A daily history podcast from Patriot Compass. Each episode explores the events that shaped America on this day in history, told through expert narration and grounded in primary sources.
The phone rings at the Justice Department. It's Saturday night, October twentieth, nineteen seventy three. The president wants a man fired. The attorney general says no and reaches for a pen to write his own resignation instead. This is the American Record from Patriot Compass, one story from this day in American history.
Narrator:Richard Nixon was fighting to keep his Oval Office tapes secret. Archibald Cox, the independent prosecutor investigating Watergate, had subpoenaed them, and a federal court had just sided with Cox. Nixon wanted him gone. Standing in the way was Attorney General Elliott Richardson, who'd personally promised the Senate he'd let Cox work free of interference. That promise was about to cost him his job and set off one of the strangest nights in the history of the presidency.
Narrator:The day before, Cox had turned down a compromise Nixon offered to quiet the tapes dispute. Nixon wasn't willing to let it go. That Saturday night, the order came down to Fire Cox. Richardson refused. He later told Justice Department attorneys he didn't doubt Nixon's sincerity, that the president genuinely believed presidential conversations deserved secrecy.
Narrator:He just couldn't carry out the order himself. He wrote his resignation and walked out. Nixon didn't want to look like he'd fired Cox directly. Aide Pat Buchanan later recalled the president framing it as a matter of pride. He couldn't let Soviet leader Leonid Brezhnev watch him, as Nixon put it, be bullied by a member of his own cabinet.
Narrator:So the order moved down the chain to Deputy Attorney General William Ruckelshaus. He lasted about as long as it took to write his own letter. He refused to and resigned. That left the Solicitor General Robert Bork now the senior official in the building. Bork actually considered resigning himself.
Narrator:Richardson talked him out of it. Someone needed to keep the department running through the crisis. So Bork was driven to the White House that night, sworn in as acting attorney general, and only then did he have the legal power to do what Nixon wanted. Within hours of taking the oath, he fired Cox. The White House's first story to reporters was that Ruckelshaus had been fired.
Narrator:He hadn't been. He'd resigned. And the correction ran the next day, But for a few confused hours it looked like a purge rather than two men walking out on principle. Cox's own statement that night was simple. The country would now have to decide through Congress and the public whether it remained a government of laws or of men.
Narrator:Telegrams poured into the White House and Capitol Hill by the thousands, more than either had seen in years. Within days, members of Congress were drafting articles of impeachment. A federal judge ruled Cox's firing illegal less than a month later. Nixon got a new special prosecutor, the tapes fight resumed, and less than ten months after that Saturday night, Nixon resigned the presidency. Bork's role in carrying out the firing followed him for the rest of his life.
Narrator:It came up again in 1987, when the Senate rejected him for the Supreme Court. Two Senate confirmed officials chose unemployment over an order they believed was unlawful. That precedent, that Cabinet officers answer to the law before they answer to the president who appointed them, outlasted both their careers. Public opinion flipped almost overnight. For the first time, a plurality of Americans told pollsters they favored impeachment.
Narrator:It's still the reference point whenever a president is accused of leaning on the Justice Department. Some nights, the people who refuse an order matter more than the order itself. Richardson and Ruckelshaus walked out of that building with nothing but their letters. And on this date, other Americans made their own kind of exit from the old order. In 1774, the First Continental Congress adopted the Continental Association, binding the colonies to a boycott of British goods years before independence was even on the table.
Narrator:And in 1803, the Senate ratified the Louisiana Purchase Treaty twenty four to seven, roughly doubling the size of the country for about 3ยข an acre. This has been the American Record from Patriot Compass. Come back tomorrow for another story from America's Past. Before you go, if you want to know more about nights like that one at the Justice Department where a single decision reshaped the presidency? That's the kind of story we tell every day.
Narrator:This show comes from Patriot Compass, a free app with a new piece of American history daily, plus deeper dives on the moments worth more of your time. Find it at patriotcompass.us.