Subscribe
Share
Share
Embed
Northwestern's Ground Game Vanished With Chiles, and the Return Game Made It Worse
A weekly, unique recap show for each college football team that played a game. This unique look at what occured has a forward-looking approach and gets you what you need to know. For hardcore fans, casual onlookers and the gambler looking for an edge. Check out the Depth Dossier!
This is the Depth Dossier: the Northwestern Wildcats, Week 10.
Iowa left Ryan Field with a 24 to 10 win over Northwestern, and the story isn't really about the final score. It's about a running game that completely disappeared and a kickoff return that turned a fightback into a rout.
Northwestern lost its first home game of the season, and it happened without its starting quarterback. Aidan Chiles was out, so Nicco Marchiol made his first career start, and he actually played well, going 24 of 32 for 181 yards and no interceptions. The problem was everything around him. Iowa sacked him six times, held the running game to just 105 yards on 37 carries, and built a 14 to nothing halftime lead on two long scoring drives. Northwestern's defense did get a bright spot when safety Robert Fitzgerald picked off a pass, but it wasn't enough to slow Iowa down.
If you want the one play that decided this game, it's not complicated. Northwestern kicked a 45-yard field goal to cut the deficit to 14 to 3 late in the third quarter, its first points of the day and a real sign of life. Then Iowa's Braeden Jackson took the ensuing kickoff back 96 yards for a touchdown. In the time it takes to jog to the sideline, a one-score game became an 18-point game, and that was effectively the ballgame.
Third down was brutal. Northwestern converted just one of eleven attempts, and one of four on fourth down, a huge drop from how this team had been performing all season. A lot of that traces straight back to those six sacks, which kept putting the offense in long-yardage situations it couldn't escape.
The possession numbers are almost misleading. Northwestern actually held the ball for about 32 minutes to Iowa's 28, and had more first downs, 19 to 14. But Iowa still out-gained them, 288 yards to 265, and Northwestern averaged just three and a half yards per play. A team that had been averaging around 200 rushing yards a game managed only 105, and most of that came from Marchiol scrambling, not from the running backs. Komolafe and Himon combined for just 52 yards on 13 carries between them.
There were a couple of other things worth knowing. Griffin Wilde and Luke Dehnicke each caught five passes for 52 yards, solid production but nothing explosive. And defensive lineman Dominic Kirks got his first career sack, forcing a fumble that Braydon Brus recovered, a real positive buried in a lopsided score. A late touchdown pass from Marchiol to Himon avoided a shutout, but Iowa recovered the onside kick afterward.
Now, to the health and depth picture, because that's going to shape next week more than anything else. Chiles was ruled out before kickoff with an upper-body injury. He's been responsible for 23 touchdowns this season, so there's no bigger storyline right now than when he comes back, and there's no confirmed timeline yet. Until we hear otherwise, Marchiol is the starter, and based on this performance, that's not a bad fallback option.
Running back Komolafe appeared to get hurt early but stayed in the game, finishing with just 25 yards on seven carries. Nothing's been confirmed about his status beyond that, so his workload going forward is something to watch rather than assume.
On defense, Fitzgerald's return from injury was an unambiguous plus. His interception extended his streak to picks in four straight starts, and he looks like a difference-maker again in that secondary. And Kirks, with his sack and forced fumble, looks like a guy who should be pushing for a bigger role on the defensive line regardless of how this particular game ended.
So heading into next week, the biggest question isn't really about scheme or play-calling. It's about health: how long Northwestern is without Chiles, and whether that running game can rediscover itself with Marchiol under center in the meantime.
This was the depth dossier. For everything college football, be it depth charts, data or dossiers, head over to C F B Depth dot com. We will be back next week. This was an AI-generated podcast from content developed by real human beings passionate about college football.