Nimble Youth

Episode 59: Preparing Kids for Their First Smartphone

Summary
In today’s digital age, the milestone of giving a child their first smartphone has become a pivotal moment for families. Yet, many parents find themselves grappling with how to prepare their children for the vast responsibilities that come with it. In this episode, Jennifer Berger of Ready, Set, Screen discusses how parents can prepare children for smartphones and social media, emphasizing media literacy, gradual introduction, and open communication.

The Smartphone Dilemma
Jennifer Berger highlights the challenges parents face when introducing smartphones to their children. Since 2010, she has observed a significant shift in how young people interact with these devices, often becoming overly attached. As Berger notes, "I gave her a phone and now she's like disappeared into it."

The key question that often goes unanswered is: Is our child truly prepared for what happens when we turn the smartphone on? Smartphones are not merely phones; they serve as social hubs, entertainment centers, and gateways to a world of information.

The Social Media Driver’s License
To tackle this issue, Berger created the Social Media Driver's License, a program designed to equip children and their parents with the knowledge needed to navigate the digital landscape responsibly. She likens this preparation to teaching someone to drive. "We don't hand someone the keys to a car simply because they've reached a particular birthday," she explains. Instead, we teach, practice, and gradually grant more independence. The same approach should apply to smartphones.

Preparing for the Digital World
A crucial aspect of readiness is understanding emotional maturity. Berger stresses that there isn’t a one-size-fits-all age for giving a child their first smartphone. Instead, parents should look for signs of resilience and responsibility. "Kids need agency," she emphasizes, indicating that children should have a say in their digital habits and rules.

Berger also advises that families should engage in conversations about digital literacy before the phone is even turned on.  "It's very useful to have someone other than a parent tell them that as well," she points out, noting that peers often have a more significant impact during these formative years.

Practical Steps for Parents
When the time comes to hand over the smartphone, Berger recommends the following:

1. Social Media Driver’s License: Ensure your child participates in a program that teaches them about digital literacy and the importance of safe online behavior.

2. Set Up Controls Together: Parents should go through the process of setting up parental controls with their child, ensuring transparency.

3. Create a Judgment-Free Zone: Establish an environment where kids can talk about their online experiences openly, without fear of judgment. "Kids don’t go to their parents, even if their parents are great," Berger warns.

Monitoring vs. Surveillance
As parents consider how to monitor their child's smartphone use, Berger emphasizes the need for a balance between supervision and privacy. "Some level of surveillance is important," she acknowledges, but stresses that parents should foster an atmosphere of openness and trust.

"Monitoring to a certain extent is key," she concludes, suggesting that spontaneous checks on a child’s device can help maintain a healthy dialogue about their online interactions.

In concluding our discussion, it’s clear that preparing our children for their first smartphone is not just about the technology itself but about fostering a sense of responsibility, independence, and open communication. As we navigate this new territory together, let’s focus on empowering our children to make informed decisions in their digital lives.

Key Topics
  • Media literacy as a foundation for digital safety
  • The social media driver's license analogy
  • Timing and maturity for smartphone introduction
  • Balancing supervision and independence
  • Teaching kids to ask critical questions about media
  • The importance of judgment-free reporting of online issues
  • Monitoring versus surveillance in parenting
  • Creating collaborative rules for device use
  • Addressing online risks like sexting and inappropriate content
  • Early media literacy education from age three

Sound Bites

"Phones have the potential for both freedom and risk."
"Kids need a judgment-free way to report online problems."
"No devices in the bedroom or bathroom, especially at night."

Links
https://readysetscreen.org/
Social Media Driver's License


What is Nimble Youth ?

Welcome to the Nimble Youth podcast, where we provide expert insights and valuable resources for parents navigating the complexities of their children's mental health. We empower parents to nurture healthy minds in children, teens, and young adults through real conversations.

Our team of seasoned professionals, including physicians, therapists and educators, delve into pressing topics, share research-based strategies, and offer practical advice for fostering mental and emotional well-being within your family.

Matt (host):

Welcome back to Nimble Youth, the podcast where we explore the emotional lives of children, teens, and young adults, and give parents practical tools for helping them navigate an increasingly complicated world. I'm your host, Matthew Butterman. Today we're talking about a milestone of growing up that didn't exist when many of us were children. The first smartphone for many families it arrives sometime around middle school and think about how much preparation goes into choosing it. Which phone?

Matt (host):

Which carrier? How much data? What case? What parental controls? How much does it cost?

Matt (host):

But there's a much bigger question we may spend considerably less time answering: Is our child actually prepared for what happens when we turn it on? Because a smartphone isn't simply a telephone, for a young person it can become a social world entertainment center, camera, news source, gaming device, classroom, status symbol, and a doorway to virtually unlimited information and interaction. So how do we prepare children for that responsibility without frightening them about everything online, spying on everything they do, or simply handing them a device and hoping for the best? My guest today has spent about two decades teaching young people how to understand media. Jennifer Berger is the founder and executive director of the nonprofit Ready Set Screen and creator of the Social Media Driver's License, a program designed to prepare children and their parents for smartphones and social media.

Matt (host):

And I love this driver's license analogy because we don't hand someone the keys to a car simply because they've reached a particular birthday. We teach them, we practice, we establish rules, we talk about risk, we gradually allow more independence. Eventually we trust them to make good decisions when we're not sitting beside them. Jennifer's argument is that perhaps we should approach Smartphone the same way. Jennifer Berger, welcome to Nimble Youth.

Jennifer Berger:

Thank you so much for having

Matt (host):

me, Matt. So, when did you realize that giving a child their first Smartphone had become something families needed to actively prepare for?

Jennifer Berger:

Really, as soon as 2010 when phones started becoming more accessible, more pervasive, and I just saw the kids in our programs at the nonprofit that I was working with just completely attached to their phones. And it was very difficult to remove them from their phones. Also, parents would complain to me all the time. Like, I gave her a phone, and now she's like disappeared into it. So, you know, after a little bit after 2010, I guess 2014 ish was really, really showed me showed me what needed to happen, and especially watching them go through Instagram and having...

Jennifer Berger:

You know, they're showing me what they're looking at on Instagram. I was like, this is just like a lot of the other media that we taught about and something needs to be done now.

Matt (host):

Right. So let's start with the name of your program, which is, you know, social media driver's license. Why do you call it a social media driver's license? I guess I should ask, what does learning to drive have in common with learning how to use social media?

Jennifer Berger:

Absolutely. So, social media or not social media, sorry. Smartphones and cars have something in common. They're both very powerful machines, and they both have the potential for both freedom and independence and also damage to one's self or to others. And it just seemed perfectly apt.

Jennifer Berger:

So, there's so many other metaphors that we can put in there. Everybody needs to be prepared to drive a car. Everyone needs to be prepared to use a smartphone and use social media, and texting, by the way, on a smartphone. So, it seemed like a very, very normal kind of comparison, really. And also, there are things like the idea of guardrails or seat belts.

Jennifer Berger:

You know, we want kids to know what the guardrails are as far as what's normal, what's not normal online so that they can be safe, smart, and happy online.

Matt (host):

Right, because, you know, when we teach someone to drive, we don't begin by saying, you know, cars are terrible, never get in one, but at the same time, we don't say, here's the key, you figure it out, you know, you learn how to drive. We acknowledge that driving has benefits, risks, rules, and responsibilities. Yeah. So, I want to put your approach alongside that of Jonathan Hite, the author of The Anxious Generation, a book that we've referenced on this podcast a lot. Your philosophy seems to be preparation rather than panic, teaching children the skills that they need to navigate a digital world.

Matt (host):

Hyde goes somewhat further, he argues that we've moved from a play based childhood to a phone based childhood and so he recommends no smartphones before high school and no social media before 16. I think even in Australia they've implemented a, you know, a rule or a law actually on the books that social media companies can't sign up people in Australia until they're 16. So, that's a, you know, a sort of withholding the technology until they reach a certain age. So where do you agree with what a Height is Height's approach and where do you think maybe he goes too far?

Jennifer Berger:

I certainly agree with most of his approach. However, I think that it's unrealistic to think that kids are not going to get on social media until they have a phone, number one. There are laptops, and there are tablets for these things as well. Kids are in a private space when they're on a device, and parents can't watch everything. So, number one, I don't think it's realistic to think that we can delay phones and social media until age 16 or until high school, I think it was age 16, that he recommended.

Jennifer Berger:

It's an ideal. Great. That would be great if we could do that. But in today's reality, are... First of all, they are inevitably going to get a smartphone, now or later.

Jennifer Berger:

And so, what happens when they are 16 and they do get a smartphone? We also want them to be prepared then for what they're going to find online. We want them to have the basic information about how it works and some ideas for themselves about how to handle it. So, I agree with his... The ideas that he brings on about play based childhood, phone based childhood, but I do think a lot of smart parents are getting away from this phone based childhood thing, and they're definitely seeing that kids get sucked into their devices and need to do other things as well.

Jennifer Berger:

So I think that we're moving a little bit past that now. But my biggest problem is that he never mentions media literacy, which is the key tenet and the thing that I know is effective for helping kids be well while using these devices. Think it's impractical in a lot of ways. It would be great though, it'd be great if we could delay and ban phones and everything until they're 16. But I don't think that that's realistic right now.

Matt (host):

Right. So, guess that leads to my next question, what age do my child, you know, get a Smartphone at? Or I suppose you might tell me, well, there's a chronological age and there's, you know, an age of maturity, so that might vary from child to child, but is there a benchmark somewhere there where we should introduce this technology?

Jennifer Berger:

I certainly would not use age a number because kids develop differently, faster, slower. You know, emotional maturity is an important piece of this. Neurodivergent kids have different responses and reactions to what they find on a smartphone and social media. It really needs to be case by case with parents know their kids. But the signs that they are ready is that they show resilience when something difficult happens in their lives.

Jennifer Berger:

They can care for their belongings, and they are able to have some sense of why rules and restrictions are in place. And even better, it would be amazing if they had their own thoughts about rules and restrictions for themselves, some digital wellness habits that they create for themselves, not just parents down to kids kind of rules. Kids need agency. And when they can show agency and independence is when they might be ready. Now, are also the external factors and environmental factors.

Jennifer Berger:

Do all their friends have a phone? What are their friends using on the phone? Are they just texting? If they're just texting, then maybe it's okay. You know, maybe you restrict everything else.

Jennifer Berger:

So, it also just depends on what's happening in the environment, the school environment and social environments.

Matt (host):

Right. So, you've said that there are some practical things that families should do before handing over their first smartphone to their child. So, let's walk parents through them. If the phone is still sitting unopened in the box on the kitchen table, what should happen before that child logs in for the first time?

Jennifer Berger:

Well, first of all, they absolutely should get their social media driver's license, which is what our program exists for. This exact situation that you're describing. So, how can they be ready? Number one, even if a parent or caregiver is talking with their kids about digital literacy and telling their kids things about how social media works, sometimes indefinitely, pretty much always, it's very useful to have someone other than a parent tell them that as well. It's like validating, especially for like a 12, 13, 14 year old who might not want to listen to their parents as much anymore.

Matt (host):

That usually happens that, you know, the outside voice, you know, rules the room there, sorry.

Jennifer Berger:

That's right. And that's normal. And it's completely normal development. And so, that's what the social media driver's license plays into is that we have older teens talking with the younger kids about what they've experienced online. It's not a talking head adult just wah wah, saying things about what social media and smartphones are, and you should do this, and you should And do so, I think that that honestly is number one.

Jennifer Berger:

Number two is the parent needs to get their hands on that phone when it comes out of the box and know what their... Set up their parental controls and use some guides for doing that and kind of, you know, lock down whatever they need to lock down. But once Yeah. Once the kid's on there, you know, they can get on... Even not on a phone, even elsewhere, they can get on social media without a parent's permission.

Jennifer Berger:

Even if they're, like, a rule following kid, the draw is just too strong.

Matt (host):

Yeah. Yeah. So something in your approach really caught my attention and you say that children need a judgment free way to report online problems. Why is that so important?

Jennifer Berger:

Well, really it's the importance of being able to talk about what they see online without feeling some of the shame that can occur. For example, if they come across adult content, they need to be able to talk with someone, and they need to know that this is part of growing up and curiosity could be part of growing up and, you know, so on.

Matt (host):

Absolutely.

Jennifer Berger:

But... And then also, you know, and it... Just bullying types of situations. You know, they need to be able to talk about people mistreating them online and so on and so forth. So, in our program, we really lean on the idea of trusted adults, not just parents, but generally trusted adults.

Jennifer Berger:

So, in the second video, we talk about who are your trusted adults. One of them should probably be your parents, if possible. But two others, you know, is it a counselor? Is it a coach? Is it Is it your aunt?

Jennifer Berger:

Is it your uncle? Is it your grandma? Like, who can you talk to when things go askew? Because the research shows that kids don't go to their parents, even if their parents are great. And that's dangerous in a lot of situations.

Jennifer Berger:

To get very serious about it, it's quite dangerous for them not to have anyone else to talk to. So, that's why it's incredibly important for them to have judgment free ways and people who they feel safe with and they can talk to about these things.

Matt (host):

Right. So, this raises one of the hardest questions in digital parenting. How much should we monitor? Because parents now have tools that can potentially tell them where their child is, which has some safety, you know, benefits certainly, but also, you know, what they're downloading, how long they're online and sometimes, you know, much more than that. So, at what point does reasonable supervision become surveillance?

Jennifer Berger:

You know, think some parents, some parents I've spoken with feel that all of it is surveillance and they want their children to have privacy. I disagree with that to a certain extent. I do think that some level of surveillance and monitoring is important. However, let's be realistic again. You know, we are all about practicality at Ready, Set, Screen.

Jennifer Berger:

Some of the tools that are out there, parental attention all the time. And if something goes askew, then it's real easy for parents to blame themselves that they weren't watching closely enough. And I don't think that I don't think that it's fair. Like I said before, kids are alone on the Internet when they're on the Internet. As much as that terrifies everybody to think about and hear, they have to have their own skills.

Jennifer Berger:

So, some combination of those two things maybe at first. I'm not an expert as to which tools are the best or whether parents should do any of that per se. But I will say that a couple of the great parents who I know who I talked with about this said that they would just kinda grab their kids' phone for a check unscheduled and just be like, I'm gonna take a look at your text messages. I'm gonna take a look at your apps, you know, so on and so forth. And they just, like, would scroll through it and look at look at things.

Jennifer Berger:

So Right. Yeah. I think that that that can be one of the things. But they also need to know if something goes wrong, then they have their parents to talk to and they have other people to talk to. Right.

Jennifer Berger:

Monitoring to a certain extent, but really leaning on agency, really leaning on can we start teaching our child how to think for themselves and how to manage themselves? Because that's what we want for them as they leave the nest.

Matt (host):

So let's say I'm creating the first set of family phone rules. So what works better, sort of a long contract containing 25 rules, you know, a phone constitution, or just a handful of clear principles that everybody understands?

Jennifer Berger:

I'm not sure I recommend a family digital agreement in the first place. Truthfully, it does work for some families. It depends on how it's done. How it's done really matters. What I recommend is that kids and parents engage in the social media driver's license.

Jennifer Berger:

It's two courses. A child does their five to six hours of their self paced course and learns a variety of different skills, pieces of knowledge, ways to think about these things, and the parent does their course on their end. And then if they can come together and have a conversation that can be collaboration and not parents bring a piece of paper to the table and say, These are the rules that we've set, period, then your success rate is going to go way up as far as kids actually buying into those rules and restrictions. So, if you're going to do it, do it in a collaborative way where everybody can think about it together, even if the parent has the veto power, even if the parent is like, Actually, I know what's better for you, and we need to do this. But there's also even some coaching in our parent audio course, parent companion audio course, about how to collaborate with your kids in a way where they can hear you.

Matt (host):

So, background is in media literacy, and I think this is an important distinction. Digital safety isn't simply teaching a child, you know, don't talk to strangers, but it's also teaching them to ask, who made this video I'm looking at? Why am I seeing it? What are they trying to make me feel? Are they trying to sell me something?

Matt (host):

And is this verifiably true? So how early can we begin teaching children to ask those questions?

Jennifer Berger:

I think we can begin teaching them as early as three years old, probably. My two nieces, the kids in my family in my life, I started with them when they were watching something on Netflix, and an ad came up. And I talked with them about, Okay, so somebody put this in the Netflix video so that they could try to sell you something. What do you think they're trying to sell you? And how do you think they're trying to get you to like it so that you buy it or you ask your parents for it?

Jennifer Berger:

That is really, really simple. And even if they can't answer at first, it's okay. Repetition is everything. And then, the other thing that I think is really effective is just making it transparent that someone or a large group of people made the movie that you're watching, for example, or whatever you're whatever you're listening to or any of that. Who are the people who are behind it?

Jennifer Berger:

So we were watching a movie and all of the titles, the credits started coming up. And I said, these are the names of all of the people who made this movie all together for you so you could watch it. And they're like, what? Really? So that just brings it...

Jennifer Berger:

Also making videos of your own stories is just kind of like empathy, the empathy aspect. Like, you've done it yourself. You know that grownups do this so that you have entertainment, for example. So, are just a couple of different things I'll throw out there, but there are amazing resources through the National Association for Media Literacy Education and lots of other organizations who are member organizations of that one that have wonderful, wonderful, very early media literacy. But you're right on the nose about what media literacy is.

Jennifer Berger:

It's exactly that. It's knowing where your media came from and we can apply that to social media. Who puts these things into your feed? How do these things get into your feed? For example.

Jennifer Berger:

And just that questioning kind and thinking for themselves about how this could have been made in the first place is really important very early.

Matt (host):

Right. Yeah. You know, the distribution of media, social media is itself, you know, we think of it as being sort of democratic, you know, it's free, everyone can get an account, but there are the gatekeepers who are, you know, profiting heavily off of this. So, it's always important to remember that, I think. So, there'll be some situations that I think parents will face, unfortunately, but they'll need to discuss things like sexting, sexual content, predatory behavior, and inappropriate contact.

Matt (host):

But, you know, understandably, they worry about frightening a 10, 11, or 12 year old or introducing So, subjects they're not quite ready how do we have age appropriate conversations about serious online risks without making the technology or the internet itself feel terrifying?

Jennifer Berger:

Well, way that we do it in the social media driver's license is, I think, ideal, at least as a starting point, and then parents can add on in a age appropriate and kid appropriate type of way. But not telling the absolute worst story, I think is A number one. What happened to that girl when she went and met somebody line and, you know, online, but offline and so on and so forth? That is totally terrifying and not very helpful. What is helpful are things like what we teach, which is if somebody you don't know starts talking to you on Roblox or whatever you're using, here are some ways to figure out if they're really a mutual friend or who they are.

Jennifer Berger:

And by the way, you don't owe anybody a response to any questions. So those types of little guardrail things. And, you know, I think parents can just be like, say things like, because dangerous and bad things can happen to you. So you do that. You know what I mean?

Jennifer Berger:

Like, it can be really, really vague. They don't need these pictures in their in their minds. As for the sexting and things like that, we also just talk about, like, don't send anyone. Really, it's like, this is like maybe the one that's a rule. There are like basically two rules, but one of them is like, don't send anyone a photo of yourself if they request it or at all, really.

Jennifer Berger:

But if they ask you for a photo, you know, don't send it.

Matt (host):

That's a red flag.

Jennifer Berger:

So, you know, there's a whole other conversation to have there with, like, AI creations of nudity and all sorts of intense nutty things that can happen there. But I think, again, with the guardrails that maybe are a little vague for younger kids, but maybe necessarily vague for younger kids.

Matt (host):

Right. So, I wanna be careful about simplistic claims that social media automatically causes things like depression or anxiety, but we also have legitimate concerns about some patterns of use. So, what should parents watch for? Things like sleep disruption or, you know, withdrawal from their activities not done online and maybe things like constant comparison? What are some of the things that parents should look for?

Jennifer Berger:

I mean, it's really all of those things. The answer is pay attention to your kids and notice how much but what they're using on their devices. I just... I can't say enough. Also, this isn't only smartphones.

Jennifer Berger:

Just keep keep an... Make sure that you keep your eye on the laptop on the laptop, even if it's like a school Chromebook or something like that. Just all of it. Just don't forget those things also matter. But I think the receding or isolation into online gaming, for example, or just scrolling through their phones with their heads down on the couch for hours and hours and hours is honestly probably a factor, a symptom, in and of itself.

Jennifer Berger:

So, it's not a one way causation issue as far as their mental health goes. But in addition to that, just like with anything else, if there weren't smartphones in the world and your child were losing interest in the things that they used to like or can't sleep or whatever it is, you know, you're the grown up. Like, go take charge. Go do something about it and don't listen to, I'm fine, mom, I'm fine. When it gets to the point where you feel that they might...

Jennifer Berger:

You know what? I always say, if you're wrong, like, if they're actually fine, then great. You've lost pretty much nothing except a little time trying to find someone for your kid to talk to. So, that's what you want. If it's not nothing, good on you.

Matt (host):

Yeah. Yeah. So, let's finish with something listeners can use immediately, whether their child is about to get their first phone or whether they already have one. Can you give us five things or five, it could be, you know, a number of things that parents can do this week to help build a healthier digital relationship.

Jennifer Berger:

Yes, absolutely. So number one, not villainizing the phone. Not thinking the phone or social media is not telling them or showing them they think it's stupid or dismissing it. That's definitely, you know, A number one. Number two is just putting yourself in their shoes, and this is kind of a corollary to tip one.

Jennifer Berger:

Putting yourself in their shoes, sitting with them, and looking at what they like with them, and trying to understand, just like, you know, I liked a bunch of, you know, silly stuff when I was a kid too, so this is what they like. Another tip, and this one I think really should be a rule in all households, is no phones or devices at all in the bedroom or the bathroom. Especially the bedroom, but especially if you share a bathroom with anyone in your family. You let a device in there with your kid and that's right. Zoom scrolling in the bathroom but for use...

Jennifer Berger:

You know, the issue of use in the bedroom, number one, they will always probably say, I use it as my alarm clock. We have real alarm clocks too that plug in still. Believe it

Matt (host):

or not. Exactly.

Jennifer Berger:

They exist, and they were really easy to use back in our day. But but also, you know, to be serious, the worst things happen overnight in the bedroom with the device in the kid's hand. Yep. So figure out a way to talk with them about that. Honestly, it's so much better if you have to buy in from them too.

Jennifer Berger:

Let's talk about whether it's healthy for you to have that in there. Okay. So that way, when you take it, you take it and you put it somewhere else at night, I mean, you might have to lock it up or something. You know, this stuff happens all the time. But whether you do that or whether you just have an agreement and you trust your kid, having their buy in is just so incredibly important.

Jennifer Berger:

And, and those are kind of like the two... You know, those are the two actual... That's a real actual rule, I would say, as well. Also, sleep disruption, of course, like notifications going off in the middle of the night because your friend texted you because they're awake at 3AM. Something totally unacceptable.

Jennifer Berger:

We can all agree that that's an issue. And really, again, do the social media driver's license with them. Do the parent audio companion listen to parents talk about difficult topics and the topics that are discussed in the social media driver's license for kids, specifically so that they can plug in to what their kids are learning and hearing. We have conversation starters and all sorts of great information that parents can use to have these conversations. I think my last tip really is listen more than you talk.

Jennifer Berger:

So if you ask some questions, hey, how do you feel when you have been scrolling for two hours? And then be quiet. If they say, I don't know, which they often will, I don't know, then come back to it later. Well, think about it. Let's talk about it later.

Jennifer Berger:

Just keep coming back to it. Parents' job is to be annoying. Our job is to be annoying in some ways. We walked around trying to not annoy them, what would we even do that 13 year old?

Matt (host):

Exactly.

Jennifer Berger:

You know? So, just let them talk and know that you're listening instead of using questions to lead into a lecture.

Matt (host):

My guest today has been Jennifer Berger, founder and executive director of Ready, Set, Screen, and creator of the Social Media Driver's License. Jennifer has spent approximately two decades teaching media literacy and helping young people understand the messages, pressures, incentives and influences they encounter through media. The social media driver's license is designed for children roughly ages 10 to 14 and their parents with separate learning tracks that help parents prepare for, families prepare for smartphones and social media together. We will have links to the social media driver's license website and ReadySetScreen at our show notes for this episode. If there's a parent in your life currently hearing the words, but everyone else already has a phone, please do send them this episode.

Matt (host):

And if you enjoy Nimble Youth, follow the podcast and leave us a rating or review. It helps more parents and professionals find these conversations. Until next time, remember, giving a child a smartphone isn't the end of a parenting decision. It's the beginning of a conversation. I'm Matthew Butterman.

Matt (host):

This is Nimble Youth. We'll see you next time.