Retailgentic, presented by the ReFiBuy Media Network and hosted by Scot Wingo, is where Agentic Commerce meets retail innovation. We help retailers and brands prepare for the future of agent-driven shopping with actionable news, expert insights, dxis, forward-looking predictions, and practical guidance on Agentic Commerce Optimization (ACO).
Organizations and customers or consumers use AI or rely on personalization to help them make decisions and make their experiences form a... Feel more relevant. A layer of a loyalty or or rewards program that is sort of branded to your own organization is really important to help build long term relationships and kind of deliver on that value. One of the challenges is those that everybody, I mean, everyone has a loyalty program, right? It's like 99% of brands we surveyed, they offer a loyalty program and 80% of customers belong to more than one loyalty program.
Speaker 1:But brand loyalty programs don't always hit on the things that are most important to people in the in in the loyalty space.
Speaker 2:Welcome to the Retailgentic podcast where we explore the intersection of retail, ecommerce, and AI agents, which we call Retailgentic. Our mission is simple. We are shining a bright light on the new agentic AI shopping megatrend, which will disrupt the trillion dollar digital retail market. The stakes are high. Google, OpenAI, Microsoft, Perplexity, Amazon, Apple, Meta, and Anthropic are all fighting to be the consumer AI shopping agent winner.
Speaker 2:There are gonna be some tough decisions for online brands and retailers to make. What happens to checkout? How should payments work? Could you continue to invest in retail media networks? What does the world look like when over half of your traffic is not from humans but from AI agents?
Speaker 2:These existential questions are the tip of the iceberg. On this podcast, we're talking to industry experts, analysts, and influencers to get answers to these questions, identify trends, and best practices. This is Retailgentic, your podcast partner in navigating our AI shopping agent future. And now here's your host, Wingo.
Speaker 3:Welcome to this episode of Retailgentic. Today, I am joined by two leaders of Deloitte's Deloitte Digital team. We have Apurva Pangam, and he is the commerce practice leader, and Bobby Stephens, who is the head of US Retail and CPG. If you're keeping track of this, for longtime listeners, these are the fifth and sixth guests we've had from Deloitte. Way I think about that is Deloitte is clearly very serious about adjunctive commerce.
Speaker 3:They have gotten the religion. We spend a lot of time talking to them and, really enjoyed the conversations. You know, from what I what I gather is they are taking a lot of inbound from their retail and and branded manufacturers, CPG clients. So so they're they're quite busy there, helping their clients understand this, and I think we can all learn from from what they're seeing. In this podcast, they do give Retailgentic an exclusive first look for the Retailgentic audience and, of a new report.
Speaker 3:Mhmm. And what's interesting is this report, is called Deloitte Digital's twenty twenty six B2C Commerce Research. We'll link to the report that just got published today in the show notes and also on the subs tab. In addition to the fact this is exclusive for the Retailgentic audience and hot off hot off the presses, it's fresh data, which is always... We always love fresh data.
Speaker 3:It is survey data, but it... What's really interesting about it is it's a double sided, meaning it looks at the consumer side on one angle, but also the merchant side. Deloitte was able to get, over 500 large merchants, and when I say merchants, mean retailers and brands, to respond to this survey. This goes to show you the the reach of their client relationships. I'm sure that a lot of them are Deloitte clients, but it was not exclusive to Deloitte clients.
Speaker 3:So it's interesting to kind of like see both sides of the report and see where consumers and the providers merge and where they differ. So maybe a consumer says we want X and the merchant says we think consumers want Y and those are not aligned. So it's really interesting to see alignments and misalignments from this data. The other part that's interesting about this data is they did this last year around this time. So now we've got we've got we've got basically four data points, merchant and consumer from '25 and '26.
Speaker 3:So we can see time track trending as well about what's improving in importance to consumers. Do merchants feel like they're really making progress, or do they feel like they're falling further behind? We only had about forty minutes to go through this, so we hit on the highlights and I encourage you to download the report to see more about what's going on in the data. I'm not going to spoil any of it because I want you to kind of hear it from them because they do a really good job analyzing it and have had a lot more time to sift with the data than we have. But the topics we cover are, one thing they've discovered is they call it the basics of the new battleground.
Speaker 3:And I think that's kind of interesting. We... I spend so much time thinking about the more advanced stuff. It is interesting to kind of remember. We we still have a bunch of basics that we have to get right.
Speaker 3:Personalization is a is a big topic, that one's always super squishy to me. So I try to, really understand what they're talking about there, we get progress on that. Loyalty, very important. Those two are kind of tied together. Peanut butter and jelly, if you will.
Speaker 3:And then finally, we look at where the biggest gaps are, where the biggest alignments are. And then they can tell by looking at this who's doing the best and what are they doing right as a case study. I get this question a lot like, who should I look up to in agenda commerce? Who's like a leader of the pack? So they don't name names because that's just like against our policy, but they they have a profile.
Speaker 3:And what are they doing? So so that's better than nothing. Now without any further delay, here is a Retailgentic exclusive from our friends at Deloitte Digital, your first look at the 2026 b to c consumer and merchant research report. Enjoy. Welcome to this episode of Retailgentic.
Speaker 3:This is a big one, folks. We are featuring an exclusive first look at Deloitte Digital's 2026 b to c commerce research. Here to help guide us through all the new insights and learnings, we have two folks from Deloitte Digital. We have Apurva Pangam, also known as AP, and he is the Commerce Practice Leader at Deloitte Digital. Also joining us is Bobby Stephens, and he is the Head of US Retail and CPG also at Deloitte Digital.
Speaker 3:Bobby and AP, thanks for joining us today.
Speaker 4:Thanks, Scot. Good day. Thanks for having us.
Speaker 1:Hi, Scot. How are doing?
Speaker 3:I'm doing good. Thanks for coming on. Very excited. Appreciate you guys giving us a first look at this new data. We love data here at Retailgentic and we love to get stuff earlier than the rest of the world.
Speaker 3:So we really appreciate it. It's all about getting that little edge as you guys know in our world. Let's start with a little bit of backgrounds and I know we're a little jammed on time, so we'll do the highlights of your career. I know they're long and amazing. But AP, we'll start with you.
Speaker 3:How long have you been at Deloitte and what do you do at Deloitte and a little bit of thumbnail of what you did before?
Speaker 4:Absolutely, Scot. I've been about with Deloitte for about twenty years now. And throughout my journey, I've focused on everything customer experience, marketing and commerce across the board, helping both b to c as well as b to b clients across the board, and then helping, helping drive large scale digital transformations globally.
Speaker 3:It's kind of embedded in your part, but, do you work with retailers primarily or brands or a little bit of both?
Speaker 4:A little bit of both. Yeah.
Speaker 3:And Bobby, let's, let's hear where... What's your background and what are you doing at Deloitte?
Speaker 1:Yeah. I've got, a little bit of a mixed background. I started in retail in the buying office department store doing men's fashion. And at the same time, that same company was launching a website. And I think I must have just been the young guy there.
Speaker 1:They, you know, And they said, hey. Can you help us with that? So did that and made a quick move more onto the technology side and did a lot of work around, designing, building, and launching websites through the early stages of that. Then left Deloitte in the around 2012 and raised some money from Venture to, start a footwear startup in Chicago which I ran for about four years. Sold that business.
Speaker 1:Took about a year off after that. I came back to Deloitte in 2016, 2017, and have been in the role ever since. I I essentially look after our retail and CPG across The US here.
Speaker 3:Yep. So you took a little, side journey and and had an entrepreneurial fund. I like that.
Speaker 1:I did. And I have a lot of shoes now to show for
Speaker 3:it too. I bet you do. Yeah. A lot of it's yeah, CP you chose the hardest quadrant. So much respect to you on that one.
Speaker 3:Whenever I see a founder, then they're like, I think I'm thinking of doing a product of any kind, be it CPG or footwear. I'm like, well, I just want make sure you know what you're up against. You've chosen the hardest of things. Yeah, consumer's the hardest. And then to do that is very hard.
Speaker 3:So far on the pod, we've had Stefan Ritter, and I know he's like a European guy. And then we've had Saurabh, Vijay Vergia, if I'm getting that right, and Brian McCarthy, and Casey Lobaugh. Where do you guys fit in with those folks? Help us understand Deloitte is such a big sprawling org. Kinda like help help listeners and me figure out where where do you guys fit in with those folks?
Speaker 1:The last three are all on our kinda retail team. Kinda writ large here in The US.
Speaker 3:So they're on your team. You know them. Those are not names who are like, who is he talking about? Okay.
Speaker 1:No. Casey and I have worked together for quite a long time, and Brian and I work together quite a lot now as as with Sara up as well.
Speaker 3:And then Stefan's like a random German dude.
Speaker 1:Oh, he's got
Speaker 4:to have one.
Speaker 3:Not random, he's kind of like.
Speaker 1:Yeah. He's got one of those. Right?
Speaker 3:He's over there. Yeah.
Speaker 1:Keeps it interesting.
Speaker 3:He's very, very excited about his Internet commerce. I like his energy. Well, let's jump into this report. So, Bobby, maybe I'll start with you. Give us kind of the setup.
Speaker 3:As data nerds, we'd like to kind of, it's always at the back end of a report, but I always like to put it up at the front. Like, tell us kind of like where does this data come from and, and, you know, was this observed data or stated preference data from like a survey? And, then we'll kind of dig into what the data's telling us.
Speaker 1:Yeah. I'd say what's most interesting about this is we we have two audiences for this or or two participant groups in this. We've got over 500 respondents who are working at and are above a certain, you know, senior manager level or above in customer user experience, e com, exec leadership, you know, forward facing executives at companies that have a a business to consumer commerce presence out there in the world. And then we pair that up with a consumer survey which is over a thousand respondents who, you know, are in the right age range and have purchased a product or service in the past sixty days from a from a US based online website. And so we mix those two together.
Speaker 1:We we did these observations or this survey in Feb March of this year. So it's actually relatively recent. We pulled the data. We've now been analyzing it for the last month or so. So And this is kind of a bit of a great unveiling.
Speaker 1:Now that being said, we did this same survey, like two years ago as well. So we will be able to also see some trends from that as well. But it is always interesting, to see the where the, thought processes converge between the consumer and the retailer, or the merchant and where they they really have differences of opinions of how they're doing, what's important, etcetera. So we'll dig into that. We talk here.
Speaker 3:Yes. So the retailer could think, man, we're crushing it. On-site search is amazing. Then consumers like, I can't find anything. Yeah.
Speaker 3:So it's interesting to kind
Speaker 1:of Yeah. That never
Speaker 3:happens, right? Yeah. Those things actually more frequently diverge than converge.
Speaker 1:Correct.
Speaker 3:So it's really cool because we've got also, we've got both sides of the coin and we've got some trend data. So that's, I could probably talk about this for two hours, but we'll have to kind of curtail it to the highlights. So what are let's start on the consumer side first. Maybe what are some of the and I'll defer to you guys to figure out who answers first. But what are some of the things that you noticed on the consumer side, either looking at the year over year data or...
Speaker 3:So we'll talk about Consumer First then do Merchant and then maybe like kinda how they... You know, the alignment kind of piece of it.
Speaker 1:I mean, the Consumer First side, you you kinda started hitting on it. I think consumers still are looking for the basics. They are... This should be a channel and or a way to interact with a brand that is efficient that helps you. A lot of times you're squeezing this into your day or you're multitasking while you're doing a shopping journey or an occasion.
Speaker 1:And so thinking about accurate, search, quick search, inventory visibility so you know it's really available, and when can I get it by? And so even post purchase as well because we didn't just talk like the user experience of making the purchase and then moving away. We also talked through the post purchase experience but when's my stuff gonna be here? How easy it is for me to return? So those just are not differentiators for consumers anymore.
Speaker 1:They're absolutely expected. And I think that that's really, really important. The other the other pieces that we were we were capturing a little bit, and this is maybe more of a broad view of just economic uncertainty is that, you know, over half of our consumers say they're spending a little less on products and services. So what they're looking for with that is either one, I'm reinvesting my time and my spend with a few brands where I feel very comfortable with the experience. Feel very comfortable that I'm getting rewarded for instance in a loyalty program, or rewards program that's helpful to me.
Speaker 1:And overall just kinda looking for, hey, how do I get the best deals? And so that's the other other thing that we've... That consumers are looking for person personalization. That that beautiful golden term that we all like to talk about lots of times, but we have probably 57 different definitions for. And a lot of that is around either convenience and speed or give me the best deal.
Speaker 1:And so how do I get to that? And so that's what we're really seeing from a from a consumer at the overall.
Speaker 4:Bobby, what's really interesting is, you know, when you start looking at the the numbers about, like, somewhere between 16 to 18% of consumers rate the brands as excellent, but the brands themselves are rating themselves in the, you know, low to mid thirties. So it's a really interesting sort of disparate things that we're starting to see what consumers are expecting, what consumers are actually rating brands than the brands rating themselves. So... Scot, that's that's starting to... It's a good sort of introspection for the brands themselves to look at and understand, you know, are am I actually getting the right consumer data?
Speaker 4:Am I getting the right first party data and understanding that to be able to improve my experiences for them?
Speaker 3:The brands think they're doing better than they are. So
Speaker 4:Oh, yeah. So the perception gap is... Yeah. It's it's feeling... I feel like it's creating some false confidence there.
Speaker 4:And sometimes, like Bobby said, even for personalization, we can get into that a little bit more in detail. But it's kind of starting to create some of those underinvestments in where the moments really matter for for those end customers as well.
Speaker 3:Yeah. Yeah. Let's dig into personalization. Say say more, you know... And and at some point, this will result in recommendations for merchants.
Speaker 3:Right? Like, and I'm fine going in and going there. Like, what do you... How do you help merchants cross that gulf that's there?
Speaker 4:Yeah. I mean, first and foremost, I feel like, you know, consumers just want the experience to feel relevant to them. I feel like that's one of the most things, and I feel like I... In in our research, about 70%, you know, said that the personalized experiences are important. They actually care about personalization, not just, you know, just show me a different banner, but actually show me things that are a lot more truly personalized to me.
Speaker 4:The offers are actually super valuable to people when they're better personalized. But interestingly, only about, like, in the high thirties is where people or the brands are actually saying that the offers to them are a high priority. To customers, they're significantly higher in terms of personalization, But the brands don't actually consider that as much of a priority, and they don't really operate with, you know, better better first party or zero party data, and or either the consumer location where they are. So that that that perception gap really starts to shine in personalization far more than before. And if you don't get it right, I mean, I think it's actually hurting the trust and the brand perception far more than actually helping it.
Speaker 4:So we're starting to see some of the leading brands, you know, set that bar pretty high, offer better hyper personalization. But then for the rest of them to catch up, it's becoming more and more important that they invest in that and they catch up quickly.
Speaker 3:Now in our industry, there's lots of surfaces that brands and retailers interact with consumers. And here on Retail Gentic, spend a lot of time talking about answer engines. Right? It seems like you're you're teasing out more like what's happening on the website with... Which is also of interest to us.
Speaker 3:And, you know, Amazon, Walmart, and some of the really big stores, are really investing a ton in in their on-site agents. Do you see that as a way that... Like, should retailers... Like, you think... In your mind, does Rufus, Walmart, I mean, Sparky, and I guess Target calls theirs TSA and that that kind of generic thing, you don't have to specifically talk about one of them.
Speaker 3:But is that like one of the things retailers should be investing in as an on-site agent or it doesn't really necessarily need to take that format in this personalization kind of world?
Speaker 1:I don't think it needs to necessarily take that format. I would say that there is a, let's call it segment of the retail, retailer population that can can and should go that route. You know, what... What's the DNA of of one of those? They're big.
Speaker 1:They're comfortable investing in technology. They have a wide variety of product categories. They have the ability to get you stuff in a in a in a, you know, lots of different modalities that work for you. And so when you have that broad set of experiences of products of price points, I think, you know, anything to help the customer sort through that to get to his or her preferred, you know, selection for that given moment will... Is helpful.
Speaker 1:I I do think you could flip the coin on that and say, hey, if I am a much more considered purchase, higher price point, you know, luxury goods, experiences, etcetera, etcetera. Maybe that that format is not what we wanna look for and or we may not even wanna do that because we don't want to have people think to shop for us that way because it... What if they actually shift off platform to an LLM or, you know, one of the more public ones? Like, do we wanna just be one line in there of, 50 places you get this and we lose the magic that comes with our brand, our, you know, the luxury experience or the high end experience? I think there's kinda two sides to that coin.
Speaker 1:So should they invest? Don't know. But we are definitely seeing a certain set of retailers invest. Think have the right underpinning DNA to them to to make that happen and continue to inject technology into their business even from a customer facing perspective.
Speaker 3:Deloitte is really good at having, like, frameworks and playbooks. What's... Do you guys have a framework playbook for this? Is this like a CDP thing? Is this a...
Speaker 3:I know there's, a thousand personalization platforms out there, and I I can't everyone... Like to your point earlier, everyone uses that term and sometimes you'll dig into it and you'll be like, oh, this is just an on-site search engine. You know? And I'm like, I wish they would just call themselves that because like... Or or...
Speaker 3:So it seems like everyone's using personalization, but it can mean something that cuts across everything, an on-site search engine, an on-site agent, or even just like how your SERPs are are organized. So I always like to get a little more tactical with it so I can kinda like understand. Are those part of what you guys are calling personalization? And, and then what's, what's, what's like your playbook for helping all these folks implement better personalization?
Speaker 1:There's probably a thin line between some of those things and personalization. We probably define personalization a little more broadly than that, across, you know, the experience you can provide on the site, in the mobile app, some cases in the store, if there's a clienteling type environment in the store where there is data about a customer. And so it all starts with the with the PDP or the, you know, the customer record, and how do I think about a customer and his or her lifetime value. And and to some extent, that's a mind shift that we at least suggest that you think about as the shift from a merchandise or a category based p and l to a customer based p and l, or at least having both of those viewpoints available to you when making decisions. But I...
Speaker 1:Well, certainly, is some degree of AI or agentic powering most of those decision engines, for sure. But do we have a playbook? I think it's pretty new for everybody. We we we have one, but we have to change it almost every two days at this point, so we can't really print it. It's gotta be digital only at this point.
Speaker 3:And it's probably so custom per client because they all have the unique... You know, like, what you would recommend for someone selling mattresses, which is a much longer time to your next purchase versus shoes or a replenishable. It's like, it's so you almost have to like customize it to fit the situation I imagine.
Speaker 1:The only other thing, and AP might be able to expound on this a little bit, is we're seeing investments in AI for the customer experience, but we're also seeing equal importance put on, AI or AgenTic for operational efficiency. So thinking about, you know, how do we get scale to support personalization? How do we quick... More quickly analyze the customers and break them into micro segments or, you know, tiny hyper segments so you can get closer to that one to one personalization, but while still getting the scale of of some of the segmentation out there. So there's a lot of things maybe the customer doesn't see that are being invested in now to set the foundation to to invest harder in the customer experience from personalization.
Speaker 4:And I and I think, Scot, that's that's starting to become a differentiator where, you know, the organizations that are starting to be more mature, are not just focused on the experience driven, but they're... The experience is actually being driven by better internal processes, whether it's even merchandising or or pricing. If you think about the ability to price personalize or the the ability to be rapidly respond to those couple of... Or internal processes, I think becomes super important, just as much as the experience that you're creating directly, whether it's an owned property, whether it's a... An LLM based.
Speaker 4:How are you personalizing across all these properties becomes pretty important just like, you know, you've had omnichannel store versus online in the past. So so what we're seeing is is a lot of that investment going not just towards the the the Sparkys and the Rufus' as you said, or similar as you're starting to see across across brands. But you're also going to see a lot more of that internal decision making, a lot of efficiency that's being driven. That internally is also being a lot more AI and agentic driven more and more so. I'm really rethinking those processes to be a lot more agentic first, and AI first rather than just an additional layer sort of added on.
Speaker 4:Those are big investments that are... We're starting to see.
Speaker 1:I mean, to put a fine point on that, Scot, like, in the retailer survey or the merchant survey, two of the... Or the two top reported benefits from the merchant side aren't customer experience benefits. They are better decision making and greater efficiency. Right? So two out of five of our executives that we that we surveyed, those were their...
Speaker 1:Those were the top that they chose. So you can you can certainly see what they're thinking about their own, maybe their own house in order first.
Speaker 3:The challenge is those are like projects with a capital p though, like in my experience. So anything that's going to go and like work on inventory optimization, sourcing, those things are like such complex workflows and so essential. It's like it's going to be I don't know. You guys may disagree on that. That regardless AI everything goes fast in AI, but in that stuff, don't really want to mess around or warehouse fulfillment sequencing and all that kind of jazz.
Speaker 3:That requires a lot of thought and QA and... Because if it goes wrong, it can go horribly wrong and be a be a huge problem.
Speaker 1:Yeah. There's probably just more resistance to... Or awareness of potential change in those areas. Right? It's been the way it has been for a long time.
Speaker 1:And you know, in some cases, it's it's a little easier to make a change for something newer. But the only... Other place that people are investing a lot here, which is, I think, pretty interesting is just thinking about how to make my product my product data readable machine... As machine readable as possible. That's sort of less about the what do I have on-site to offer in my own owned environment, but just getting ready for the inevitability of this will be scraped.
Speaker 1:This will be pulled in across multiple different tools that customers are beginning to adopt at pretty fast rates. And so how am I ready for that? Maybe how does loyalty help me in those instances to at least create a little bit of a a moat or even a small fence for you to get over to purchase, you know, a product that I'm known for from somebody else even in those environments. So I I think that's pretty interesting investment that people are making.
Speaker 3:The setup I found that that's happening there is as they invest in these things either, you know, so this is happening at the answer engines first, but now it's rippling down to the website. Let's say they invest in the CDP and all this cool personalization technology. Most of it's increasingly based on LMs. LMs are really good at understanding context and intent. So the the the amount that the website and answer engines know about the shopper has grown dramatically, but our product information and intent is still teeny tiny.
Speaker 3:And and, you know, we we've kinda over optimized it for keywords from the keyword era. So... Yeah. Even if you beef it up just for your website and you've invested in some of these personalization capabilities, we've seen some really dramatic increases in, the key metric everyone looks for is that conversion rate kind of popping. And are you showing the right product to the right customer at the right time?
Speaker 3:LMs end up being very, very good at that. Another risk is if they don't solve the on-site personalization problem, their business will get pulled up into the answer engine layer, right? So if Google is going to deliver a 10 times better customer experience than you are through AI mode in Gemini and all the technology there, then you're going to effectively, the consumer is going to choose that. I know your survey doesn't go into that. I think that's the a lot of people ask us, why should I care about this stuff?
Speaker 3:And we're like, well, this is your future is being decided right now. And if you want to say in it, you need to kind of start start figuring out some of these things.
Speaker 4:Yeah. Scot, Scot, it's... If you're like me, you know, you used 20 tabs in the past to go make a decision and open an Excel sheet. And and and it's... It...
Speaker 4:You've taken the time. But if you look at that sort of discovery to decision making process, I feel like that's collapsed very quickly because of the LLMs really being able to help you make that decision faster. That that is collapsing in terms of how fast people are able to make decisions now based on the data available. Couldn't agree more with you because it's... The the story being told so far was all left to kind of human inference.
Speaker 4:When I looked at those five different products, I was trying to infer which one would make the most sense for me or fill in the gaps. Those gaps don't exist... Those gaps exist and are kind of almost amplified if that data isn't available or that content for the product isn't available to your LLMs. They don't they don't know. They're not making those inferences, they're just giving you what is available.
Speaker 4:So making sure that content available is also, you know, starting to be thought through a lot more differently, both for even human consumption and agent consumption. Machine readability is is becoming really critical. I I think it's where a pretty interesting transition point of where, you know, rebuilding that layer of content and of of product itself, I think, is becoming pretty critical as a a function here.
Speaker 3:I'm very biased, but strongly agree. So we've kind of learned that the basics matter. You'd like, you know, show me, like, stuff that's in stock and, give me a picture. It's kind of surprising. We still talk about that.
Speaker 3:But hey, that's where we are. And then personalization. And then kind of like the next stack on there is loyalty. And Stefan and I had a good conversation. It was funny.
Speaker 3:He had just gone to this Talon One show and was like super fired up about loyalty. Then like the next day, between recording the pod and publishing it, they got acquired by, a payments company, which is interesting. Can talk about Right? Yep. Yeah.
Speaker 3:Aiden. Yeah. We're seeing the payments companies are are, they they see an opportunity, but there's also an existential threat that if if these transactions, they they they have a risk of being hyper commoditized. So they're all trying to, like, go up the vertical stack from the bottom kind of where they are in the transaction flow and and differentiate that way. So there's a lot lot going on there.
Speaker 3:What... Did did these these kind of two surveys, what did they surface about loyalty? Are there folks totally nailing it? Or is there another, like, divergence there?
Speaker 1:There's another gap, I would say. It's short. But to your point, like... And I think this is a good segue from AI and personalization into loyalty is that as as both organizations and customers or consumers use AI or rely on personalization to help them make decisions and make their experiences form a... Feel more relevant.
Speaker 1:A layer of a loyalty or or rewards program that is sort of branded to your own organization is really important to help build long term relationships and kinda deliver on that value. One of the challenges is those that everybody... I mean, has a loyalty program. Right? It's like 99% of brands we surveyed, they offer a loyalty program and 80% of customers belong to more than one loyalty program.
Speaker 1:In fact, I I lead our loyalty practice as well. And one thing that the average US consumer is a member of over four... It's like between fourteen and fifteen loyalty programs, but they're only active in four or five of them. So it's like you are fighting for some headspace there, that I think is really important because one third of consumers are much much more likely to buy from a brand whose program they, they, belong to. But brand loyalty programs don't always hit on the things that are most important to people in the in in the loyalty space.
Speaker 1:So that's where, for example, consumers constantly state that cat programs are their favorite. Right? I think two thirds belong to one. Over half of our consumers said it's the program... Program component or type they would value the most, but only 14% of brands offer one.
Speaker 1:Now there's some economic reasons probably for that or there's some, you know, traditional, here's how my loyalty program has always worked. Company ABC, we don't wanna change that. But it's just interesting to see a mismatch between, like, what customers want, which is financial value, ease, and simplicity in their loyalty program and brands, you know, continuously trying to sort of take some of the financial benefits out of there to profitability as much as possible. And then maybe add complexity around tierings and redemption structures. Again, to drive as much profitability as possible, but in the, you know, in the face to some extent of what customers are looking for.
Speaker 1:So...
Speaker 3:Yeah. I'm a big Star Wars enthusiast and the star program has gotten progressively more complicated, like is now a PhD level loyalty program. Yeah. Yeah. I use differential calculus to figure out if I can get a...
Speaker 3:When I'll get my next coffee.
Speaker 1:That doesn't sound that exciting.
Speaker 3:The number one question I get is, so people, once they get kind of... Once brands and retailers get over the hump, they're like, okay, but who's doing a good job at this? And I know you can't specifically talk about clients or anything, but like when... What does the survey tell you both from the consumer? Where where is there some alignment?
Speaker 3:Where you've got a merchant that thinks they're doing well and the consumer's like, yeah, these guys are doing a good job? Is it like a certain vertical? Or is bigger companies are pulling away? Or is it the disruptors are this is a way they're disrupting, a dimensional that they're disrupting on?
Speaker 1:I think it's a bit of a build like you mentioned earlier. So we we mentioned at the very beginning, that there's a mismatch between the perceived delivery on the basics of retailers and the expectation of basics from consumers. And one of the things I found most fascinating was, majority of our consumers said that brands have not improved on the basics in the last two years. Sort of said that they... It's been stasis, so to speak.
Speaker 1:And so, you know, with that that that, I think that's really important because there are a few subset. Like, there are some leaving brands that consumers then do separate from the pack and say, not only are they delivering on the basics, continue to improve how they deliver on the basics of, is this something... Can I find it easily? Do you tell me the inventory? Can you communicate delivery and and return options?
Speaker 1:Like, delivering on those expectations. And so, you know, the winners really do focus on delivering that experience at the basic level first because what that does for them is consumers spend more. Consumers then more often, and they recommend that brand to their family or friends. So, essentially, the the the types... And there isn't a ton of rhyme or reason.
Speaker 1:It is really the sort of leaders in each category in that broader view of the digital experience and and what we're doing on the basics, plus strategic personalization, plus a loyalty program that is sticky. When when that happens, you know, our survey, those those folks get classified as the leading companies and and consumers spend, like I said, 34% more with them. And 57% of our consumers said that they'll purchase an additional product or service from that brand that they haven't tried before. And then 55% of those same customers said, I'll recommend that brand to family or friends. So if you add those three things up, I know that they're not supposed to add up to a 100 because they're three different questions, but those are all, to me, indications of brands that are not just surviving but grabbing market share probably from others as you think about the current environment.
Speaker 3:Yes. There's a there is a prize to this investment that you'll have to make to do these three things well. And it's yeah. It's taking share and winning. Yeah.
Speaker 3:And it's a zero e commerce digital retail is a zero sum game. Someone's going to get the order and someone's not. So yeah, you gotta... It's not... The pie will get bigger, but but within that, it's still a zero sum game.
Speaker 1:100%.
Speaker 3:AP, what... Did you have a different set of, things that, you know, the winners are doing?
Speaker 4:I I think it's a little more related to to what Bobby said. I... Instead of... You know, I I feel like the the biggest differentiators... And Bobby talked about the ones that are, like, leading the pack versus not so much.
Speaker 4:I think the biggest differentiator really comes down to a bit of that commerce execution, what they're doing about in terms of how they're actually getting this to market. It's great if you have data. It's great if you, you know, have a loyalty program. And it's great if you're using some AI somewhere in the organization. I think what really matters is starting to bring those things together.
Speaker 4:How are you actually starting to connect the dots and across the... And execute across those three areas. So that's gonna start affecting your spend loyalty, both brand advocacy, etcetera, that you... That we we just spoke about. But I think it's it's how you actually use that to create that measurable impact, that more direct commercial impact, for the...
Speaker 4:For your customer as well as for your organization. I think that connecting the dots becomes so much more important, than just having individual independent programs that you're running, that aren't really bringing those things together.
Speaker 3:I what... Like, say say a bit more about that so I can kinda understand what you're what you're saying there.
Speaker 4:Yeah. Absolutely. If you look at even connecting the dots across, your own property versus the LLM that we that we spoke about earlier in the in the show. You know, your your data is completely different sometimes. You're you're starting to see a different experience.
Speaker 4:Which one are you trusting? You're starting to have those, you know, those brand issues as well across where you're looking at those. But secondly, are you... Is your loyalty program connected? Is it actually satisfying your your customers' needs?
Speaker 4:Bobby, you talked about cashback. I think the the the gap between people expecting a a cashback program versus not is so distinct. But but if you're not executing, for example, even on the the core data program, if you're not bringing that together with, you know, improved AI as an example? Are you actually improving the quality of your data? You know, Scot, we've spoken about even with with with Retailgentic and RefiBuy, how that's actually improving data across the LLMs.
Speaker 4:If you're not really doing that on a consistent improved basis, and it's not a one time thing either. So if you're not really bringing that together and improving that across those channels, that is just failed execution. I mean, it's... You you got good intent that you were trying to do that, but that's failed execution. So bringing those sort of kind of those multitudes of things together becomes pretty important for for either a brand or a retailer.
Speaker 1:One thing I'd just add really quickly is I think it's important, and this was... This goes back away. It's like, you know, in the olden days, we'll call it. Like, how do I give you the same experience on my website as you get in the store or or as close to... And I think that that is probably, a, not possible and b, and especially as you now add this third channel, so to speak, of the LLMs, nor is that the right thing to do.
Speaker 1:So I think there needs to be, to your point, AP coordination, connective tissue, consistency in certain things. But then you have to make actual strategic choices for what's the purpose of the store, what's the purpose of the website, what's the purpose of the mobile app, what's the purpose of my presence on name your favorite LLM here, insert your favorite LLM here, and how those things connect together, then how you measure across all of them. Because now you've got a broader ecosystem of both product performance and customer performance that you need to try to measure.
Speaker 3:I know we're up against time. Let's do like a little final round. Any other insights, you guys wanna share from the report? And then last question, I'll go ahead and ask it, is where can people, we will link to it in the show notes, but, you know, where can people follow you guys, and then where can they find the report?
Speaker 4:I I I was just gonna end with, you know, a lot of what we spoke about, don't just don't just make that a a promise to your customers. Actually, put it into practice is is what I'll leave you with.
Speaker 3:And then, do you do you, frequently, put stuff on LinkedIn or or it's all underneath the Deloitte digital banner on the website?
Speaker 4:It will be under the Deloitte digital banner. We'll actually have the report out, Scot, on the... On on LinkedIn as well shortly, both from Bobby and myself. So look out for that.
Speaker 3:Alright. We'll link to your LinkedIn profiles as well.
Speaker 1:Yeah. LinkedIn's probably the best thing for this type of thing unless you wanna see pictures of me at, you know, kids soccer games or something on Instagram. Probably not as probably not as relevant. But... Yeah.
Speaker 1:Instagram and then, you know, out and about at all the same conferences you're probably at, Scot, and all that good stuff as well. So I really appreciate the time, and allowing us to share, at least some early portions of our of our research here. And if we start getting more more details on that as it comes out, happy to come back and talk more.
Speaker 3:Sounds good. Thanks for joining us.
Speaker 4:Thanks for the time, Scot. Take care. Thanks, sir.
Speaker 2:Follow, rate, and share to stay up to date with Retailgentic, your guide to the future of AI shopping agents.