The Monégasque Table

The FDA's take-it-off line was written for toppers. You can lift off a star on a stick. You can't lift dust back off frosting.

Show Notes

Can you use non-edible glitter on a cake if you take it off? For a topper, yes. For loose glitter, no. The FDA says decorations that are not edible should be removed before the food is served and eaten. A solid piece such as a topper, ribbon or sprig can be lifted off. Loose glitter and dust cannot be taken back off frosting, so non-edible loose glitter should not go on a cake at all. Margaux reads the FDA advisory and the CDC report on luster-dust poisonings in Rhode Island and Missouri, which concern products that were not edible. Dana brings 3 objections: it says non-toxic, it's only on the part nobody eats, and it's only a tiny bit. Margaux would skip toppers; Dana wins the round, because a solid paper star that comes out in one piece is exactly what the FDA's sentence allows. In this episode: - What the FDA's take-it-off line actually covers - Why non-toxic and edible are two different promises - What the CDC found on 2 birthday cakes - A 3-question label check for the aisle - What to ask when someone else bakes the cake Who should skip it: any jar with no ingredient list, any loose decoration not made to be eaten, and any topper that sheds on your fingers. MONÉGASQUE Silver Sparkle 10 gram edible glitter is on Amazon at $14.99 standard; check the listing for current pricing. Direct answer: The FDA says decorations that are not edible should be removed before the food is served and eaten. A solid piece such as a topper, ribbon or sprig can be lifted off. Loose glitter and dust cannot be taken back off frosting, so non-edible loose glitter should not go on a cake at all. - 00:00 Cold open: the craft aisle - 00:32 The verdict: solid yes, loose no - 01:19 What the FDA said - 03:43 Objection 1: it says non-toxic; the CDC report - 06:24 Objection 2: only on the part nobody eats - 08:34 Dana's round: the paper star - 09:33 Objection 3 and the 3-question check - 12:16 Dana in the aisle, and buying instead of baking - 14:50 Who should skip · Dana's Scorecard · footnote Produced with AI-crafted hosts. Full transcript: https://monegasque.transistor.fm/episodes/non-edible-glitter-on-a-cake-can-you-just-take-it-off/transcript. New questions answered every week at The Monégasque Table.

What is The Monégasque Table?

Straight answers about edible glitter — is it safe, how much do you use, and is it really worth it? The Monégasque Table is a show where two hosts, Margaux and Dana, settle the questions home bakers and party hosts actually ask: safety, value, technique, and what the label really means. Every episode answers one question, gives the verdict up front, and says honestly who should skip it. Brought to you by MONÉGASQUE. Produced with AI-crafted hosts and human-checked facts.

Dana: It said non-toxic on the front and for decoration only on the back. In tiny letters. And I thought, well, I'll put it on the cake, and I'll just take it off before anybody eats it.

Margaux: Welcome to The Monégasque Table. Today's question is one a lot of people are too embarrassed to type: can you use non-edible glitter on a cake if you take it off before serving?

Dana: I'm not embarrassed. I'm a person standing in a craft aisle in December, and the jar was right there.

Margaux: And you're right to ask. So here's the answer up front. The FDA does have a line on exactly this. It says if a baker chooses to decorate a food item with decorations that are not edible, the decorations should be removed before the food is served and eaten. So a solid thing you can lift off in one piece, a topper, a ribbon, a sprig, that can come off. Loose glitter and dust cannot. You can't take powder back off frosting. If it's non-edible and it's loose, it doesn't go on the cake at all.

Dana: So the answer is yes for the thing on a stick, and no for the thing in a jar.

Margaux: That's the whole episode in one sentence, and we're going to spend the rest of it on why.

Dana: Because I have objections.

Margaux: I'm counting on it.

Margaux: Let's start with what the FDA actually said, because it's short, and it's plainer than people expect. There's an advisory written for home and commercial bakers. It tells them to avoid using glitter and dust products to decorate cakes and other foods, unless the products are specifically manufactured to be edible.

Dana: Specifically manufactured. So it's about how it was made, not what it looks like.

Margaux: That's right. Because of the next part, which is the part I'd put on the fridge. It says these products are sold in craft and bakery supply stores under names like luster dust, disco dust, twinkle dust, sparkle dust, highlighter, shimmer powder, pearl dust, and petal dust.

Dana: Hang on. I saw a video. A very calm woman in a very clean kitchen, brushing this stuff on a cake. Nobody said anything about a label.

Margaux: The advisory mentions that too. It says a variety of online videos, blogs and articles promote using these dusts on cakes, cupcakes and cake pops. So you aren't foolish for thinking it was fine. A lot of very calm people told you it was fine.

Dana: And luster dust is on that list? I thought luster dust was the edible one.

Margaux: Some of it is. That's the problem. The name doesn't tell you. Some luster dust is made to be eaten, and some luster dust is made for a craft project or a display piece, and they can be sold under the same words, on the same shelf.

Dana: So the words on the front are useless.

Margaux: The words on the front are a starting point. The back is where the answer lives. The advisory says companies that make edible glitters and dusts are required by law to include a list of ingredients on the label. And it says most of them also state edible on the label.

Dana: And if it doesn't?

Margaux: Then here's the sentence. If the label simply says non-toxic or for decorative purposes only, and does not include an ingredients list, the product should not be used directly on foods.

Dana: Okay. So that's my first objection, and it's the big one. Mine said non-toxic. Right on it. Non-toxic. Doesn't that mean it won't hurt anybody?

Margaux: I understand why it reads that way. It sounds like a safety word. But non-toxic and edible are two different promises. Non-toxic on a craft product is about the craft use. It isn't telling you it was made to go in a mouth. And the CDC took this up directly.

Dana: The CDC wrote about glitter?

Margaux: It did. A report in 2021, about luster dust and toxic metal poisonings in 2 states. I want to be very clear about what this report is about. It's about products that were not edible. It isn't about edible glitter. It's about what happens when the wrong jar goes on a cake.

Dana: Go ahead.

Margaux: Rhode Island, October 2018. Six children, aged 1 to 11, got sick after eating cake from a local bakery at a birthday party. Vomiting and diarrhea, starting 30 minutes to 10 hours after they ate it. Usually over in less than 10 hours.

Dana: A birthday party.

Margaux: A birthday party. The cake had a rose gold dust on it. And the jar for that dust was labeled nonedible, nontoxic, and for decoration only. All 3, on one label.

Dana: So the label told the truth, and it went on the cake anyway.

Margaux: It did. Investigators looked for where that dust came from. One of the possible sources was a cake pop bakery that sold it as a cake decoration. And an importer identified it as fine copper powder, first sold as a metallic pigment for consumer goods such as floor coverings.

Dana: Floor coverings.

Margaux: Floor coverings. When the state lab tested the frosting, it found 22.1 milligrams of copper per gram of frosting. Nearly 900 milligrams of copper on the slice.

Dana: Okay, wait. I'm going to push on you here, because this is where shows like this lose me. That's one cake. One dust, in 2018. You can scare anybody with one number. You could find one bad anything.

Margaux: That's fair, and I don't want to do that to you. So here are the other 2 numbers. The same health department went on to test 28 other inedible luster dusts from that same bakery. And it found elevated aluminum, barium, chromium, copper, iron, lead, manganese, nickel and zinc.

Dana: 28.

Margaux: 28 others. And then the second state. Missouri, 2019. A child aged 1 had an elevated blood lead level. During the inspection of the home, they found a primrose petal dust. It had been used for decorative flowers on the child's home-baked birthday cake. That one wasn't from a bakery at all. It was somebody's kitchen.

Dana: And what did that label say?

Margaux: Nontoxic, and made in USA. And the company selling that brand marketed it as a color for decorating baked goods, candies, chocolate and sugar art.

Dana: So that one wasn't even hiding. It said it was for cake.

Margaux: It said so. And here's the sentence from the CDC report I'd want you to keep. Labeling indicating that a product is nontoxic does not imply that the product is safe for consumption.

Dana: Okay. That answers my first objection. I don't like it, but it answers it.

Dana: Objection 2. I'm not putting it on the part anybody eats. I'd put it on the fondant bow, or on the board around the cake, or just on the top layer, and the top layer comes off.

Margaux: So think about what loose glitter does. Have you ever had it on a table?

Dana: It's December. I've had it in my hair since 2019.

Margaux: Then you know. It doesn't stay where you put it. And frosting is the stickiest thing in the room. We've said on this show, over and over, that a wet surface holds glitter. That's the whole reason the edible kind works. It's also why the non-edible kind is a problem. You can lift off a bow. You can't lift off what came off the bow.

Dana: What about the board, then? The cake stand. Nobody eats a cake stand.

Margaux: It's funny you say that. That CDC report lists 3 possible sources for the rose gold dust. One of them was a wholesale culinary company that sold the powder to decorate cake stands.

Dana: So it was sold for the stand.

Margaux: The report doesn't say which of the 3 supplied that bakery. What it does show is how close those two things sit. The stand is an inch from the frosting.

Dana: But the FDA says take it off.

Margaux: Look at what that sentence needs to be true. It needs you to be able to remove all of it. For a plastic star on a stick, you can. For a feather, you can. A university extension page, explaining that same advice, lists feathers and greenery as the kind of thing it means. And a news story covering the CDC report put it this way: some should be used for display only, like on a cake topper that's removed.

Dana: So the rule was written for toppers, and I was trying to use it for dust.

Margaux: That's what happened. And I'd say a lot of people do the same.

Dana: So now I want to fight about toppers. Because I can hear you about to tell me not to use one.

Margaux: I was going to say I'd leave them off altogether. A glittery one can shed. If you've got any doubt at all, the simple answer is no topper.

Dana: And that's my round. My daughter made a paper star on a wooden stick at school. It's coming to Christmas dinner. It's solid, it comes out in one piece, and it goes in the middle of the cake where I can see it. The FDA's own sentence says I can do that. You're telling me to throw out a thing that sentence allows, and that my kid made.

Margaux: That's the round you win. The advice is remove it before the food is served, and a solid piece with a stem can be removed. Keep the star. Here's what I'd add. Take it out before the knife comes out. Not after the slices are on the plates.

Dana: Before the knife. Fine. And if it leaves glitter on my fingers when I pick it up?

Margaux: Then that's the one that stays on the mantel. That's just my rule of thumb, no agency wrote it. If it comes off on your hand, it'll come off on the frosting.

Dana: I can live with the mantel.

Dana: Objection 3. And this is the one everybody's really thinking. It's a tiny bit. I'm talking about a pinch on a whole cake. One slice would have a speck of it.

Margaux: I hear you, and honestly, that's the argument that sounds the most reasonable. Here's the trouble. To say a tiny bit is fine, you'd have to know what's in the jar. And with a jar that has no ingredient list, you don't. That's the whole issue. Nobody in Rhode Island looked at a rose gold powder and thought, that's copper.

Dana: So it isn't about how much. It's that I can't know what the how-much is of.

Margaux: That's a better way of putting it than I had. With the edible kind, you've got a list. You know what it's made of, and you can ask how much goes on. With the other kind, there's no amount to reason about.

Dana: And this is not a small problem, right? This isn't just me.

Margaux: An analysis of about 2,400 category reviews sorted the complaints buyers had. 9.5% of the negative mentions said the product turned out not to be edible. People thought they'd bought one thing, and they'd bought another.

Dana: From a listing that looked fine.

Margaux: From a listing they trusted. So here's the actual check, for the aisle or the screen. 3 questions, in order. Does it say edible on the label? Is there an ingredient list? And does that list name food color additives, things like mica-based pearlescent pigments or FD&C colors, along with ingredients like sugar, acacia, maltodextrin or cornstarch? Those are the ones the advisory names as common in edible glitter.

Dana: And if I get 3 yeses, I'm safe?

Margaux: It's the first check, and it's a good one. It isn't the whole of the law. Even an ingredient list can name a color additive that isn't cleared for that particular food. The federal listing for mica-based pearlescent pigment, 21 CFR 73.350, works food by food. But if you get a no on any of those 3, you've got your answer, and you didn't need anything else.

Dana: What does that listing actually do, though? It's a number with a dot in it.

Margaux: Sparkle Lab for a minute. That listing spells out what the pigment is: titanium salts deposited on mica and then heated. And it writes purity limits right into the regulation. Lead no more than 4 parts per million, arsenic no more than 3, mercury no more than 1. That's what the law asks of that pigment.

Dana: So somebody sat down and wrote a number for lead.

Margaux: For a pigment that's going in food, somebody did. That's the difference. A color additive made for food has a list of rules it has to answer to. A jar made for a craft table was never asked those questions.

Dana: Okay. Let me tell you what actually happened, because I said I was standing in the aisle, and I was. Last December. It's the 22nd. I've got a white cake planned, I've got a kid who wants it to look like snow, and I've got a jar in my hand. And I'm not a chemist. I just want the snow.

Margaux: What did the jar say?

Dana: Non-toxic. Fine, sparkly, beautiful. And I turn it over, and there's no list. No ingredients at all. And that was the moment. Because I thought, I'm about to feed this to my kid, and I couldn't tell you one thing that's in it.

Margaux: That's better than anything in the advisory.

Dana: So I put it back. And I went home with no glitter, and that was the cake. Just white. And you know what? When I brought it out, with the candles and the lights off, nobody said a thing about what it didn't have. It was the quietest my house had been all week.

Margaux: There's a real lesson in that. The cake without glitter is a perfectly good cake. Nobody needs shimmer. If the only thing you can get your hands on is the jar with no list, then the right amount of glitter is none.

Dana: And if I'm not the baker? If I ordered it?

Margaux: Then you can ask. That university page says talk to your bakery about the decorative products they use, and when in doubt, ask to see the labels. A good bakery won't be offended. And if you're the one running the bakery, even out of your own kitchen, the FDA was talking to you too. The advisory says it's the responsibility of a food maker, whether that's a large commercial bakery or a small, home-based business.

Dana: So if I sell 1 cake to a neighbor.

Margaux: You're in that sentence.

Dana: One more, and it's the one that's going to hurt. What if I've already done it? It's on the cake. I spent all day on that cake.

Margaux: Then I'm sorry, and I wouldn't serve it.

Dana: I can't scrape it off?

Margaux: Same problem as before. You can't know what you left behind. More frosting over the top doesn't take anything away, it just hides it. A cake from the store is a better dessert than that one.

Dana: And if somebody's already had a slice?

Margaux: Then call your doctor or your local poison center, and have the jar in your hand when you do. That label is what they'll want to read. And I wouldn't wait around to see how anybody feels. In Rhode Island, it started anywhere from 30 minutes to 10 hours after the cake.

Dana: Okay. Who should skip it? I mean, who should skip the glitter part?

Margaux: 3 skips. If the jar has no ingredient list, skip it, every time, no matter what the front says. If the decoration is loose and it isn't made to be eaten, skip it, because you can't take it back off. And if you've got a topper that sheds on your fingers, skip that one too, and put it on the mantel with the others.

Dana: Dana's Scorecard. I came in thinking the FDA's take-it-off rule was my way out. Where I landed. One: take-it-off is for things you can lift off in one piece. Not dust. Two: non-toxic is not edible, and the CDC said so in writing. Three: there's a 3-question check, edible on the label, a real ingredient list, and food color additives named on it. Four, my round: my daughter's paper star stays, and it comes out before the knife. Five: if it's the 22nd and all I've got is the wrong jar, the cake goes out plain. My caveat: I'm going to stand in that aisle again next year, and it's still going to look pretty.

Margaux: It will. And that's why the label matters more than the shelf. The footnote: the MONÉGASQUE Silver Sparkle 10 gram edible glitter is on Amazon at $14.99, with the ingredient list on the jar.

Dana: Next time, something happier. Gumdrops. Homemade. There's a step where you roll them in sugar, and I want to know if the glitter can just go in the sugar.

Margaux: It can, and it's the easiest answer we've had all year. And after that, a holiday party drink that's mostly cranberry and bubbles, where the question is how much to buy for a crowd. One note before we go — this show is produced by the team at Monégasque, with AI-crafted hosts. See you at the table.