The Clinical Excellence Podcast

Dr. Michelle Kittleson and Dr. Adam Cifu get real about the patient-doctor relationship, especially when the stakes are high and the answers are not simple. She shares a small move that can ease a patient’s anxiety in seconds: showing you came prepared, with their story already in your hands. They talk through shared decision making, why patients should steer, and why clinicians still need to give a clear recommendation. They also spend time on the toughest pivot of all: when cure is off the table, what do you say next, and what can you still do to reduce suffering?

What is The Clinical Excellence Podcast?

The Clinical Excellent Podcast, sponsored by the Bucksbaum Institute for Clinical Excellence is a biweekly podcast hosted by Drs. Adam Cifu and Matthew Sorrentino. The podcast has three formats: discussions between doctors and patients, discussions with authors of research pertinent to improving clinical care and the doctor-patient relationship and discussions with physicians about challenges in the doctor-patient relationship or in the life of a physician.

[00:00:00] Dr. Cifu: On today's episode of The Clinical Excellence Podcast, I am joined by Michelle Kittleson, talking about the evolving doctor-patient relationship.

[00:00:13] Dr. Kittleson: My triggers for irritation are more about me than about the patient. And I think every doctor probably has different personal triggers that just irritate them, and I know what mine are, and I've done my best to try to combat that.

So one of my personal triggers is when patients are super anxious, and it's not... I get it. I understand why. If I was in their situation, maybe I'd feel that way too.

[00:00:45] Dr. Cifu: Welcome to The Clinical Excellence Podcast, sponsored by the Bucksbaum-Siegler Institute for Clinical Excellence. On this podcast, we speak to patients and doctors about all aspects of excellence in clinical medicine. I'm Adam Cifu, and I'm joined today by Dr. Michelle Kittleson. Dr. Kittleson is a professor of medicine at Cedar-Sinai, medical director of heart transplantation, co-director of the Cardiac Amyloidosis Program, and director of Education in Heart Failure and Transplantation at Smidt Heart Institute.

Dr. Kittleson has authored over 300 publications and has chaired multiple expert consensus documents for the ACC/AHA and ISHLT on topics ranging from cardiac amyloidosis, dual organ transplantation, cardiac sarcoidosis, pregnancy after heart transplantation, heart failure with preserved ejection fraction, and obesity and heart failure.

She received the American College of Cardiology Distinguished Teacher of the Year Award in 2025. Dr. Kittleson's essays and poems have appeared in The New England Journal of Medicine, JAMA, JAMA Cardiology, and Annals of Internal Medicine, and her book, Mastering the Art of Patient Care, is excellent. I'd say it's a classic, but it hasn't been around that long, so hopefully, will be a classic, and totally worth your time. Michelle, thank you so much for joining me today. It's really a pleasure to see you at least electronically, like this.

[00:02:15] Dr. Kittleson: Thank you. I'm delighted to be here.

[00:02:18] Dr. Cifu: The breadth of the things you've been involved in, you know, in cardiology is really something. I'll ask before we kind of get into the real topic. Was that sort of something you, like, set out to do or is that just like, I like this field, I like a lot of things, and once I'm sort of in with the crowd on a national level, you get into doing all these things?

[00:02:41] Dr. Kittleson: More of the latter. I consider myself sort of an accidental academician in the sense that I love, love, love taking care of patients. I've never written a grant in my life, but my superpower turns out to be writing clearly and quickly, anti-procrastinating, and never missing a deadline. It seems like those skills make you highly prized, and I think because I'm so clinical, I kind of understand what clinicians need from these documents. So that's been a real joy and fun to be involved in.

[00:03:16] Dr. Cifu: Maybe at the end, I'll ask you what medications you're on to achieve the procrastination suppression and productivity.

[00:03:24] Dr. Kittleson: I'm convinced it's actually genetic, so I'm not sure I can help you, but gene editing, who knows? We may get there.

[00:03:30] Dr. Cifu: So we're going all in on the doctor-patient relationship this season, and, you know, reading a lot of your work, you're definitely someone I wanted to talk to this season. So my first question is, you know, you've been doing this for quite some years, and I wondered kind of how your relationship with patients has changed over the years. And I'm interested in kind of the evolution of how you relate to patients, both new patients who you're seeing for the first time, or maybe people you've seen, you know, for a few years.

[00:04:02] Dr. Kittleson: Absolutely. You know, in a way, some of the evolution comes from the years and having the gray hair and a bit more gravitas.

You know, I found it's hard, when you're a young new attending, to establish that respect. And cardiology is so cool, especially heart failure transplant, that you essentially have to establish that connection and trust quickly because within five minutes, you may be telling someone, "We need to evaluate you urgently for a transplant, and you're not leaving the hospital until you get one."

So how do you do that? So early on, I found that preparation, tons of preparation in advance, so I knew everything about the patient before I walked in the room, was key to establishing trust, and that has sustained me now over the years. I still prepare assiduously for every patient before I see them. Having the gray hair, having the titles does, I think, make that process a little easier, but those building blocks are in place. When I think about my relationship with patients, I think there's some ways I'm nicer. There's some ways I'm not as nice. And I'm much more comfortable with uncertainty. So I'll give you an example.

How am I nicer? You know, medicine, the facts are no longer so overwhelming, so now I feel I can see the bigger picture more easily. So I think of things like, how can I make your trips to the medical center easier? Can I coordinate this appointment with the other three specialists I know you need to see in the same timeframe? Can we shift to telehealth? You don't have to pay the exorbitant parking fees when you're in the hospital. Do you want to get food from home from your family? As long as it's low salt, 'cause you're waiting for a transplant in cardiogenic shock. So kind of like those things I never really thought about before, but now I try to think more about what's the logistics of the experience 'cause my mind isn't so overwhelmed with medical facts.

In a way, I'm also not as nice in that I'm very comfortable saying no when I don't think something is the right thing to do. For example, just the other day, a patient reached out to me via the portal and said, "Three of my friends just had bypass surgery, so you need to do a stress test on me."

And I said, "Hold up there. There is no utility of a stress test of asymptomatic patients. They do not predict the future, nor do they prevent heart disease. Let's set up the visit so I can explain this to you in more detail." And you know what? I am going to stand firm and you throw a rock in Los Angeles, you'll hit a cardiologist, and they will order lots of tests for you but I got to vote my conscience, and so I've gotten much more comfortable explaining my stance and going from there. On the other hand, I also feel much more comfortable with uncertainty. I feel very comfortable saying, "I don't know the right answer. Science doesn't tell us the right answer. The right answer is what works. So let's figure out what works for you." So being less prescriptive. So a patient says to me, "I don't want to take a statin." I say what I say to my middle child, who's 10, I say, "You don't have to take the statin, but if you don't, there can be consequences, and you can play the odds, but I'm not sure they'll be in your favor." So not pushing things. And I'll say, "Yes, you can live to the age of a hundred, never having a heart attack, and you didn't take the statin. Kittleson was wrong, but the odds are I'm not going to be wrong." So I think in those ways, my practice has changed, I think, for the better.

[00:07:26] Dr. Cifu: I love your comment. I struggle a lot, being maybe less gray than you, but a whole lot more bald than you, with knowing what that brings actually in my relationship with patients, and I struggle often when I'm with trainees, like, God, I have such an advantage just 'cause I walk in and they're like, "Oh, here's the old guy in the white coat, you know, we're going to believe everything he says." I love you really doubling down on the preparation as a way of sort of overcoming that early on 'cause I do think part of what you get, you know, with age is the confidence and the ability to say like, "You know, this is truth or as best as we know truth, but you're right, you can get some of that with real preparation, knowing the patient, knowing about the disease process well.

[00:08:19] Dr. Kittleson: Yeah, I have many rules in life. I'm trying to patent them. Just kidding, I'm not, but give me attribution if you use any of them. One of them is, preparation is the antidote to nerves, right? And I feel that's so true. When I was younger, I was like, oh, I want to go into medicine because I don't want to be a salesperson. I just want to have... That sounds so stressful. You know what, we're all salespeople, we're all... You all have to do... You're making a first impression that matters so much. And I think to walk in that room, and the first thing I typically say is, "Welcome to the cardiology clinic." And the next thing I say is, "I've reviewed your records in advance, let me pull up my notes," and then I pull up my prep chart. And it's astonishing to me that literally a hundred percent of the time, you see relief on the patient's face because when they're coming to see me, they've been funneled usually to at least one cardiologist before me. And that, no matter how gray or how much Botox we get in Los Angeles, I don't get any, but regardless of that, you can still establish trust.

[00:09:21] Dr. Cifu: Do you think... This topic has actually come up on a few of the episodes, about how, you know, we change, the longer we do this, and a lot of people have said that what they sort of pictured as professionalism early in their career almost gets dropped as they get further along because they're able to be, I don't know, a little bit harsher, a little bit more definitive, and they're like, "I never would've dreamed about that 'cause I wouldn't have considered that professional behavior," but as you yourself become sort of more professional, you know what professionalism is almost becomes broader. Is that sort of true to you?

[00:10:05] Dr. Kittleson: I do think it is. I think you become, as you said, more comfortable in your role. And I consider my role as the medical expert. I say a lot to patients, "I'm the consultant, you are the boss of your body, but I will give you my medical expertise," and I'm a huge fan of shared decision-making, but that's not abdication of medical, you know, responsibility and opinion. I have a medical opinion, and I do think what surprised me... So I think professionalism to me is treating the patient with respect and giving them the optimal care you can provide, but what you realize the more you're in medicine is to read the room and how that changes for different people. So sometimes I have a big, burly, gruff old man who just fits that stereotype of he's big and tough, and he doesn't complain. And I'll say to him, "Listen, dude, I can tell that you're hiding stuff from me, so tell me how you're really feeling." I probably wouldn't have said that 20 years ago, but I would never say that to the patient who's much more worried or tearful, you know, or upset. So I think you learn how to push patients, meet them where they are in a savvy way.

[00:11:17] Dr. Cifu: So one of the great things about medicine is that, you know, it keeps you humble, right? You never really master it. Whenever you're like, "I got this," something terrible happens. Just thinking about the doctor-patient relationship, are there things that, you know, almost predictably challenge you? Like, "Ah, this is something I struggle with," or "Oh, there it goes again. You know, this is hard for me."

[00:11:41] Dr. Kittleson: Yes. That's such a great question because what I've come to realize over the years is my triggers for irritation are more about me than about the patient. And I think every doctor probably has different personal triggers that just irritate them, and I know what mine are, and I've done my best to try to combat that. So one of my personal triggers is when patients are super anxious, and it's not... I get it. I understand why. If I was in their situation, maybe I'd feel that way, too, but I kind of joke with my trainees that I, in some ways, have an anti-anxiety disorder. It takes a lot to make me get all head up. And so how do I deal with that? Because I don't want them to feel anxious, but again, their anxiety is a bit out of my control. So this is what I try to do. I try not to get into discussions about the details of anxiety. Listen, I'm a cardiologist, right? So what I'll say is if they start, "Well, I'm so scared about this diagnosis," but I'm really not equipped to talk about how to manage fear, am I? I'm the wrong person. So I've got a system that helps me help them, which is number one. "Of course, you are scared. If you were not scared, that would be weird. It would mean you don't understand what's going on here. Number two, my job here is to put together a plan. We don't worry. We make a plan. This is our plan. These are the medical facts. This is what you should be focusing your energy on. This is what we do need to be concerned about, but this is our plan to address it." And I found for me, that's very helpful to organize the anxiety in a productive way. And I think that's been useful over the years as well.

[00:13:30] Dr. Cifu: It's so good to have that, you know, called so many things, right? Insight or mindful practice, but to be sort of, you know, the third person in the room and to be able to say, ha, you know, this is a situation which gets me. And, you know, let me step back. Let me think about how I've thought about how to respond to this. And it's funny because it is so different for all of us, right? What gets us, the kind of people who get us.

[00:13:59] Dr. Kittleson: Yes. Whereas it's funny, I have some doctors who say to me, "Oh my gosh, they bring in the spreadsheets of their vital signs. I can't take it." I'm like, "Oh, I'm so excited when the accountant or the engineer is my patient, 'cause I feel like we can talk the same language here. Let's come up with a plan."

And the other thing that, you know, the rooms I feel like as a team sometimes we don't want to go into on rounds, are the rooms where we no longer have a plan because there's nothing else we can do. And I think it's so important in those rooms to address the elephant in the room, to say, "I am so sorry that there is nothing else we can offer you that's going to prolong your life or be curative. We still have a plan. We have to shift our focus to what we can control, which is your pain and suffering." And I think that often leads to a huge sense of... A deep sigh of relief from everyone in the room 'cause what was making us feel so horrible is that we felt we weren't being honest.

[00:14:51] Dr. Cifu: Right. You got to watch out. You're revealing a lot about yourself. You're like, "Oh, I like these numbers people, and I hate these feely people." You know...

[00:14:58] Dr. Kittleson: Oh no. And what is it? INFJ, whatever. I'm one of... Whatever I am exactly.

[00:15:04] Dr. Cifu: At this point in your career, what are things that you sort of appreciate most about your role in the doctor-patient relationship? And that could either be, you know, things you're actually sort of proud of, like, "I do this well," or things that just kind of like bring you joy, that you're like, you know, "These are the things I love and this is what keeps me kind of getting up in the morning and going to work."

[00:15:25] Dr. Kittleson: Well, I'm going to cite you, I think, who wrote a beautiful essay about the Sunshine folder. Yes? And I love... I tell trainees about that. I think it's so important to keep a well of your victories close because you should cherish them, because you know, everyone remembers the bad stuff, but you should really appreciate the good things you do.

So I'd say one thing that I am so... And I think experience is so important and the only way out is through, well, reading my book may help. You can learn from my mistakes and not just yours, but really, you just got to do it to get good at it. And one thing I think is the hallmark of experience, it's been so wonderful for me is experience allows you to predict the future.

[00:16:12] Dr. Cifu: Mm-hmm.

[00:16:12] Dr. Kittleson: Meaning, I've admitted a patient to the hospital with decompensated heart failure. I can predict the future pretty well about whether it's going to be a set it and forget it: diuretic, GDT, get outta here admission, or, oh no, something horrible's going to happen in the next seven days. And that is so comforting, because I can make a plan and I can teach my trainees how to make a plan. So to me, that has been one of the most rewarding things professionally or intellectually. And what's been so rewarding from an emotional standpoint is the way clinics kind of turn into social hours. You know, my dad was a private practice internist, cardiologist for 40 plus years. And he said to me, "The first five years are going to be tough." He was right. "And after that, everyone's going to know you, and it's going to be really fun." And he was right. And I have to sometimes guard myself. I don't want to fall into the inertia of socialization and not actually pay attention to medical things that are changing, but it is so delightful to have that long-term, fun relationship. How are your kids? How are my kids? And as we grow old together.

[00:17:20] Dr. Cifu: I'm not sure we do a good enough job at preparing our young doctors for how difficult the first five years out of training are. You know, we give a lot of credit to, you know, residency is kind of hell, both from a physical and a mental side. Fellowship is, you know, sometimes overwhelming, you know, amounts of material to master, but you talk to anybody, and it's those first years that you're like, no matter how well prepared you are, you're sort of not prepared enough. And every patient's a new patient. Many patients doubt your qualifications. You know, that's a big hill to get over.

[00:18:01] Dr. Kittleson: It is, and if there's anything I could convey to young doctors, the only way out is through. And I see, I think, or at least, in my small sample, there's a lot of turnover, especially of internist primary care in those first few years, and I just want to tell 'em, "Unless there's something awful about your job, you know, you're being abused in some way, if you just stick it out, the rewards will come, because it's that time you put in that creates those beautiful relationships."

[00:18:35] Dr. Cifu: Michelle, I want to thank you so much for taking the time to talk to me today. This was great. I think we share a lot of insights, but you... Whenever I sort of read your stuff, I recognize that, like, "Oh, I've thought about that, but she sort of brings me a little bit further on these thoughts." So it's really wonderful to talk to you and ask you these questions.

[00:18:54] Dr. Kittleson: Well, I'm totally delighted. Thank you for having me.

[00:18:57] Dr. Cifu: Thanks for joining us for this episode of The Clinical Excellence Podcast. We are sponsored by the Bucksbaum-Siegler Institute for Clinical Excellence at the University of Chicago. Please feel free to reach out to us with your thoughts and ideas via the Institute webpage: bucksbauminstitute.uchicago.edu. The music for The Clinical Excellence Podcast is courtesy of Dr. Maylyn Martinez.