
The Forward Thinking Dental Podcast
SEO METADATA
SEO TITLE:
Before You Extract: Intentional Replantation in Practice, with Dr Samuel Kratchman | PDP256
META DESCRIPTION:
Dr Samuel Kratchman and Dr Shivakar Mehrotra explain intentional replantation: indications, protecting the PDL, step-by-step technique and success rates.
URL SLUG:
intentional-replantation-in-practice
PRIMARY TOPIC:
Intentional replantation for failing root-treated teeth
SECONDARY SEARCH TOPICS:
- What is intentional replantation?
- Intentional replantation success rate
- Treating failed root canals on lower second molars
- Atraumatic extraction for replantation
- Keeping the PDL alive with Hank's Balanced Salt Solution
- Root-end filling outside the mouth
- Splinting after intentional replantation
- Alternatives to implants for failing endo
BEFORE YOU EXTRACT: INTENTIONAL REPLANTATION IN PRACTICE
THE PROTRUSIVE DENTAL PODCAST, EPISODE PDP256
HOST: DR JAZ GULATI
GUESTS: DR SAMUEL KRATCHMAN AND DR SHIVAKAR MEHROTRA
EPISODE SUMMARY
On this episode of the Protrusive Dental Podcast, Dr Jaz Gulati is joined by endodontist Dr Samuel Kratchman, who directs surgical endodontics at the University of Pennsylvania, and UK-trained Penn resident Dr Shivakar Mehrotra. They explore intentional replantation: atraumatically extracting a failing root-treated tooth, performing the root-end resection and filling outside the mouth, and placing the tooth back into its own socket, with reported success rates of around 88 to 89%.
They cover when to retreat conventionally first, which teeth suit replantation, including lower second molars and upper molars, how to consent patients, keeping the PDL alive with Hank's Balanced Salt Solution or similar, imaging, handling the tooth, managing crowns and cracks, success and complication rates, case selection, slow atraumatic extraction technique, splinting and post-operative care. Jaz's Protrusive Dental Pearl is to protect the PDL at every stage.
IN SHORT
Intentional replantation means atraumatically extracting a failing root-treated tooth, sealing the root end outside the mouth, and replanting it in its own socket. Dr Samuel Kratchman says it has a well-documented success rate of around 88 to 89% when the tooth comes out in one piece, and that a skilled general dentist could do it with careful case selection.
KEY TAKEAWAYS
- Jaz's pearl: protect the PDL by extracting atraumatically and keeping the root moist.
- Consider conventional retreatment first; replantation suits teeth where surgery is hard to access.
- Lower second molars and upper molars are the most common candidates.
- Straight roots with bone between them are ideal; dilacerated roots usually rule it out.
- Patients must be prepared to leave without the tooth if it can't be removed in one piece.
- Dr Kratchman avoids scraping the socket walls, to preserve the PDL lining.
- He reports splinting fewer than 15% of cases, as prolonged splinting may promote ankylosis.
- Failures usually happen in the first year, from resorption or cracks.
QUESTIONS ANSWERED IN THIS EPISODE
1. What is intentional replantation?
2. When should I consider intentional replantation instead of retreatment?
3. Which teeth are best suited to intentional replantation?
4. How do you keep the tooth alive outside the mouth?
5. What is the success rate of intentional replantation?
6. How do you extract a tooth atraumatically for replantation?
7. Does the tooth need splinting after replantation?
8. How should I consent a patient for intentional replantation?
IN THIS EPISODE
1. Introduction: a last resort before you extract
2. Protrusive Dental Pearl: protect the PDL
3. Meet Shiv: from fearing root canals to Penn
4. Meet Dr Samuel Kratchman
5. What is intentional replantation?
6. Indications: which teeth, and when
7. Retreatment first: where replantation fits
8. Consent: preparing patients to leave with one less tooth
9. Keeping the PDL alive, and thinking outside the box
10. Step by step: imaging, handling the tooth and the root-end filling
11. The curveball: coronal seal, crowns and consent
12. Success, failure and complications
13. Case selection and atraumatic extraction technique
14. Post-operative care and splinting
15. How to reach Shiv and Dr Kratchman, and outro
CHAPTER 1: INTRODUCTION: A LAST RESORT BEFORE YOU EXTRACT
JAZ:
So the root canal has failed in that lower second molar. We at Protrusive, and you who listen, believe we should try to save the tooth, the whole tooth and nothing but the tooth, where possible, before considering implants. You want to delay implants. Implants are awesome, but they're a replacement for a gap, not a replacement for a tooth. But that failed root canal...
What are you going to do? It's already had a fantastic root canal filling from an endodontist, under rubber dam. So the next thing would be an apicectomy, or microsurgical endodontics: raise a flap, clean out the abscess and do a retrograde filling. We've discussed that in a previous episode. But how are you going to do that for a second molar?
There are so many vital structures and nerves you could damage, let alone the challenge of getting access to that region. This is where a little-known, last-resort endodontic technique has a success rate of up to 89%, and I'm joined by the world authority on the topic, Dr Samuel Kratchman.
Thank you so much to Dr Shivakar Mehrotra, who brought his teaching faculty onto the show as well. I sat next to Shiv on a crown lengthening course, and six years later I heard from him: he was in the States doing an endo programme. I had no idea about this thing called intentional replantation, and when I've asked dentists whether they've heard of it, very few have heard of this strange technique, which, with the right case selection, actually has a pretty damn good evidence base.
Look, I'm not going to do it justice, but essentially, you atraumatically extract that second molar, do the apicectomy and the retrograde filling outside the mouth, extraorally, and then push the tooth back into place. That, my friends, is intentional replantation. Isn't that mind-blowing? It kind of makes sense.
It makes so much sense, but it leaves so many questions, which this episode will answer. There are, of course, nuances, case selection dilemmas and atraumatic extraction considerations, but we're going to do a deep dive into how you could potentially offer this to your patients.
Because Dr Samuel Kratchman believes this isn't just the remit of the endodontist. You, my friend, could do this. And as with every piece of education, the role isn't to teach you every single step, because you'll only remember so much. Yes, there's AskJaz, our AI, and everything will be recorded, so there's a reference.
But if, based on this podcast, you identify a case you want to do, do read the literature. Do read the step-by-step protocol followed in the literature. Do read that 1997 paper by Dr Samuel Kratchman, which we'll put in the show notes. But please enjoy this episode. It's an absolute cracker.
CHAPTER 2: PROTRUSIVE DENTAL PEARL: PROTECT THE PDL
JAZ:
The Protrusive Dental Pearl I'm giving you relates closely to the key themes of this episode on intentional replantation. If you ever do this treatment, imagine that lower left second molar I described: be careful with how you extract the tooth. Be very atraumatic, and try not to put forceps on the root.
Why? Because the root has the PDL, and that ligament is make or break. Just as with an avulsion, where we want to keep the extraoral dry time as low as possible, if you atraumatically extract that second molar, be efficient. You want to do the retrograde filling and everything involved as efficiently as possible.
And of course, you want to store it in saline. All these things are there to protect the PDL, because when intentional replantation fails, it fails biologically before it fails endodontically: think resorption, ankylosis and that kind of stuff. Once you've done the hard bit, the atraumatic extraction, the retrograde filling is actually easy, and that will fill you with confidence for the rest of this episode. Just remember to protect that PDL. Let's now join Shiv and Dr Kratchman, and I'll catch you in the outro.
CHAPTER 3: MEET SHIV: FROM FEARING ROOT CANALS TO PENN
JAZ:
Dr Shivakar Mehrotra and Dr Samuel Kratchman, welcome to the Protrusive Dental Podcast. It's so nice to have you from across the pond. Let's start with you, Shiv. I went to school with your cousin, and then I sat next to you on a perio crown lengthening course.
Years later, I heard you were in America, and I thought, "Wow, okay, this is cool." So tell us about yourself and how you ended up there.
DR SHIVAKAR MEHROTRA:
Hello, and thanks for having me, Jaz. I myself don't know how I ended up here. It's definitely a happy accident. But to rewind, I finished dental school at Leeds, and I came away thinking I never wanted to do an exam again. Then during VT, I realised I didn't quite know what I was doing, especially with root canals, which scared me so much. I remember thinking I was probably more scared of a root canal than the patient was, which is a weird thing really.
With that in mind, I took on a few DCT roles, and I went to the faculty and told them, "Look, this is something I struggle with. Please help me." In Cardiff, there was some lovely faculty, who took me under their wing, demystified it, unravelled it for me, and helped me learn in a controlled environment.
Then, piece by piece, you learn to love the progression and you get addicted to that growth. I went from someone quite nervous to someone who enjoyed and appreciated it, and then decided to pursue it indefinitely.
How I ended up here at Penn was something of a perfect storm. I knew I wanted to do endo. At the same time, a lot of my sisters got married and moved abroad here, so my head was turned about what life might be like abroad. Looking at different programmes, I came across Penn, all the great surgery work, and the opportunity to spend time with Dr Kratchman himself, whom you have here today.
So I just shot my shot. I somehow managed to get in, and I thought it was a once-in-a-lifetime opportunity, so I took it.
JAZ:
I recently hosted the two ladies, Hazel and Doreen. Did you catch that? Did you see them around?
DR SHIVAKAR MEHROTRA:
Yes, I know them quite well. They're actually teaching, so I bump into them quite often, and last year they were residents alongside me. So yes, I saw the episode.
CHAPTER 4: MEET DR SAMUEL KRATCHMAN
JAZ:
I feel like everyone I know is at Penn right now, doing great things. Dr Samuel Kratchman, thanks so much for joining us to share your experience and wisdom.
Tell us about yourself, how long you've been affiliated with Penn, and your career journey. It's nice to learn what got you to where you are.
DR SAMUEL KRATCHMAN:
Thanks very much, Jaz, for having me here. It's a pleasure and an honour. First of all, about Shiv: we needed a resident with a British accent, to diversify ourselves. We quizzed him on American football before we'd let him in, and to see if he could get us Liverpool tickets, which is very difficult from America. As for me, I was born and raised in New York, then spent eight years in Boston at Tufts University for both my bachelor's and dental degrees.
Then I came to Penn for two years. I had black curly hair and a beard similar to Shiv's, not all this white. Endo was kind of by default. At Tufts, we had to do a lot of prosthetic work, including all our own lab work: waxing up teeth, crowns, even flasking dentures. The prosthetic professors were only a couple of years older than me, and they'd go out drinking with you at weekends.
But during the week, they'd look at my wax-up, say, "This looks like a toe," throw it on the ground and step on it, after I'd spent all weekend waxing it up. Meanwhile, the endodontic professors at Tufts would put their feet up on the table and say, "Sam, how can I help you?"
So I got a good feeling about endo. And in all seriousness, I feel that being a general practitioner is perhaps the most difficult type of practice, because you have to be an expert at everything, and that's not how my mind works. I'd rather focus on one particular field. Economically speaking, endodontics is great. We say it's recession-proof, because if patients are in pain, they'll be motivated to come to you.
And as an endodontist, it's very rewarding that in a matter of minutes we can open up a tooth and relieve the patient's pain. That's what drove me. I was always a New Yorker at heart, and figured I'd finish at Penn and go right back to New York. Thankfully, my wife, who was my high school sweetheart, said, "We're not going back to New York.
"It's too much traffic, and it's too expensive." So I took a job in Philadelphia, and like a mushroom, a fungus that grows on you, Philadelphia grew on us. It's been our home since 1989, we raised our two children here, and it's been a really nice journey.
In terms of teaching, when I finished the programme, I came back and started teaching two days a week the following week, because I knew that if I started working five days a week and earning a real living, I'd never give up part of that to teach.
I've always done three days of practice and two days of teaching, for 35 years now. I have four private practices in the suburbs of Philadelphia, with seven doctors, all of whom I trained at Penn. They're my family, as are Penn and my residents. I've always been two-day faculty, and honestly, residents like Shiv keep me going and keep me young. It's the more enjoyable part of my week, let's say. But the practice obviously pays the bills and keeps my hands dirty and able to work.
CHAPTER 5: WHAT IS INTENTIONAL REPLANTATION?
JAZ:
What a lovely balance you have in your week; that's great to hear. I'm very excited to distil the experience you have. So, we're talking about intentional replantation. Is it replantation or reimplantation?
DR SAMUEL KRATCHMAN:
It's funny you say that, because technically it's replantation: you're only taking the tooth out once and putting it back. I've also been criticised, because historically it's been known as intentional replantation, when of course every time I do it, I'm doing it intentionally.
It's not that, say, a resident of mine accidentally tapped off a bridge, took the tooth out with it, and asked, "What should I do, Doctor?" and I said, "You're going to unintentionally replant it." You didn't mean to take it out. But in the textbook it says intentional replantation.
It is replantation. The important thing is not to confuse it with transplantation. Transplantation is, for example, taking a third molar and transplanting it into a first molar site. Those are done, and I've done some, not nearly as many as replantations, but they're much more difficult, with a lower success rate.
The beauty of intentional replantation, and this is how I describe it to patients, is that you're taking the tooth out and putting it back into its original socket, so you don't have to worry about rejection. I'll say to them, not really as a joke, "Hey, look, in medicine they've been transplanting hearts from animals to humans, or from human to human,
"and what you worry about most is rejection. With replantation, you don't have to worry about rejection, because it's your own tooth going into its own socket." It's been around for many, many years. The articles we read with the residents go back to the 1960s. It's a procedure I want to talk about today so that everybody, after they listen to this podcast, thinks about it and realises they could do it in their own practice.
It's not magic, as in, "Oh, you have to be an oral surgeon with 30 years' experience." You could be a dental student taking an oral surgery course and learning how to take a tooth out atraumatically, which is the most difficult part. After that, everything is done outside the mouth. It's a relaxing and easy procedure.
Ready for this? Success rates of 88 or 89%, documented over years and years. There was a paper in 2017 by Dr Mainkar, a systematic review from the sixties all the way to 2017, showing a success rate of 89% for replantation.
JAZ:
Good confirmation there, Shiv. But the first thing to check, for those who haven't heard of this technique, even though it's been around for so long: it's not really even touched on at dental school.
I may have read about it once upon a time, but I've never done it. I go to a lot of CE, and I haven't seen anyone present on it, not even once. So you've explained what it is, taking the tooth out and putting it back in. But why would you do that?
DR SHIVAKAR MEHROTRA:
Sorry, just to add, and correct me, sir: one of my motivations for wanting to do this talk is exactly what you said about our education. It's not really mentioned. I had no clue it even existed. In fact, the first time I saw it was when I came here on a visit, and I thought it was witchcraft at the time. I've obviously come to learn it's not witchcraft. It's based on hard science and evidence.
JAZ:
Shiv, you trained in the UK like me, so we were taught in the ortho clinics, the multidisciplinary ones, about autotransplantation: using a wisdom tooth or a premolar to replace a central incisor, that kind of thing. But I actually hadn't heard of replantation.
DR SHIVAKAR MEHROTRA:
Yes, which is bizarre. I've come across lectures where it's been presented at international conferences, and in the break room everyone's talking about it, baffled about what it is and whether they can really do it.
Just to add testament to what Dr Kratchman said, here's something that's different from England that I want to highlight. A lot of dental students here go straight from dental school into residency, which is a big difference from England, where you have to rack up years in DCT and practice and so on.
So we have residents here who've only done the undergraduate requirements, going straight in and doing it confidently and with precision. With that in mind, I just wanted to highlight how user-friendly and applicable it really is.
CHAPTER 6: INDICATIONS: WHICH TEETH, AND WHEN
JAZ:
So what are the indications, the ideal scenarios? Before we hit record, you mentioned certain teeth. What would be the requirements or indications for this treatment?
DR SAMUEL KRATCHMAN:
Sure. I'm the director of the surgical part of the programme, which deals with teeth that have already been treated and are failing. We always think about treating it conventionally first, endodontically. So you look at the reasons for possible failure, and at the location of the tooth. You always have to consider being conservative first. But lower second molars are too far back to reach, and the bone is too thick. Upper molars are close to the greater palatine bundle, or right up in the sinuses, and difficult to reach. Those are the two most common teeth we do.
That's a real indication for replantation: you've already done the root canal, you've done a retreatment, and now there's a persistent infection.
And you have to be realistic with the patient. The most difficult part is the treatment planning, meaning the tooth has to be conducive to being removed in one piece. Obviously, the more of these you do, the easier it is to look at a radiograph and say, "Well, these roots are pretty straight."
The best case is when there's some bone between the roots. That makes for not only a nice extraction but, when I replant it, ready for this statistic, less than 15% of the time do I even splint. Because if you take it out carefully, and I'll go step by step as we go along, the concept is to take it out by gently luxating it.
You're not causing acute inflammation and widening of the socket. It's not how fast can I get it out; it's how atraumatically can I get it out. When you take it out, the lesion is attached to the root. You cut off the end of the root. We use the microscope for documentation purposes, but a pair of loupes is fine to see.
You prepare the end of the root, fill it, and then put it back in. We manually compress the plates, because the gentle luxation opened them up. We have the patient bite down on gauze, go over post-op instructions, take an x-ray, and check mobility. Nine times out of 10, it's plus one or less.
So you don't even have to splint it. The patient walks out with their tooth, often without splinting. In fact, if you splint it and leave the splint on too long, you'll promote ankylosis, which could actually be detrimental. So the number one indication, as I said, is lower second molars, because of the proximity to the nerve bundle and how thick the bone is.
Upper molars, as I said before we started recording, are if anything even easier to remove in one piece, because the maxilla is thinner, more pliable and more elastic. I also told you about some cases we've done on lower bicuspids with lateral canals,
where there's a lateral lesion that's not due to a fracture. To get to that lesion surgically, you'd destroy bone and probably destroy the tooth. We've done replantations in cases like that, and they're even easier, because the roots are conical, so you can even rotate the tooth to take it out. So that's another reason. Please stop me if I'm talking too much.
JAZ:
No.
DR SAMUEL KRATCHMAN:
Also, say you have a post perforating the tooth, and you can't get to the perforation surgically. It's going towards the furcation, lower down, or it's in the palatal root of an upper bicuspid. To go in surgically, you'd have to cut through healthy bone and healthy root, and sacrifice crown-to-root ratio.
Instead, pull out that bicuspid, leave the bone alone, address the perforation, and put the tooth back in. There are so many different reasons to do it. I've done several hundred of them over the years, not all myself, but with my residents and partners. And what you said before is true: a lot of people don't know about it.
Even in the United States, it's pretty rare for a programme like ours to teach it and do it. I know this because, in all my years of practice, when I send a report back after a replantation, I get a call from the dentist: "What did you do there? The patient said you pulled out their tooth. Are you crazy?"
And it's an amazing practice builder. I've had patients referred to me by people I'd never heard of. I asked one, "Where'd you get my name?" and she said, "You pulled out my friend's tooth, fixed it and put it back in. I figured if you could do that, you could do a simple root canal on me." So it's a matter of educating dentists and the community to want to save their natural teeth, and having this as an alternative.
CHAPTER 7: RETREATMENT FIRST: WHERE REPLANTATION FITS
JAZ:
In a nutshell, to simplify, it's the easiest apical surgery you'll ever do, if you can get the tooth out atraumatically. It's basically how to make apical surgery not anatomically compromised or difficult. But for our younger audience, we need to clarify the scenarios where you might decide that this is a step too far,
and you need to do the root canal retreatment first. Like you already mentioned, try to be conservative first. If you have a poor-quality obturation, unfilled canals, instrument fractures, or signs that it perhaps wasn't disinfected well, the first port of call would be root canal retreatment.
So how can you help younger listeners look at the radiographs and the tooth in the mouth, say a lower second molar? What factors should tip them towards, "Okay, definitely do the root canal retreatment first," rather than jumping to anything more surgical?
DR SHIVAKAR MEHROTRA:
Great question. Broadly speaking, you want to look at the tooth and understand your skills and limitations relative to the challenge ahead of you. If you look at the root canal in front of you and think you can do a better job than what you see, then conventional retreatment makes the most sense.
Say there isn't a big crown and post you have to get past, the canal doesn't look that hard, and maybe there's a separated instrument you think you've got it in you to get out. Then of course conventional retreatment is on the table. But occasionally, you'll look at a case and think, "There's a curve there.
"The instrument is past the curve, and I don't think I can access it. There's a lesion associated with the tooth as well. Plus, anatomically, it's in a place where surgery isn't the most approachable or easy for my particular skillset." That's when you'll think about intentional replantation, and that's where it fits in the treatment hierarchy.
CHAPTER 8: CONSENT: PREPARING PATIENTS TO LEAVE WITH ONE LESS TOOTH
DR SAMUEL KRATCHMAN:
And you always have to be honest with the patient. I'll tell you what: the very best patient comes to my office saying, "I had a root canal, I had a second root canal, and that's enough already. I'm ready to lose it." For every replantation, the patient has to be mentally prepared to leave the office with one less tooth.
They have to be mentally prepared to lose the tooth. These are the words I use: "Okay, you have two choices. You can go to the oral surgeon, who'll take the tooth out in about five minutes and throw it in the garbage.
"Or you can let me try to take the tooth out, and if I can get it out without breaking it, how do you feel about me fixing it and putting it back in?" And I'll joke, "You're 50 years old, and this is your 12-year molar. You've had it for a long time. Why not try?" When you explain it that way... and don't get me wrong, if it's fractured or cracked, I don't charge them for a surgical replantation procedure.
Those patients are the best, because it's a win-win situation. If it fractures or you can't get it out, they expect that. And interestingly, you'd think that with how popular implants have become, at least in the US, I'm not sure about the UK, this would be something we did 20 years ago and don't do so much anymore.
It's the opposite. Twenty years ago, implants were going crazy, everything was getting extracted, and endodontically treated teeth were getting extracted for implants, because "we know endo is eventually going to fail". Now, in the United States, the pendulum is swinging towards saving natural teeth, and this is a great alternative.
Because worst case, if the replantation fails or fractures, the patient gets an implant. But we now know implants aren't 100% successful, and if an implant fails, that's much, much more difficult to manage. So it's really just a mindset, and something we should all keep in the back of our minds as a possible treatment.
JAZ:
Well, the teeth you described as the most common are also the most difficult for implants, because of the sinus, or because it's a lower second molar. So sometimes replantation may be the last-chance saloon anyway.
That makes a lot of sense. What you said reminds me of a recent episode we did on surgical extrusion of, say, anterior teeth and premolars, where they take the tooth out atraumatically. They often don't take it all the way out, just enough to splint it again.
And now they have the ferrule. In your case, you're taking it out, chopping off the ends of the roots, doing your cleaning and, I guess, a retrograde restoration, and putting it back in. I guess it's a bit like an avulsion in trauma, but with the extraoral dry time in a very controlled situation. You try to create a-
CHAPTER 9: KEEPING THE PDL ALIVE, AND THINKING OUTSIDE THE BOX
DR SAMUEL KRATCHMAN:
That's the important part. I want Shiv to talk about his case this afternoon, which falls right into that. But first, two very important points. The most important thing is to be able to get the tooth out in one piece, okay?
Then, once the tooth is out of the mouth, and we did a study on this 10 years ago, you have to keep the periodontal ligament moist. So there's no extraoral dry time. We've done our studies with Hank's Balanced Salt Solution, a transport medium that basically mimics the constituents of saliva. It keeps the periodontal ligament alive for 30 minutes.
You can buy that from a supplier, or you can go to the supermarket and buy something called Pedialyte. Do you have that-
DR SHIVAKAR MEHROTRA:
I've got to interject. Unfortunately, we don't have Pedialyte itself. There are alternatives, like Dioralyte, which is a sachet you mix with sterile water.
For Pedialyte, I'd have to find an import. If you message me, I'll try to bring some back over Christmas. But we have alternatives. Dioralyte is probably the brand you're looking for, unless you can find something on Amazon.
DR SAMUEL KRATCHMAN:
That's the key, because when the tooth is out of the mouth, you have to keep those cells alive, so that when you put it back in, the body doesn't reject the tooth. Getting a little technical: when you gently luxate, bending the plate of bone and taking the tooth out successfully, you're severing the periodontal ligament. So there's PDL on the root, which stays alive via Hank's Balanced Salt Solution, Pedialyte, or some type of electrolyte solution.
And there's still viable PDL in the lining of the socket. I found out the hard way years ago, when I'd scrape and scrape in there thinking there might be granulation tissue. But no, you don't want to touch the walls of the socket, because there's important periodontal ligament there.
When I replant the tooth and compress it, I want the cells in the socket to join with the PDL on the root for reattachment. Very, very important. Now, Shiv, just today... wait until you hear about this case, and how he's thinking outside the box about a way to save a tooth.
DR SHIVAKAR MEHROTRA:
Yes. I don't want to confuse people, because replantation is a very simple procedure, including the decision-making: you think about conventional treatment, then surgery, then replantation in your timeline. But very occasionally you'll have to think outside the box. In this particular scenario, a young lady had an upper molar. We did the retreatment, but unfortunately it wasn't successful.
The root affected was the palatal root, and for those of you who do surgery, palatal approaches aren't the most comfortable for the clinician or the patient.
In this case, the anatomy was too close, so surgery was contraindicated. But, I wouldn't say thankfully, she's also undergoing orthodontics at the moment. So one of the discussions Dr Kratchman and I had was this: although this tooth has quite splayed roots, which traditionally wouldn't be the most fun extraction, because she's having orthodontics, could we orthodontically extrude the tooth a little bit for us?
We could just ask the orthodontist to adjust the brackets a little, to give us a little bit of mobility on that tooth. And while they're doing that, we could file down the crown a little, because it currently has a stainless steel crown on top.
With that in mind, we could potentially take the tooth out atraumatically, assess it, snip off the root, as you mentioned, put in a retrograde filling, and then put it back as though nothing had happened. Of course, we'll wait and see how it turns out. But these are things you can delve into to make it more comfortable, for sure.
CHAPTER 10: STEP BY STEP: IMAGING, HANDLING THE TOOTH AND THE ROOT-END FILLING
JAZ:
I've got so many questions, but I think the best way to tackle this next bit is to go through the protocol for a standard case. My first question is about imaging. What's the minimum level of imaging required? Do you need a CBCT to exclude a crack, or is a crack something you'll always check for when you inspect the root itself? Let's start with imaging, then go step by step from there. Also, you've described the solution you keep it in, but how does that actually work?
How do you keep the tooth still? I'm trying to picture the ergonomics and the actual mechanics of how you do it.
DR SHIVAKAR MEHROTRA:
Yes. The first step is imaging. Here at Penn, we'll always take a cone beam CT for this. The reason is that you want to know the anatomy of the tooth you're dealing with.
You want to see whether the tooth can come out feasibly, the best approach and the best angle, et cetera, and of course its relationship to the surrounding anatomy. Once you're happy with that, the procedure itself, and the Hank's solution or Pedialyte you mentioned, is very simple.
Your assistant will have a syringe of the solution ready. As soon as the tooth comes out, you'll have a little gauze soaked in it to rest over the tooth. Make sure you're working over a surface so you don't drop the tooth; very important. Then, little by little, they'll gently squirt it, drop by drop, to keep the tooth moist while you're working on it, inspecting it, staining it, whatever you need to do. Then, once you're ready, you just pop it back in the socket.
DR SAMUEL KRATCHMAN:
You ask a great question. Let me elaborate on two things. First, with the CBCT, unfortunately you often can't see cracks or fractures, because there's too much distortion or noise from posts, crowns and even adjacent teeth. But you're looking at the pattern of bone loss, which might be suggestive of a fracture.
But for sure, if you take it out in one piece, or if it breaks while you're taking it out, you'll confirm it. The most frustrating thing is when I get the tooth out in one piece, I'm all excited, and then I see the root is cracked.
Forget it. I've tried cutting into the crack and putting a bioceramic in there and putting it back, but it doesn't work. As for your question about how to stabilise the tooth: we have special forceps, two forceps we use for all of them, which have a good grip on the tooth.
We put a little rubber band around the forceps handle, so once we've taken the tooth out, if your hand loosens, you still hold onto it. We work under a microscope, and I make sure the resident positions their hands like this when they're looking.
With Shiv, I'm holding his hand so it doesn't move around while I'm trying to look through the scope. Because you're right: normally the tooth is in the patient's mouth, whereas here you're holding it. So you just have to keep your arms rested down.
We're looking through a scope or loupes, but it's so easy, because you're just cutting the end of the root with a high-speed. We keep the tooth constantly bathed in the solution. We have a little emesis basin, a little basin, filled with the solution.
So we can always pause, dip the tooth to keep it moist, work, then dip it again. One of the most difficult parts of lower molar apical surgery is angling your ultrasonics for the root-end preparation, but here you're looking right at it, so that's even easier. We do it with the high-speed, and we always place a root-end filling with a bioceramic putty, which we've researched for close to a decade. It's a great biocompatible material that we use for all our apicals and for this. Then we replant the tooth.
JAZ:
On bone grafting: I don't do implants, but I've been on a grafting course where they curette the chronic infection, trying to remove all the granulation tissue,
then put in some doxycycline for a few minutes and rinse it out. Is anything sophisticated like that required, in what's described in the literature? You made a really good point about not being overzealous and removing the PDL, which is more coronal. But if there's usually an apical infection, I imagine we're still curetting that area.
DR SAMUEL KRATCHMAN:
Well, first of all, the apical infection usually comes out attached to the tooth, and you're cutting off the end of the roots. If there's some tissue left down apically, yes, we'll suction it or remove it with forceps. I just don't want you scraping the walls of the socket. You raise very good questions.
On treating the socket: every single time I give this lecture, I'm asked that question, especially overseas. Now I actually answer it before it's asked, because I know it's coming. Especially overseas, there's a lot of Emdogain and lots of different things used to treat sites, whether osteotomies or, in this case, the socket.
There's really no indication for treating the socket. We're even doing PRF studies here at Penn now, and people say, "Maybe we should put some platelet-rich fibrin or something in there," and I say there's really no indication. I'll explain why. There are a lot of studies in our field on where the bacteria are when you do a root canal.
They're in the canal space, especially apically, in the apical delta. When you have a lesion or granulation tissue around the tooth, there can be extraradicular biofilm on the surface of the root, but the granulation tissue itself is inflammatory tissue. It's sterile. So once you cut off the tip of the root,
you get rid of that, along with whatever tissue comes with it. If there are little pieces of tissue left, that's inflammatory tissue, right? Inflammatory tissue actually has some growth factors and can attract osteoblasts. So I'd much rather you leave a tiny bit of tissue in there than go scraping. You're taking care of the source of the problem, which is the tip of the root, prepping it and sealing it so there's no leakage coming out.
Every single resident is always so nervous about leaving a piece of tissue here and a piece of tissue there. And I just say it won't have a negative effect on the treatment.
CHAPTER 11: THE CURVEBALL: CORONAL SEAL, CROWNS AND CONSENT
JAZ:
Gents, I've got a curveball scenario for you now, something that's really at the crux of endo-restorative. Let's say you have-
DR SHIVAKAR MEHROTRA:
We didn't say baseball-
DR SAMUEL KRATCHMAN:
Oh, a cricket curveball. That's very different from a baseball curveball.
JAZ:
A doosra. I'm going to bowl a doosra at you. Okay, the scenario is a lower left second molar. It's root-filled, and the root filling looks well condensed and okay, so because of the anatomical reasons you mentioned, you're thinking apical surgery will be very difficult. It may be a candidate, and the roots aren't too funky or curvy, so you think you'll be able to retrieve it.
However, there's secondary caries under the crown. So I imagine you need to go back to basics: remove the crown, fix the caries, put a temporary crown on, and then do the replantation, right? It sounds too basic, but it's a fundamental principle.
DR SHIVAKAR MEHROTRA:
I'd say that's mandatory. You want a good coronal seal before you start doing anything, because there's no point doing a retrograde filling and getting a great apical seal if the coronal seal is flawed. All you're doing is inviting bacteria to cause a nuisance. So yes, to answer your question, spot on. I'd do it in exactly that workflow.
JAZ:
But here's the tricky element. Fair enough, our restorative dentistry and our ability to achieve a seal may be predictable.
DR SHIVAKAR MEHROTRA:
Yeah.
JAZ:
But say you do that, put a nice temporary crown on, and then start taking the tooth out, and your core and everything fractures, and now it's subgingival. You've lost your ferrule despite your best efforts, because these are often heavily restored teeth. Or you take it out and the root cracks, so you've essentially wasted the patient's time and resources.
So the consent discussion gets a bit more complicated in these scenarios, where you have to do a lot of foundational restorative work before something that might be a bit of a maybe afterwards. Do you get what I'm trying to say?
DR SHIVAKAR MEHROTRA:
Absolutely, you're quite right. That's where the discussion with the patient becomes paramount, I think. I know you've done an episode with Dre, from Dre Composite, who always talks about CYA, cover-your-back, statements. I think that's prudent. When you're having these conversations with the patient, it's paramount to say, "Look, this tooth is traditionally, quote unquote, unrestorable, or not in the best shape.
"It's pretty battered, for whatever reason, and it doesn't have a great prognosis. Most likely it's due for extraction. All we're saying is, if there's an opportunity for us to take this tooth out in one piece and do what we need to do to make it whole again, would you like us to put it back in and see how many more years you can get out of it?"
Then it's up to the patient whether they roll the dice or prefer something more terminal, which is just an extraction, with or without replacement. But at that point, the patient has to take on some of that risk as well.
DR SAMUEL KRATCHMAN:
And to expand on what you said, almost all these teeth are fragile, in the sense that they've had a root canal, a second root canal, and a crown and build-up. Absolutely correct. First of all, if there's recurrent caries and they need a temporary crown, at least in the US, that can be worked out with their general dentist. I say, "Do me a favour: can you take off that crown, remove the caries and put a temp on, without charging the patient yet for the full crown, since you haven't delivered it, and then let me do my replant to make sure there's enough tooth structure first?"
Now, whenever there's a crown on the tooth, which is much more than 50% of the cases I've done, I always keep temporary cement on the table. Years ago, if the crown came off but the tooth wasn't broken and I did the replantation, I'd put the tooth back in the mouth without the crown and think, "Wow, this is great. Now there won't be any occlusion on it."
The patient would feel great, but I learned the hard way: you have to get that crown back on pretty soon, or else the tooth will super-erupt and the crown won't fit. So now, if the crown comes off without damaging the tooth, without breaking or taking out the whole build-up, I do my replantation.
My assistant cleans out the inside of the crown, and the last thing I do outside the mouth is re-cement the crown with temporary cement, wipe up any excess, and put the tooth back in, so I don't have to worry about it later. If the crown and build-up come out, then I'm looking under the scope: is there a crack?
Is it damaged? If not, you'd better have something handy to put inside the access, whether you're taking it out of the existing crown or putting it back as a whole. And to jump ahead a little to another question: say the crown breaks, but the replantation is still successful. When can the patient get a new crown?
We usually like to give it at least three to six months to make sure it's successful, meaning there's no resorption or ankylosis, and it's comfortable and functional. Then you can prep it and make a new crown, and there's less risk involved.
CHAPTER 12: SUCCESS, FAILURE AND COMPLICATIONS
JAZ:
With this technique, you're essentially inducing trauma to the PDL, as atraumatically as possible, but it's still trauma.
Then there's the resorption risk you mentioned. Do you have any numbers on what percentage have such a complication? Is that included in the 89% success rate? For the 11% that fail, is it because of resorption, lack of tooth structure, or reinfection?
DR SAMUEL KRATCHMAN:
It's a perfect question, and whenever I give this talk, I always have to be upfront. The 88 to 89% success rate is for cases where the tooth was successfully removed. I'm always asked how many times I've treatment-planned a replantation and it's become an extraction, and it's a perfect question.
I can't answer it honestly, because, for example, in private practice I'm much more careful about the cases I choose. Maybe there's a little mobility to begin with, or the roots are fused, and I'm pretty confident I can get it out. Whereas at school, in a learning institution, maybe we take a few more risks, and-
JAZ:
Push the boundaries.
DR SAMUEL KRATCHMAN:
Yes. And when a tooth cracks, we don't know whether I cracked it trying to take it out, or whether there was an existing crack. We had a resident, Mohammad, who tried to go back through all the treatment planning at Penn to see how many times the code for replantation was entered and then became an extraction code afterwards.
It's a very difficult question, because you just don't know whether you caused the crack or whether it already existed. But the success rate of 88 to 89%, which is very well documented, is for cases that have been successfully removed and replanted. And as you said, you've hit on the two biggies.
That 11 to 12% failure rate comes from either resorption or fractures and cracks. Most commonly, if it fails, it'll happen within the first year. It'll either be aggressive resorption... when you luxate a tooth, obviously you'll get a little damage here and there.
A little bit of resorption can actually tighten the tooth up, so it won't fail. It's those cases where the body rejects it, and within the first year the tooth looks moth-eaten. Sorry, I didn't let you in.
The other cause of failure, again usually within the first year, is a tooth that perhaps had a crack we didn't see, or develops a crack with use after replantation. If you get past one or two years, it stays like this; it doesn't drop down much.
DR SHIVAKAR MEHROTRA:
Just to add to what Dr Kratchman said: severe, unrestorable replacement resorption, while possible, is quite rare. It's not common. There's a really good study, I think it's Cho, 2016, that looks at how many times they tried to take the tooth out and failed.
I think out of 150-odd teeth, only five times did they break the tooth in a way that wasn't salvageable. So I'd say those are pretty good odds. Once the tooth is put back in, what can go wrong? The most common complication the literature describes is probably ankylosis, which is still roughly 16%.
But ankylosis isn't really a bad thing, because it's transient, and it's not replacement resorption, where the tooth itself is being eaten up. It's just fusion of the tooth with the bone, which is essentially a natural implant. So when you take that out of the equation and look at the true complications, it's very low: you could call it sub-10%.
JAZ:
I guess, then, if the success rate is 89%, the survival rate should be quite impressive.
DR SHIVAKAR MEHROTRA:
Yes. There's data that tries to map it statistically, and it can easily be 93 or 94%, I think over 12 years. That's probably the best figure you could quote.
CHAPTER 13: CASE SELECTION AND ATRAUMATIC EXTRACTION TECHNIQUE
JAZ:
My final question, because this has been very inspiring. It's unlocked an area of everyone's brain: "You know what, this makes sense. Why haven't we talked about this before?" For a lot of colleagues, it'll be, "Okay, that's interesting." And in private practice,
you sometimes have to wait for the right case to come along. When it does, you'll have an opportunity to implement the knowledge you've shared today. You've described it in a very tangible way. I don't think it's rocket science; I think it's within the remit of a skilled general practitioner.
You've given me confidence. I think the initial mistake a young colleague could make is in sussing out whether they can remove the tooth atraumatically. So it's really about surgical hand skills and being good at atraumatic extraction, which, like you said, is the most difficult part. Once you get it out, the actual retrograde restoration with a putty is all fairly simple, and that makes sense. So, to finish: what radiographic signs tell you, "Whilst it would've been a great idea, this tooth isn't going to come out atraumatically, so replantation isn't on the cards"?
DR SAMUEL KRATCHMAN:
Shiv covered a lot of this, so I'll build on it. The best choice for replantation is roots that are fairly straight, with, believe it or not, some bone between them. That's the best candidate. Those will come out without breaking and go back in without splinting.
Then there's the fused root. One thing we see an enormous number of times in these failing second molars, even when the radiograph looks like a well-done root canal, is the phenomenon called the C-shaped canal: a letter C, with two or three main canals.
JAZ:
I get nightmares about these. I used to work in Singapore, so I get nightmares about C-shaped canals.
DR SAMUEL KRATCHMAN:
Yes, exactly, in the Asian population. Very, very true. And even though in the United States we have all these different lasers, negative pressure irrigation and all that kind of stuff, it's almost impossible to clean those isthmuses or fins. When I take out a tooth, I see this letter C all the time, and you know what I do? I take a small 245 or 330 high-speed bur, sink it in three millimetres, and connect the dots. It maybe takes 30 seconds to connect those dots.
JAZ:
And this is all retrograde, right?
DR SAMUEL KRATCHMAN:
All retrograde, and we put our bioceramic putty in there, so we're sealing it. Those cases are easier to remove, but because the roots are fused, when you replant them they'll be more mobile and easier to splint.
Either take a suture or two over the occlusal surface to passively hold it down, or use one of the fibreglass splints, like Ribbond, or what we have, GlasSpan, which comes as a rope or a flat strip of fibreglass you can use to splint it. When the roots are dilacerated, curved, that's the number one reason you won't even attempt it.
DR SHIVAKAR MEHROTRA:
Just to add to that: you asked about tooth-related factors, but there's also the technique itself. There's something called the Ögram technique, which leverages the tooth's own biology to aid you in the extraction. Something I didn't know until I learned it through my training here is that when you do your levering movements on a tooth, you induce a lot of inflammation.
That inflammation actually helps you by severing the ligament, expanding the site and giving you more space and mobility to take the tooth out. It actually degrades the PDL for you. You just have to be patient and give it time. The whole premise of the technique is to make exaggerated movements, hold the pressure, and give it time.
Sometimes you just wait, not long, maybe 10 minutes or less, then come back to it, and you'll notice it's more mobile for your second go, getting successively more mobile. So the tooth factors, for sure, but also the technique. Once you understand what's going on and how to do it, it becomes much easier, and more utilitarian, even for new dentists, in my opinion.
DR SAMUEL KRATCHMAN:
It's perfect that you brought that up, because I didn't mention it. I'm always asked, "How about having an oral surgeon come into your office that day to help take the tooth out?" I don't want the oral surgeon there, because they only know one thing: hemisect it and take it out as fast as possible.
What Shiv said is absolutely perfect. It's a gradual motion where you lean and purposefully stay there, then lean lingually and purposefully stay there. With that technique, you also use a little rotational force. And then I joke: take the forceps out, have a cappuccino, have a smoke, whatever you call it.
JAZ:
I was just going to say that, because I've heard that too. In England we say, "Go for a cup of tea, come back, and it'll come out."
DR SAMUEL KRATCHMAN:
Exactly. Then all of a sudden there's hypermobility, so you do a little bit more. Not this; just do the exaggerated movement. And on CBCT, I have a beautiful case in my presentation of a curved root. The CBCT showed me that, because of the curvature, if I luxated one way, I'd actually be using the curvature of the root to help take it out. If the root is curved like this and I luxate the other way, it's going to break as I'm trying to get it out.
So 3D imaging, and for years I did this without 3D imaging, without CBCT, has actually helped. It's our roadmap for determining the direction to take the tooth out without breaking it.
CHAPTER 14: POST-OPERATIVE CARE AND SPLINTING
JAZ:
Excellent. My final one is post-operative instructions. I imagine: don't eat on that side, and analgesics. I don't think antibiotics are needed. Or are they standard protocol?
DR SHIVAKAR MEHROTRA:
That's a question for the doctor.
DR SAMUEL KRATCHMAN:
No, they're not standard protocol. Also, one thing I didn't mention: we almost always do these without an incision.
I'm extracting the tooth without cutting. The only time I'll make a small incision is if I can't get a good purchase on the crown. You want forceps designed to fit around the CEJ. I purposely don't use elevators, because I have less skill and control with an elevator, and I don't want to go down onto the root surface.
I don't use cowhorn forceps, because I don't want to reach into the furcation area. So I use these forceps, which get a good grip on the tooth. If the papilla is overgrown and I can't grab the tooth, I might just lift the papilla back. Other than that, there's not even a wound. You might give the patient ice.
Sure, ice will make them feel better. One very important post-operative thing, which I learned the hard way, is to give the patient gauze to bite on, big two-by-two cotton gauze, and I give them a pack of sterile gauze to take home. I tell them, "As silly as this sounds, not only are you going to bite on it now, you're going to bite on it while you take the subway home.
"And when you get home, you'll bite on it for the rest of the day, except when you eat or drink." Because while the blood clot is forming, you don't want it to push the tooth back up. You want to keep that downward pressure for at least the rest of the day, as best you can.
Then the obvious post-op instructions are to chew on the other side and eat softer foods, nothing too hard. But it's the same form I give every surgical patient. And in fact, a lot of the time they'll be sore, but the site itself will be less sensitive than when we raise a flap and the air dries the exposed bone. In many, many of these cases, it's actually a lot less traumatic for the patient.
JAZ:
You don't need to take it out of occlusion, out of the bite, or anything?
DR SAMUEL KRATCHMAN:
Well, if you think about it, you're cutting off the end of the root, and the granulation tissue comes out with it. So usually when I put the tooth back in, it's actually slightly infra-occluded. After the post-op instructions, I'll always check, first, mobility.
If it's greater than plus one, I'll splint, and then I'll check the occlusion. If there's a high spot, I'll adjust it. One train of thought is that the more you reduce it, the less potential pressure it'll be under. But there's another train of thought that even a little bit of contact, allowing for physiological mobility, will actually delay or prevent ankylosis.
DR SHIVAKAR MEHROTRA:
And how long would you splint for? What would you say, seven to 10 days?
DR SAMUEL KRATCHMAN:
Well, if it's a suture, you'll take the suture out within a week.
DR SHIVAKAR MEHROTRA:
Yeah.
DR SAMUEL KRATCHMAN:
If the tooth is hypermobile and you're splinting it with fibreglass, you can keep that on longer, up to a month or so. Fibreglass is technically a semi-rigid splint, as opposed to a thick wire or something like that-
DR SHIVAKAR MEHROTRA:
To splint it.
CHAPTER 15: HOW TO REACH SHIV AND DR KRATCHMAN, AND OUTRO
JAZ:
Amazing. Guys, thank you so much. I've really enjoyed learning about this topic, which really hasn't had the limelight until now, and it's been an honour to host you both. How can people send their love and emails of thanks? How can we reach out to thank you for sharing your knowledge with us today?
DR SHIVAKAR MEHROTRA:
Sure. I've recently made a pledge to try to boost my Instagram and actually use it, so feel free to follow me. Just type in my first name and whatever. Then yeah-
DR SAMUEL KRATCHMAN:
I've just started an Instagram account. I'm very delayed with Instagram; one of the residents started an account for me. But can I just say one thing, really briefly, in closing?
DR SHIVAKAR MEHROTRA:
Here we go, if you want to look me up. Okay.
DR SAMUEL KRATCHMAN:
In closing, the purpose, whether I'm giving the talk or doing a podcast like this, is to get the word out that, number one, this procedure exists. Number two, my goal is for everybody who listens to this podcast to at least think about it and add it to their armamentarium. And one thing we need to mention economically is that it's inexpensive. You need a pair of forceps, some solution and a little bit of putty. It's not like you're buying expensive equipment for this. And of course, we can't do every case.
Of course, there are many contraindications, like root shapes, or teeth that are ankylosed or too fragile. But I think it's something we should all include in our armamentarium as a possible treatment option for patients. That's really the goal whenever we give these kinds of talks.
DR SHIVAKAR MEHROTRA:
I found his Instagram handle: @sikratch. S-I-K-R-A-T-C-H.
JAZ:
I appreciate that very much. This is going to inspire people, but as I always say, if your first case is coming up, or you've identified a suitable case, do your due diligence. Read the papers you've mentioned and read the evidence. It's really important to read the protocols different papers have published.
And that systematic review you mentioned. Shiv, if you don't mind, could you send us some of these, or the PubMed links, so I can share the information that way?
DR SHIVAKAR MEHROTRA:
Yes, and some lovely post-op cases.
DR SAMUEL KRATCHMAN:
Yes, if you want, we'll send cases.
JAZ:
I'll make that available as a next step for the hungry minds who want to learn more about this technique and have been inspired. Thank you so much; I really appreciate your time.
There we have it, guys. Thank you so much for listening to Shiv, me and Dr Samuel Kratchman. Wow, what a legend. And what a cool new thing to have up your sleeve: being able to tell your patient, "Look, there's one more thing we could still do."
The trickiest thing is the atraumatic extraction. If you can do that, the rest is easy. That's the make-or-break moment. All of this information is being fed into AskJaz, our Protrusive AI. So if you have a case coming up, of course we recommend you read the papers, and we'll add as many as we can to the show notes.
Dr Kratchman gave permission to share all the resources, which is wonderful. I love guests like him. But it's also available via AskJaz, so you can ask our AI about any specific protocol or nuance of intentional replantation. Everything it's learned from this conversation, it'll be able to share and reason through with you,
using all the previous episodes we've done and all the resources we feed it. By June this year, AskJaz... I mean, it's already awesome, but it's going to be a beast by June, because we've got a whole content plan to make it really clever so it can serve you. I want AskJaz to make your life easier and more successful.
Of course, I want to thank our guests again. Shiv, thank you so much for bringing on Dr Kratchman. You were both brilliant, and we were so lucky to host you. For those of you on our premium plans, answer the quiz, get the CE certificate, and keep racking them up.
By the end of the year, you won't have to worry about CE credits. And of course, day by day you improve by 1% and become the best dentist you can be. With that, my friends, I'll catch you same time, same place next week. Bye for now.
FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS
QUESTION:
What is intentional replantation?
ANSWER:
Dr Samuel Kratchman describes intentional replantation as atraumatically extracting a failing root-treated tooth, removing the end of the root and placing a root-end filling outside the mouth, then putting the tooth back into its own socket. Because it's the patient's own tooth in its original socket, there is no rejection to worry about, unlike transplantation.
QUESTION:
When should I consider intentional replantation instead of retreatment?
ANSWER:
Dr Shivakar Mehrotra suggests conventional retreatment first if you think you can improve on the existing root canal. Replantation fits when retreatment has failed or isn't feasible, there's a persistent lesion, and conventional surgery would be difficult because of anatomy, such as thick bone, the sinus or nearby nerves. Dr Kratchman stresses always considering conservative options first.
QUESTION:
Which teeth are best suited to intentional replantation?
ANSWER:
Dr Kratchman says lower second molars and upper molars are the most common, because conventional surgery there is difficult. He has also used it for lower premolars with lateral lesions and for post perforations that can't be reached surgically. Fairly straight roots with bone between them are ideal, while dilacerated, curved roots usually rule the technique out.
QUESTION:
How do you keep the tooth alive outside the mouth?
ANSWER:
Dr Kratchman explains that the periodontal ligament on the root must be kept moist throughout. His team uses Hank's Balanced Salt Solution, which he says keeps the PDL alive for around 30 minutes, or Pedialyte. Dr Mehrotra notes that Dioralyte is an alternative available in the UK. The assistant keeps the root bathed while the dentist works.
QUESTION:
What is the success rate of intentional replantation?
ANSWER:
Dr Kratchman cites a 2017 systematic review by Mainkar reporting around 89% success. He stresses that this applies to teeth successfully removed in one piece. Most failures happen within the first year, due to resorption or cracks. Dr Mehrotra adds that ankylosis is the most common complication, at around 16%, and is not necessarily a bad outcome.
QUESTION:
How do you extract a tooth atraumatically for replantation?
ANSWER:
Dr Kratchman uses forceps that grip around the cementoenamel junction, avoiding elevators and cowhorn forceps. He applies gentle, sustained pressure buccally and lingually, sometimes with a little rotation, then pauses to let the tooth loosen before continuing. Dr Mehrotra explains that this lets inflammation gradually loosen the ligament, so patience is key.
QUESTION:
Does the tooth need splinting after replantation?
ANSWER:
Dr Kratchman says he splints fewer than 15% of cases, because careful extraction usually leaves mobility of plus one or less. If mobility is greater, he splints with sutures over the occlusal surface, removed within a week, or a fibreglass splint for up to about a month. He warns that splinting for too long may promote ankylosis.
QUESTION:
How should I consent a patient for intentional replantation?
ANSWER:
Dr Kratchman says patients must be mentally prepared to leave without the tooth if it breaks during removal. He offers a choice between straightforward extraction or attempting replantation, and doesn't charge for the replantation if the tooth fractures. Dr Mehrotra suggests explaining clearly that the tooth has a poor prognosis, so patients understand the risk involved.
ABOUT THE GUESTS
Dr Samuel Kratchman is an endodontist who has taught two days a week at the University of Pennsylvania for 35 years, where he directs the surgical endodontics part of the programme. He runs four private endodontic practices in the Philadelphia suburbs and has carried out several hundred intentional replantations with his residents and partners.
Dr Shivakar Mehrotra graduated from the University of Leeds and worked in UK practice and DCT roles, including in Cardiff, before joining the postgraduate endodontics programme at the University of Pennsylvania.
- Dr Samuel Kratchman on Instagram: @sikratch