This podcast covers the fascinating world of psychological science through discussing the research behind popular myths related to psychology, such as the idea that we only use 10% of our brain. Hosted by Dr. Karla Lassonde and Dr. Emily Stark, psychology professors, we discuss misconceptions about psychology and how they have been researched by psychological scientists.
Karla, did you learn how to write in cursive?
Karla:I sure did, Emily. I think it was about third grade. What about you?
Emily:Yes. Yeah, probably about the same. I remember the sheets where it had the two bold lines, a little dotted line in the middle to show you how tall to make the letters because some only went up halfway and then some went up the whole way. I remember the banners that would go around the top of the classrooms that would show the letters both printed, but then also in cursive. And remembering how say the cursive Q and cursive Z just looked so odd.
Emily:So yes, clearly remember working on my handwriting.
Karla:I was watching something where YouTube popped up and they were asking Gen Z to read and write things in cursive and they asked them, Do you think you can do this? And most people on YouTube, they would go into it and they're like, Yeah, we can do this. And they'd start writing a letter like Q or they'd lose their mind. But to be fair, to your credit too, I remember getting to those letters or the occasion that you would be on cue, like you'd be on cue for a whole week.
Emily:Oh yeah, yeah, yeah, because you also had to write so many cues too, we gotta get this right. It is like thinking about how people learn to write and then what type of handwriting, just the style that we have, sometimes I look back at old journals I kept in high school and college and sometimes I can see the quality of my handwriting is similar. Sometimes even though today if I'm looking at say different to do lists or other things that I'm writing down, my handwriting can vary dramatically. It doesn't always look like the same person wrote this. And this relates to the topic of today because some people claim that our handwriting reflects our personality.
Emily:That by examining people's handwriting, we can learn more about a big range of personality traits and other things about the person. So this is called graphology, but there is an issue here. Research suggests that we can't actually learn useful information about people's personality traits by examining their handwriting. My name is Emily Stark and I'm a social psychologist.
Karla:And my name is Karla Lassonde and I'm a cognitive psychologist and this is Brains Debunking Psychological Misconceptions.
Emily:So, graphology, or believing that we can learn about your personality from your handwriting, has been around since the eighteenth century when an Italian physician first discussed the idea that different aspects of writing, like say the slant of your letters, could signify different personality traits. And we are both professors who read a fair bit of student work and most of the things my students turning in are typed, but I have them do in class a lot, maybe just a quick reaction where they'll handwrite. Do you when you look at that student handwriting, do you sometimes think like, oh, this is that type of student or you're matching handwriting aspects to something about them? I
Karla:think that maybe the closest that I've come is thinking about gender and maybe look at that as more flowy or loopy and is that a woman? Conversely, this is really choppy or messy or hurried. Maybe that's a man. Coincidentally, my kids, they don't learn how to write in cursive right now anymore. And that's part of this whole thing, right?
Karla:But I have had teachers say that one of my kids, Oh, they write really nicely, really neatly for a boy. Wow. And not that, you know, psychology, kind of the crux of this is thinking about your personality, but also more in psychology, like how are things socialized? Are we socialized to reward one sex or gender for having certain types of handwriting? And does that bear out in what we see in our college students?
Karla:I don't know. I'm thinking in a loop here, but that's the closest that I've got.
Emily:That's so interesting. Cause yes, I think that I probably have that bias of expecting different types of handwriting from women versus men. But then when I actually look at student handwriting, it's so varied and all over the place that there's I probably, based on the research I'll be talking about here, should not be drawing any conclusions about them whatsoever from Yeah, the ways in right. Which they
Karla:as long as you can read it, I mean your next important variable is this accurate.
Emily:That's what they tell students. As long as I can read it, that's fine. When we look at what graphologists believe about handwriting, there's really quite a range in the types of things that they look at. So for example, some have said that wide spacing between words relates to a sense of isolation. Or if you're writing on a page, say, with outlines, if your handwriting like drifts upward on that page, then you're an optimist.
Emily:And another connection I found, if you have large round loops on your G or Y letters, that means you're preoccupied with sex. Yeah. Obviously. Not much on the why.
Karla:It's like top three variables, optimism,
Emily:maybe And anger, the general idea here between connecting handwriting to personality might make sense. You think about how handwriting, it's very individual. It's me just expressing my individuality. And so perhaps it could be that aspects of my personality are influencing my handwriting. One thing I found that I thought was really interesting when I was researching this topic is that handwriting analysis has been, and in many places still is, often used in job selection, more so in Western Europe perhaps than in The United States, but it has popped up in the hiring practices of some US companies.
Emily:I found a website for the Handwriting Analysts International. It had a specific menu for HR managers. So people who might be involved in the hiring process, and they claimed your handwriting is as integral to your true self as your fingerprints. And that handwriting analysis offers a way to identify someone's personality traits and aptitudes to determine if they fit a specific job. And so they had some examples of what they were directing HR managers to look for.
Emily:And one example was consider the lowercase letter T, is the T bar, is it midway or high or low on the T stem? Because the higher the bar is on the stem, the higher the person's goals and the more they will want to stretch their talents or abilities.
Karla:Wow.
Emily:And I didn't realize how much, say, handwriting, an examination of handwriting might be playing in to how we are judged from other people.
Karla:Yeah, if you think of the lore and the history going back to, what did you say, the eighteenth century, it's a product of each person. And in psychology, we know one of the things that makes our discipline new and sometimes hard is that explaining human behavior is really difficult. We can't see the brain. So we can see how this would have come out as, Hey, Emily, your handwriting looks like this, and can we use that to decipher who you are without asking you? So it's a classic investigation type of tool.
Karla:We don't certainly want to say, Oh, this is terrible. This is awful right away. But again, we want to look at the science behind this. So that's very specific, and it does start to lend itself to, Hey, if you're looking at the Ts and the crosses and the loops, that could be science.
Emily:Right? Yeah, yeah, it does sound science y that there is this defined thing that we are looking for. And you're absolutely right, we are constantly interested in learning about other people and learning about ourselves and trying to do that in a systematic way. I'm going to play a short snippet of a video I found. You'll hear a graphologist.
Emily:What he's doing is having people just write out different samples in front of him and then you'll hear him making some observations about what he's seeing in their handwriting.
graphologist clip:I mean, your eyes here, the dots, this is so you get irritated easily. Maybe you didn't like to write writing what I'm telling you to write. One of the first things that stands out is your tea. You see how it's it floats. It says you have a dry sense of humor.
graphologist clip:You also got a little hook in the front that says you want to acquire things. I don't know what you acquire, but something you like to acquire. You made your signature larger than your regular handwriting. This tells me when you're out in the public, you project yourself in a different image. It took you a while to design a signature like that.
graphologist clip:And what it's saying to me is you really don't want people to really know who you are. You notice this and this and frankly all the handwriting is identical. So you don't put on any airs for anybody.
Emily:So this video was outside, say the job selection or hiring context. And you heard him say one example that I like from there is, oh, that like that little loop or hook on the letter that indicates that you're trying to acquire something. So sometimes you can maybe see what the connection is. Like, oh, this looks like a hook that I might use to grab something. So that's what's happening in my personality.
Emily:And you mentioned you're using, like, is an investigative approach that is just so natural to humans. But graphology has been used in crime investigation. It's called forensic graphology. I found a web article written for a website called policeone.com pulls together a lot of information on policing. And it talked about using forensic graphology in cases that may be involved fraud or ransom notes.
Emily:And it suggested having suspects handwrite information during interrogations, and then to use their handwriting as insight into their guilt. So for example, they say nervous or shaky strokes or abrupt pressure changes or excessive corrections could indicate emotional stress or dishonesty. And I want to be clear, I'm not talking about say like matching signatures or forging signatures, that is a different type of thing. We're talking about can I learn about you and maybe if you're lying to me by looking at qualities of your handwriting?
Karla:Yeah, I've seen a few things too looking back at the FBI utilizing handwriting. We had talked about the polygraph again a few weeks And it seems like if this is going to be a good tool, then we should use it. And you can imagine why people buy into that sort of thing. But how about the implications of do you think you've committed this crime? We look at there was an article I read where they were looking at person A and person B, and they were having the journalist who was writing the article decide, Does person A look guilty or does person And B look there was a graphologist who actually had kind of briefed that journalist on these are the things that you're looking for.
Karla:What was interesting about it is the graphologist was feeding, Oh, don't you remember I told you that this Oh, boy. Yeah. And so not only was it it was interesting because they were kind of putting this person on the spot, but there was a little bit of coercion, might I say, Yes, in the
Emily:yes, just like we discussed with the polygraph. If someone has an initial bias that, oh, this person might be guilty, then they might be interpreting a polygraph in a certain way. Definitely could see the same thing happening with graphologists. And yes, if we are going to be using graphology to determine if someone might be guilty of a crime or to determine if someone should be hired for a job, then we better be very sure that yes, your personality is revealed in your handwriting. So we need to study.
Emily:Do certain aspects of personality reliably relate to characteristics of handwriting? So, graphologists claim that handwriting reveals aspects of our personality. How can we test this with valid research techniques? And there's a few different approaches that have been used. In one, we ask all participants to write the exact same sentence.
Emily:So that means it's the same, like, letters that are being produced that gives us little bit of consistency across sentences. And then we could ask multiple graphologists to independently analyze what they see in that sentence.
Karla:That's funny because going back to the way we began this particular topic, Remember when you're looking at the line and going across the middle, at one point we were like, no, you're not uniform enough. Now we're,
Emily:well the pendulum is long. So this type of study was actually done by a researcher back in 1977 with university students. And they specifically focused on extraversion. And the students had all taken a personality test, so we had a sense of where we would put them on the scale of extraversion. And then they all wrote the same sentence.
Emily:And, they looked for 16 different handwriting signs that were claimed to represent extraversion, but there was no connection between the handwriting of the students and the scores on the personality test.
Karla:Okay, so breaking that down a little bit, we have the analysis of their handwriting, and let's say you get put into the extroverted pile, but based on the graphology, and then in the personality assessment, are you also at the same perceived level of extroversion?
Emily:Yes, that's exactly the idea. What they found was that no, the graphologist might say you're extroverted based on your handwriting, but the personality test is not revealing that you're extroverted. So there wasn't a connection between this other measure of personality and what the graphologists were saying.
Karla:Right, and maybe to just remind the audience in terms of personality, one of the most valid ways of looking at a feature is introversion and extroversion. So we do have something called oceans, where it's known to be a way to look at these very distinct pieces of personality. So I like that they were using that part of the scientific assessment. And so just to let the audience know, one half of that piece of research had some sort of validity to
Emily:it. Yeah, that trait of extroversion introversion is one of what we call the big five personality traits. Like you mentioned, it has been studied extensively. We have a number of consistent and accurate measures that help us understand the extent to which someone is extroverted introverted. So yeah, that was a great personality trait to focus on, but it's not coming out in the handwriting analysis.
Emily:Okay, very good. I also mentioned we could look at, well, if we had multiple graphologists? And another study done in 1976 had six different handwriting analysts rate different handwriting samples and then they also compared those with actual scores on a personality assessment. Okay. And they found that the six didn't even agree with each other on the personality scales that were pulled out of the handwriting and whatever they suggested didn't map on to the personality tests anyways.
Emily:So again, we're not seeing connections between when we bring in some other measure of personality and then also ask graphologists to make assumptions about people.
Karla:Yeah, for our students interested in what that might be called, we talk about the inter rater reliability. Observation is a fairly long standing and typical way of looking at behavior. It'd be like, Okay, Emily, we are looking for signs of anxiety in the children that we're observing, and maybe whatever you think are the signs and whatever I think are the signs do not match. That would be a lack of interrayer reliability, and that's exactly what happened in that particular study.
Emily:Yes, yes, the raters did not agree with each other. Before I was talking about using graphology and job selection and some research has looked at this. So now, instead of comparing handwriting to personality tests, we're comparing handwriting to actual job performance. This was a study done in 1986 focused on bank employees, and they had like job performance histories of these actual employees, so they had the graphologists rate them on traits such as attention to detail. And then when they look at their actual job performance, they did not find a connection.
Karla:Oh, too bad.
Emily:Yes. So overall, back in 1992, a meta analysis was done where they take together all the existing studies, they found over 200 studies that included scientific tests of graphology and concluded that there is not a connection between handwriting and personality traits or job performance. So overall, graphology is considered a pseudoscience by the scientific community, which basically means that researchers have not been able to systematically show how specific aspects of handwriting relate to particular personality traits.
Karla:I see.
Emily:So although when graphologists talk about this, it might sound perhaps very precise and objective as if there is some type of science. That's where we use that word pseudoscience. Because it sounds scientific, but there's not any actual science backing it up. Or when we try to do those scientific studies, they do not show those connections.
Karla:Yeah, and I think for the listener, when you look at some of the studies that you've been citing, 1977 is a long time ago for many listeners. 1992 is even a long time ago, but going through decades of this research, we continue to look underneath the rock and say, Is it there yet? Do you see it yet? And it's pseudoscience because we cannot find using scientific tools that it's there. And sometimes that's frustrating to people, but it's worth the effort in saying, Yeah, we don't want to just throw everything out and say it's not scientific, but there's been a real earnest assessment of graphology.
Emily:Yes, we have tried to study it. And you mentioned inter rater reliability. And I just want to come back to that topic of reliability because it pops up in so much when we study these things where we might be using the word pseudoscience, or we might question the claims that someone is making. And reliability is a key aspect of a good measure. Like if I'm measuring your personality, maybe I'm giving you a scale of questions, or maybe I'm observing you interact with others at a party.
Emily:A reliable measure is one that is consistent. So if you take the test a few times, you should get about the same score. Or like you said, if multiple people observe you, they should all reach a similar conclusion about your personality trait.
Karla:Yeah, I think for thinking about what might help align that with what people know, A thermometer or a scale would be good examples of how do they fall in terms of reliability. And so if your scale's batteries cause it to be off your weight, unless you know that you've gained or lost a lot of weight, should be at least on the same day or maybe the next few days, you're going to see that you're measuring the same.
Emily:We want that consistency. And what we've learned from these scientific studies of graphology is that it isn't consistent. So when we have multiple graphologists, they reach different conclusions. Whenever you see that lack of reliability, that is also a good warning sign that we are dealing with pseudo science.
Karla:Got it.
Emily:One last related concept here is what's called the Barnum effect or the Fourier effect. And this refers specifically to when we find vague personality descriptions, like say your typical horoscope, seem to represent key details about ourselves. And so some of those claims that you hear graphologists make, like that little video snippet where they said, oh the hook on this letter suggests you're trying to acquire something. While that might sound somewhat specific, that could apply to pretty much anyone. Right?
Emily:Like, I can definitely think of something I want, right? So, Yeah, it's vague, but if I am just thinking about, oh my gosh, I do want this thing. You're pulling that out from my handwriting. I'm not necessarily, we are not natural scientists. I'm not walking around going, but how many people want to acquire something?
Emily:What's our control group?
Karla:I don't know about you.
Emily:And I do that a lot. I do do that a don't do it enough.
Karla:Question everything. Yeah, when you think of people going to get Chinese food and the favorite fortune cookie, really think about my kids, they will actually trade fortunes or be upset if their fortune doesn't predict something that's universal and positive. Like, you are going to have something amazing happen to you this week, or you're going to come into money. Like, it's, you know, that trade of, will this be widely accepted as good? Oh, yes, it's my fortune.
Emily:Yep, yep, yep. And I mean, it's a general human bias and it makes it difficult for us to accurately judge statements, whether it's coming from a fortune cookie or from a graphologist, we have to rely on well designed research to help us overcome this tendency. So even if graphology could feel really interesting, like there's something there, when we do the research, it's not showing a connection between your handwriting and your personality.
Karla:Got it. Let's look at some key takeaways.
Emily:All right.
Karla:When we are studying graphology or this idea that we can find out information about our personality from our handwriting, overall we find that there is no scientific evidence to support this, maybe something that we want to believe's claim, but it does not bear out in terms of science.
Emily:Exactly. Again, even if it seems intuitive that something as personal as my handwriting would relate to other unique characteristics that I have, Research has studied this and have not found any consistent connections between handwriting and personality traits. This is a pseudoscience and graphology is not an effective way to screen job candidates or to learn about others or ourselves. You heard it here on Brains versus Beliefs. You can learn more about this podcast on our website called communicatingpsychologicalscience.com.
Emily:You'll find references and a link to the episode. Feel free to contact us on our website with any comments or ideas for future episodes and follow Brains versus Beliefs wherever you find podcasts. Thanks for listening.