National Health Executive Podcast

In episode 41 of the National Health Executive podcast, we were joined by Dr Angela Smith, research fellow at Bournemouth University, and Andy Oakey, research fellow at the University of Southampton, to discuss the viability of drones within the NHS transport system.

Angela and Andy talked about some of the misinformation about drones and suggested that drone travel is not quite ready for the NHS yet.

Angela said: “The eDrone project has been focused on NHS case studies, but what we have found is that the reporting around these case studies – the trials in particular – has led to some misconceptions about what the trials are achieving and the future benefits of drones.”

Andy explained: “If you actually look back at our project bids, we were sucked into this rhetoric of drones being the next big thing. The original idea was to look at where’s best to use them [drones], with a positive spin, but as we have gone into it we have learnt more and understood how there is a lot more than meets the eye.”

What is National Health Executive Podcast?

The National Health Executive Podcast is the perfect place to garner insights from across all aspects of healthcare, as we get into the crucial ‘whys’ behind the stories and how they can impact all of us to improve our work, our lives and the care and services we provide as an industry.

Tune in, discover more about our diverse and talented health sector and it may well spark the solution to help you see a problem or challenge in a new light.

Yeah, ​I ​suppose ​the ​reason ​why ​we've ​come ​to ​the ​national ​health ​executive ​to ​speak ​to ​you ​is ​partly ​to ​overcome ​this ​issue ​of ​misinformation, ​and ​also ​to ​draw, ​• ​• ​um. ​• ​• ​• ​Um, ​NHS ​executives ​attention ​to ​the ​fact ​we've ​got ​this ​big ​evidence ​base ​that's ​been ​generated ​over ​three ​years. ​So, ​one, ​we'd ​like ​people ​to ​be ​aware ​that, ​• ​• ​• ​• ​• ​to ​be ​alert ​to ​misinformation, ​and ​two, ​we'd ​like ​you ​to ​kind ​of ​delve ​into ​the ​evidence ​base, ​contact ​us, ​ask ​us ​questions, ​• ​• ​um, ​feedback, ​if ​there's ​anything ​you ​don't ​agree ​with. ​We ​would ​love ​that ​interaction. ​It's ​often ​quite ​hard ​for ​non ​health ​researchers ​to ​interact ​with ​people ​in ​health. ​Um, ​and ​we ​know ​that ​from ​the ​difficulties ​sometimes ​getting ​people ​to, ​um, ​take ​part ​in ​our ​study, ​we ​have ​got ​sort ​of ​a ​few ​main ​points ​about ​kind ​of ​things ​to ​think ​about ​when ​you're ​reading ​or ​thinking ​about ​drone ​deliveries ​and ​the ​reporting ​around ​it, ​and ​some ​of ​those ​questions ​that ​you ​need ​to ​ask, ​things ​like, ​• ​​is ​there ​really ​a ​need ​for ​speed? ​Um, ​so ​we ​recognize ​that ​drones ​can ​deliver, ​um, ​quicker ​than ​some ​modes. ​How ​much ​difference ​that ​faster ​delivery ​will ​make ​to ​any ​services ​needs ​to ​be ​considered. ​And ​the ​second ​point, ​which ​is ​my ​favorite, ​is ​really ​about ​consolidation. ​Consolidation ​is ​likely ​to ​be ​cheaper ​and ​greener ​than ​using ​a ​drone. ​Um, ​and ​there's ​an ​awful ​lot ​of ​transport ​being ​used ​by ​the ​NHS, ​which ​is ​on ​the ​network ​right ​now. ​I ​think ​we ​need ​to ​understand ​• ​• ​what ​that ​transport ​is, ​what ​it's ​doing, ​and ​have ​perhaps ​a ​better ​general ​understanding ​so ​we ​can ​all ​tap ​into ​it ​potentially ​then, ​is ​the ​drone ​actually ​up ​to ​the ​know? ​Andy's ​outlined ​some ​of ​the ​weather ​limitations, ​but ​there's ​also ​capacity, ​there's ​also ​things ​about ​where ​they ​can ​land. ​Um, ​so ​you ​need ​to ​think ​about ​those ​things. ​I've ​mentioned ​time ​savings, ​but ​if ​you ​look ​at ​the ​whole ​practice. ​So ​if ​you ​look ​at, ​um, ​• ​• ​• ​• ​not ​just ​the ​final ​journey ​leg, ​there ​are ​often ​time ​savings ​that ​can ​be ​found ​elsewhere ​within ​a ​system, ​not ​just ​in ​terms ​of ​transport. ​• ​Um, ​and ​finally, ​think ​about ​that ​cost. ​Um, ​you ​need ​to ​take ​a ​holistic ​assessment ​of ​the ​whole ​service ​cost ​and ​think ​about ​whether ​the ​cost ​is ​worth ​it. ​And ​it ​might ​well ​be, ​but ​it ​needs ​careful ​consideration. ​So ​those ​are ​kind ​of ​my ​main ​points, ​really. ​Do ​delve ​into ​our ​evidence, ​do ​contact ​us, ​um, ​and ​do ​read ​the ​article.

Speaker A
Yeah, ​I ​kind ​of ​second ​all ​of, ​um, ​what ​Angela ​says ​there. ​• ​Um, ​but, ​yeah, ​I'd ​just ​kind ​of ​like ​to ​add ​that, ​um, ​not ​everything ​coming ​out ​the ​drone ​industry ​is ​that ​honest. ​Um, ​and ​just ​be ​very ​aware ​of, ​uh, ​that, ​um, ​• ​• ​• ​• ​there ​are ​some ​fantastic ​innovations ​out ​there ​and ​no ​doubt ​some ​of ​them ​have ​a ​place ​in ​certain ​situations. ​You've ​got ​to ​really ​dig ​into ​it, ​um, ​to ​make ​sure ​you're ​really ​understanding ​where ​that ​situation ​is.
Yeah, ​and ​we've ​had ​key ​takeaways ​there. ​Uh, ​and ​this, ​um, ​isn't ​a ​question ​directed ​to ​anybody ​in ​particular. ​But ​​now ​we're ​coming ​towards ​the ​end ​of ​the ​podcast. ​What ​would ​you ​advise ​based ​on ​the ​back ​of ​this, ​that, ​uh, ​health ​leaders ​do ​with ​this? ​What ​should ​they ​do? ​What ​action ​should ​they ​take? ​What ​next?
Essentially, ​I ​think ​what ​I'd ​really ​like.
To ​see ​is ​honest ​reporting ​from ​trials, ​so ​that ​we ​know ​exactly ​what ​they ​found ​out. ​Now, ​I ​do ​believe ​that ​trials ​are ​really ​important ​to ​understand ​how ​technology ​works ​and ​where ​it ​has ​a ​role ​in ​society. ​But ​at ​the ​moment, ​I ​don't ​think ​we're ​seeing ​quite ​enough ​in ​terms ​of ​transparency ​and ​what's ​been ​found ​out ​by ​doing ​these ​trials. ​I ​think ​that's ​what ​we'd ​like ​to ​know, ​that ​it's ​often ​public ​money ​that's ​funded ​them. ​So ​that ​would ​be ​my ​takeaway.
Yeah. ​And ​I ​think, ​um, ​just ​to ​build ​on ​that, ​if ​you ​have ​better ​reporting, ​it's ​a ​lot ​easier ​to ​actually ​learn ​from ​what ​was ​actually ​understood ​rather ​than ​what ​people ​think ​was ​understood. ​So ​if ​I ​say ​I ​moved ​ten ​tons ​of ​cargo ​and ​it ​made ​the ​NHS, ​um, ​50,000 ​pounds ​saving ​or ​whatever, ​• ​• ​um, ​and ​that's ​completely ​false, ​that's ​not ​going ​to ​help ​anyone ​because ​everyone ​will ​think, ​right, ​yeah, ​let's ​go ​straight ​for ​that ​cargo ​when ​it ​might ​be ​that ​there's ​another ​cargo ​that ​is ​superbly ​• ​• ​suited, ​uh, ​• ​• ​for ​whatever ​use ​case ​it ​is. ​so, ​yeah, ​I ​think ​honest ​reporting ​is ​really ​key.
So ​transparency ​is ​the ​word ​of ​the ​day?
Transparency, ​definitely.
And ​that's ​been ​national ​health ​executive ​podcast. ​Thank ​you ​for ​listening ​and ​we'll ​catch ​you ​next ​time.
You've ​been ​listening ​to ​the ​National ​Health ​Executive ​podcast, ​don't ​forget ​to ​like ​and ​subscribe ​to ​make ​sure ​you ​receive ​every ​new ​edition.