Relationships aren’t supposed to be perfect—they’re supposed to be real. In this episode of Live On Purpose Radio, Dr. Paul sits down with Judy Herman, licensed therapist and author of Beyond Messy Relationships, to talk about why conflict and imperfection are not signs of failure, but invitations to deeper connection. Judy shares how traditional approaches to counseling sometimes over-pathologize couples, leaving them feeling more broken than healed, and offers a fresh perspective that normalizes the “messy” side of love. Together, they explore how authenticity, self-awareness, and healthy communication can transform even the toughest seasons of partnership. Whether you’re navigating a rough patch or simply want to strengthen your most important connections, this conversation will help you see your relationships with new eyes—full of possibility and hope.
Formerly Live On Purpose Radio.
Real psychology. Remarkable stories. A radically different way to live.
Think you know what positivity is? Think again. Pathological Positivity is a weekly podcast with psychologist and author Dr. Paul Jenkins. He challenges conventional thinking, explores the science of positivity, and talks with extraordinary people who put it into practice.
Each episode gives you one practical idea you can use the same day, from why you can stop waiting to feel motivated to how to stay positive through a hard week without pretending everything is fine. Episodes run about 15 to 30 minutes, and a new one comes out every Thursday.
Same show, same feed, same archive. Visit pathologicalpositivity.com to listen.
This is Live On Purpose Radio episode 668, Beyond Missy Relationships with Judy Herman. Now is the only time to create and live the life you love. I'm doctor Paul Jenkins, the positivity psychologist. My job is to connect you to powerful positive psychology principles that immediately upgrade your relationships, business, and mental health. Are you ready?
Let's jump in. Hello, everybody. Welcome back to Live on Purpose Radio. This is doctor Paul, the shrink, who expands your life with another episode of Live On Purpose Radio. Joining me on the mic today is my friend and associate, Judy Herman.
Now Judy is a counselor, a therapist, psychotherapist. She's been working with individuals and couples. She's also a speaker and an author. And you're probably already noticing some similarities because I came from the mental health industry myself. We've met through the National Speakers Association in a specific event that we both attended just a couple of weeks ago.
Welcome, Judy, to Live on Purpose Radio. Well, thank you so much. I'm very honored to be your guest, doctor Paul, and, this is amazing. I really resonate. I think we're, like, we are, kindred spirits in the work that we do.
I think so too. And that that became apparent fairly quickly as you and I had a chat at an event we were both attending in Miami just a couple of weeks ago, but before the recording of this episode. And I I shared with you a little bit about how how shall I put this? I left the tribe of traditional psychotherapy. And, unfortunately, and you can probably relate to this because in in the mental health industry, where you and I are both professionals, we are credentialed licensed professionals in the mental health industry, unfortunately, the times...
The term psychotherapy sounds a little like therapy for psychos. You're absolutely right. And that's unfortunate. Oh. Because the principles that we can dial into, you know, in our clinical practice, for example, are useful for anyone who's in a messy relationship.
Absolutely. Absolutely. That makes so much sense. Can I ask you this? What percentage of people do you think experience a messy relationship at some point?
You know what? I would say one hundred percent of us, if you're in any kind of a relationship and you're on this planet and you're a human being, you will experience messiness at seasons. Uh-huh. And it's a matter of, like, is this a toxic mess that we can't get out of, or is this a mess which is an invitation for a higher level of awareness and of growth? Yes.
Mhmm. And, of course, mental health professionals are immune from having messy relationships. We... Now you're chuckling again. Yes.
Absolutely. Because we're not immune. In fact, in your book, Judy, I've just, I've had an opportunity to read your book, Beyond Messy Relationships. This is a very authentic, very raw recounting of your own experiences. And and you are a professional in the mental health industry.
You counsel with people and provide therapy for their relationships. And here's my story. It's basically what you're saying here. You know, doctor Paul, when it gets to a point where you're sitting across from your clients and you're working with a couple or an individual and you think, oh my gosh. If they only knew how, like, my mess is so much worse than what they're going through.
That was a book that I couldn't not write. And you know what? We're human. We're human as mental health professionals in this industry just like everybody else. Well, a couple of weeks ago in Miami, when you had a chance to hear me speak and share some of the origin story from, you know, where these positivity models came from.
I I think I shared on the stage that day that positivity wasn't the plan. Mhmm. It was the lifeline. Yes. I needed it.
And I'm seeing that, you know, sometimes we feel like we're drowning in these messy relationships. And you used an acronym that I think is so appropriate that you you need air. You do. You definitely need air to breathe. You need air to live.
Right. Yes. And in the book, you've you've labeled that air. The letters in the word air stand for awareness. Mhmm.
It... Just becoming aware, more conscious, more present of what's going on here. Intentionality. Mhmm. Because where you wanna go with this matters.
Absolutely. And without intention, I think we get default. And then finally, risks. Mhmm. Which...
That one surprised me a little bit. Mhmm. But it makes total sense after reading your book. There... There's a risk involved at every stage of the process.
And if you, apply the awareness and the intentionality around the real risks that exist, then you can start to steer this thing in a direction that doesn't have to bring about misery. Because I I agree with you. I think a 100% of the humans on the planet are gonna run into messiness. Mhmm. In their generations.
Yes. At times. Right. Mhmm. It doesn't have to be the default.
A lot of us live in that default of that messiness based upon lack of awareness. Right. Right. And you and I both know and I'm sure your listeners do that the neuro pathways that are in our brains in which we show up with such automatic ways of relating and we all as humans move toward pleasure and away from pain. We've learned to do that even from childhood.
Right. And how we inadvertently take all of that into our adult relationships. And then according to imago therapy, which is what I'm certified in, Imago relationship therapy, Imago meaning image, like you you are attracted to the person and the brain is attracted to what's familiar. Our our subconscious agenda is to complete those gaps in our childhood. Whether we were traumatized outwardly or inwardly, we want to complete that in our adult relationships.
Yes. So raising our level of awareness is absolutely essential for that to happen. I think as we raise that awareness, it helps us to realize, at least for me, it does this, that this messiness... And I love that you used the word messy in your title because that's so real and relatable. We can all get there.
We realize that it's more normal than it is extraordinary. Everybody's going to experience this. And part of the process we see psychologically is that our brain is asking, why is this so messy? Mhmm. And the traditional way of looking at that is, well, somebody's broken.
Somebody's damaged or disordered or broken. And I'm not arguing with the fact that there are real mental health issues out there. In fact, you're very open about that in your book Mhmm. About some of the mental health issues that your husband experienced Mhmm. And what a challenge that was.
But I think I think where we sometimes go wrong in the industry is overpathologizing. And sometimes those traditional approaches to counseling can make couples feel like, you know, something's wrong with me or there's obviously something wrong with my spouse Mhmm. As opposed to reframing this in a way that is a little more productive and doesn't pathologize. Now I'm talking too much, so I'm going to just zip it to a minute and see what kind of responses you have to that. You're you're absolutely right because we, as mental health therapists, counselors, psychologists, We learn the Bible of our profession which is a diagnostic and statistical manual, which years ago it used to be rather thin and now it's really thick.
So you can... Like those... We we are trained to be looking for a diagnosis and then there's a bigger system of the insurance and being reimbursed. And there there can be like normal people that are coming to counseling because of their, you know, conflict that they can't get over communication wise or something. But but then we're in a system in which in order for us to get paid for this session, which, it's like it's craziness, isn't it?
Because then we keep the the people in the diagnosis and we are so much... We are humans going through a human journey. And I think you're absolutely right. And I I do know that there's some some that have said and neuroscience confirms that that where focus goes or where energy energy goes, focus flows. What is that saying?
Are you familiar with that?... That. Yeah. Where the energy flows, the focus goes or something. There you go.
Yeah. Like, when you're focusing on... And people do. They come to therapy because they're in pain. Now when I work with folks, number one, I don't see them in a therapy office anymore, and I do offer like nature experiences and packages and retreats because there's so much value in in nature.
So getting them... So I know you you exited the mental health field, but I'm kinda like... In a way I'm still in it, but I do not give diagnosable codes to people just saying. There... And then when folks come in and they're feeling so much pain, number one, we have so much...
We have a harsh critic in our head all the time anyway. And and if you've got the accusation coming from a spouse and and it's gotta be you, it's got... It's like, you know, just to get away from that, I I let couples know that, you know what? This is just a little tiny piece of the pie here, you know, that I'm seeing. And there's a bigger there's a bigger life that you have, and I know you all are awesome and amazing people with some tremendous strengths.
And just want you to know that you are valuable. And and, anyway, I think to, like, knock off the shame and the guilt, all of this that comes with having experienced the thing... The messiness that we're going through. Believe me, I know what it's like because of what I've been through that you... That I shared in my book as as well.
Right. Mhmm. Which is very real and and raw and authentic. Judy, I really appreciated that about your book because here you are, a licensed mental health professional, and displaying your humanness Mhmm. And the the human...
I think you called it the human journey or the human experience. Well, that's not that's not a billable diagnosis. You're absolutely right. You're absolutely right. We try to put people in boxes.
And even so, just to let your listeners know, my second marriage met my, dance partner. I knew he had bipolar disorder, he had been well for several years and I thought you know what I can handle this, but it was it was much bigger than and the marriage was not viable. But anyway, the catalyst for me to write the book in the first place was to break with reality. I had to, you know, so it was kind of like it was a book that I I had to write. I couldn't not write it.
And now looking back I'm thinking well the book really wrote me because there was so much transformation that I went through in my own way of thinking of the mental health system up close and personal and also clinically speaking. But when I wrote the book, I got to tell you, I I... Then I thought, oh, my clients are gonna read it and they're gonna say, and why are we seeing her as our therapist? Like, I was going through all of these shame issues, imposter syndrome, but it has caused me... I mean, it's every trauma I think that all of us go through, but especially, you know, in in my field here, it has been an invitation for more awareness, but it's been a transition too.
So, yeah, reinventing myself and thinking differently than I did, say, five years ago, ten years ago, which is what the human journey is all about. We There's there's value in it. There's purpose to the messiness. It's getting our attention. Our relationships are like mirrors to us.
What is it the the thing that... The conflict that's coming up often? What do we need to pay attention to? What are we not aware of? Because those are our blind spots.
Right. And the relationship show us that. You know, I'm I'm reflecting as you share that, Judy, on, an experience that I had with Michelle Villalobos. And it was Michelle's event where you and I met a few weeks ago. Mhmm.
And I remember in an earlier event that I attended that this is what landed for me. All diagnoses are broken, and some of them are useful. Now that was an interesting realization. Right? Interesting.
Yeah. I know there was a part in your book. In fact, I I, I dog eared this page because I wanted to come back to it. Where where you say, one of my pet peeves Mhmm. Is when I hear the phrase, he's bipolar or she's bipolar Mhmm.
Or he or she is not bipolar. Rather, they are persons of value and dignity just like any other human being with or without a disorder attached. Mhmm. And I'm I'm quoting that from your book because it grabbed me that sometimes we think that people actually have or are defined by a disorder. Mhmm.
Mhmm. But going back, if you will, with me to the DSM, k, the diagnostic and statistical manual, the Bible of psychiatry, where it... These are the disorders. Right? And Uh-huh.
That book... It's in its, like, fifth or sixth edition. I don't know. I lost track after number three. Right.
Because that's about when I left the tribe. And I stopped the... I have I have the fifth edition, by the way. So... You got five.
Okay. So it it keeps getting revised. Why? Because these are not real things. They're made up.
Mhmm. And they're made up by professionals in the mental health field who are trying to do their best to categorize the human experience. And that alone should tell us something. This isn't something you can have. It's someone's attempt to describe what you're experiencing.
I I absolutely love the work of doctor Gabor Mate, and I read his book recently. I don't know if you've read the myth of normal, a Canadian, psych... Or, psychiatrist and anyway, so yes, and since actually within well three years ago I went to India and it's got me to thinking of all of how dysfunctional here we in America are. I mean not that India is you know not dysfunctional, I'm sure a lot of I mean it's like a bigger dysfunction is what I'm saying rather than individuals, but we're in a culture, right, that categorizes and uses a DSM, whereas if you go to some indigenous cultures and someone who is had having a psychotic break, they have then the witnessing of a supportive community. They have, you know, a shaman or a guru that helps them through that and a lot of them do, you know, have these spiritual enlightenments.
But here in America, we we give them medication. We, you know, we label them. And we are so much more. We're humans having an experience. Mhmm.
I appreciate that someone in your position, Judy, is so sensitive to that and willing to push up against some of the traditional approaches, which might represent sell out. I mean, I think I think in in the world of psychology and and psychotherapy, there was a little bit of a sellout because it started as a very spiritual journey. Mhmm. Mhmm. And then it morphed, I think, so that we could somehow get a piece of the insurance dollars.
And and that's what I'm referring to as the sellout because I think I think that's unfortunate that it went there. But I've I've got another thing knocking on my brain. Can I ask you a different question? Absolutely. Absolutely.
This jumped out at me in your book, and, it's something I've thought quite a bit about. And you mentioned it a couple of times because the tradition... Now this is a little different topic, but it has everything to do with how we show up in relationships. The tradition is forgive and forget. Mhmm.
And you grabbed that, and you changed it. Yes. Yes. And I'm not even gonna reveal it. I'm gonna let you reveal it.
It's forgive and remember. We're not gonna forget. No. We're not gonna forget. We remember....
Stupid. Because, yes, forgiveness and letting go is not the same as reconciliation, especially if the thing that harmed you and the other person is not aware and continues to harm you, that that's crazy. That's craziness right there. Yes. So so it is not the same as reconciliation.
You're gonna forgive. You're gonna remember. Hopefully, you can reframe and whatever if you need to create some boundaries around that, but always keeping your heart open. Not, because there's only so much that we can hold. You know this, energy wise.
Our energy habits that we have, if it... If you're landing on the resentment and the unforgiveness and the depression and all of those things, you're not gonna have room in your heart for openness. So so forgiving and remembering, I think, are more more aligned with who are we kidding here? We can't really forget. You...
Right. And you shouldn't. Mhmm. Mhmm. Because in forgetting, it's like denying the value of the entire experience in the first place Mhmm.
And dooming you to repeat it. Absolutely. The body keeps the score. Right? The body keeps the score.
Yes. So our bodies remember whether we consciously are going to or not. That's why we get triggered. You know, while I was reading your book, Judy, and I came across that. And like I said, you mentioned it in a few different places in the book as a strategic, approach.
What are we going to do with the way we've been hurt, traumatized? And that's another thing that's universal, by the way. Trauma. Absolutely. Right?
Some people think, well, I'm a special case. I've had trauma. It's like We all have. Right? Welcome to the planet.
Right. Right. But I remember Hiram Smith. He's one of the cofounders of Franklin Covey who passed away maybe about a decade ago. And I heard him speak just a little while before he had passed.
It was one of the last presentations he had given here in my neck of the woods. And he talked about taking some veterans, World War two veterans, who fought in the Pacific Theater and taking them from The United States to Japan to have a meeting with other World War two veterans from that country. Mhmm. And these are old men at the time. And he described this scene whereas they're getting off there at an airfield.
I think it was a military airfield. And the Japanese, veterans were assembled there on... Under a tent or something. Anyway, they fly in in on this plane. And these old men at this point, some of them with walkers and other things, they get off of the plane, and they see each other for the first time.
These are the people they used to shoot at. Mhmm. Mhmm. And he wasn't sure what's gonna happen. In his mind, he's like, was this a good idea?
I don't know. Wow. But they looked at each other. They they acknowledged each other, and they closed the gap. They walked toward each other, paused as they came face to face, and then embraced.
Mhmm. Wow. And and that is such a powerful image in my mind because did they forget? No. No.
There's no way they could. It was a life altering experience. Two of my grandfathers fought in that conflict. Mhmm. They remember.
I promise. Mhmm. And in the remembering, they make a conscious choice to forgive and to say that is in the past now as they embrace each other. And what a powerful image that was that he shared with us. But that came to my mind, Judy, as I was reading your book.
What if we could forgive and remember? That's right. And we need to. And and and and and, like, being reunited with troops from the other side and and having a momentary embrace, you know, is gonna be different than living under the same roof with a person day in and day out. Right?
Those are different kinds of, forgiveness or remembering. Yes. And, so so it really does, like... Let me give you an example. So there was a whole lot of shame and and a lot of hurt and, not just one way.
I mean, you have to learn how to forgive yourself as well. So... But but it took me a long time because I would, like... So first marriage of thirty years and go to a family gathering and you just feel sucked up in this black hole even to be in the same space. But now through my journey, now with two marriages, forty years of marital experiences to two separate husbands, I tell people it's not at the same time.
But the first the first marriage of thirty the first marriage of thirty years, that was not a failure. No. That was an experience. Five grandchildren. The second marriage of ten years is rather a miracle that I could be married for ten years to to my loved one that had severe bipolar disorder, and so that's a that's a miracle too.
So in my opinion, I I've had two successful marriages both ended in divorce, but they I I... They both raised my level of awareness. If it weren't for those forty years and those two men, I wouldn't wanna live him over again. I'm just saying, but to bring me to a higher level of life, of awareness, higher level of growth, taking a risk of growth. I mean, it was a huge risk to write the book in the first place.
It was a huge risk to let go of my private practice that was successful. Right now in my soul, I realize, in other words, the narrative about the remembering has taken on a transformation in me. So then now I have then the room to keep my heart open to my four now grown adults who are now parents and my grandchildren. Like I don't have room in my heart to allow the resentment or unforgiveness to build, and and I don't wanna live there. So there you have it.
And it's a choice. Beautiful. Until we see it as a choice, it's not. Because choice ourselves because there's a whole lot that I wrote in my book in the early part of my life, and I'm thinking I have no choice. I have no choice.
That's the belief that we all... I think we think we don't have a choice, but that's because we're not on the other side of seeing the choices. Right? And it's, again, raising awareness, but we do have choices. Everyone has choices.
And I love that awareness is the first part of your ac... Acronym because awareness precedes choice. And that's when we can bring in intentionality and face those risks head on. Yes. Ah, beautiful.
Thank you, Judy. Again, the book is Beyond Messy Relationships. That's not the only book you're gonna find with Judy Herman. She's also got relationships with purpose, and she's doing some phenomenal things to push up against some of the traditional ways of looking at this that I think are so much healthier. And, so I would encourage you to connect with Judy.
Her website is judycounselor.com. And, what else can they find there, Judy, if they connect with you? So I work with heart centered professionals, and there is a heart centered check-in quiz that you can take. Who? So take that quiz, find out where you're at.
A lot of folks that come to me for for counseling are, like, getting out of the toxic pattern. They realize this is not helping and and and it's affecting them physically, and they've made a choice to get out. But they might think they're further along than they really are, but the the heart centered check-in is a great quiz you can take and just evaluate where you are. It's only for you. Like, nobody can take that quiz for you.
But take it and tune into your heart. See where you are in the process. Yeah. That... That's how you're gonna get your air because a stands for awareness.
So that will connect you. Judy, thank you so much for contributing today here at Live on Purpose Radio. What a delight to talk to you. My pleasure, doctor Paul. You're doing some amazing things.
You're a man after my own heart. You might have left the, industry suddenly, I don't know, fifteen years ago. My my leaving is, like, kinda gradual, I guess. Still, but I... Honestly, I do more I do more coaching than I do therapy.
Just saying. Yes. Well, I think that's part of the thing that brought us together. Absolutely. Alright, folks.
You've heard it. It's time to apply it. Let's go live on purpose. Did you get what you came for? Give yourself the gift of taking real action on what you realized today.
Please share this episode with someone you know would value it, and leave us a rating too. It's time now to live on purpose.