How do you scale a subscription app with Meta ads?
Start with an offer whose value is obviously outsized for the price, then test the packaging rather than the product. Format Finder moved from a single $97 plan to $29, $59, and $97 tiers, and the single change that moved AOV the most was toggling annual billing on by default. Free trials failed outright because the cost to acquire a trial on Meta never backed out. Target customers with a need rather than a want, since need-driven buyers churn less and complain less, and turn your best users into your ad creators by paying them a percentage of the spend their ads carry. Scaling a subscription app with Meta ads comes down to the offer, the pricing packaging, and where the creative comes from. Brad Ploch and Zach Stuck sit down with Naveed, who went from affiliate marketing to a 45-person performance agency to an ecommerce brand to Format Finder, the app he built in three weeks and now runs at $20,000 to $25,000 a day in Meta ad spend. You'll learn how he builds an offer, the pricing tests that worked and the one that failed, the campaign structure behind the spend, and the creator flywheel that turns his own users into his best-performing ads.
We discuss:
- How to tell whether an offer is worth running before you spend a dollar - Why problem-solution fit matters more than unit economics at the start - The move from a single $97 plan to $29, $59, and $97 tiers, and why the free trial never backed out on Meta - The pricing change that moved AOV the most, and it was not the price - Why customers with a need churn less than customers with a want, and how a realtor funnel tested that theory - Why he runs one CBO split by geo, no ABO testing, and no interest targeting - The creator flywheel: users who hit a million views make his ads and take 5% of the spend those ads carry - What a one-click AI video editor actually costs to run, and how SaaS margins survive per-user API fees - How he runs the ad account, customer service, and product development through AI agents in Telegram and Slack - Why the harness around the model matters more than the model
Subscribe for a new episode every week.
Get the newsletter: https://www.scalabilityschool.com/scalability-newsletter Learn more: https://www.scalabilityschool.com Connect with Naveed https://x.com/navuud To connect with Andrew Foxwell send an email Andrew@foxwelldigital.com To connect with Brad Ploch send him a DM at https://x.com/brad_ploch To connect with Zach Stuck send him a DM at https://x.com/zachmstuck Learn more about the Foxwell Founders Community at https://foxwellfounders.com Learn more about the The Hive Haus Creators Community at http://HiveHausUGC.com
Scalability School is a weekly show from Andrew Foxwell, Brad Ploch, and Zach Stuck about what is actually working right now in DTC growth. No theory, no recycled LinkedIn takes, just the numbers and decisions behind real brands and real ad accounts.
Chapters
00:00 How to scale a subscription app with Meta ads 00:29 Meet Naveed: Switch Research to Format Finder 02:45 From affiliate marketing to a 45-person performance agency 04:06 Getting banned by Meta and what it exposed 05:45 Why the ecommerce inventory cycle burned him out 08:10 How One Peak turned viral videos into a course business 10:10 Building Format Finder in three weeks with AI 11:50 What the app does, from format quiz to finished cut 13:15 Why the offer is the biggest lever nobody talks about 16:18 How to price a subscription without killing conversion 19:15 The pricing change that moved AOV the most 19:55 Why customers with a need beat customers with a want 22:05 A word from Northbeam 23:20 Why your ad does the targeting, not your audience settings 24:45 Ad account structure: one CBO, no ABO testing 25:31 The creator flywheel: paying users 5% of ad spend 28:35 How the video editor cut churn and unlocked scale 29:35 SaaS margins when every user burns API tokens 32:50 Why the TAM for creator tools is enormous 37:50 Running ads, support, and dev through AI agents 42:00 Where to find Naveed
Scalability School is your cheat code for building a more profitable DTC brand or agency.
We break down tactical strategies, real-time wins, and tough lessons from three powerful perspectives: operator, agency, and community. It's not theory—it's what's actually working in the wild. Skip the fluff, steal what works, and scale with confidence.
1
thing.
I feel
my whole
history has been around
identifying a good offer,
that's from the affiliate days
where if I can't visualize or understand
the value
this provides to your who your customer
then you know, spending my own money
as an affiliate isn't going to make
So Everything.
Everything comes down to problem solution
And now let's take a
listen to the Scalability School podcast.
Welcome back to another episode
of the Scalability School podcast.
Zach's here.
Andrew's not.
And we have a very fun guest today
who I'll introduce in a second.
I feel like last time
Zach and I were left up
to our own devices,
I said something questionable
about not being here.
He's alive and well.
I think he's just cranking a webinar for
for Foxwell founders right now.
So he's he's doing great.
He's doing great.
It's just not he's just not here today.
But we are pumped to have Naveed here
with us
to talk through his journey
in from e-commerce
into what he's doing right now.
So I'll give you
give a little bit of background.
My experience with coming across
like your work
was with Switch
Research years ago, right?
So I followed you on Twitter,
saw the work that you're doing,
and then recently,
it's like every couple of months I see
we're at 100
and I see
we're at 4 million
AR and I see we're at 10 million RR.
I'm like, holy on.
Like we.
Yes, for sure, for sure, for sure.
But it's like the growth rate
looks looks incredible.
And I'm sure there's there's a ton
that we'll get into it that.
But I'll be honest,
like the thing that most impressed me
is the $2,000
a month you're spending on DoorDash.
So I want to start there
actually, like let's, let's,
let's get the go to DoorDash order.
Like what?
What are we buying? What are we buying?
How many meals a week is that?
Yeah, it might even be more than that.
We just don't cook.
Is is the key component there.
So my wife and I,
we've got kids
and almost every night it's something
whether it's like sushi for dinner or,
you know, snacks like 9:10 p.m.
because I'm usually up to like two,
3 a.m. grinding away.
And so I got to get that, like,
last minute 7-Eleven ordering.
That's that's respectable.
I, I had a pretty,
pretty gnarly stretch of thought myself.
I've toned it down a little bit,
but I'm the same way.
Like,
I just
I don't if I'm left to my own devices,
I'm probably not going to cook.
And I'd rather just, like, sit here
and then have food handed to me.
Just do that.
So, so so I get Cool.
Sweet.
Well, let's we can
we can jump into
some of the tactical stuff.
So I think like it would be great
to just get a little bit of background
and just kind of share the,
the 2 to 5 minute overview,
like background like okay.
How did you how did you get into E-Comm.
Maybe there's
maybe there's a story before you come
and we can get into.
But switch is my first
acknowledgment
into the work that you've been doing.
And we'll we'll work
all the way through Format Finder,
and then we'll dig into
some of the tactics from there.
Yeah.
So my background originally is affiliate
marketing started that
when I was like 20 years old.
First
affiliate network I ever worked with
was ads for Doe run by Jason Active
So I started off doing
affiliate marketing, got pretty good
at that, partnered
with my ex partner
at a performance marketing agency
that we had called straw House.
That's Jason Christy, and we were doing
the performance marketing
affiliate model
for a bunch of different clients
in the US.
One of the big ones was Golden Hippo.
Sure, you're familiar with them?
So we
we were on the scene
when they first started,
and they had Doctor Gundry
and Probiotic America
and all of those brands.
And so we drove a couple
hundred million dollars
in revenue for for them
on that affiliate commission type deal.
And then we brought on other clients
like Butcher Box.
We did a ton of volume for them
and very good butchers
and a bunch of other ones.
Giddy up. Worked with them a bunch.
And then after the well,
we ended up growing to
about 40, 45 people.
And at that point,
I mean, I was like 26 at the time.
And I was like, this is
this is like very dependent
on a few good clients that we have.
It's the affiliate model. Right.
And we were Canada's
biggest video advertiser
at the time for meta.
And they were they were loving us.
They were flying us to Toronto.
And then like two weeks later,
they just like randomly banned our
ad accounts because they were like, oh,
no more, no more golden hippo type stuff.
We loved you last week.
This week you're off.
You're off the platform.
We ended up getting our accounts back,
but it was kind of like a
it kind of showed
how much of a straw house
the company actually was built on,
the type of performance
marketing that we were doing.
And and just like
the model itself is being like,
you need to have those,
those that arbitrage working
between what you're getting paid out
and what you're spending on that,
that CPA on meta.
What year was this one was
this was like 2013 to 2016,
I want to say okay. So early. Got it.
Yeah. Yeah.
You guys were early. All right. Cool.
Keep rolling on that. And then,
so we got
kicked off the meta for a little bit
and then got back on.
I was kind of feeling the stress of like,
having 40 employees
and only having a few campaigns working
and it being like, oh,
you know, our monthly net is like two,
300 grand
and we can do this
with a team of like five people.
So I ended up
selling my shares
to my ex business partner there.
I was like,
I'm kind of I'm kind of done with this.
We did pretty well with it.
I want to take a break, got married,
decided to have a few kids,
and then, well, we had our first kid.
And then for my second kid,
we had a bunch of trouble
with that, unfortunately.
And it kind of that's the word
like propelled
the idea of switch research
or started the journey of getting into
building this mental
health journaling brand
because my wife ended up,
you know,
we're lucky
we had access to a therapist for her
for for what she went through.
And,
and journaling
was a big part of her journey of,
you know, dealing with
it was it was miscarriages at the time.
And so we decided to
to build out this, this brand
where we work with therapists, develop
these mental health journals
and then sell them through ecom.
And that did really well.
But there were a lot of ups
and downs
where we would get a campaign working.
My thing was meta, like,
I know how to advertise on meta,
I know how to build those performance
marketing style direct
response campaigns, and we would get you
it working really well.
And then I would order 30, 40,000, 40,000
units of inventory,
and then it would fall off a cliff.
And this was like a cycle
that happened for three years
where making a profit
run out of inventory,
have to order a shit ton of inventory.
I'm sure you guys know.
Yeah, yeah.
And so that was the kind of like
I just got bored of it to some degree
where I'm like,
we keep going through this cycle
and unless I make a change and snowshoe
some of that risk across
different channels or some organic,
it's just going to be a cycle
that keeps repeating.
Or I would need to be better at
outsourcing the generation of funnels
and, and,
and the actual
ad campaigns that end up performing.
What did the team look like?
Like up until.
I'd be curious if you like. Don't mind.
Feel free to keep going,
but I'd love to hear, like,
what the team looked like at switch,
because I know you're kind of like a
a solo operator to some degree.
And I want to know,
like how Big switch
actually turned into
and tell us about that.
It did like mid
like 5 to 9 million in revenue
per year for about four years.
And the team was like me
on all the marketing,
one person
doing some organic and social,
a customer service agent
and then a business partner on that
who is handling
all of the inventory,
the product development side.
So, so very similar
to like with straw House
where I was the marketer
and my business partner
is the one who's either
bringing in the product,
developing the product,
or bringing in the business
doing the business.
So pretty small.
Yeah. Pretty small team. Yeah. Cool.
Keep the inventory.
Yeah. Totally.
Keep keep rolling up okay.
So we're they're getting bored.
That's rich.
And then I start working with
some friends in town.
One peak creative.
They did
like they blew up their
just a video agency at the time.
And they blew up on Instagram
during Covid.
They did some like ad solution
is what they called it, where every week
they would create a video
that goes or create
an ad for a random company
and then ended up going viral.
So like every week it would go viral too.
So they did really well,
but they got like what they did
one for Ryan Reynolds
Gin Brandish or Whiskey or whatever.
It was.
Vodka, I can't remember.
And then he ended up.
Yeah, yeah, that's right.
He ended up commenting
and reposting it and shit,
and that kind of
made them blow up a bit more.
And then they decided to launch a course,
and I,
I was always talking with them,
providing some guidance around
like how to create an offer
that you can sell through meta ads.
So they created this course on
how to go viral on TikTok and Instagram.
And, and I just ran the ads for them.
Kind of like
as a percentage of spend type deal
doing it for my friends.
And we, we
we ended up scaling that to 20 to 30 K
and add spend.
And it's a course
which I love the digital products.
You don't have inventory.
So I'm like, yes, this is amazing.
Is that like that or a day
like what are you talking 2030?
K sorry, sorry a day.
That's what we scaled that course up
to 2030, 20 to 30 day
and spend very profitable too
which is amazing.
And then they introduced
a high ticket item
and then so that we've been doing that
and I was doing the media buying
for that up until January of this year
where I started.
Well, December,
I started playing around with Claude
and obviously all of the vibe
coding tools
that came out around that time,
as everyone did.
And then that's when like grind season
kind of hit.
I think for a lot of people
where you could see
the capability of these models
being able to actually create, bring,
bring your vision of whatever app or idea
you had to life.
They're very capable.
So anyway, I approached
one peak
and I was like, hey,
let me make an app for this.
We have
we have all the methodology
around helping somebody go
viral on TikTok and Instagram.
We have these 62 or 64 different formats
that are part of the kind of like the IP
that we've generated over time
that are proven to go viral
for different niches.
So let me take a crack
at turning this into an app,
and then took me about
three weeks to develop,
like the bare bones
for what format finder is right now.
Through
just working
with Claude and Codex
and Terminal, that kind of thing.
And then and then we just decided
that we, we,
we would run it as an upsell
to the course business.
That was like the first test
to see how well it would do
and if there was any reception for it
from the audience.
And it did really well
as a as an upsell.
And that was like introduce
this recurring revenue
because it was a monthly subscription.
And then
and then
we just started
transferring everything to that.
So now I'm an equal partner in
we just turned it into one peak software,
and it holds all of the IP, all of the
the entire everything is the app now.
So all of the courses exist in the app.
Everything is subscription based.
And then the app itself.
So it aims to provide creators
with everything they need to go viral.
So you would put it in your niche.
It identifies what format of the 62
you should probably try.
And that could be like a challenge,
a skit, you know,
a knowledge gap
type format,
and you play this little taste game.
It identifies the format for you.
And then from there with that format,
you can generate ideas, hooks,
save your ideas and hooks.
It'll generate the script for you,
tell you how, the shop
plan, how to film it.
Once you're done filming it.
We have a one click video
editor in the platform
where you drop in all the footage and
it'll use the transcript
from all of the footage you've
you've put in there.
Identify kind of like the best hook,
the best body
payoff, all that,
and it'll cut together
your video for you.
And if you have been added in as well,
it'll add that in.
And then you can export that video
and you can put it through our
analyze feature,
which does something similar.
But it
it does take frames from the clip
to identify
the visuals, the lighting, all that.
And it'll give you kind of
a bit of a score around
what you can do better
or if it's ready to post.
And at this point, it's
really good at identifying
because we've just been able to
train it on,
like what videos do
we now
have actually from our
from our subscriber base
have actually gone viral.
So it'll be able to identify
pretty well
whether something is going to flop
or do really well.
But in the in-between of like
whether you're going to get 100
K views
or 50 or 400
like that is a bit more nuanced
and it's hard to predict that,
but it's something we're working on.
So anyway,
there's this
this whole flywheel in there,
plus all the courses. Yeah.
That's crazy.
I have a I wrote down a note
I want to go back to.
It's something you said early on in
that story,
which was kind of helping
the one team develop
an offer around that.
And I feel like that's a it's
kind of like a slept on topic in general.
Like every talking about last year
or two years ago,
I was like creative and creative volume.
I feel like the wave this year
in like the last seven podcast episodes,
we don't have been about landing pages,
but like an offer
like is
probably the biggest like
could be one of the biggest levers
out of those three.
And it probably has the least discussion
because it's
probably the hardest to crack.
Is there like a process
that you went through
in order to develop that?
I mean,
I'm sure you had something similar
in the affiliate days, but like,
how did you even get to that?
That's the thing.
I feel like my whole
history has been around
identifying a good offer,
and that's from the affiliate days
where if I can't visualize or understand
the value
this provides to your
who your customer is, then you know,
spending my own money as an affiliate
isn't going to make sense.
So what problem?
Everything.
Everything comes down to problem
solution for me and my history.
So like what problem I started
solving is a very clear.
And then is the offer that you're,
you're providing
outsized in the value for the cost.
And then it just comes down to
the marketing.
How well can you how well can you.
What's the word like a
display the problem?
Or,
you know, create
the emotional need in the user for
or meet them where they're at to,
you know,
are they aware of the problem
or are you trying to
create that awareness in them
and then provide your product
as the solution or for
does it kind of sell itself,
which some products do
where, like how to go viral
on TikTok and Instagram?
It's pretty obvious to the user
why they want to do that.
They can like add in their own personal
kind of like journey in there
on their own.
Whereas if you're selling something that
where you have to actually introduce
the problem,
like getting up
in the middle of the night
to P9 times and then introduce
your your offer
as the best solution for that. Yeah.
Is there a
is there a like
so when you
when you're describing the offer to me
it sounds like it's not actually
maybe not primarily about the actual
like unit economics of it,
which I think that's a
that's a part of it for sure.
But you're actually kind of talking
about the entire package,
which is like the offer itself,
which is you
kind of led with was going
viral on TikTok like that.
Is that the is that the offer
or like how how do you break those down.
Yeah.
So for me I would say like
the offer.
It's like the keystone of it is the,
the need, the desire,
the the value that you're providing.
And then and then the unit economics
because you can
you can change that over what?
You change all of it over time.
But that's something that typically
we need to split
test, identify like adjust.
It's like once we so for for one peak
you know we developed the
the offer go go viral the landing page.
And then we did a bunch of split
testing around price point.
You know is this like a 2.99.
Because it also depends on the platform
you're running on.
How much is it going to cost
to acquire a customer
and how good are your ads.
And so do
we want to have this like a $299 one time
fee for this course,
or is it going to be
a monthly subscription? Do we?
And we started off
with like monthly subscription.
I think it was like 97.
And then we realized, oh,
if we give them 40% off
the unit economics based on the CPA,
we end up making way more money.
You know,
our conversion rate will be much higher.
AOV, it ends up being lower.
But net net
we make more profit
and then we can scale more.
So
a lot of that comes down to testing.
Yeah.
And the creativity
I guess in in coming up with those ideas
when you guys.
So when you guys were setting prices
for this, I'm curious like
did you just play with that a bit
or like how
how much of the actual price of
format finder you guys mess with?
So Format Finder itself, definitely.
We started off with that
like 97 price point,
and we even started off
with like
a first month 58 and then 97 every month
after that.
And I think I started spending a couple
thousand dollars a day to that.
It was payback period was like month two.
But then we we decided to test
no, no, no.
After we did that,
we got a bunch of feedback from users
and we waited a bit,
so I didn't scale it.
I kept it at around like that.
I think that like two to 5KA day
because we wanted to see,
you know, where's turn going to come at.
And then there was a huge cliff for churn
when they hit that 97 renewal point.
And then a lot of people were like,
oh, I didn't realize it was actually 97.
So and we bolted on
a bunch of new features
and decided to try like the three tiers,
which is more typical to a SaaS model.
So it's like we came from the course
where it was 58
and we're like,
okay, let's let's go with the tears.
So 29 is starter package.
And then I even tried Free
Trial and that sucked for us
when it came to
like the cost to acquire a customer
on Facebook was still really high
for the free trial.
And then it just didn't back out. Sure.
But having that that 29.99 starter
price, 59 and then 97
ended up being in our split test,
kind of what worked best.
And the
the actual thing that move the needle
the most surprisingly, was
toggling annual by default.
Yeah, I was just looking at that.
I would literally didn't even realize
that this was annual pricing at first.
So yeah, yeah,
yeah, that's super interesting.
Yeah. Super interesting.
So that that,
that had a huge impact on our AOV.
And now like we don't
we don't get many complaints
I guess the customer service.
So people doing by accident.
But yeah I think like
again
these individuals that
are trying to go viral on TikTok
or Instagram or whatever, right,
like to spend $300 with, with their
hope to make,
you know, hopefully,
you know,
six figures doing this as a career.
It's not that crazy
in the scheme of things.
If it's the if it's the right tool.
So that is really smart.
I wouldn't have thought that that
like I went to the said like,
oh it's immediately toggle annual.
But yeah super cool.
Yeah.
And that's where we have found
that our best customers are
the ones who have a need
for the product as opposed to like
just a want, if that makes sense.
So like
an example of this would be Realtors.
People don't own a business.
People who want to be a business.
Does that make sense?
Like you want to be
like a health influencer
and that'll be like your business
where you have your personal
training clients come in or whatever,
versus like the,
you know, the woo woo spiritual.
I want to talk about meditation.
Worst customers who like
most customer service requests from them,
most complaints.
And I'm sure this applies everywhere,
but it's just like it's
something that we realized
about a month ago that, like,
we need to really go after
the ones who have a need for this.
Because for them, spending
this much per month is nothing like it
for for the value that they're getting.
And then also they will move
into the high ticket item,
which is like
a $4,000 community with coaches.
It's more hands on.
So we have that in the back end.
And then that's like
the only upsell that we have right now,
which is sign up for that masterclass.
Nice. Okay.
So I was going to say
you stopped running ads in California
is what you're trying to say.
Yeah.
No, no I'm just I'm just go it.
Go for it.
I was
I was going to get to the realtor thing
because like I was
looking at the attic count
and it looks like that realtor
funnel is relatively new,
but it makes sense, right?
Because like,
they sell one more house
and they paid for the software for six,
seven years, maybe, maybe more than that.
It's like it's like a no brainer.
Okay,
so maybe a couple questions around that.
It sounds like you.
It was pretty obvious to identify
because like,
they just didn't complain as much
and their turn wasn't as high.
Are you doing anything?
I want to come back
to that upsell thing too.
But are you doing anything inside of meta
that's like
unique structure wise for the realtors,
like creative for them.
Landers for them is. Yes.
Are you like anything crazy
with the pixel
like optimizing for those people
qualified leads not qualified
All right, friends, quick break.
This episode is brought to you
by North Beam,
the marketing attribution platform
that we love over here
at Scalability School.
If you're a marketer,
I mean, you probably agree, right?
Incremental testing is broken.
They were.
These tests
require tons of labor
spreadsheets to reference,
and the designing of the test
is slow and error prone.
How are you supposed to know
what to test in the first place?
Right.
There's a million factors
that can make incremental
testing difficult.
But the good news is North
Beam has completely changed the game,
and they fix this.
Only North Beam
incrementally automates
your incremental test
design and monitoring,
while protecting you
from the major mistakes
that plague incremental testing.
North beam builds tests
using your own MTA data,
launches them directly
in ad platforms,
and automatically
monitors them throughout.
If something threatens validity,
you're alerted before
it ruins the result.
With North Beam,
you can launch tests in platform
with a single click,
saving you tons of time
and reducing any chance for errors.
And when the
test concludes, your results
flow straight into your MTA,
meaning you can easily
see results
alongside the rest of your data.
Incrementally. Was broken.
North beam fixed Yeah.
So that's like a
that's a small split test.
So like right now
we are spending like 2020 5KA day
us on on ads in that in that ad account
and the that realtor funnel.
It was at like 500 a day.
It was just a small test.
And it's about breakeven.
It's not doing better
than the rest of the funnel
or like the general population stuff.
And it's
like it seems like it's because
when obviously
we target realtors in the copy,
look,
I don't do any interest targeting
or anything like that.
I'm like,
I'm a believer that your ad
does the targeting.
So talking about realtors in the ad media
puts it in front of realtors.
But what we've noticed
is like
obviously the cost
per click for those users is a lot higher
because of the type of person they are.
And the conversion rate
with that quiz funnel isn't high enough
to support the increased cost
to get them there.
So
it ends up being at this point where that
the general funnel that we're leading
people to is doing better.
I do still want to
explore the quiz funnel
as like a method.
I think I can get that working,
but it's just
it's just a small test right now,
like off the side
and then in the account.
Sorry. Go ahead. No. Go ahead, go ahead.
No, I was just gonna say
in the ad account itself,
I just, I just run CBOs
that are split up by by the location.
So like, a US only CBO
and then the other two are just, like,
tier one, English speaking, and then a
tier two,
whatever, but
everything gets it's
I don't like
I used to do the, the abo
where you would test in your Abo first
and then throw it into the CBO
and performance that are winning.
But at this point,
I just throw everything into
the one CBO campaign
and just let it compete in there
against everything else.
We do have a pretty cool flywheel
right now
for generating ad content,
and so we are getting a ton more, more
ad content from our user base
and then using it in there.
Yeah, that's nice
because it's like it's
baked into its baked into the product.
It's like they're making I'm
making
they're making content
as a result of that,
of using the product.
Or you're like actually
just reaching out to them
on top of that and saying like, hey,
what were your results?
What does the flywheel look like?
Yeah, I'm so stoked on this
because it's working so well.
So when somebody in the platform
gets like a million views or more,
we'll reach out to them
and we'll be like, hey,
do you want to be part of
like, the UGC creator?
Product, like Pro or whatever?
Yeah, program we have and
we give them the formats
that are working for us in ads.
So the script, everything that's working,
and they'll send us back the footage
and we give them 5% of ad spend.
So they're incentivized that way.
And so the first one
we tested the beginning of last week
and she heard it was Becca.
She had a view, a video
that got 20 million views
using our platform. So we reached out.
She made the content,
we cut it up using our app and
and then we
and it's now getting like 16 k a day
worth of spend all of our ads.
And so this is like great for her
and for me.
I'm like sure 5% of ad spend
like I'm
the one managing the ads right now.
It doesn't matter.
That's like for ads that are crushing.
And the CPA is like
30% lower than what
we were seeing on everything else.
So yeah, it's
you're painter like 25 grand a month
if that,
if that holds at like 15 K,
which is like no joke for,
for a content creator
for making one banger ad for you.
So yeah, that's super cool.
That's super cool.
But now it's like,
since then
we've had like two other creators
submit their own content,
and so now they're all like
in the platform fighting for the spend.
That's like the best though.
Like, are you going to like,
they know about each other and like,
what's going on?
Like you're going
to throw them in a group chat
and make them make them competitive or
keep it separate for now.
And I'm wondering
if we want to keep it
like limited to ten spots or something.
It has something we might do.
I don't know, it
depends on on how much it scales.
Yeah, well, it's like everybody's
I know, like
tribe is getting a lot of momentum
right now
because like tribe enables
the TikTok shop of occasion
of of meta content. Like.
And it sounds like you kind of
have the same thing, but yeah,
it's like you, you don't want to.
It's a balance
between getting a bunch of new creators,
and then all of a sudden
you're out of count, like, yeah,
you net increase spend.
But maybe they feel like I'm earning
less as a percentage
because mine don't spend as much.
But it's like,
I don't know,
just keep making bangers and then,
you know, you keep earning.
Yeah, exactly.
Yeah. That's sick.
So they sounds like there's like a couple
there's a couple of like things
that made like
Sep function changes and like,
I've tweeted at least three times
about like RR roughly is there.
So it sounds like
a couple of those
were offer to a degree
and like the annual switch
and then the
the creator flywheel is like recently
it sounds like it's cranking.
Is there anything else that you did
like any landing page wins.
Any any other adjustments
you've made
that made a step function change?
Well, one of the big ones is like
there's more on the product side.
I would say
it's when we launched the video editor.
So a lot of it was product feedback.
For the first few months,
I was doing all of the customer service,
and so I was able to see
what people wanted in the app and
what they wanted out of a tool like this.
And so being able to reduce churn
by providing that outsized value
with the product itself
has been a huge lever
for us being able to scale ads.
That's that's why one of the biggest ones
I'm I'm super curious on this.
Like,
I don't understand pricing of like SaaS
and then pricing of like AI usage.
Like I'm kind of an idiot
when it comes to like all this stuff,
so bear with me.
But like,
I don't understand how you could do
like, one
click editor
for a customer and like,
still have margin
plus a catch on like $15 a month.
Like there's got to be
something really interesting
that you guys are doing on
like the back end
to think about like usage
and all this other stuff too,
that then like contributes
to the profitability of the business.
Like,
can you talk about that
a little bit like,
I don't know how much you want
to share on that or not know for sure.
Yeah it's fine. Yeah.
Like I'm super curious because like,
that's the math
that I was doing in my head
as we were kind of running through this
and I'm like,
I just don't understand how this works.
So yeah,
just give us like the quick TLDR of that.
Yeah.
So in terms of the actual cost
to run the app.
So like let's say let's take like
the average user maybe spends
spends like 5 to $10 a month in actual
API fees.
But the,
the key to the model is similar to
I think what like anthropic is doing
where they're subsidizing the tokens,
where some users or power users,
they're hitting their limits every day,
their five hour limit,
their weekly limit, whatever it is.
And they might be not worth the $280
a month cost it is or whatever. Sure.
But because of the number of users
who aren't those power users,
it just it averages out.
Yeah.
So for us, you know, our actual margin is
is pretty good in that like 90%.
Yeah. Got it. Cool. Yeah.
API fees
and like the one called editor itself
that's like the cheapest
because it just uses like,
you know,
just has to look at a few frames.
So a vision model there and then it also
just transcribes, which is pretty cheap
because it was just like the transcript.
Did that make
a big difference on retention?
Because it's like people
were able to film the content,
but it's like, okay,
I'm going to take seven hours
to edit this fucking thing. Now.
I can't even get a live to see.
What it does like.
Is that, is that like,
is it as simple as that?
Yeah, it is, but it's also like
I'm
we have to curb expectations
with people now a bit
because they'll dump their whole camera
roll in there
and, and be like, make me a banger.
And then they'll complain when it's like,
there's no, there's no like,
this is all B-roll.
You have no, like, coherent story
or video or hook
or anything that you've done with this
at this like, yet.
And so it just comes down to us
educating the person.
So we're taking steps in that regard.
Overall, the turn though
is, is at a place where, you know,
our payback
period is like within two months and then
everything after that is, is profit.
And so like
right now we are profitable overall.
And then that's just
where like it's a business decision
at this point where we're like,
what are we even building here?
Are we building something like
do we get investors like what do we do?
I don't know
if you guys have an answer to that.
I, I'm all ears. Like,
yeah, we run at a
loss to just try to like,
get the revenue numbers, revenue
multiple to sell this thing. Yeah.
I mean it feels like
I mean, if you even looked up the amount
like how big your Tam
of your customer list
is, like, it's anyone that has north of.
I mean, like,
even if you just looked up
anyone north of 10,000 followers
on on the platforms,
it's like any one of those people
to a certain degree
could be a customer of yours.
So it's got to be like huge.
Like, have you done
any research on Tam of like,
how many customers
you think that this is even possible?
Like,
I think there's thoughts like that
that I have
that I'm like,
it's so interesting
because it's like, okay,
this could be useful
for like you said, realtors,
this could be useful for people
that make UGC content.
This could be useful
for like
the gamut of creators is massive.
So I don't know.
I think that's that's
the thing
that is really exciting about it to me.
Yeah. No. Me too.
Because I do think
the Tam is absolutely enormous worldwide.
This is like
everybody wants to be a creator,
whether it's for like
the notoriety,
the ego boost
or to actually make money that way.
And so if we can
make that process easier in any way,
that's like,
that's why
I can't sleep at night right now.
Like I slept like in like five months
since January. Yeah.
I feel like the most interesting thing
is, like,
how good you can get that video
editor to be because it's like scripts
I think are pretty,
like scripts are getting better
and I think
is doing a good job with that.
I think knowing the formats of
what can go viral,
you guys
obviously like one peak is done
a very good job of of identifying those.
But like getting that editor to
to actually produce bangers
with like as little context as possible.
Like that is where I think the source is.
Because why would you
not use a tool like this then?
Yeah. Yeah.
And even getting
at like
90% of the way there
and only having the tools in there
that somebody would need
for creating content to go viral,
it's like not creating,
you know, landscape footage
for some other use case,
like a commercial or something.
But like
everything in their built around
creators is something that I feel like,
let's say Cap Cut or Canva.
You know,
they're they're they're speaking
to such
wide use cases that to adjust their app
for this specific use case.
I think we have like some time here
to develop this and really get it good.
Yeah.
And so that's my focus.
I'm like the
I went
I'm speedrunning the path
to becoming a developer here.
Yeah I'm like the sole developer on this
app right now.
Yeah it's crazy proud of me.
You've got more questions in here.
Yeah.
So is there I
this was one of the questions
I asked you on Twitter.
Like I was just curious,
like generally speaking.
So we talked about like,
real estate agents is obvious
because it's like, yes, I'll sell
literally anything.
And you've paid for this for a long time.
It's like anybody
making business content,
some people are just trying to generate
ad revenue.
But like UGC creators,
people are making content
for people like us
that are trying to run up e-com ad spend.
It's like,
is that, you know,
is that cohort like,
are you thinking about
expanding the product out
towards those type of people?
Or like, it's
not even worth at this point
because what you have is already
a big enough Tam
and you want to master that.
It is. It's just not
it's not a big focus.
Like it'll happen for sure.
Like,
personally,
I've thrown put ads into the platform,
the auto cut feature, and it works like
you can definitely use it for.
UGC there's no reason you can't,
and a lot of the people
who are using the app,
are you actually using it
for that purpose to like
they're like agency style businesses
who are using it for their own clients.
And it is like it's the next thing on
my list
is creating that,
like higher tier in the app
where somebody can have,
you know,
the different clients that they have,
like more of the agency focus.
And then from there
we'll just do the same flywheel where
when we get somebody get
get a good case
study,
we'll just get them
to make the ad for us.
Yeah, right.
What is I'm bouncing around here
because I just remembered
that I had this question.
You have that the,
like the high ticket offer
on the back end.
So it's twofold.
One like is there
is there an additional high ticket offer
because like it sounds like it was
a it's a it's a group
and like coaching type of thing,
but maybe not like a done for you
which is maybe what one peak
had previously done.
Is there
like another expansion to that
and then like
is that really meaningful for LTV?
Like, does it take great high enough that
that's like unlocking
quite a bit
or you're just
that's like
it's gravy on top of everything else?
Yeah, I kind of treat it as gravy.
I don't calculate anything based on it
based on it at this point. But it does.
It does convert pretty well
and it adds like 10
to 15% to the LTV overall.
Across all across all customers.
But yeah it is.
Yeah.
It's the it's the it's 4K
I think for for a four month program
they get access to the community.
They get access to coaches who like
look at their videos,
tell them what they can do
differently, group coaching calls.
And then we are thinking about like
higher ticket.
the.
Yeah.
Cool, man. Sweet.
This is awesome.
I know you could probably continue
to go for a long time.
Like we didn't even
we didn't really even get into like,
the AI piece of it at all.
I think it was crazy.
You know, you have AI like your AI.
AI building.
I'm not giving you enough credit
when I say this,
so don't take this the wrong way.
But like AI is building the product.
Sounds like
I might be running the ad account.
Obviously Metis got their own AI.
Are you still are you still doing that?
Like is still running it
or something else?
Yeah. Yeah.
So like my and everything is run through
AI for me it's through telegram.
It's like my whole command
center business.
Everything is through telegram.
I've got like,
it's either Claude or Codex or Cami
and I've got
like 40 sessions at any
given time running on my home computer.
I feel like, okay, so, like,
I feel like
this is like one of the biggest unlocks
for anyone using AI.
It's like vanilla Claude
or vanilla ChatGPT is
okay,
but it's the harness
that you build around it
that really matters.
It's like for copywriting,
it kind of sucks,
but the harness being like the skills,
the process that you put in place
can actually take it
to producing something
you can actually run
in in your ad account.
So for me, my harness is built on on
everything is telegram.
I've got agents running,
you know,
on their own, identifying
bugs, triaging them,
bringing them to me with like a solution
for for how to solve it, my ad account.
Like when I get new creative,
I literally just like,
send a link to my bot with the,
like the slack link.
That's how lazy I am at this point.
I don't even like export it.
And I'm like here, use the
format finder, add
uploader skill
and get these into the ad account
and it knows it has a whole process.
It knows to like
look at,
do an analysis
on the ad account, determine
what the best copy
is, transcribe the video.
It just got to identify
like who it's talking to right?
The ad copy like it does everything.
It uploads the ads
and it just tells me when it's done.
And then I can I can go in and confirm.
But at this point
it hasn't made a mistake in months.
So it just
it just runs on its own
and then it just,
it knows to
give me an analysis of every morning
or every whenever I want
all of our customer services
run through like a slack
bot that I've got set
up, which is
like the company brain as well.
And it's a clawed bot in slack
where it triaged
all customer service
as it comes in, identifies like,
oh, is this a refund?
This is what I want to do.
This is the draft reply.
I've checked the previous tickets
that are very similar.
All you have to do is to prove
and so the customer service agent
can clear.
Like I'd take it a minute at this point
and she just hits approve and it goes in.
Then it goes in
and it does the refund updates the user
account and sends the email.
And then I have another bot that comes in
and just verifies that it did
what it said it was going to do,
just like as like a QA.
And at the end of the day,
there's another one that comes in
and checks that whole day,
make sure nothing is missed because like,
you even have these redundancy layers
built in
because, you know,
they give you peace of mind,
but then it's just also like, why not?
Why wouldn't you kind of every week
a dollar. Yeah, exactly.
It costs like a dollar.
And so yeah, I don't know.
It's sick.
I'm so stoked on AI right now.
I gotta love every bit of it.
It's so much.
Yeah.
Andrew, Andrew's not here,
but Andrew has a
has another podcast,
and it sounds like
I'm gonna have to come.
Come on and join it.
But it's called
I think it's called AI, dtc tf
or something crazy.
A lot of acronyms
and I know it's DTC specific,
but we'll have to
just like
do a side episode
or we just nerd out on like the
AI side of it
because we're not
going to have time today.
But is there anything else that, like,
we didn't go through that
you think is like super interesting
to share that you want to share?
Yeah.
Not on the unless it's on the AI side.
That's like where where all my,
my like time is going
towards is just creating
the process here.
Like I feel like what we're doing
would require
10 to 15 like developers on this thing,
but we're being forced to create process
that hasn't that no one's ever
not no one's ever done.
But like that is cutting edge,
let's say with AI.
So that's like one of the funnest,
funnest things for me right now. Yeah.
I'm gonna text I'm going to text Andrew
and tell him he needs to set up the,
the follow up to talk through.
Yeah. Oh, man.
Well appreciate you appreciate
making time to to join us.
It's it's been really fun.
And I know this was our first time
getting a chance to chat.
And sounds like you and Zach
got to reconnect
for the first time in a while,
so that's awesome. Yeah.
Thanks for having me.
Before we hit record, you mentioned
you might start tweeting
a little bit more
and I got hold you to it, but
is that where you want
people to find you?
Do you want people to reach out?
Do you want to leave you alone?
No. Yeah, definitely reach out.
I mean, like I said before, I need help.
Like, I'm like to a large degree in over
my head here, like, as a developer
or as somebody who's, like,
building a company
that might be worth something.
If anyone has any advice, you know,
let me know.
My my Twitter handle is nav ud.
So cool.
I'll make sure it's
linked up in the show notes.
But yeah man appreciate you joining us.
It was super fun and I'm sure we'll we'll
we'll have a follow up on all things
AI coming soon.
Sounds good. Thanks for having me.
Thanks, man.
The only way
that we grow
this podcast is by
you sharing it with your friends.
Honestly, like reviews
kind of don't really mean
anything too much anymore.
They're really meaningful,
but they don't do a lot
for the growth of the podcast.
And so sharing YouTube links,
sharing Spotify
links, sharing
Apple, whatever
we call it under the podcast app now,
anything you can share,
the better we're going to be.
Guys, anything else
you want to say on this?
Yeah, please go check us out on YouTube.
Rack up those views for us.
We'd love to see it and then subscribe.
Make sure to subscribe on YouTube
as well.
And I relentlessly
refresh the YouTube comments
because it dictates
my mental health for the day.
So please say something
nice about all of us.
Thank you everyone.
Thanks for listening. Honestly.