Scalability School

Question: How should you change your Meta ads plan for Black Friday 2026?
Direct answer: Expect Black Friday Meta ads to report worse than last year even when sales hold, because Meta now counts only link clicks as click-through conversions and moved saves, shares, comments and video views into engage-through attribution. Set Black Friday targets against aMER (new customer revenue divided by ad spend) using this year's ratio to Meta-reported ROAS, make same-day decisions from aMER and your MTA rather than Ads Manager, and don't change attribution settings or debut new Meta tools during the sale. Assume the budget you set is not the budget that spends, keep new and returning customers in separate campaigns, and launch your real offer at least two weeks before Black Friday.


Black Friday Meta ads are going to report worse this year than last, even if
your sales hold, because Meta changed how it counts click-through conversions
in 2026. Andrew Foxwell and Brad Ploch break down everything that changed since
last November: the new attribution rules, how to set Black Friday targets with
aMER instead of Meta-reported ROAS, four Meta settings to handle carefully over
the weekend, and why the 2026 calendar will throw off your comps.

We discuss:

- The 2026 Black Friday calendar: a 21-day window and why Friday, Dec 11 matters
- Why Cyber Monday back in November breaks month-by-month comps
- Meta's click attribution change: link clicks only, engage-through for the rest
- How to set Black Friday targets with aMER, not Meta-reported ROAS
- Why Ads Manager can't steer your spend on Black Friday day
- Meta's rolling budget option and the weekend overspend risk
- The new customer acquisition setting vs separate new and returning campaigns
- Flex ads, incrementality and why Black Friday isn't the time to test
- Black Friday creative under Andromeda and GEM
- Offers, VIP early access, agentic commerce and the Black Friday don'ts

Get the Scalability School newsletter (free, short, no spam):
https://www.scalabilityschool.com/scalability-newsletter

Listen to the full podcast: scalabilityschool.com/scalability-school-podcast-Your-Meta-ROAS-Will-Look-Worse-This-Black-Friday

Last week, Zach's $100K Black Friday morning: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=pX7q1FYlqwE
The BFCM tactics that worked last year: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=T9ilMMhToBE
Learn more: https://www.scalabilityschool.com

Scalability School is a weekly show from Andrew Foxwell, Brad Ploch, and Zach
Stuck about what is actually working right now in DTC growth. No theory, no
recycled LinkedIn takes, just the numbers and decisions behind real brands and
real ad accounts.

This episode of the Scalability School podcast is sponsored by NorthBeam and they just launched Northbeam Incrementality. Northbeam Incrementality gives you easy, automated, self-service incrementality tests, while protecting you from the major mistakes so many people make while running incrementality tests. Your MTA handles the daily tactics, your MMM guides the long-term planning, and Incrementality provides the causal truth. It’s a closed loop that allows you to scale what works and cut what doesn't. Right now when you head over to www.northbeam.io/incrementality, they’re offering Scalability School listeners 50% off unlimited tests for a year when you join. Just tell them we sent you.

This episode of Scalability School is sponsored by Alia, the AI-powered pop-up platform. Head to aliapopups.com, book a demo, and mention AI DTC WTF for an extended 45-day free trial.

Chapters

00:00 Black Friday Meta ads: what changed since last November
01:25 Black Friday 2026 dates: why your pacing and comps are off
06:29 Meta's attribution change and setting Black Friday targets with aMER
13:29 Meta rolling budgets and the Black Friday overspend risk
17:58 Should you use Meta's new customer acquisition setting for BFCM?
20:03 Flex ads and incrementality: don't debut new tools on Black Friday
21:22 Black Friday creative under Andromeda and GEM
22:54 Black Friday offers: launch early, skip the teaser, run VIP access
26:36 Agentic commerce: prep your site for AI shopping traffic
29:01 What not to do on Black Friday (and the case for a promo lander)

What is Scalability School?

Scalability School is your cheat code for building a more profitable DTC brand or agency.

We break down tactical strategies, real-time wins, and tough lessons from three powerful perspectives: operator, agency, and community. It's not theory—it's what's actually working in the wild. Skip the fluff, steal what works, and scale with confidence.

Meta is measuring differently

than it was last Black Friday.

So this is the biggest change

of the year.

You're starting to look year over year.

It's going to look worse.

Like by default it's going to be worse.

It doesn't mean it is worse.

So what this did in Q1 is it reported.

You know there's CPA jumps across.

There's like 2,030% overnight

a lot of accounts while the back end

revenue didn't really move.

So Meadows rolling

budget option

lets a daily budget flex

across a seven day window

instead of spending the full amount

that day.

So that's a direct hit

to the most important mechanic

of the entire weekend,

and do not build a promo specific lander.

I do think the promo

specific landing page

is something that can work really well,

and the landing page still had a

20% increase in efficiency.

Let's talk about it.

Number one, segment one

the calendar no one has looked at yet.

So, Brad,

this is a thing that I know is really

you wanted to continue to call out.

We called it out

in one other episode two,

but the dates are Thanksgiving's November

26th, Black Friday, November 27th.

Everyone moved.

Everything moves up one day.

So Monday before Black Friday

through December 13th is 21 days.

It was 19 and 24 and 20 and 25

and 24 and 2023.

So, you know,

it's it's in the middle

a little bit longer.

And December 13th is a Sunday.

So the last real shipping

weekday is Friday, December 11th.

So Brad, why does all this matter.

There's a there's a couple of things

you got to keep in mind for this.

So I think the first thing

is just pacing in general.

So you're going to be setting

you know

you're going to be setting goal targets.

The first thing that the finance team

or the marketing team is going to do

is are going to look at year

over year comes and they're going to say,

what should November

look like as a whole?

What should December

look like as a whole?

It usually wouldn't seem to do this.

They kind of do them individually.

They kind of do a month by month,

which I think makes sense

for most of the year.

But obviously this is a unique time

of year.

Cyber Monday for the last two years

was in December.

And so,

you know, two, two years ago now,

we were having the same

conversations like,

oh shit, cyber

Monday is in December, it's not November.

So how do we adjust comps

and pacing for that?

So that's the first thing to keep in mind

is when you're

you're thinking about your pacing

and even just like setting goals

in the first place.

You're, you know, your, your,

your comps,

which we'll talk about

a second are going to be

be a little bit messed up.

But just like pacing in

general is going to be important to,

to keep in mind.

So and I think I've said this

in a previous episode on Black Friday,

but I'll make a follow up here

where, like I did

last year,

where I kind of

go through like, here's

how you can actually build

your pacing sheet for this year

and kind of break it down into daily

and then hourly targets.

But, Black Friday is earlier.

Cyber Monday is still in November.

That matters a lot.

And then to the point that you just made,

the the window is

actually spreading out a little bit more.

If you're listening to this podcast,

you've probably heard

about the Foxwell founders community.

It's a community of the best

digital marketers in the world,

brought together in slack

and a bunch of other tools

that help us communicate, support,

and take care of one another.

It's got 600 members from 30 countries,

and we spend an average of 500 million

a month just on meta.

So if you're advertising on meta,

if you're taking control of your own ads,

if you're doing stuff on TikTok,

Pinterest, Google,

you're doing things with CRO,

you're doing landing page testing,

you need help with pixels.

I mean, on and on and on.

There's not a better place

than the Foxwell Founders membership.

Apply today

at Foxwell founders.com,

and let us know why

you think you'd be a great member.

So what does that mean?

It's a good question.

And I don't know that I have like

the perfect answer to this, but

does that mean that,

the the the revenue

gets spread across more days

because there's actually more time

from the Monday before Black Friday

through the shipping cutoff?

Or does it just kind of hold the same?

You know,

I think that's

that's something

you'll have to analyze your own,

your own data to dig into.

But just yeah, from a pacing perspective,

just you just got to start to know

that the days fall differently.

So you just want to be prepared for that.

Yeah I think common

same same day the same day instead.

Right.

I think that's important to look

at versus the calendar.

Because the calendar, if you look at that

screw, is going to screw it up.

I think that people

make the majority of their revenue

on starting promos early.

I think that people

have really started to do that,

and then they make the big hits on the

Black Friday, Cyber Monday.

So all that we're saying

is, I think just be

aware of the timing

of when all this hits, right?

Because,

you just you get one

extra gifting day after Cyber Monday,

versus last year.

So yeah,

just kind of keeping all this in mind.

Yeah.

And like,

I guess, like a bonus

tip is just like you,

you actually noted this.

I didn't realize,

but given that December 13th is a Sunday,

you know,

a lot of shipping cut offs

tend to be kind of early like that.

So you should be checking

with your provider

and seeing what that actually looks like.

And then if you're on Amazon,

you need to be thinking about

what am I doing

from shipping

cut off on the website

through actual shipping,

cut off on Amazon.

What does my advertising change

or pointing people towards? Amazon?

What are we doing there?

And how do we adjust our targets?

Because all of a sudden

that is going to look like shit,

even though traffic

might be going to Amazon, it's

just other things to

keep in mind in there,

which again, I'll kind of go through

when we

dig into that pacing video specifically.

But yeah,

your comps are also going

to look really weird year over year.

So if you have the ability

to go back to 2023

and like if you're

if you've been around that long

and you've got a decent amount of data,

then you can actually get a perspective

of what this might look like.

But the last few years

will throw it off a little bit.

So what I like to do

is just combine November

and December into one big chunk,

but the whole like it's

not a Q4 number,

but it's like a Q4 minus October number

and then divide it

across the days by putting Friday

where it lines up on Black

Friday, Cyber Monday where it lines up,

and then adjusting that way.

Okay, perfect. So I think,

lots to say.

Just be aware of these dates.

We'll move on to the next piece.

So meta second part here is meta

is measuring differently than it was

last Black Friday.

So this is the biggest

change of the year.

Probably going to

it could cause some bad decision

making on Black Friday morning.

So what changed is

meta tightened

the click attribution in early 26.

Only actual outbound link

clicks count

as click through conversions.

Now like saves,

shares, comments and video views

move to engage through

which is a one day window

and the engage

gauge view threshold for video

drop from ten 10s to five,

and the old seven day

click no longer exists.

If you

if your ad set says seven day click,

it is the new seven day click.

So what this did in Q1 is it reported.

You know there's CPA jumps across.

There's like 2,030% overnight

a lot of accounts

while the back end revenue

didn't really move.

So it hits harder.

And by Friday, Cyber Monday a week

because the two weeks before the sale

already show

roughly a 40% gap between one day and 30

day click.

And that gap widens

as you approach the sale.

So layer the reclassification on top,

and pre Bfsi

reporting looks worse than it ever has.

Anyone benchmarking Bfsi m 26 against 25

inside Ads

manager is comparing

two different measurement systems.

I think you have to be aware of that.

So

all of these things just say Brad,

what can people do about this

with these changes? Yeah.

So since the changes happened,

I think the best thing you could do

is like,

look at if your,

let's assume

that you kind of know what I like to,

I like to understand

the relationship between a Amr.

So acquisition and the R,

which is just new customer

revenue divided by ad spend.

And my meta reported Roas number.

Whether you're using seven day

click, you're using an MTA

reported number,

whatever it is like,

you understand the relationship

between those two things.

And in this case

particularly looking at meta.

So let's say your

your aim

typically reports

a three and meta reports of two.

You've got a one

and a half multiplier

from meta to a more.

And like just assume that's correct.

If you have if you have like incremental

reads like

you've done

actual haul that test and no,

then you can just continue

to rely on those. Probably.

But basically what this means is

you want to understand the relationship

between those two things historically,

but you need to update it for this year.

So this post post click change.

If you look at like June,

like you just pick a random month,

you look at June year over year

and you're looking at your seven day

click attribution window.

You're looking at different

forms of attribution.

So this year should look worse,

unless all of a sudden

you just got better at marketing

and something changed

and all of a sudden

you were more efficient.

I think that's the biggest point.

And so as you're setting,

you know, targets for this year,

you just have to think like, okay, well,

how is the relationship changed?

So if you're two in meta it's now

a one five,

but you're getting the same me a Amr.

Then you should be adjusting

your Black Friday

targets in the same way,

and just kind of know if you're starting

to look your over year,

it's going to look worse.

Like by default it's going to be worse.

It doesn't mean it is worse.

So you just have to understand

that relationship.

But here's the tricky thing

about Black Friday

anyways, is that I don't know, like,

especially if you're you're a high

AOV tool,

if you open up meta in like,

let's say it's noon on the same day

and you look at your,

your meta reported, it's going to look

almost always look horrible

because it's not caught up

like there's, there's,

there's still that 4872 hour delay

or up

to just because of iOS

and their privacy modeling changes.

And so it just looks like shit,

which means it's really hard to use meta

on the same day

to make this like to on Black Friday.

You can almost like not rely on meta

at all

to make decisions

for how much you're spending.

You kind of

have to rely on

like something like Amer and just like,

you know, use that as the guide,

which I think is

the is the best default

and then use an MTA

to a multi-touch attribution tool

like a North Beam or triple or whatever.

If whatever

you're using to make make decisions

because you can

you can rely a little bit

more on their kind of like click based

or last click models in that moment. So,

yeah, I think it's

good to know,

like how your attribution has changed.

Like how does seven day click

look different your viewers

so you can have that understanding.

But it's probably

not going to be very useful regardless,

when it comes to the actual day

of Black Friday, it's

more of the leading up into Black Friday.

Yeah.

I mean,

I think you're always wanting

to make sure that you're

I mean, I think let's talk about

do this before November. Right.

Put the a m or expectation in writing,

put last year's Black Friday

numbers today and note

which attribution setting produce them

and kind of lay that out.

The caveat goes

you know like

I would put that in front of your clients

like soon now. Right.

Then decide whether you're running

click only click plus engage

through or testing one day

engage through the weekend.

I would not change the attribution

settings mid weekend

I don't know I mean probably Brad are you

which one of these

are you going to run

for high growth accounts in your opinion.

Like are we doing click

click buzz engage or one day engage.

Yeah I think you just need to stick

with what you've done

like for up to this point.

Like whatever's working right now,

I would not take Black Friday

to be the time that you test

if you want to have

some backup campaigns.

I think David Herman made

a good point of this last year.

He was using incremental attribution.

So, like,

you can set up backup campaigns

that are running on these,

and if all of a sudden

your MTA tool is reporting that,

that campaign attribution is much better.

You know,

like in theory,

one click

sounds like it should be the thing

that works the most during Black Friday.

That doesn't mean it will.

You can have it as a backup,

but I would not deviate from

what you've used up to this point.

Yeah.

And I would also say

a delivery consequence worth airing right

and click only fewer

signals can mean higher CPM,

because fewer people will get predicted

to purchase at the same budget.

So that's something to just

kind of throw out there.

I think, you know,

having an idea of what the a m

r expectation is,

having an idea of what

your sort of percentage is of

your north beam versus

what it looks like in reality with armor.

Right.

We've talked about this

a little bit in the past

and other episodes,

but making sure that that

that the relationship of understanding

of what it looks like,

what it says it is in Shopify,

what it says

it is in North

Beam, and making sure that you're

you're choosing

how you're following that

to scale things up and scale things down.

I think that's been a real challenge

for advertisers over

the last few years is like

really understanding

what number am I looking at to know?

Because, you know,

they're like, oh, I'm an import form guy.

And you're like,

okay, well, you're losing out

because you don't know.

It's just not pulling up, like you said,

especially Black Friday.

Just like it's going to be wrong.

Like there's no way

you can make it's very hard

to make good decisions on Black Friday

if you're using it in platform.

Reported number

just doesn't move fast enough.

And do you think still kind of.

One thing we talked about last

year was running a one day

click separate retention campaign

on a high min Roas.

I think that's still a good idea here.

I mean,

even though the definition changed,

do you disagree with that

as something we talked about last year?

No, I think you might have to

adjust that.

You might have to adjust

your attribution target.

I guess down in this case,

because now it's a little bit

more conservative of a

one day click bid

because it's not including

some of those engaged view things.

But yeah, no 100% still do that.

I think it'll be really solid this year.

Okay, cool.

All right.

Segment three

we're talking about four settings

that did not exist last November.

So let's talk about this like these are

these just kind of settings

that will quietly change

what your budget does in Black Friday.

So number one, rolling budgets okay.

Now some have called this

the sleeper problem the sleeper problem.

So Meadows rolling budget

option lets a daily budget

flex across a seven day window

instead of spending the full amount

that day.

So that's a direct hit

to the most important mechanic

of the entire weekend.

The working math is six x normal daily

spend on day one,

3.3 x on midday, when mid window days

and 0.5 to 1 x of your whole

October spend across

Friday through Monday.

Every one of these numbers assumes

the budget you set is the budget

that spends.

So, you know,

I think just kind of

throwing it out there.

Do you think this is a good idea?

Do you think we should do this?

Do you think this is something to test?

Do you think you do lifetime budgets?

You know,

what's your opinion of rolling budgets?

That and you know,

I mean, what you're hearing about it,

what you've seen, work with it, etc..

All right, friends, quick break.

This episode is brought to you

by North Beam,

the marketing attribution platform

that we love over here

at Scalability School.

If you're a marketer,

I mean, you probably agree, right?

Incremental testing is broken.

They these tests require

tons of labor spreadsheets to reference,

and the designing of the test

is slow and error prone.

How are you supposed to know

what to test in the first place? Right?

There's a million factors

that can make incremental

testing difficult.

But the good news is North

Beam has completely changed the game

and they fix this.

Only North

Beam incrementally

automates your incremental test

design and monitoring,

while protecting you

from the major mistakes

that plague incremental testing.

North beam builds tests

using your own MTA data,

launches them directly

in ad platforms,

and automatically

monitors them throughout.

If something threatens validity,

you're alerted before

it ruins the result.

With North Beam,

you can launch tests in platform

with a single click,

saving you tons of time

and reducing any chance for errors.

And when the

test concludes, your results

flow straight into your MTA,

meaning you can easily

see results

alongside the rest of your data.

Incrementally. Was broken.

North beam fixed it.

Hey, this is Andrew from Foxwell Digital.

This episode is sponsored

by Aliya Quick Gottschalk.

What did it cost you

to get someone to your site last month?

Now think about

how many of those people left

without giving you any way to reach them.

Again, that's money you already spent

walking out the door.

Often, the fastest way

to grow your email and SMS list

isn't more traffic,

it's capturing the traffic

you've already have.

And that's what Aliyah does.

It's an

AI powered

pop up platform

that turns more of your visitors

into high quality subscribers

without touching ad spend.

More than 5000 brands use it like Nike

Strength, Peloton Grooms,

Hollow Socks, Mars Men

and the brands commonly

see 2 to 3 times

more signups in their first 30 days.

So go to all the pop ups and book a demo.

Our listeners

get an extended free 45 day trial,

so make sure you tell them

that Andrew Fox will set you.

Yeah,

anybody who runs cost controls

like pretty,

pretty extensively knows

that the day after a promo,

if you don't go

manually adjust your bids down

is like

it's a really it's a recipe

to just like blow money.

And obviously like,

you know,

people who are running,

you know, auto bid and kind of like

giving meta the ability

to spend their full budget.

They know

to go pull their budget back

the day after.

And so I think

it'll be really interesting to see this,

but I think it just means you're going

to have to probably more aggressively

be thinking about

what's your total like, what what

what total

are you allowing to meta

to spend during the day,

and how are you changing it

throughout the course of the day?

And so

I actually think you did an episode.

There's,

there's an episode somewhere

on this YouTube channel with,

forgetting his name off

top, my head, but he talks about like,

intraday scaling, I believe.

So that's probably something to

to dig into. But Brandon Fink yes.

Yes. Brandon. Yeah.

Yeah.

So an insane if you're not seeing that.

It's actually not something

we released on audio wise.

But it's on the YouTube channel.

And it's insane. Intraday scaling stuff.

I mean it's

I wouldn't recommend it for

for the faint of heart.

Yeah.

You got

you got to have your big boy pants on

if you're going to be doing that shit.

Yeah.

And then so I guess

like the

maybe the tactical thing you can do

right now is like, go

look to

a recent promo that you've had

that's been a bigger one

and see what happens to your budgets

leading the week up.

And then,

probably primarily

after like Friday into Saturday, Sunday.

I think that's probably

where the biggest opportunity

for it

to overspend would be,

because it got a ton of signal on Friday

that it's going to crush,

and then into Saturday and Sunday.

You need to be just like conscious

of how you're pacing.

And so if you're pacing

too hot in the morning

on Saturday or Sunday,

you know, to go

adjust your bids down even further,

pull the budgets back even further.

I'm not

I don't I've never really been

a big lifetime budget kind of guy.

But I think

this any interesting strategy. Yeah.

I mean

I think it's something that, you know,

I've never been big on this,

but I think it's interesting.

Give it a shot. See what happens.

You know, an option for you. Right.

And I think if you

cost control the property

like you talked about,

it's an interesting one.

Even if it's on something like a,

you know, more of a retention style

potentially, or,

you know, warm customers.

And that's interesting one.

So there's a lot of opportunity

to think about that number

two thing that did not exist

last November,

acquiring new customers

at the asset level. Okay.

So this is a real setting now

not the old broad plus exclusions thing.

You know

this is doing a genuinely decent job

of reaching net new customers.

CTAs are higher in platform

reads lower course

because you

strip out the returning buyers.

But the tension

I think that's worth abating.

Here is Bfsi

is one of the best acquisition

windows of the year.

I mean

it is the best and CPA's drop

because everyone's in by mode.

So do you

turn on new customer acquisition

for the weekend

or do you not turn this on?

Right.

I think this is sort of like contrasting

with the old ASC debate, which is,

you know, do you do 0% new, you know,

0% existing

and then walk it up through the weekend,

whatever you do.

I mean, I would decide

on this and test this,

kind of

what's your opinion on, on this one.

And it's something you could use

during BFS.

Yeah.

I'm generally

I mean there's probably

some caveats to this.

And so if anybody is wondering like

would this work for my brand,

feel free to leave a comment.

And we can we can give you a better,

nuanced response.

But I generally think

that especially during this time period,

you should separate do

and returning customers

into separate campaigns because

and this is actually true

for most of the years.

Like they just have

a different incremental waiting.

It's easier

for people who have

purchased from you before,

especially if it's recently,

to come back and buy again.

They don't need as much convincing.

They just want to see the sale.

They're going to come back and buy.

And then that also gives meta.

It gives you like a clearer

kind of understanding of who's responding

to what as well.

And you could set targets appropriately.

So if you're a cross control person,

you can set your bids differently.

And even if you're not

using cost controls,

you can still just like

adjust the bids or, sorry,

adjust the budgets

and hold them to different standards.

So I generally lean on

keeping them separate.

Yeah, it makes sense. It's interesting.

So yeah, something to think about if you,

you know,

if you're just don't make decisions

on these things like later. Okay.

Just like try this stuff now.

See what it works. See what's helping.

Let's talk about flex ads.

Right.

Automated creative combination testing

I think flex ads overall for doctor

advertisers have been a win

but wouldn't debut it

during the main event.

But would you be running some?

Are you going to be running

some flex ads in your opinion?

Brad yeah, I think if you

if you if they work for you

now, there's no reason to to deviate off.

I think it's nice

that you can just like

load up a bunch of your,

your Black Friday

specific assets into flex ads.

But to me

if you're running them evergreen,

you're just going to keep

those things rolling.

But, yeah, I think it's a great idea.

But to to

to the point that you just made,

I think that's true

for all of these things is like

Black Friday

is probably not the time to, like,

use most of your budget

testing strategies

if you want to reserve 20% of it

to to see if it'll stuff will hit,

and if it hits,

you could scale it up or down intraday.

But otherwise, yeah,

I would not be just yellowing new things

and you're out of count.

I mean, the thing that the reason

we're bringing this stuff

up, right, is

because we want you to be like,

okay, these are new things.

What do we do with them in Black Friday

and how do we

that's sort of why

we're bringing this up.

And the fourth

one to mention is incremental, right.

Wouldn't do in

sort of incremental

testing in Q4 or in BFS.

I'm rather

it's just not going to be

no, you

know, it's not going to be useful

for you. Don't debut stuff.

The note here is don't debut

some stuff, new stuff

at this period of time.

Let's go to the

let's go to the fourth idea

for segment creative under Gen. Right.

So we have the previous episode.

We called about specific

creative tactics.

You know, I would say

leave your evergreen on.

Do not rely on them to carry the weekend.

And you know, don't stop reskilling them.

But like leave the evergreen ads on.

This is a

one that we talked about last year.

It's huge.

But you also want to try

to make creative specific to the moment,

because different people under Gen

and under Andromeda

respond to different types of things.

Some people are promo responders,

some people respond to

social proof stuff.

You know, it depends. Right.

So making sure that you have a variety

is big.

And you know,

we keep seeing like Black Friday

and gifting specific creative

take a larger share of spend.

So meta seems to like that.

You know,

as I would

say, as the years have gone on, last year

it was more than I'd seen in a while.

So look,

you just got to make more of it, right?

Distinct concepts.

Not for hooks on one

angle that you're swapping out,

like you got to do

a lot of different things.

Anything to say about this

as it relates to diversifying

creative know?

I think you

you brought this up on the previous

like tactic review episode

and why it probably works

so well last year.

But I think the biggest point

is that,

the, the specific creative is,

is working better year over year.

It doesn't mean pause evergreen,

it just means I think it's worth

putting more time and attention

into the Black Friday

and the gifting specific stuff this year,

because I think it grows again

as a percentage of overall

spend in accounts on average.

Yeah, well,

you're noticing themes

and the things that we're saying

and I think hope that's true

because these are things

that are important. Important.

Segment five,

the offer and the calendar

where things didn't change. Right.

I think there's

a whole bunch of things to talk about

that are just

valid points to bring up one.

Launch a minimum of two weeks

out with your real offer, right?

I think a teaser doesn't do much for you.

Do you agree with this?

What do you think?

Like,

I think

if you can go strong with your offer,

I think it's helpful

with a sweetener on Bfsi.

N what do you think?

Yeah, I,

I think we always suggest

if you're comfortable

starting November 1st

let it rip start November 1st.

I'm sure there's going to be brands who,

you know, tend to not do that or,

you know, they want to go.

I mean,

I don't know

many brands who just do the Thursday

through Friday at this point.

And I think, like most people start

at least by the Monday before now,

but I think

November 1st or two weeks

before is totally safe.

I don't know how I feel

about the sweetener piece just because,

like you,

you run the risk of

potentially pissing off

customers that bought earlier.

So that's where I always get a little bit

hung up.

But I think it could be

brand by brand case.

The thing that I do like

is something that Zach did last year,

which was kind of the, the intraday

what our flash sale things

to maybe

clear out some of the funnel

that wasn't buying

or maybe would buy more.

So that's

that's where I like it the most.

I tend to not be like a

hey we're going to launch with 20% off,

and then on Black Friday

we're going to step it up to 30% off.

I think it just means that

it leaves people.

It leaves room for people

to be skeptical about if

if this is the best offer.

And so if you can make it the best offer

and communicate that, that's good.

And I don't know that I think people feel

that they have a Black Friday

offer running for four weeks,

like it's falling on deaf

ears and eyeballs

and just don't think that's true,

especially if

this is like one of the best times

for new customer acquisition

throughout the year. So,

I just don't think it

starts to fall on deaf ears

maybe to your email list.

And that's where

some of the sweeteners can come in.

But if you're reaching

net new eyeballs, then,

I don't think it does.

Yeah.

I mean, I think to your point, right.

It was something like,

the hourly deals that Jack had with gift

with purchase was like, totally absurd.

Like it.

What did he say?

Something like it moved revenue 50 to 142

K to 172 K,

while holding it a nine x mark.

Yeah.

And so,

you know,

it's like I think

I think for a while we

we thought that it had to be one offer,

one product for,

you know, the whole thing. And that's it.

Make it simple.

And like

I think actually people are coming back.

They're seeing the ads.

They're at their relative's house

looking at Instagram.

They're like, yeah,

I'm going to get that.

And it's like,

if it's a different hourly offer,

it makes sense.

And to that point,

sending a ton of emails

and a bunch of SMSes a lot like I think

Zach said it was like 20 emails and 5 or

6 texts or something, right.

Was was like not out of line with him.

So I think it's kind of interesting.

The

what do you think about VIP early access,

as it relates to, to Q4

and or to BFS

and going through this like it,

I think it's

I think it's cool

and I think but it's important

to make sure that,

if you're going to do VIP,

I think you explain it.

I like plain text.

I mean, SMS is a great example for this,

but I like plain text emails

for this reason

because you can clearly say like, hey,

like you,

if you go to the website right

now, you're not going to see this offer.

That's important because we're giving you

the special offer.

And here's what the special offer is.

If you want to wait

until like Friday, that's fine.

But the offer on the website at that

time will be this.

And so I think

as long as you can

clearly communicate to customers

and make them feel like they are truly

getting a VIP deal,

I like it quite a bit. We run that.

If clients have said yes in the past,

we run it as as many times as possible.

So I think it works really well

as long as you can explain it to people.

So let's talk about the next segment

of segment six, the

kind of the

piece that nobody really budgeted for,

nobody really thought about,

which is a Genta Commerce,

which is here, and AI referral traffic.

Right.

Shopify

now has

this muse is pushing shit through.

People can sell inside of ChatGPT.

There's a lot here. Right.

And it's and it's going up significantly.

I think that there's

there's something to say.

If you look at post-purchase surveys,

we know that this stuff is happening.

So it's like,

what can you do now to prepare for this?

You know, I think you

you want to probably do a couple things.

I wouldn't

probably build

Q4 plan around this,

but it's something that like

going into next year,

you know, really need

to be taking seriously,

making sure that your sale terms,

the discount, the shipping cutoff

and the return policy

are readable as structured data,

not just baked into a banner image.

So making sure that that's like

listed out as text, on the site

so that it can read that as really big

because people will

be searching that way.

Adding a GA

for if you're looking at Ga4

right filter to separate the AI traffic.

So you can sort of

like have an idea of what came from,

you know, a

stuff over this period of time.

Right.

And make sure the PDP's

answer questions

that a person would type into a chat box,

really try to walk through, like,

what are the questions?

What are the FAQs?

I think this is going to be

this is it's small stuff,

but I think it's important.

The structured data is important.

And you can

we can put some resources

that show notes about how to do this.

Not that difficult,

but it'll make it much more readable so

that you can do that better.

Can you ask and like, can you give a PDP?

I know basically nothing about this,

but yeah,

can you give your PDP

to an LLM and say like,

how do I make this more discoverable,

particularly during Black Friday?

Yes. Amazing.

Somebody, a friend asked me,

how did you learn how to do this?

I was like,

I don't know, I fucking ass clawed

how to do it.

Yeah, that's what I did.

So it's like,

you know,

it's like, how did you figure it out?

Oh just ask.

So yes, it does do this.

And that's something that we've done

with all of our Foxtel digital stuff.

And this is

I know that we're a little bit different

in Foxtel Digital and Fox founders.

But you know

we get on average now

about 10 to 20 applications

a month just from AI.

So it's pretty

amazing what comes through

because we've done a ton

with structured data.

So

let's talk about a couple of things

on segment eight.

There's

these are kind of recap pieces.

But I think we want to talk about right.

Don't compare number one.

Don't compare meta reported numbers.

So last year's it talks about that.

Number two don't debut new meta tool.

Right. Number three.

Don't consolidate down to one

winning ad because it looks

the most efficient gems

going to punish you on that.

Number four,

don't assume the budget

that you set is the budget that spends.

Okay.

So it will spend more if it's doing well.

So just be prepared for that.

You know, don't gas the account

completely in November and starve Q1.

So make sure that you model

Q1 inventory

to commuting before

committing to Q4 spend.

Do not discount thin inventory.

Lean into urgency instead,

and do not build a promo specific lander.

I don't think

I think you want it to be on the website.

If you possibly if you can do that,

because that's the thing

that meta knows the best.

And don't try not to panic.

I know I said don't two weeks

before the sale, right?

It's always terrible.

So just prepare yourself

that it's going to be

that it's going to be going to be bad.

You know,

I think there's some other things

to say, Brad. Any comments on that?

I would

I do think the promo

specific landing page

is something that can work really well.

So I would

if I,

if I'm if I'm picking fighting words

out of anything here,

I do think that can work really well

if we've been testing this

a lot more recently.

So you know we've seen fourth,

we had a brand during 4th of July.

We built a promo specific landing page.

They they like

doctored up their homepage.

They added all the stuff

which you should do.

Like I'm not saying don't do this

because there's going to be traffic

that lands in your home page

that doesn't go to your,

your, your LP,

but you should, you know,

get the announcement bar set up.

You could maybe change your hero

image, whatever.

You should add tags

and make sure that it's very clear

what your sale is.

They did all of that,

and the landing page still had a 20%

increase in efficiency,

and new customer

traffic was even better than that

by sending the traffic

to a landing page first.

So I do think that you can do that.

And if you need any ideas on those,

you can just send me a DM on Twitter

and I can send you some examples

or build one for you. So

yeah, that can work really well,

but nothing else to add. Otherwise

it's good.

You know,

I think it's something that we saw

that was in the notes

and it was like,

let's be careful about that.

And so it's good

if there's a specific lander that's good.

You've seen it doing a lot more

and that's that's awesome

I appreciate it. Okay.

So we just went through

a whole bunch of shit.

We went through a lot and not shit.

It's actually good stuff.

Really good shit is what it is.

So thank you for listening.

Hopefully this is helpful to you

as you start to prepare for

everything that you're doing.

Brad, any final words?

No, I mean, sleep now.

Maybe,

make sure you have childcare prepared,

tell your relatives

you love them,

and you'll see them

after you retire on Thanksgiving

one of these years.

I don't know.

So you're you're busy.

You got to lock in.

That's right, that's right.

All right, well,

thank you for listening, everybody,

and have an awesome rest of your day.

The only way

that we

grow this podcast is by

you sharing it with your friends.

Honestly, like, reviews

kind of don't really mean anything

too much anymore.

They're really meaningful,

but they don't do a lot

for the growth of the podcast.

And so sharing YouTube links,

sharing Spotify links,

sharing Apple,

whatever

we call it under the podcast app now,

anything you can share,

the better we're going to be.

Guys, anything else

you want to say on this?

Yeah, please go check us out on YouTube.

Rack up those views for us.

We'd love to see it and then subscribe!

Make sure to subscribe on YouTube

as well.

And I relentlessly

refresh the YouTube comments

because it dictates

my mental health for the day.

So please say something

nice about all of us.

Thank you everyone.

Thanks everyone for listening. Honestly.