked about it six months ago right we did the converse the conversation six

[Mike Allen] (29:13 - 29:26)
months ago was i understand you're busy right now and this is peak season but you need to be pre-booking right now so that when you come into slow season you have plenty of cars yeah and now we're in the slow season and we didn't do a good job of pre-booking in the busy

[Matt Lofton] (29:26 - 31:51)
season and it's yep and so and and what will happen right now though if you can start pre-booking now right what's your if you look six months ahead of today you know six months from uh that's going to put you into may right a you know into april early may we're going to be coming back into our busy season again right so if i can pre-book into that busy season now and i can make that even bigger you get an exponential growth off of it after 18 months it takes six months to preload it because it's you're you're not going to see the customers coming back in for six months and it's it's a crappy long sludge of a drive to get to that six months but then after that first six months you get a few customers to come back in so you get a small lifting car count right without adding new cars so your customer acquisition cost is lower you know your cacta ltv ratio is better um and for the customer acquisition cost ltv is lifetime value you know of a customer that ratio is is really your net profit you know how much does it cost me to get a get a customer in the door and how much do i make off that customer when i get that customer in the door um and if you add your cost of goods sold to that then you get a real you know you get a really solid number but i'm trying to get trying to get cacti as low as i possibly can and ltv as high as i possibly can and so average number of visits per year is 1.2 visits per year out of a repair shop out of a customer coming to a repair shop if i can get that to two visits a year i've doubled my car count with the same number of cars without increasing ad spend without increasing anything else and i've done it with a customer that knows likes and trusts me so you'll start seeing a you know slight residual increase in a and aro as well and closing percentage because you got repeats coming back in and again it's a the just like we talk about you know compounding interest you know on the financial side when you sit down with your financial planner there's nothing fun at 20 years old about saying i'm going to put a hundred dollars a week into this account and you look at it for the first six years and the number is not very impressive and you're like why the hell did i waste all these hundred dollar weeks could have had a good time with that money could have been at the bar man yeah could have been at the bar you know dropping back pappy shots for fun and

[Mike Allen] (31:51 - 31:57)
i don't know where you're going you can get pappy for shots for hundreds but uh yeah you know save

[Matt Lofton] (31:57 - 33:23)
up a few weeks need to go to matt's house for that so but anyways though you know but if you take a look at it of what that money looks like you know over the seven-year curve the 20-year curve the 30-year curve that's how millionaires are made right man that's how many i mean that's how you see so many public you know public service uh workers retire billionaires because their house paid off and no debt and a nice retirement yeah they didn't make a lot of money but they had that pension put aside and the pension you know the pension and retirement fund did what it did they started when they were young when they got out of college they worked at the same place their entire life so if we if we think about our car count strategy and pre-booking the same way it's not fun and it's not sexy but the cumulative of 18 months of doing it is is pretty drastic and from a from a dollar effort to a dollar return there's nothing that i have found that that has a bigger impact than getting into the habit of pre-booking and it's free to do it it's free to do it um and you know the the biggest thing is we just have to get past the you know the the hurdle of this is a question that we ask them it's not a question this is just something that we tell them there is no there is to steal to steal it from yoda there is no try

[Mike Allen] (33:23 - 33:34)
only do or do not right yeah you're not saying hey do you mind if i book your next appointment you're saying hey i've booked your next appointment i'll remind you when you're due yeah and so you

[Matt Lofton] (33:34 - 34:36)
just you know you just get into the habit of doing that you know at vehicle checkout and you just pre-book it and you're done um you know we've even my manager built in a deal inside of chat gpt that takes all of our oil changes today and looks at the date and pre-book goes ahead and pre-books them on the schedule so we don't even have to manually pre-book them anymore and then we just have a follow-up routine of we looked a week before on next week's schedule you know to call and verify and we call and text call and text call and text to confirm those appointments but and again if you can if you can take a look and package those with your state you know package one of those with your state inspections then you can start eliminating a lot of your state inspection only tickets so i i go back like my first my first year in business at the end of the first year we were doing about 100 120 cars a week and there's a lot of folks that sounds pretty good

[Mike Allen] (34:36 - 34:42)
right it can't be great if all the other systems work and you've got the capacity but it can be

[Matt Lofton] (34:42 - 37:35)
right yeah and i remember going to eagles for the very first time and i was talking to you're gonna remember borst automotive oh yeah it used to be a part of pro service their general manager was there and he was the younger guy and and we spent some time at dinner together and we're asking all the shop questions you know uh you know subtle pp measurements by numbers measurements right and he's like what's your car count what do you do and he's like so when i told him 120 cars a week he says he's like my gosh you know uh he's like you guys got a big operation and i'm like yeah thank you you know and then he then he asked what your aro is and i was like oh and it was like 175 and and he's like he's like damn are y'all a lube shop and you know at the at the answer was yes yes we were a shop but my coach used to ask me that question all the time like at the end of every meeting he would ask me hey matt what business are you in and it really got annoying and repetitive over time but we finally got you know the point that he was finally making was over 60 percent of your business is coming from an oil change only or a state inspection only you're and you're you're a lube and inspection shop that's all you're not doing any repair work you're not doing any maintenance work and so if that's not the business that you want to be in then you got to start structuring the schedule to make it that way and so you know we we went on the journey and you know matt doesn't have a dimmer switch so we went from 115 cars down to 30 cars a week um and you go from 175 to 500 really quickly too we went from 175 when we were down to 30 cars a week we were over 800 for aro you got to be to maintain revenue right yeah and that's and look that that was better than 120 cars a week at 175 yeah um the issue with that is there you know there's a there's a fine line with all of it and there's a balancing act when it comes to car count aro the problem is when you get so low on on car count if you have seasonal trends that happen that cause a 10 15 20 dip in car count or cause a dip in conversion percentage for aro you are screwed you just don't have enough volume to make up for it right you don't have enough swings at the back and so you know it and it limits your ability to grow because i'm not adding people to the you know to the funnel for six months from now 18 months from now 24 months from now i'm not adding that new customer to it um and so if you have any attrition issues at all then you know you really start to see it uh in in that in that low car count model um so again i think the only change that we made from that 30 cars a week to trying to get back to 70 80 90 cars a week has been pre-booking that's it so you just committed to it

[Mike Allen] (37:35 - 38:17)
yep so the conversation at checkout among other conversations right we're gonna you know review what they've taken care of on that visit and the warranty and kind of resell the value right we're going to talk about anything that may have deferred for future services um we're gonna you know ask them for a review and we're gonna tell them you know and by the way miss jones you know i've gone ahead and i've set up reminders for your next oil change appointment uh i'll text you and i'll call you a few months out when you're due and just solidify that it's just like in passing you're just letting them know or are you telling them the day and the time in that conversation so we're

[Matt Lofton] (38:17 - 39:18)
going to give them the day and the time on that conversation i'm also going to write it on the back of the invoice holder and then we also staple one of our business cards on there with the appointment reminder on the business card as well just so they can't say i didn't know that you guys pre-scheduled this appointment for me and spoiler alert they're still going to say i didn't know that you pre-scheduled this appointment for me so it just it just kind of is what it is but i'm trying to give them as much you know fair warning as possible about what's getting ready to happen but we're going to go into the conversation of hey listen i know you have no idea what you're six months from now i don't either i have no idea but i'm going to pick up the phone and call you a week beforehand i'm going to verify what day and time works best for you and we can move it to whatever day and time works best for you that we have availability for and uh i'm if i don't get you on the phone i'm going to text you if i don't get a text response from you i'm going to call and text you three days in a row until you tell me to you know jump in a lake or you give me a confirmed

[Mike Allen] (39:18 - 39:53)
time yeah it's that easy and once you move through the database two or three times you've trained them to expect it just like the dentist trained us to expect it that's right you know um my we have a piano in the living room my kids just take piano lessons i got a text message reminder that i'm due for my annual piano tune-up today that's uh if the fucking piano tune-up guy can set up pre-booked uh maintenance appointments i'm pretty sure that we can do that for automotive repair

[Matt Lofton] (39:53 - 40:41)
100 it's doable um and you know you're going to have a segment of the customer base that really enjoys it right um some of them are not but that's okay too but that would that would be something that i would really work on there i think that would be twofold um a i think you'll have a higher um and then i think you'll get a shrinkage of no opportunity car count right um because you'll get rid of some of that some of those state inspection only tickets which will allow you because it's not that they're a bad car they're a bad customer it's just a it's a it's a bad appointment right it's at the same time do i want to turn away

[Mike Allen] (40:41 - 40:49)
somebody because do i want like do i want to put guideposts that we're only going to do three inspections a day or something up because then if they go somewhere else then i have the

[Matt Lofton] (40:49 - 41:14)
opportunity of losing that customer so this is what i would do um so we did this again there's so much emotion that gets brought into this of if i make this change i might lose this customer right but you have the data already in your database of whether a state inspection keeps a customer or not all right look at your retention rate off a first time customers coming back for a

[Mike Allen] (41:14 - 41:21)
second visit off of a state inspection yeah it's probably single digit it's purely it's purely a

[Matt Lofton] (41:21 - 43:42)
commodity item and so they're calling you a lot of times because they've already called three or four other places right and you were they come they came to you because you were the one that said yes now will you win a few of those customers yes the problem is though it's like the to-go order at a nice restaurant right so like the angus barn we're familiar with angus barn here in raleigh angus barn is a really nice steakhouse it's been around for 10 000 years it's a good steakhouse let me put it this way it's not a cheap steakhouse how about that it's a really expensive steakhouse yeah that's you're buying the atmosphere you're buying the atmosphere so a to-go order at the angus barn is a complete waste yes absolutely for them and from a customer experience standpoint for them and for you the end user it's not the same yeah right you are not going to be thoroughly impressed with your 300 dinner that you get in a styrofoam thing in a plastic bag yeah when you get home and eat it right yeah so this is the to-go order for your you're fine automotive repair experience that you have yeah like they're getting not they're getting no experience from you right because your team is trying to this is a low opportunity all they want is the inspection get it in get it out right so they're not doing good intake conversations your technician's annoyed by the fact that he has to go do it i've never met it i've never met a technician that was like yes another inspection i get to stop this timing job to go do a quick state inspection waiter it's just i mean nobody's excited about doing it your service advisor is not excited about it coming in because he knows he's limited to what he can get out of it your technician is is upset because again he knows it's more than likely going to be a waiter and it's going to be an inspection only situation and you know what it's even worse when it fails yeah when it turns into opportunity i mean i hate it it's like the worst thing in the world when you have to walk out there and tell somebody that their state inspection failed because it feels like you trapped them to them like in their mind this was just some money grab situation and why it's different when they bring it in for an oil change and you show them versus a state inspection and you show them i don't know but i can just tell you psychologically it is different and the reaction that you get from them is completely different i do recall when i was

[Mike Allen] (43:42 - 44:10)
writing service and i would have somebody fail an inspection you know i always be like look you got 90 days to get it re-inspected it won't cost anything extra you have to get this fixed you i do not have to do it and they would say well i guess i don't have a choice and i say oh no no no i want to be totally clear you absolutely have a choice i do not have to do this for you so i'm almost trying not to sell it to avoid that you know but yeah yeah and so you know so that that's where i

[Matt Lofton] (44:10 - 45:09)
take a look at that and say you know if we can it it's not that i'm trying to limit your car count i just don't want to limit no opportunity i just want to limit no opportunities yeah right and so if you if you go back and you do the math and you find out that you have really low retention rate from first-time customers coming in on a state inspection if i can't retain them as a customer and i if it can't be a profit today and it can't lead to a profit tomorrow why the hell am i doing it yeah like i don't mind doing it if it's going to lead to a profit tomorrow and if we can mathematically prove that oh we had 16 customers come in last month for a state or six months ago for a state inspection only ticket and they've they've booked again already this year for other services great let's do it you know but if if that's if the numbers are really low if it's single digit retention like you know like you said i think you're wasting a lot of time and i think we need to replace that car count with better car

[Mike Allen] (45:09 - 45:23)
count well i mean if i take the state inspection only tickets out of the mix that puts us up to three hours per repair order on the ones that are not state inspection only which is a far happier

[Matt Lofton] (45:23 - 45:45)
place to operate for sure and so i know you're not doing a lot of marketing at that location because you have a lot of baked in car count but maybe we need to maybe we need to improve the quality of some of the car count so it it might be worth taking a look at if we if we lost 40 cars how would we replace those 40 cars with a marketing campaign that gave you higher opportunity

[Mike Allen] (45:46 - 45:57)
so you're saying the next time i sit down and record with carrie lynn i need to have that conversation i would yeah i can do it how was uh how was the eagles class in rhode island

[Matt Lofton] (45:58 - 49:11)
so uh we had our fly with the eagles three-day management shop owner class in providence rhode island which is right in between uh boston and new york city so it was filled with a bunch of italians and honestly it was probably the greatest three days that i've had in the automotive industry it was the most i've laughed in a really long time so joe marconi was in his in his wheelhouse it was he was in his wheelhouse and he knew a lot of the people there so that made our dinners out really special uh providence has a uh a little italy district which has italian restaurants going down a whole square block and these were we don't know anything about real italian down here like olive garden is good italian to us right hey if you're here your family and so but uh it was it was nice to go into what they would consider really authentic italian restaurants and the food was phenomenal uh we would sit down and these guys would order everything off the left side of the menu to start off with and so you know there was like you know 50 appetizers flowing around the table before we even got going so it was it was a great time the class itself was phenomenal um we had a lot of good engagement uh joe spent a lot of time working on uh his presentation for day three and we made a lot of improvements to uh to that that material and content so a lot more a lot more time being spent on operational workflow how to build processes and procedures how to implement those processes and procedures uh so again we're trying to make sure that we're improving the value uh for the take-home value for for what the attendees are showing up and getting when is your next one our next one is coming up in march and clindale california and that is i know it's a i know it's a trip for a lot of us because it's all the way on the left coast so if you're if you're not already out there it can be a bit of a travel that's such a phenomenal group of shop owners um that kind of come we've been doing that one now consistently for the last three years and a lot of those guys keep coming back um and if if you're able to make it to be in a room where multiple people uh when we do our pnl reviews our our netting seven figures or more um there's not many rooms that you're going to sit in with automotive repair shops we're going to have that many you know really strong operators uh in a room at one time it's and it's a great they have a big association there and um i'm jealous of those big cities where all the guys are they have so much cars that they're all friends with each other and so it's it's really cool to go in the room and those guys you know the husbands wives are their heights it's kind of like going to a pro service event it's really what it's like but really strong operators uh if if you're if you're looking to grow and get better um that not only is the content great that we put on uh but you know similar to what we've talked about with the peer groups and pro service stuff you know the ability to you know network with those those individuals after hours um i mean it's it you get up you get three extra days of classes just by going to dinner every night it's phenomenal for sure that's one that i actually

[Mike Allen] (49:11 - 50:16)
might um want to make it out to there's a busy schedule next year right but we've got um tectonic uh is in april but before that we have ignite coming up and that's in february i think that's four through six yeah right back in vegas baby right back in vegas um but not in the heart of the strip i think that was a really good call to put it down uh it's at bm i think is is that the name of the resort yeah um it's where the raiders have their practice facility uh and so it's it's 15 minutes south of the strip and kind of a standalone resort and a lot of good golf and that kind of stuff in the area too if that's your gig but um and you don't have to be an elite member to go to ignite so it's a great way to go out and kind of try out elite and meet uh a bunch of the a bunch of the folks there i mean obviously matt will be there i'll be there um i'll be recording so if you ever want to hop on and record with um the biggest blowhard windbag in the industry yeah should be a message um so if they go to elite worldwide.com

[Matt Lofton] (50:16 - 52:00)
forward slash ignite i think it is uh or they can go to our events page okay um so uh elite worldwide.com forward slash ignite will get you there uh if you forget that go to the website go to events it'll show you all the events that we have coming up ignite is our next event that we have um we would love to see you guys there again it's a uh it is not a it's if you've been to all the other training events like vision and asta and sema and apex and all that those are all phenomenal but they're 100 focused on automotive um this one is we try to make it a little bit different so it just doesn't feel like the same thing that you get everywhere else there will be some automotive specific aspects to it obviously but we try to just bring in some you know some some leadership and uh and just general business uh speakers as well and just like the the name you know says ignite you know our goal with ignite every single year is just try to get everybody re-energized it's hard coming out of that holiday season we know that's a you know that's a slow time for the industry as a whole it's a stressful time from a family you know family standpoint um usually we're still in that you know the the winter doldrums of seasonal depression disorder you know and so uh our goal with ignite is just to you know kind of get out of that funk you know that we have from the holiday season uh get prepared and and get our minds you know kicked off and ready to go for that you know that second half of q1 and and getting into q2 where everything starts to bust wide open at the seams and make sure we're we're re-centered with a good good mind and a good energy getting into the busy part of the year so what are the odds that we can

[Mike Allen] (52:00 - 52:12)
get like uh like a track day put together and go out there and uh do something silly there's been talks i mean i support i support these talks just let me know how you guys have a great time i'm

[Matt Lofton] (52:12 - 52:21)
gonna go play golf i hold up that gold trophy baby i still got my bronze back there in the background

[Mike Allen] (52:24 - 52:56)
all right dude well it's been fun um i hate that i won't see you next week at uh apex but i totally understand your reason and i think that as much as i hate to say it might be a valid reason being a good father more important than uh going to see uh giant lifted million dollar project cars um yeah with bluetooth drive shafts and uh if you go next week check it all the monster trucks and all the custom they were all pushed in and they're all gonna be pushed up because the large majority of them don't even have drive shafts connected it's yeah yeah but

[Matt Lofton] (52:56 - 53:19)
they're pretty my advice is take a pair of sunglasses be the weird guy that wears them inside there's so much eye candy and everything is so sparkly you're gonna wind up with a headache just walking around looking at everything um but it's a fun time we do it's it's something fun to check off the bucket list i i can't say that i didn't enjoy going but it's uh also also not

[Mike Allen] (53:19 - 54:17)
envious that i'm not going to be there so uh hit me up uh on facebook uh dms or you can text 704 confess if you're a shop owner and you're going to be at apex and sema and you'd like to sit down and have a chat uh i'd love to meet you thanks i'll see you dude all right man thanks for listening to confessions of a shop owner where we lay it all out the good the bad and sometimes the super messed up i'm your host mike allen here to remind you that even the pros screw it up sometimes so why not laugh a little bit learn a little bit maybe have another drink you got a confession of your own or a topic you'd like me to cover or do you just want to let me know what an idiot i am email mike at confessions of a shop owner.com or call and leave a message the number 704 confess that's 704-266-3377 if you enjoyed this episode be sure to like subscribe or follow join us on this crazy journey that is shop ownership i'll see you on the next episode