Podcasts from Confluence Investment Management LLC, featuring the periodic Confluence of Ideas series, two bi-weekly series: the Asset Allocation Bi-Weekly and the Bi-Weekly Geopolitical Report (new episodes posted on alternating Mondays), and a new monthly Q&A format called the Confluence Mailbag.
Welcome to the Confluence of Ideas from Confluence Investment Management. I'm Phil Adler. The Confluence Asset Allocation Committee met recently, as it does every quarter, to consider changes in the investment mix for the firm's five model portfolios ranging from income to aggressive growth. And today, we meet with the chair of the committee, Kaisa Stucke, to discuss the results of the latest rebalancing heading into the fourth quarter of twenty twenty six. Kaisa, before we get to the allocation changes, I'm curious how you and the committee digest what currently appears to be unusual uncertainty and and accommodate the possibility of highly variable market outcomes.
Phil Adler:After all, your forecast this quarter does come at a at a very sensitive time two weeks before the US election. You must consider as well the timetable of the war in The Middle East. Oil prices could plummet when the war ends, but at the same time, higher oil prices and inflation do seem likely if the war is extended. Then you throw in the angst over whether the AI boom is a bubble. I I assume the committee wishes to avoid making a big bet on some of these scenarios.
Phil Adler:It seems to me, though, that overcaution might ultimately be a losing choice. What's your approach?
Kaisa Stucke:Hi, Phil. Good to be here. You know, uncertainty doesn't mean every outcome is equally likely or that every risk is worth avoiding. One of the biggest risks is building a portfolio that only works if a narrow set of expectations materializes. We have a base case, continued economic growth, but we also need to understand what happens if inflation persists, the conflict lasts longer, or the AI investment boom disappoints.
Kaisa Stucke:By the way, that does not mean sitting on the sidelines. Being too cautious is also a decision, and it carries an opportunity cost. Our approach is to participate in the expansion, while making sure each portfolio's risks are appropriate for the investor. We don't need certainty to invest, but we do need discipline about how much depends on any one assumption. The goal is to identify attractive opportunities while limiting dependence on any single outcome.
Kaisa Stucke:Excessive caution has a cost, too. Uncertainty doesn't stop businesses from investing or earning profits. We need to participate in that growth without assuming the path will be smooth.
Phil Adler:I guess we should emphasize that your forecast is always for a three year period, and and that alone acts as a buffer for some of the sharp edges?
Kaisa Stucke:It does. Although a longer horizon doesn't make risks disappear, it gives us room to distinguish a disruption from a lasting change. For example, an election result can move markets immediately, while resulting policies may take much longer to take effect on earnings, on economic activity, and so forth. We're interested in both, but we don't want a three year allocation to become a prediction about the next three weeks. We review that outlook quarterly and adjust as evidence changes.
Phil Adler:How does the Iran war then fit within this three year outlook?
Kaisa Stucke:Yeah. You know, our base case assumes that the conflict is resolved within the forecast period. That should eventually ease some pressure on energy supplies, household purchasing power, and business costs. But the economic effects depend on the duration of the disruption, damage to infrastructure, and how quickly reliable supplies return. Even after fighting stops, energy markets may take time to normalize.
Kaisa Stucke:So we therefore allow for volatility along the way. A prolonged disruption would be a headwind for growth and inflation, but we don't currently expect it to derail the expansion over the full horizon.
Phil Adler:Let's take a look back for a moment. What stood out to you about the way the markets acted in the latest quarter? Did anything surprise you?
Kaisa Stucke:Yeah. You know, what stood out was how different the quarter looked depending on what you owned. US large cap stocks gained about 2%, while small caps and long term bonds both lost around eight or so. Large companies benefited from strong earnings and continued enthusiasm for AI, while smaller companies were more vulnerable to rising financing costs. Bonds also fell as yields rose.
Kaisa Stucke:So, the economy remained resilient, but that resilience didn't translate into gains across the market. Looking only at the large cap index would miss much of the story.
Phil Adler:Your committee is positioning portfolios for continued economic expansion and no recession over the upcoming three year period, and that seems reassuring. But faced with so many apparent challenges, what is the factor that will drive this growth?
Kaisa Stucke:Business investment is an important part of the answer. Spending on computing capacity, software, power infrastructure, and manufacturing supports activity today and can expand productive capacity over time. The next step is turning that investment into greater efficiency and productivity. Think of financial firms processing documents faster, industrial companies reducing equipment downtime, or healthcare providers spending less time on administration. That transition matters.
Kaisa Stucke:Building capacity supports growth initially. Using it productively helps sustain growth later. And we expect both to contribute over our forecast period.
Phil Adler:Well, does it appear at this point that growth will mostly be confined to the first part of the three year window?
Kaisa Stucke:We expect the source of growth to change rather than growth simply running out. Investment should remain supportive, but its growth rate may moderate. At the same time, affordability pressures and financing costs could weigh more heavily on consumers, particularly lower income households. But later in the period, productivity gains become more important in offsetting those pressures. So we expect some moderation and a more uneven economy, but recession is not the base case.
Kaisa Stucke:The timing of that productivity payoff is one of the key assumptions we're watching.
Phil Adler:What do you expect from the Federal Reserve?
Kaisa Stucke:We expect further tightening initially, followed by eventual easing as inflation moderates and demand softens. We don't expect inflation to trend down in a straight line. Services prices, tariffs, and energy costs can interrupt that progress. So the Fed will need to maintain credibility without responding too aggressively to every fluctuation. The risk is that policy works with a lag.
Kaisa Stucke:By the time weakness becomes obvious, earlier tightening may still be moving through the economy. We expect the Fed to calibrate carefully, but excessive tightening remains a meaningful risk.
Phil Adler:Well, looking at your portfolio recommendations now, US large cap stocks remain a consistent value in each strategy and a dominant value in the three more aggressive portfolios. Do you expect different leadership to emerge within the large cap group?
Kaisa Stucke:Good question. We see room for leadership to broaden, with earnings doing more of the work. And our equity exposure is well diversified between different return drivers. The AI rally has reflected substantial expectations about future growth. Over time, companies need to demonstrate how that investment translates into profits and cash flow.
Kaisa Stucke:So, the question becomes, what are they earning from the spending? That creates opportunities beyond technology infrastructure, in financials, industrials, and other businesses using AI to improve operations. But, at the same time, we hold a more defensive overlay, with a value tilt and a dividend overlay for the tail risks that we talked about earlier. Large caps remain a foundation of the portfolios, but our exposures vary by risk objective with more emphasis on value and dividends and lower risk strategies and a modest growth emphasis where greater volatility is appropriate.
Phil Adler:Kaiser, what stands out to me about the changes in your allocation recommendations this quarter is a decreased confidence in international developed market stocks. These allocations are cut across all five strategies. Are you getting nervous about Europe?
Kaisa Stucke:Right. That that change is region specific. We've removed the dedicated Europe overweight. While Europe remains represented within our broad international holdings, we see opportunities there, but energy access, political uncertainty, and structural growth constraints make an additional regional overweight less compelling. So, we've retained significant developed international exposure overall, including broad based holdings and selected positions in Asia Pacific, international small cap value, and mining companies, the Rebalance allocates capital towards opportunities we find more attractive within each opportunity set.
Phil Adler:In the aggressive growth strategy, you're adding to a previous allocation in emerging market stocks. Now, this is the only strategy where emerging markets are showing up. Where do you specifically see the increased opportunities for more aggressive investors?
Kaisa Stucke:You're right. We increased emerging markets in aggressive growth, including a dedicated Latin America position. We think risks exist within EM, but the risk adjusted return opportunity is appropriate for a more investor. Let's talk about Latin America specifically. It provides exposure to resources needed for infrastructure, electrification, and industrial investment.
Kaisa Stucke:Selected markets also offer attractive valuations dividend income, with potential support from domestic monetary easing as inflation allows, but it adds a different mix of businesses and economic drivers to the portfolio. Keep in mind, with currency movements, commodity cycles, and political developments, all those factors can produce substantial volatility. That's why we've placed the allocation in the strategy designed for investors with greater risk tolerance.
Phil Adler:Turning to bonds, they do remain a key stabilizer in the three more conservative portfolios. As for changes, you're adding a 3% allocation in short term bonds to the income with growth portfolio and a 3% allocation in long term bonds to the slightly riskier growth and income portfolio. Both are made possible by the decreases in international developed market stocks that we already discussed. What's the reasoning here?
Kaisa Stucke:Yeah. The changes serve different portfolio objectives. In Income with Growth, adding short term bonds provides income with relatively limited sensitivity to interest rate changes. In Growth and Income, the modest addition to longer maturities extends duration and provides greater potential to benefit if yields eventually decline. Both portfolios still hold most of their bond exposure in intermediate maturities, the belly of the curve.
Kaisa Stucke:We're making measured adjustments around that foundation. The portfolios have different risk budgets, so they don't need identical responses to the same outlook.
Phil Adler:Kaisa, do you see a reasonable scenario where bonds might experience a broad based rally?
Kaisa Stucke:Yeah. You know, a combination of sustained disinflation, softer growth, and expectations for Fed easing could support a broad rally. But Fed cuts alone wouldn't guarantee falling yields across the curve. Long term yields also reflect government borrowing, inflation uncertainty, and the compensation investors require for holding longer maturities. And credit matters too.
Kaisa Stucke:In a sharp slowdown, treasuries could rally, while corporate bonds face wider spreads. So, we distinguish between being positive on interest rate exposure and being positive on credit risk. Our preference right now remains for quality and income with selective opportunities for appreciation.
Phil Adler:Last question for today. I know the committee meets quarterly to consider allocation changes. Has the committee ever decided to change allocations mid quarter to address rapidly changing circumstances?
Kaisa Stucke:You know, we get that question regularly. The quarterly meetings are at the formal rebalance point, but we monitor portfolios and economic conditions continually. A material change in the outlook or the risks facing a strategy would warrant reassessment between scheduled meetings. We do meet formally between the quarter, and we could make portfolio changes if conditions warrant. That flexibility remains part of our portfolio management process.
Kaisa Stucke:The important distinction is between a change in prices and a change in the investment case. Markets move every day. That alone doesn't require a trade. We want act when the evidence changes enough to justify it while maintaining the discipline of our longer term process.
Phil Adler:Thank you, Kaisa. If our listeners would like to read the detailed fourth quarter twenty twenty six asset allocation outlook report and see all the changes in viewer friendly charts, that's easy to do. Just access confluenceinvestment.com, and there you'll find a tab for the asset allocation quarterly on the top right. Our discussion today is based upon sources and data believed to be accurate and reliable. Opinions and forward looking statements expressed are subject to change without notice.
Phil Adler:Also, this information does not constitute a solicitation or an offer to buy or sell any security. Our audio engineer is Dane Stole. I'm Phil Adler.