Protrusive Dental Podcast

🦷 Plaque Friday™ is here!

Get 20% off Protrusive Guidance Ultimate for as long as you stay, plus 7 days free to try it. That’s every masterclass, AskJaz, verifiable CPD on hundreds of podcast episodes, and our new live series Caries, Cracks and Contact Points with Dr Ronit Patel. Use code PF26 at checkout. Ends Monday 30 November, 11:59pm UK.
👉 https://protrusive.co.uk/plaquefriday

(This episode discusses suicide prevention and mental health. It does not include graphic details, but please listen with care. If this topic feels close to home, consider pausing and reaching out to someone you trust or a mental health professional.)
Why does dentistry have such high levels of stress and burnout?
Why do so many clinicians feel isolated despite working in busy practices?
What are the early warning signs that a colleague might be struggling?
And what can you actually do — practically — if someone is in crisis?
In this powerful and deeply important episode, Professor John Gibson shares his personal story and the mission behind the Canmore Trust. The conversation explores suicide prevention in dentistry, how to recognise warning signs, and the simple but life-saving actions every clinician should know.
 https://youtu.be/F8uWxhn3B8k 
Watch IC071 on YouTube
Key Takeaways
  • Dentistry has a well-recognised issue with stress, burnout, and suicide risk
  • Suicide is always multifactorial — never caused by a single event
  • Toxic culture, including harassment and unrealistic expectations, contributes to distress
  • Social media comparison can amplify feelings of inadequacy and isolation
  • Dentistry is uniquely demanding — both intellectually and technically
  • Mental health stigma prevents open conversations within the profession
  • Neurodivergence is increasingly relevant and often underdiagnosed
  • Perfectionism is a key risk trait linked to suicidal thinking
  • Working below your moral standards creates significant psychological stress
  • Warning signs include changes in temperament, withdrawal, and isolation
  • Asking directly about suicide does not increase risk — it can save lives
  • Use the “double bounce” approach: ask the question twice if needed
  • If someone says yes, act immediately — hospital or emergency services
  • You are not responsible for managing the crisis alone
  • Early support includes sharing concerns and involving a trusted person
  • GP support can be transformative and should not be delayed
Highlight of this episode:
  • 00:00 Teaser
  • 00:51 Intro
  • 04:16 John Gibson Introduction
  • 07:15 Understanding the Scale of Suicide in Dentistry
  • 09:59 Why Suicide Happens in Dentistry
  • 11:13 Key Risk Factors of Suicide in Dentistry
  • 12:09 Social Media and Comparison
  • 12:52 Isolation
  • 13:04 Difficulty of Dentistry
  • 14:03 Mental Health Stigma
  • 15:22 Neurodiversity
  • 18:18 Perfectionism and Moral Conflict in Dentistry
  • 21:44 Recognising Warning Signs of Suicide
  • 21:46 Midroll
  • 25:07 Recognising Warning Signs of Suicide
  • 26:21 How to Approach a Suicidal Colleague
  • 28:49 Double Bounce Technique
  • 30:44 If the Answer is YES
  • 33:36 Support and Resources for Dentists
  • 34:12 Key Suicide Prevention Steps
  • 37:40 Creating a Supportive Workplace
  • 39:18 Reflective Space
  • 40:00 Daily Positivity Practice
  • 42:46 Canmore Trust Podcast
  • 42:59 Outro
Learn more about mental health in Dentistry:
Check out more episodes on mental health, burnout, and wellbeing in dentistry.
PDP185 – Mental Health in Dentistry
IC040 – Overcoming Adversities
💙 Support and resources
If this episode resonated with you or someone you know, explore the Canmore Trust for practical support and guidance:
👉 thecanmoretrust.co.uk
👉 The Canmore Trust Podcast
They also offer helpful resources and podcasts focused on suicide prevention and mental well-being for healthcare professionals.
➡️General Dental Council – Mental Health and Well Being in Dentistry: A Rapid Evidence Assessment
#InterferenceCast #Communication #BeyondDentistry
This episode is eligible for 0.5 CE credit via the quiz on Protrusive Guidance.
This episode meets GDC Outcomes B
AGD Subject Code: 770 Self Improvement (Mental Health / Stress Management)
Aim: To enhance clinicians’ understanding of suicide risk within dentistry, including contributing factors, warning signs, and practical approaches to supporting colleagues, fostering open conversations, and creating a mentally healthy workplace.
Dentists will be able to –
  • Recognise the multifactorial nature of suicide in dentistry and identify key contributing risk factors such as toxic culture, isolation, and stigma.
  • Identify behavioural and emotional warning signs of suicide in dental professionals and apply appropriate communication strategies, including direct questioning and empathetic support.
  • Implement practical steps to support colleagues in crisis and contribute to a workplace culture that prioritises mental health and wellbeing.

What is Protrusive Dental Podcast?

The Forward Thinking Dental Podcast

SEO METADATA

SEO TITLE:
Before the Breaking Point: Mental Health and Suicide Prevention in Dentistry | IC071

META DESCRIPTION:
Prof John Gibson of the Canmore Trust on suicide prevention in dentistry: warning signs, how to ask the question, the double bounce, and getting help.

URL SLUG:
mental-health-and-suicide-prevention-in-dentistry

PRIMARY TOPIC:
Mental health and suicide prevention for dental professionals

SECONDARY SEARCH TOPICS:
- Suicide risk in dentistry
- The Canmore Trust
- Warning signs a colleague is struggling
- How to ask someone if they are thinking about suicide
- The double bounce
- Toxic culture and harassment in dentistry
- Mental health first aid and ASIST training for dental practices
- Building a mentally healthy dental workplace

BEFORE THE BREAKING POINT: MENTAL HEALTH AND SUICIDE PREVENTION IN DENTISTRY
THE PROTRUSIVE DENTAL PODCAST, INTERFERENCE CAST EPISODE IC071
HOST: DR JAZ GULATI
GUEST: PROF JOHN GIBSON

EPISODE SUMMARY

In this Interference Cast on the Protrusive Dental Podcast, Dr Jaz Gulati talks to Professor John Gibson, emeritus professor of oral medicine and former dental school dean, who founded the Canmore Trust after his son Cameron, a young veterinary surgeon, died by suicide. John explains why he is challenging the GDC to publish data on suicides during fitness to practise processes, and why he sees suicide as complex and multifactorial rather than having a single cause.

John describes the pressures he sees in dentistry: a toxic culture including sexual harassment, competition fuelled by social media, isolation, the demands of the job, stigma around mental ill health, undiagnosed neurodivergence, perfectionism, and having to work below your own standards. He sets out the warning signs to look for, how to reach out with empathy and boldness, how to ask directly whether someone is thinking about taking their life, the "double bounce", and what to do if the answer is yes. He also shares where to get support and how practices can build a culture that protects mental health.

IN SHORT

This episode explains how dental professionals can recognise when a colleague is struggling and help prevent suicide. Prof John Gibson's advice is to look for changes in temperament and withdrawal, reach out with empathy and boldness, ask directly whether someone is thinking about taking their life, ask a second time if they brush it off, and, if they say yes, get them to a place of safety or dial 999.

KEY TAKEAWAYS

- John describes every suicide as complex and multifactorial, rarely down to a single cause.
- He identifies pressures in dentistry including a toxic culture, harassment, social media comparison, isolation, stigma and perfectionism.
- Warning signs include a change in temperament, professional withdrawal and social withdrawal.
- Reach out with empathy and boldness, in a confidential, non-judgemental conversation.
- Ask one clear question: "Are you thinking about taking your life?" John says asking will never cause suicidal behaviour.
- Use the double bounce: if they brush it off, ask again.
- If the answer is yes, take them to a place of safety, such as an emergency department, or dial 999.
- Practices can help with mental health first aid training, ASIST training, a wellbeing lead, reflective spaces and lunch breaks free of meetings.

QUESTIONS ANSWERED IN THIS EPISODE

1. What is the Canmore Trust?
2. Why are dental professionals at risk?
3. What are the warning signs that a colleague is struggling?
4. How do you ask someone if they're thinking about suicide?
5. What is the double bounce?
6. What should you do if someone says yes?
7. Where can dental professionals get support?
8. How can a practice protect its team's mental health?

IN THIS EPISODE

1. Introduction: dentistry has a suicide problem
2. Meet Professor John Gibson: Cameron and the Canmore Trust
3. How big is the problem? A challenge to the GDC
4. Why dentistry? Toxic culture, isolation and the demands of the job
5. Stigma, neurodiversity, and dentists as ordinary people
6. Perfectionism and breaking your moral code
7. Spotting the signs: temperament, withdrawal, and reaching out with empathy and boldness
8. Asking the question, and the double bounce
9. If the answer is yes: a place of safety or 999
10. Getting support: the Canmore Trust, talking to someone, and your GP
11. Building a workplace that protects mental health

CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION: DENTISTRY HAS A SUICIDE PROBLEM

JAZ:
Protruserati, every year or so I release an episode that can really send chills: an episode that could potentially save a life. That could be the life of a colleague, or even your own.

It's something we cannot, and must not, ignore in dentistry. I'm just going to go ahead and say it: dentistry has a suicide problem. We knew that. You knew it when you entered dental school, and you knew it when you left. It isn't a random myth. It's backed by data.

One of our missions here at Protrusive is not only to make you fall in love with dentistry again and help you improve clinically and non-clinically. We also have a duty to shine a light on the not-so-nice stuff in dentistry: the stress, the pressure and the burnout.

And it's these three things, my friend, stress, pressure and burnout, that make up this month's theme. Since the start of 2026, we've been doing monthly themes, with at least two episodes each month dedicated to that theme. Today I present an extremely powerful guest with a crushing, truly tragic story.

But he's using that tragedy to fuel suicide prevention and mental health support for dentists. Joining us today is Professor John Gibson, emeritus professor of oral medicine. He's extremely humble. I didn't realise until we were recording how distinguished he is, and I love that.

I love humility like that. He's allowed me to call him John. John has a very sad story: his son, Cameron, died by suicide. As a father, I can only imagine what kind of loss that is, and the emotional turmoil surrounding it. It's what eventually led him to open the Canmore Trust.

Canmore is an anagram of his son's name, Cameron, and as the name suggests, we can do more. We can all do more to help prevent suicide. The Canmore Trust is a suicide prevention and mental health charity. In 2021, the General Dental Council welcomed the launch of the Mental Health and Wellness in Dentistry Framework, and this is what they said:

Conversations about mental health should be encouraged. Dental professionals should feel able to share their experiences and think about the steps that can be taken to improve and safeguard mental health and wellness. You may have come across this indirectly in your practice. Perhaps your practice has already adopted the framework, for example by identifying a mental health and wellness lead.

Another part of this initiative is stress awareness training: all members of the dental team should undertake stress awareness training. So this episode is eligible for CE and CPD, and it forms part of that training. But guys, forget the certificates. This is real-world stuff. You could save a life.

At the very least, you can reduce your own stress, or identify signs of distress in your colleagues. We openly discuss the toxic culture in dentistry. It's not everywhere in dentistry, but I'm sure we can all recognise that it exists. One of the things we can do to counteract it is to talk openly about our mental health.

That's what this episode is about, my friends. I'm not going to lie: if you've been affected by suicide, perhaps through a colleague, this will make for some tough listening. It's never nice to talk about these things, but is it important? Of course it is.

It's really, really key, and I want everyone to listen to and watch this episode just as much as you enjoy our resin veneer, onlay or geeky occlusion episodes. We owe it to ourselves and our colleagues to listen to episodes like this, so we can better look after our own mental health and our colleagues'. Let's now join the main episode, and I'll catch you in the outro.

CHAPTER 2: MEET PROFESSOR JOHN GIBSON: CAMERON AND THE CANMORE TRUST

JAZ:
John Gibson, welcome to the Protrusive Dental Podcast. You have such an important mission, and thank you so much for making time to be here. John, can you please tell us about yourself, the Canmore Trust, and how it all came to be?

PROF JOHN GIBSON:
Thanks, Jaz, and thanks for the invitation to be with you today. It's a great opportunity to speak to my fellow dental professionals, because I'm still a registered dental surgeon, and historically I was a clinical academic. I taught dentistry for 35 years, loved every second of it, and was eventually dean of a dental school.

But things didn't go so well for the Gibson family. We have three fantastic children.

Just before COVID kicked in, our youngest child, our younger son, Cameron, who was 24, took his own life. He died by suicide. He was a young veterinary surgeon. We didn't know then that the veterinary suicide rate is about three to four times the national average. We know that now, and we also know that other professional groups are at increased risk of suicidal behaviour too, which I'm sure we'll talk about.

We faced devastation, and I had my own suicidal crisis. Eight months after Cameron died, we realised there was a real dearth of practical support for people in mental health crisis or suicidal crisis, or who had been impacted by suicide,

who had lost someone to suicide. So we set up the Canmore Trust. In fact, we're just coming up to our fourth birthday: it started as a registered charity in January 2022. It might not be obvious to your viewers and listeners, but Canmore is an anagram of Cameron, our son who died.

But there's also the sense that we can do more, and indeed must do more, for suicide prevention and wellbeing, not least within the dental profession.

CHAPTER 3: HOW BIG IS THE PROBLEM? A CHALLENGE TO THE GDC

JAZ:
I appreciate you sharing that with us. I appreciate the adversity, the sheer emotion and the trauma you went through, and how you've repurposed it into a mission to help others.

That's really important, and thank you so much for doing it. You shared an insight into the veterinary world, which I'd read about previously. But when I was coming into dentistry, it was one of those things people said: "Oh yes, dentists have one of the highest suicide rates."

Sadly, in the last few years, we have lost good people in dentistry to suicide. Do you have any stats on this? What's the scale of the problem in dentistry? 'Cause I can think of at least two people in the last two years, and they were really well-known people.

They were speakers, and most of the profession knew them. One was in Europe, in implantology, and the other... I'm sure you know who I'm talking about. It was just devastating, absolutely devastating. So do you know the scale of the problem?

PROF JOHN GIBSON:
It's very difficult to estimate, and the General Dental Council have taken a baby step towards helping us with this, but they've got so much more to do. Towards the end of 2024, the GDC published figures, covering a three-year window, on those who had died during fitness to practise processes: individuals who were under investigation by the GDC.

Those figures were published, but the GDC didn't take the final step of saying, "These are the numbers that were suicides, and these are the numbers that were cancer," or whatever. That's yet to be done, and I have a genuine challenge for the regulator to do it.

I think there's an obligation to do that. The General Medical Council does it without hesitation, and I think the GDC should too. It's only a small subset of what's happening in the rest of the profession, but it would give us some understanding of the impact and the stresses on dental professionals, on the whole dental team at the moment, because it's not just dentists. It's DCPs and others who are part of the dental team.

So we've got a journey to go yet, but I think we need to do it. The objection is that because our profession is relatively small, the numbers become identifiable people. My argument is that no one dies by suicide in dentistry without the profession knowing about it. It becomes common knowledge very quickly.

So there's no breach of confidentiality. I think we need to do it, and the challenge is for the GDC to take that forward. But credit to them: they've taken the baby step of at least publishing data on deaths during fitness to practise processes.

CHAPTER 4: WHY DENTISTRY? TOXIC CULTURE, ISOLATION AND THE DEMANDS OF THE JOB

JAZ:
With the insight you have after your tragic loss, you then found out about the situation in the veterinary world, and we know about the situation in dentistry. Suicide is the very apex of the breaking point, but it's the tip of the iceberg.

I believe there was a BDA survey, and you may know the figures, where a shockingly high percentage of respondents, surveyed anonymously I think, said they'd thought about taking their own life. So why do you think we are where we are?

PROF JOHN GIBSON:
It's a great question, and a really difficult one, so don't expect any trite or simple answers from me, because we're now entering a world of utter complexity. If I've learned anything about suicide since Cameron died, it's that it's complex.

When we talk with clients about this, we often talk about pieces of a jigsaw going onto a board. With clients who've lost someone to suicide, the immediate reaction is often, "It happened because of Y": there was a row at work, a falling-out at work, a financial issue, something.

But the reality is that every suicide is complex. It's a multifaceted, multifactorial event. People find that reassuring when we talk to them about it, because they'll often be holding on to the thought, "If only I'd done this, or hadn't done that." But the reality is that it's complex.

We just need to understand that. Having said that, in dentistry there are clearly a number of issues at work, and several recently published papers have really helped us understand them. The first, I think, is toxicity within dentistry.

Dentistry is a toxic place. I know viewers and listeners may find that difficult to understand. I've found it difficult to understand. But there is a toxic culture, including a toxic culture of harassment, particularly sexual harassment, within the dental profession. Recent publications have demonstrated that quite clearly.

It happens in dental schools and in vocational training, and it carries on from there. So there is a toxic culture. When you look at the figures for those who've been sexually harassed, and we meet these individuals through the Canmore Trust, some reach suicidal crisis because they're working with someone who continually touches them, or says things that undermine them. So there is a toxic culture.

I also think there's a toxic culture around achievement in dentistry at the moment. As far as I'm concerned, people never share the things that went wrong or badly on social media. They always share the things they think went particularly well, and that creates a really competitive environment in dentistry nowadays. For the ordinary practitioner just running their business, that can feel very difficult and very isolating: "I don't do social media. Why are they all doing social media?

"I don't do social media." That can lead somewhere significant: "I'm just doing my job. I go to work and do my job. How do I not have time for all this as well? Why am I not building the portfolios that appear on social media?" So there's the toxic culture.

There's the whole issue of feeling isolated and alone as people seem to climb the ladder of success while "I don't feel particularly successful." And then there's a really important part: all the aspects that make dentistry quite difficult. I'm doubly qualified. I did medicine and dentistry, and I can tell you,

dentistry is by far and away the harder course, and actually the harder profession. I'll get all kinds of comments on social media for saying that, but it's true, because there's not only the intellectual challenge of what you're learning in dentistry, but a real practical skill challenge, in a very short period. I think many people realise they're not quite stepping up. They're in a job that's almost exclusively practical, they're struggling a bit, and they know they've committed to this course and this profession, and they know inside that they're not the best dentist who's ever going to walk the face of the earth.

They take that struggle into their lifelong professional work, and it's a genuine struggle. It comes out a lot in conversations with people we meet who are struggling with their wellbeing.

CHAPTER 5: STIGMA, NEURODIVERSITY, AND DENTISTS AS ORDINARY PEOPLE

PROF JOHN GIBSON:
There's another aspect to this as well. I'm increasingly aware of the stigma around mental health in dentistry. Despite being in a welfare and wellbeing profession, we don't actually look after ourselves, or our co-workers, very well, and there remains within dentistry, as in medicine,

a stigma about mental ill health. We can't show this so-called weakness. Despite all being biologically trained, and understanding that your inner turmoil is a biological process, just as your myocardial infarction is a biological process, mental ill health is a biological process too. Yet we separate it off as something different, something with stigma.

So we can't talk. "I can't go into work and tell my boss I've been diagnosed with depression. I can't tell my partner I've started going to Alcoholics Anonymous. I can't tell my partner I've started antidepressants." These are all challenges people face, and I wonder why, because we wouldn't hesitate to go to our boss or our partner and say, "I've been diagnosed with pancreatic cancer.

"Nine months to live." So why don't we bring that transparency around mental ill health and wellbeing into our workplaces? It's a very genuine challenge. And there's another part to this: neurodiversity. If the current figures are correct, we're looking at around 26% of the UK population being neurodivergent by 2030.

That may even be conservative, and it has implications for education, for dental school, and certainly for dentistry: how we train dentists, and how neurodivergent people, whether diagnosed or not, deal with the profession and get on with their professional lives.

And here's a really important point. If you're neurodivergent but undiagnosed, and therefore unsupported, you've got a difficult journey ahead. Rates of suicide may be increased among neurodivergent people, and for those who are undiagnosed and unsupported, a number of papers together have estimated that the suicide rate is eight times the national average. So all of that's in there. But we forget one other thing: dentists and DCPs, dental care professionals, are just ordinary people as well.

They turn up on a Monday morning and get on with all the professional stuff that's hitting them, which we've just talked about. But they're also ordinary people, with marriage difficulties, cancer diagnoses, kids who are struggling at school, all of that going on, maybe a failure, a mortgage payment.

And then here we are, the erudite professional. We step into the practice or clinic on a Monday morning, the smile goes on, and we have to carry all of that, because we couldn't possibly let it out, could we? Could we? Because, my goodness, what happens if we let it all out? Well, there's the challenge.

What does happen if you let it all out? What happens if you take your partner aside and say, "I'm really struggling just now, and I'm going to have to take two or three weeks off until I can sort it out"? You think you can't do that. You've got patients, you've got treatment plans going forward. But we have to do that. It's our professional and personal responsibility to say, "I'm not doing well at the moment.

"I need to step back and look after myself just now, and I'll be much better when I come back, but I just can't do this right now." That has to happen more.

JAZ:
That was such a succinct summary, with two particular insights I hadn't come across before. Thank you so much for sharing all of that. It was a really relatable summary, and I think we can all relate to it. But I didn't know about the scale of the sexual harassment. Thank you for sharing that. Honestly, I was completely oblivious to it. And also the neurodivergence being a potentially hidden issue. That definitely needs exploring further. And your insight about medicine and dentistry is very useful. Yes, please.

CHAPTER 6: PERFECTIONISM AND BREAKING YOUR MORAL CODE

PROF JOHN GIBSON:
I was just going to say that one classic feature of certain aspects of neurodivergence is perfectionism, and perfectionism is one of the major traits associated with suicidal thinking. There are a number of traits that move people towards suicidal thinking, but there are two characteristic ones in dentistry, and one is perfectionism.

The other, which figures frequently in those who think about suicide, is breaking our moral code. We can cope with breaking our moral code if it happens infrequently. But if you're working in an environment where you want to work at this level,

but the workplace forces you to work at this lower level, you can't be in that environment without it significantly affecting your mental wellbeing.

This whole issue of breaking one's moral code comes up very frequently for me, as I work with dental professionals and other professionals, in discussions around suicidal thinking: "I just can't be here anymore, because I'm like an alien life form. I want to work at this level,

"but I'm forced to work at that level." That's a really difficult thing to deal with, and for many people-

JAZ:
It's like cognitive dissonance. My mind was really ticking as you said that, because it's very relatable. Sorry to take it to clinical dentistry, but let me give you a relatable example.

One of my endodontic mentors once taught me that the more endodontics you learn and the more courses you go on, the more you finally acquire the skills of where to find the MB2 and how to navigate it. And once you've learned that, you can't unlearn it. Now you know.

So the next time you've only got 15 minutes to finish off a root canal, and you know the MB2 is there, but because of time, or some other issue, or so many other factors, you choose to be blind to it and finish the treatment, that's a level of cognitive dissonance that can raise your cortisol.

'Cause again, you're breaking that moral code. Once you've developed and raised your standards, and then because of a system, an environment, or which nurse you're working with that day, you can't work to that level and have to take a shortcut you know is a shortcut, that can really eat at you.

PROF JOHN GIBSON:
Yes, indeed, completely. You've got it.

CHAPTER 7: SPOTTING THE SIGNS: TEMPERAMENT, WITHDRAWAL, AND REACHING OUT WITH EMPATHY AND BOLDNESS

JAZ:
I think the purpose of this episode is threefold. One is to learn more about the scale of the problem. Another is how to identify people we can help, because at any point in time there are colleagues we know who may be struggling, maybe not at the tip of the iceberg, but just below it.

How can we work out, "You know what? I think the associate next door is struggling a bit," and how can we help them in a non-judgemental way? That's one thing I want to talk about.

Then I want to talk about how the Canmore Trust can be supported, how it supports others, and the other resources out there, because the more we talk about the resources available, both for prevention and at crisis point, the better.

Ideally, we want to stop people getting to crisis point, but there are many who are already there and need urgent help. How can we get them that help? So let's start with patterns we can look out for, so we can give targeted help and advice. How do we begin to tackle this big problem?

PROF JOHN GIBSON:
That's a great question, and the pivotal one, because we need to be able to see when things are changing in our colleagues and our family. There are three things that are reported to us again and again.

The first is a change in temperament. Mr Easy-going becomes Mr Angry: shouting at staff, colleagues or patients. A change in temperament is a major issue. The second is withdrawal, which can be professional: "I used to sit in the staff area at lunchtime with my sandwiches, and I don't anymore."

So why has John withdrawn in that way? The third is social withdrawal. Why isn't John going to the Christmas night out? Why doesn't John come anymore? John used to go to social functions at the weekend with his wife and family, and he'd always come in and tell us about it.

He has clearly changed. Something has happened. Those are the three things I'd suggest point to something not being quite right. Then there are two words in combination: empathy and boldness. We need to be bold enough to reach out to someone and say, "We need to talk," not from a place of judgement, but from a place of empathy and a desire to help.

"We're going for a walk at lunchtime, and I'd like a chat with you," or, "Are you free one night this week? Let's go for a coffee and a chat, chew the fat together and see where we're at." Then we need to do some fact-finding: "How are things? Are you struggling a bit? Tell me about it. This is a confidential space, so it isn't going anywhere else.

"It isn't going to anyone else in the practice or the clinic. Just share with me what's going on, if you can. I'm keen to hear from you."

CHAPTER 8: ASKING THE QUESTION, AND THE DOUBLE BOUNCE

PROF JOHN GIBSON:
Then the boldness transmogrifies to a different level, because you need to ask a question, and the question is simply this: are you thinking about taking your life? There's a silence for a moment,

even as I share that question with you. But we need to know a number of things about that question. The first is that by asking it, you'll never precipitate suicidal behaviour. Never. And you may indeed bring someone back from suicidal crisis. So the boldness needs to be reinforced. We need to ask that question.

The difficulty is that, as healthcare practitioners, we always want to couch it in a bit of positivity. So instead of asking the question boldly, we say something like, "You're not thinking of doing something silly, are you?" Immediately, we've brought judgement into the room. The person sitting with us may have just had their dog put to sleep, and that may have been the final thing for them, with lots of other stuff further upstream. So you must not bring judgement into the room. That's why, in training, we say you need to ask one question. Don't think about other questions. One question: are you thinking about taking your life? And here's a really important further point. This is the pivotal moment.

Every healthcare professional I have ever asked that question has said, "John, don't be silly. Yes, things are bad at the moment, but let's go and have a glass of wine or a beer. It'll be fine in the morning." Never accept that response from a fellow healthcare professional.

In the Trust, we call it the double bounce. You bounce the ball once: you ask, "Are you thinking about taking your life?" You get the response, "Don't be silly." Then you bounce the ball again and ask again: "No, this is really important. I can see you're struggling. Are you thinking about taking your life?"

The response, "Yes, I am, and I need help," on that second bounce is profoundly more likely than on the first. So if you take nothing else away from this discussion today, please remember the small bald man sitting in front of you in a podcast. You may not remember his name, but he talked about the double bounce.

You bounce the ball once, and you ask the question without embellishment: are you thinking about taking your life?

Then, of course, if the answer is yes, we have to do something. And one of the mistakes we make is-

CHAPTER 9: IF THE ANSWER IS YES: A PLACE OF SAFETY OR 999

JAZ:
John, I'm just going to pause you there. Firstly, thank you for sharing this really important question. I think we need to instil a level of courage and boldness in our colleagues so they can ask it.

I've had some training on this before, because I treat patients with chronic pain, and I've asked my patients this question because I've been trained to. And I know, from my training, what the follow-up question is if they say yes. How deep should we go? This is all very good stuff, because it can help dentists with their patients as well.

In terms of suicide prevention with anyone, including a family member, should we go through the protocol of what the follow-up question should be when they say yes? I think it's very valuable information. Or do you feel it's something everyone should learn in their own time? How would you like to approach it?

PROF JOHN GIBSON:
I think we've covered the emergency work here, and that's what people need to know and understand. If someone says yes, your obligation is either to take them to a place of safety, meaning the emergency department of a local hospital, or to dial 999.

Those are the only two options, and that's all I want to say on it, because people say, "Well, I'd phone the GP," or, "I'd do this or that." Those are the two options: you get them to a place of safety, or you dial 999.

JAZ:
One thing I was trained in, very much in terms of my patients, and it's a very dark conversation, but a very important one, and we have a responsibility as healthcare professionals to ask the right questions at the right time, is this: if they say yes, you stay very calm and ask, "Have you thought about how you would do it?"

That tells you how serious it is. If someone has already thought about how they'd do it, that's another level of escalation. But I think what you've said is perfect advice for anyone listening, because if they say yes, it gives us a clear action, without feeling we have to be the therapist, or take it on by ourselves.

At that point, let's get help rather than taking it on yourself. I only did the additional training because I'm alone with patients in that room, and I wanted to equip myself a bit more. But I think what you're saying, at the level we're pitching it here, is perfect.

So for colleagues listening to this episode right now with you, I don't think we need to teach them the other bits. If you get a yes... firstly, the double bounce, asking again, is a really, really important distinction. And if you get a yes, taking them to safety or dialling 999 is very pragmatic and easy for everyone to remember.

PROF JOHN GIBSON:
Yes. And I don't want it to be more complex than that, because you can make it hugely complex, and then you take the burden on yourself. The burden isn't with you. All you're doing is helping this person get to a place of safety. And believe me, if you do this, and I've done it many times now, the joy of saving a life is a remarkable thing, and those individuals will come back and say, "Jaz, thank you so much for what you did."

CHAPTER 10: GETTING SUPPORT: THE CANMORE TRUST, TALKING TO SOMEONE, AND YOUR GP

JAZ:
Thank you so much. I think that's the biggest takeaway. I want to wrap up by finding out how, once we've identified these colleagues and asked the tough questions, we can make sure the word gets out about the right resources. How can we point dentists to the right resources, not only at crisis point, but for prevention?

For people who are approaching a crisis, what resources are there? For example, how does the Canmore Trust operate? How do you help dentists avoid getting to that point? What other resources are available for those listening who are feeling really burnt out and stressed? What should we do next?

PROF JOHN GIBSON:
My strong advice is to visit the Canmore Trust website, canmoretrust.co.uk. We've been applauded for the resources on our website. There's a whole list there, and it's not just about suicide. It's about wellbeing: when you feel burnt out, or in a mental health crisis, and how you might find and get help.

So I'd encourage people to take a look at that. The second aspect is a very personal one: we must learn to share with other people when we're struggling. It's such an important message. Because of the stigma around mental health, which is still so prevalent, there's so much work to do. We need, again,

to take a bold step and speak to our partners, our wives or husbands, and say, "This is where I'm at, and I need help. Please can you help me?" Because when someone is in a mental health crisis, or struggling with depression or anxiety, and I know this from personal experience, it's very difficult to go to a website and think, "La la la, that looks good.

"I'll have a shot at that." It's so much more helpful when you've got someone sitting next to you saying, "That might be good. Let's take a look at it, dig into it and see what it might be." So that's really important. And the third step is the general practitioner. We've moved on from the crisis moment, and now we need to involve the GP.

You need to have a professional-to-professional discussion: "You might know me from walking up the high street with my dogs, or from the golf club, or wherever," because professional people know each other, don't they? But it's time to have that discussion and say, "I'm really struggling. I'm really not okay.

"I need help." Yesterday I was speaking to a dentist, another healthcare professional, who had done exactly that and was astonished at how compassionate and kind the GP was. The GP just opened doors to immediate, transformative help. We talk about waiting times all the time, and about how parts of the health service are broken, but we need to look after each other.

If we can't look after each other, we're not looking after patients very well. So we need to look after each other well. The GP is pivotal in all of this. Just go and have a chat with your GP and say, "Here's where I'm at. Please give me help."

CHAPTER 11: BUILDING A WORKPLACE THAT PROTECTS MENTAL HEALTH

JAZ:
John, one final question, if I may, because I've just thought of another really important one. What advice can you give workplaces, whether corporate or a small family-run practice with associates and team members? How can we create the right workplace culture? Practices nowadays have social media policies and policies for this, that and the other.

I don't know if there's such a thing as a suicide prevention policy, or how a mental health policy would be worded. I don't remember reading one, unless I signed something and skimmed past it. Policies are the obvious way.

But how can you create the right framework? Let me give you an example. I want to shout out my previous place of work, Triangle Dental. I used to work in Reading, and I've now moved to Richmond in West London, but they really created a safe environment. My practice manager, D, was lovely. Any time I was feeling really burnt out and anxious, I could step in, have a meeting and let it all out.

They were able to change my hours or my days to help me, and that really helped me in my career over the last four or five years, when I was feeling down. I really wish everyone could have that kind of relationship with their workplace, where they can have that conversation.

So I just want to say thank you to my previous workplace for creating that environment. I wish it for everyone. So my question to you, John, is: what's the next step for workplaces to instil a culture that helps people be compassionate?

PROF JOHN GIBSON:
Step one: the boss needs to go on a mental health first aid course, because that will help you understand what mental ill health is. We talk about mental health and mental ill health as if they're the same thing. We need to understand what mental ill health looks like. A mental health first aid course is a great opportunity to learn how to look after staff and be there for them.

You talk not just about the computer system and where the car parking is. You also say, "We care about mental health in this practice. It's a priority for us. If you're struggling, here is the accountability officer." So appoint an accountability officer: someone who looks after the mental health and wellbeing of all staff.

That's certainly an important part. Next: provide reflective spaces. And don't have meetings at lunchtime. No staff meetings at lunchtime, no meetings of any kind. Walk around the block at lunchtime instead. In a previous workplace, when I was the boss, I banned all lunchtime meetings unless people walked and talked at the same time.

Lunchtimes are for people to relax, to sit and chat and be human beings together, and share life together. So no meetings at lunchtime, and encourage people to exercise if they want to. We can also build in accountability partners in the practice. And providing reflective spaces is really important.

I know space is often tight in practices, but have a place people can go to unashamedly and unabashedly and say, "It's been a rubbish morning. I'm just going to sit in the reflective space for 10 minutes to regain my balance and my thoughts." Fantastic.

There can be books in there. My daughter just gave me a brilliant book about how to laugh 365 days of the year. Every day you open it at a page, and there's a lovely little thing to read that makes you smile, which is great. Another good thing to do, in the midst of tough times in dentistry, when people are often saying how bad, bad, bad things are,

is for each member of staff to share three good things that happened during the day. As you're getting ready to leave, say, "Share with me three good things that happened today." "Well, Mrs Smith loved her new dentures. Fantastic." So instead of taking home the negativity, you take home the positivity.

That's so significant. Once you've done mental health first aid training, I'd like someone in the practice to do ASIST training. A-S-I-S-T training is the exemplar suicide prevention training. It's a two-day course.

It's the best you can do. Get someone in the practice booked onto it, so they can feed back into mental wellbeing within the practice. It also allows people to talk very openly about their mental wellbeing and any suicidal thoughts or behaviour, anything around that.

So that's very important as well. And then there are mental health services. Does the practice have a policy? Would it engage not only with NHS services, but also with private healthcare, to provide the best level of support for someone in the practice who needs it? Those are all the things I'd wrap up in how a practice develops wellbeing.

JAZ:
That was such a brilliant, comprehensive, pragmatic and practical answer. My mind was wandering to the reflective space. In the practice where I work in West London, space is very tight, but I was thinking even of having one chair dedicated as the meditation chair or the mindfulness chair, something like that.

Even just one specific chair where, if you're sitting there, you can be in your zone, and having those books there is a great idea. Thank you so much for sharing these wonderful guidelines. They'll help everyone, including practice principals who want to cultivate a compassion-focused culture and help their team avoid even getting to burnout.

You gave some wonderful tips there. And for all the colleagues out there who may have recognised those signs, the change in temperament, the social withdrawal and everything you talked about, you've given them the courage to ask the question, with the double bounce. Some really great tips.

I'll put the Canmore Trust website in the show notes so people can click through, and also links for things like ASIST training and mental health first aid training, so everyone knows their next step and everyone's covered. Thank you so much for your time and guidance, and for running the Canmore Trust and putting it out into the world for such a great cause.

PROF JOHN GIBSON:
Thank you so much. It's been a pleasure to be with you. There are also Canmore Trust podcasts. Just google "Canmore Trust podcast", and there's a whole series that might help people who are struggling as well.

JAZ:
Amazing. I'll put a link to that as well. John, thank you so much for your time. I really appreciate it.

PROF JOHN GIBSON:
Thank you, Jaz. It's been a pleasure.

JAZ:
Well, there we have it, guys. Thank you so much, honestly, from the bottom of my heart, for making it to the end of this episode. It's not a sexy area of dentistry, but it is super important, and I'm really proud of you for making it here.

This episode is eligible for CE and CPD credits. It's part of the growing initiative to encourage more CE and CPD in mental health and wellness in dentistry. We're a PACE-approved education provider, by the way. Head over to protrusive.app and answer the quiz below this episode. If you agree these kinds of episodes are really important, please share it with someone.

Please share it with someone you care about. Share it in your practice WhatsApp groups, with all the associates, the dentists and the entire dental team. Like I said, this is one of those episodes that can genuinely save a life, and I'm so, so grateful to John Gibson for giving up his time, and for his mission. His mission is beautiful.

It comes from tragedy, but what he's doing now is really admirable, and as a profession we all thank you, Professor John Gibson. Protruserati, thanks so much. Next week we continue the theme, and I look forward to catching you then. Same time, same place next week. Bye for now.

FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS

QUESTION:
What is the Canmore Trust?
ANSWER:
Prof John Gibson explains that the Canmore Trust is a suicide prevention and mental health charity he set up after his son, Cameron, died by suicide. It became a registered charity in January 2022. Canmore is an anagram of Cameron, and also reflects the idea that we can, and must, do more for suicide prevention and wellbeing.

QUESTION:
Why are dental professionals at risk?
ANSWER:
John stresses that every suicide is complex and multifactorial. In dentistry, he points to a toxic culture including harassment, competition fuelled by social media, isolation, the intellectual and practical demands of the job, stigma around mental ill health, perfectionism, and being forced to work below your own standards, alongside the ordinary life pressures everyone faces.

QUESTION:
What are the warning signs that a colleague is struggling?
ANSWER:
John highlights three signs that are reported again and again. The first is a change in temperament, such as an easy-going person becoming angry with staff or patients. The second is professional withdrawal, like no longer joining colleagues at lunch. The third is social withdrawal, such as skipping work nights out or weekend events.

QUESTION:
How do you ask someone if they're thinking about suicide?
ANSWER:
John advises reaching out with empathy and boldness, in a confidential, non-judgemental conversation, perhaps over a walk or a coffee. Then ask one clear question, without softening it: "Are you thinking about taking your life?" He warns against phrases like "You're not thinking of doing something silly?", which bring judgement into the room.

QUESTION:
What is the double bounce?
ANSWER:
John explains that healthcare professionals often brush off the question with something like "Don't be silly, it'll be fine in the morning." He says never to accept that response. Instead, ask a second time: "This is really important. I can see you're struggling. Are you thinking about taking your life?" He finds people are much more likely to say yes then.

QUESTION:
What should you do if someone says yes?
ANSWER:
John says there are only two options: take the person to a place of safety, such as a hospital emergency department, or dial 999. He keeps it deliberately simple so the burden isn't placed on you, as your role is to help the person get to safety, not to treat them yourself.

QUESTION:
Where can dental professionals get support?
ANSWER:
John recommends the Canmore Trust website, canmoretrust.co.uk, which has resources on wellbeing, burnout and mental health crisis, as well as the Canmore Trust podcast. He encourages people to tell someone close to them that they are struggling, and to speak to their GP, which he describes as pivotal in getting help.

QUESTION:
How can a practice protect its team's mental health?
ANSWER:
John suggests the practice leader takes a mental health first aid course, someone in the team completes two-day ASIST suicide prevention training, and a named person looks after staff wellbeing. He also recommends a reflective space, no meetings at lunchtime, sharing three good things at the end of each day, and support beyond NHS services.

ABOUT THE GUEST

Professor John Gibson is an emeritus professor of oral medicine and a registered dental surgeon, qualified in both medicine and dentistry. He taught dentistry for 35 years and was dean of a dental school. After his son, Cameron, died by suicide, he founded the Canmore Trust, a suicide prevention and mental health charity that became a registered charity in January 2022.

- The Canmore Trust: canmoretrust.co.uk