The Honest Money Show is your guide to understanding what money really is, and where Bitcoin fits in. Hosted by Anja Dragovic, Australia's female-led, Bitcoin-only podcast, it cuts through the noise to explore how money shapes our lives, why the current system leaves so many people behind, and what a clearer, fairer future could look like.
Expect honest, accessible conversations with some of the most interesting thinkers in the space, the kind that take you from "I don't really get this" to genuinely curious. No hype, no pressure, just money, made clear.
Whether you're brand new to these questions or already deep in them, you're welcome here.
I think it’s all red flags.
I think it’s just a set of red flags.
...is a huge, huge, huge red flag.
It’s probably the biggest red flag in the bill.
...that Bitcoin is gone in a single transaction.
It’s completely irreversible at knife point.
The government’s not going to step in and
help recover your funds the way they
would in the traditional banking system.
Joining me today for another episode of
Honest Money is Jordan Ditloff. I will
shortly get Jordan to introduce himself,
but we're going to be talking about a very
important piece of legislation that's just
being rushed through for consultation,
which is the Treasury Laws Amendment Bill
2026 Tax Information Reporting. And we'll
be talking about other things as well. So
welcome to the show, Jordan. It's good to
be here, Anja. Good to finally be on the
show. Yes. So would you like to give my
audience a bit of an introduction into who
you are? Because, yeah, as we've spoken
offline, you do quite a few things and I
thought it'd be better that you do it
yourself. Yeah, look, in high school,
people sort of, you know, as a euphemistic
way to say I'm a bit of a Renaissance man,
I'm a jack of all trades, master of nuns.
Some more critical people might say
dilettante. But I'm a law graduate. I'm a
libertarian party activist and former
libertarian candidate. I was the lead
Senate candidate for the federal election
in Victoria. And still remain very
passionate about Bitcoin, about free
speech. And there's a lot of intersections
between libertarian policy and the Bitcoin
community. So I'm certainly not an
accountant. I'm not an expert on the
technical side of Bitcoin necessarily. But
people like Sean Clark, who I'm sure you
know and have a great deal of respect for
as well, really opened my eyes and made me
sort of aware of how, I guess, big the
Venn diagram overlap between Bitcoin and
libertarian ideology is. So, yeah, so I
guess I spend a lot of time. The way I
best describe sort of what I do for work
on a day-to-day basis to people is it's a
bit like Clockwork Orange, where my eyes
are sort of taped open and I'm forced to
watch and report on and be aware of all
the terrible things the government is
planning every day. So it can sometimes be
hard to sort of keep a smile and a
positive outlook. But I think that in the
long run, you can't stop the signal. Yeah.
And we'll talk about that as well in this
episode, because, yeah, obviously, I think
I've shared a number of times on this
podcast that I have definitely started
turning more libertarian since the COVID
shenanigans. And it's not something that
was on my radar so much in my prior life.
And we can get into maybe the reasons why
that is the case in Australia. But let's
talk about this bill that's been rushed
through. The typical consultation period
is, I think, 27 days. This one has only
given the industry 13 days to respond. So
the deadline is 28th of October. We don't
have a lot of time. There are definitely
ways for people to make a submission. But
let's talk about what some of the red
flags are. Yeah, well, it's interesting
because this bill, compared to many, is
quite small. It's eight pages long. The
exposure draft that's been provided. And
what it fundamentally does, I think, look,
to be frank, I think it's all red flags. I
think it's just a sea of red flags. I
don't think there's really anything in the
bill that isn't concerning. And what it
seeks to do is essentially continue this
campaign that the federal government have
been on now for, I'd say, really the last
five or six years. Certainly, I think,
since COVID, it's escalated. And you might
even say it sort of traces back to the GFC
when, obviously, sound money sort of first
had its origins. But essentially, this
bill seeks to do two things primarily. The
first and I think most concerning
immediately for Bitcoiners in Australia is
that it's going to require from the kick
in date. And they're sort of saying in
this exposure draft that it's going to be
essentially from July 2027 is when these
reporting obligations are going to
commence. And it's going to require
domestic exchanges, so digital exchanges
that are cryptocurrency or in the case of
the Bitcoin exchanges, Bitcoin only
exchanges. It's going to require them to
essentially report, not only collect
information, but actively report
information to the ATO whenever there is a
transaction, an exchange, a disposal, any
transaction essentially through a digital
exchange. And the predecessor to this was
the travel rule, which came in June or
July, ironically, when I was in America.
So that was pretty unsettling. And it's
kind of this process of steadily drawing
the net closer and closer. And if it feels
that way, that's because that is what is
happening. They're sort of trying to close
off all the escape exits or the rabbit
holes that people might previously have
used to try to persist with the idea that
what you do with your own money is none of
the government of its business, which is an idea
that they very much disagree with. So,
yeah, so essentially this bill creates a
mandatory line-by-line reporting
requirement. And that's concerning for the
very obvious reason that it's going to be
a huge breach of privacy and a huge change
to what people interacting with digital
exchanges can expect in terms of their
privacy and in terms of what the ATO knows
about your financial position or your
digital assets. But I think it's also
concerning for another reason, and that is
because it's continuing this trend of
almost treating people who are investing
in Bitcoin, and I would say investing in
the true sense, not in the accounting
sense, which is how they sort of maintain
this fiction of their entitlement to tax,
what they would say are capital gains if
you convert Bitcoin back into fiat
currency, which I know from watching your
show, you're probably a proponent of the
idea that people shouldn't do that anyway.
So the one solution to this, which I'm
sure we'll come to, is probably just not
to sell your Bitcoin, just to stack away,
which you'll still be able to do without
being taxed. But the government will
basically be watching. So as you're
stacking sats, the ATO is watching with
interest and keen to know about it if you
convert it back the other way or try to
send it overseas. And that brings to the
second primary thing the legislation does,
which is it gives the government the power
to implement rules to coordinate with
similar international schemes and
reporting frameworks. Most notably, the
UK, the EU, a number of other sort of
BRICS countries are starting to do this.
The US, as we talked about offline, kind
of proposed legislation like this. And I
think Trump's re-election really put pay
to that. He's all in, not obviously as
much all in on Bitcoin as we'd like. He's
sort of into crypto more generally. But
Trump's re-election at least delayed the
US implementing something like that and
bought some time. And the other really
concerning thing, so those are the two
things the Act purports to do,
essentially, is it's trying to essentially
have a line-by-line visibility on every
transaction you make with an exchange and
then tie into international reporting
frameworks. But another thing, and one of
the reasons that the bill is so short,
that it's only eight pages in length, is
it doesn't actually tell you how any of
this is going to happen. And I can tell
you there's a few phrases in law that
raise the hackles in the back of my neck
more than the minister may, by regulation,
prescribe. Because those words mean that
essentially, once the bill's passed, you
have no way of knowing what kind of a
hydro it's going to morph into. It will
soon rapidly span forest's worth of pages
of regulation. There'll be guidelines,
frameworks, all manner of rules that are
not voted on by parliament or subject to
consultation with industry groups or
Bitcoiners that will just be whatever the
minister of the day and their department,
the public servants that don't change from
election to election, decide is going to
be done. So that's always a big concern as
well, because these decisions that
ministers make to implement regulations
aren't reviewable. They're not subject to
parliamentary scrutiny, essentially. Once
this enabling... I should be careful using
the term enabling act, but this is what it
is. It's essentially Bitcoin's enabling
act. Once they pass this legislation, then
that gives the minister free-ranging
powers to do whatever they believe
necessary, essentially, to implement those
priorities. So, yeah, look, I know that
that doesn't sound great, and it's not.
But I think that one thing to remember is
that these kinds of legislative
developments are always reversible. What
parliament gives, the parliament can also
take away. And so Bitcoiners are very good
at taking the long view and looking ahead
and, you know, planning for the winter, so
to speak. And so I think that that is an
advantage as a body of people who are
affected by government overreach, that,
you know, they can't make you sell it,
right? They can't, you know. So, yeah, I
think that hopefully long before Bitcoin
maxis, who are just, you know, stacking
sats and holding on, have to interact with
this regime, there might be a new
generation of politicians who understand
these things better and can change the laws.
Yeah. When I was reading the bill
with the help of Claude, trying to dissect
what some of the red flags are, what's
kind of been intentionally left out of the
bill, it really raised a lot of red flags,
which you've just covered. But I just kind
of maybe want to bring it, I guess, in lay
terms for the audience. So the biggest,
well, there's a number of red flags. One
of the red flags is the intention of this
bill is to help with tax reporting,
essentially, to make sure you are not
committing tax fraud. Now, what's not
required is in the bill, it's required
that you, exchanges submit a transaction
ID. So you already have on the exchange
the amount of Bitcoin you purchased that's
passed on to the Australian taxation
office. What's not required, in my view,
is for you to provide your transaction ID,
which is essentially you sending Bitcoin
to your own hardware device. It is
basically you just pocketing your money.
Why do they need to track your private
wallet? That's really concerning. And,
like, that's not a taxable event. So it's
kind of being pitched as something that is
to prevent tax fraud, but then they're
implementing things that are kind of reach
beyond what's necessary. That's kind of
one thing that really gives me the ick.
And, like you said, the fact that they've
left a blank check, that, you know,
they've basically just given the minister
all this power after the fact to be able
to implement any future framework without
it going back through parliament and
having a vote is a huge, huge, huge red
flag. It's probably the biggest red flag
in the bill. And I'm glad that you
mentioned that these things are
reversible. It's always good to give
people hope. But I just feel like this is
so far a lot worse than the travel bill.
And I also think that it puts further
strain onto the industry to provide
reporting. And I think the frequency of
reporting is a lot higher than, let's say,
the banking industry has to provide on
this very same equivalent data in fiat
terms. So it just seems like the
government has this thing. They don't
understand it. They're a little bit afraid
of it. And they're just tightening the
noose around, I guess, this currency, new
form of money, and also, by extension, the
people who hold it. Now, Australia has
about 30% of adults that own some form of
crypto. 70% of those own Bitcoin. That's
according to some of the research done by
some of the bigger exchanges. And as you
know, people in, you know, there's an
increasing number around the world of
wrench attacks. What the government fails
to see and what the Australian Bitcoin
industry body has been advocating for and
I've been advocating for on my podcast is
the fact that you can't treat $100,000 in
a bank the same as $100,000 in your
private hardware device. If you're at a
nice point, if you're traveling overseas,
you know, you want to go to South America
somewhere, do a Machu Picchu trail, you
know, that you've always wanted to do. If
you come across criminals and this data
has been leaked on the dark web, that
Bitcoin is gone in a single transaction.
It's completely irreversible at knife
point. The government's not going to step
in and help recover your funds the way
that they would in the traditional banking
system. And the government is aware of
this, but they just don't seem to care.
Now, a huge percentage of the Australian
population cares. So it just seems really
reckless and really careless. And I'm
sorry for this little rant, but that's
just my two sats on the bill. By all
means, by all means. And I would tell you
that as you were talking about, you know,
well, it's not a taxable event to transfer
to your own private wallet. Well, it's not
right now. But if you look at the way that
the government has been treating capital
gains in some other areas, such as
superannuation, for example, above a
certain threshold and other things,
they're talking about unrealised capital
gains tax. And I suspect that,
unfortunately, Bitcoin and other forms of
crypto looks like a very juicy piñata to
whack when it comes to unrealised capital
gains, because the government will be
saying, well, maybe you're holding on to
it for 50 years. When do we get a piece?
How do we know it's not going to slip out
of our fingers? So I think that they are
setting up the stage for that kind of
encroachment. Because, you know, when they
talked about unrealised capital gains in
recent budgets, there was a huge outcry
because the people that affected largely
were boomers. And there's a lot of
political power there. And the government
understands that. And they've sort of
walked back a lot of those proposed
changes. But it shows you that always, and
I think there's two things happening here.
First is the government's broke, right?
And the government basically is addicted
to spending. They engage in inflationary
expansion of money supply constantly. I
don't need to sort of talk about this to
your audience. I'm sure they are well
aware. So there's that. So there's the
fact that the government is essentially
looking for new ways to extract resources
from their subject population. And then
the second thing is as well that I think
while it's true that they don't understand
Bitcoin, what they do understand is
competition to their power and to their
authoritarian ability to control. And I
think that while they don't understand how
Bitcoin works, they understand what it
allows people to do, which is to escape
their clutches more easily and be more
sovereign. And I think that that is one of
the things that is driving this escalating
campaign. So I think that there's those
two dimensions. There's the government's
broken and, you know, the biggest of all
wrench attacks on Bitcoiners is from the
government, passing capital gains,
unrealized capital gains tax that they can
just claim, you know, that you have to pay
for things that you haven't even benefited
from notionally. And then there's that
trying to take out a competitor where
they're viewing an inflation resistant
alternative form of money that isn't
within their control. And they're
thinking, oh, that's not good. And I think
you see that. And I'm sure exchanges like
Hardblock and others in the Bitcoin
industry body would see there's a huge
uptake as well in people moving their
superannuation into self-managed super
Bitcoin funds. And I can also predict on
the horizon, I'm certain, that there will
be restrictions or closing of ability or
making it harder for people to do that in
the future as well. Because not only does
that tick all of the two boxes I've talked
about of the competition and the taking
away money from the government, but it
also is competing with the super industry,
which is a huge rort for people from both
sides of politics, unions, ex-banking
officials, all that sort of thing. The
industry super thing that they do, that is
just a complete rort for the government.
And the more self-managed super in
general, and in particular, the double
whammy of self-managed super with Bitcoin,
that's like alarm bells are ringing for
them. So I think that's what's going on.
And in some ways that should be heartening
and kind of reassuring to people who might
be fairly early on in this journey, like
myself, or more further along, like
yourself and others and people who are,
you know, movers and shakers in the
industry, that essentially it's that
Starship Troopers meme. It's afraid, the
brain bug, you know. They are responding
to the success and the value proposition.
So in one way, if you want to be a glass
half full sort of person, which I have to
be, because otherwise I'd probably just,
you know, be curled up in a fetal position
and never come out or talk to anyone like
yourself. If you're an optimistic person,
it's a sign that the inherent value and
the increasing awareness of and
realisation of why people should be doing
this is what the government's responding
to to try to deter them. So, yeah, that's
what I would say about that. Yeah, thank
you for that. That's some really good
insight. I always wonder what the state of
Australia is, and I guess I've been
reflecting this. It's similar to what you
just recently said. I don't think we have
a cost of living crisis in Australia. I
think we have a cost of government crisis
in Australia. The reason I'm grinning as
you say that is because that was my
campaign slogan for the Senate, for the
federal. Oh, really? Okay, no, I didn't.
Yeah, I don't know if I can send it to you
before this goes to air, but I'll send you
some great billboards we had where it said
fix the cost of and it had living crossed
out and then it had government spray
painted over it. Yeah. Yeah. That was,
yeah.
Yeah, we have one of the largest
governments in the world.
There's more public workers per 1,000
citizens in Australia than there is
pretty much in any other country.
Why we need something like 143
public workers to service the needs of
1,000 citizens, I don't know.
And they just seem to be expanding the scope.
And like you said, the SMSFs,
they are coming after them.
The fact that Albanese has recently said
that they see the industry super as
essentially what was the word he used,
the phrsase he used, he said a national asset.
And then they're now implementing
further restraints on people getting an SMSF,
like a self-managed super fund,
essentially by requiring to have some education
around how it all works and who's
going to be administering that education.
Well, of course, it's going to be the government.
So they're not only increasing the scope
of what they do,
obviously that all requires more funding.
The only way they can always come up with,
you know, an innovative solution to how
they can essentially fund all of those, um
jobs that they create for themselves is
through taxing the population more and
more. But do you find that Australians are
waking up to this? What are your thoughts
on that? I think that you, I think that's
true. And I think that while the electoral
fortunes of the Libertarian Party that I'm
a passionate advocate for and member of
are not yet reflecting that, you can see
the footprint those concerns and that
those policies have in things that One
Nation are now taking on and advocating,
which are essentially lifted from the
Libertarian Party platform. And I think
that imitation is the greatest form of
flattery, sincerest form of flattery. And
at the end of the day, if through the hard
work and great policy development of the
Libertarians, we can see Libertarian
policies being advocated and taking hold
before the Libertarian Party follows that,
then I'm very happy to see that. And I
think Australians are looking around and
wondering, hang on a sec, aren't we meant
to be the lucky country? Aren't we meant
to be easygoing? Aren't we meant to be
free? You know, it's in our national
anthem. And I think that, you know, like
yourself, I'm a sort of a second to third
generation migrant. My family came over
from Germany. And so I sort of still have
this kind of almost little bit still
outside perspective looking at Australian
society. And I think for a society that
has prided itself as being, you know, like
Crocodile Dundee, and that's the
impression the rest of the world still has
about Australia a lot. When people from
overseas come here now, they're like,
there's so many rules. There's so many
regulations about everything. There's
like, you know, don't walk your dog on the
beach, don't litter, this and that and
everything else, you know. And they just
go, what's going on? Like, I get that
feedback all the time from people visiting
us. Can I just give you an example? I did
a trip around Australia. I've never seen a
country with so many signs. There are
signs everywhere. I would love to know,
for someone to do an analysis, just how
much we spend on signage in Australia. It
is just out of control. Like, you will
drive somewhere in the outback in the
middle of nowhere and there will be signs
everywhere that have never been taken down
and there's so many of them. Like, what's
going on? Anyway, sorry. Did you? No, I
agree. No, I agree wholeheartedly. And I
think that slowly, slowly the Overton
window is starting to shift and we're
seeing that with the rise of One Nation.
And I personally, and I'll say this up
front, you know, I don't think One Nation
is the long-term answer. I think there's a
lot of risks that they become what they're
fighting because they don't really have
that ideological core. Like, they arrive
at a lot of the libertarian positions we
advocate sort of by the route of common
sense because a lot of what libertarian
policy arrives at is what would once have
been called common sense. But when you
don't have that principle route by which
you arrive at those positions, it's much,
much easier for the system to, you know,
get you to compromise, get you to shift,
get you to, you know, turn away from what
got you to the dance. And so I, but I do
think that it's very clear people want
less government, people want lower taxes,
people want more individual responsibility
and accountability. And they can see that
suddenly the government's sitting around
their living room table or at the kitchen
table parenting their children, you know,
and how long before, and I have a very
unfortunate habit of making predictions
that come true just because the government
is so predictable. But how long until
there's a sugar tax, you know, where kids
under a certain age aren't allowed to buy
certain foods or all this sort of stuff,
because why wouldn't that logically
follow? What's the difference between the
way that the, you know, age assurance
technology with social media is being, you
know, justified? What's the difference
between that and saying that the
government knows better than parents what
their kids should be watching on TV, what
their kids should be eating? There's no
difference. It's like, you know, the age
old horror trope of once you invite the
vampire into your home, then that's it.
And more and more people have realised,
oh, actually, by asking the government to
solve all of these problems and by
demanding the government come up with
solutions, we're actually letting the
vampire into our home. Do you want to just
define for the audience, I imagine
majority of them will know exactly what
libertarianism is, but in case someone is
not, because it's not necessarily taught
in our public government funded schools.
It's absolutely not taught in our
government schools. I can promise you
that, because I've got mates in the
Libertarian Party who are school teachers
and they're like, no, we're being taught
that the Industrial Revolution is the
oppression of women and, you know,
children being exploited for labour and
not all the amazing, wonderful things that
came from that for our society and
civilisation. So I can tell you it is
definitely not being taught. Yeah,
absolutely. But let's define it for the
audience.
At it's most, at it's most
simple, the easiest way to explain
libertarianism is it's the premise that
you are the best person to make decisions
for yourself and your family. Wow.
Revolutionary, right? Like, I know, mind
blown, exactly right. And literally, if
you said that to many, many people in
government or in government departments,
they'd be like, oh, no, you can't do that.
Like, well, like, how are they going to
know what the optimal thing for them is?
The government should be telling them.
And, you know, flowing on from that core
principle is the idea that people have a
right to their own property, including the
property in their bodies. They have the
right to make decisions, even bad
decisions. They have the right to hold and
share and debate ideas, even if those
ideas are reprehensible or wrong. So it's,
look, it is, I sort of joke, but it is
almost very, very countercultural to what
started, I think, in the post-war sort of
50s and 60s and has kind of now manifested
as this socialist sort of nightmare where
the institutions are just completely
captured. I'm currently doing my PhD and
I'm seeing firsthand how absolutely warped
and the university system is not great.
And, you know, in high school, kids aren't
being taught things. And then in uni, what
they're being taught is the opposite of
what's true. You know, on X, every time we
have debates about economics, I see these
comments like, oh, you don't understand
Keynesian economics. Like, no, I
understand tax and spend Keynesian
economics, but it's just wrong and counter
to human nature and counter to what
actually happens in the market economy.
So, like, yeah. So libertarianism, I think
that there are many Australians who would
be listening to what I'm talking about and
nodding along, but have never heard the
word libertarian. And I saw a guy the
other day who was like, I'm economically
conservative and socially classically
liberal. And I'm like, you might be a
libertarian, mate. And it's the premise
that there's a difference between
tolerance and promotion. And you should be
free to make whatever choices you want
about your life, as long as it's not being
forced on me. And I don't have to be
coerced into accepting them or promoting
them myself. So it's really very simple
and it sounds sort of almost too
straightforward and simple to be true. But
it's a set of principles that really
arrives at the right conclusion every
time. It's really heartbreaking. You know,
Elle, like, she's obviously, I guess, a
member of our community, Elle the Freedom
Fairy. And she's had a very similar
experience in university where that
diversity of thought was actually not
welcomed. And it's heartbreaking for me. I
think universities maybe back in the day
used to be such a wonderful institution.
Maybe some people won't agree with me.
But, like, you know, there's, like, old
school heritage listed universities and
used to come, you know, used to go there
and used to debate. And that was welcomed.
I don't feel like that's been the case
for, like, decades now. And it's... I
literally this morning had to complete my
diversity training as part of my
compulsory confirmation of candidates just
stuff for the PhD. And I have to tell you,
I'm like... It took all my self-control to
complete that. But it was, like, speed
running, like, out of Toy Story with the
pigs pushing the button. I'm just like...
Complete. You know, I hope my university
doesn't see this. But, yeah, I think that
really we have been conditioned to
relinquish our personal responsibility
and, therefore, our personal sovereignty.
And that's why I think Bitcoin is such a
great on-ramp to libertarianism and vice
versa. There are a lot of libertarians who
don't know as much about Bitcoin as they
should, I think. And so it's two
communities that I think are very, very
aligned along that sort of Austrian
economic tradition and the ideas of
individual sovereignty, suspicion of what
you're told rather than what you can
verify, all these kinds of things. But on
that, too, I think that it's worth noting
that all of this that we've been talking
about today from a legal point of view,
this applies to transactions through
digital exchanges. And while we have many
fantastic Bitcoin-only digital exchanges
in Australia and they are secure and
excellent at what they do, the government
has realised that the way to regulate
cryptocurrency and Bitcoin specifically is
to regulate the bottlenecks through which
people engage with that technology. It's
not illegal to purchase Bitcoin off
exchange. It's not illegal to do a whole
number of things. But the moment that
things come through the exchange, that's
the government's... That's their... They
say it's like a watering hole. You know,
in the African savannah and the crocodile
that's the government is going, yes, we
know where you are now. So I would just
note, and I'm not going to go into
specifics or whatever, because it's
possible to go out there and do quite a
bit of research about options for
potentially purchasing Bitcoin in the
first instance in a way that then sort of
escapes this anti-money laundering, anti
-terrorism financing trap. But those
things are worth considering going forward
as well because the downside,
unfortunately, the structural downside of
Bitcoin that is the verifiability of the
chain is that once you know where
someone's on-ramp onto the blockchain is,
then you can track everything they do from
that point onwards, essentially. So the
moment there's a compromise of the
anonymity of where someone is, then that
can be traced and tracked after that
initial sort of tagging. So, yeah, those
are things to consider as well. And I
don't say that to diminish the value or
suggest that people shouldn't. I think the
exchanges are a great starting point. But,
you know, down the track, I think the
importance of understanding self-custody
and the importance of understanding ways
of obtaining Bitcoin that maybe aren't
under the government's watchful eye of
souring might be worth also educating
itself about. Public service announcement.
Um, but going back to libertarianism,
I really wanted to ask you
what you thought of like in Australia.
We very much all think where we stand
on our political spectrum in a
one-dimensional way,
where the left or right of centrist,
people don't so much think
where they, you know, sit vertically.
Do you think that's intentional?
Why do you think that is?
Yeah, I think people tend to think or
they're conditioned to think, as you say,
from left or right on particular issues.
But that almost north-south axis that
you're referring to, if you're listeners
or viewers who might not know what you
mean, it's the authoritarian to
libertarian axis or authoritarian freedom
axis, where it's like whatever you think
should be the case in terms of how you
want to live your life. The moment that
you accept using the government to impose
those values on others is the moment that
you accept your enemies doing the same
when the wheel turns. And that's like, I
think personally, even socialists should
be libertarian and vote libertarian
because then they're protected from their
political enemies. You know, there might
be the far right or the NSN or whoever in
future using the system against them. But
unfortunately, in politics, few people
seem to grasp the cyclical nature of
things and realise that things they put in
place thinking, oh, this is only going to
be used by people I like to do things I
agree with. And temporarily. Exactly,
that's right. The wheel always turns, you
know, and what you bring in for the best
of intentions today, according to your
worldview, will be used against you
tomorrow. And I think the same is true,
for example, of Christians. I think that
all Christians should vote libertarian
because that's the only way to prevent the
enemies of faith from using government to
suppress or persecute. So, and I think
those things are poorly understood. You
know, people always imagine that it's
going to be them in charge making the
calls and, you know, directing the sword
of government at their enemies. But they
never stop to think, well, what happens 10
years down the track when today's freedom
fighters are tomorrow's insurgents and,
you know, unclean, unvaccinated? No, we
saw that through COVID. It's people who
were gleefully using and supporting use of
government power to suppress and attack
people that were making decisions they
didn't agree with. But those same people
subsequently might have the opposite
precedent used against them. So, I think
that that's really important to remember
is really the best way to protect your
ability to live your life the way you want
to is to make sure that you're not just
getting in and using the levers of
government to do the things you want to do
in the short term. You're getting in and
limiting what it is the government can do
and making that interference in private
life as small as possible. What are the
things that we truly need government to
do? And I'll tell you, the list is very,
very small. And even the things that
people would have traditionally said,
like, oh, who's going to build the roads?
I don't know if you've gone out and driven
on the roads lately, Anya, but the
government's not doing a very good job of
it. So, I don't think that the private
society and the free market could do
worse. Same thing with law and order and
crime. You know, I live in Victoria and,
unfortunately, I've recently become aware
of a new nickname for Melbourne, which is
Melba Dishu. And, you know, Melbourne
Dishu, like the capital of Somalia. And
it's just increasingly the sense that the
government not only doesn't care, but
they're not on their way or interested in
helping you or saving your family and
providing those core things that
supposedly the government is meant to
provide. Yeah. And do you think that
sometimes people who, I guess, understand
libertarianism a little bit, mistake it
for just right wing? Do you feel like
that's the case? Well, there's two kind of
assumptions people make. The first is that
it's like this far right extremism, which
you see, and that's because the mainstream
media portrays it that way. Yeah. You
know, you see Javier Malay, the president
of Argentina, described as far right, you
know, and he's a literal economist.
Austrian economics and all of the policies
he's been putting in place in Argentina
essentially have been doing exactly what
we say they would do, which is reduce
inflation, get spending under control,
produce balanced budgets. House prices are
falling, rental availability is up, all of
these things that we, you know, it's like
having the magic bullet in terms of the
policy formula that is proven to work, the
cure to cancer politically, and then
saying, no, we don't want to do that.
We're not interested. So that's the first
problem is this sort of far right
portrayal. The second problem, I think, is
that a lot of people think because
libertarians believe people should be free
to do things, even things that might be
harmful to them, like, you know, people
should be free. You know, if you want to
knock off a slab of alcohol, like that's
not illegal today. But, you know,
libertarians believe that you should be
free to do things that might not be a
great idea. You should be free to gamble,
all these things. But people confuse that
premise with endorsement or support or
promotion of those things, this sort of
idea that libertarianism is libertine,
that we just think society should be
hedonistic and there should be just
everybody going out and having no regard
for the society around them. And I think
that's the furthest thing from the truth.
I think that libertarianism is about
voluntarily assumed obligations to your
fellow man, to your family, to your
community, to your sporting club, to your
church or your faith. So libertarianism
isn't saying that the individual is the
most important. They're saying that in the
real world, in the free market and
society, individuals don't operate in a
vacuum. The government is the one that
wants to rip apart and atomise society and
make us all individuals. Because then
we're dependent on the government for
everything. The government views free
society and free voluntary associations
and voluntary obligations as competition.
So I think that's really important to know
as well, that libertarians aren't saying
that the government should be replaced
with nothing. They're saying that the
natural building blocks of society are
family, are faith, are sporting groups,
all these things that, you know, humanity
was doing just fine before the modern
nation state intervened in many of the
areas. That it's come to take
responsibility for. For anyone who is a
defender of the state, who's listening to
this show, if they say, well, we need the
government to, I guess, step in and
prevent, you know, people from drink
driving. Yes, someone is free to go and
drink themselves to death if they wish,
but it's not the best for them to go on
the road and put other people's danger,
sorry, life into risk. What would you say
to that? Well, I'd say that the government
making that illegal doesn't stop it from
happening. Like, you know, I think that
the reality is that much of what we
perceive as crime prevention is, in fact,
crime enforcement or crime punishment
after the fact. You know, and I think this
idea that people who are making bad
decisions in their own life, like drink
driving or people who are career
criminals, all the sort of thing, that the
fact that the idea that they're sitting
around the campfire and going, you know
what? Like, the government passed this law
the other day that said we get an extra
two years in prison if we get caught. And,
oh, we're just not going to do it. Pack
up, boys. We're going home. That's not how
the world works, whether it's gun laws,
whether it's laws to pass. Like, I'm
firmly convinced that whether it's
speeding restrictions, seatbelts, drink
driving, whatever it may be, I'm convinced
that the effect on road fatalities and
casualties and that behaviour actually
occurring is about zero. Because people
aren't, that's not how human nature works.
People aren't automatically, they're not
mechanical inputs that some Keynesian
economist or government behavioural
theorist can sit there and go, okay, if we
modify this or if we pull this lever, then
correspondingly people will do less of
this. That's not how society works. It's
never how it's worked. And I truly believe
that, in fact, in many instances, the idea
that the government will take
responsibility for these problems makes
them worse and makes people almost export
their responsibility for their own life to
the government. Because they say, well,
why should I help my neighbour? That's the
government's job. Why should I do this or
solve this problem? The government will do
it. Why should I? I was the other day
driving and there was a giant pothole in
the middle of the road. And basically,
it's a long story and I won't repeat it,
but in the end I was able to kind of like,
it was fixed pretty quickly because I was
like, oh, this is a problem. That happens
so rarely because everybody thinks it's
somebody else's problem. So the government
displacing private initiative, private
responsibility is one of the main reasons
why I think we have such a dependent,
unaccountable and irresponsible society.
Yeah, I can certainly relate to that. And
that is one of the reasons why I moved to
the Northern Rivers region is, again, I
guess, as part of my libertarian journey.
I realised I don't really like living in
cities. The bigger the city, the worse the
people. There's a sense of anonymity and a
lack of personal responsibility that
doesn't really necessarily yet exist to
the same extent in the Northern Rivers.
I agree with you. I think that the, you
know, it's funny because I'm born in the
country. I grew up on 20 acres in the
middle of nowhere. My nearest neighbours
were like kilometres away. We were free
range kids. It was a beautiful way to grow
up. But when you're a kid in that
environment, you think you want to live in
the city and you think that's the worst
thing in the world or whatever. As an
adult, I can tell you, I was incredibly
blessed to have the society, to have the
childhood I was able to have. And now I
realise the value in that. But I think
that society more broadly used to have
that sense more. There used to be more
sense, even in a neighbourhood in a city,
that you would know each other, that
you'd, you know, keep an eye on the
neighbours' kids and that a responsible
adult would sort of be around and would
have some sense of what was going on. And
I think that that is, you know, everything
the government does takes oxygen away from
private initiative and from private
enterprise. And that's not just in
business and in the market. It's in
society and in the way we interact with
each other. A great example is the
charitable societies that used to exist
before Centrelink displaced that. And what
happened was you had a system where there
was a little bit of a safety net. Sure, it
might have been a bit more hit and miss
and not as overall consistent everywhere.
But it also meant that if you were
receiving welfare, freely donated charity
from your neighbours, you had a face to
that. You understood that you were being
helped to get back on your feet by people
you had to see every day and that you had
a sense of accountability for and to.
Whereas now the modern state becoming the
welfare state turns it into an entitlement
and robs that welfare of its dignity and
of its opportunity to actually be a short
-term fix for somebody to then restore
them back to full participation in
society. So, yeah, I think that there are
a huge amount of assumptions that we make
about how the world has to be, how the
world has always been and how the world
could be in future but has never been yet.
And I think that we're so eager and
willing to get locked into this tunnel
vision that I do think, yeah, the future
is bright and there are lots of
opportunities and possibilities for how we
might organise ourselves that we haven't
so far. And that we are going to have
generational change where both politicians
and people who vote in elections, the
demographics are going to change. There
will be, like you say, this cycle and
there will be people that are wanting to
live differently. Now, let's just go back
to One Nation. I know we're running out of
time with your phone battery, but is there
any hope that you have that they might, if
they do come to power, that they might
actually move them a needle and change
anything? Or do you think they're
ultimately going to be subordinate to the
same incentives that, I guess, the Labor
and Liberal Party have been all along? So
I think that in one very important sense,
One Nation and their rise is pivotal and
positive, and that is that it's giving
people the comfort that they can vote for
someone other than the major parties, that
the world isn't going to end, the sky's
not going to fall in, that there is no
such thing. You know, the definition of
major party appears nowhere in any
electoral legislation, in our
constitution, even in convention in
Westminster. There's no such thing as a
major or minor party. There's just
political parties that have more or less
support, and nothing's set in stone. You
look at the Liberal government in WA, or
sorry, the Liberal Party in WA, they've
got like three lower house seats. You
know, nothing is forever, and there's no,
you know, special privileged spot of major
party. In Germany, which is my family
background, grand coalitions, coalitions
between multiple parties often exist, and
what it creates is a long-term thinking
and a way of having to compromise and
having to actually look at a shared vision
going forward. And the debate and
compromise and all that that necessitates
means things are less taken for granted
and there's less short-termism. So I think
in that sense, the rise of One Nation is
an inherent good because it will lay the
foundation for a change in the way
Australians think about and interact with
politics. In the more literal sense, in
answering your question, I do think, and
I've been around and involved in and
observing politics for long enough, to
remember that the original Palmer vehicle,
the Palmer United Party, got four or five
senators elected to Canberra. By the next
two years, they were all independent
senators. They'd been kind of picked off
one by one by the machine because this is
a machine. It is a system, and it's a
system that will fight back and will
proactively defend what it has and what
it's used to having. And I think that you
can already start to see it in Victoria, I
think, where it starts with something
innocent, like, oh, currently people are
getting $200 for LGBT whatever things.
We're going to spend $300 on putting kids
into sports because it's good for kids to
be in sports because they'll get better
discipline and health and whatever, and
that's good for fighting crime. Now, okay,
sure, but you've just said instead of
taking away the funding on LGBT stuff in
schools and replacing it with nothing and
reducing the debt Victoria's in, you've
just swapped Peter for Paul. You've just
said, okay, we don't agree with this
thing, but we're going to now spend it on
something we agree with. And however good
the intentions of that might be, whether
or not that's true, whether or not it's
effective, you've just accepted the
premise of the major parties, which is
that you can pork barrel, you can spend
money we don't have on things that are
your pet priority. And those are the
instincts that I see that really concern
me because I think it's going to look good
for a little while until it doesn't. And I
think that there's nothing structurally or
ideologically to stop one nation from
becoming what they're fighting. You know,
there's that saying, he who fights demons
should look closely that he doesn't become
one himself. Yeah. That's a bit of a
saying. So I think that until we see a
genuine ideologically motivated
alternative to the major parties that is
more inherently immune in their DNA from
those kinds of incentives. You know, we've
had MPs in Victoria stand on the no side
of the chamber in the Legislative Council
when they are the only MP to vote against
something. The banning of Nazi salutes in
Victoria, our MP Tim Quilty stood alone
against 40-something other members of
parliament. He was the only person
standing in the no side of the chamber
when that vote was passed. And that would
be an incredibly difficult thing to do.
Like, it doesn't matter how determined you
are or how sure you're right. There'd be a
part of you that'd be thinking, am I right
here? But what we've seen play out since
that was banned, we've seen this huge
resurgence in actual Nazism. We've seen it
be used for propaganda purposes. We've
seen everything we predicted that would
happen with it has played out. And what we
need is politicians and political
movements that will be prepared to be the
one person saying, no, we shouldn't do
this. Or no, this isn't right. It doesn't
matter if it's popular. It doesn't matter
if it's what the people are clamouring
for. We need to persuade and convince, not
just mirror. And I think that until that
happens, we're not going to see long-term
change. Yeah. Well, thank you very much
for coming on the show, Jordan. Is there
anything else you'd like to, any final
thoughts you'd like to leave with my
audience? Only that if you like what
you've heard, if anything that we've been
talking about or anything that I've said
about libertarianism or anything else
rings a bell or sounds like something you
want to know more about or hear more about
day to day, my socials are on all
platforms at Ditloff, the number four
cents. That might sound really clever, but
I had to change Ditloff for Senate to
something that I didn't want to throw off
whatever momentum I'd built through the
federal election. But at Ditloff for Sense
on all platforms, including YouTube. And
I'd love to bring you into that community
and start to spread the awareness. Great.
Thanks so much, Jordan. No worries. Thank
you, Anja.