The Clinical Excellent Podcast, sponsored by the Bucksbaum Institute for Clinical Excellence is a biweekly podcast hosted by Drs. Adam Cifu and Matthew Sorrentino. The podcast has three formats: discussions between doctors and patients, discussions with authors of research pertinent to improving clinical care and the doctor-patient relationship and discussions with physicians about challenges in the doctor-patient relationship or in the life of a physician.
[00:00:00] Dr. Cifu: On today's episode of The Clinical Excellence Podcast, I am joined by Dr. Tanya Zakrison, talking about the evolving doctor-patient relationship.
[00:00:13] Dr. Zakrison: A lot of the reasons why we're seeing the trauma we see is for reasons that relate to not just the social determinants of health, but even the structural challenges and injustices that many are faced with just trying to struggle to survive or live a life of dignity.
[00:00:41] Dr. Cifu: Welcome to The Clinical Excellence Podcast, sponsored by the Bucksbaum-Siegler Institute for Clinical Excellence. On this podcast, we speak to patients and doctors about all aspects of excellence in clinical medicine. I am Adam Cifu, and today I'm joined by Dr. Tanya Zakrison. Dr. Tanya L. Zakrison is a professor of surgery in the section of trauma and acute care surgery at the University of Chicago.
Dr. Zakrison specializes in trauma surgery, emergency general surgery, and surgical critical care. She's the principal investigator and program co-director of Recovery Legal Care, a novel medical-legal partnership in association with the Violence Recovery Program at the University of Chicago Medicine.
She's also director of Critical Trauma Research, which uses mixed methodologies to explore the connection between intentional and interpersonal trauma. Dr. Zakrison is also a senior faculty scholar in the Bucksbaum-Siegler Institute for Clinical Excellence. Tanya, thank you so much for joining me today. With how much you do, you must be busy to carve out time for this.
[00:01:50] Dr. Zakrison: Adam, I really appreciate the invitation. Thank you so much.
[00:01:53] Dr. Cifu: Of course. So we're going all in on the doctor-patient relationship this season, and I was so interested to have you here because of your work and because your sort of interactions with patients happen in such a different place and different settings than mine do.
So, my first question is, kind of, how has your relationship changed over the years? I'm interested in like the evolution of how you relate to patients, and as I mentioned, I'm especially interested because I assume that you meet many of your patients for the very first time at times of kind of critical illness of like the worst part of their life. So what's changed over the course of your career?
[00:02:33] Dr. Zakrison: Thank you, Adam, and yes, you're correct. We certainly do meet people at their worst moment in their lives, often. And that's kind of the nature of trauma surgery, but you know, it's been interesting over the time and evolution of my training as a medical student, resident, fellow, and now a junior attending, you know, and a more senior full professor, at this stage, what's been interesting is the privilege I have now of being able to take more time with the patients and actually sometimes even sitting down, being able to talk with them, and realizing and learning that a patient actually belongs to a family. Then you get to know the family better, and you realize that family belongs to a community. And you learn about the community. I remember, and you remember being a medical student, being residents, and you're just... You're running around, you're trying to round on 20 patients before morning report at six o'clock or seven o'clock in the morning. And time is really of the essence, and it's a challenge, and you sort of miss those moments of getting to know your patients as well as you would like to. In fact, we wrote a paper about the communications and discommunications between trauma residents and trauma patients here, and it's... There is that desire to get to know them, but you are still trying to make sure they're doing well, they're not septic, they're not infected, their surgical incisions are clean and dry, but as a professor, like even yesterday, I had a lovely conversation with a family in the surgical ICU about so many different things about their lives, their children, and I'm clearly non-subtly pregnant right now, and so it's a conversation starter, but it's truly a privilege to get to know them on a deeper level.
[00:04:31] Dr. Cifu: Yeah. You know, you talked about the sort of relationship between you and the patient, and given what you do, sort of necessarily you and the family. And it's almost been a theme this season that so many people have talked about the importance of the people who are maybe not in the room.
[00:04:51] Dr. Zakrison: Mm-hmm.
[00:04:52] Dr. Cifu: But you're probably the first person who draws that out to the community. And given the sort of medicine you practice, you know, are you aware of kind of what happens, I don't know, in the emergency room, in the ICU, and its impact on the wider community? Is that something you're sort of thinking about, I don't know, on a daily basis, or weekly basis, or when you reflect?
[00:05:18] Dr. Zakrison: That's a great question, Adam. You know, I think it is, and I think for many of us, sure, in trauma surgery, but just frankly, you know, many of us in medicine, we're drawn to that, not just because it's the pathophysiology that fascinates us. It's not just because we like cutting in the operating room, you know. And I think in trauma surgery, it's certainly an area where you can't ignore what's going on on a community level at all. And it certainly is part of the research I'm doing, because it is impactful for families, and also you hear about it. You learn about it.
[00:05:56] Dr. Cifu: Yeah.
[00:05:57] Dr. Zakrison: And it's hard to therefore ignore, you know, sort of the local injustices that our patients are faced with and the resilience they need to survive.
[00:06:10] Dr. Cifu: Yeah.
[00:06:11] Dr. Zakrison: Because a lot of the trauma we see is... And that's whether it's the south side of Chicago or Miami where I was before, or my colleagues in other cities across the country. A lot of the reasons why we're seeing the trauma we see is for reasons that relate to not just the social determinants of health, but even the structural challenges and injustices that many are faced with, just trying to struggle to survive or live a life of dignity.
[00:06:39] Dr. Cifu: Yeah. It's interesting how many ways that comes in, you know, to the medical center. I mean, as you talk, I think so much of, you know, COVID and all the kind of craziness about ideas and beliefs and you know, whether people were, you know, thought that social distancing helped or masking helped, or vaccines helped and everything that people were hearing outside and then coming in. And there was this interesting sort of play, you know, in the office around what people were hearing, what they were believing, what they would and would not do. And then you got the feeling that everything that you said was probably being repeated out into the community, and it was this strange way of impacting, you know, how people were responding to the crisis.
[00:07:27] Dr. Zakrison: Right, right. Very much so.
[00:07:29] Dr. Cifu: So I always find that, you know, one of the great things about medicine is that it keeps you humble. Right? Every time I feel like, "Ah, I've got this," you know, then something bad is sure to happen. I try not to say that. So what about the sort of patient-doctor relationship specifically still challenges you? Do you still feel like, "Ah, this is really hard!" Or, "There I go again. You know, I've fallen into this trap again." What are difficult parts to that for you?
[00:07:55] Dr. Zakrison: Right, right. You know, it's an interesting question because it's one that's easily answered on the surgical level.
[00:08:03] Dr. Cifu: Yeah, yeah.
[00:08:04] Dr. Zakrison: And in fact, you know, I think... Actually, I don't know if I've talked to my colleagues about this, but I can speak for myself as a trauma surgeon. Sometimes, when you're in these just really horrible cases, and you can get to a point where you realize the injuries are not compatible with life. And you might be on unit 30 of blood, the anesthesiologist is trying to keep up with all the blood loss, and you just realize, you know, these holes in these great vessels or the heart or whatever, you just can't fix them.
[00:08:40] Dr. Cifu: Yeah. Yeah.
[00:08:40] Dr. Zakrison: And for me, there's a physiologic, almost visceral feeling to that, of feeling impotent. And it's an incredibly humbling, as you say, and an incredibly frustrating feeling. It's a horrible feeling because we obviously want to fix problems. We want to fix 'em fast.
[00:09:04] Dr. Cifu: Yeah.
[00:09:05] Dr. Zakrison: So, but you know, when it comes to the patient-doctor relationship, I think something that keeps us humble and it's a bit of a trap, or certainly, it's a learning curve for me right now, is how do you maintain that balance where you are getting to know your patient? You know, I said how it's such a privilege and such a joy to get to know your patients better now, get to know their families. But as you get to know your patient, you get to know their pain.
[00:09:34] Dr. Cifu: Yeah. Yeah.
[00:09:35] Dr. Zakrison: And there's a lot of pain. You get to know their strengths.
[00:09:39] Dr. Cifu: Right, right.
[00:09:40] Dr. Zakrison: And you learn from that. You learn, you know, how resilient and, you know, I have mixed feelings about the term, but how strong they are and how they overcome all of these things, but it is pain.
I was at a conference, you know, a couple of weeks ago, and a friend of mine who's also a trauma surgeon in California, she just up and asked one of her trauma patients who is, you know, very underweight, she operated on him after a gunshot wound and said, "Hey, you know, what's your nutritional status or access to food?" And he's like, "No, no. I eat, I eat. I eat four times a week." And literally, that's how often he could eat.
[00:10:21] Dr. Cifu: Yeah, yeah.
[00:10:22] Dr. Zakrison: And you know, any physician would feel pain with that. So it's how do you turn that pain into something, you know, much more productive, like our medical legal partnership, or how do you turn it into something to address the bigger issues? But that fine line of communicating with them, not absorbing everyone's difficulty and pain, but maintaining your own balance.
[00:10:47] Dr. Cifu: Right. And it is absolutely, I feel like, when I eventually stop doing medicine, it may be the thing that I miss the most: the just constant demonstration about how amazing we as people are, you know, to be able to sort of rise to these challenges and the number of people who... You know, I watch them decline over the years, but it sort of doesn't affect, you know, their spirit, their optimism, their ability to do something is really amazing. I feel like we probably see it... I see it over a long timeline. You see it over a shorter timeline. The other thing I just wanted to highlight, because I've never thought about it before, I think a lot about how we come to rely on our reactions as almost clinical tools, and for me, it's often that like, "Oh, you know, this is how I feel when I'm with someone with depression or with an anxiety disorder," right? And I can actually kind of use that as a diagnostic tool. It's interesting to hear you talk about it, where you become almost like an ICU instrument that like, "Okay, I'm having this feeling, I get this feeling when there's futility." You know? I don't know. I'm more of maybe a psychiatrist in the room, and you're more as like, you know, a beeping tool in the ICU.
[00:12:15] Dr. Zakrison: Thank you, Adam.
[00:12:16] Dr. Cifu: Yeah. Hope that's not an insult.
[00:12:18] Dr. Zakrison: No, but yeah, very apt description. Yeah. Yeah.
[00:12:23] Dr. Cifu: At this point in your career, you know, you've been doing this for a while in a bunch of different settings, what do you sort of appreciate most about your role in the doctor-patient relationship? And that might be just, you know, what gives you joy and pleasure, satisfaction, or honestly something that you feel like, you know, "I'm kind of proud of this, you know, I've worked up to this and I feel like I do this generally well."
[00:12:46] Dr. Zakrison: Mm-hmm.
[00:12:46] Dr. Cifu: I don't know. How do you think about those things?
[00:12:49] Dr. Zakrison: Again, it's interesting. It's something that, to be honest, I haven't really reflected upon too, too much 'cause we don't sort of sit on our laurels and say how good we are. And also, we have that culture in surgery of like the weekly morbidity, mortality rounds that we're always sort of questioning what could we have done better. Which I think is good, and that keeps us humble, but it is important to remember our successes, even though the quote unquote, success is like going to work every day and just doing our job. But, you know, I think something that's interesting is... And something that I'm proud of, you know, with all the clinical and surgical stuff aside, the, you know, intensive care management aside, but just on the humane interaction level, is just being there for patients. Now, not 24/7, 365 days a year, but... And I have to be honest, this is something I kind of learned from my husband, who's also a surgeon. He's a general surgeon and a familypractitioner. He's based in Havana, Cuba. We have a home there. That's a whole other topic of another podcast, but he maintains such a close relationship with his past patients, his current patients. And they call him on his cell phone. And they're like, "Oh, my second cousin has a hernia, we think. Can she come see you on call?" And so, I started doing that here, and in fact, a lot of my other colleagues do that here at Chicago, too. And there's something so special about being able to call a parent, a mother, a father, a loved one to say, "Hey, I just operated on your son."
[00:14:32] Dr. Cifu: Yeah.
[00:14:33] Dr. Zakrison: "He's okay for now. We're going to put him in the intensive care unit," and you answer their questions because you're frankly, running back to the trauma bay. You might not be able to find the person and speak to them face-to-face, but to say, "This is my personal cell phone number. I may not answer your text or your call in real time 'cause our hours are different, but I will do my best to respond and help you with anything you need." And the psychological support something as simple as that can provide is interesting.
And then sort of that goes on to what we were talking about earlier, you know, I'm proud of just being there for that and, you know, giving the cell phone number to patients that I know will be here long-term, might be frightened, who want to just know someone has their back. And so being that patient advocate, but also, you know, that matures into the idea of witnessing or [unintelligible], you know, as the ethical, you know, idea in terms of how do you tell a patient's story, but not 'cause you're guessing at it, but because they're telling you. How do you fight that injustice? How do you change the structural challenges?
[00:15:50] Dr. Cifu: We are so good in medicine at, you know, reacting to our failures, right? I mean, and it's probably a good thing, right? It is like built into the culture that when something bad happens, you sort of stop and discuss within, but it's so part of, like, the coaching world to identify the successes and like, how can we build on this? How can we use this? And I do think that's something we've got to figure out how to use more. Not to like just celebrate, but actually to figure out, okay, that went well, you know? How can we make that happen every time we do that? The other thing, just to... I think that accessibility right, is so important to people. I've sort of recognized it when I'm on the patient side, right? And it's often not needing a phone call back like in 30 seconds, right? It's just knowing that, like, there's someone there who's going to attend to this eventually, and it's amazing that I think we all find that when you put yourself out there, it tends to not be abused. Right? I mean...
[00:16:57] Dr. Zakrison: A hundred percent.
[00:16:59] Dr. Cifu: And I often have to sort of tell my nurse, it's like, "You don't need to protect me."
[00:17:02] Dr. Zakrison: Yes.
[00:17:03] Dr. Cifu: You know, like everybody's sort of doing the best they can, but sometimes it comes off as putting up a wall.
[00:17:09] Dr. Zakrison: I couldn't agree further. I'm often actually shocked at how judiciously our numbers are used. You know? And it's really when there's something serious going on.
[00:17:21] Dr. Cifu: Right, right. And in fact, a lot of times people actually don't access you when they should because, "Ah, I don't want to bother you."
Tanya, I want to thank you so much for coming in. This has been terrific. A lot of great different angles on some of the topics we've already talked about, so thank you.
[00:17:37] Dr. Zakrison: Thank you so much, Adam, for having me.
[00:17:40] Dr. Cifu: Thanks for joining us for this episode of The Clinical Excellence Podcast. We are sponsored by the Bucksbaum-Siegler Institute for Clinical Excellence at the University of Chicago. Please feel free to reach out to us with your thoughts and ideas via the Institute webpage: bucksbauminstitute.uchicago.edu.
The music for The Clinical Excellence Podcast is courtesy of Dr. Maylyn Martinez.