In this episode of Scalability School, host Andrew Foxwell is joined by Phil Kiel of Taikun Digital and co-host Brad Ploch to tackle the single most-asked question in the Foxwell Founders community: how do you actually test creative on Meta in 2026? The question was asked over 160 times in just 45 days, making it the undisputed #1 topic among media buyers and brand operators in the community.
The conversation digs into two distinct camps of creative testing, forced spend (ABO) versus letting ads earn spend (CBO) and unpacks the real-world pros, cons, and trade-offs of each. Phil, who runs accounts at significant scale, makes a compelling case for the CBO-first, content-centric approach, arguing that the role of Meta's algorithm is to allocate spend to the best creative, not for buyers to manually dictate it. The episode also confronts the volume trap: the pressure media buyers feel to launch massive quantities of ads every month. Phil's take is refreshing and practical, 8 to 10 solid concepts per month (roughly 40–50 assets) is a solid starting point for most brands, built around strong creative briefs rather than raw volume. The hosts challenge the Twitter/X culture of flex-posting ad launch numbers, arguing the real metric that matters is creative quality and concept diversity.
Key Takeaways:
This episode of the Scalability School podcast is sponsored by NorthBeam and they just launched Northbeam Incrementality. Northbeam Incrementality gives you easy, automated, self-service incrementality tests, while protecting you from the major mistakes so many people make while running incrementality tests. Your MTA handles the daily tactics, your MMM guides the long-term planning, and Incrementality provides the causal truth. It's a closed loop that allows you to scale what works and cut what doesn't. Right now when you head over to northbeam.io/incrementality, they're offering Scalability School listeners 50% off unlimited tests for a year when you join. Just tell them we sent you!
To learn more about Phil Kiel and the Taikun Digital team you can follow him on X https://x.com/PhilKiel or head to https://www.taikundigital.com/
To connect with Andrew Foxwell send an email Andrew@foxwelldigital.com
To connect with Brad Ploch send him a DM at https://x.com/brad_ploch
To connect with Zach Stuck send him a DM at https://x.com/zachmstuck
Learn More about the Foxwell Founders Community at https://foxwellfounders.com/
Learn More about the The Hive Haus Creators Community at http://HiveHausUGC.com
Scalability School is your cheat code for building a more profitable DTC brand or agency.
We break down tactical strategies, real-time wins, and tough lessons from three powerful perspectives: operator, agency, and community. It's not theory—it's what's actually working in the wild. Skip the fluff, steal what works, and scale with confidence.
And then you're launching these ads into
those ad sets and you're allowing
Meta to either
spend or not spend.
And there is a whole host of pros
and a whole host of cons.
A whole host of pros mainly falls under,
you're probably going to lose
less often, lose less
tests, also lose less money,
cash, profit.
The con is you're probably
going to make a
lot of ads that don't ever
receive any spend.
A bit more like how I like
to think of apparel
and fashion, which is you walk
into a department
store for a brand.
Each section of the shop is
a different campaign.
So you've got like jackets and you've got
men's wear and you've got
women's wear rather
than testing area of the shop and
a scaling area of the shop.
I like that.
I'm not a Zuck apologist here.
So like I'm not dying on any hills, but I
think for most of the time it's
like, no, you don't
need to make room.
If your budget is set on
the campaign, an ad
set level where you can get
out of learning,
then you should trust that
Meta is 90% of the
time or more is going to make
the right allocation.
Brand owners or founders over
the last couple
of weeks where they felt really
guilty because
they're not hitting this volume
of ads that's going live.
Because I've got to work on
something creative.
I've got to work on something creative.
And instead of launching any, they're
just launching none.
And my recommendation was
always the same.
It's just like, forget about trying
to launch a certain number.
Create one piece of content as if it was
going to be posted organically.
And instead of posting it to organic,
just upload it to the ad account.
All right.
Welcome to scalability school
episode about
how to do creative testing
in 2026 and beyond
really, hopefully, but you know how
to do creative testing today.
Insane guest for this.
We have Phil, who is an absolute
legend in the DTC space.
Is Phil Kiel, of course, from
Tycoon Digital.
Has been somebody that people follow all over
the world and is an absolute legend.
And so Phil is here to help talk about
this at 9 p.m. his time.
So thank you, Phil, for joining.
I would for sure not have
said yes to this.
So thank you.
Well, I've slept all day and I've
awoken like Dracula.
And of course, we have the always handsome
Brad here with us to my co-host.
Rumor is that could be coming back soon.
We'll have to see.
He is currently, you know, doing a million
things and raising a child.
Still on on dad leave a little bit.
So we look forward to that.
One thing I want to mention at the top of
the episode is we do drop
in the newsletters
on scalability school dot com.
You can sign up for our email newsletter
worksheets and extra perks and things.
So you may want to go over
there and sign up
for the email at scalabilityschool
dot com.
Make sure that you have,
you know, kind of
all the resources that you're
getting or that
we talk about on here.
Those sometimes get sent out via email.
So, you know, a little plug there
at the beginning.
So going into the episode, talking about
how to do creative testing.
Number one thing to say is
this is the number
one question in the Foxwell
Founders community.
So I got a report on our bot, which is within
the Foxwell Founders community.
You can basically ask a
question to the AI
bot, which sources answers
from, you know,
from Slack, basically from our community.
And it this is interesting
because it came
back and said that the number
one question that
people are asking it over the last six
months was it was asked one
hundred and oh, yeah,
forty five days.
It was not six months asked over one hundred
and sixty times in forty five days.
How do I do creative testing?
And this is something I asked Brad and he's
like, yeah, you just like rip it.
I'm like, but what does that mean?
So we need to get into talking
about this.
And and Phil is a perfect guest
to get into it.
So number one on creative testing,
two camps, I
think there's the for spend
under ABO creative
testing.
And then there's the second camp,
which is let ads earn spend.
Brad, you want to give a little
more color on this?
Yeah, I can.
Before I say that, Phil's Phil, I go to
I go to Phil for two reasons.
One, incredible Twitter content,
amazing learnings.
I really enjoy what you put
out on the Internet.
Two, when I'm trying to convince
my wife to
let me get my hands tattooed,
I'm just like,
look, look at how sick this guy looks.
You're making the first mistake where
you're asking the wife.
That's true.
Yeah, that is a mistake.
I just need to show up.
I just need to show up.
OK, let's talk about the two camps.
Phil, do you do you would you prefer to
take the CBO side or the ABO side?
Not because we're picking one better,
but we can explain it.
I'll let you explain whichever
one you prefer.
I mean, it's a tough it's a tough one.
So I'm more of a CBO fan.
I am.
We are running both.
Definitely.
We are definitely running both.
And I'm much more on the mindset of like what's
right for the business right now.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Makes sense.
OK, so let me I'll tee up.
I'll tee up the ABO camp.
You tee up the CBO camp.
And we'll talk about pros and cons.
Just kind of go back and forth.
So on the ABO side, so to Andrew's point,
there's there's there's really
two camps that
people kind of fall into.
And there's like mini versions of both of
them that kind of exists
across ad accounts.
But it's basically we force spend.
We let meta decide.
And there's a little bit of like a middle
ground in the middle there
where you can do
the mid budget, things like that.
But I'll talk about the forced
spend, which
generally looks like ABO creative
testing side.
And I'll just present a couple of
ways that you can do it.
We'll talk.
We can talk about pros and cons
after we present the both.
So on the forced spend side,
basically what
this looks like is you set
up when I say ABO,
if you're not familiar with that, ad set
budget optimization and each
new creative test that
you're launching gets its own ad set with
its own dedicated budget budget.
And you were telling meta,
I want to spend
these dollars no matter what
the efficiency
is, whatever, like I want
to spend because
I'm going to learn against this creative.
That's what I'm trying to do.
There's a couple of ways that people split
their ad sets then on top of that.
So you can either you can batch ad sets
based on like creative batches.
So maybe you have like a
weekly cadence for
producing creative and your
team submits a
batch and you get the batch and
you can launch like that.
There are people who I laugh,
but like I've
seen it and I'm sure it's
fine in many cases,
but people will set up a single
ad set per ad,
even to a degree where they're
running literally
one at a time.
And they're just like trying to say like,
okay, does this, does this work?
And it's got single ad with
its own budget.
There's a couple of like
mini variations of
that where it's like similar
to batch where
it's like maybe you have a video concept,
you have three hooks for
the video concept,
you launch that into an ad set.
The last way that I generally
see that these,
these are run is kind of some
kind of grouping.
So it's an ad set budget,
but I have a theme
behind the way that I'm grouping
my ad sets.
So maybe it's handsome men with glasses
and a beautiful beard.
Like that's who I'm targeting.
And then the mustache, the mustache group,
like those are the two groups.
And you're like, put your creative tests
go into, into those ad sets.
But the, the, the big takeaway from, from
camp number one is you are
setting up mainly
ad sets where you were forcing spend into
creative tests and saying
meta, I don't really
care what the results are.
I'm framing that maybe a
little bit poorly,
but like I'm going to spend
these dollars no
matter what, because I'm going to use the
learnings of that to dictate
what I want to
do as opposed to this other camp, which
Phil, as you jump into that,
which is the letting
ads earn spend.
And I wonder if you agree
with the framing
of that camp, which is a
forcing versus not
forcing.
Yeah.
I think that's, I think you've, I think
you've explained it beautifully
there, Brad.
Um, and yeah, the CBO approach
is where you
are, you're controlling more
of the activity
outside of the ad account.
And then when it goes into
the ad account,
you're essentially letting
the babies leave the
nest and, and I have a fly or fall.
And we can keep going on that metaphor
or we can leave it there.
But yeah, you're essentially having a CBO campaign,
campaign budget optimization ad
sets per whatever.
There's lots of options there and we can,
and we can talk through that.
And then you're launching these ads into
those ad sets and you're allowing
meta to either
spend or not spend.
And there is a whole host
of pros and a whole
host of cons, a whole host
of pros mainly falls
under.
You're probably going to lose less often,
lose less tests, also lose
less money, cash,
profit.
The con is you're probably
going to make a
lot of ads that don't ever
receive any spend.
The counter argument to that
is if they don't
receive spend, how often
when you then force
spend into those ads, do
they, are you just,
you know, meta's decision
is confirmed as a
whole, you know, the right thing
to have happened.
And it's quite often that
that is the case.
We have, you know, zombie
campaigns, which
we can talk to, which is
sort of like round
two and which, which is always
a good thing to do.
I think the main thing that
I think about is
what's right for your ad
account right now.
And there's so much content
out there on the
internet around brands that
are doing amazing
things and the structures
that they're using.
And so often I order ad
accounts and we're
getting into the why rather
than maybe we should
just talking about how first, but, and so
often I order ad accounts
and I'm like, when
was the last time you tested an ad that won
and you're still doing ABO testing?
It's like, you keep banging
your head against
this brick wall and admit,
and yeah, I think
that's, that's usually where we then make
the suggestion to move to CBL.
I mean, it's so much of it
is like, I think a
lot of the, the ABO method
was built and from
what people thought was the
right thing to do
and where a lot of the education
was focused
for a long time, which was the
graduation method.
You put it in there, it's separate,
it's clean, right?
And then you don't do that.
And I think this reason that CB, well,
let me, let me wrap that up.
So you, you know, take an ad, if it works well,
you put it into a scaling campaign.
Well, this is not something that I think
the majority of us are doing anymore.
You're, you're, you know, it's just,
it kills the performance of it.
And I think if you're still doing this, you're
putting yourself at a disadvantage.
And so, you know, now what we're talking
about is putting it into a CBO
campaign, which is
one goes on the, the idea of,
you know, consolidation.
But also the second option
of the CBO campaign
in that camp, which I think
you'll learn through
this episode, we're, we're
certainly in more
is you have to have a certain
amount of budget
in that CBO campaign to really
like be able to do this.
Is there a way that you calculate
that, right?
Like, let's say that you
have a CBO that's
running and you're going to
launch a new creative
into it.
And the budget is hypothetical.
It's a thousand dollars a day.
Okay.
If you're going to add 10
new creatives into
it, are you going to increase
that to $1,500
a day as you're testing it?
Or are you going to keep it
the same and just
say, we're just going to let
it compete against
these other ones because spend
is the metric, right?
And I was talking to Harry, Harry
D shout out Harry Demelish.
He was just an incredible advertiser,
creative strategist about this.
And he really is like, look, spends
like the only thing.
And we've talked about that in this
podcast as well, right?
You can talk about creative metrics.
Somebody I noticed this morning asked you
about your, some of your social
content about
asking how you track, fill your win rate,
which I'm interested in
hearing about that
too.
But I think, is there, is there a budget
there that you have to think about?
You can just keep tossing stuff
in the same CBO?
In the agency, we scale based on performance,
not based on launching new ads.
And if the performance isn't there, we're
launching new ads to try to improve
the performance
rather than we're in a hole.
Let's get a bigger shovel.
So we keep, so we, so we dig
ourselves into an
even bigger, we're going to
improve performance
by launching different ads.
And there's a very big chance that,
especially if the performance
isn't there, there's a
very big chance that new
ads will get spent.
And that's a good place to be in.
The bad place to be in is
when your highest
spending ads aren't good
enough because they
can become a bit of a crutch
where, you know,
got to keep them live to drive
that performance.
But when you launch anything new,
it doesn't get spent.
And then you have to ask, okay, why aren't
those new ads getting spent?
That then I think is a question around
everything else other than testing
method, offer, message,
angle, you know, the creator, product market
fit, all of those sort of things.
And I think that's a much bigger
lever than ABO versus CBO.
I think if performance isn't
there, moving
from CBO to ABO will rarely
improve performance
in the short term.
So we should probably end
the podcast there.
Just like that's, all right,
lesson learned.
I did write it down as well.
If you're asking the question,
ABO or CBO,
and this isn't to put anyone
down, but I think
if you're asking the question, ABO or
CBO, you should probably choose CBO.
And that goes back to, you know, a lot of
the content that we see online
and, you know,
how all these huge brands
that are growing
massively year on year, they're
so aggressive.
Their margins are so aggressive.
Their performance targets are like 0.8x
ROAS, for example, from an
acquisition point.
If you, they're in a very good
place to do ABO.
Yeah.
The budget, the budget point is an
interesting one, Andrew, because
it's like, Phil, you
answered it exactly how I would have.
So it's like, I'm going to say it's brilliant,
but it's because I totally agree.
It's like, yeah, like you shouldn't need
to, you shouldn't need to make room.
And like, we have, we, we
get, we will have
people, you know, I'm sure, Phil,
you've experienced
this, or it's like every once in a while,
a client will send you an audit.
And it's like, hey, did you
see that they said
you have too many active ads
in your campaigns?
And it's like, well, what does too many
ads mean and how you define it?
Because it makes these, it make you, what
assumption you're making
when you say that
is meta is treating all these ads equally
and spending against them equally.
And I think it really like, should,
should you increase budget?
I mean, the, the, the 80%
answer I think is
like, no, for most people
where it can get
weird is if you have a really
high AOE product
and you launch a ton of creative
all the time.
And when, to your point, Phil, it's like,
when you launch something, it's
going to get some
spend.
It might not be a ton, but
if you launch a
hundred ads and you have a $500
AOV meta is going
to spend against all of that.
And so it's going to try
to use a good chunk
of your, your existing budget
to go towards
stuff because it wants to give it a
chance at least at the beginning.
And so that can screw up
efficiency in the
short term, but otherwise
it's like, no, you
don't need to increase the budget because
meta is, meta is allocating.
And I'm not, uh, I'm not, uh, I'm
not a Zuck apologist here.
So like, I'm not, uh, I'm
not dying on any
Hills, but, um, I think most
of the time it's
like, no, you don't, you don't
need to make room.
If your budget is set on the
campaign, uh, an
ad set level where you can
get out of learning,
then you should trust that meta is 90% of
the time more and more is
going to make the
right allocation decision.
You know, let's talk about bidding as it
relates to this and do create,
doing creative
testing.
So, you know, sometimes I've heard people
saying, look, we're going
to, we do all of our
testing, uh, or, you know, we run it all
on lowest cost or we run it all on min
ROAS or, um, I've even heard
things about,
um, you know, minimum spend
with new creatives.
Um, do you, number one, do you put in
minimum spend in your opinion?
Is that a good thing to do?
And number two, what do you
think about the
bids as it relates to testing
within CBOs?
So I want to just real quick
on it, like say
like, okay, so if we're, if,
if, if, if you're
coming to, to, to Brad and Phil to make a
recommendation on like what you should
do in your ad account,
we're, we're both collectively leaning
towards like, Hey, the CBO
approach is probably
the right one.
So the reason to stay away
from ABO to your
points is try to avoid this
because you're
going to be forcing spend.
And if you don't have a good hit rate or
success rate with your creative,
or you've been, you
know, bad at making ads for
a while or your
offer sucks or whatever it
is, you're going
to, you're going to, you're picking up a
bigger shovel, shovel and digging
yourself a bigger
hole.
So if we're leaning towards the AB or the
CBO camp, what does the CBO
camp look like?
Which I think is what Andrew is starting to,
to, to the path that we're going down.
Um, and like, what does that
actually look like?
So we're saying you should
probably go CBO.
So like within CBO, there's now a bunch
of different ways to set that up.
Um, the way that we generally
do it, and I
think this might be a little
bit different
from how you guys do it.
Um, and I think you'll be able to better
answer Andrew's actual question
as a result of that
is we generally, like we have
a single campaign.
Like let's say we, we'll use, we'll
use Zach cause he's not here.
We're selling socks and we have
one specific sock product.
We're setting up a single campaign
for that skew of socks.
And with one ad set in there for the socks,
we're not launching new ad sets.
In most cases, when we have
new creative, we're
launching everything into that
existing campaign,
regardless of who it's speaking to.
Because on an ad level,
and I think I have
a point saved on this at
some point, like on
an ad level, meta is still
making a decision
around how much to spend into
each individual
ad, um, based on your total budget.
It's not looking at who it's delivering.
Like the ad set, this ad set learning
thing, I think is-
Yeah, you're giving it the freedom and you're,
and you're segmenting it by product.
Yes, exactly.
And, and by product is not
because we're trying
to force creative learning to
a specific product.
It's because those products might have
a certain margin of the profile.
That's because that's where you're
making those money.
Yeah, right.
Yeah, exactly.
I'm just printing socks, you know?
Yeah, exactly.
But yeah.
Yeah.
It's like, I'm trying to
set, I'm trying to
build a funnel around socks
because they have
a certain margin or a certain offer
profile or whatever it is.
And so, so what we're doing,
I guess, is to
wrap that up is single, single
ad set in most
cases.
And we're just launching in new
ads until we max it out.
Very rarely are we going through
and pausing a ton of ads.
Again, not that we don't do it.
It's just like, it's just
rarely we do it.
So that leads to the mid, the min spends
and like those variations.
I guess I'm curious if you
are doing the budget
and bid adjustments or like
how you're looking
at that.
We don't use minimum spend
very often, but
we have done in the past and
it's, I like the
idea of it.
And they did bring out, so the first iteration
of that product or feature was cash.
So we've, we've got the, the campaign
budget is a thousand dollars.
We can say, I'd set one at a hundred
dollars per day minimum.
I'd set two at $200 per day minimum.
And then, you know, that's
$700 remaining.
That will be spread wherever Meta wants.
The latest development of that, which I
think is a couple of months
ago was percent.
So you could essentially
say 10% of spend.
And then as you scaled the total campaign
budget, that would then mean,
you know, that 10% stays
relative.
And I think there's a, you
know, there's a,
there's a logic to why that
is attractive, but
we don't, we don't, we don't
use it whatsoever.
And the main, yeah, we don't use it.
The main reason is because
quite often we'll
launch ads and they'll get
spend in some format.
If we launch five ads, two of
them will get spent.
And if they don't, then that's a
pretty strong indication.
The bids, I think is a, is an interesting
topic and a good, and a good argument.
And this moves away from
sort of how to test
creative and more into sort
of lowest cost and
bid caps and stuff.
We don't do any, we don't do any manual
bidding on creative testing.
And we do do some of it on
sort of scaling.
I think it's just like, I think, you know,
you've got, you've got all these.
Yeah.
I mean, what's the difference for you from
a creative testing versus a scaling?
Like the reason I asked this question is,
by the way, Taylor holiday,
a hundred percent
listens to this.
So if we talk about cost caps the wrong
way, he's going to flame us all on X.
Okay.
So actually I'm sure he doesn't
listen to this.
All right, friends, quick break.
This episode is brought to you by North
beam, the marketing attribution
platform that we
love over here at the pod and good news.
North beam is launching North
beam incrementality.
North beam incrementality
gives you automated
easy self-service incrementality
tests while
protecting you from the major mistakes.
So many people make while running
these incrementality tests.
Cause honestly, most of these incrementality
tests are kind of a mess, right?
So what I love about it is you, it
gives you a casual truth.
You can act on every day, not
one-off siloed reports.
And it does it end to end.
So it automates lift testing does.
It connects you with your MTA and MMM.
So you can scale.
It works and cut what doesn't
all in one dashboard.
That's the real game changer.
Now the North beam has incrementality.
It means you can run the absolute
trifecta of
marketing measurement in one
single platform,
all using the same data.
North beam incrementality launches
this quarter.
Get over to north beam.io forward slash
incrementality and be the
first on the list.
And they're offering 50% off unlimited
tests for a year to advertisers
who join now.
Tell them we sent you at the
scalability school.
Can't wait.
Actually, I'm sure he doesn't listen
to this by the way.
But you do, listener, and you
are freaking awesome.
So good job because you're
smarter than most
people on the internet by
listening to this
podcast.
So on that sense, like you have, what's
the difference between those two?
Is it scaling versus creative testing?
The only place where that will be really
dramatically different is when you're
using something like
inflated budgets, where
you're setting the
budget at like $20,000 per day,
but it's only spending
2K, 3K.
And structurally, this would
be you taking
banger ads that have worked
and keep working.
And they are in a new, they're in a CBO
that's been running for a
while or something.
Yeah.
And you're going to jack it up to let it spend
when it does, when it's really good.
And to that, and that's like
a scaling thing.
So these are a group of ads
that have started
as babies that have grown
up that are now in
their own scaling thing.
And you have a new CBO that then you're
testing other stuff in.
Is that correct?
Yeah, correct.
We don't do that very often.
And it's kind of, and I
don't know how you
would test creative if you
were doing using
an inflated budget structure,
because you're
essentially saying you can
spend as much as
you want here when the performance
is good,
but I'm going to force spend
into this, these
assets over here.
And it feels like you're trying to do
two things at the same time.
And there's also going to be a
hell of a lot of overlap.
So you've been asking, you just asked,
how would we do that?
And I've answered the question, whether
or not we would do that.
No, no, no.
I mean, I'm not talking about that.
Like, I'm not talking about you inflating
on a testing one.
I'm talking about on a scaling one.
So like, how many ads have to get in?
Like, one of the things I've heard within
these, within the challenge
of, okay, it's
a CBO's, you know, testing structure is, won't
I have too many ads that are live?
Like I have too many ads that
are live, you know?
To answer that question,
if you've got too
many ads live and your performance
is good,
then you would increase the budget.
And that increased budget would therefore
go back to your original
question, you know,
earlier on, which was when you launch more
ads, do you increase the budget?
So if performance is good, you
can double the budget.
In theory, that gives more room
for assets to go live.
For assets.
Yeah.
The way I'm sort of thinking
about it now is
more from like a, an organic
marketing structure.
And it's less about, it's less about
scientific test and scale and
duplicate, which I think
is where we were sort of five,
six years ago.
And it's more around make
the best possible
content that we can for the
brand, try and learn
along the way and have a piece of strategy
and then scale it most efficiently.
Yeah.
And so that's kind of your
mentality with it,
which is not trying to do
much manual stuff,
but letting meta decide.
I think that, I mean, I completely agree.
It's focused on the, it's content centric
versus, you know, logistic
centric and, and
lever pulling centric.
So what I wonder is, let's
say that you are
scaling, have, you know, you're
scaling in this,
you're doing, it's doing
well and you want
to launch a, well, in what instance would
you launch a brand new CBO then?
Brad, do you want to answer that?
Or do you never launch a brand new CBO?
I mean, like I've heard both.
Like some people will say, look, I'm going
to do a new CBO every quarter.
Cause like it's becomes too much.
I don't want to have everything
dependent on this one.
You know, some of it's obviously product
or offer or funnel centric, right?
They're going to launch a new thing.
And it's like, that's what
we're going to do.
What's your opinion on this, Brad?
So we will generally speaking, we have
campaigns by product or by offer.
So like, let's say we sell
the same product,
but we're splitting up into,
we have different
offers.
We'll generally make a new
campaign for the
new offer because we, Taylor
is listening.
We do run a lot of bids, so please
don't yell at me.
Um, but no, we, because, because we're,
because we're setting bids differently
based on the
goals of that campaign, then we
want them to be separate.
You could do that within, you could do
it within a CBO, but so, okay.
So let's go back to our socks examples.
Um, if I have a sock campaign and it is,
let's say it's, you know, lowest
cost or cost cap,
cause it's bidding on the same thing.
Well, functionally, um, depending on if
you're putting a limit at it or not.
So you've got a sock campaign
on lowest cost
or cost cap, and you've got
your single ad set
in there.
Um, we will just keep launching
ads in there.
And the only time we'll make a new ad set
is if we need, we ran out of room.
They, thankfully in most
cases, now they've
increased the limit on that
to 150 from 50,
but there's still, there's still
ads that are limited at 50.
Um, so what it might look like is we have
a, we have a campaign with
a bunch of ad sets
in it that, um, are all in purpose
of the same thing.
They have the same bids.
It's, but it's all for that same product.
So when do we introduce a new campaign?
There's a couple of, couple of cases, new
product or new offer, um, or promo.
Um, we want to switch to a different
type of bidding.
So maybe we're going to go
from a cost-based
bidding to a value-based
bidding, um, which,
in which case we'll do that.
Um, and those are really like, that's
really like the only scenario
that we're adding a
new campaign.
Like we're not doing any like crazy
horizontal scaling thing or like,
you know, trying to
do it that way or we're forcing budgets.
Um, and the main reason from that, like
I've, the consolidation point
is like, it'd been
an interesting topic on my mind lately.
I saw, I saw a thread recently
where, um, I
can't remember who it was, but
he was talking about
his bid caps and his lowest costs.
And he's like, you know, I split out interest-based
testing on top of that.
And all of a sudden the interest-based
testing
looked, looked good, but it
made my broad not
perform as well.
And then it's like, I think what we're
trying to do is like give meta
the meta, the, the,
the parameters on what success
looks like,
which is purchase optimized
campaigns for a
lot of people for a very long time.
Um, maybe use cost controls,
maybe you don't,
but then as much as I can
allow them to make
decisions within those guardrails
of, of that,
like they're going to do the
best job allocating
things.
Uh, so long winded way of answering
your question.
It's like they really, the only time we
change and add a new campaign
is we've added a, uh,
a different way we're doing value-based
bidding instead of cost-based
bidding or alongside
or running both.
We, um, we've run an ad account, which is
for a, a single supplement
and we have a CBO
campaign per, uh, segment and that's,
and it's a liver product.
And that segment is, is the types of people
that would buy this liver product.
So it's, uh, people who are overweight,
people who drink too much,
people who have fat
liver disease, you know, X, Y, Z, and you
can continue down that route.
And there's logic that those campaigns
could work together.
Or there's a, you know, there's a sort of
romantic idea that each one
of those different
campaigns are going to be targeted
in different audience.
There will always be overlap, but it supports
our input, which is creative.
So if we're going to 10 X
the number of assets
for over drinkers, where are
they going to go?
We have to have somewhere to put them.
Um, and that's the main reason is for, it's
just folders on a computer essentially.
And to ensure that we are
acquiring customers
across all of those different
segments, because
obviously we can control the budget
at the campaign level.
Whereas if we didn't, and we had them all
grouped together, maybe one CBO
with all the ad sets
being those different segments, then in
theory, we could, that could
actually lead to risk.
We've moved away from CBO
to, from APO to CBO.
We've moved away to, into CBO because
we want to limit risk.
But actually if we do, if the example I had
where all those different segments were
different ad set in the CBO, we would
over focus on one audience.
And that would, um, you know, put us in a
potentially a tough situation after a
couple of years, you know,
we're over focused on
one product, one audience that
then disappears.
That's a business risk.
Our competitors are over focusing
somewhere else,
you know, when we're not taking
market share there.
So, yeah, but I think there's a good, if
you've got a single product, I think
there's, there's, there will be reasons why
you could launch more CBO campaigns.
I would probably recommend focusing on
persona, angle, uh, creative
type, potentially.
And we could talk about that in partnership
ads going into CBOs.
Um, Brad's example of like a CBO per product
is a bit more like how I like to think
of apparel and fashion, which is you walk
into a department store for a brand.
Each section of the shop is
a different campaign.
So you've got like jackets and you've got
menswear and you've got women's
wear rather than test.
You don't have a testing area of the shop
and a scaling area of the shop.
I'll set up like that.
I like that.
But like in the, in the event, so like, uh,
on the, on the example that you gave,
the supplement example you gave, um, those
personas, like the, the functional
benefit inside of meta to you guys is
it's folders, it's organization.
We can see how performance looks
on each of these things.
And like, maybe it's not perfectly
delivering to
that exact segment, but like
the intent behind it.
And that drives what you guys do from a decision
making basis and how your creative
strategy comes together, which I
think is really valuable.
The argument that people make in favor of
ABO testing, which I think is a totally
fair one is like, it's, I think it's, I think
it's fair in theory, but I think it
makes a wrong assumption about people's intent,
which is like, we're forcing it.
So it means we need to care more
about the, the input here.
Um, and we're going to pay
more attention to it.
Cause we know if we need to turn
it off, we know if it's
not working, we know we can learn
from it as a result of that.
Um, but so anyways, the, the functional benefit
of the CBO splitting that you're
talking about is we can talk to
these different personas.
We're going to be accountable
to making creative for
these different personas actually
in meta's delivery.
There's maybe not a massive like functional
difference because of they're really
just folders to your point, but like it
drives how you guys take action.
Is that fair?
Yeah, exactly.
And then, and then there's benefits
from a business level.
We can see which customers come
from those campaigns.
We can track them in Clavio.
We can track their LTV.
We can, we can, we can pause one.
We can double down on the other.
We can raise credit to support one campaign
cause the LTV is so strong.
But you wouldn't do that if you only had
a hundred bucks a day or if you had 500
bucks a day, like you're, you're, you're
getting new campaign when you feel
confident that this is going
to be efficient.
I'm using the term learning now cause I
think there's something magical about
learning, but like, it's just a good practice
to have, which is like, we shouldn't
be splitting out new campaigns
if we don't
think that we're going to
be efficient enough.
One really quick example.
We have a apparel client who like ran out of
inventory through the end of the year,
basically through most of January, cause things
just went really well in November.
And so, yes, they have a bunch of different
products across a bunch of different
price points, but it's like we, if we start
to split those campaigns out, it's like
we have seven campaigns and
there's like no budget
going through here where that could
possibly be efficient.
So then we, we did consolidate everything
back down and we made, here's
all products.
It's value-based bidding to
control for the ROAS.
We're just going to let it rip because otherwise
there's no way where this is going
to be efficient enough cause we
just can't spend enough.
The second inventory is back and
we can push spend back up.
Then we're going to split those back out.
But like, it all kind of comes
back to the whole point.
Andrew, you brought up earlier
consolidation.
It's like, it's context dependent on
what the program is spending.
So Phil, I guess what I'm saying
is like you, you
wouldn't be doing that if you had
a hundred, 500 bucks a day.
It's like you're doing that cause
you feel confident
that each of those are going to
be efficient on their own.
Yeah.
Yeah.
And they, they take, they take months,
courses, years to build up to.
Yeah.
Yeah.
I mean, spend is a huge function
of this, I think.
Right.
In terms of the testing.
Let, let me talk about the, you know, metrics
that we look at when we're testing.
So, so I'm going to do create, I think, you
know, I'm going to do creative testing.
I'm a brand.
I haven't done it very efficiently.
I've spent all this money on creative.
I'm hesitant to put it all
into the same CBO.
Right.
Because what if I don't
get clean metrics?
And I think that there's two things to say
here is like, one, I think to a degree
advertisers and brands have been sold the
idea that the metric is the whole, like
metrics, creative metrics specifically
are the holy grail.
Right.
And I think that actually what we're learning
about really scaling brands is that
spend within an efficient
CBO is like the most
efficient thing and is the best
metric to look at.
Because, you know, many times these, there's
not necessarily a correlation between
an ad having a good creative
metric or a good
creative hit rate and actually
selling something.
So how do you feel about creative
metrics now, Phil?
And how are you judging this if something
isn't getting the spend?
I think because like I know this is a common
thing that we hear from clients like,
you know, I spent all this
money in creative.
You're not even going to look at the, you
know, how are you going to say like,
well, actually, we have some
early indications here
based on this rate that this
is doing pretty well.
What is that and what are you measuring and
how are you explaining that to clients?
We use the leading indicators
other than spend.
So, and we can, and we can talk through
those, but we use those other metrics,
everything that's available, CPM, CTR, cost
per click, thumb stop, everything up to
when someone buys the product, add to
cart rate, cost per add to cart.
We use those to justify why something got
spent or why it didn't get spent.
So 90% of the spend went to add
A and we had five ads.
Why do we think that happened?
The click through rate was 3% and all the
other ads had a click through
rate of 0.5%.
Okay.
That tells us something.
What was this?
What was the, what were
the other metrics?
Thumb stop, add to cart rate,
CPA and ROAS.
Were they good?
Yes.
Okay.
That's good.
That 3% click through rate was
logically relevant.
People were clicking on it for the right
reason or the same thing again.
All the spend went into add A.
It had a 3% click through rate and
the performance was awful.
Okay.
Why did it have that click through rate?
Oh, the first three seconds,
something happened.
You know, there was a dog.
There was something in it
that looked phallic.
I've seen that before.
Okay.
We should probably pause that,
pause that ad now.
And the other ads, two to five,
will then get spent.
So we'll use those to justify
why something got
spent or it didn't because clients
do not want to hear.
You spend five grand on these assets.
This one ad, it had a click through
rate of 5% and it spent $40.
Clients do not.
That doesn't, that doesn't communicate
trust from us as an agency.
Right.
Yeah.
Yeah.
That doesn't, that's not
going to go well.
I have a slightly different take, which is
I used to like, we can force spend into
it if you want, but we're not going to,
we wouldn't recommend doing that.
And it's just like, yes, you spend
five grand on the assets.
Would you like to spend an additional five
grand finding out they still don't work?
So it's like, I'm, I'm the arbiter
of your money.
I'm not making an opinion about whether
I like or don't like the creative.
I'm making an opinion about, will
this make you more money?
And I, if Meta doesn't think it will, I'm
inclined to think that they're
right most of the time.
But I, but what you said there is really important
is like, you can't just get us
to have all this money spent on the creative
and then do nothing with it.
I think back to the point about what people
who prefer ABO, their argument is,
well, it forces us to look at it and reconcile
why something did or didn't work.
Fine.
Um, what, what, what I'm not saying, what
you, what you said is like, we're going
to look at the, we're going to look at the
creative and we're going to look at the
metrics and we're going to
try to come up with
reasons why it didn't spend and
justification for it.
Cause that's super valuable.
Cause you can take, you can,
you can take the
analysis and do something with
that information.
So what I'm not saying is, nope,
sorry, it didn't work.
See ya.
Let me know what you got to do creative.
But we're saying is like, okay,
it didn't get spent.
If you want to force spend,
sure, we can do it.
We probably wouldn't recommend doing
that, but we can do it.
But here's some of the reasons
why it might not work.
If you compare it against other
ads in the ad account,
um, we, I will say we shy away
from the soft metrics.
We try not to lean into soft
metrics too much.
Cause I think that I personally just think
that they cause more confusion than
anything, um, in the way that
we communicate at least.
Um, but I think it's like the broader
point is like you
were trying to give reasons to why
something didn't work.
So there's actionable takeaways
with that, um,
whether or not it's, it's spent
or it didn't spend.
So I think we're, I think
we're getting to the
same conclusion just in that slightly
different paths.
I really liked the idea of benchmarks when
I've been training paid social execs
over the past couple of years, what I've been
trying to train them on is like, get
a, get a daily sense of what the benchmarks
are in your ad account.
And that just takes, that just takes looking
at the ad account every day, even
though you're not potentially
doing anything
every day, you're looking at the
ad account every day.
So you understand the benchmark
of every metric.
And then if every video that goes live has
a 20% thumb stop rate and you launch
some new ads with a different creator
and some different
hooks and it's, it's high production
versus low production.
You've never done that before.
And then all of a sudden the thumb stop
becomes 40% rather than 20%.
It's like, hold on, let's see
what happens here.
Because, you know, we, we, it's not very
often that performance dramatically
improves.
It's not a very often that you go from like
a $200 CPA down to a $50 CPA, you know,
doubling your thumb stop
could be a sign of
something that's really, that's
really big to happen.
Especially if you're making
a big jump when it
comes to the type of assets
that are going live.
We're not, we're not, we're not looking at
thumb stop every day, but again, it's
those benchmarks that, okay,
you know, what's a
benchmark click through rate
in this ad account?
Okay.
It's about, it's about 1% normally.
Okay.
Let's just make sure it stays
around there.
I mean, so let's talk about this.
So we're talking about, you know, to do creative
testing properly, recapping your,
you know, your, you're putting assets in a
CBO, potentially by product, if you're
able to do that or by funnel or by offer,
maybe if you've expanded that way.
There also, I think is this, you know, thought
about, look, what, but, but I love
an ABO because, you know, it's a
container that it keeps it in.
And, you know, I think it was Brad,
your meta rep, right?
Said something like outside of different
bids, targeting or exclusions.
It's a, it's just organization.
That's all that an ad set is, right?
We had two clients over a short
window of time,
basically say like, we want to try
forced spend into this.
And I said, I wouldn't recommend it.
And I gave, gave the logic, but it's like,
look, I'm comfortable doing it.
But I'm, I'm going to tell you that,
like, I don't, I don't
think it's the move, but if you want
to do it, let's do it.
So we did it.
And all we found was losers.
It's like, and like, we were
all making creative.
Like, it wasn't just like, it wasn't
like we were making shit ads.
Like they weren't, it's like, we were
all making a ton of ads.
And what, what happened is we just ended up
spending more into, into the worst ads
when we, and then you look
in the CBO and they
just, they weren't getting, they
weren't getting spent.
And that happened, that happened twice
where I tried the forced,
forced spend method.
And all I found was just force efficiency
across the board.
Or when we had something that
looked like a winner and
we dropped it in the CBO, it just
still didn't get spent.
Cause like, it was so contained in that
small, that small window.
And so, um, I messaged our
rep cause I was
just like, I need to know what's
going on here.
Cause I think the, the, the thought for a long
time was if I use, because targeting
is, is, is tinkered on, on an ad set level,
because I can put an interest, because
I can exclude people, because I can
do this on an ad set level.
And that has implications for learning.
The ad set is where the learning
is stored.
I think that's what the thought
was for a long time.
I thought this for a long time
until I saw a tweet from,
from Yoni, who I don't think he's
even on Twitter anymore.
I don't even know where that guy went.
He's, he's, he's in, he's in Canada
and he's awesome.
He's super helpful for meta.
Um, what happened is he probably
got a bunch of
DMs asking for people to get their
accounts unbanned.
And he's like, I'm out.
But I saw him say like, no, the, the
actual ads, it doesn't matter.
So I messaged our rep.
I said, does the ad set do anything?
Is there actual functional learning?
If I put two ads that are speaking to
completely different people
in the same ad set,
is that going to mess up my delivery
on an ad set level?
And his, his answer was no.
Like it makes no difference.
If you exclude people in
a different way, or
you, you set value-based rules
on that ad set level,
you can influence the way that
delivery happens.
But the ads themselves are delivering
independent of each other within
that to a degree,
like independence and extreme works.
Like if you have a video and
an image, the video
might drive more new, new, um,
visitors to the website.
But if you have completely
different personas
and an extreme example of this,
we have a client,
we had a client that sold
this like body wash
product and they had a, they had
a collab and we had, um,
creative for the girlfriend and
the creative for the mom.
And they delivered properly to those
segments within the same ad set.
And so I guess like the confirmation is like
the ad set is functionally a folder
outside of what you can do on
the ad set level to
influence targeting and bids
and things like that.
Now there's this feeling, you know, look,
you look at an account and every brand
owners here, you need to be
testing more creative.
You need to be trying more creative.
That's, you know, huge narrative that we're,
we're pushing as advertising agencies
and, you know, because it's true and it's,
it's needed in, in most cases.
So how do you think about type Phil?
Um, you've mentioned it previously
a little
bit, but like, you know, is
it creative diversity?
Uh, that you're just like, kind of like the
way that you're doing, like, look, you
need to, you know, develop personas and
then, you know, you need to be testing
video statics, need to be
testing partnership,
whitelisting, like, cause it's
a diverse set of ideas.
And, you know, within the same CBO, is it
kind of that mentality or like, how do
you determine a number or how much you should
test creatively in terms of type?
In terms of creative diversity across
type of asset, so formats.
Yeah.
I mean, like, how does it, how
do you determine that?
Or is it just like, I fricking
don't know.
We should have five videos, five statics
and five partnership ads.
You know, like, what do you, like,
what's the number and
like, how do you determine how much
you should be testing by type?
Because I think we've all seen that we're testing
down persona, but like what, what
by type is the, is the number
that makes sense?
Yeah.
Yeah. I mean, if you were starting, if you were
starting at scratch, so you didn't have
any data to start off with to tell you what
type of asset you should be launching,
I would be trying to be as equal
as possible within reason.
Probably gonna, you're probably gonna lean
more into images just because they're,
they're easier to, and cheaper to deliver
and quite, and quicker to deliver.
So, um, it could go, it could, it could go
50, 50, for example, 70, 70% statics,
30% video is probably a good
starting point.
That's not going to cause too many
issues for most brands.
So, um, where we try to strategically
do that
is when we look at percent
of spend per format.
And the only time we'll ever do that really
is when there's other, there's a reason
to invest into a format that we're
not currently spending on.
Like, uh, okay, video shows some promise.
We should be doing more.
We should be creating more videos.
If the data is showing this ad account
never works with videos and statics
absolutely crushing it, then we're not
really going to be revisiting that.
I'd say for a good year, you know, circle
back at Q4, for example.
Uh, so that's sort of like diversifying
across formats.
The, the second piece is, okay,
so when do you go into it?
Well, how do you go into videos?
And a, and a logical way is you test an
asset in statics, find some copy.
Okay.
How do we make that into a video?
You know, we've got a headline,
we've got a
couple of bullet points on
a static image ad.
Let's just get the founder
ripping a video,
face the camera, talking through
those points.
And that would be a very straightforward
way to start that.
Uh, you've got justification
from the static ad.
Got spend and it performed the static ad.
Let's turn it into a video.
Does it get spend again?
Um, and then we can get, we can get busy.
We can get nerdy.
Those different formats spend
in different placements.
That would be great.
You know, the static goes to more
Facebook feed, desktop.
The video goes to more Instagram
reels and stories.
Great.
We're, we're active across all placements
where audiences are.
The partnership ad is really, is really just
like all chips on black, to be honest,
because every time we test them,
it's all anyone,
I mean, it's all anyone's ever
banging on about.
Very rarely.
I don't think we've ever actually seen a brand
who's really invested in partnership
ads from a volume and time point of view,
where it hasn't turned out
to be a fruitful.
So it's worth, it's worth it to
you at this point in time.
As part of how you do creative testing.
Yeah.
But it does fail if you just try it
once and it doesn't work.
And then you stop.
I think that that's what you're
saying is like the volume.
It's like the time that they put in.
So they, they figured out who
is worth partnering
with, take the time to make
those relationships,
get the content, brief them
thoughtfully, and
then get it in the ad account
as a result of that.
All right.
Yeah.
Yeah.
Yeah.
So we're like where we want to get to the sort
of the, the, the destination that we
want to get to is where we've got new
partner content that we can
pull live every week.
And that could just be free for ads.
It doesn't need to be any more than that,
but we're doing it every week.
Like clockwork.
And it'll really compound over time.
I think it's good to bring
us to this segment
in the show where we call,
we call this beefs.
And this is a time to sort of
take out the trash.
If you have any, you know, I think my beef
with creative testing, you know, really
is that there's this idea that it has
to be scientifically done.
And you kind of mentioned this
previously, right?
And I think that's how we as marketers
were taught to think
and how we were brought up of, okay,
it has to make sense.
It has to be a clean test.
It has to be statistically significant,
et cetera, et cetera.
And the reality of it is meta is now serving,
whether it's an ABO or a CBO to
Brad's earlier point, they're serving it
to the proper audience, looking at the
content of the ad and the landing page
that it's being sent to.
So the more that you can consolidate and test
alongside things that are getting a
lot of spend, it doesn't feel like
that's the right thing to do.
But that ultimately is actually the right
thing to do in 2026, I think, for
creative testing and also diversifying
on persona
and the things we've talked
about, creative type.
But, you know, that's my beef is that it
has to be this like clean
scientific thing.
And it's like it doesn't.
It's actually like a lot simpler.
It's what Brad told me via DM last week.
Like, just fucking rip it.
That's like, you know, so
like, I don't know.
What do you guys any beefs on creative
testing or anything you guys
want to get into?
I would just say it feels like
when people start to
talk about creative testing, they
are in these camps.
And like, I'm cool with you
being in either camp.
But like most of the people end up
talking past each other.
Because like what we're talking about is
being thoughtful about the types of
creative that's going into
the ad account.
And then Phil, to your earlier points, like
spending more time on the things that
actually influence the ad account
performance, which is like
the analysis of the creative, the
partnership focus and ads.
And how do we get more of that?
How do we get more content?
How do we set up these systems?
How are we thinking about
the landing pages?
Is the ad to landing page to offer
consistent with the person?
It's like, if you set up creative testing
in a way where it's like you have a
system for getting it live and paying attention
to it and analyzing it, reviewing
it and doing something with it, then it
shouldn't be some like complex, crazy
system that, you know, is like so confusing
that you just don't do it.
But I guess my beef is like most people
are just talking past
each other when they argue about creative
testing structures.
Because like what we're all saying is, and
this is true of the, this is true of
cost caps, bid caps, lowest costs
argument as well.
It's like, well, all of all, most of us are
saying that generally know what they're
talking about is like, you should focus
on the things that actually move the
business forward, which is probably not the
nuance between a cost cap, a bid cap, a
lowest cost and all that dumb shit
that we argue about.
I've got tons of beefs. I'm quite a, I'm quite
a, I'm quite a mind mannered, happy
person, but yeah, I've got tons of beefs.
Specifically on creative testing, I think
my beef is on, we've moved away from how
much spend you've measured as a size of your,
you know, sort of, that's the wrong
thing to say, but you know, like your talent
level is how much spend you manage.
And now the thing to measure on
is how many assets you
launch. And there's always going to
be someone with a faster car.
There's always going to be someone who's
launching more ads than you. You know,
it's like, I launched 5,000
ads last month.
It's like, someone's going to
say a bigger number,
but we've, we've got, we've got
a brand at the moment.
I don't think we've launched an ad this
month, this year. I don't think we've
already launched any in January,
sorry, in December.
They're, they're growing massively, like 50%
year over year. They're like, I think
they're like, they did 20
million last year.
They're going to try and double
again this year.
They're spending like six,
7k a day in January.
They're a massive Q4 tax season brand, which
is obviously coming up. And it's
nothing, it's nothing that, that gets the
tactics and nothing that gets
engagement on Twitter.
It's everything but that.
That's not fun.
I mean, obviously the model is built, of course,
as we've talked about that, it's
like shock and awe, try to make people, you
know, feel like an idiot and feel like
they have FOMO and then like sell your product
and that you have all the answers.
You know, I think, yeah, it, it doesn't give
enough credit to the fact that most of
us are so busy on a daily basis running around
trying to just like keep the ship
running on the brand or
the agency or with
clients and bringing them
like good creative.
That's going to scale on a
regular basis that
like this other stuff on X is
like kind of a joke.
It's like, here's my seven step
process of how I, you
know, and you're like, all right, like
nobody's, it's not real.
It's just fake.
I have spoken to a couple of brand owners or
founders over the last couple of weeks
where they felt really guilty
because they're
not hitting this volume of ads
that's going live.
Because, you know, I've got to work
on some new creative.
I've got to work on some new creative and
instead of launching any, they're
just launching none.
And my recommendation was
always the same.
It's just like, forget about trying to
launch a certain number and
just work on one ad.
Yeah.
Don't, don't try and do four
with different hooks.
You know, we're going to test the hook.
And there's like Andrew was saying, you
know, there's this scientific test.
Just create one piece of content as if it
was going to be posted organically.
And instead of posting it to organic,
just upload it to the outcome.
Yeah.
I think it's great advice.
You just got to set up the system that
you'll be, it's like a, it's
like diet advice.
It's like pick the diet that you'll
be, you'll adhere to.
At least at first you can optimize from there,
but it's like, you got to at least,
you got to at least build them
to build the muscle.
Yeah.
Yeah.
The system is, is interesting.
With most.
Okay.
One more question makes me
think about this.
With most of the clients that you guys have
on creative testing, is there, like you
said in the system, is there an amount or
is there, is it, or is it just about
like, we need to get net new ideas
into the pipeline.
And if we're doing that on
a weekly basis, as
long as it's not more than
zero, we are okay.
How do you approach telling
clients about that?
So we've, we have a default starting point,
which is eight to 10 concepts a month.
And we certainly focus on the
number of concepts.
It's like the briefs.
Start with the number of briefs
that we've got to write.
Not to the clients then say, well, how many,
how many assets is that going to be?
And I try not to answer that, but it's usually
around five to six assets, five to
six assets, a brief to call that
40 to 50 assets a month.
And I think if you're being really intentional
about the briefs and the variation
between those assets in each
brief, then that
should be, that should be enough
for most brands.
We could, we could talk
about spend figure
where you might need to start doing more.
I think in most cases, if you're not doing
that, then that's a good starting point.
Yeah.
Was that, is that like the situation
you find yourself in?
It's like when you're doing these audits and
you're talking to these brands, it's
like, okay, you've launched three
things in the last month.
Like you don't, you just haven't,
you don't have the baseline.
So like our baseline is taking you away
above where you are today.
No, for most of them, they're
launching too many.
Really?
Yeah.
Like I ordered, ordered an account the
other day where, and I've
got the transcript.
So maybe I can like turn
the transcript into
like an AI piece and then
drop it in Foxwell.
Well, that's, that's quite helpful.
Usually it's use.
That's quite helpful usually to
get the sort of points
across, but they were launching
a new ad set every day.
Sure.
With new assets in.
And I'm like, when was the last time
you launched an ad that would?
I'm like, I don't know.
It's like, well, why are
you still doing it?
So.
Yeah.
They're trying to, I mean, I think
to some degree, right?
Like people in their brain want a system.
And I think that their ad sets are
a clean way to do that.
And that's what's also was
the predominant
knowledge and the prevailing knowledge
for a long time.
So you can't really like blame people
for, for thinking this way.
Um, because it's what makes sense to them
and it's what they're trying to do.
We're all trying to build a system.
The system is, yeah, I think
more of what you said.
It's around different concepts with briefs
and then, or, you know, different sort
of pitch towards different personas
and whatever.
And then we develop the ads around that.
And that makes sense.
So look, great episode, uh,
almost an hour.
Thank you to those of you that listened
all the way through.
And Phil, thank you for joining
us late night.
Hopefully you can get some good rest tonight
after now you're stoked after this.
You're just going to have
to go do a workout.
Brad, as always a pleasure.
And, uh, thank you for listening.
If you like what you hear, please
rate us on all of the
platforms because we are lonely
and need to know that.
We are validated by your votes.
So like, comment, share, whatever,
all that shit.
We appreciate it to the tens
of listeners out there.
And, uh, yeah, look forward to next time.
Adios.
This episode is brought to you by Brad's
company, Work Marketing.
If you need a D2C marketing agency, let
me tell you, Homestead is great,
but Work Marketing is also fantastic.
And let me tell you, you aren't
going to find
friendlier people out there, uh,
in the e-commerce space.
So we decided to do these little ads
for each other's companies.
So hopefully you find it interesting, but
seriously, great team at Work Marketing.
Very smart.
Brad and Jordan are incredibly dialed in.
Um, I just gave them a lead,
already made this
brand that I gave them, like,
I don't even know,
double, double revenue that they had in
the previous month or something.
So, you know, it's very exciting to,
to be connected with Brad.
And if you need a great agency, there's
really no one better.
Uh, Zach, anything to comment
on Work Marketing?
Yeah.
I mean, if you want an agency
that cares about your
business much more than they care
about their own website,
I just tried to load workmarketing.com
and it was broken.
So they're definitely going
to give more of
a shit about your business
than their own.
So I highly recommend Brad and
the team over at work.
They've been incredible.
We've referred a lot of business
over to them as well.
Really, really good as far
as like cracking
funnels and figuring out like
rapid growth for brands.
So I highly recommend these guys.
The only way that we grow this podcast is
by you sharing it with your friends.
Honestly, like reviews kind of don't really
mean anything too much anymore.
They're really meaningful, but they don't
do a lot for the growth of the podcast.
Um, and so sharing YouTube links,
sharing Spotify links,
sharing Apple, whatever we call
it under the podcast app.
Now, anything you can share, the
better we're going to be.
Guys, anything else you want
to say on this?
Yeah, please go check us out on YouTube.
Rack up those views for us.
We'd love to see it.
And then subscribe.
Make sure to subscribe on
YouTube as well.
And I relentlessly refresh
the YouTube comments
because it dictates my mental
health for the day.
So please say something nice
about all of us.
Thank you, everyone.
Thanks for listening.
Honestly.